Excellent summary of lack of commitment to corporative federalism from FM and Union to states , people of India mostly rural are the losers and State govt has no inflow of funds
70 saal se economy, unemployment, inflation , vikash blah blah blah ... soon soon k kaan pak gaye hai thoda hhindu -moosslim debate karao woh jada entertaining hota hai ...
Economy is going well, Education system also going well. But the unemployment is due to the expectation and opportunity mismatch . Opportunity is limited so the expectations have to adjust accordingly . Even there is no panacea for unemployment 'gig economy' and compulsory inclusion of 'entrepreneurship' as the part of curriculum in all discipline viz. Engineering, Medicine, Law, Management, History, Commerce, Language etc. will cultivate a different culture among students to live with the actual situation prevailing rather than living in a virtual world.
@@adityabanerjee7145 no he understands nothing of economics and this is coupled with his myopic view of current dispensation . I think he loves pakistani jazba wale economists😂😂
@@anitapadhi325 no.. his economy is hum jazba wali qum haai, humney kalma padha hai, yeh hhindu baniye darpok haai, hum iislamb ka kila haaai, yeh sab raaa ki sazizh haaai.... this is there economy.
Unfortunate that Indian Ruling Classes in the last 75 years have looted the rural poor and this continues without any opposition from extremely poverty stricken masses. It has been Ravan Raj and continues to be so. God only knows where this Country is headed with such Demographic nightmare.
Mr Pranob Sen responses are highly informative and to the point.... very nice experience listening through the interview.. Mr Karan Thapar is as good as ever!!
I have been watching his predictions since the pandemic and all of them have been way off the mark. He is cut off from realty and regurgitating things only out of hatred for Modi.
@@adityabanerjee7145 😂😂 lmao these people want the government to be in loss making In every public sector so that can enjoy public benefits while India becomes financially weaker.
Terrible budget. I had high hopes when Nirmala Maam took over as Finance Minister but all she has done so far is nothing sort of stupidity. Very poor budget
And that is odd. It seems like he's unsure and very careful, too careful about what he says. Which isn't a good trait for someone whose opinions are sought after.
@@hammer67459 no wonder this channel has become an echo chamber these so called Liberandus themselves don't have knowledge. They want India to some socialist communist country. Even the Mr Sen said. India did remarkably well after covid.and talked about growing middle class
If Panautiat continues GDP likely to be in negative in second quarter (if certain sector performs below averaged) it means more borrowings ,means more unemployment,means more mehangaay etc.
OMG the twists and turns in this groveling. Masterclass in fence sitting. Apparently “we are a nation of entrepreneurs” - why didn’t I get this memo? Either he’s blind or we’ve been idiots all this while
@@raykaiop8457 so private investment was pouring in India during upa government when most of our public sectors was in loss. High rate of Npa. and with no direct benefit transfer thanks to p chidambaram.
Eagerly waiting for the next interview on the State of economy with Pronab Sir and if possible, please involve Mr Arun Kumar in the discussion. Love from Kashmir❤
iindia's number one problem is --1. iislamb , 2. need double digit gdp growth , 3. unemployment , 4. modernise the defense sector, 5. need inflation under 6-5% , 6. massive investment in infrastructure and health sector & etc.
Pronab da - you are a fantastic statistician. Kindly refrain from suggesting that you have expertise in General Equilibrium, and decide which subsidies are necessary and which are unnecessary. The fiscal deficit reduction must be probed by a trained Economist. By the way - can be zero probabilities (there is something called Measure theory).
This guy is a political aspirant! He was parsing his words carefully! He was an apologist for FM & loath to criticize the govt! Good Work Karan! Sen U will b guaranteed a job with this criminal govt!😂😂😂
Mr Sen pointed out the fact that rural landless have suffered badly and also the fact that migration from rural to urban areas is close to nothing but didn't point out the fact that the pandemic had induced reverse migration from urban to rural areas. It simply means that the employment in rural areas is distress employment because the same class of workers that used to find jobs in urban areas are unable to find those jobs anymore and perhaps that's getting reflected in the rise of self employed in the economy as a whole due to their involvement in lowkey jobs. The other point Mr Sen pointed out is that the private corporate sector is thriving but they're not investing it back. What the interview didn't highlight is the fact that these corporates have thrived by wiping out the competing MSMEs and we all know that the sector is in crisis. The question that arises is if Private investment isn't happening, the jobs aren't being created and labour intensive MSMEs are in crisis, then how are the new jobs being created even in urban areas? The data about self employment simply suggests that the falling unemployment levels aren't anything to cherish about and the data is inflated due to the structure of the surveys being conducted because the disguised unemployment is getting reflected as the employment and that too in petty low income jobs. Loved the discussion about the lack of state finances getting translated into lack of non corporate investment which in essence is the lack of hand holding smaller enterprises need. Very productive discussion❤
USA debt 33 trillion $ / 33 million population = 1 million $ debt per person China debt 51 trillion $/ 130 million population = 400,000$ debt per peroson as of 31/3/2023
Debt are serviced by growth rates, do you even know what are you saying every country on earth runs on debt, there is short term mid terms and long terms where did you get your doctorate from? A fake college?? If you are a medico dr please stick to medicine donot talk on economics on which you have 0 knowledge ,clearly evident no good student of economics either a under-grad or a Masters holder talks about money in absolute terms.
@@GuzzarAwan u r saying usa has 10crores debt per person, China has 4crores debt per person, So india has only 1lakh debt per person. India is paying 20% budget as loan repayment. If india multiples debt by 5 times then then there would be no money to repay. Did u check China's and usa tax revenue with india before comparing
The panelist is confused and trying to cover up the lies of the FM . Questions by Karan are excellent.I have no doubt that this budget is scanty on detail as it is targeting the elections a few months away . BJP is good at lying and coverups. Not mentioning the unemployment is strange and a part of the coverup.
Unemployment is high I do get it but overall consumption and private sector investment is increased or slowly going to get increased in fy 24 25 because of public sector divestment procedures.
Unemployment and private sector investment issues are there since independence . But The Wire opened it's eyes today when FM NS presented interim budget .
Where has India done well during corona? Other countries distributed money out of humanity. The insensitive Modi didn't do so. That's not out of economic sensibility, it is rather indifference towards the people. I always observed Pronab Sen lacks ethical clarity and excessively desires to sound rational even when the persons in question are utterly unethical.
Are the wire readers such ardent communists? "distributing money" like the west would've given us extreme inflation (like west faced) For a developing country without reserve country, that means Pakistan level of inflation - 20-30%
Prabir either is confused about his judgments or has no real information before facing an interview. Always says well….then no idea. Why did u call him without any preparation on his part about data? Rajiv Canada
I have watched a documentary pertaining to the miserable life of the terribly deprived poor Indian families who live n shabby self made shelters built with bamboo and plastic sheets near the sea side in a metropolitan city like Mumbai.These families are raided by the BMC from time to time to time and they again rebuild.In Kolkata poor labour class working as workers with gold smiths dive down into the sanitary drains in order to collect the sludge containing some particles of the gold in order to earn few more rupees to sustain their life's.Similarly youth selling pirated books to the people waiting in their vehicles for the traffic signal to go.These poor guys sleep in municipality parks along with their families.In conditions like these the statistics of progress and development by the Indian government officials are nothing more than an eye wash.
Karan Thapar should do his homework and attend some classes on economics before venturing into such interviews. He was trying his best to "push" his views!
No populist announcement --even in the election- year-budget. Wonderful! It seems FM Nirmala Sitharaman has started following Election's Code of conduct so early. She deserves 'appreciation' for it.
The problem with some intellectuals and experts is that they think they are smart enough by giving diplomatic answers, like may be or may not be true, if this is the answer, what sort of expert they are?, for analogy the great poets are those who write in common man language and straight forward massage, no need to interpret, at such a ripen age, what to fear of, speak from heart.
Drama of the budget was fully visible from Onion 🌰 aunty, she seems to enjoy like batman movie joker and of course she is well trained by the master joker. She isn't talking about budget or even onion but just trying to hide the elephant in the room but smiling and forcing elephant to dance. It's not just double whammy but triple whammy, this gentleman is behaving like CJI, lecturing everyone to speak but himself, oooh, aaah, ooof and not able to pass clear verdict on the dance master or joker's team drama flored on the public, opposition or Karan Thapar has to emphasize the dilemma and drama but not the so called specialist. It looks he is getting readied for next retired or looking for opportunities in Modi and Hindutva lobby's new India.
political propaganda is the norm, the cultural, no matter who and when.. look back 50-60 years, nothing new this year!! To treat this budget speech as sacrosanct is naive.
2004 se 14 tak Atalji ka majboot arthavyavastha ko organised loot karke fragiled banaaya aur gariib desh banaaya? One crore berojgaar? 80 crore ati gariib? 2014 tak Modiji ne fragiled Bharat banaaya? Modiji ne 100 crore youngsters ka desh ko gariib desh banaaya 2014 tak? Wire kiske liye vote bank politics karta hai saheb? Tukade tukade gang keliye? Karnataka men DK tukade tukade gang ka money power satta ko praapt kii?
Pehla baat tera jasa ko yeah bhi nahi karan और ghosh ki interview kis topic pe chal rahi ha sirf bjp ke it cell or WhatsApp university ke propaganda ko dekho ge tu kuch samaj nahi aaya ga
With a 7.3% GDP growth this year and 7% next year - the government did well to stay the course. Full budget after the elections. I can only see Pronab and Pappu are unemployed - others are running to earn a living.
Whatever the GDP growth, there's very bad distribution of wealth among the nation through creating jobs and decreasing poverty. PEOPLE are still flying abroad cor jobs l 20:48 leaving families behind., in warzone countries..
Certainly the guest is afraid to speak up against govt. And keeping the favour of budget. He is talking about growth of industrialist only and according to him rural areas are barrier in the way of development.
Hello Karan, Why does our exert feel that decreasing migration from rural India to cities is bad ? Isn't it indicative of people prefer to work on their lands doing farming rather than slogging in the cities ? Most of the prestitutesare cursing Ms.Sitaraman that she ignored middle income group completely while your gyani says that they are doing very well . Also, most significant pibt if the budget is that FM didn't announce any revadis to please the electorate and gain in the elections . P be generous enough to give the devil the due ...
Why do you ignore the other more important point in the same statement? If rural incomes are down, wouldn’t you expect more urban migration in search of higher incomes?
@@dramatispersonae1315 lmao the above comment said that people are migrating less from villages to cities. 😂😂 seems like you don't understand the question. Income increment is low but various things are also highly subsidized in rural areas food inflation is less in rural areas although high in cities. But it will come down in a month or so. 5 kg ration is free on the top of that more subsidiary of ayushmaan bharat are village people only.
Then a Jumla "Garibi Hatao"in 1972 by Librandus Still after 52years Librandus jumla "Garibi Hatao" Garibi,BEROJAGARI,Mahangayi only a tool for Librandus to provocate people against government in realty Librandus wish for Garib Bharat.
In ram rajya jumla bhazi 56 he will remove our trousers and underwear 🩳🩲 without knowing what is happening to us after sometime only we know that we are standing naked
Govt is giving half truth as bengali gentleman says..doesn't half truths amount to lies..?per capita income cannot be measure of progress where income distribution has been unequitable... the condition of masses have been bad as the data of rural consumption shows..to some extent gentleman is trying to give erroneous impression about real state of affairs..?🤔
Excellent summary of lack of commitment to corporative federalism from FM and Union to states , people of India mostly rural are the losers and State govt has no inflow of funds
The Burning Issues like Educational Systems, Unemployment etc have always been ignored.
Tumhara india se kya waasta hai.
@@VedaCareNature Joh tera waasta hai!
70 saal se economy, unemployment, inflation , vikash blah blah blah ... soon soon k kaan pak gaye hai thoda hhindu -moosslim debate karao woh jada entertaining hota hai ...
Economy is going well,
Education system also going well.
But the unemployment is due to the expectation and opportunity mismatch .
Opportunity is limited so the expectations have to adjust accordingly .
Even there is no panacea for unemployment 'gig economy' and
compulsory inclusion of 'entrepreneurship' as the part of curriculum in all discipline viz. Engineering, Medicine, Law, Management, History, Commerce, Language etc. will cultivate a different culture among students to live with the actual situation prevailing rather than living in a virtual world.
@@ceeveemydeen5174 hhindu-mmosslim debate karao usmay jada entertainment hota hai ....
RSS-BJP govt. is not a double engine govt. but double whammy govt.😭😭😭
FM is an idiotic box
@@adityabanerjee7145 no he understands nothing of economics and this is coupled with his myopic view of current dispensation . I think he loves pakistani jazba wale economists😂😂
@@anitapadhi325 no.. his economy is hum jazba wali qum haai, humney kalma padha hai, yeh hhindu baniye darpok haai, hum iislamb ka kila haaai, yeh sab raaa ki sazizh haaai.... this is there economy.
@@adityabanerjee7145 r u andhbhakt
@@mohanv88 I am a Pappu bhakt
@@adityabanerjee7145 Yes I am. Pappu is doing great job to restore democracy, pluralism, diversity, technology, security...
Unfortunate that Indian Ruling Classes in the last 75 years have looted the rural poor and this continues without any opposition from extremely poverty stricken masses. It has been Ravan Raj and continues to be so. God only knows where this Country is headed with such Demographic nightmare.
Those who can afford , have been giving up Indian citizenship and opting for citizenship of other countries like UK , US etc.
Mr Pranob Sen responses are highly informative and to the point.... very nice experience listening through the interview.. Mr Karan Thapar is as good as ever!!
I have been watching his predictions since the pandemic and all of them have been way off the mark. He is cut off from realty and regurgitating things only out of hatred for Modi.
Thanks!
firstly railway budget was elliminated .Soon we will see financial budget will also be elliminated .
The legendary railway budgets - Lalu, Momta style... maybe a new train "Garib Rath" will be announced from Calcutta to Patna
Adani budget
@@adityabanerjee7145 😂😂 lmao these people want the government to be in loss making In every public sector so that can enjoy public benefits while India becomes financially weaker.
Terrible budget. I had high hopes when Nirmala Maam took over as Finance Minister but all she has done so far is nothing sort of stupidity. Very poor budget
It is truly a blessing to be able to watch and listen to such interviews.
I loved pronob sen. Can't be bullied by anyone including KT. Strictly apolitical and terrific economist.
An insightful interview exposing various pitfalls and challenges India faces!!
Prof. Sen is. very cautious with his words
you forgot.... jcb??
@@JJJVE123😂😂 han lol economy pe baat nhi karega toh jcb koi logic hai kya
Intelligent questions and insightful answers. Thanks a ton! 🙏🙏
Why was this man being so careful with his words and mincing them? Very odd.
He was my professor, thats just how he speaks.
That's how he naturally speaks.
And that is odd. It seems like he's unsure and very careful, too careful about what he says. Which isn't a good trait for someone whose opinions are sought after.
FM just produced another Onion budget 😂 like herself no betterment.
she doesn't eat onions but makes good recipes with the vegetable
@@hammer67459 no wonder this channel has become an echo chamber these so called Liberandus themselves don't have knowledge. They want India to some socialist communist country. Even the Mr Sen said. India did remarkably well after covid.and talked about growing middle class
Would be helpful to see an interview with raghuram rajan, P chidambaram, and many imminent economists on the India growth outlook.
😂😂😂what raghuram rajan and p chidambaram have become a joke now
@@pipipupu5104 your mental capacities must be very limited if you think that. Go watch big boss or hindi music videos
Thanks
There has been no census, how do we know the per capita income has actually gone up?
Per capita isn't determined by census .
Really!? Our great Indian economists estimated country’s Capital expenditure to be 11,11,111 Cr!!! Jaise puja time par Dakshina me diya jata hai.
If Panautiat continues GDP likely to be in negative in second quarter (if certain sector performs below averaged) it means more borrowings ,means more unemployment,means more mehangaay etc.
Sir this the collective discussion and what discussion you had with Mr. Kapil sibal what you think future of india and Indian young india
OMG the twists and turns in this groveling. Masterclass in fence sitting. Apparently “we are a nation of entrepreneurs” - why didn’t I get this memo? Either he’s blind or we’ve been idiots all this while
Absolutely right. KT was trying his best to prove the FM wrong on all fronts. The interviewee was fence-sitting because perhaps it is indeed so.
@@sathyanarayanan9997😂😂 lmao I always enjoy these bengali economist. And how funny they are
Mr. Thapar, Why you didn't ask that 81 crores are being hungry and they are desperately looking for FREE RATION 5 KGS ???
When Private sector investment comes, People cry about Budget being Ameero ka budget.
Wtf study the data pvt investment has been sluggish throughout narendra modi's period
1st u should clear your concept ,then comment
@@neerajsinghbhar966 thik h sir
@@neerajsinghbhar966 clear your what concept.
@@raykaiop8457 so private investment was pouring in India during upa government when most of our public sectors was in loss. High rate of Npa. and with no direct benefit transfer thanks to p chidambaram.
Eagerly waiting for the next interview on the State of economy with Pronab Sir and if possible, please involve Mr Arun Kumar in the discussion. Love from Kashmir❤
Maii Fiyaj nahi Kati 😂 Maii Budget v nahi Banati bass bolti
Education and health budget needed to be discussed
iindia's number one problem is --1. iislamb , 2. need double digit gdp growth , 3. unemployment , 4. modernise the defense sector, 5. need inflation under 6-5% , 6. massive investment in infrastructure and health sector & etc.
@@urrasscal8380 Education and health itself can get many other aspects and sectors on speed
Hi Karan, I would suggest you to publish it as a pod caste too. It becomes easier for viewers to listen.
Fake figures are the Hallmark of the jhumla bjp in power
Yeah everything is fake then why does international forum also quote it from wec, to imf to World Bank to various car companies.
Please put up the name of the interviewee right at the top, with tags, instead of at the bottom of the description box.
Pronab da - you are a fantastic statistician.
Kindly refrain from suggesting that you have expertise in General Equilibrium, and decide which subsidies are necessary and which are unnecessary.
The fiscal deficit reduction must be probed by a trained Economist.
By the way - can be zero probabilities (there is something called Measure theory).
This guy is a political aspirant! He was parsing his words carefully!
He was an apologist for FM & loath to criticize the govt!
Good Work Karan!
Sen U will b guaranteed a job with this criminal govt!😂😂😂
Ayo yeah he should parrot some socialist bullsh!t for India😂😂
Mr Sen pointed out the fact that rural landless have suffered badly and also the fact that migration from rural to urban areas is close to nothing but didn't point out the fact that the pandemic had induced reverse migration from urban to rural areas. It simply means that the employment in rural areas is distress employment because the same class of workers that used to find jobs in urban areas are unable to find those jobs anymore and perhaps that's getting reflected in the rise of self employed in the economy as a whole due to their involvement in lowkey jobs.
The other point Mr Sen pointed out is that the private corporate sector is thriving but they're not investing it back. What the interview didn't highlight is the fact that these corporates have thrived by wiping out the competing MSMEs and we all know that the sector is in crisis. The question that arises is if Private investment isn't happening, the jobs aren't being created and labour intensive MSMEs are in crisis, then how are the new jobs being created even in urban areas?
The data about self employment simply suggests that the falling unemployment levels aren't anything to cherish about and the data is inflated due to the structure of the surveys being conducted because the disguised unemployment is getting reflected as the employment and that too in petty low income jobs.
Loved the discussion about the lack of state finances getting translated into lack of non corporate investment which in essence is the lack of hand holding smaller enterprises need.
Very productive discussion❤
These are all not immediate concerns of the country. How to manage the seat-sharing?
😂😂😂😂 Karan ji I love when you say " these as you know are tough times " ......
Indian debts is ₹155 lakhs crore ÷ 144 crore population = ₹1, 10,714 debt person as on the 31/3/2023
USA debt 33 trillion $ / 33 million population = 1 million $ debt per person
China debt 51 trillion $/ 130 million population = 400,000$ debt per peroson as of 31/3/2023
@@GuzzarAwan Comparing US economy with Indian economy 🙄🤥
What's your point?
Debt are serviced by growth rates, do you even know what are you saying every country on earth runs on debt, there is short term mid terms and long terms where did you get your doctorate from? A fake college?? If you are a medico dr please stick to medicine donot talk on economics on which you have 0 knowledge ,clearly evident no good student of economics either a under-grad or a Masters holder talks about money in absolute terms.
@@GuzzarAwan u r saying
usa has 10crores debt per person,
China has 4crores debt per person,
So india has only 1lakh debt per person.
India is paying 20% budget as loan repayment. If india multiples debt by 5 times then then there would be no money to repay. Did u check China's and usa tax revenue with india before comparing
The panelist is confused and trying to cover up the lies of the FM . Questions by Karan are excellent.I have no doubt that this budget is scanty on detail as it is targeting the elections a few months away . BJP is good at lying and coverups. Not mentioning the unemployment is strange and a part of the coverup.
Mr.Karan , please invite the great economist Mrs. Nirmala Sitaraman for the interview.
61% reduction in University Grants Commission budget. If you can not afford to send your kids abroad or afford pvt university, it should concern you.
does the FM knows the meaning of there words Unemployment, Private Sector Investment & Consumption ?
Unemployment is high I do get it but overall consumption and private sector investment is increased or slowly going to get increased in fy 24 25 because of public sector divestment procedures.
Budget is a damp squib..much like Nirmala's tenure as FM..iam sure her husband would have called it pathetic as well
Unemployment and private sector investment issues are there since independence . But The Wire opened it's eyes today when FM NS presented interim budget .
"Let the opposition raise it.. what are they there for"... Karan quickly moves on lol..
Sir please interview Subramanyam Swami
Worst FM in the history of india or any country. Zero knowledge but total arrogance. Mein pyaaz nahi khati G
God bless you
Urban income has also declined and also become stagnant
Bang on that this govt is super confident of coming back. As if it ‘knows’ it’s coming back.
1000 saal ka budget will
Be presented next time in July-24.
It’s time income tax payers demand parity with corporate tax rates. 21% max. At least the income tax payers will spend or invest unlike corporates.
No one knows exact number of population
But 90+ crore are below poverty line..achieved what ?
Where has India done well during corona? Other countries distributed money out of humanity. The insensitive Modi didn't do so. That's not out of economic sensibility, it is rather indifference towards the people. I always observed Pronab Sen lacks ethical clarity and excessively desires to sound rational even when the persons in question are utterly unethical.
😂😂 lol all Librandus are crying in comment section
@@pipipupu5104 They should cry na when a criminal is supported......
@@HeartistMurali which criminal ?
@@pipipupu5104 Domi😁
Are the wire readers such ardent communists?
"distributing money" like the west would've given us extreme inflation (like west faced)
For a developing country without reserve country, that means Pakistan level of inflation - 20-30%
Prabir either is confused about his judgments or has no real information before facing an interview. Always says well….then no idea.
Why did u call him without any preparation on his part about data?
Rajiv
Canada
I have watched a documentary pertaining to the miserable life of the terribly deprived poor Indian families who live n shabby self made shelters built with bamboo and plastic sheets near the sea side in a metropolitan city like Mumbai.These families are raided by the BMC from time to time to time and they again rebuild.In Kolkata poor labour class working as workers with gold smiths dive down into the sanitary drains in order to collect the sludge containing some particles of the gold in order to earn few more rupees to sustain their life's.Similarly youth selling pirated books to the people waiting in their vehicles for the traffic signal to go.These poor guys sleep in municipality parks along with their families.In conditions like these the statistics of progress and development by the Indian government officials are nothing more than an eye wash.
Don't call such people who are reluctant to speak the truth when it comes to public interest fi
Karan. Request an interview with Owaisi or Mallikarjun Kharge on The contents of the ASI report of Gyanvapi. You are secular? Please conduct this.
Karan Thapar should do his homework and attend some classes on economics before venturing into such interviews. He was trying his best to "push" his views!
Real inflation in india is atleast 20-25% and probably even higher 😂😂
No populist announcement --even in the election- year-budget. Wonderful!
It seems FM Nirmala Sitharaman has started following Election's Code of conduct so early.
She deserves 'appreciation' for it.
BJP is prepared to loose. So gobbling up taxes, GST, unclaimed funds, selling psu's. Jola uttake jaareha
Subtle RAVANRAAJ
Don't understand why Karan is splitting hairs over vote-on-account. 😮
The problem with some intellectuals and experts is that they think they are smart enough by giving diplomatic answers, like may be or may not be true, if this is the answer, what sort of expert they are?, for analogy the great poets are those who write in common man language and straight forward massage, no need to interpret, at such a ripen age, what to fear of, speak from heart.
Drama of the budget was fully visible from Onion 🌰 aunty, she seems to enjoy like batman movie joker and of course she is well trained by the master joker. She isn't talking about budget or even onion but just trying to hide the elephant in the room but smiling and forcing elephant to dance.
It's not just double whammy but triple whammy, this gentleman is behaving like CJI, lecturing everyone to speak but himself, oooh, aaah, ooof and not able to pass clear verdict on the dance master or joker's team drama flored on the public, opposition or Karan Thapar has to emphasize the dilemma and drama but not the so called specialist.
It looks he is getting readied for next retired or looking for opportunities in Modi and Hindutva lobby's new India.
This guy has blown Karan’s agenda 😂😂😂
Half truths ?
Making fool of the public. han???? super smart finance minister and this governmnent
Speaking as per posted comments. Always funny.
political propaganda is the norm, the cultural, no matter who and when.. look back 50-60 years, nothing new this year!!
To treat this budget speech as sacrosanct is naive.
This economist is double speak.
But modi happily became as Dharmavir modi and again going to rule over us for 5 years more at least...
2004 se 14 tak Atalji ka majboot arthavyavastha ko organised loot karke fragiled banaaya aur gariib desh banaaya?
One crore berojgaar?
80 crore ati gariib?
2014 tak Modiji ne fragiled Bharat banaaya?
Modiji ne 100 crore youngsters ka desh ko gariib desh banaaya 2014 tak?
Wire kiske liye vote bank politics karta hai saheb?
Tukade tukade gang keliye?
Karnataka men DK tukade tukade gang ka money power satta ko praapt kii?
Pehla baat tera jasa ko yeah bhi nahi karan और ghosh ki interview kis topic pe chal rahi ha sirf bjp ke it cell or WhatsApp university ke propaganda ko dekho ge tu kuch samaj nahi aaya ga
The comment section is full of fools.
You have realised late 😅
With a 7.3% GDP growth this year and 7% next year - the government did well to stay the course. Full budget after the elections. I can only see Pronab and Pappu are unemployed - others are running to earn a living.
This GDP growth itself is questionable as it does not say current price or fixed price method
What is your job? looks like you don't need to know anything about GDP estimation.
@@nikhilspeaking Do you have a different number - please tell that to India and challenge the FM. Otherwise, have fun on youtube.
Whatever the GDP growth, there's very bad distribution of wealth among the nation through creating jobs and decreasing poverty. PEOPLE are still flying abroad cor jobs l 20:48 leaving families behind., in warzone countries..
@@adityabanerjee7145 go on and post more evidence about your lack of understanding.
Certainly the guest is afraid to speak up against govt. And keeping the favour of budget. He is talking about growth of industrialist only and according to him rural areas are barrier in the way of development.
Hello Karan,
Why does our exert feel that decreasing migration from rural India to cities is bad ?
Isn't it indicative of people prefer to work on their lands doing farming rather than slogging in the cities ?
Most of the prestitutesare cursing Ms.Sitaraman that she ignored middle income group completely while your gyani says that they are doing very well .
Also, most significant pibt if the budget is that FM didn't announce any revadis to please the electorate and gain in the elections .
P be generous enough to give the devil the due ...
Why do you ignore the other more important point in the same statement? If rural incomes are down, wouldn’t you expect more urban migration in search of higher incomes?
@@dramatispersonae1315 lmao the above comment said that people are migrating less from villages to cities. 😂😂 seems like you don't understand the question. Income increment is low but various things are also highly subsidized in rural areas food inflation is less in rural areas although high in cities. But it will come down in a month or so. 5 kg ration is free on the top of that more subsidiary of ayushmaan bharat are village people only.
Another flop interview by Thapper 😂
Third
Channelised Misinformation.
💙💙💙
no number of hearts are gonna clear your brain
Then a Jumla "Garibi Hatao"in 1972 by Librandus
Still after 52years Librandus jumla "Garibi Hatao"
Garibi,BEROJAGARI,Mahangayi only a tool for Librandus to provocate people against government in realty Librandus wish for Garib Bharat.
BJP: muslim hatavo
This Pronob sen shd have resigned from CSO as soon as BJP came to power. L00ser kept holding the govt job which was against his ideology.
In ram rajya jumla bhazi 56 he will remove our trousers and underwear 🩳🩲 without knowing what is happening to us after sometime only we know that we are standing naked
communists need to fear that. Most r loosing underwear one by one as their loot money has stopped
Have you given him license to do that 😅
😂😂😂
@krisgopi_8 andhbhakts have given full licences
Govt is giving half truth as bengali gentleman says..doesn't half truths amount to lies..?per capita income cannot be measure of progress where income distribution has been unequitable...
the condition of masses have been bad as the data of rural consumption shows..to some extent gentleman is trying to give erroneous impression about real state of affairs..?🤔
When will you stop anti india agenda ?
Lavade fake
Who is this dog barking.