@@donjiedonjiedonjie leave? N go where? Do you want them to finish their careers for one member's mistake? She was hxrny n it's wasn't there fault. Shut this shxt up.
You will pay for this… I can’t believe you are taking advantage of the girls. Disgusting. My poor madein… gaeun:( I waiteddd so much for limelight and madein, but if I knew all of this and how u wanted to leave…for those reasons… we would all support you! You are so strong and brave.😞❤️
MADEIN’s GAEUN, a 19yo female idol that was SAed by her CEO who then tried to cover it up by claiming she went on a hiatus for “health reasons”… disgusting.
the editors in this video even had the guts to feature their names in the credits here after this monstrosity of an mv 😭 god fire these untalented people using ai is so cheap??
@slaytaurus9164 not by their own decision. the company relocated them; if you haven't seen their finale Japan concert as a 9 group; you can see that the members had been heartbroken. not everything is black and white. there's plenty of bts regarding the management and company dealing with talents. I gotta say, mashiro and yeseo had been relocated here. but aside from visual that had been heavily AI, that is also hardly their fault where they end up nor how the MV visuals had been. they're talent and whoever directed is lazy AF to not highlight talents on their beauty to abilities.
The song is genuinely so cute but the moment I saw that blank clay like texture I had to side eye, like they could have used extra footage that didn't make it or if they wanted something new they could have used props etc or done something cinematic ,like ai was not needed and I 100% bet they paid for it aswell
they 100% could just use footages for the two real locations because the AI parts don't link at all.... very unnecessary. some tiktok editors can do better than this....
They used drone shots so it's not just $5. The problem is the editing and visual effects. It's like there are 3 people with different ideas. 😂 One wanted a story MV and another wanted lots of ai and vfx.
The AI really cheapens the video... There's a whole deepfake scandal happening in South Korea right now and their producers really thought using AI was a good idea to use in their debut mv...
where's AI? and also that's the entire point is it was nonconsensual and this was.. you think its poor taste to use snapchat filters right now with dog ears on yourself?.... this wasn't even ai with the face it was just sets and practical effects... your being weird comparing this to the deepfake scandal right now honestly because its nowhere in the same level of violating
i feel like they somehow deleted clips and had to scramble and use ai like there's no way there wasn't enough clips filmed to make a whole mv??? the ai doesn't fit the rest of the mv too. the fact that this was supposed to release a whole 2 hours ago also gives me that idea
ai parts are so embarassing! i love yeshiro and i liked limelight so i will support girls but it's not something people out of this bubble would like to watch (i dont like to watch it to so I can't judge them). so much potetial and they just... throw it. I don't understand what happended because i remember limelight's mv to be nice
this is what i thought too. im just hoping that this is a pre release and not the actual debut track? everything limelight has put out is so much better :(
to support my theory, i just remembered the white and black outfits the girls talked about and you can see those outfits on their teasers too but you don’t see them here
They probably could have gotten away with using ai if it was only for small special effects details. Doing full on ai visual scenes probably wasn't a good idea lol
If it was a high school project theyd get an A+ but were talking about an effing industry here, if the company keeps lacking budget/effort on the mv theyll just stay nugu
Update (2) : The edited version of the MV has been posted on MADEIN’s channel as the "Natural Ver." Update : The CEO posted an apology on instagram and we should be getting an edited version of the MV without the AI scenes soon.I’m glad the company listened and I’ll keep supporting MADEIN even after this and so should everyone who liked tjis song before the girls deserve all the support they can get as they're clearly very skilled. Using AI for the mv is so disappointing,all the AI scenes look horrible but the rest of the MV is really pretty and the song is really good too.
True, could have done better but maybe because of budget that is why Does limelight have theories and stuff? Or the seem have storytelling is just in madein?
Using AI in a video is the best way to say: we don't have budget, we don't have taste, we are cheap and we think our artist don't deserve better. Like come on, the song is cute, you could have made something different with a storyline.
They don't have a budget because their are a small company. They didn't debut a lot of groups before and Madein are they first big project. Give them a break
@@kirbynaelgas6913their company chose to make them leave kep1er and join this. they were set to debut with limelight since they joined kep1er but they rebranded to madein
Why do people complain about AI so much. Howa bout you guys learn korean instead. Do something practical, useful. Not that you will, you guys only listen to title tracks lmao, kpop fandoms are hilarious. Nonstop complaining. No matter what. Maybe listen to the song, the MV is just there for the sake of being there. Look at western music videos lol, theyre low budget asf. Who cares. Go watch some disney movies if you want singing with a video lmao. 99% of users listen on spotify or tidal lmao.
As a kep1ian I'm so happy to see yeshiro redebut again 🥹 the song is so beautiful and the mv looks nice although they should've just not added the ai clips tho. I'm definitely gonna stan them now.
AI..? Do you mean CGI? Or did you hear somewhere they were actually using AI-generated art? There are major outstanding legal risks with using AI-generated art for commercial purposes, so I'd be interested/surprised to actually see it used on such a public product, especially in a jurisdiction with copyright laws as strict as Korea. Only asking because I'm genuinely curious
I won't claim the whole MV is AI generated. I don't think anyone is assuming that. They could have probably used CGI for some shots. But there are very suspicious momments like the solo shots between 1:18 - 1:22 . The sequence is a classic AI generated image. The biggest giveaway is the fact that they don't even look like the girls. Had this been Girls doing stuff with a green background with CGI, their faces would be clearly recognizable every time. And wouldn't deviate too much. Mashiro & Yeseo have 2.5 years worth of MV's to compare their faces by so at least kep1er fans can CLEARLY see that these aren't authentic images of them in a studio. Regardless, they have just debuted and they will probably release MV behind the scene videos later on and explain all this. We will see what was an actual set and what wasn't. Also, even if they did use AI, there is still music and live performances to look forward too so it isn't that big of a deal ( just a really sketchy choice that makes it seem cheap )
@@BlackkTigerstop trying to defend it is it clearly ai. The “girls” aren’t even looking at the camera and it all has this very air brushed and incomplete look to it. Also extremely uncanny. Whereas CGI wi give a more rounded, completed look bc there is a human behind it actively checking to make sure it’s done right and looks normal.
I really hope that LIMELIGHT as the original trio is still a separate group as Madein. They were doing great as is. I liked their style way more. They didn't need more members.
Well Limelight was originally supposed to debut with 5, if Yeseo and Mashiro didn’t make it onto Gp999 and into Kep1er they were going to debut in Limelight as a backup plan. This isn’t Limelight and tbh their style really didn’t garner a lot of popularity, maybe with Mashiro and Yeseo they’ll become more popular, staying a trio from a nugu company isn’t gonna pay the bills.
i was SO HAPPY to see yeshiro debut even after the UNTIMELY disaster of pulling them out of kep1er but i am so disappointed in the AI videos like that just screams unprofessionalism and laziness to me like you would think with the amount of work that goes into debuting and planning would make the mv good but it is so rushed, im so sorry to the madein girls and yeshiro because when they look at the mv theyre gonna be like wt/f is that... like at 1:23 that is NOT mashiro that is evilshiro where IS MY GIRL
Evilshiro lol but for real tho! Those are not the girls, those are ai generated garbages that have no soul. The company had to put their faces in some ai website to do this and I wonder if the girls even consented, it’s so disrespectful to them and their hard-work like why did you even put them on set if it’s to do this. I wish it was like Limelight MVs
To the remaining girls, please LEAVE. Justice for GAEUN
@@donjiedonjiedonjie leave? N go where? Do you want them to finish their careers for one member's mistake? She was hxrny n it's wasn't there fault. Shut this shxt up.
This company is not safe for these girls. Please let them go free from this abusive CEO. GaEun deserves justice and respect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You will pay for this… I can’t believe you are taking advantage of the girls. Disgusting. My poor madein… gaeun:( I waiteddd so much for limelight and madein, but if I knew all of this and how u wanted to leave…for those reasons… we would all support you! You are so strong and brave.😞❤️
Im so sad #WE_DEMAND_JUSTICE
#STAY_SAFE_GAEUN
#MABYS_ARE_WITH_GAEUN
#PROTECT_GAEUN
I knew putting Yeseo and Mashiro in some nugu company would ruin their careers.
I hate 143 entertainment.
Free every single member
I said that from the start that they should rejoin KEP1ER 😢
AIより本人たちの方が圧倒的に自然で可愛いことが証明された
PLEASE JUSTICE FOR GAEUN THE PEOPLE HAVES TO KNOW...
生成AIを使ったことは残念だけど、このMVを見てどんなにAIが発展しようとも生身の人間は生身の人間に惹かれるんだと強く感じた
まだそこまで発展してないだけでは？
まだそこまで発展してないだけでは？
la ia aún es un bebé, espera a que se perfeccione a ver si seguirás diciendo lo mismo JAJA
MADEIN’s GAEUN, a 19yo female idol that was SAed by her CEO who then tried to cover it up by claiming she went on a hiatus for “health reasons”… disgusting.
the editors in this video even had the guts to feature their names in the credits here after this monstrosity of an mv 😭 god fire these untalented people using ai is so cheap??
The mv is great, I hate the AI in the video, it ruined it,
Plus, this group deserves better
Concordo. Esse produtor deveria ser preso por ter ganhado dinheiro com essa bosta de MV
If I somehow had anything to do with this horrifying mess I would be so embarrassed, wow those untalented editors are so brave
i take back what i said months ago. i was so ignorant. these girls are NOT in good hands. please stay safe :(
this is tragic
Justice for gaeun
BOYCOTT 143 ENTERTAINMENT! #WE_DEMAND_JUSTICE
#STAY_SAFE_GAEUN
#MABYS_ARE_WITH_GAEUN
#PROTECT_GAEUN
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN
AI問題は解決した
曲は良い、メンバーは抜群に可愛い
みんなもっと再生しよう！
解決したん？
してないよ
@@さたさ-c4xAIなしのMVが出ているから解決できているのだと思います！
AI生成ばっか言われてるけど音楽に関してはほんとに凄い、めちゃくちゃトラックおしゃれでかっこいい
AIのせいでMVの見栄えが悪くなるので、みんなががっかりするのも分かる
曲が微妙に感じるのはMVのせいだったのかな…
tu mens papa le mv est nul sans vouloir etre mechante hein
楽曲も生成AIなのかなw
こんなことならいっそダンス 動画だけで良かった
The company really had the guts to pull out Yeseo and Mashiro from Kep1er just to debut this group and blatantly use AI-made media. 💀💀
I know! What a waste! 😭 These girls deserve better! And I miss them in kep1er! 😢💔
I like them better here. Kepler never stopped being messy
so you’re telling me they left kep1er where they were successful, to be HERE? okay…
@@Kaybye555yes you are right a least here they have lines and screentime
@slaytaurus9164 not by their own decision. the company relocated them; if you haven't seen their finale Japan concert as a 9 group; you can see that the members had been heartbroken. not everything is black and white. there's plenty of bts regarding the management and company dealing with talents.
I gotta say, mashiro and yeseo had been relocated here. but aside from visual that had been heavily AI, that is also hardly their fault where they end up nor how the MV visuals had been. they're talent and whoever directed is lazy AF to not highlight talents on their beauty to abilities.
Delaying the mv for production quality just for it to contain these much AI
Yeah, i don't understand it. The AI's presence completly thrown of the vibe...
they're have so much potential and visual but why using AI...
definitely not needed!
ikr like the song is a bop but wtf is the mv?? worst mv I have seen in a while
It looks a noob produced. Not professional at all!! Good song though
The song is genuinely so cute but the moment I saw that blank clay like texture I had to side eye, like they could have used extra footage that didn't make it or if they wanted something new they could have used props etc or done something cinematic ,like ai was not needed and I 100% bet they paid for it aswell
Fr and the transitions 💀💀
they 100% could just use footages for the two real locations because the AI parts don't link at all.... very unnecessary. some tiktok editors can do better than this....
the worst part is that it's on purpose, there's a ''natural'' version that's still got some ai shots, but they're not so blatant.
this song is so good, but the video definitely gives $5 and a dream
They used drone shots so it's not just $5. The problem is the editing and visual effects. It's like there are 3 people with different ideas. 😂 One wanted a story MV and another wanted lots of ai and vfx.
You have a sh##ty 5 dollar taste along with your 5 dollar clothes. Gtfo.
The ceo destroyed both kep1er and madein. Free these girls !!!!
The AI really cheapens the video...
There's a whole deepfake scandal happening in South Korea right now and their producers really thought using AI was a good idea to use in their debut mv...
yeah the timing really makes it an especially poor choice
THIS!
where's AI? and also that's the entire point is it was nonconsensual and this was.. you think its poor taste to use snapchat filters right now with dog ears on yourself?.... this wasn't even ai with the face it was just sets and practical effects... your being weird comparing this to the deepfake scandal right now honestly because its nowhere in the same level of violating
yall say this but when aespa do it, yall go crazy and think its unique
the video was probably done before the scandal
ひっさびさに清純コンセプトに振り切ってるグルでてきた、、超いい
あたらいメンバーになったfifty fiftyも清楚グルだからコンセプト的にライバルになりそう
This whole MV look atrocious fire the editor. The transition looking like a power point presentation
REAL
Help I’m combusting
FR
RIGHTTT
Just imagine if this was edited on ppt actually 😀😭
i feel like they somehow deleted clips and had to scramble and use ai like there's no way there wasn't enough clips filmed to make a whole mv??? the ai doesn't fit the rest of the mv too. the fact that this was supposed to release a whole 2 hours ago also gives me that idea
The editing also is very amateurish (swipe transitions)
ai parts are so embarassing! i love yeshiro and i liked limelight so i will support girls but it's not something people out of this bubble would like to watch (i dont like to watch it to so I can't judge them). so much potetial and they just... throw it. I don't understand what happended because i remember limelight's mv to be nice
this is what i thought too. im just hoping that this is a pre release and not the actual debut track? everything limelight has put out is so much better :(
to support my theory, i just remembered the white and black outfits the girls talked about and you can see those outfits on their teasers too but you don’t see them here
I agree. That was my first thought too. It’s very unfortunate that the music video has turned out like this 😭 But at least the Songs are stunning
MVの件、編集し直して数日以内に新しいverのものが公開されるみたいです。曲はとても良いのにMVのAIだけが謎だったから本当に安心…
本当ですか！？良かった、、
対応が速いのは素晴らしいですね
嬉しい❤
@@みしゃちゃん-z1x imfdmこのアカウントのインスタのストーリーに載ってました！社長さんかな、？
@@みしゃちゃん-z1x社長のインスタのストーリー
グループの可愛い系の子達を集めたって感じがして眼福だわ。全体的にバブっぽさと儚さが併存してて、清純なコンセプトがすごく合ってると思った。
the ai.... and the messy transitions..... im speechless
also the the credits font and placement...
I feel like they were just too lazy to make an high quality MV with a lot of effort or they just broke now idk😭
@@KirbyGirl broke ≠ lack of creativity and effort, some groups litterely can rock some white ass wall backround
They probably could have gotten away with using ai if it was only for small special effects details. Doing full on ai visual scenes probably wasn't a good idea lol
dont forget the meaningless random lyrics..... i hope they do better in the future
this is insane actually 😭😭 it looks like a high school project, they’re really setting these girls up
If it was a high school project theyd get an A+ but were talking about an effing industry here, if the company keeps lacking budget/effort on the mv theyll just stay nugu
It got me laughing bc of how bad it is
@icythang exactly. It's an A+ in highschool standards. HIGHSCHOOL!!! not a damn professional🤣🤣
MASHIRO FINALLY GOT THE RECOGNITION SHE DESERVEESSSSS BUT DAMNNN THE AI PARTS THREW ME OFF SO BAD
なんか映像に一貫性がない気がする...「いい構図思いついた！」ってものを繋ぎ合わせただけに見える。
めっちゃそれだ！
背景とかならまだしもAIで顔加工するとかありえない
各々が理想のビジュアルになれるように血の滲む努力をしてるのに、簡単な操作でいわゆる美人を無限に生産できるAIの、まさにその質感で顔を上書きされてるのはメンバーへのリスペクトを全く感じない
それに彼女たちは綺麗な衣装を着て自分のためのセットでMVを撮るっていう機会すら奪われてるわけだし、コストカットのためにAIに居場所を奪われてるって思ってしまって辛い
努力を踏み躙らないで
あくまで新しい技術を取り入れようとしだけで、メンバーの顔を加工しようという意図はないでしょ。流石にひねくれすぎ。
小さい事務所だけど、かなり金かけてるほうだよ。
ライムライトも知らないくせに、外野が好き勝手叩くの本当に害でしかない。
Update (2) : The edited version of the MV has been posted on MADEIN’s channel as the "Natural Ver."
Update : The CEO posted an apology on instagram and we should be getting an edited version of the MV without the AI scenes soon.I’m glad the company listened and I’ll keep supporting MADEIN even after this and so should everyone who liked tjis song before the girls deserve all the support they can get as they're clearly very skilled.
Using AI for the mv is so disappointing,all the AI scenes look horrible but the rest of the MV is really pretty and the song is really good too.
the sad part: they could easily get a better outcome by investing in outfits and cgi
Przestań narzekać typie 😂
True, could have done better but maybe because of budget that is why
Does limelight have theories and stuff? Or the seem have storytelling is just in madein?
There’s AI?😭😭😭
Interesting chorus. 😊
サムネなごみなの天才すぎる。
それな！
デビュー曲でサムネが和一人の顔面ドアップなかなかすごいよね笑
推されてるのかな？
1人だけ載せるとかあり得なさすぎて、
和1pickだったし、可愛いんだけどデビュー曲はみんなでよかったかなと。
これから変わるかも知れないけど。
Using AI in a video is the best way to say: we don't have budget, we don't have taste, we are cheap and we think our artist don't deserve better. Like come on, the song is cute, you could have made something different with a storyline.
They don't have a budget because their are a small company. They didn't debut a lot of groups before and Madein are they first big project. Give them a break
@@eti9793 the ia use still being a dumb thing to do, they can do a good mv like Starligth for example
@@eti9793 Not an excuse, other small companies are doing without AI. It's a choice.
@@eti9793Have you seen Limelight MVs?? Literally what happened to the quality
@@eti9793The ai was their choice, they were bragging about it on a a post. How did they think this was a good idea??
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN. Unfollowed and unsubscribed.
Our MASHIRO convinced 143 boss to make UNO the title track and I understand her, this song is magical.
Really? Chef Ma is amazing then 😮❤
What was the original title track?
@@dianeatup3238 Dadarida
I read it as she convinced 143 boss, as 143 people lol until I remembered this was the name of the company.
@@Raphael-2Lol 😂
i cant even imagine how the members would react to this, especially yeseo and mashiro. going from a high quality mv to this?😭
lowk 😭 I'd rather have the performance video than the ai
why did they leave kepler?
@@kirbynaelgas6913their company chose to make them leave kep1er and join this. they were set to debut with limelight since they joined kep1er but they rebranded to madein
Why do people complain about AI so much. Howa bout you guys learn korean instead. Do something practical, useful. Not that you will, you guys only listen to title tracks lmao, kpop fandoms are hilarious. Nonstop complaining. No matter what. Maybe listen to the song, the MV is just there for the sake of being there. Look at western music videos lol, theyre low budget asf. Who cares. Go watch some disney movies if you want singing with a video lmao. 99% of users listen on spotify or tidal lmao.
Because their contract 2.5 years only when in Kep1er and they have contract in new agency before join GP999@@kirbynaelgas6913
As a kep1ian I'm so happy to see yeshiro redebut again 🥹 the song is so beautiful and the mv looks nice although they should've just not added the ai clips tho. I'm definitely gonna stan them now.
AI..? Do you mean CGI? Or did you hear somewhere they were actually using AI-generated art? There are major outstanding legal risks with using AI-generated art for commercial purposes, so I'd be interested/surprised to actually see it used on such a public product, especially in a jurisdiction with copyright laws as strict as Korea. Only asking because I'm genuinely curious
@@BlackkTiger trust me, as an artist myself, i can pick out AI pretty easily and this MV is full of it. there's no mistaking it for CGI.
I won't claim the whole MV is AI generated. I don't think anyone is assuming that. They could have probably used CGI for some shots. But there are very suspicious momments like the solo shots between 1:18 - 1:22 . The sequence is a classic AI generated image. The biggest giveaway is the fact that they don't even look like the girls. Had this been Girls doing stuff with a green background with CGI, their faces would be clearly recognizable every time. And wouldn't deviate too much. Mashiro & Yeseo have 2.5 years worth of MV's to compare their faces by so at least kep1er fans can CLEARLY see that these aren't authentic images of them in a studio.
Regardless, they have just debuted and they will probably release MV behind the scene videos later on and explain all this. We will see what was an actual set and what wasn't.
Also, even if they did use AI, there is still music and live performances to look forward too so it isn't that big of a deal ( just a really sketchy choice that makes it seem cheap )
@@BlackkTigerstop trying to defend it is it clearly ai. The “girls” aren’t even looking at the camera and it all has this very air brushed and incomplete look to it. Also extremely uncanny. Whereas CGI wi give a more rounded, completed look bc there is a human behind it actively checking to make sure it’s done right and looks normal.
@@BlackkTiger 143ent. said they used ai to produce the mv
AIを使うシーンがあるくらいなら全て彼女らのダンスパフォーマンスで十分だったよね。素晴らしいメンバーでの再出発だったのに作品がこれで悲しい。
彼女らの実力や努力の問題ではない。製作側の問題であると感じる。
だよねー、個々の素質が大きいだけに何か出し切れてない気がする。次に期待だ！
選りすぐりの素材揃っているのに調理失敗したみたいな。
もしかしたら、、予算が足りなくて、、、だったら
@@SHIO-ks4sdlimelightは少なくともこのMVより予算かけてた印象がある
JERSEY CLUBサウンドなの流石すぎる最高！！！まさかせりなごがこのトレンドに乗るとは。
Also got some stutter house element
MADEINデビューおめでとう🎉
和ちゃん一生ワンピック！
ずっと味方でいるからやりたいこと何でもチャレンジしてね！
NASTY CEO . SAVE THE GIRLS FROM THIS COMPNY
AIのせいで顔が歪むMVとか前代未聞すぎる。自社のアイドルの一番売り出したいのは顔でしょ…売り出す気本当にある…？
ほんとに、、、これは酷すぎる
期待してただけに残念、、、、、
真偽までは分からないのですが、最近の犯罪関連の対策として変更に至ったのでは？という見解もあるみたいです…😢
どちらにせよ、皆の実写パートが減りすぎて寂しいですね、、
@@tktks_mdn 批判とかでは全然なく純粋な疑問で、AI利用が犯罪の対策になる可能性があるんですか？
というか韓国では数日前に生成AIディープフェイクポルノの対策で、規制を打ち出す方針が決まってる位、問題のある技術を
デビューという一番大事なタイミングのPVに採用しちゃったプロデューサーがヤバい、アイドルをもっと大切にしろよ
Los productores de aespa hicieron lo mismo en Supernova
LIMELIGHT、Kep1er、日プの全ての良さが詰まってる🫶
wtf is this... the ai????
143 didn't renew yeshiro contract in kep1er just to give them a sh1t mv for their redebut😭
ぶっちゃけこのバージョンも悪くない
色彩はこっちのが好き
まあ事務所が儲かればもっとお金かけて色々作ってくれるはずなので買うーみんな応援しよー
we love you yeshiro congrats on your debut, but why did they used AI with this...
MADEINデビューおめでとう！！MADEIN最高だよ！！MADEINが花道を歩み幸せでありますように。
舞白ちゃんが恋してる表情する所儚い
和もせりなも最高にかわいいし元々デビューしてた5人は貫禄があって最高のグループができたな
AIのパート全部消して欲しい、全然合っていない😭
良い曲なのに勿体無い
同じ人いたーー！本人をみたいのに！！！
だよねだよね🥺🥺🥺🥺
マシロがこんな演技上手とは知らなかった！後半めっちゃいい！🥰
きっともうAIは使わないだろうと信じてます😂
#justiceforGaeun #WeStandWithMadein
#WeStandWithGaeun
MADEINおめでとう！！！今まで3人で頑張ってきてこうして他界隈とも繋いでくれたミユスへガウンも、アイドルを続けると決めてくれたイェシロも、アイドルとして輝く姿を見せてくれたせりなごも、全員大切で全員大好きです！！花道を歩こうね！！！
え、なんでこんな言葉入れたら作成してくれるAIアートのMVなん…顔も不自然笑…曲いいのに😭
全く同じこと思いました😢
このグループが大好きです…😢
無くならないでほしい…
出た方がいいでしょ、もっといいとこに。メンバーがかわいそうだよ
私たちの推しが愛のある運営の元で活動できますように…
まさかの、社長がメンバーに性的暴行を与える人だとは思いませんでした。ショックです。絶句です。
ガウンは本当に辛かったはず。考えただけで涙が出ます。
大切な女の子たちをこれ以上傷つけないで。社長は今すぐ去勢しろ、辞任しろ。
デビュー前から応援してきた女の子たちがこんな社長が居る会社にいるのが辛すぎる。なんでこうなるんだろう、なんで社長が潰すの
LIMELIGHTのMVは低予算を感じなかったのに、MADEINになると急に低予算を感じる、？？
曲やコンセプトは儚い感じでLIMELIGHTでは見れなかった部分が見れて嬉しい！！
キャッチーなメロディとノスタルジックな映像が素敵です
日本語で文を書けよ。
AI生成で豪華に見せたかったんだろうけどAI特有の見飽きた描写で余計安っぽさ出てる。安っぽいのにインパクトだけ大きいからメインであるアイドルの良さが半減してる。
ZEROSEです！デビューおめでとうございます！イェソとマシロ以外は知らずに見たんですがみんなかわいい！歌もいいしどこか儚さを感じる素敵なMVですね素晴らしい！これからの活躍がたのしみ！
ナチュラルver.出たんだからもうAI云々コメントせんでも。。。
良いコメントで溢れますように
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN JUSTICE FOR MADEIN
#BOYCOTT143ENT
#WeStandWithMadein
#WeStandWithGaeun
( The song is so beautiful )
小さい事務所だし低予算なのは仕方ないんだけど、今これだけディープフェイクポルノが問題になってるなかあえて生成AIを使ったこと、それも決してメンバーへのリスペクトが感じられる仕上がりではないことは批判されて然るべきだと思う
言いたい事は分かるけど流石に厳しすぎないか？
決して雑に扱ってるわけじゃないと思うよ。今までライムライトをのんびり平和に推してきたのに、過激なファンで荒れない事を祈るわ
2:14 BRUH THIS TRANSITION RIGHT HERE
Ok and
@@federicavalentini2314 u must be livid w the debut but this mv is a literal garbage. i feel sad for the girls
its like they put no investment in this
Straight up powerpoint presentation my goodness.
制服＋可愛い系の顔で日本のアイドルみたい
曲はお洒落で想像より良かった
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN JUSTICE FOR MADEIN #BOYCOTT143ENT #WeStandWithMadein #WeStandWithGaeun
Fire the editor for this mv IMMEDIATELY
CEO is scum. I hope these poor girls escape
kep1ianです。イェシロの門出が誇らしい気持ちと寂しい気持ちを抱えながらUNOとShooting Starを交互に聞いて儚さに浸ってます
Mカ投票もしてきたよ。素敵なデビュー活動になりますように
The C.E.O is going to do a new MV, let’s support the girls no matter what 💖✨🎀🦢
I knew it got recommended because of something kpop related, glad Yeseo and Mashiro debuted!
生成AI・・・みんなかわいいのにもったいない
それな…AIについてのコメントなくて思ってるのもしかして自分だけ？って思ってたから安心。
AIなんですか!?
@@sa.0414途中で結構使われてます、、
背景だけかと思ったら多分人も？だよね？みんな可愛いのになんでわざわざAIを使うのか…AIの部分だけ不自然で不気味…
@@sa.0414 本人の顔を元に一部生成A I使ってると思います。
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN
#BOYCOTT143ENT
#WeStandWithMadein
#WeStandWithGaeun
曲はいつも通り良いけど、なぜにAI？
ともあれ新メンバーを加えての再出発に幸あれ✨
本当曲もメンバーの雰囲気もいいなあ～気づいたら再生してる！AI無し版楽しみ
as a native spanish speaker, i love how madein counted 1,2,3... in the lyrics plus the song is so catchy
#WeprotectGaeun
Kep1ianです！
MADEINデビューおめでとう🎉
舞白ちゃんをもっと大きなステージへ…！
リーダーは大変だけど頑張れー！
あなたならできる！
舞白醬就是正!那睿緒呢?
MASHIRO、MiU、睿序 鐵三角
This mv....I just want yeseo and mashiro back kep1er...🥲
@Idontwantahandlem but Yujin is 27y old and shes worried!
@Idontwantahandlem If not about the contract issue. cj must butter than 143.
It is a small probability that a small company can make money。
kep1ianです。イェシロ！2人が幸せに活動できることを心から願ってるよ；；
正直まだ心が追いついてなくて寂しい気持ちもあるけど、kep1ianがずっと傍で見守ってることを忘れないで！応援してるよ！！！ファイティン😭💜
JUSTICE FOR GAEUN AND ALL THE GIRLS!! 😡
노래도 괜찮고 컨셉 좋길래 다행이다 싶었는데 뮤비 무슨 일이예요..?????
챗 gpt가 그린 거임..?? 너무 ㅈ소 그자체라 좀 많이 당황함 우리 예시로 잘 챙겨주세요..ㅠㅠ
I think so too
なごみちゃんとましろちゃんイェソちゃんが同じグループにいるのが嬉しすぎる
なごみちゃんのクールな感じのお顔が好きすぎる
まさかの、社長がメンバーに性的暴行を与える人だとは思いませんでした。ショックです。絶句です。
ガウンは本当に辛かったはず。考えただけで涙が出ます。
大切な女の子たちをこれ以上傷つけないで。社長は今すぐ去勢しろ、辞任しろ。
デビュー前から応援してきた女の子たちがこんな社長が居る会社にいるのが辛すぎる。なんでこうなるんだろう、なんで社長が潰すの
誠意のある回答を待っています。
Justice for Gaeun . .we love you gaeun
I really hope that LIMELIGHT as the original trio is still a separate group as Madein. They were doing great as is. I liked their style way more. They didn't need more members.
Well Limelight was originally supposed to debut with 5, if Yeseo and Mashiro didn’t make it onto Gp999 and into Kep1er they were going to debut in Limelight as a backup plan. This isn’t Limelight and tbh their style really didn’t garner a lot of popularity, maybe with Mashiro and Yeseo they’ll become more popular, staying a trio from a nugu company isn’t gonna pay the bills.
運営は新しい事に挑戦しただけ。
過剰な批判は良くないし、デビュー曲が否定的な意見ばかりなのは見てて良い気持ちにならないよ😢
新しいverを作り直すみたいだけど、それによって再生回数が分散してしまうほうが心配だね。
i was SO HAPPY to see yeshiro debut even after the UNTIMELY disaster of pulling them out of kep1er but i am so disappointed in the AI videos like that just screams unprofessionalism and laziness to me like you would think with the amount of work that goes into debuting and planning would make the mv good but it is so rushed, im so sorry to the madein girls and yeshiro because when they look at the mv theyre gonna be like wt/f is that... like at 1:23 that is NOT mashiro that is evilshiro where IS MY GIRL
Evilshiro lol but for real tho! Those are not the girls, those are ai generated garbages that have no soul. The company had to put their faces in some ai website to do this and I wonder if the girls even consented, it’s so disrespectful to them and their hard-work like why did you even put them on set if it’s to do this. I wish it was like Limelight MVs
최신 ai기술 도입 나쁘지 않아요 표현이 다양한 장면을 가능하게 한거니
bffr @@cheeseburger516
@@cheeseburger516no ai at its current state looks dogshit
@@izkmj facts
케플러 제대로 알게된지 6개월 정도 됐는데 너무 아쉽다. 재능 이렇게 쓰게 할거면 돌려줘…
MADEINデビューおめでとう！！！
みんなが幸せになれる未来でありますように！！
MADEIN デビューおめでとう！！
楽曲がおしゃれでとても素敵！！
なごみ！デビューおめでとうだよ💛
素敵な道を歩み続けれますように
今MADEINが頑張っているのにAIの話はもういいじゃないですか
Naturalバージョンも出て解決しました
デビューおめでとっ！！
マシロちゃん可愛すぎるし、最後のイェシロも最高〜🤍🤍
早く会いたいな〜
イェシロ再デビューおめでとう！
みんな初恋ビジュすぎるよー♡
the use of AI is disgusting, why would you put this out
such a disrespect for all of the girls
MABYなら分かるこの子たちの努力
無駄にしてはいけません
LOVE THE SONG BUT HELP!.. THE AI SCENES IM DEAD! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
LIKE I WAS SHOOK AND CRIED AFTER THE AIS SCENES I CANT...
MADEINデビューおめでとう！
芹菜デビューを諦めないでくれてありがとう🩵💙
一曲で2パターンMVあって、ひとつは芸術的でもう一つは自然体って考えたら最高なのでは……