SNSD's stage without autotune (They can sing even while dancing)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2020
- 라이언하트는 중국방송에서 한 게 원본이고 발음향은 아니지만 좋아하는 라이브라 넣었어요 !
#SNSD #소녀시대 #Girlsgeneration #GG #Taeyeon #태연 #Sunny #써니 #Tiffanyyoung #티파니 #Hyoyeon #효연 #Yuri #유리 #Sooyoung #수영 #yoona #윤아 #Seohyun #서현 
Видеоклипы
![[Sositamtam] Mission is to collect everyone's hair,,Taeyeon decided to just cut it not to get caught](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UBeWjAM4_U0/mqdefault.jpg)
몇주전에 올렸다가 저작권문제로 재편집한 영상입니다!
그리고 라이언하트 공연영상은 2017 슴콘이지만 음성은 중국방송이에요(저작권문제로)
라이언하트 공연 원본링크입니다!
라이브를 너무 잘해서 ar로 오해하시는분들이 계시길래...
ruclips.net/video/jSRf8nmnRDo/видео.html
Hi, im a new subscriber. I watched almost all of your videos and i especially love your compilations. I noticed your profile cover of the girls, i really really really love it and would love to know where you got it from? Perhaps you can share it with me? If its okay with you, i promise to credit you and your channel for it
Rica Carmel Lanzaderas it‘s from Holiday Night album photoshoot
첫번째 다만세무대 링크알수있을까요ㅠ
에스엠은 애기목소리 안내서 좋다 한결같이 정확한 발음이랑 바이브레이션 고집해서 지금들어도 촌스럽거나 하지 않음 소시보면 에스엠 교과서 같음 그리고 너무 소중ㅎㅐ❤️
과거 행사, 보정없는 공연실황은 저렇게 적나라하게 나갔는데 그때마다 너무 당연하게 라이브하던 소녀시대라 그냥 태연 잘하지 ~ 이런식으로 넘어갔는데 시간이 지날수록 메보 태연뿐만아니라 전멤버가 사기급 능력치를 가진게 재평가되는듯...
The biggest difference was already there when they had two main vocals doing the high notes! Nowadays in the new groups it’s only one who’s carrying the high notes..
Snsd have 5,periodt
Snsd hv 5. Fx hv luna and krystal even tough krystal didn’t did it in title track but fx most of bside fx songs hv much krystal high note sometimes and redvelvet have wendy seulgi and joy. And ses only hv bada so if you mention nowdays is not accurate
Dreamcatcher do have two members who hits high notes. Gfriend as well on their recent songs
@@markjohnramos3461 GFriend is a true vocal group, they are all amazing vocals
in Mr.Mr snsd has 4 members doing high notes
개인적으로는 소원을 말해봐 태연 마지막 애드립이 제일 대단한거 같음. 그냥 고음 지르는 애드립도 아니고 8명 다 부르는 와중에 본인 목소리로 가사를 들리게 해야한다는게..ㄷㄷ
맞아요 고음이 폭발적으로 높진 않아도 고음을 계속 큰 성량으로 길게 끄는게 되게 어려운거 같아요
그때 티파니성량터져나오려고함ㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@shidostarr 아니ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 최근에 소녀시대가 콘서트에서 생라이브로 마지막에 다만세 부르는거봤는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 티파니 안무는 ㄹㅇ 다죽어가는사람처럼 추는데 싸비에선 티파니성량이 압도적임ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 몸은힘들어도 노래는 꿋꿋하게ㅋㅋㅋ하는거 개웃겨서ㅋㅋㅋ
이 영상 맨 앞에 다만세 후렴에서도 티파니 태연만 확실하게 구분되서 들림요ㅋㅋ
태연도 레전드인데 태연이 애드리브로 빠졌을 때 싸비 부분 티파니 서현이 든든하게 채우는 게 너무 좋음
it's funny how SNSD's dance line can be a main vocalist in other groups
SNSD be like : ok try to find our main vocalist
Lets be real not all SNSD can sing properly to the extend of being main vocalist in other groups 🤷🏻♀️
@@danaa6988 Did you watch this Video? Or you just skipped to invalidate somebody else's opinion that's basically a fact. I suggest you should clean your ear, it seems as if you can't hear very well. 💀
@@ownaessis Everyone one can have opinion, and I am being realistic. Therefore, I suggest you clean your ears. There is no need to insult to prove your opinion.
let's be real... it's not hard to find snsd's main vocal
@@gopoleen Exactly my point, but people like to exaggerate 🤷🏻♀️
뭔가 다른 그룹들은 조금씩 아쉬운 부분이 있는데 라이브 군무 비주얼 예능 소녀시대만큼 밸런스 좋은 그룹은 소녀시대밖에 없는 거 같음 이래서 소시한테 못 벗어남...
소녀시대최고입니다. International fans 인정
저도ㅜㅜㅜ 소시 컴백만을 기다리고 이써요ㅠㅠ
진짜 태연 데뷔초 저 싱그러움과 풋풋함을 따라갈 아이돌은 절대없을듯... 진짜.... 다만세때 너무 예쁘다 ㅠㅠ ..........
근데 성량은 엄췅 파워풀해요ㄷㄷㄷ
춤추면서 전맴버가 다 라이브가 되는게 레전드;;
8:20 저거 골디 대상 앵콜인데 진짜 대상 가수다운 라이브 실력임
Tmi) 트와이스는 knock knock 으로 대상탐^^ 이게 나라냐.. 나도 트와이스 한창 인기있을때 많이 좋아했었는데 같은 대상인데 급이 이렇게 차이나는건 말이 안되지...
그냥 그 해에 앨범 3~4개 내서 준듯 성적도 비슷비슷한데 합치면 다른 가수에 비해 높아보이는 효과도 있어서 ,, 물론 5년전 대상때랑 무게감이 다르긴함
@@Pdochi98 누군가가 올라간다는건 다른 누군가들은 내려간다는 거죠
자기 그룹명을 자신있게 말할 수 있는 그룹 어느 그룹이 나 소녀시대야 란 말처럼 임팩트를 줄 수 있을까...? 노래 뿐만아니라 안무 따는것도 괴물급임...
Seriously SNSD really set the standard really high.
PERIODSÉ
@interlude llama hahahahahahhahahahaha i am dead
The way hyoyeon, yuri and yoona always get the harsh comments on their singing stability during this era but to think back, their vocal are actually not that bad as compared to the new gurliessss these days 😂😂😂😂😂
mostly their old performances they didn't use in-ear and still slay singing live
yass, and it's actually hard to match with the beat, coz you can't hear clearly in the stage, and the delay of the speaker also made it harder
Truly they are Legend
party isn't that old of performance, neither is lion heart
Like what she/he said, mostly of their old performances. 😊 She didn't said party and lion heart are one of the old performances. 😊
@@EmanNabil actually you can read the word "mostly" before typing that comment. (:
이때가 진짜 듣는 맛이 있었지... AR없던 시절... MR도 지금 MR이랑은 사뭇 달랐고
말그대로 정말 생라이브이던 시절... 마이크도 음향도 보정도 없던 시절이라 더 적나라하게 드러나던 시절에 이렇게 잘하던 우리 소녀시대 진짜 내 자부심이야 ㅠㅠ 요새 다시금 울 언니들의 대단함을 느끼고 있어서 자랑스럽구 그래 ㅠㅠ 컴백하쟈ㅑㅏㅏㅏ!!!
진짜 날것의 느낌이 너무 좋아요. 요즘은 목소리 두개로 들리는거 너무 싫음..
마즈으으으으아 마지막 컴백은 이제 3년 되었어요, 진짜 언니등 돌아와야돼요 이제ㅠㅡㅠ
It's so rare to see a Girl Groups hitting high notes 100% live while having a difficult dance but still so stable. Especially in this generation
@So What I really hope so but I mean doesn't have high notes define the group a little less talented no but we would love also to hear the powerful strong wide range of a singer🥺
the thing about SNSD is, they didn’t just automatically get perfect vocals since day 1. these women worked hard and sacrificed everything to train and be the best that they can be for SONE’s. it’s about practice and effort!! that right there is why SNSD is the Nation’s Girl Group.
when some fandom say their idol was tired.. cannot sing while dancing.... YAYAYA see this video please...THIS WE CALL LEGEND.. no matter how many gg was debut this day..SNSD IS THE ONE MAKE THE WORLD KNOW KPOP INDUSTRY HAVE GIRL GROUP...they face BLACK OCEAN Back then..Now see what their level right now..
lol, ikr? tiredness is not an excuse, idols supposed to sing.
watching this suddenly made me realized one thing: its been 13 years for the girls. they have worked so hard and achieved so much. maybe they finally reached the stage in their life when they no longer want to sing and dance on TV. they are pursuing their individual dream and i am completely cool with that. i don't need another comeback when i have 13 years of content to watch and rewatch.
i will be happy with the girls just gathering together once in a while and have fun, eat good food, reminiscing their past, post a group photo on social media.
i am contented with that...
Very true. Today, SNSD's instapost is equivalent to TWICE's best performance. Lol
They are rich queen now
They do that when they celebrate a member birthday
Fuck we’re getting old lmao
Same mindset gurl, as a fan I'll always be here staring at their pictures in a gathering every once in a while. I'm happy that they can finally do what makes them really really happy😊
태연 음색은 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ네
Snsd VOCAL LEGENDS. PERIOD.
“역시 소녀시대 잘해” 이말 한 마디면 끝
소녀시대 = 2세대 레전드 걸그룹 교과서
아이돌 = 댄스가수 = 가수 = 진짜 잘 하는 가수
They sing literally EVERYTHING, even the sound effects, nowadays even the groups/soloists known for good live stages, they tend to skip the chorous or dance intense parts, and are still praised for singing, i just don't get it.
Yes true. Nowadays, pure hyped
I can't tolerate the fake high notes these days.. and people applaud it
@@OxxselphiexxO because they can’t tell what is live, autotune and lip sync. as long it’s their bias fans/people will always applaud and boast it🤦♀️. missing this kind of performances now and hardly new era do live without autotune. ☹️
SNSD managed to go viral and be popular even though internet isnt accessible much that time, compare now. I mean, it is hard to watch their videos in youtube before (in their time) than now.
True. Real popularity. No cheatcodes.
Exactly ..
Ikr... i knew them through tv with Gee. Hahaha.
Ijust simply remember watching Hello Baby with SNSD and the title of the show in RUclips was like “H3LL0 B4BY $N$D Part 2/36 with Eng Sub”... then you get annoyed if one part is missing😅
@@swagwanhyung8413 omg same! 😂
It was a different time back then. Groups had to be able to sing live like 98% of the performances. And SNSD was top notch. No group today can match them when it comes to live singing.
진짜 이 당시에는 댄스라인 노래실력 까이고 그랬는데 지금와서 생각해보면 어처구니 없이 그냥 욕먹은 거 같음.. 보컬리인들이 너무 잘하니까 그게 평균치라고 생각하고 그랬던 것 같다ㅠㅠ 2022년엔 절대 볼 수 없는 쌩리이브..
the chances of us getting a GG that will reach SNSD performance is if they were carefully picked with criteria like stable vocal, can hit high note and can go low note and lastly voice color compliments each other.. Can dance any genre and lastly visual..
SNSD is special group because everyone can harmonize with each other..
No one will ever be like them. It will only GIRLS GENERATION. TODAY, TOMORROW AND TILL MY LAST BREATHM
It's 200% chance that you will be hit by a lightning than finding another group just like SNSD. 🍵
Pre debut TaeYeon alone outsings more than half of kpop girlies today lmfao SNSD vocal legends come thru
periyat
!!!!
Louder
Louder for the Once at the back
LOUDER👀
이때는 2세대 여돌들 라이브 못한다고 맨날 글 올라오고 그랬는데....진짜 악의적인 글들이었고...
소시는 보컬라인만 뿐만 아니라 댄스라인도 라이브 안정적으로 잘하네
글고 슴은 확실히 화음맛집....비는 부분 없이 다같이 부름ㅋㅋㅋ존멋
마자여!! 그래서 그 소리 듣기 싫어서 라이브 오지게 노력했다고 들었어여!!
스엠 이 인재들을 3년동안 공백기를 만드는건 진짜... 무기징역이다
얼른 컴백시켜 스엠!!!!!!!!
이게 스엠탓은 아닌걸 알지만......저도 소시를 탓할 수 없어 스엠이라도 탓해야겠네요ㅜㅜ
스엠아니였으면 이 인재들을 한그룹으로 알고있지도 못했겠지
스엠은 데뷔만 잘시킴
There is no earpiece in their early days of debut and still they sung live..
The most amazing part here is that their harmonization is still the best among gg's in South Korea. They're singing the chorus as one!
That's why SNSD is known as KOREA NGG, Nation Singer and over the years the ONLY girl group Legends! Major GROUP that made Kpop known and #1 girl group who help their own country economic crisis and major help in Korea tourism as well. SNSD also set the girl group standard.
The only girl group that made me learn all their songs and the dance choreographies.
HAHAHA SAME!
@@roselybaniaga4103 ME TOOO
Same same😂
Omg yes. They always have the perfect choreo that was just the right amount of simple and complicated enough to look cool or pleasant.
Yessssssss
They said SNSD is legend because of the 13 years experience....
THEY ARE LEGEND FROM THE BEGINNING!!
Yup! Really annoyed when fans say "They just debuted. They will get better." Sweetie, they're supposed to be good AT DEBUT. That's what their training is for.
@@notapotato_ exactly
@@notapotato_ exactly. some of groups' main singer even need more training for not only hitting high notes that sounds like shouting
@@notapotato_ I KNOW RIGHT OMG FACTS UAHAHAHAHA
라이언하트 라이브 미쳤는데,,?
Yoona, only a visual and lead dancer, but can sing as stable as the lead vocal of some popular groups these days
She's a sub-vocalist too 😌😉❤️
@@lian5377 no she is not
Im solid fan of snsd but i dont agree with you because many idols can sing stable too while dancing and can sing stable- subvocalist... like gfriend blackpink red velvet itzy izone and many more😊no hate😄
@@Mgraceyyy I said "some popular groups"
All the groups you state are stable, but that'not "that group" I wanted to mention
Everybody here know's Krystal Jung? A visual, maknae and lead vocalist.
ㅇㄴ.... 당장 babybaby만 봐도 떼창식 싸비를 멤버 전원이 부르는 그룹이 어딨어요 진짜ㅠㅠㅠ요즘엔 다 AR 처리 하고 한두명 만 부르는데 ㅋㅋ
진짜 맨마지막 라이언하트는 보면서 눈물이 난다.....
언니들 실력으로 장악해버리는 소녀시대가 그립고 너무 고파ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 컴백하자 언니들 ㅠㅠ
I'm so lucky I was born to kpop world earlier to be a SNSD fan! A proud Filipino SONE here!
SONE SINCE 2010 MARS HUHU miss ko na silaaa 💯💗
Sone forever, gg4eva ..
Apir!!! Filipino SONE here!!!
SONE Philippines!!!!
Sone since 2011 The boys era
소녀시대는 진심 걸그룹의 교과서라 생각합니다!! 2007년도에 데뷔하고 2009년
Gee때 부터 본격적으로 각 시상식에서
상이란 상들은 전부 다 차지하고 걸그룹
최초 멜론 어워드 7관왕에 그후 몇년간
골든 디스크,서가대 등등 쭈~ 욱
대상수상에 진짜 걸그룹에 전설이 되었다
생각이 드네요!!
They only group who didn’t use backtracks but just pure instrumentals ...
I see that all gen 2 didn't use backtrack
@@khanhhuynh3145 yeah, most of 2nd gen groups did that. That's why i'm always proud to be 2nd gen fans.
Third gen has representative which is LOVELYZ... Their intrumentals every concert is literally a LIVE BAND-
Girls Generation was raw, genuine, had their own true trademark. You can put them on stage even without in ear monitors and they will sing it. Groups in the current generation rely wayyy too much on technology. 😎
와 깔리는 거 하나 없이 완전 쌩라이브네... 진짜 잘하네......
요즘 이만큼 라이브하는 아이돌 보기힘듦,,,,,,
Being a SONE is the best decision i've ever made.
소시는 음방만했다하면 엠알제거영상 엄청 핫했지..지금 다른 누구처럼 못해서 핫한게 아니라 음방만 했다하면 레전드를 찍어서. 심지어 멤버들끼리 화음쌓는것도 다들림...소녀시대는 저때 저평가되는 그룹중에 손꼽음 진짜ㅋㅋㅋㅋ저때 생각만해도 복장터짐ㅋㅋㅋ저렇게 멤버들 다 모아라해도 못모음 이젠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ소녀시대는 걍 레전설임~~
@@mumohada1895 소시 억까가 그당시 많긴했음
Mu Mohada 소시 악플은 원래 데뷔전부터 많았고 아이돌이라는 타이틀이 소시때부터 나왔고, 그 당시 가요계가 아이돌잎주류가 아니다보니 상대적으로 못해보이는 거지 다만세 추면서 생라이브하는게 쉬운게 절대 아님 예전에는 그냥 아이돌이여서, 소녀시대라서 까이는경우가 허다했음
그당시 음원차트보면 못한다고 할만하지 근데 요즘아이돌이 그때 노래나왔으면 그냥 웃음거리임
Oh they already had a good vocal from their start of career which you can't find to most of new kpop groups today ...
True!
IKR!!!
GIRLS' GENERATION PAVED THE WAY!
CD 몸에 안좋은데 공연할때마다 드시네 울언니들....💿
언니들은 그냥 아침 점심 저녁 CD 씹어먹겠다...
4:22 내가 다시보려고 해놓는 타임라인....미친 개이뻐
율현 미모... 정말 고대로 잘 컸어 ㅠㅠ
I wonder when we'll get back to this era of groups singing live? I can confidently say little than 10% off all active idols sing live, and if they do, they're not stable or only the main vocalists carry the group performance.
that's what I'm thought, SNSD really trained to be a singer, with that awesome coreography too.
Only SM idols (most of the time) sing live and still be stable throughout the performances.
Some popular groups today like twice/ bts have vocalists that can barely be stable it's quite sad.
@@user-dy4yi7fd3t don't need to brag any group name bro, it's really sesitive these days
@@adimasmaulana7143 it is a fact.
Idol nowday suppose to be able to be an idol like 2nd gen.
Those 2 idols mentioned could not prove themselves.
when eyeliner and lipstick is not yet invented yet they slayed the whole world Philippines hereeee unies
Those were already popular back then, but it didn't fit their image at all as they were always promoted as the innocent and pure girl group.
태연 성대 말짱한거 참 대단함
에셈은 참 별로인데 육성시스템은 세계최고임👍👍👍에셈애들이 노래랑 춤으로 까이는 걸 본적이 없네
역시 태연은 데뷔때부터 탑클라쓰
the fact that our girl's generation is queen because when they debut they didn't know in-ear and they didn't use it, so they practice really hard. and now even they using it their voice is never disappointed us as SONE.
소녀시대한테서는 평생 헤어나오지 못할 것 같다ㅠㅠ 어케 헤어나와...
저두요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 내소시 영원히 최고
12:27 라이언하트 진짜ㄹㅈㄷ다...라이브랑 얼굴이랑 의상 진짜 여유.. 완벽..ㅋㅅㅋ
2:15 김태연 여기 미쳤다 ㅠㅠ
They can sing even better without autotunes, they can also dance even better
SME is really good at training their trainees and artists whether it would be singing, dancing or acting. But they're also really good at treating their artists like shit. These advantages and disadvantages makes me think whether I would still prefer SM as the best entertainment. But nevertheless, we can't deny the power they hold in music industry as well as their artists.
Ikrrrr
the talent they give comes with a really expensive price. in return you have to give your life to a slave contract, and spend years of harsh training. people think idol training is really easy but it honestly isnt.
SME also has "talented" wife beaters, drunk drivers, and sadly... the highest suicide rate in the Kpop industry.
JYP quote: *_"My artists may not be the best singers, but they are the best human Beings."_* Can you name any JYPE artists that went to jail? I can name a bunch of "talented" SME and YGE artists that did.
@@theninearemine8499 Huh? Which SM artists are in jail?
@@justsomegirlwithoutamousta3173 SME tells you "they left the group", but the truth is many of their artists did crimes. One from Super Junior beat his girlfriend, then said "he was practicing martial arts". 🙄
소녀시대라서 살아남은 거지 진짜 이딴 음향으로 방송사고라도 나면 어쩌려고 일을 이렇게 하냐
다신 나올수없는 레전드그룹;
Hyoyeon at 1:43 makes me sad that SM didn’t train her vocals more. She has potential and I know she’s the main dancer but she could’ve been much more.
Well its actually not that sm didnt train hyo vocals but its sm that push hyo towards rather than vocal though and hyo didnt get many opportunity to showcase her vocals back in early soshi days and even in their albums too :] The only time where we could get to hear hyo lovely natural voices when soshi were guesting in radio shows do cover of songs etc
Besides, eversince hyo has gone solo we finally get to hear a lot more of hyo underrated vocals and do stay tuned for ballad singer hyo in the future >
Then check hyo's dessert
Strawberry C I have and I love it but it doesn’t showcase her full talent. She mostly raps in that song
@@spencernguyen2642 bcause hyoyeon main dancer not main vocal :) my bias is hyoyeon since debut until now
nvnsnjy well yes I know that, but it would’ve been nice to see more vocals :)
No hate for the idols today but when one or two members are not in the group they would use the ar for those members. But for 2nd gen. Idols if they are not complete due to conflicting schedule or they are sick they would not use ar but the other members would cover for them
That thing alone sets them.apart and that why they are called Legend
But SM artist really good for their vocal, like RV psycho, seulgi singing wendy part
P
@@jayjung9073 RV skips all of Wendy's parts when she's not on stage. I've seen it. And the whole "unit" thing was just because Wendy was injured... it wasn't planned that way. Tell me you heard anything about a RV unit release before Wendy's accident? And nobody is singing "Really Bad Boy" if Wendy's not there. If you have a link to it, please share.
@@theninearemine8499 lmao but after that seulgi did that lol, skip RV is talented
the only thing i love about SM Ent. is they really trained their artist well, not just for their dance and singing ability but their personality too. most of SM artist is just..... a perfect idols
*uhuk* Irene*uhuk*
@@triwijiyanto9635 maybe not all 😉
I agree with everything that u said except personality. We cannot claim that as facts for we don't hang with them 24/7 nor know them personally. So yes.
I think SM was lucky to have all the girls as trainees and debuted them as Girls' Generation.
@@triwijiyanto9635 irene’s issue was abt their personnel who didn’t do they job properly. every “boss” would scold a worker whose not doing their work properly.
Wow even the members who aren't in charge of singing are so stable even while dancing. And Taeyeon is ofc a powerhouse.
This one is for the haters who says snsd members can't sing
Just look at them singing while dancing , snsd are not legends for nothing
Snsd queens of visuals dancing and vocals 💗💗♥️😊
아니 큰 공연장이나 야외무대는 그렇다치고
도대체 음악방송에서 ar을 떡칠해대는거임? 수차례 리허설이랑 사녹으로 거의 진행하는데
중간중간 추임새나 백보컬 박자들어갈 타이밍 빼고는 생라이브 해야 하는거아님? 그래야 보는 맛이있지 가수인데
소시는 진짜 대단한거 같음 실력이 원래 받쳐주니깐
이런말해봤자 요즘돌판 덕후들은 지들가수들이 라이브겁나 잘하는줄앎ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 무대에서 AR없는 라이브라곤 단한번도 안해본 가수 팬들이 지들끼리 까내리고 싸우는거보면 기가참
@@fnb8171 솔직히 콘서트도 AR충분히 깜.
@@fnb8171 그리고 요즘은 보정기술 좋아서 라이브여도 보정되고
@@fnb8171 응 느그돌 라이브한다고 착각하며 사는게 차라리 정신건강에 이롭겠다
솟시 실력 100 점 확인
One and only girls' generation
Missing them too😭
Now I just realized that tiffany was the backbone of snsd's choruses, omg after being sone about 10 years 😭
You'll know it's live when all you hear in the chorus is Tiffany's loud voice.
And seobb's breath
this is not a matter whether you got a good vocal technic or what. its the effort that counts. even snsd is not perfect from debut, they strive to be better for the sone. they dont want sone to be ashamed and dissapointed. and this video show their improvement. proud to be sone since 2009. cause snsd pride is sone. and sone pride is snsd.
like it also that theyre learning different languages to be able to communicate to their international fans
Thank you for this
Yes, always try their best for us Sones not only the money or anything else.
The only group who doesn't get traumatized whenever they will have to sing Live😊
Idk why i love ths comment 🤭
Yeah i agree with you... Girlgroup nowadays easily exhausted with one song plus fear of making mistake during live thats why they rely too much on backtrack or lipsync
SNSD already sing live in their first day on stage
여긴 구멍이 없어... 효연 라이브는 진짜 볼수록 놀랍다... 댄서인데도...👍🏻
Amazing. You can see even here the dance line, even Hyoyeon whose singing everyone always used to criticise, can sing extremely well even while dancing. This is the only nation's girl group. Most of this generation's groups can't even compare.
That's why they are the legendary KPOP girl group
소녀시대한텐 엠알이고 에이알이고 다 필요없음
그냥 소녀시대라는 이유로 완벽해버려서🤍
Yoona sings so good in the early eras (her falsetto in Girls Generation). At times, even best out of the dance line. She lost her confidence in singing due to the antis :((
I noticed that too!!
when you show this to others they will say "PRE-RECORDED"...
Stupid mindset of immature people tsk
Ikr HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA
They're underestimating the Nation's Girl Group 😌
It's because most of their faves nowadays are doing that. They can't relate to our goddesses 🤷♂️
생라이브 지린다....역시 소시...음향이 이상해도 전혀 불안하지가 않음
저때 모습 보면 왠지 눈물날것같다
진짜 윤아 진짜 이쁘다 지금나왔어도 엄청난리났을듯 윤아 태연 제시카 티파니소녀시대 4대장이였지 심지어 서현도ㅜ풋풋 지금보니 5명 미쳤다
당시 자주가던 연예계 관련 카페에서 소시 안티 진짜 많았는데 데뷔 무대였던가 그 다음 무대였던가 라이브를 다 잘해서 안티들 할말 잃었던 일 있었음 ㅋㅋㅋ
세대가 지날수록 재평가되는 소녀시대... 과거에 있지도 않았고 앞으로도 나오지 못할 소녀시대급 걸그룹
엠알 깔린 거랑 생라이브랑 구분 못하는 건 나뿐인가
언니들 나 라이브도 구분 못하는 바보로 만들었어ㅜ
엠알이 아니라 ar아니에요...?
jh와이 뭐든지간에요 그게 중요한 건 아니니까
@@user-de1317 많이 듣다보면 레코딩된 목소리 위에 라이브로 더블링하는게 들립니다
11:05
이게 생라이브지 다만세 안무에 저렇게 숨차면서 부르는데 요즘 라이브인척 라이브ar까는거 별론거 같음. 속이는것도 아니고 립싱크할거면 그냥 하는거지 굳이 왜 라이브ar하는건지..
근데 이렇게 생라이브도 충분히 잘하는 가수들까지 (소시, 보아) 똑같이 트렌드 따라가서 더 아쉽다구혀.....
소시 보아 나이도 좀 생각해조 나이 먹으면 더 힘들자너
@@user-lz9sw9nk7p ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개웃경ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 같이 늙어가는 처지에 이해는 하지만 아쉬운건 아쉬와ㅠ.ㅜ
2:57 키싱유 때 티파니 목소리는 진짜 다 들리네 ㅠㅠ 서현도 진짜 안정적임
8:04가 대박임ㅋㅋㄱㄱ 티파니랑 태연이랑 보컬대결함ㅋㅋ
역시 프로페셔널 👍 넘치는 실력과 최선을 다하는 태도가 돋보이는 소녀시대 ❤ 너무 존경하는 모습. 지소 앞소 영소 💖
Proof positive that Taeyeon had the best vocals in SNSD. Also proof that, yes, Hyoyeon could project and was highly underappreciated as a vocalist.
와 태연 서현.. 진짜 목소리 보물이다
힘내 영상 처음 나올 때 써니 목소리 진짜 너무 좋다
When i watch Taeyeon, I came to realize how hard she worked at her singing to make SNSD known. Of course everyone played their parts the best way too
now that's what you call the Nation's Girl Group 😌❤
I'm so thankful that I was born early than the newbie kpop fans because they don't know the real definition of main vocalist
And I present to you, the Nations' Girl Group for more than a decade!!
소시님들...ㅜㅜ(동갑인데 차마 반말하기좀 뭐해서..) 얼렁 컴백해서 1위 당당하게 차지해가지구 애들 코를 납작하게 해주세요!!! 1위는 정말 어렵게 받는 자리인데 그걸 당연하게 하는 모 그룹 때문에 연예계가 망하고 잇단...
1:44 효연 목소리 너무 좋다 ㅜㅜ