What If White Russia Won Not The Reds?! HOI4

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 553

  • @AlextheRambler
    @AlextheRambler  4 года назад +638

    *Ya BOI is BACK*

  • @Mr.ShadeO
    @Mr.ShadeO 4 года назад +727

    Mod creator here (Shade93). Thank you for playing another one of my mods Alex :). I'm glad this went better than with Carthage! The Anastasia tree will be getting a rework soon, in a couple weeks probably, but I'm happy that you showcased her path. I hope you return to try another path too. Cheers!

    • @craigels2143
      @craigels2143 4 года назад +21

      would Poland's border be the same? Perhaps with the reds on the retreat they wouldn't bother poking them?

    • @krasnamerah1926
      @krasnamerah1926 4 года назад +25

      Man, your RP stuffs is great.
      Whelp, i have a good suggestion for your next mod. Either focused on South East Asia or on Arabian Peninsula.
      The concept is similar to your Carthage mod. Revolves around unity of a region through warfare or diplomacy.

    • @Mr.ShadeO
      @Mr.ShadeO 4 года назад +23

      @@craigels2143 This will be expanded on further. Basically the war between them still happens, but Poland would win far faster since the Whites are pushing from the East. Territory and other reworks may come in the future.

    • @Mr.ShadeO
      @Mr.ShadeO 4 года назад +11

      @@krasnamerah1926 Maybe one day. I still have a lot planned for this mod that I need to finish first.

    • @legateexpendable9308
      @legateexpendable9308 4 года назад +2

      What happened to Denikin and Kolchak? Surely they would be in charge over Wrangel if they were still alive, right?

  • @badskoomadealer6899
    @badskoomadealer6899 4 года назад +514

    "Cant say War!" - 1 minutes later "Warsupport is at 40% hrmmm"

    • @amykelley666
      @amykelley666 4 года назад +14

      Funnily enough, right at that moment of him saying war support was when I got a mid-way video ad :P

    • @David-fi9yu
      @David-fi9yu 4 года назад +1

      He also said "the Great War..."

    • @mandalorian4620
      @mandalorian4620 4 года назад +2

      It's like they don't want us to learn about it

    • @vince758
      @vince758 4 года назад +7

      *D E M O N I T I Z E D*
      .

  • @NavyVet9702
    @NavyVet9702 4 года назад +607

    RUclips has turned into Basil Fawlty, "Don't mention the war!"

  • @abush325ix
    @abush325ix 4 года назад +111

    The US and Russia had really good relations prior to the October Revolution. Catherine the Great was one of the earliest supporters of US independence.

    • @modarnwarfare2rull
      @modarnwarfare2rull 4 года назад +15

      Obviously, Russia didn't like England.

    • @galaxypl7756
      @galaxypl7756 3 года назад +4

      >Catherine the great was one of the biggest supporters of US independence
      A soul for a soul

    • @thunderbird1921
      @thunderbird1921 3 года назад +12

      Some have even suggested that if Russia hadn't become unstable and then fallen to communism, the US might have formed a "special relationship" with them instead of Great Britain. Imagine how different THAT world would have been.

    • @crusader2112
      @crusader2112 3 года назад +2

      @@thunderbird1921 Much better. 😎👍
      Who needs England anyways?

    • @crusader2112
      @crusader2112 3 года назад +1

      @Napoleon Bonaparte You’re one to talk, also you fought against Britain.

  • @NormalChannel95
    @NormalChannel95 4 года назад +201

    0:02 never have i ever been more terrified of that...

  • @thewackymole9204
    @thewackymole9204 4 года назад +218

    Dunno if Alex is gonna do this, play as Democratic Czech, refuse the german ultimatum towards sudetenland and defeat the German Reich, you may not join the allies.

    • @craigbiggam2111
      @craigbiggam2111 4 года назад +6

      Everytime I've tried this, usually majority of the balkans join in and and France turns facist!

    • @jordray5823
      @jordray5823 4 года назад +13

      didnt he already do this? Or am i thinking of Taureor?

    • @mrgoodgamesgaming3462
      @mrgoodgamesgaming3462 4 года назад +1

      He's already done this

    • @MasterChiefSamus
      @MasterChiefSamus 4 года назад

      Easy, just join Soviets.

    • @marekpetrlik8165
      @marekpetrlik8165 4 года назад

      How about accepting the Munich Diktat but refusing the fate of Czechoslovakia ?

  • @crabscycle988
    @crabscycle988 4 года назад +70

    The way Alex says ‘Pyotr’ makes me break out in hives

    • @MeinungMann
      @MeinungMann 4 года назад +6

      As Russian, hearing him pronouce Russian words give me uncomfortable

    • @sciolist3109
      @sciolist3109 4 года назад

      this always confuses me. why is the city called “Sankt Petersburg” when no one is named Peter. Shouldnt it be “Sankt Pëtersburg” instead? always confusing

    • @alex_gaimar
      @alex_gaimar 4 года назад +1

      @@sciolist3109 then it would be Svyatopetrovsk (and still no ё) in Russian. However, the name is not of Russian origin in the first place.

    • @alex_gaimar
      @alex_gaimar 4 года назад

      @@sciolist3109 and if you're wondering why this switch is happening, ё in Russian is always stressed, so if the stress is shifting, ё is switching to е.

    • @markvorobjov6185
      @markvorobjov6185 4 года назад +5

      @@sciolist3109 Because Peter the Great wanted to make his capital look westernised, so that's why he chose westernised name for it. Also it was named (well, at least officialy) after saint Peter.

  • @Madmuli
    @Madmuli 4 года назад +49

    Now THIS is a focus tree worthy of Russia

  • @twenity8852
    @twenity8852 4 года назад +66

    Alex: What if White White Russia Won?"
    me: you what

  • @HeadsetHatGuy
    @HeadsetHatGuy 4 года назад +11

    Hitler: Give me your land
    Austria: no
    Hitler: 15:05

  • @ghosttaker3251
    @ghosttaker3251 4 года назад +17

    Alex: *tries to pronounce Pyotr*
    Alex: *Pioutré*
    Me: *slams head on the table*

  • @Sindrewino
    @Sindrewino 4 года назад +5

    I found this more fun than normal, when watching Alex. I'm only 11 min in, but his reactions from 7:20 to 10:56 ... Cant put my finger on it, but it was some kind of next level excitement

  • @alaskagyal
    @alaskagyal 4 года назад +30

    This mod was very well made!

    • @unlivethesystem8634
      @unlivethesystem8634 4 года назад

      It is based on a real girl that was though to be an amnesiac Anastasya Romanova back in the day.
      But it was concluded that it wasn`t her and certainly wasn`t.

    • @derniercaesar5319
      @derniercaesar5319 4 года назад

      @@unlivethesystem8634 so, in this timeline, a normal peasant woman become czarina?

    • @unlivethesystem8634
      @unlivethesystem8634 4 года назад

      @@derniercaesar5319 No, she was found in Germany with amnesia, speaking Russian, after the royal family in Russia was wiped off. She resembled Romanova, but was later concluded it wasn`t her.

    • @cranner2053
      @cranner2053 3 года назад

      seems weird that Rokkosovsky, and Zhukov are still generals considering they fought for the reds in the civil war

  • @stephen9381
    @stephen9381 4 года назад +47

    Last time I was this early, Alex’s hairline wasn’t a joke

  • @calebp7781
    @calebp7781 4 года назад +5

    'White Russia might collapse into another civil ..... SOMETHING!" hahaha

  • @incompetence10881
    @incompetence10881 4 года назад +7

    Damn, this mod has made me want to reopen HOI4, I haven't done that since beginning of 2020. Props to you Mod

  • @StupiditySyndrome
    @StupiditySyndrome 4 года назад

    I love the new editor Alex and the content you're putting out. Also very happy to hear the mental health is in less of a kerfuffle. I really appreciate having someone on this platform be open about their struggles and help normalize the kinds of things we all go through.

  • @mihai_1114
    @mihai_1114 4 года назад +8

    13:02 Alex is wearing a oversimplified T-Shirt lmao

    • @gabon6088
      @gabon6088 4 года назад +1

      omg i just noticed it xD

    • @BaraWilmer
      @BaraWilmer 4 года назад +3

      Dude
      Uncool

    • @Jimothyjohns
      @Jimothyjohns 4 года назад

      m s oversimplified is probably the best history RUclipsr. He and Alex should do a collab

    • @mihai_1114
      @mihai_1114 4 года назад

      @@Jimothyjohns that would be amazing tbh

  • @bradmielke1910
    @bradmielke1910 4 года назад +2

    The first World disagreement? Conflict? Argument with armaments? Debate with demolitions?

  • @batlx1
    @batlx1 4 года назад +5

    Alex: doesn't whant too say war
    Alex 5 minutes later: WARsupport

  • @odysseas1711
    @odysseas1711 4 года назад +4

    1:56
    Alex shows us 5 fingers
    Me a Greek: are you cursing me

    • @yourlocalbicronoverlord
      @yourlocalbicronoverlord 4 года назад

      Out of curiosity, what does five fingers mean exactly in Greece?

    • @odysseas1711
      @odysseas1711 4 года назад

      @@yourlocalbicronoverlord it is a gesture from the middle ages, and for some historians, from the ancient greece so the exact meaning is doubtful. What i have heard is that the 4 fingers represent the 4 men that will carry rhe coffin of the curced and the fifth finger is the priest that will do the burial. Paralelly it means really, really complete disdain. Pretty usual gesture but when someone does it, usually shows only contempt and no curse to die

    • @sleepyuser5189
      @sleepyuser5189 4 года назад

      @@odysseas1711 Ok knew it was an insult but I had no idea about those facts.

  • @TheSeriousCat
    @TheSeriousCat 4 года назад +12

    This is me interacting with the youtube algorithm for alex's pleasure ;)
    LOOK! Look little robots it's genuine engagement :O

  • @Sugsaggu
    @Sugsaggu 4 года назад +7

    Alex: Hello!
    RUclips: We'll take your ad revenue and if you continue this rebellious path your channel will be deleted.

  • @perunproductions9126
    @perunproductions9126 4 года назад +3

    Wait.. how did they make a portrait of Anastasia Romanov? Did they just sketch some random person with no reference?

  • @flachzange1614
    @flachzange1614 4 года назад +6

    I think we can lable this as a musical episode.

  • @il-duce1921
    @il-duce1921 3 года назад +1

    Fun fact burial site General Wrangel's is in Belgrade today

  • @OrkosUA
    @OrkosUA 4 года назад +1

    You have to admit that mod has been done quite well and has a lot of potential.

  • @ckhound1
    @ckhound1 4 года назад +1

    I'm in Quebec on vacation watching the ramblerooni. What a fun vacation haha

  • @Johan1263___
    @Johan1263___ 4 года назад +2

    I really liked this video, I hope in the future you make more videos that have around the same length.

  • @AJ-qc9zq
    @AJ-qc9zq 4 года назад +19

    Alex:"I can't say the Civil war or I get no ad revenue"
    also Alex:"3:33"

    • @Dhjaru
      @Dhjaru 4 года назад

      He said beginning of the video.

    • @AJ-qc9zq
      @AJ-qc9zq 4 года назад

      @@Dhjaru but he later on could have said civil war but he didn't he only said civil... 🥺

  • @zombiehunter1977
    @zombiehunter1977 4 года назад +1

    Alex competent Rambler

  • @dimazaharov8565
    @dimazaharov8565 4 года назад +2

    Russia - Yekaterinburg
    Alex - Yantigaburg

  • @kazibazi
    @kazibazi 4 года назад +4

    Would love to see you do this one again but with different focuses. :)

  • @thiccchungo1041
    @thiccchungo1041 4 года назад +1

    Humanity wouldn’t be over 100 million unnecessary lives in the hole

  • @ghostlyswat12
    @ghostlyswat12 4 года назад +1

    Man this mod seems really polished

  • @danielstover4129
    @danielstover4129 4 года назад +2

    I swear, the picture of Anastasia is actually Ingrid Bergman.

    • @Mr.ShadeO
      @Mr.ShadeO 4 года назад

      It is. An imposter of an imposter was the best option for her portrait, seeing as Anastasia died at 17 in real life

  • @tomascinnsealeach9979
    @tomascinnsealeach9979 4 года назад +4

    Maybe say Civil disagreement ? Civil conflict ? Haha

  • @alaskaball188
    @alaskaball188 4 года назад +1

    *Farewell of Slavanka plays in the back*

  • @Fermak-ib4se
    @Fermak-ib4se 4 года назад

    My psychologist: Anastasia Rambler doesn't exists The Anastasia Rambler: 13:31

  • @Holm_GG
    @Holm_GG 4 года назад +60

    Hope that anyone that sees this has a good day.

  • @RoSoEroTheGreat
    @RoSoEroTheGreat 4 года назад +18

    10:22
    As russian i died from laugh

    • @MeinungMann
      @MeinungMann 4 года назад

      Да он все слова так читает

    • @RoSoEroTheGreat
      @RoSoEroTheGreat 4 года назад

      @@MeinungMann тем не менее, это слишком рофельно

  • @SpacedudeProductions
    @SpacedudeProductions 4 года назад +1

    You made thousands of people clench their ass checks just by seeing the thumbnail

  • @superkooper6594
    @superkooper6594 4 года назад +4

    Would love to see this mod again!

  • @malcolmlaprairie5115
    @malcolmlaprairie5115 4 года назад +1

    There is no war inn Ba Sing Rambler

  • @stralex_3748
    @stralex_3748 4 года назад

    *No one:*
    *Absolutely f@cking no one:*
    *Alex:* I just gonna have my own multi vitamin to keep my immune system boosted👍
    (Corona check🤙)

  • @brendanobrien8198
    @brendanobrien8198 4 года назад +1

    Please keep playing this mod

  • @meowrkatt9731
    @meowrkatt9731 4 года назад +1

    Anastasia Romanov was actually claimed to be alive by a woman. Turns out, she was just a peasant woman from Poland, but honestly, that’s quite a scam.

  • @jackstickeye5139
    @jackstickeye5139 4 года назад +4

    Nobody:
    Educate focuses in HOI4:
    Educate. This is a threat.

  • @youtobebrosyt2127
    @youtobebrosyt2127 4 года назад +3

    Im from latvia and in latvia 40% is russian and i have a russian friend and he said охрана(ahrana) from russian translates "security"

    • @Mr.ShadeO
      @Mr.ShadeO 4 года назад +1

      This is true. I took the focus icon from The Fallen Eagle mod. I can't edit focus icons unfortunately.

  • @MGoogle3146
    @MGoogle3146 4 года назад

    Recently found your videos through TommyK and thoroughly enjoy them, thanks for all your hard work and putting up with RUclips being crap.

  • @yellowplate4539
    @yellowplate4539 4 года назад

    I like how barely any of the borders changed

  • @matthewssilva4781
    @matthewssilva4781 4 года назад

    Yakov Yurovsky in this mod seems like Dimitri Rascalov in GTA IV, begging for his life.

  • @napoleonibonaparte7198
    @napoleonibonaparte7198 4 года назад +2

    We need new Soviet focus tree

  • @mrcoolkid5492
    @mrcoolkid5492 4 года назад

    You should play this mod again but go a different branch of the focus tree to mix it up

  • @Spoon80085
    @Spoon80085 4 года назад +1

    If you don't have a good lighting setup you could just use a phone flashlight

  • @minne_music
    @minne_music 4 года назад +2

    Yeah, play it again! Would love to see the other possibilities!

  • @gunnarcollins1466
    @gunnarcollins1466 4 года назад

    alex: can't say w ___ r
    later: adapt great war tactics, how great!

  • @jonasb104
    @jonasb104 4 года назад +1

    White White Russia...??? Alex is indeed 4 parallel universes ahead of us.

  • @johnf.kennedy893
    @johnf.kennedy893 4 года назад +2

    Hey you can use words like "conflict" or "strife"

  • @andreasmuller5185
    @andreasmuller5185 4 года назад +9

    Yeah, school is closed until Easter 🙁

  • @jesusaguilera6572
    @jesusaguilera6572 4 года назад

    the line is actually POWER,UNLIMITED POWER

  • @thegorb2653
    @thegorb2653 4 года назад

    I have the same issue sometimes were all the units move to one tile on a line so annoying, it's like they get sucked to one provinces as soon as the line gets extended.

    • @emperor_ra
      @emperor_ra 4 года назад +1

      I think it has something to do with the other country being your ally, like here Ukraine is in the same alliance as Russia initially. I could be wrong but that is my HOI4 theory.

  • @kevinhatcher3765
    @kevinhatcher3765 4 года назад +2

    This is a really cool mod

  • @joliver9992
    @joliver9992 4 года назад

    i swear that this is a old video and that alex already did this mod and brought back the czarinzin

  • @Blackburn_GTV
    @Blackburn_GTV 4 года назад

    civil conflict, 101 on how to avoid saying war

  • @syedjazibhassan4855
    @syedjazibhassan4855 4 года назад

    Alex: hey I am Russia it doesn't matter if 20 million Russians die
    China: I have 1.4 billion people are you sure about that

  • @SwedishEmpire1700
    @SwedishEmpire1700 4 года назад

    Pyotr is part of the Swedish noble family Wrangel

  • @bradenanderson6989
    @bradenanderson6989 4 года назад +2

    If there was no polish-soviet war, how did poland get all that land

  • @moonshinei
    @moonshinei 4 года назад +2

    I’d comment that you need to cut your hair but that hair would never come back

  • @AshGamer007
    @AshGamer007 4 года назад +2

    When you see your country getting independence 32 years sooner

  • @laurocuha6546
    @laurocuha6546 4 года назад

    That crooked looking/sitting headset is triggering lol

  • @dga6147
    @dga6147 4 года назад

    5:25 Did you just say insurgency? tssk... tssk...

  • @reichtanglevictor1694
    @reichtanglevictor1694 4 года назад +1

    how many times is he going to edit his mouth on that german officer?

  • @ojisanhoward8940
    @ojisanhoward8940 4 года назад

    ANOTHER RAMBLER SUCCESS!

  • @marko6235
    @marko6235 4 года назад +1

    its the best mode ever
    srsly

  • @pmike9739
    @pmike9739 4 года назад

    *DAMNNN ALEX GOES NATURAL*

  • @andrewlentner
    @andrewlentner 4 года назад +1

    Please cover this mod again some time!

  • @matteoclementi
    @matteoclementi 3 года назад

    Romanov massacre was one of the darkest chapter of URSS.
    Since day 1 the Bolsheviks start their terror regime that end only with Gorbacev.

    • @fireiron369
      @fireiron369 3 года назад

      After Stalin, terror wasn’t used to control the people.

  • @owainvaughan2448
    @owainvaughan2448 3 года назад

    Great video Alex

  • @juliuscesar7277
    @juliuscesar7277 4 года назад +2

    Nobody:
    Alex: White White russia

  • @giolomidze3647
    @giolomidze3647 4 года назад

    hey alex i have interesting challenge for you. remember when you made a video with a mod called what if putin won ww1? play it again but this time as germany or ussr and defeat kaliningrad

  • @scaregalaxy6275
    @scaregalaxy6275 4 года назад

    When ur just trying to watch Alex but ur mom walks in when he gets an encercelment and she thinks ur watching porn

  • @mlcday
    @mlcday Год назад +2

    17:02 "let me just put my army around Ukraine" 💀💀

  • @ForgottenSock1
    @ForgottenSock1 4 года назад +1

    Mexican Soviet Republic is a mood

  • @nathanielnelson1597
    @nathanielnelson1597 4 года назад

    Let’s see a go on this mode but only anti-air divisions

  • @Alterdon123-ju7gl
    @Alterdon123-ju7gl 4 года назад

    Do a hoi4 where all countries are their alternative versions from civil wars or something like that

  • @UlulvarCape
    @UlulvarCape 4 года назад +3

    Just hire the mod developer for this mod and put him on the paradox team already.

  • @ВладиславШевченко-с8р

    Well, what if white Russia won is too realistic scenario. A really incredible scenario would've been what if Green Russia (anarchists) won the Civil War (they never had more than 20 000 men strong army)

  • @natreed8382
    @natreed8382 4 года назад

    Despite his heroic efforts... I got no ads

  • @jimik89
    @jimik89 4 года назад

    More of this mod please

  • @theultimatefootballmanager900
    @theultimatefootballmanager900 4 года назад

    Love it, love it, love it, Alex

  • @countjondi9672
    @countjondi9672 4 года назад +1

    ENGAGEMENT

  • @VinumDeus
    @VinumDeus 4 года назад +1

    Can't say civil war. Continues to say war support 🤔

  • @hunterbg7531
    @hunterbg7531 4 года назад

    Now thats a extra thicc focus three

  • @hetecks1385
    @hetecks1385 4 года назад

    0:16
    Ramblar (yeah so sue me): what if the whites won there...
    Me yelling: *JUST SAY CIVIL WAR GOD DA- MENT*

  • @matijajelinic9575
    @matijajelinic9575 3 года назад

    Oh now that's a sexy Independent State of Croatia!

  • @YTADHD24
    @YTADHD24 4 года назад +1

    Why do add rates plummet if you mentioned the W word?
    Also try a Kaiser Reich play through again as a disadvantage country. That could be good.
    Or play through as Japan (in a non mod) and try to naval invade USA super quickly. Could be fun.
    Or try Medieval 2 play through as Venice and try to rebuild either Roman empire or Byzantine if Roman empire is too much.
    Have a think.

  • @Myjacob99
    @Myjacob99 4 года назад

    Bangladesh asking to separate from Pakistan during decolonization
    British: 18:53

  • @sirtaytentheboss2141
    @sirtaytentheboss2141 4 года назад

    HAH i heard u say W*R! Best part, im not gunna tell u where. (Drops Mic)