Everything Wrong With Alien In 11 Minutes Or Less
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 май 2024
- My personal favorite horror film (yes, it is both sci-fi AND horror), Alien, still has sins... as every movie does. So we listed them. It's kind of what we do.
Next week: Modern horror sequel & Disney animated sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Podcast: / cinemasins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Jeremy's book now available: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasi... 
Кино
![A Boogie Wit da Hoodie - Body (feat. Cash Cobain) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RMT3AlAs0r8/mqdefault.jpg)
since NOBODY wrote anything about this im just gonna say it
there is no need for a space ship to be aerodynamic
dude i cant believe somebody FINALLY noticed that flaw!
really? NO ONE wrote this?? Did you even read the comments
+Paws ForHead you have not caught on to sarcasm get have you?
The Joke
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Your head
Unless it needs to land on a planet with an atmosphere.
From the Alien’s perspective, this movie is “Die Hard”
I saw this comment on another video
The accurate way to say it is, in "Die Hard" from the Germans perspective it's an Alien movie, lol just chronological basis.
You keep leaving the same Die Hard comment on all the Alien videos. We get it already.
That's Kinda True 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
or rambo
The "space cat" is a play on the old naval traditions of having a "ship's cat" partly to control rats, partly as a good luck charm/mascot.
tommy cooper it worked out well for these guys 😂
Or else it's a Flerken.
"Ship's Cat's" were crazily outnumbered by "Ship's Rat's" Somebody had to eat
I wonder if the Navy still uses ships cat
@@raymondhamill8421 on the ships, no. On the bases, yes
I love how they spoofed "Alien" in "Spaceballs" by bringing John Hurt back and having him say "Not again!" when the alien bursts from his chest.
🤣Fucking classic👏👏👍
Brilliant move on the writer's part.
🤣😂
🎵🎶"Hello my baby, hello my honey
Hello my ragtime, summertime gal
Send me a kiss by wire, by wire
Baby, my heart's on fire, on fire
If you refuse me, honey, you lose me
And you'll be left alone, oh baby
Telephone, and tell me, tell me
Tell me I'm your very own"🎵🎶
Hated it and couldn't have been more forced "gag" - like the whole movie.
@@superwilliam6432 it is the greatest movie on earth
"aerodynamic"
in the only place where air has little-to-no impact.
What about take off on earth
+DieHardGamingClips What about it? Didn't you see the scene where they left that planet?
Built in a scaffold in space, maybe? It's a large ship. and the bulk of it is storage. The Nostromo itself is just a tugboat.
The bit that looks like a bouncy-penis-castle was the cargo; the actual towing ship is a fairly compact if unlovely-looking thing, but you can clearly see the huge thing in space is not what lands dirtside - the lander is the Nostromo itself.
"Space stations"
>aerodynamics in space
Good lord.
Right? The prefect example in the real world is the Apollo Lunar Lander.
He meant when the ship escaped Earth's atmosphere.
No, I don't think he was smart enough to mean that. I think the statement was actually as dumb as it sounds.
I think something that size would have been built in space. :P
+Multi Colored Psychopath much more likely that the refinery was built outside of the atmosphere.
I saw this movie when it debuted. I was literally shaking when I left the movie theatre. No movie
before or since has done that to me.
Yep, saw it on opening weekend in 1979 and to this day it is my all time favorite movie. I'd never seen anything like it. It blew my little high school mind.
Lucky you!!!
interstellar?
I probably was, too, after seeing it in the theater. I was also shaking after seeing both SE7EN and Requiem For A Dream in theaters.
What about Samurai Cop? 😂
Actually, I think the cat on the ship is a tribute or homage to the old tradition that sailors used to have of keeping a cat on the ship to hunt bilge rats and keep food stores preserved longer.
It should be dead if it doesn't had a cryosleep for itseof
Complaining about a spaceship not being aerodynamic even though it flies through space where there is no air and where aerodynamics are pretty much pointless.
[DING]
he didn't know shit about space
But if they land on a planet that does have air and an atmosphere they're screwed
Well, in the case of re entering the atmosphere of a planet, it would be useful. But yes. Also, I love your videos!
Nerd. They don't use the main ship to land. They have an extra smaller vessel attached to it.
Anonymous yes but we're exploring planets and we can't land the main ship on them?
Dude in space making your ship streamlined doesn't make a difference.
Thank you
Lea to the rescue!!!!!!!!!!!! now please!!!!!!!!!!!
THANK YOOOUU THAT WAS KILLING ME
This spaceship is not aerodynamic! I LOL'ed
You have to get the thing out of the atmosphere first though, and for that you need an aerodynamic ship.
It's sad to think we've lost more then half of this iconic cast just in the last 5yrs. Holm and Hurt died in 2017 and Kotto and Stanton in 2021 😣
Nobody gets out of life alive.
The movie IS pretty old, these people would eventually die
7:31 "aktually" if you listen close to that scene you hear the door opening very quietly while ripley is typing
Aktually
For some stupid reason, youtube thinks that the other comment is in another language. Except the language it thinks its in is just british english. And it doesnt even change what it says when it “translates” it. This is where ai has come to.
4:00 Our stomachs can hold acid by there being a layer of mucus that regenerates ever 2 weeks, maybe that's how
except I'm pretty sure our stomach acid can't eat through the floor of a spaceship in seconds...
MissKTonik actually i think it can, im gonna google it
It can't. There are very few acids that could do something like that in a fashion like that. And the ones that are would be super concentrated.
***** I'm dumb. I thought he was saying that our stomach acid couldn't go through a couple spaceship floors. Which it probably can but not in seconds.
FierceKoolAid you know a xenomorph's blood is composed of flueroantinomic acid right? The most corrosive substance ever.
I love how most of the comments are people jumping on the aerodynamic 'sin', as if they feel the pressing need to inform the one person that somehow missed all the other comments about it.
OMG. I know!
I know. It's fucking pointless.
Surprises me how none of them seem to realize that CinemaSins doesn't give any shits about how many people they piss off, by any manner.
When somebody doesn't know something that a third-grader should know, or a graduating student at the very worst, you kinda cannot sit silent.
it's not something a third-grader would know, js, and i never even knew much about aerodynamics and stuff, and i'm a graduated student :\ you can't just assume that everyone knows this. like, i major in psychology and childcare, why would i have to know about aerodynamics and stuff if i won't have to use that knowledge?
The level of mastery in every aspect of this film never ceases to astound me. The insane level of realism in everything.
The incredible sets alone, its astonishing to think it was made in 1979, its aged so well.
No sci fi film before or since has ever really come close to it. The space jockey scene alone. The sense of wonder, mystery and just pure alieness of it. The sets have an organic, lifelike nightmarish quality. The Star Wars franchise by comparison has aged badly and just seems so amateur. Alien is peerless.
Even modern sci fi can't hold a candle to it. Take Avatar for example. It just looks ridiculous and cartoonish, with terrible clunky dialogue and dull, uninspiring acting. Prometheus is still painful to talk about...
The acting and screenplay in Alien is a masterclass. The cast are just playing average, working people. It's all so believable. There are no loud stereotypes. Even making a cat a part of the crew was a masterstroke not to mention the brilliance of making a woman the hero of the story.
The sound and editing is flawless. The pacing of the film, the slow build up, the sheer sense of dread and impending doom, the intelligent , sparing filming of the alien itself, not revealing all until the end.
Its hard to describe just how brilliant the score is too. Without a doubt one of the greatest and most terrifying soundtracks ever committed to film and imho Goldsmith's best work.
So many aspects came together so perfectly for this film. The amazing level of creativity and originality despite being inspired by so much from the past. The nightmarish, twisted genius mind of the late great H.R Giger. Will we ever truly see a more terrifying alien design?
Alien is a landmark of film that truly stands the test of time.
TLDR: Alien is a fucking work of art.
All of that. Yes yes and yes.
The answer is H.R. Giger - RIP
Hashpotato amen my friend!!!
So you didn't like it
My favourite movie of all time and it still holds up after all these years. The space jockey was a hard-fought battle by Scott. The bean counters considered it superfluous and wanted to delete it from the plot. Scott insisted that the few minutes the space jockey was to appear would be the movie's "Cecille B DeMille" moment; the Wow-factor scene, and goddamn, was he right.
No amount of CG can compete with the super-detailed sets of Alien.
And thank the Lord Jodorowsky's Dune got cancelled because that event led to the creation of Alien and the bringing together of all that artistic and imaginative talent. A Perfect Storm of creativity. We may never see such a combination again.
Dont hate on Jonsey! That cat is a national treasure.
"You did alright, Jonesy, but you left me high and dry."
Hello, kitty kitty kitty ... Jones..Jonsey
i thought it was Goose from Captain marvel 😂
Monday's amiright? 6:18 lol
He's and international treasu... no, an intergalactic treasure
According to CinemaSins spaceships should look like submarines or airplanes. Because how else would they move through all that air in space? Maybe they should have headlights too, otherwise they won't be able to see where they are going since it's so dark. And a horn in case another ship gets too close.
you know that space ships have to go through the atmosphere, which la de da has air. So I get the joke you're trying to make but fyi this time CinemaSins has a point. Spaceships need to be aerodynamic.
Navarro Peck
No they don't if they are built in space, either in orbit or at some kind of shipyard, or someplace like the moon with no air and far lower gravity. You could design it anyway you wanted without having to worry about it ever touching an atmosphere. That's what the smaller ships attached to it are for.
You could make it as aerodynamic as you wanted, but you'd be limited to how big you could build your ships because of fuel costs just to get it off the ground. Just look at how much fuel it took to get the shuttles off the ground. The boosters and fuel tank were bigger than the craft itself.
Well one there was no implications that ship was built that way two even if that was true the ship still has to deal with photodynamics
But I see your point
seriously. like wtf
The cat has the highest authorization on the ship because he's a cat
Jones had no authorization whatsoever... Because he is a cat. Our feline overlords do not require our authorization. Quite the opposite...
(At least that's how their strange little brains seem to perceive it)
dude.... cat = highest authorization. deal with it!!!
@@Mr.Wpunkt I could try to explain that cats transcend authority completely, but i dunno if I can really make you understand. There is a difference between having the highest authorization and being completely beyond the need for any authorization. That's about the best I can do.
But now that I've had to explain my joke, it isn't funny anymore.
If you want to understand all about cat authority in space and a Alien on a ship...watch the movie Lilly C.A.T. everything in the Alien..the Thing..looper..naruto universe will make sense.
It's really pretty fun 80 horror anime movie to boot.
@@nonner242 I actually saw that once, many years ago, when the SciFi channel still had Saturday anime.
Just a space cat!? Just a space cat? Jonesy is a survivor just like Ripley! In fact I think they should do a reboot from the cats POV! Maybe Jonesy even aided in the overall survival!
I love this movie, watch it every year on 4/26 (Alien day)... this year I noticed something new. When the facehugger fell on Ripley seemingly on its own, it was not an accident! Ash pushed the already dead alien onto her from the other side. He probably hoped it was still alive. Then he rushed over to pretend to help.
My face when he says the ship isn't streamlined when it's space and there's no air 😂
you have to get it into space first so it needs to be streamline for that
+Al B Ever heard of orbital construction?
Al B they made it in space
Church of Gingism yeah
+Al B if you have the ability to mine asteroids you don't have to launch from earth, you better off assembling crafts on spacestations
“I don’t know s*it about space”
Yes, clearly.
Stop whining, nerd
Dorian Gray are you gunna cry? Oh dont kawhyy!
Complaining about aerodynamics in space which has no fucking air is supremely retarded
I'm just here because I like Alien.
@@heartless604 Ahhh, defending your fellow nerd? Nice! I can tell you are one as well because your talking like that and you think you just beat him with the best person in the world.
"This hallway looks like ribs...I should keep going" lmao
The "Nostromo" the towing vehicle is the ship that could and did land on the planet, it could land on any planet with a surface, the giant automated ore refinery it towed was built in space never to land or enter any atmosphere. The refinery was probably loaded with ore via large ore carrying shuttle crafts. once the the automated refinery is fully loaded it is towed back to Earth or wherever by a vehicle like the "Nostromo,"during the journey the ore is being processed and refined automatically to save time , and when it arrives at that destination you have a fully refined product ready to be unloaded and taken down by the shuttles waiting for it. think of it as a automated unmanned steel factory and refinery in space
It’s also possible the ore it was mining was in space, like asteroids, and wouldn’t even require lift off from a high gravitational body
You know your lore! The Nostromo is somewhere between a dumptruck and a barge with mining capabilities.
It should be a sin that the special effects are better then modern day effects.
@Destiny Rosales yes
What about the final shot of the Alien being blasted into space when we finally got to see the entire creature revealed as the traditional guy in a monster suit? Oh, and the risible decapitated head of Ashe and the even more risible obvious cut to the no less risible real head of the actor covered in milk and with a rubber collar!
No, I think that like "2001: A Space Odyssey", the film's reputation for effects that compare favourably with today's is a misty-eyed assertions that doesn't bear close scrutiny. They only compare favourably to the FX in contemporary movies that haven't spend enough time or money on them.
*than*
Yeah, fuck over abusing CGI. It's _Hollywood_ people, let's be _actors._
@@noneofyourbeeswax01 shut the fuck up kid dont try to talk shit about special effects they rule
Apparently that chestburster scene was pretty traumatizing for the actors. They weren't told what the alien would look like or that blood would spray all over the place. The actress who played Lambert genuinely freaked out.
@theeverlastingspiral9617 People go to Haloween haunted houses knowing that their are jump scares to be expected and are still freaked out so there's that. You give actors too much credit.
She freaked out, because she slipped on the fake blood and fell ass over elbows. It’s in the extras; she wore cowboy boots in the scene.
@theeverlastingspiral9617The actors werent informed about what was gonna happen, beside a vague "something emerges", the director explicitly wanted that so their reactions were real and way more intense
@@dondee5439 People generally aren't "traumatized" by haunted houses. About the only truth to this urban legend was that Lambert's actress was surprised by the amount of blood and freaked out a little. That's it. People making it out like all the actors were genuinely terrified are ridiculous.
What won't actors say afterwards to hype up a movie.
Jones was the ship's cat
Its tradition
Keeps the space mice away
For some of us, that first sight of the Nostromo in all its un-aerodynamic glory was the moment we realized we were watching a mature sci-fi film that actually had some basic understanding of how space works. Heck, they even knew that in space no-one could hear you scream ... although Cameron forgot that at the end of Aliens ;)
I do recall H.R. Giger designed the face huggers to specifically target the male audience subconsciously. Something about reverse impregnation...
Oral rape.
well it worked on me.
I remember reading somewhere that Geiger described the alien warriors were vaginas with teeth
I vaguely remember hearing the eggs originally had a single slit instead of a cross opening but apparently looked too 'vaginal'.
well entire Gigers art style can be only described as Dicks ex Vagina so nothing new here, also his early oncepts for the movie were even more hardcore ;)
In space , no one can hear cinema sins nitpick.
Incredibly underappreciated.
Ding
I wanna go to space then.
@@grug1343 yeah I’m I’d rather get slaughtered by a xenomorph
Cheers Ill drink to that bro
Watch the scene where ripley talks to mother. You can clearly hear the door open as mother explains special order 937.
"How fired are these people?"
Me: "Well, considering property damage, disregard for protocol, endangerment of the crew, failure to retrieve the alien... I'd say the likeliness of them getting their last paycheck is imperceptibly small. Except the cat. The cat did his job impeccably. I didn't see a single rat this whole movie."
So that's the reason the cat was exploring the ship It was hunting rats.
It’s implied that the little alien nommed on all the remaining rats. It had to grow quickly, of course!
4:58 - Actually, there was a deleted scene after the facehugger's acid blood dripping on the floor. In it, the whole crew arrives to check if nothing has happened to Kane due to the acid spill, only to find that nothing has happened to him. However, Ripley takes a look at Kane's X-ray scan and notices a stain on his lungs, which gets dismissed by Ash. Nevertheless, this scene was cut out so as not to ruin the suprise of the chest penetration. And boy, it surely fucking worked!
Although yes, that still deserves a sin.
Nothing. There is no sin for this film
I never found her that sexy tbh
ANYBODY HUNGRY? moment killed me lol, and also, the suprise bitch moment
flat yes, but bonus points for being perky (see what I did there?)
+Gmaniac01 is that Neo From RWBY?
+Shadow07Warrior1989 holy shit calm doen
The scene where Parker sees the alien kill Brett is in the Director's Cut, and so is the scene where Ripley burns Dallas to death to put him out of his misery
I swear there was a scene where they were looking for the cat and someone accidentally stumbled upon the hiding Chestburster. Did I imagine that?
Should make a video called 'Everything Wrong With Plan 9 From Outer Space'. I've noticed a couple of things wrong with that movie.
Bro you late
Yes: everything between the first “Action!” to the last “Cut!”.
Hey man,stop dissing the cat! That cat is one if the most important cats in cinema history. The members of the crew loves their beloved kitty so much they risked their lives to save him. If I was in that situation, I would do the same thing. So don't diss on Jonesey.
There's a fine line between 'owner of beloved cat' and 'crazy cat lady'.
That's why I like dogs. Dogs can handle themselves while you're off getting your face mauled by an alien.
So can cats. And cats are much more stealthy than dogs, who's very tail is a hazard to lamps and coffee mugs everywhere...
+Inebriated Skunk
Not my lamp you son of a bitch! Oh wait, your a dog.
Hm, what?! Cats can handle themselves far better than dogs.
RIP John Hurt :'( This was the first movie I saw him in. We lost a true movie legend.
The fact that he takes off five sins in the beginning was the best part of this video
Ships have ALWAYS had cats. There are still rats in the future.
I was about to say "If you think a rat is going to have a chance in hell of getting aboard the closely-monitored environment of a spaceship, you've got another thing coming!"
But then I remembered all of the bullshit these cretins brought aboard the Nostromo, so yeah. Probably need a cat to kill the likely billions of rats living in there.
This movie is fantastic but the shots outside the ship during space travel really make you appreciate how a head of it's time Star Wars was 2 years earlier.
2001 looks even better, and that was 1968.
+Pierre Levtschenko Internal ship shots yes, but not space flight
why? star wars were ment to be flashy, this was ment to be dark and foreboding, apples vs oranges?
It's totally comparable, more like apples vs green apples.
Dude, Star Wars has banking space ships. SPACE SHIPS CAN'T FUCKING BANK. BANKING REQUIRES AN ATMOSPHERE. Not to mention all of the space ships are aerodynamic. Space is a vacuum, the lack of an atmosphere. Star Wars WAS ahead of its time, but not in its understanding of science.
@9:52 She starts the self destruct sequence then runs for the shuttle. She's stopped because on the last stretch before the shuttle her path is cut off by the alien. So she runs back and attempts to disable the self destruct sequence, which conveniently can't be stopped when the counter's half way expired. (Implying that she has exactly enough time to get back to the shuttle as it should take her to run there). Since it's her last shot regardless of where the alien might be, she runs straight back to the shuttle.
The alien was in the hallway in front of the shuttle, and gone missing 5 minutes later. The alien simply walked into it the same way she did. Based on the havoc in the hallway, you could assume its animalistic impulse was to run to where it was calm and quiet and tuck in a corner (a notion subtley introduced by Jonesy the cat), or it was intelligent enough to realize that's where Ripley was headed the first time, or both.
tl;dr -- it makes perfect sense within the context of that scene for the alien to be in the shuttle when she arrives.
None17555 Why destroy the ship in the first place? Just take the shuttle and leave. No need to destroy anything.
Kevin De Smet because Ripley figured the Alien was on the ship, and not wanting anyone to find said ship and Alien, and most likely retributive vengeance for her crewmates, she wanted to know the Alien was dead.
Thank you 😍 I always wondered why would the alien be hidden in that possition as if sleeping. Your explanation makes a lot of sense.
Well played!
In the director's cut she also stumbles across the cocooned Dallas and Brett on her way from delf-destruct room to escape ship, eating up a minute or so.
"Why don't you guys just freeze him?" "They ain't no doctors!" Case dismissed.
A "true" spaceship is never meant to land or take off and does not have to be streamlined. The lunar landing module is an example.
the Nostromo does land through an atmosphere and is not streamlined
you mean when the us faked going into space? well i mean the film and the landing were fiction.
@@stevenmacaulay8807 Nonsense.
@@bartonpaullevenson3427 no it's not, do the research and I mean multiple sources not just wikipedia's or a government owned or funded site says. But I will give you this, NASA has publicly said everything relating to the moon landing planning and schematics disappeared they have no idea apparently where it went and dont care...
@@stevenmacaulay8807 Steve, get ahold of an introductory physics textbook, read through it, and work the problems. There's nothing intrinsically impossible about going into space or to the Moon. I also don't believe the space agencies of several dozen countries are all cooperating to lie about what the US did, especially since many of them are enemies of the US, and not all space travel was by the US. Your conspiracy scenario really isn't plausible.
We were laughing so much because of the cats face when the guy died. He's a cat, he doesn't care
@Henry Ramsey
Rescue 911!
At that point I knew I was dead. Every episode someone said that.
Fuck that show was hilarious I forgot all about it.
Beth H if the Alien didn’t do it the cat had plans too
Forget didn't care, Jones lured the dude in by meowing and kept him distracted so he could be aliened.
Then he sat back and watched his work.
One of my friends was watching the movie, and he said that the cat is definitely scared of the alien, but seemingly “admires” it for being a fellow solitary hyper-carnivorous super predator like itself. Total bullshit of course, but I think it’s more interesting when you see the scene that way.
9:57 - The Alien literally walked onto the escape pod before it took off. It was guarding the escape pod door when Ripley saw it, prompting her to try and turn off the self-destruct system. It crept on board when she wasn't looking and hid until she startled it.
Also like to add that it didn't attack her in the narcissus until she attacks it is because of its short lifespan, it crept into the narcissus looking for somewhere to die according to Ridley Scott
@@samanson302 I came here hoping CinemaSins would sin this! The alien was a bloodthirsty killer for 1 hour (it didn't even EAT people, just killed them) and then at the end of the movie it's like "nah I'm just gonna chill in this duct in order to give the hero a sporting chance." Jesus.
@@samanson302 yeah, but i think james cameron retconned any chance of this being the case. we learn the xenomorphs become sedentary when hosts are no longer available, and become dormant. if they just died, then you probably wouldn't see the molted warriors from "aliens" running around so viciously.
@Clu Rosencrans Actually, in the director's cut, Dallas and the others were cocooned and transformed into eggs. This was cut from the theatrical release. Which is why James Cameron came up with the Queen egg-layer in Aliens.
I'm looking and I'm surprised that the the third and fourth installment of the franchise has yet to receive a well deserved sinnin'. On a personal note; my heart will always belong to the first two entries in this franchise.
ehhh 4 was a nice popcorn flick but nothing more so yeah sin it! but sin the fuck out of 3!!!!! only seen it a few times since i was a child and it gets worse everytime.
It occurs to me that the reason the crew of the Nostromo was picked over, say, a trained military unit might be because their main goal was to trick them into getting it past quarantine. Weyland-Yutani could just pin the whole thing on a crew unprepared for what they were facing. Whereas if they'd sent a highly qualified team of soldiers or whatever, there would be a lot more questions
It's actually explained in detail in the novel this way. It was an illegal act on the Company's part and they used a commercial vessel in order to smuggle the Alien past the authorities. Full marks Michael!
in all the movies no alien ever, ever dared to mess with a cat
drrsc Didn't Alf eat cats?
The cat has powers to keep the aliens away he’s too strong for them
In one of the AVP games there is a mission where you play as a Chestburster and in order to grow, you have to devour a cat.
Only with a dog or an ox.
CRO guys don’t man DONT
4:00 - 40 years and I never realized the floor was made of styrofoam and the "acid" blood was probably just acetone...
great comment!
Used to pour gas on Styrofoam when I was a youth, to watch it melt.
Good eye, lad
Acetone is bad. You need Toluene. Aromatic solvent dissolves aromatic plastic.
Really? Obvious
That about the eggs being there and suddently opening is the entire thing that you didn't seem to understand, the distress call was made to lure humanoids over there and into the basement where the eggs were layed to "sleep' in some icelike fog that you can even see in the video and movie, by entering that place they had activated the entire ship's mechanism to unsleep the eggs...
Yep👍🏻
Not a distress call. It was a warning message that THE COMPANY knew about and sent a disposable uninformed crew to do their dirty and deadly retrieval work.
That tail tightening on his neck was an incredible touch in '79. Freaked me the f*** out. 😅
The sin for how it isn't streamlined doesn't count because there is no friction in space
The dewdicks But it's designed to land on a planet with an atmosphere
it was never meant to land. That's why they have the shuttle that looks completely different to fly into planets with atmosphere.
uh, yeah, but it had to lift off right? Which also requires certain levels of aerodynamics. Thus not being streamlined does in fact matter then.
Ryan Pack Or, it was built in space with pieces brought up to space to build it, like any smart engineer would do. So it was never meant to land or take off.
Oink ards And just what in the whole movie made you think that these were smart people? Joking aside though it is possible that a streamlined body would have been necessary at some point.
my question has always been how does the face-huger get through the helmet without melting his face off
the face huger healed his face and brain back, because he came from that black goo. TL;DR midichlorians
yes but we clearly see a melted helmet in the movie so how did it melt it and how only the helmet and why did he not in the time it most have taken to get through the helmet he did not throw that thing off of him and kill it or make a run for it
No
I always assumed it was just strong enough to bend and break through the plastic visor and maybe cut itself only superficially on an edge. The script is ambiguous on the point as well.
Yeah but in Aliens there were live facehuggers kept in plastic jars. If they can break/melt through helmets, why not jars?
I can't believe I forgot how awesome Sigourney Weaver is
the title should read "Everything wrong with you!"
You guys made a mistake... When Ash opens the door from outside the ship, it's because he has higher level clearance than Ripley. No one on the ship is aware that Ash is a robot, and he is there to ensure that the company's orders are carried out, and to bring back the alien specimen. Crew is expendable. I think Ripley is aware that Ash has a higher clearance than her, but was expecting him to observe the quarantine protocol. That would have contradicted his mission though.
Shane Shank Wouldn't someone think it's weird then that he opened the door instead of Ripley?
When Dallas and Kane are off the ship, Ripley is the senior officer. Ripley says this when she and Ash discuss him letting the Alien on-board when Kane is still comatose with the Facehugger attached.
" I think Ripley is aware that Ash has a higher clearance than her, but was expecting him to observe the quarantine protocol. That would have contradicted his mission though." I think of Ash's going rogue as an homage to HAL in 2001 who developed a psychosis due to conflicting orders.
Saying he opened the door from outside the ship would imply that he was part of the scouting party. He opened it from the inside, clearly. "Inner hatch opened".
Another mistake he made is he says the Facehugger falls on her and then just dies..... When the movie shows us Ash using a metal prod to push it out onto her and it was dead long before he did that.
An explanation was given in the comic books (or one of their novelizations). The mission to get the xenomorph was thrown together last-minute. The Company had already deciphered the message and just needed a crew to check things out. There was a mission that was near the area, so they swapped science officers out and added a few directives to the mission profile. They were worried about another firm possibly getting there first, which is why The Company was willing to sacrifice the crew to get the xenomorph. The projected profit of the bio-weapons division would've easily eclipsed the loss of the ship, cargo, and crew.
I agree with all you said except I believe that the company did not calculate on the loss of the Nostromo and refinery. If the company lost contact with the ship and expected the crew to be dead, then the company would send out another expedition to claim the derelict ship and (hopefully) capture any aliens on board.
@@tim_davidson6344 guess that's why aliens was made lol anyway I hear you 😆
@@tim_davidson6344 yep they had marines this time right lol
@Tim_Davidson63 There would've been potentially hundreds of other xenomorphs still inside the chestbursters which were still inside the ovamorphs (eggs) which were still inside the derelict.....all weyland yutani would have had to do to recover them is to find some way of retrieving the eggs without triggering the facehuggers within them especially not if they didn't want to sacrifice any other humans because as we all know that given enough time they evolve into fully grown highly uncontrollable & highly lethal xenomorphs.......the whole success of using them as bio weapons would have hinged on some way of keeping them in stasis until such time as they were needed....the rest of the story we already know about
(1:05:55) Can water dripping inside a spacecraft ever be a good thing? Brett acts like its a light rain on a warm summer day. Refreshing.
given that there is gravity {which is the bigger mystery} it is not such a problem
@@DrWhom Still, you know that’s some nasty water. You make an interesting point.... Which is the more unexplainable... Gravity on the ship OR how did that critter get so big without some energy input (food)?
also, the cat slept in one of the tubes with one of the crew members, as you see in Aliens, so another sin should be removed. lol
Dude chill out, in space no one hears you sins.
It's his favorite horror film
VladiSSius it's thee best horror film
The Thing is better.
the thing is great but alien is the best. its only majority of the world that agrees.
Majority of the world is also religious and they are all wrong. No, The Thing has a way scarier concept than Alien, you could stop aliens entirely with sensors and guns as they are little more than beasts with claws, the thing can be anything or anyone.
You have a horror movie called "Alien"? That's offensive! No wonder you keep getting invaded!!
Brione stop it now
Brione i get this reference
Profile pic with that comment: Nice.
Brione Doctor?
doctor who!
1:58 It was a maritime tradition to have a cat on board to bring good luck to a ship and keep the rats down. so think that's where they got this idea of cat in space.
4:43 ceiling console was inspired for or reused by "Red Dwarf" :)
Clearly the cat was a Flerken. The alien knew it was outmatched.
I'm having trouble figuring out which theory i like more tbh
Complaining about the skin being cut by metal yet it holds acid. Ever heard of your stomach?
a) It was a laser scalpel and b) not even stomach acid will chew through the deck plates of a star freighter in five seconds.
actually Stomach is burning little layers of stomachs, but every 2 weeks, our stomachs makes a new layer
A glass beaker might have been a better example.
@@Sin1s_ter our stomachs have a lining made of mucus.
@@theradgegadgie6352 Acid chews through things by inducing a chemical reaction. Laser cuts by heating up the material. Scalpel cuts by doing mechanical damage. You can be resistant to one of those, but completely vulnerable to other.
Ripley repeatedly going back into danger for the cat is one of my favorite bits of characterization in the movie. Is it stupid as fuck on her part? Of course. Is it something most cat lovers would do in this situation? I think I would. It greatly humanizes the character. Nobody acts on cold, calculated logic 100% of the time, especially not in a panic.
1:17 this reminds of that unique smell and temperature and unique self body feel or awareness combination that I felt whenever I visited my school's air conditioned computer classes in the 90s. I can't recall the exact smell but it's as if I can smell it in my mind.
Why would a ship be aerodynamic when there isn't any air?
you have to get it into space first so it needs to be streamline for that
+Al B Spaceships of this size would have been built directly in space and not in a planet.
+Al B Look at it's size and cargo. It was built in space dock.
+Al B OMG FUCK OFF ALREADY STOP CORRECTING EVERYBODY WHEN YOU KNOW YOURE WRONG
There is air when they take off.
Dude, you're telling me you wouldn't fuck around and investigate mankinds first discovery of an alien ship?? Cmonnnnnn.
Dr. Manhattan Hell nah. And you see why
Dr. Manhattan if I had your fuckin super powers I would
Watched this film with a friend for the first time last week. Even knowing a couple of the plot twists (the dinner scene, a certain “imposter”) I was holding onto her for dear life for a good while. Terrifying. So exciting though! My first proper horror movie.
In the novelization, the alien found the ship's food container and that's how it was able to get sustenance to grow larger.
In hours?
"What do you waste your time with a novelization for?"
"Why? Because it's easy and it pays well."
I also heard that it could break down inorganic materials such as metal for sustenance.
@@dinoflagella4185 HR Giger described these creatures as "biomecanoids" so I always figured it mostly did not grow, but assembled itself out of pieces of tubing and then grew biological tissue in and around the "mechanoid" component
@@DrWhom mostly
Even with flaws. This is the best movie of all time. I can't ever get over it or tired of it.
I watched it for the first time last night and it was awesome
I just watched it and I have to say that it really wasn’t as good as I had hoped. I’m not shitting on your opinion I’m just saying mine.
Pubudub - You have to remember that this film is now coming up on 40 years old, And they had to work within the limitations that special effects had back then. It was an amazing movie when it came out, But I feel that we've become spoiled by the effects in big budget CGI enhanced blockbusters these days, And it's easy to watch something this old and think "Thats not scary, It's just some skinny guy in a rubber alien suit !".
Reman1975 actually, I watch plenty of old horror films and tend to dislike most modern movies. This one was something I had been wanting to see for a while. I watched it and it wasn’t that good even by older standards. It’s not the special effects or anything like that. It just isn’t a scary, or good, movie.
I think they are stretching the whole "Flaw" thing now for desperation
SPEAKING OF RESTAURANT AT THE END OF THE UNIVERSE. COME ON BRO. GIVE IT TO US. HITCHHIKERS GUIDE.
Nah, the movies suck, the books are where it's at.
IKR? Seriously, it sucks to see a great book made into a terrible movie. That way people dont make more, but WE WANT TO SEE A GOOD HITCHHIKERS GUIDE!
Have you seen the television series? It maybe dated by quite a few years now but still did a better reproduction of the books to moving picutres than the recent film did! Edit: A quick search and you can actually find the episodes on youtube. Lucky people.
Der be spaceballs in dat dere universe.
The movie was really good, you aren't British, you wouldn't understand.
Heretical tripe!
As I've aged this is one of the few films I've never tired of watching again
I love you CinemaSins, but this movie outta be exempt. It’s perfect.
People need to realize first that the Nostromo was a towing vessel and the four tower looking thing is the refinery and the payload. The nostromo is actually a quite nice looking ship.
Thank you. I get tired of pointing that out, lol.
Thank god space has very little gravity otherwise they wouldn't be able to tow what is the equivalent to a Space station.
Bruh what
@@Boamere The craft that separates from the mass and lands on the planet is the actual Nostromo. Its a space towtruck essentially. The rest is the orbital refinery complex and its ore load. Think of those big trucks that haul prefab houses down the highway. Same concept.
@@stormtempterf8058 I was replying to Fenris.
lmao im still laughing at how the cat just was looking at that guy getting killed by the alien. he had that "better him than me" look
Yung Dynamic having the pleasure of watching another carnivore at work, ha ha
"do these eggs just live forever until a host walks by"
yeah, pretty much
A ship's cat is the maritime equivalent of a house spirit. Jonesy has a much greater role in this movie than 99% of fans realize. Notice that he detects the presence of the alien ship right before the away team actually sees it.
no air in space means no need for aerodynamics...
*atmosphere
They need to land dummy
+George Christidis why? are space stations too technologically advanced for people who build that giant space ship and refinery? *sin*
Sam Perry You nigga are too mentally advanced for me im outta here bruh
+trha2222 different set of problems. you need to be hydrodynamic to get over the immense friction.
The xenomorph was more intelligent than it let on. It was in the escape pod with Ripley so it could escape too. It must have a sort of adaptability, considering how well it could even hide in the spaceship.
0:30 Aerodynamics only matter when there’s air; there’s no drag in a vacuum. That’s why it works to have Borg ships (Star Trek) that are literally just massive cubes.
You do realize the aliens are killing machines (not literally but you get my point) and if you look at what they said in AvP they made them grow really quickly to be able to hunt them down sooner right? So the rapid growth isn't that ridiculous
It is because in the context of the movie it is never explained, it just goes from baby to adult like an hour, that crazy.
I would have went back for the cat.
What's wrong with you?
With Jones you are safe. The Alien is scared of the cat. The proof is in the film, because the Alien encounters Jones TWICE on camera and each time it left. First time is when Brett is killed the 2nd is when the Alien is blocking the way to the Narciuss (the escape shuttle).
I would sacrifice myself for that damn cat
Don't worry the cat survives and is actually put on a safe ship in the second movie while ripleys away
I Would Go i Love cats
I think the cat is part of the "space is an ocean " theme that is common on every single sci-fi ever. It's common to bring a cat for a long voyage on a ship, so he can catch mice and provide a feeling of homeliness. Is it really that far fetch to think mice will invade a space ship?
Well yeah, from where the mice should come? The only thing that could happen that the mice were on board when they were leaving earth.
Yeah, as 32,000 people pointed out, THE SHIP WAS BUILT IN SPACE. GOD JEREMY, DONT YOU FUCKING KNOW ANYTHING? So, yeah, how the fuck would rats get on the ship?
or packed with food that would have to be transported from space dock which would have to get it from either planet or spacestation hydroponics...
+Professor Tech I always thought the cat was just the ships "mascot" even though there's possibly no rats
+Asghaad I hadn't considered that. That seems somewhat plausible though, for sure. Good point.
How DARE you question the space cat!
Love that “do androids dream of electric sheep” reference
The opposite of an SOS is an OSO
Aerodynamic space ships? Fucking really?
leaving the atmosphere ?
Built in space?
***** Yeah that's what I though. There's no way that huge thing flew up from a planet.
A ship that size would be built in orbit, eliminating any need for aerodynamics
+Bob Builder Why would you land a spaceship on a planet? you have shuttles and landers for that
Possibly THE best film ever made followed by possibly THE best sequel
same! a lot of people try to credit terminator 2 as the best sci-fi sequel but, while T2 is a great film, It doesn't follow the rules of the first movie which immediately makes for a bad sequel.
Alien 3 is the best in the franchise. Fight me, Cameron fanboys! FIGHT ME!
ArnoldTohtFan Alien 3 is a flawed classic. I love it.
Noxious Didn't you think SAW 2 was super obvious though? The police set up in a SAFE making factory and he keeps saying 'He's safe' over and over. Saw was great, but making the point 8 times is surely just annoying. Did it offer any new perspective or point in any of the sequels? Or just new traps?
CarreraGT ikr
Everything wrong with Alien..... Nothing!!! It's perfect!!!
it speaks volumes of both the movie and this channel that just about every one of these can be explained away with general knowledge or explained in the film
3:58 their skin doesn't need to be tough, just highly basic to neutralize strong acids inside. {DING}
Yeah like our fucking stomachs that have acid inside them, this guy is such a clown
@@benijager1372 yeah dude, there are quite a bit of flaws in this.
Ehhh...it needs to be non-reactive. A highly-basic skin would result in a constant output of chemical byproducts that could be potentially lethal.
'Painful movies afterwards' ? Sure, the third and fourth were....ehh, But Aliens was a fucking masterpiece.
The third is a great one and the fourth had a few light moments too thought yeah otherwise the 4 is really bad
i think there is a 'thing' about the creature 'reputation' that sting us when watching them... a kind of mystic of the supreme killer that got into us when watching the first movie... i must say i loved them all even the 4th one. i love when the creature appear from above the prison warden and pick him up as he is saying 'there is no reason to panic...' or someting like that... lol love it!.
Seeing the Alien-human monstrosity get sucked into space through a 3 inch hole wasn't good enough for you guys? And come on, Wynona Rider.
He was talking about the pain in the subsequent films caused by the crew of the Nostromo's encounter with the Xenomorph.
Nothing worth shoplifting on the ship, I guess..
When in space, you don't have to worry about aerodynamics because there's no air...
CinemaSins apparently doesn’t know anything about cats. As if you can contain them in a certain part of a living quarters.
6:06 Actually it's supposed to have taken at least 3 days, since (if I remember correctly) that's how long it took Cane to make the motion tracking device.
Minus one sin.
Fuck, not Cane.
The Android mofo.
I be fuckin' up
it's Kane.
A point from the movie that always bugged me was how did the face-hugger get IN the suit when it was OUTSIDE the suit to actually hug Cane's face? Re add that sin.
Josh Aponte I believe that it used its acid to melt the faceplate.
+Josh Aponte They already counted that as a sin dude.
I demand you remove the 'aerodynamic' sin and award it to yourself for being so dense. I DEMAND IT!!! (shakes fist)
you ship still needs to be aerodynamic if you land on planets with it....which that ship does. so it is a justified son.
+VeryDryBones sin
+VeryDryBones It was built in space. A ship that size couldn't and wouldn't be able to take off from Earth.
+James Bond but it still has the ability to land so therefore it needs to be at least somewhat aerodynamic or that ability would be useless
+Mr.62 There's lees air to break through making the process of doing so much more easy.
"Death by rolled up magazine" is a thing in the future, won't ya know?
lol, "I don't know a lot about space, but that ship doesn't look very aerodynamic." Probably the dumbest statement I've heard in a while. HAHA