This episode is a stable time loop guys. That's like the opposite of the multiverse theory. It's the concept that time is self-consistent, any attempt to change the past will create the past you were trying to prevent. Celestia didn't need to be involved, it's just how time travel works in Equestria.
well multiverse can still exist since Twi didn't do anything to change the past (EX: kill herself, [watch?v=zaaEB0eKiRs]) she just fellow what her "future" self do, and somehow make a curcle....
***** If multiverse time travel is possible it requires a different spell than the one Twilight used in this episode. And that's exactly what I said, it's a stable time loop, a circle of time where the outcome cannot change. And honestly I think time parodox's as an actual physical threat need to be reserved for soft sci-fi because in all accounts it doesn't make much sense. The multiverse theory works because a timeline is by definition, a series of events that happened change the events and you change the timeline/universe. The idea that time can be destablized is non-sense because science has show that time is actually a subjective aspect of reality and thus isn't a force in and of itself.
Multiverse isn't mutually exclusive with stable. Alternate universe are often formed by quantum mechanics or as the result of different possibilties. For an example of mutilple universe that clearly didn't involve time travel there's "The Farnsworth Parabox" in Futurama. There the difference between the two universes wasn't a change caused by time travel, but the fact that coin flips held the opposite result. This is a take on a quantum mechanics thought experiment where a single coin flip leads to an entirely different set of events occuring in the long run. Granted neither time travel nor quantum mechanics REALLY explains how the EQG universe is so similar to regular Equestria. The best I can come up with is some kind of bastardized quantum entanglement which ensures that everything that happens in one universe is reflected in the other. Quantum mechanics is extremely complicated.
Kaitlyn McCaffrey so where did you get your degree on quantum mechanics, I mean all this unsupported rambling without a source is completely useless because without a source no one knows what theory you are using, unless you have a degree in quantum mechanics and proposed your own. even then unless it was published it would still be a load of rambling.
This episode: "But if he's here, then all the ancient evil creatures that have been imprisoned there could escape and destroy Equestria!" "Great. I got him back before any of the evil creatures could escape." Twilight's Kingdom: "Scorpan returned to his own land, and Tirek was sent to Tartarus for his crimes. But it appears he has found a way to escape." "We believe it happened when Cerberus left his post at the gates." And this is not a sin why?
I never even noticed that the first time. Who thought that that's how you say it!? It almost sounds like there's supposed to be a pun in there, like it's Tar-_Taurus_, but that doesn't make sense since the characters aren't bovine.
It may be pronounced like that in Canada. For a reason I do not understand people in the UK say tah-tah sauce and It could well be that Candians say it the same way
Rhino Dartey Coincidentally, I'M FROM CANADA! We don't have the habit of often saying Tartarus, but I've never heard it said like Twilight says it here.
Rhino Dartey Europeans as a whole don't always pronounce things like Americans. Example "Uranus". its CORRECT pronunciation was "U-ran-nus" and this is what the rest of European similarity pronounces it in however they spell it. these days everyone says "ur-Rain-nus" even here in the UK. I tend to think since English originated from England that our way is the "correct" way of saying English. Trouble is, saying this always leads to arguments. Even down to "colour" or "color". (The "U" is a voiceless vowel and not spoken, it signals a pronunciation slide). I'm actually not sure how to say "Tartarus "... Its not a typical word spoken in everyday life. I imagine how its spoken in this episode, however, is closer. :-/
Master Markus Yeah most people seem to go with the other way of saying it but I was just theorising it on the basis that her in the UK we say tartar sauce similar to the way twilight says tartarus, again not sure how canadians say it but I thought it could well be similar to the british way of saying it as Canada uses a mixture of british and American pronunciations
there is also one major sin...this isn't possible, even in a world of magic. Something has to happen first to cause the loop, kind of like the grandson killing his grandfather paradox, so twilight would never worry about any thing bcuz her time traveling self wouldn't go back in time if she hadn't worried about anything
This actually correspond as a "self-sufficient" time theory. Time travels can be justified by themself. And no, it's not similar to the grandfather paradox, which presents a situation that prevents the travel to happen in the future. If we had to compare to another, it would be the song of storms paradox: Adult Link learn the song because young link sang it to that wierd music box guy, but young Link knows it because Adult Link went back in time to become young link ang sing the song to the guy. To sum up: time travels happens because they happened.
One thing i'll say in favor of this episode was the guard's reaction on finding her there made a lot more sense when they retconned that the captain of the guard is her older brother.
Actually, the time travel theory as presented in this episode is one of the most realistic versions in my opinion. It's basically the same thing used in Harry Potter 3: it's impossible to change the past. If you go back in time, it's because you were meant to go back in time; your time-traveling self was always part of the events you try to change. The timeline fits together like a jigsaw puzzle, and reality remains constant. Also, it's kind of sad that Harry Potter and My Little Pony are the only shows I've ever seen that get time travel right like this.
Tartarus is the GrecoRoman equivalent to Hell. Elysium/Heaven, Fields of Asphodel/Purgatory, Tartarus/Hell. Tartarus is where the Titans are imprisoned, but that's not it's only purpose.
WHEN I WAS A LITTLE PHILLY A GALLOPING BLAZE OVERTOOK MY CITY SO THEY SHIPPED ME OFF TO THE ORPHANAGE SAID DITCH THOSE ROOTS IF YOU WANNA FIT IN SO I DUG 1000 HOLES AND CUT A RUG WITH ORPHAN FOALS NOW MEMORIES ARE BLURRED AND FACES ARE OBSCURED BUT I STILL KNOW THE WORDS TO THIS SONG WHEN YOUVE BUNGLED ALL YOUR BANGLES AND YOUR LOVED ONE'S HAVE BEEN MANGLED LISTEN TO THE JINGLE JANGLE OF MY GYPSY TAMBOURINE!!
1:36 Imagine if Spike actually DID send someone directly to Celestia like that, accidentally or otherwise. THINK OF THE POSSIBILITIES! Garble - dead or sent to moon Fluttershy - onslaught of nervous stammering and apologies Derpy Hooves - cries incessantly until Celestia gives her a muffin (or alternatively, she appears and says, "I just don't know what went wrong!") Vinyl Scratch - karaoke with Celestia and/or Luna, which Cadence and/or at least one guard walks in on and an awkward silence ensues Rarity - "The WORST! POSSIBLE! THING!" Rainbow Dash - a situation that could stand to be 20% cooler Pinkie Pie - "IT'S PEANUT BUTTER JELLY TIME!" Twilight Sparkle - instantly faints, mortified, and proceeds to mumble the phrase, 'Notice me, Senpai' over and over until Celestia manages to wake her Applejack - "WUT IN TARNATION?!" Any (or all) of the Cutie Mark Crusaders - one of them says something stupid and Luna turns into Nightmare Moon Discord - "Well, THIS is awkward..." Maud Pie - a very dull conversation about rocks ensues The 'Great and Powerful' Trixie - same fate as Garble, except preceded by a very thorough spanking from Luna Owlowiscious - a lengthy reprise of the 'who' joke Angel Bunny - Celestia is found dead by the guards, drowned in a pool of her own blood Queen Chrysalis - the Equestrian apocalypse ensues Spike - total mindfuck for all involved
1:33 it's not racist, RD was trying to protect the poor mouse, which would have been crushed to death by Twi's hooves had she not warned her about said mouse.
You missed the biggest sin of them all in this episode: Neither Celestia nor Luna checked Tartarus to make sure that a certain magic-sucking being was still there and didn't break free, thus starting to slowly suck up unicorn magic for two years until meeting up with Discord.
They forgot to add that twilight wouldn't have been stressed about anything if she hadn't gone back in time to warn herself and that she could have simply cast the time spell again and try to warn herself again!
***** Silly BlueFox, the answer was obvious, money makes the world go round. Thats why people who think they can rule the world are stupid, they forget we are already under the reign and power of paper and pieces of round metal.
People assume that _Time_ is a strict progression of cause to effect, but actually from a nonlinear, non-subjective viewpoint, it's more like a big ball of _Wibbly-Wobbly, Timey-Wimey stuff_...
Nerd time. Okay so, with time this is considered a Bootstrap Paradox: where someone goes into the past and a chain of certain events occur because of that time travel and later leads up to that person going into the past and those evens go on and on forever[until someone bonks it up and causes a paradox within the bootstrap paradox which will result in the universe collapsing in on itself] Now, there is no actual beginning point in the paradox, it's an event within itself and some more wibbily-wobbliy timey-wimey stuff.
I love these videos and i'm happily waiting for more. One missed chance for a sin: Twilight: Is there some epic pony war in the distant future? Sins Guy: Twilight Sparkle foreshadows Fallout: Equestria. (Ding)
41 is the total amount of sins... This was made on January 16th. So, you add 16 to 41, which is 57 The year is 2015. So you minus 57 by 20, which is 37. This video ends at 3:35. So you minus 37 by 35, which is 2. Since this was made in January, you add 1 more which makes it 3. The Eye of Providence (Illuminati) has 3 vertices. Illuminati confirmed in My Little Pony.
If you think about it, Twilight only went to visit herself after all these events happened. Her visit to her past self is the only reason she started worrying and went through all the events that occurs in the episode. So that means that there would have to be one first event that caused her to do all this without her visiting herself, so what caused the first event?
RUclips, All I want to do is watch a video, stop making me update. In a alternate time line where smell-o-vision was invented you have far more to complain about.
This episode is actually a good example of the Bootstrap Paradox. Essentially if A only happens because B goes back in time and warns A of future then A's future becomes B present. The main part of the paradox is if A only knows because B influenced them and B only knows because they were A, who started it
Dear bronies my little pony friendship is magic is leaving Netflix on February 2nd 2015 only equestria girls and rainbow rocks will remain please warn your friends too !
Paianni I realized i do actually have another way of watching mlp, but it dosent look as good as netflix does. I could also react to it with the Equestria's Reflection guys, i watch the vid and react to it with them. But i'm stil sad it's leaving netflix :(
Just to be pedantic, this episode features a closed time loop. The closed time loop makes perfect senses because, due entirely to the fact that information has in fact been sent backward in time to cause its own existence, causality MUST therefore function in reverse. It's not a loop, as we think of it with our puny, rational, linear human brains. It's just cause and effect working backwards. Which makes perfect sense according to quantum mechanics. Because quantum mechanics enjoys watching you suffer.
THE TITLE IS CONNECTED TO A PINKIE LINE OF TANKS FOR THE MEMORIES! "Or maybe an *its about time* party" does that mean this episode happened on the first day of spring?
When they say, "It's about time" they mean like when you're waiting for something for a long time and it finally comes you would say, "It's about time!"
'All of your fanfictions are now canon'... Well this just took a dark turn.
frick thats dark
Even the familiar one where pinkie pie brutally tourtures, kills, and bakes her friends into pastries?
I am an acorn. Cupcakes......
“In the rainbow factory”
your daily dose of anxiety
Don’t remind me
This episode is a stable time loop guys. That's like the opposite of the multiverse theory. It's the concept that time is self-consistent, any attempt to change the past will create the past you were trying to prevent. Celestia didn't need to be involved, it's just how time travel works in Equestria.
well multiverse can still exist since Twi didn't do anything to change the past (EX: kill herself, [watch?v=zaaEB0eKiRs]) she just fellow what her "future" self do, and somehow make a curcle....
*****
If multiverse time travel is possible it requires a different spell than the one Twilight used in this episode. And that's exactly what I said, it's a stable time loop, a circle of time where the outcome cannot change.
And honestly I think time parodox's as an actual physical threat need to be reserved for soft sci-fi because in all accounts it doesn't make much sense. The multiverse theory works because a timeline is by definition, a series of events that happened change the events and you change the timeline/universe. The idea that time can be destablized is non-sense because science has show that time is actually a subjective aspect of reality and thus isn't a force in and of itself.
Isn't multiverse theory made canon by EQG?
Multiverse isn't mutually exclusive with stable. Alternate universe are often formed by quantum mechanics or as the result of different possibilties. For an example of mutilple universe that clearly didn't involve time travel there's "The Farnsworth Parabox" in Futurama. There the difference between the two universes wasn't a change caused by time travel, but the fact that coin flips held the opposite result. This is a take on a quantum mechanics thought experiment where a single coin flip leads to an entirely different set of events occuring in the long run.
Granted neither time travel nor quantum mechanics REALLY explains how the EQG universe is so similar to regular Equestria. The best I can come up with is some kind of bastardized quantum entanglement which ensures that everything that happens in one universe is reflected in the other. Quantum mechanics is extremely complicated.
Kaitlyn McCaffrey
so where did you get your degree on quantum mechanics, I mean all this unsupported rambling without a source is completely useless because without a source no one knows what theory you are using, unless you have a degree in quantum mechanics and proposed your own. even then unless it was published it would still be a load of rambling.
This episode:
"But if he's here, then all the ancient evil creatures that have been imprisoned there could escape and destroy Equestria!"
"Great. I got him back before any of the evil creatures could escape."
Twilight's Kingdom:
"Scorpan returned to his own land, and Tirek was sent to Tartarus for his crimes. But it appears he has found a way to escape."
"We believe it happened when Cerberus left his post at the gates."
And this is not a sin why?
I mean, it's got continuity, and it's consistent. Maybe he mentions it in Twilight's Kingdom?
@@TheQuashingoftheTub you were 6 years late
You think she knows every evil creature in the entirety of Tartarus
I wish the episode was based off a purple unicorn taking Cerberus to the gates of hell :(
Then Twilight returns from her epic adventure...
"Wait... wasn't I trying to prevent a disaster happening in the future?" **credits**
SpectrumUK
I can't be the only one who instinctively started singing and humming the end credits theme afterwards, right? Right?
Same...
Iza Rose I wish it were about an ORANGE unicorn guiding Cerberus to the gates of hell. 🙀
Time line? Time isn't made of lines. It's made of circles. That is why clocks are round!
Bleep bloop, you got an achievable!
Hey chicka bum bum
Mind blown.
And they also aren't made of roads, because where were going, we don't need roads!
Sorry but I have to do this please don't kill me
"That's is" what is wrong about this
Why don't we rename "My little pony" into "It's about ponies."?
yes.
Yes
"It's about Ponies, Hal."
Best ending ever..."prevent the disaster in the future", well the disaster still comes months later...
You mean ‘years’... the Corona is here
@@ilovesharkz_ yes
@@ilovesharkz_ but that comment was 5 years ago
@@wixan
I know *that*
Cadence already existed, the disaster was only a matter of time.
I'm glad they later said Tartarus the normal way at the end of season 4. The Tar-tar-us thing was kind of strange.
I never even noticed that the first time. Who thought that that's how you say it!?
It almost sounds like there's supposed to be a pun in there, like it's Tar-_Taurus_, but that doesn't make sense since the characters aren't bovine.
It may be pronounced like that in Canada. For a reason I do not understand people in the UK say tah-tah sauce and It could well be that Candians say it the same way
Rhino Dartey
Coincidentally, I'M FROM CANADA! We don't have the habit of often saying Tartarus, but I've never heard it said like Twilight says it here.
Rhino Dartey Europeans as a whole don't always pronounce things like Americans. Example "Uranus". its CORRECT pronunciation was "U-ran-nus" and this is what the rest of European similarity pronounces it in however they spell it. these days everyone says "ur-Rain-nus" even here in the UK.
I tend to think since English originated from England that our way is the "correct" way of saying English. Trouble is, saying this always leads to arguments. Even down to "colour" or "color". (The "U" is a voiceless vowel and not spoken, it signals a pronunciation slide). I'm actually not sure how to say "Tartarus "... Its not a typical word spoken in everyday life. I imagine how its spoken in this episode, however, is closer. :-/
Master Markus Yeah most people seem to go with the other way of saying it but I was just theorising it on the basis that her in the UK we say tartar sauce similar to the way twilight says tartarus, again not sure how canadians say it but I thought it could well be similar to the british way of saying it as Canada uses a mixture of british and American pronunciations
I never expected you to use a bit of "Gypsy Bard" here!
I can't be the only one who thought there was going to be a gunshot at the end to "prevent the disaster in the future"
Nice reference.
Boi this is a show targeted for kids there can’t be any gunshots
Oh yes
there is also one major sin...this isn't possible, even in a world of magic. Something has to happen first to cause the loop, kind of like the grandson killing his grandfather paradox, so twilight would never worry about any thing bcuz her time traveling self wouldn't go back in time if she hadn't worried about anything
The bootstrap paradox
Celestia got bored again.
This actually correspond as a "self-sufficient" time theory. Time travels can be justified by themself. And no, it's not similar to the grandfather paradox, which presents a situation that prevents the travel to happen in the future.
If we had to compare to another, it would be the song of storms paradox: Adult Link learn the song because young link sang it to that wierd music box guy, but young Link knows it because Adult Link went back in time to become young link ang sing the song to the guy.
To sum up: time travels happens because they happened.
Krwzprtt Gentleman, our mothers were right all along...
*_Because yes_* is a valid argument!! :O
Oso_dobla_cabeza XD
*LittleshyFim confirmed as part of the audience*
Nice Deduction Captain Dumbass ALL MINI MINOTAURS LIKE TAR TAR SAUCE!!
For all we know flash sentry is season 5 main villain >:3 10s of thousands of bronies would agree lol
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!
Then 10s of thousands of bronies would be idiots.
there is no season 5. nor will there ever will be because the creator of it is now dead.......did i say that to calmly?
Step off Slashsentry!
Chrisroder a um no she isn't...
The Bootstrap Paradox: A situation where objects or information can exist without ever being created, as demonstrated in this episode.
One thing i'll say in favor of this episode was the guard's reaction on finding her there made a lot more sense when they retconned that the captain of the guard is her older brother.
Actually, the time travel theory as presented in this episode is one of the most realistic versions in my opinion. It's basically the same thing used in Harry Potter 3: it's impossible to change the past. If you go back in time, it's because you were meant to go back in time; your time-traveling self was always part of the events you try to change. The timeline fits together like a jigsaw puzzle, and reality remains constant.
Also, it's kind of sad that Harry Potter and My Little Pony are the only shows I've ever seen that get time travel right like this.
This and Gravity Falls
0:58
“Pinkies mane is a disaster in waiting , but only when it’s straight!”
I died.
“How can there be two me’s? That’s not scientifically possible!”
(Glances at Equestria Girls) Yeah, you keep thinkin’ that, Twi.
Nearly six months after this video was made, good timing of Gypsy Bard is still funny enough to make me laugh out loud.
Tartarous is not hell it's a prison. Not just in the show but in mythology as well.
isnt hell a prison?
Tartarus is the GrecoRoman equivalent to Hell. Elysium/Heaven, Fields of Asphodel/Purgatory, Tartarus/Hell. Tartarus is where the Titans are imprisoned, but that's not it's only purpose.
Uh, no, I'm pretty sure it's hell.
In Greek Mythology it's hell, in MLP it's a prison.
It's a kids show, they're not going to show people being tortured in the hellfire. =P
1:58
AND WHICHEVER WAY HE TILTS IT
KNOW THAT WE MUST BE RESILIENT
WE WONT LET THEM BREAK OUR SPIRITS
AS WE SING OUR SILLY SONG
(should i go on)
WHEN I WAS A LITTLE PHILLY
A GALLOPING BLAZE OVERTOOK MY CITY
SO THEY SHIPPED ME OFF TO THE ORPHANAGE
SAID DITCH THOSE ROOTS IF YOU WANNA FIT IN
SO I DUG 1000 HOLES
AND CUT A RUG WITH ORPHAN FOALS
NOW MEMORIES ARE BLURRED
AND FACES ARE OBSCURED
BUT I STILL KNOW THE WORDS TO THIS SONG
WHEN YOUVE BUNGLED ALL YOUR BANGLES
AND YOUR LOVED ONE'S HAVE BEEN MANGLED
LISTEN TO THE JINGLE JANGLE
OF MY GYPSY TAMBOURINE!!
NOW THESE CHORDS ARE HYPNOTIZING AND THE WHOLE WORLDS HARMONIZING SO PLEASE CHILDREN STOP YOUR CRYING AND JUST SING ALONG WITH ME!
3:00 You just predicted "Loki"
How can it be, that no one sees the MGS references?
The eyepatch, the bandana, the Hair, the sneaking suit...
Totally no Metal Gear Solid Reference.
+GermanKraut Don't worry, I'm mad about it too.
+GermanKraut Exactly. Obviously, this is about Snake Plissken!
I agree, these Pacman references are so obvious!
Twilight, try to remember the basics of Unicorn Magic.
DJ Lightning
Your'e pretty good!
1:36 Imagine if Spike actually DID send someone directly to Celestia like that, accidentally or otherwise.
THINK OF THE POSSIBILITIES!
Garble - dead or sent to moon
Fluttershy - onslaught of nervous stammering and apologies
Derpy Hooves - cries incessantly until Celestia gives her a muffin (or alternatively, she appears and says, "I just don't know what went wrong!")
Vinyl Scratch - karaoke with Celestia and/or Luna, which Cadence and/or at least one guard walks in on and an awkward silence ensues
Rarity - "The WORST! POSSIBLE! THING!"
Rainbow Dash - a situation that could stand to be 20% cooler
Pinkie Pie - "IT'S PEANUT BUTTER JELLY TIME!"
Twilight Sparkle - instantly faints, mortified, and proceeds to mumble the phrase, 'Notice me, Senpai' over and over until Celestia manages to wake her
Applejack - "WUT IN TARNATION?!"
Any (or all) of the Cutie Mark Crusaders - one of them says something stupid and Luna turns into Nightmare Moon
Discord - "Well, THIS is awkward..."
Maud Pie - a very dull conversation about rocks ensues
The 'Great and Powerful' Trixie - same fate as Garble, except preceded by a very thorough spanking from Luna
Owlowiscious - a lengthy reprise of the 'who' joke
Angel Bunny - Celestia is found dead by the guards, drowned in a pool of her own blood
Queen Chrysalis - the Equestrian apocalypse ensues
Spike - total mindfuck for all involved
"And reports of two-legged creatures dressing up like us!"
LOL
Well,...
...
...it's about time.
That library sure is haunted… Floating scrolls, self licking ice cream…. What else?!
1:33 it's not racist, RD was trying to protect the poor mouse, which would have been crushed to death by Twi's hooves had she not warned her about said mouse.
You missed the biggest sin of them all in this episode: Neither Celestia nor Luna checked Tartarus to make sure that a certain magic-sucking being was still there and didn't break free, thus starting to slowly suck up unicorn magic for two years until meeting up with Discord.
What I learned today: MEY FANFICTIONS ARE CANON!!! THE MULTIVERSE IS CANON! TIME IS A PARADOX! *is randomly laughing, curled up in ball on floor*
They forgot to add that twilight wouldn't have been stressed about anything if she hadn't gone back in time to warn herself and that she could have simply cast the time spell again and try to warn herself again!
HOW DARE YOU to forget the Metal Gear solid reference, how dare you to deny Big Boss!!
Big Boss to Twilight: What took you so long?
That's not a metal gear refence. It looks like but it isn't
It is something else
***** :v :v :v U didn´t know that Tara Strong made the voice of two characters in MGS before MLP right? so its obviously a MGS reference :V :V :V!
Israel Arispe No it isn't !
Twilight is like Snake Plissken! from a old movie WHICH inspired Solid Snake> Big Boss
Haha I knew I was right !
Dude!!! Solid was based on Plissken,BB on Sean Connery and as you can see Twilight is wearing a bandana, Plissken never used it so its a MGS reference
1:54 My favorite song from Friendship is Witchcraft. I still listen to it on my way to work sometimes.
Some kind of epic pony war? Twilight, you have no idea...
I NEVER UNDERSTOOD THE 'It's about time" JOKE! I get it nowwww! Thank you XDXD
00:31 "Is there some kind of pony war in the distant future?"
Season 5 finals episodes foreshadowing...
I REMEMBER THE GREAT PONY WAR OF NEXT TUESDAY!
1:57
my favourite sin from any Cinemare Sins episode up until now
Lel the ending is very accurate
Sin #42: Discount Big Boss. *Ding*
When are you going to collaborate with the actual CinemaSins?
When all of the bribe money has accumulated.
*****
Silly BlueFox, the answer was obvious, money makes the world go round.
Thats why people who think they can rule the world are stupid, they forget we are already under the reign and power of paper and pieces of round metal.
Lane Arias I am so confused.
Be confused.. be very confused.......
You should really consider approaching the actual CinemaSins for a collaboration video.
People assume that _Time_ is a strict progression of cause to effect, but actually from a nonlinear, non-subjective viewpoint, it's more like a big ball of _Wibbly-Wobbly, Timey-Wimey stuff_...
Got away from you, did it?
Wes Evans Well, we *can* hear him, after all.
Haha I love that episode of doctor who
I have a t-shirt of that :D
i expected this
Nerd time. Okay so, with time this is considered a Bootstrap Paradox: where someone goes into the past and a chain of certain events occur because of that time travel and later leads up to that person going into the past and those evens go on and on forever[until someone bonks it up and causes a paradox within the bootstrap paradox which will result in the universe collapsing in on itself] Now, there is no actual beginning point in the paradox, it's an event within itself and some more wibbily-wobbliy timey-wimey stuff.
Okay to sum it up the butterfly effect
Princess Luna of darkness Nightmaremoon No Luna, it's wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey stuff. [I don't even know what the butterfly effect is]
amy small the butterfly effect is when one small thing happens then a whole bunch of big things happen
Princess Luna of darkness Nightmaremoon ... ...
Princess Luna of darkness Nightmaremoon ...
1:38 "this is the same background"
1:40 "this is the same mane cut from future twilight"
Anyone noticed that?
Not scientifically possible says the purple, magical horse that owns a dragon without wings and can read
Cupcakes is canon... Buck.
I love these videos and i'm happily waiting for more. One missed chance for a sin:
Twilight: Is there some epic pony war in the distant future?
Sins Guy: Twilight Sparkle foreshadows Fallout: Equestria.
(Ding)
Wait if all fan fictions are cannon then... cupcakes, rainbow factory...
And... my little dashie
Scootalo isnt dead.
Rainbow Dash isn't dead.
*Debunked ;3*
In that timeline they aren't. That's the point.
Imagine if a new universe is created everytime you make a decision. Endless possibilities.
+Kellen M. That one of pinkie and big mac fucking in the bakery.
2:05 Duuuh, it's the frontal fireplace levitator.
41 is the total amount of sins...
This was made on January 16th.
So, you add 16 to 41, which is 57
The year is 2015.
So you minus 57 by 20, which is 37.
This video ends at 3:35.
So you minus 37 by 35, which is 2.
Since this was made in January, you add 1 more which makes it 3.
The Eye of Providence (Illuminati) has 3 vertices.
Illuminati confirmed in My Little Pony.
ILLUMINATI CONFIRMED
So we now know because of this episode that pinkypie isn't using gypsy or her fourth wall breaking powers.
Not one single Metal Gear Solid joke? I am dissapoint XD
You've created a time paradox Snake, Sna-a-a-a-ake!
Snake, what happened? Snake?! SNAAAAAAAAAAAKE!!!
also if twilight didn’t go back to warn herself it wouldn’t have happened in the first place 😑
1:05 pause immediately
all fan fictions are canon. EVERYBODY RUN!
Three weeks, and *still* no Sins video....
Still recovering from pneumonia. I've had a chance to work on a couple scripts, so hopefully I can record those soon.
***** Wait, you have pneumonia? I had no idea.. I hope you get well soon!
ImpossibleDreamer-Mythical Beast Thanks, I'm at the tail end of it so hopefully I can get a sins video up soon :)
***** JESUS CRAST
+Mikehunt wat is po somim
I wish there was an option to 'Super Like' something after you've already liked it. That last part definitely deserved it XDD
1:11 I lost my shit
If you think about it, Twilight only went to visit herself after all these events happened. Her visit to her past self is the only reason she started worrying and went through all the events that occurs in the episode. So that means that there would have to be one first event that caused her to do all this without her visiting herself, so what caused the first event?
I wonder what witty video related quips are in the comment section
*filled with first comments*
well shit....
RUclips, All I want to do is watch a video, stop making me update. In a alternate time line where smell-o-vision was invented you have far more to complain about.
Jack Poor other me ;_;
I should send him a basket
That scene at the very end of the video just ties it all together. You're my hero! XD
yay! Tar-Tar Sauce!
I read the "Bainshed to Tar-tar-us" as "Brainwashed to Tar-tar-us" c:
Cupcakes is canon
cool
Whoa (falls)
Lol
(still on the floor with a bruse)
Are you ok
I like how they use a real paradox in a show menu for 7 year olds
00:49
DW: time travel? hahaha how silly hahaha, em gotta go
This episode is actually a good example of the Bootstrap Paradox. Essentially if A only happens because B goes back in time and warns A of future then A's future becomes B present. The main part of the paradox is if A only knows because B influenced them and B only knows because they were A, who started it
yay friendship is witchcraft
Time Travel
Such a fun and easy topic to discuss!
Somehow your Profile pic fits that statement
Max Mustermann Really? I didn't think so, I thought an overly happy sarcastic face would fit with the comment.
Dear bronies my little pony friendship is magic is leaving Netflix on February 2nd 2015 only equestria girls and rainbow rocks will remain please warn your friends too !
NNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO THATS THE ONLY THING I CAN WATCH IT ON D:
I don't have Netflix anymore, but good thing I watched all three seasons on there... and the movie. Plus, a fourth season and EG2 on the internet. :)
Phoebe Cabral You could just get the DVDs. Dailymotion has all the episodes as well.
Paianni I realized i do actually have another way of watching mlp, but it dosent look as good as netflix does. I could also react to it with the Equestria's Reflection guys, i watch the vid and react to it with them. But i'm stil sad it's leaving netflix :(
They MIGHT put it back on if high demands are high
1:10
genuinely the first thing to get me laughing aloud in a few days.
LOL LOL I LOVE DAT 'Post credits' scene! And I also noticed the Cherry Berry sin when I first saw this episode she was suddenly inside her house :P
Seeing a Everything went wrong in my subscription feed makes my day
Just to be pedantic, this episode features a closed time loop. The closed time loop makes perfect senses because, due entirely to the fact that information has in fact been sent backward in time to cause its own existence, causality MUST therefore function in reverse.
It's not a loop, as we think of it with our puny, rational, linear human brains. It's just cause and effect working backwards. Which makes perfect sense according to quantum mechanics.
Because quantum mechanics enjoys watching you suffer.
1:55 The best sin in Cinemare Sins so far.
1:34 so that's what started the war
She probably wants me to prevent whatever horrible disaster will happen in the future.
(Many months later...)
(Twilight bumps into Flash Sentry)
"All Fan Fictions are now cannon"
Fallout: Equestria is now cannon! YES!!!
CONGRATS ON MORE THAN 100K SUBSCRIBERS. YOU DESERVE IT!!!
2:12 made me kek. Thanks for helping me get over the fact that moot is retiring.
THE TITLE IS CONNECTED TO A PINKIE LINE OF TANKS FOR THE MEMORIES!
"Or maybe an *its about time* party" does that mean this episode happened on the first day of spring?
the ending was gold. good work, Littleshy.
That direct ending with "Brad" made my day xD
When they say, "It's about time" they mean like when you're waiting for something for a long time and it finally comes you would say, "It's about time!"
To quote what you said during the season 5 finale: "Time travel is stupid."
Sin, it won't even hurt, when looking at the sun but she felt pain and yes it will make her go blind
Best end gag ever. 10/10
"I have balls stashed all over ponyville!" XD I died. That's it. I probably killed the rewind button too.
OHHHH, THAT ENDING JOKE THOUGH!!!
Seriously though, this is a very stable time loop.
(and one of my favorite episodes, but I digress).
I always remembered this episode because going back in time to warn herself not to worry was absolutely pointless.
1:42 Or just...brush it.
"Covered in tartar sauce." At least it won't be attacked by any minotaurs.
its about time you reviewed this episode
I’m glad this is a stable timeloop
One of the main characters returns from the future with scars and an eyepatch, implying an unpleasantly violent encounter.
Y'know, *for kids!*
No sin for the obvious Doctor Who themed music in the background during the Twilight and Future-Twi meeting?
This is proper good, i dont even want to try to debunk this, but i might eventuly
THAT AFTER CREDITS ENDING WAS THE BEST!
I feel like after you search the episode for sins, you watch the whole episode frame by frame.
2:17 Hey Twilight, if your looking for something about stopping time, Look for a book by Ultimanecia.
"Because if Ponyville is lacking one thing..."
Not while Spike resides there, it doesn't.