As far as the studio version of this solo goes, this is easily the best cover on RUclips I've ever seen, absolutely mind blowing, finally a real guitar player and true fan of the craft. No bullshit, no stupid intros, just great playing and tons of passion for guitar, liked and subbed!
Was David Gilmour not having a most excellent day on the guitar when he came up with this Solo. It's literally everything you should do in a solo. It's melodic and gentle during the first solo. Then switches to minor in the second. The bends are deep with expressive vibrato. The descents are rhythmic triplets that mimic drum tom toms. There is a section were he is muting and pounding double stops and then he acends to the high soaring bends. Then descends back to box 1 for resolution. There are a lot of fast technical guitarists out there but Gilmour can touch your soul. I have watched a million covers of this Solo. This is really one of the best out there. You are such a great player and I have learned so much from your videos. I come here to learn how it was done on the recordings and you always deliver. With that said nobody can play it like Gilmour. There is magic in his fingers. May he live a long long time cause there is no one quite like him. A Master.
Shutup & Play - guitar tutorials You are a very inspiring guitar player.I just picked up a LTD ESP ECLIPSE 256 I hope i can make ut sound half has good has your les.
I've commented on your outstanding playing before, and I must say, this is my favourite solo of all time, so when you ACE it like that, man....it sent shivers down my spine! David Gilmour would be proud, brother! The way you play, and go through the instruction part, it's amazing to me there's EVER a "dislike". Once again, I had to "pipe in" on how awesome of a player you are.....and you are that, a true PLAYER! Cheers! 👍🍻
yes, you really are the most superb player on YT.I have watched and learnt quite a few amazing things from these beautifully tailored lessons. But in all honesty, as others have also commented on this particular "tune", the performance is stunning man.
Hats off to you sir! Not only do you come really close to the Gilmour feel and timing, but I believe you have absolutely captured the tone with the minimum amount of FX. FANTASTIC playing sir!
I just can't get over your vibrato man. I come here to learn songs but the vibrato is so good I keep flipping through videos just to see how you cover the song.
@@zefolantar Andy has been through the higher institutes of guitar learning, I believe he even went to the " guitar of technology in California, it's something like that. He earned it brother. I didn't think he was as aged as he is, I thought I was a lot older than he is but I'm not. He is simply phenomenal. I have a folder in my book marks with a lot of his tutorials. Sorry for running on like this, my apologies. God bless all
There are something strange but pretty in your lessons, I don´t know how to explain it, but I like me so much how you explain every lesson and thanks, really thanks to show and share your talent and knowledges , blessings from México.
Thanks for the channel and appreciate how accurate and precise you are playing and explaining where the magic of guitar and solos like this is hidden. I´m playing a lot more since i discover your tutorials. Thanks for that.
Oh yeah,...loved your tutorial on Buckingham's Never Going Back,...spot on! Had the pleasure of meeting Lindsey backstage after his show in Mobile, AL,...he was kind enough to sign my Martin HD-28,...very cool guy,...got some great pics with him. That guitar is my 1st Martin of 10 and it's loaded w/signatures from Eric Johnson to Neil Young,...Vince Gill(he played the old song Amie on it and did the high harmony), Phil Keaggy played some Beatles and Elvis on it after dinner, Tommy Emmanuel, Lyle Lovett, Leland Sklar, Edwin McCain, Dan Tyminski(he played I Am a Man of Constant Sorrow on it),...life is good,...thought I died and went to heaven! :-0
Music lover here, especially the Floyd, but below beginner guitar learner. I find your amazing performance very inspiring, but also intimidating! Greetings from Germany!
+The Linthicums Thanks bud. There's no reason to be intimidated. There's no special talent needed to play most things on guitar, I know that for a fact because I have very little talent. What I do have is a lot of desire and love of music, patience and a strong work ethic. It's all about how much time you can put in. cheers
No, no, no, no, no, no, no... This time I'm not buying it. I know you're just playing the record in the background and randomly moving your fingers to fool us all. kidding of course, this is outstanding as always
holy smokes----I can't keep up----this is absolutely awesome ----i haven't been sooooooo frustrated in years. but the payoff feels soooooo good once i get the songs and, mostly, the "feeling" down. thanks--you're the best----keepin my fingers on the strings----ps---absolutely have fallen in love with the acoustic since i found you!!!! now... if the arthritis would remain calm...lol
You are fantastic, I love your tutorials, the way you describe the techniques and timing is spot on. I'm really having a hard time with the timing on the long runs, I get lost.
You paly this solo so effortlessly. It's funny to me when i watch this and compare it to myself playing it. I've been playing guitar for slightly over a year, I feel like im going 100 mph when i play this solo. Meanwhile, you look as if you're going in slow motion and hardly trying and are so smooth with it.
I like watching your performance videos just for pure entertainment man! Also! Awesome job on that bend at 1:27. It's hard for me to get those to sound so clean as I release the bend.
literally the only way you can tell this is different from the recording is the lack of pinch harmonics and the very end of the solo where he improvises a bit as the actual recording fades out. incredible
Holy shit man! Outside of Gilmour, I have not heard that solo played as authentically or as accurately. Dude, you can play man. I'd love to hear you play this on a Strat! I have a '74 fitted with the Dave Gilmour EMG's. Wanna borrow it?!? Lol
Wow. I love your playing; you make it look so easy. I'm slowly getting there, I find some of the phrasing quite tricky - there's some crazy timing in there. Other than keep listening and watching carefully, do you have any tips? Oh, and what to do about sore finger tips! lol
Thanks for all the g5reat songs and your teaching is tops you have quality not many of us have, I bit disappointed on the tabs comment, as I use tabs when I learn a tune so if I for get I have ref to go to, I hope you like your donation, keep up the great teaching. Michael
As far as the studio version of this solo goes, this is easily the best cover on RUclips I've ever seen, absolutely mind blowing, finally a real guitar player and true fan of the craft. No bullshit, no stupid intros, just great playing and tons of passion for guitar, liked and subbed!
By far the best studio verison on the internet. Only thing missing is the pinch harmonics.
Was David Gilmour not having a most excellent day on the guitar when he came up with this Solo. It's literally everything you should do in a solo. It's melodic and gentle during the first solo. Then switches to minor in the second. The bends are deep with expressive vibrato. The descents are rhythmic triplets that mimic drum tom toms. There is a section were he is muting and pounding double stops and then he acends to the high soaring bends. Then descends back to box 1 for resolution.
There are a lot of fast technical guitarists out there but Gilmour can touch your soul.
I have watched a million covers of this Solo. This is really one of the best out there. You are such a great player and I have learned so much from your videos. I come here to learn how it was done on the recordings and you always deliver.
With that said nobody can play it like Gilmour. There is magic in his fingers. May he live a long long time cause there is no one quite like him. A Master.
I can't add anything, you said it all.
The most accurate and best played the 2-nd Comfortably Numb solo on YT. You are a fantastic guitarist.
nope...david gilmours the most accurate :')
@@vishnuprasad4288 no mine
Raj Shekhar I wanna see
This solo and the solo from Stairway to heaven always get me right in the heart - they never get old.
I’ve said it before. I’ll say it again. Your perfection and accuracy is amazing. Someday. I keep telling myself. Someday.
My 8 year old girl says your guitar playing is the most awesome sounds she ever heard lol.
Nothing but CHILLS. Holy smokes this is the best cover I’ve heard so far!!!
your intonation and vibrato is spot on...your sound is fantastic..just shows you don't need all the gilmour effects.
+tweed guitar Thanks Tweed, there's a quote in the description box that pretty well sums up what you're saying. cheers
Shutup & Play - guitar tutorials You are a very inspiring guitar player.I just picked up a LTD ESP ECLIPSE 256 I hope i can make ut sound half has good has your les.
Love to hear you playing in any band
The power in this solo is the restraint David uses and you capture that perfectly.
I've commented on your outstanding playing before, and I must say, this is my favourite solo of all time, so when you ACE it like that, man....it sent shivers down my spine! David Gilmour would be proud, brother! The way you play, and go through the instruction part, it's amazing to me there's EVER a "dislike". Once again, I had to "pipe in" on how awesome of a player you are.....and you are that, a true PLAYER! Cheers! 👍🍻
I really appreciate your perfectionism and talent. Your pace is great too, keeps me from falling asleep.
yes, you really are the most superb player on YT.I have watched and learnt quite a few amazing things from these beautifully tailored lessons. But in all honesty, as others have also commented on this particular "tune", the performance is stunning man.
Hats off to you sir! Not only do you come really close to the Gilmour feel and timing, but I believe you have absolutely captured the tone with the minimum amount of FX. FANTASTIC playing sir!
+mistrp13331 Thank you very much! cheers
It's a really brilliant cover ! Bravo ! Show us your face : You must be David Gilmour...
hah!😂👍
Your eye for detail is incredible
I just can't get over your vibrato man. I come here to learn songs but the vibrato is so good I keep flipping through videos just to see how you cover the song.
The most hauntingly beautiful lament ever composed for the electric guitar and you have nailed it. Bravo👍👍👍
You nail the bends SO perfectly! Well done!
Currently learning this. Gives me chills. I appreciate you more than words could explain.
www.shutupandplay.ca/donate.html If you haven't already...Cheers
Andy
One of the tightest if not the tightest version of that I've seen on youtube. Been watching CN solos since youtube began.
God Damn you are good.
That was completely nailing David Gilmour.
I wish I had your talent.
He is AMAZING! Isn't he? Just.....WOW! 😳😳
@@zefolantar Andy has been through the higher institutes of guitar learning, I believe he even went to the " guitar of technology in California, it's something like that. He earned it brother. I didn't think he was as aged as he is, I thought I was a lot older than he is but I'm not. He is simply phenomenal. I have a folder in my book marks with a lot of his tutorials. Sorry for running on like this, my apologies. God bless all
@@w.wrightjackson8317 really good to know
Just amazing! Perhaps one of my favorite songs ever
I have a smile every time you reach the 22 fret , really brillant
There are something strange but pretty in your lessons, I don´t know how to explain it, but I like me so much how you explain every lesson and thanks, really thanks to show and share your talent and knowledges , blessings from México.
This video deserves way more views.
holy Moses... that's such a architecturally well constructed solo... amazing sounds... perfect
That was amazing. In my view, You’re tied with another channel for best version of this on RUclips .
David Gilmore is the master of musicality
This is the best cover on youtube! I swear
What if I said your tone and performance is better than the original. Well it is sir! Great inspiring work.
Emmet Arnett i agree 100% it sounds soo good
Exactly !! Best cover of this solo ever , and i have watched hundreds of this solo.
Jesus. I’ve listened to this solo a million times and literally can’t distinguish this from the record. #jawdropping
Thanks for the channel and appreciate how accurate and precise you are playing and explaining where the magic of guitar and solos like this is hidden.
I´m playing a lot more since i discover your tutorials. Thanks for that.
+Pablo Morán Thanks Pablo. cheers
I can watch your demos all day man.
Obviously the best performance of this solo i have ever seen!! This needs much more views... You just amazed me :o
Oh yeah,...loved your tutorial on Buckingham's Never Going Back,...spot on! Had the pleasure of meeting Lindsey backstage after his show in Mobile, AL,...he was kind enough to sign my Martin HD-28,...very cool guy,...got some great pics with him. That guitar is my 1st Martin of 10 and it's loaded w/signatures from Eric Johnson to Neil Young,...Vince Gill(he played the old song Amie on it and did the high harmony), Phil Keaggy played some Beatles and Elvis on it after dinner, Tommy Emmanuel, Lyle Lovett, Leland Sklar, Edwin McCain, Dan Tyminski(he played I Am a Man of Constant Sorrow on it),...life is good,...thought I died and went to heaven! :-0
Music lover here, especially the Floyd, but below beginner guitar learner. I find your amazing performance very inspiring, but also intimidating!
Greetings from Germany!
+The Linthicums Thanks bud. There's no reason to be intimidated. There's no special talent needed to play most things on guitar, I know that for a fact because I have very little talent. What I do have is a lot of desire and love of music, patience and a strong work ethic. It's all about how much time you can put in. cheers
Your Amazing!...plain and simple.....
+Jerry Fisher Thanks Jerry.
That gives me some serious chills, and I love it. You are a talent of note, wish I could play even a small part of that!!!
No, no, no, no, no, no, no... This time I'm not buying it. I know you're just playing the record in the background and randomly moving your fingers to fool us all.
kidding of course, this is outstanding as always
Ben - that’s what I keep thinking. Guys incredible. Maybe someday...
This is amazing! Best performance i've heard so far! Mind = blown
holy smokes----I can't keep up----this is absolutely awesome ----i haven't been sooooooo frustrated in years. but the payoff feels soooooo good once i get the songs and, mostly, the "feeling" down. thanks--you're the best----keepin my fingers on the strings----ps---absolutely have fallen in love with the acoustic since i found you!!!! now... if the arthritis would remain calm...lol
+bart Rebman Thanks for watching Bart. cheers
no words man... you have a great feel and you're my inspiration. keep it up!
You are fantastic, I love your tutorials, the way you describe the techniques and timing is spot on. I'm really having a hard time with the timing on the long runs, I get lost.
You paly this solo so effortlessly. It's funny to me when i watch this and compare it to myself playing it. I've been playing guitar for slightly over a year, I feel like im going 100 mph when i play this solo. Meanwhile, you look as if you're going in slow motion and hardly trying and are so smooth with it.
Dude, I've been playing guitar for 50 years! Patience grasshopper! Haha. Cheers, Andy.
Thank you for the great lesson on this one. I've got it down now thanks to you. Fun to play for sure.
Dynamic original and dynamic cover - sweet work!
Loved it, first real solo I've ever attempted, insane I know, but thanks for making it so user friendly, now back to it week 2 lol.
You have a soul man!!! And thanks for great lesson of that solo.
This is the very best cover I've seen, Great job!!
Man you need to be on a stage somewhere!!! You are freaking awesome!!!
I like watching your performance videos just for pure entertainment man! Also! Awesome job on that bend at 1:27. It's hard for me to get those to sound so clean as I release the bend.
+Aaron M Thanks for watching Aaron. Well, make sure you're palm muting so the other strings don't make noise. That will help a lot. cheers
Outstanding !!
Dude...1:48...🤯sickest lick in town bro!!!!!
Awesome man. Just finished up your lesson on solo 1, ready to learn solo 2. Tasty playing...keep up the great lessons.
Your tone is so unique sir
That tone nuances and vibrato is fucking on point
I just keep watching this its so amazing man
+Dario M Thanks Dario!
Excellent job! Love the vibrato, spot on.
I've never donated to any youtube channel. You just set the bar.
+Alter Ego Thanks bud.
Parece que encontré a la única persona que sabe qué es el "feeling" al interpretar este increíble solo. Felicidades.
literally the only way you can tell this is different from the recording is the lack of pinch harmonics and the very end of the solo where he improvises a bit as the actual recording fades out. incredible
Always enjoy your lessons and playing!
+gogoggo Thanks bro.
INCREDIBLE !!!!!!!!!!!! ON PAR WITH GILMOUR MY GOD
Your vibrato is insane!
😮 Very freaking cool. Awesome.
sounds great on a Les Paul! You are one hell of a guitar player!
Sounds so good on a Paul!!!
Holy shit man! Outside of Gilmour, I have not heard that solo played as authentically or as accurately. Dude, you can play man.
I'd love to hear you play this on a Strat! I have a '74 fitted with the Dave Gilmour EMG's. Wanna borrow it?!? Lol
You could lend him a banjo and a tube screamer and he would still make it sound right
This is the correct way to solo comfortable nub 👍👍👍👍👍👍
This is just perfect.
your run downs are crisp...everything sounds almost original
Wow. I love your playing; you make it look so easy. I'm slowly getting there, I find some of the phrasing quite tricky - there's some crazy timing in there. Other than keep listening and watching carefully, do you have any tips? Oh, and what to do about sore finger tips! lol
Beautifully played!
Thank you! Cheers, Andy.
Outstanding. With playing like that you're always going to get envious thumbs down.
+Joe Sʌɪzmɪk Thanks Joe.
+Joe Sʌɪzmɪk ~Looks like he got three already.
Thanks for all the g5reat songs and your teaching is tops you have quality not many of us have, I bit disappointed on the tabs comment, as I use tabs when I learn a tune so if I for get I have ref to go to, I hope you like your donation, keep up the great teaching. Michael
thank you....that was incredible
Tone is awesome!
Wow, amazing vibrato as well !!!
Thats about right......you 'are' the vibrato king!
+hemixprs Thanks bro, I'm never satisfied with my vibrato. I have a lot of room for improvement! cheers
Again OUTSTANDING!! :)
+Jeff Downey Thanks Jeff.
Absolutely fantastic man!!
Although we couldn't see your head, I know you had a sweet guitar face going on some of those bends!
Great cover probably the best thank you for sharing it could help me to improve myself.
Have you try to make same cover with pulse version ?
Beautiful.
Amazing n thnxs for the lessons.. talent should be shared.
This is so good. I’m wondering if Gilmour should have played it on a Les Paul.
Truly amazing................
Suoni da Dio, grazie per la lezione as well
2:11 is a bit short for a Gilmour solo mate. Kidding excellent lesson, thanks man.
This is absolutely brilliant! What delay pedal are using? Btw, keep up the great work. Kudos!
+Chisti Iqbal Thanks Chris. If you look in the description box below the video, I list my gear in there. cheers
+Shutup & Play - Guitar Tutorials Thanks man! Cheers :)
Masterclass!
I'm not sure that you take requests, but it would awesome if you put out a Wish You Were Here tutorial some time. You're very talented. :)
+Riawna King Great song, maybe I'll look at it down the road. cheers
Fantastic!
Unbelievable playing. Is that lead tone coming out of the Egnater Renegade? Awesome.
What is it about this solo that is just mesmerizing.
absolutely stunning.
how do you get such a sound?
can you explain what you use as material?thanks.
chenzen it's the amp he has trust me. He has an egnater renegade, and I have that too it's the magic behind that monstrous tone.
wow, absolut fantastic :-) thumb up......
Greetings from Germany...
+Markus P Thanks Markus.
what cretin disliked this? this is the best cover on RUclips
You played with the same emotion and feel as David. I believe we all know now what this solo would of sounded like if David was playing on a Lespaul
Glorious