THE TRUTH ABOUT KIESEL GUITARS RESALE VALUE...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 май 2024
  • Join me today for a discussion regarding why Kiesel guitars typically have poor resale value.

Комментарии • 92

  • @robertp457
    @robertp457 Месяц назад +27

    If you are buying a guitar thinking about how much you'll get for it when you sell it, it's the wrong guitar for you. Resale value shouldn't matter for a custom-made guitar. You should have ordered exactly what you wanted. This has nothing to do with Kiesel and everything to do with custom guitars and people buying guitars and getting rid of them rather than holding onto them. I've heard tons of people expressing regret over selling an instrument they shouldn't have, which is why I have 13 basses.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад +3

      It's like a family trip to Disney world man, you pay for the fun and experience. You get to keep that family photo, but it's money you won't get back 😂

    • @benburnett8109
      @benburnett8109 Месяц назад

      I have 14 basses. AND everyone is custom.

    • @uvicjames
      @uvicjames Месяц назад

      Yes, you'll also get hammered on a lot of other custom instruments. Your tastes aren't necessarily the tastes of a broad market segment.
      Having said that, the general guitar market is also in a slump. I'm seeing Asian-made instruments from good brands go for a fraction of their normal retail price.

  • @lesnacke
    @lesnacke Месяц назад +5

    basically if ur worried about resale value, dont spec your guitar out like a clown

  • @zz-.-
    @zz-.- 2 месяца назад +8

    I scour the Kiesel for sale listings for this exact reason. Anything that is ordered so specific to the original buyer that isn’t *very* limited/hard to get, is going to take a huge hit on the secondary market. I’m here for it 😈

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      there we go! scavenging those bottom dollar deals haha

    • @zz-.-
      @zz-.- 2 месяца назад +2

      @@TopShelfGear the first metal flake infused that goes up for sale I’m throwing an offer on for sure 🔥🔥

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      @@zz-.- dude those are soooooo cool

  • @ME7_RR3
    @ME7_RR3 2 месяца назад +5

    Not necessarily true. Considered Dingwall bass guitars. A lot of their used customs go for their full resale value and often even more. Now a BIG part of that is because there’s a good 24 month wait for a custom.
    Thing is, Dingwall doesn’t make a bad bass guitar. They also have outstanding customer support. Unlike Keisel, they don’t blame their customers when something goes wrong with an instrument. Not that Keisel always does that, but there’s definitely many documented cases.
    I think the problem is that they’re pumping out way too many custom instruments. It’s like diamonds. The value of a diamond is partially due to its rarity. Keisel’s are VERY common. Why would I buy someone else’s custom when I can get my own in just a few weeks??
    When you deal in the boutique market where build times are 12+ months, resale value is much better.

  • @Prometheus4096
    @Prometheus4096 20 дней назад +2

    A cheap plain built Aries is going to resale decently. But a highly priced exotic body with very particular eye candy choices. Why buy a second hand 4k guitar when you could just as easily order your own, custom made to demand? Another reason for the resale value issue is that a lot of Kiesel customers spec out their guitars in quite a tasteless way. I don't really get those people that keep buying guitars and also keep selling them. Are you a musician, a collector, or a speculator? A guitar is a tool to make music. If you are a pro, you may need more than one. But most people don't need more than 3, for sure. If you just want to buy new guitars all the time for some endorphin hit, because you are addicted. Then you need to sell your old ones. And a Kiesel one likely won't sell very well.

  • @stephenstark7845
    @stephenstark7845 2 месяца назад +5

    Stoked to have found your channel - Thanks for putting in the work and making consistent, interesting stuff. Happy to be an early subscriber of yours!

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +2

      Welcome aboard! Really appreciate the support. This channel has been something I've been wanting to do for a long time. Enjoying sharing these gear related experiences. More to come!

  • @MarcAndreLevesque
    @MarcAndreLevesque 2 месяца назад +4

    I have two Carvin guitars, fantastic guitars, nothing crazy in terms of customization, however, if I wanted to sell them ... I would be lucky to get 500$ for them and one of them is a DC400W and back then was 2000$ ... so with inflation and Covid this would be at least a 3000$ guitar... so if you buy a Kiesel, buy to keep and play, forget about selling them.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      Well said, thx for your input 👍

  • @zoomzoom3950
    @zoomzoom3950 Месяц назад +1

    when you buy a guitar that you customized with your specific requirements, you shouldn't be surprised at any resale difficulties. Chances of finding a buyer that wants some, many or most of your choices are low; and they can do their own custom build - which is the value add of Kiesel guitars.
    I'd rather buy a new Kiesel with my own customization choices.

  • @ignadrs
    @ignadrs Месяц назад +4

    man, guitars are just like luxury watches (although there are watches that are good investments lol), buy them because you love them, not as investments.

  • @bearmadden1776
    @bearmadden1776 2 месяца назад +3

    Great points about the very custom stuff impacting resale value. It's especially true when you put your own original inlay design on a custom guitar. I mean... I don't want my 12th fret to say "STEVIE GUITAR GOD." lol. In my experience with selling a LOT of used custom guitars, I found that the most important factor is WHERE you list them for sale. You have to consider your potential customers, and those are going to be way different on FB marketplace and a specialized guitar forums. You will be able to get better money on the specialized boards. If it's not a collector item or a guitar previously owned by someone famous you definitely will still lose money on the transaction, but it won't be as much as when selling on "normie" platforms. This, at least, was the case for me, and I've sold close to a hundred guitars so I'd imagine there must be something to it.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      Very well said! Lol that sounds like the worst inlay ever btw 😂

    • @bearmadden1776
      @bearmadden1776 2 месяца назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear well there’s a reason why we call those super special personal inlays “tramp stamps,” right? Most of them are too cringe to own.

  • @GuitarQuackery
    @GuitarQuackery Месяц назад +1

    For most people, a guitar is not an investment, in the true sense of the word. An investment would be something that you pay for, with the calculated intention to resell it for more and make profit. By this definition, the only people who invest into guitars are those who buy them with the intention to flip them (and of course, retailers).
    That said, I think it's better to think of a guitar as an experience. That's why I don't get it why people buy Chibson. I would never enjoy playing a Chibson. For me, playing a Gibson is about the experience.
    So, if we think of paying for a guitar mainly as paying for the experience, then it's worth the money, as long as we are using our disposable income. For some people it might be a great experience, worth the money, to "build your own" Kiesel. When the time comes to sell it, the guitar is a chunk of wood for most other prospective buyers. And you can't sell that "experience" that was worth it for you when you paid for it.
    Am I being too philosophical?

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад

      totally makes sense! It's all about the experience :)

    • @uvicjames
      @uvicjames Месяц назад

      True. Buying a vintage fender can be an investment, but a guitar generally is a tool. If you are buying a vintage fender or gibson and keeping it in a case for 20 years it can appreciate faster than inflation.

  • @uvicjames
    @uvicjames Месяц назад +1

    Yes, if you bling out a Kiesel to your specs you can have a tough time finding someone else who wants to buy it. That cuts both ways though. I have a few Kiesel in-stocks that went for stupendously low. A DC that would cost you 4100 that sold for 2600 as an in-stock. I have a couple from the used market, and two that were custom made. The custom guitars (SH550s) went on black friday sales for a good discount, and if you compare them to their competitors (Sadowsky or Benedetto) the value is really good for what you get. If you are paying full price, make sure you are reconciled to a potential drop in resale. If you are buying in-stock at a discount or used, you won't do too badly.

  • @chasing_dragons
    @chasing_dragons 28 дней назад +1

    What I don't understand is why Guitar Center thinks they are going to get close to new retail prices for their Used/Pre-Owned Kiesels. I have seen this over and over again.
    It takes an eternity for GC to realize that people can actually access the interent to find other Kiesels for way cheaper because Kiesels don't hold their resale value in the first place OR people can just order directly from Kiesel NEW and to your specs.
    Sam Ash was so much worse and with ALL Used/Pre-Owned guitars not just Kiesels. Sam Ash absolutely 💯 would NOT budge on any of their Used prices regardless of make or model.
    I'm not trying to be mean either. In fact, several of my comments about Sam Ash''s Used/Pre-Owned policy on other videos about the Sam Ash closing thing were deleted, so I don't know why the whole Used guitar topic and especially my decades long observations of Sam Ash triggered people to delete my comments.

  • @lostintheflurry
    @lostintheflurry 13 дней назад +1

    your point about resale is basically true but it REALLY buries the lead of what kiesel's pretty amazing value proposition actually is and also WHY they resale like that:
    You are correct in that someone's special build is just whatever to anyone else who sees it and if you spend 1k additional cost on your kiesel (e.g. flame maple color treated fretboard, flame maple back of the neck, chambered with AAA+ burl top with an extra custom dragonburst) you are not going to be able to sell that for what you paid for it. Let me 1st mention you could not have any of that done as cheaply as kiesel will do it basically anywhere else. you'd be paying 4x as much from any other brand IF they will even do it for you. so if all the aesthetics are waste of money from any custom shop you are still wasting FAR LESS then you would be anywhere else.
    A basic kiesel is a USA made instrument made new and for you for a price you basically cannot beat for a new USA or even MIJ instrument from any other manufacturer. Hell some brands are charging as much for Indonesian import stuff nowadays (not that all imports are bad by any means but wasn't the point of them to be cheaper?).
    Many very significant selectable kiesel options like neck radius, wood choice on neck (including all wood types of a 5 piece neck even), fingerboard wood, inlays, paint color etc are also either very cheap to swap out or don't even cost anything more to change.
    the biggest reason people don't want to pay top dollar for a used kiesel is that you could just order one for yourself with EXACTLY what you want for that much money and maybe drop an option or two you don't care about and have it end up actually cheaper.
    Also they aren't THAT cheap used they are only cheap used compared to ppl who got 2k worth of aesthetic or other custom upgrades. so just order a new one just for you - just do research before you finally pull the trigger. i LOVE mine personally. anyway LONG RANT over :)

  • @megostryder
    @megostryder Месяц назад +1

    This really depends on the model and how many upgrades you pick. If you pick the right model and keep it near default and avoid the $500 tops, etc resell is pretty good. I have the Greg Howe signature (GH3) and just searching GH3 today I see them going from $1300 all the way to $2200. Mine ran around $1500 new a few years ago and the only up charge I picked was an Ash body and I think a $40 black burst on the paint. Another plus on the GH3 is it uses the old body...which is significant as Strat players like to mod and swap out pickguards and pickups. Jeff's designs (like the Delos) are almost like Apple computers. Not only don't aftermarket pickguards line up with the screw holes the actual screws themselves are a different size. Any change is going to involve drilling, filling wood and cutting the pickguard. I just won't touch any Jeff Kiesel designs as although the guitars are made well the hardware is underwhelming from pots to pickups. Pick any fender strat like the fender American standard and you'll see them going for far less than original cost.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад

      That makes sense. I can understand that. I went all out on my last Osiris with a $1,000 7A top because I knew I would regret not upgrading lol Yes it certainly would be a loss if I were to sell but sometimes it may be worth it to the individual. On the flip side for the second hand buyer going used, well they can certainly save some money! lol

  • @stevewright107
    @stevewright107 2 месяца назад +3

    Good job. I have 2 Kiesels and dreaming up my third build now.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +2

      Thanks! Planning the build in many cases is the most enjoyable part 😄

  • @tonepilot
    @tonepilot 2 месяца назад +2

    I’m not seeing any deals on Kiesel on the used market. Seems like they’re holding their value.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      Idk 🤷‍♂️ there tons of them for sale on reverb for often 50% of original cost...

    • @tonepilot
      @tonepilot 2 месяца назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear Hmm, I’d better check again then. I only saw 45 or so listed and no great deals. I’ll check my filters.

    • @beefnacos6258
      @beefnacos6258 2 месяца назад +2

      Getting guitars half off used to be very normal. Still happens a lot too. I see Gibson SG standards going for 1k. That's about half off. You can score a mexican fender for 400, I'd say that's half off. I scored a USA strat for 800 a few years back. Half off? Lol. It's not a bad investment if you ask me just don't get carried away with specs or do something ugly and you should be able to sell it.

  • @Stark4Machines
    @Stark4Machines Месяц назад +1

    I play lefty. Every guitar or bass has definitely been an investment. 😂

  • @effectosis742
    @effectosis742 Месяц назад +1

    I'm not convinced to custom brand new models... I always prefer to see how the guitar really looks... because If I'm gonna pay a lot for a guitar - I want to see how the wood grain looks on front . I also prefer to see all the defects.... if they are bearable or not .

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад

      Makes sense, fair points for sure

  • @johnbach2380
    @johnbach2380 6 дней назад

    I think besides GIbson or Fender, everything takes a pretty big hit overall.

  • @witchfindergeneral13
    @witchfindergeneral13 Месяц назад +1

    I’ve never sold a guitar. I use them all.

  • @bigred6137
    @bigred6137 2 месяца назад +1

    Wish people understood the general idea of not getting back what you put in whenever it’s time to sell. I have seen so many Reverb descriptions like “pickups alone retail for $400” etc etc. I don’t care and most others don’t either.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      haha thats such a good point! lol its like aftermarket wheels on cars with used listings lol Like bro, that doesnt add value to the car lol

  • @benburnett8109
    @benburnett8109 Месяц назад +2

    When you make a "custom 1 of a kind" you have to find the "1 kind" whom wants to buy the guitar after the other "1 guy" ordered it. That's a whole lot of custom and not a whole lot of "popular"

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад

      Yep and that one rare occasion that worked out for me in that one example with the OD lol

    • @benburnett8109
      @benburnett8109 Месяц назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear For realz. Playa!! Aint frontin on Kiesel........just reppin that all custom be cut up and domed............then be straight tryin to sell........ain't no fool got time for dat noize

  • @assassin1872
    @assassin1872 Месяц назад +1

    I have to thank resalers for letting me get my dream guitar at a great price 😂

  • @corbanjames8216
    @corbanjames8216 2 месяца назад +2

    Hey dude, I've watched a few of ur videos recently and they seem to be right up my alley tbh. But I've been curious to see what u can play though. R u ever planning on doing covers or play throughs?

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      Thanks for checking out the channel, you know I originally started this channel about 10 years ago mainly posting guitar covers but quickly stepped back due to copyright restrictions. I then later started an automotive channel in 2018 which I have continued to post regularly up until recently. I've always been a gear head so figured might as well share some info on here and see what happens. I'm getting ready to move and will be in a better place to actually post sound demos etc.

  • @simonpark843
    @simonpark843 2 месяца назад +2

    It's good to hear in-depth discussions about these guitars instead of hearing people endlessly noodling and calling it a 'review'. Thanks for your hard work.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      Lol I've seen plenty of those "reviews" myself. I'm glad your enjoying the videos!

  • @GUITARRIFIED
    @GUITARRIFIED Месяц назад +1

    That is the risk with custom-made articles... you think they are awesome, but they are awesome for you and almost nobody else and that is regardless of the quality of the article. Not Kiesel's fault.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад +1

      yup, nothing against the brand at all. The more one-off, specific, & obscure the guitar is, the less appealing it may be to the next guy.

  • @jnbovee
    @jnbovee 2 месяца назад +1

    I have a brand new Chapman baritone I got for 700 bucks that I can't sell for 500 in mint condition.

    • @12to3Guitars
      @12to3Guitars 2 месяца назад +1

      What is inspiring you to sell it? fwiw, my reverb shop went from selling stuff within 3 days to many weeks over the past year or so. Demand has just slowed across the board. Prices are getting higher and higher and people are sick of it. The new Ibanez Prestige model that dropped yesterday is $2400!!! That's old J.Custom pricing.

    • @jnbovee
      @jnbovee 2 месяца назад +1

      To be honest, I got it as a trial/experiment. I just wanted to see if I could comfortably play a baritone and if I enjoyed the tone of it in various tunings. I don't absolutely have to have it. But I'd rather keep it and maybe put some other pickups in it If I'm not going to sell it for much.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      I did a separate video on Chapman guitars, worth checking out. I really like 6 string baritones but I wish there were more options out there.

    • @12to3Guitars
      @12to3Guitars 2 месяца назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear I saw that one and it definitely answered a lot of questions I had about their offerings :)
      If anyone is interested in the player grade guitars ESP LTD sells direct on their site, I have a fairly crappy video up about them.

    • @josuastangl7140
      @josuastangl7140 Месяц назад

      ​@@12to3Guitars sadly that's the same price it always was, just inflation adjusted and it's never gonna go lower again

  • @x3a3x3
    @x3a3x3 Месяц назад +1

    Buying a custom guitar is like getting into a marriage. You do it because you know you will love her forever, not because of how much you will lose in the divorce…

  • @b-ricebobice4941
    @b-ricebobice4941 2 месяца назад +2

    No one want to buy a guitar that embodies someone else's style

  • @TimMucciDrums
    @TimMucciDrums 2 месяца назад +2

    I ran into something very similar with a custom SJC drum set that I had ordered. Definitely lost a lot of money when I sold that hahaha.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      It's like a family trip to Disney, you get a nice photo but it's money you won't get back 😂

    • @uvicjames
      @uvicjames Месяц назад

      Funny you mention that, years ago I bought an SJC custom acrylic bebop drumset kit for $700 on ebay. Bass, snare, tom, floor tom. I then figured out it was a $3000 kit if you order new.

  • @hierrogm
    @hierrogm 2 месяца назад +2

    I did ok on resale lost 200 from 2700 to 2500 ..but I agree with most of what you’re saying…I own 5 kiesels …wich I love .

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +1

      thats not bad! yep I really like them too, great guitars, honestly I can't really find much of anything I like better aside from some rare boutique builders.

  • @Azathoth43
    @Azathoth43 Месяц назад +2

    I'll call out the elephant in the room and take the hate for you...brand recognition. Just not enough people familiar with Kiesel. Doesn't say anything about quality.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад +1

      I totally can understand that. Yes "custom" made products take a rough hit on depreciation, but often times it just comes down to the name on the headstock. It's not going to have the same immediate brand recognition that a Fender, Gibson, PRS would have etc. For me, I am not any sort of brand elitist, I simply get Kiesel's because they just happen to offer the specs I'm looking for in a guitar. Thanks for watching and sharing your input :)

  • @CrustyBollox
    @CrustyBollox 2 месяца назад +4

    The problem is that people spec their guitars out like fucking clown cars and then try to sell them.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад +2

      This right here 😂😂😂

    • @CrustyBollox
      @CrustyBollox 2 месяца назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear recently I saw a grabber blue Aries with red inlays and green pickups. The seller was asking pretty much what you'd pay for it new 😂

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      Lmaooooo

    • @CrustyBollox
      @CrustyBollox 2 месяца назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear btw do you have any other channels? You seem super familiar but I can't place where I've seen you before.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      @@CrustyBollox yes! I do have another channel!
      youtube.com/@savagepandaprojects?feature=shared

  • @brycedunn8059
    @brycedunn8059 Месяц назад

    I agree with everything you said here. Personally I dont understand why different inlays would deter someone, I couldn’t see myself being deterred but why others? Great vid 👍

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад +1

      Thanks for your input. Yeah its no secret I do see some rather unappealing color combinations people will order lol Let's say your average person expects some neutral colored inlay and you come across a guitar with pink and green inlays that just might not work for everyone haha

    • @brycedunn8059
      @brycedunn8059 Месяц назад +1

      @@TopShelfGear yea true, i agree with that, good point! Haha

  • @mikesmoviemadness24
    @mikesmoviemadness24 2 месяца назад +1

    A lot of truth to what you’re saying. I was looking at used Kiesel 8 strings and also Kiesels own In-stock section. A few models came close but there was just that one detail that was off where it just would’ve been easier for me to just order a custom build.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  2 месяца назад

      Well said! always gotta aim for the best value. No sense in paying near full price when you can put that towards your dream build!

  • @JoeR203
    @JoeR203 Месяц назад +1

    I'll be damned if I'm going to pay more than $1000 for a piece of wood.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад

      hey man whatever floats your boat! Lots of cool budget brands out there too :)

    • @uvicjames
      @uvicjames Месяц назад

      That's an odd way to look at it. Is a diamond just a lump of carbon? Is a $1000 Japanese chef knife just a lump of steel? You forget about the effort that goes into crafting an item.

  • @therandom802
    @therandom802 Месяц назад

    The owner (and his attitude) doesn’t help the resale situation either.

    • @TopShelfGear
      @TopShelfGear  Месяц назад +2

      May not be the brand for everyone. I've owned 6 of them without issues but to each their own.

    • @therandom802
      @therandom802 Месяц назад

      @TopShelfGear no such thing as a brand that suits everyone. I'd sooner own a kiesel before a fender, for that matter. But it's not about the brand when there isn't an issue, it's about the brand when there is an issue.
      FWIW, I agree with your list when it comes to any custom guitar, let alone kiesel. Someone like me, would gladly buy a few used kiesels. However, on principle, the way I've personally seen the owner talk to people...and second-hand stories online, is a deal breaker. A shame really, because most of them look and sound great, and would fit my collection/style quite well.