When a director does a Criterion closet pick I really hope a Criterion release of one of their creations is to come. Joanna Hogg and Criterion is a marriage made in heaven x
@@wesleyjohndelaney106 I feel like this is a joke but I’m not sure but if it’s not what would make you not a true film fan for owning a box of movies you can’t own all of individually
All the jazz 1979 dir Bob fosse 8½ 1963 dir Federico Fellini’s La strada 1954 dir Federico Fellini Bad timing 1980 dir Nicolas roeg The age of innocence 1993 dir Martin Scorsese The red shoes 1948 director Michael Powell and emeric pressburger
I love watching these. At 3:44 Joanna talks about watching films for the first time as opposed to re-watching favorites. I've noticed that the guests to the Closet almost always pick out old favorites -- you rarely hear, "What's this? It looks interesting, I'll take it."
2:59 She seems to be a bit off when it comes to the release dates or production of "New York, New York" (1977), "All that Jazz" (1979) and "One from the heart" (1982). Nice choices, though, I should check out her work. 3:31 Tell me about it...
As of this date, I have watched 25...twenty five!...different "criterioncollection " videos. And what fascinates me, is I am noticing patterns. There are a fistful of REPETITIVE recommendations. I now have to see and see what all the excitement is about of : Bicycle Theives, 8 1/2, Weekend, and a couple of films of Cassavettes and a Fellini film. Still waiting for more recommendations.
there's a really cool quick aside she drops in here - "...if there's such a thing as "the best" film" - I like the idea of pushing back on our need to rank and categorize every film along the absolute terms like "best," "greatest," or "worst."
I'm still quite new to watching non-mainstream cinema, so I watch these to help me choose what to watch next haha I'm definitely going to look up some Fellini films later
Really like this woman and love her picks. I am unfamiliar with her work, but will check it out because I really liked her. I remember the year All That Jazz was up for an Oscar and didn't win. I thought it should have won. But some great movies were made in 1979-1980.
Archipelago was as good as any of the films she selected f... blew my mind when I saw it. It was pure excruciating tension. And very accurate of the upper middle class. Didn't know she had a period piece produced by Scorsese coming up?
Great director. Saw a bit of Archipelago late one night on telly, then went to see Exhibition on my own in the cinema and fell in love right there. My favourite, though, might actually be her debut film, Unrelated...would love to see Criterion pounce on that.
Would not have guessed any of the picks , they are so the opposite to her profoundly subdued works of authenticity and psychological portraits, really surprised, love her works.
I thought that the student film sequence in The Souvenir Part 2 was the best homage to The Red Shoes that I’ve ever seen. Not surprised at all to see her pick it
i sometimes asked myself if some of these filmmakers have a bluRay player because i've seen several grab the DVD version, but i'm pretty certain i have the bluRay version in my collectin....
Haha I just thought to myself as I watched this video, if the people behind the camera ask the participants if they have a blu-ray player; "you know, this edition is actually better..."
Criterions are US region locked. DVDs are only software locked so not a big deal, blu-rays are hardware locked, so you need an expensive hooky chipped player for them in the UK. I invested in one to watch Criterion blu-rays but I can see why many would just stick with the DVDs. That may be why.
I know it as nothing to do with the video but criterion if its possible could you please bring Hitokiri (1969), Goyokin (1969), Samurai Wolf (1966), Samurai Wolf 2 (1967), The Secret Of The Urn (1966), The Wolves (1972), Fireflies In The North (1984), 226 Four Days Of Snow And Blood (1989) and Violent Streets (1974) all directed by Hideo Gosha.
What I love about "All That Jazz" is how the airline musical number in it feels erotic and horrifying at the same time. And the film did also have shades of "8 1/2". There was a scene of Scheider in a nightclub that kind of echoed the sequence of Mastroianni in his harem of women.
Now see..this...THIS IS an intelligent woman. I value her advice, the analysis of movies, film, and thoughts and criticism. JOHN CAMPEA AND GRACE RANDOLPH AND Heroes Reforged are NOT HOTCRAP movie critics who know ANYTHING about making a film great! I get tired of hearing the excuse from movie fans and excited fan boys of Marvel, DC and science fiction fans who think that YOU CAN'T compare their movies with what Joanna Hogg's choices are. BULLSHIT. Some sci fi films CAN be made great, classic. Proof" 2001 Space Odyssey, modern The Joker, Blade Runner [the original ], The Andromeda STrain [the original] and Shatner's Star Trek: The Wrath of Kahn. Even Wandavisions Elizabeth Olson did a great portrayal of a woman's tragic pain and loss of those she loved.
New York New York was my first Scorsese film. I saw it age 7 and it felt like a pile of cocaine made a film. I rewatched it last year and it still felt like a pile of cocaine made a film
How do I get invited to do a video of my picks from the closet? I wrote to criterion asking to be invited to do a video for my closet picks but I never got any reply from them. I hope the criterion powers that be see this comment and invite me to do a video. I have a list of titles ready to go so that I don’t waste any time putting them in my bag
these movies she picks are great. And..she explains her reasoning why they are great. HERE ARE A LIST OF MOVIES AND SHOWS that ARE not great, but young, emotional, undisciplined "youtubers" fanboys and fangirls of sci fi and Marvel and DC think are "great" and hotcrap. BUT THEY ARE NOT folks, its about PERSPECTIVE! ITS easy to call things "great". But once you have to COMPARE movies, once you have to compare any movie to a gold STANDARD...then the flop is exposed. Not great: Loki, the Marvel Disney plus series. Ironfist series, Catwoman, the modern woman Doctor Who series, Birds of Pray (harley quinn movie), CAPTAIN MARVEL, Dark PHoenix, Teen Titans, Doom Patrol, Star Wars, the Force Awakens, the Last Jedi, Wonder Woman 84.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
“I’m in a bit of a Fellini phase.”
Criterion: *sweats while looking at Fellini box*
lmao
Criterion: (telepathically) *please do not take the $400 box set for free look over at the Malick films behind you*
Terry Gilliam took the Bergman box set
@@Theomite OK, that's funny! 😄Now, she probably don't have the same income as Brad Pitt, and Terry gilliam took the Bergmann box set!
When a director does a Criterion closet pick I really hope a Criterion release of one of their creations is to come. Joanna Hogg and Criterion is a marriage made in heaven x
Knowing the trajectory of Criterion I'm certain this will happen
@@gnalkhere can you explain what criterion is?
Please tell me someone at criterion made sure she knows the essential Fellini box is a thing
I hope someone at criterion made sure she knows Blurays are a thing.
True film fans don't buy box sets
@Matthew Collins I think she has the money to buy any dvd player she wants
@@wesleyjohndelaney106 I feel like this is a joke but I’m not sure but if it’s not what would make you not a true film fan for owning a box of movies you can’t own all of individually
@Sean yeah but they would have been working on it at that point and be like hey don’t tell anyone but this is an awesome thing we are working on
0:05 - *ALL THAT JAZZ* _dir. Bob Fosse_ (1979)
0:56 / 1:23 - *8½* _dir. Federico Fellini_ (1963)
2:02 - *LA STRADA* _dir. Federico Fellini_ (1954)
2:12 - *BAD TIMING* _dir. Nicolas Roeg_ (1980)
2:37 - *THE AGE OF INNOCENCE* _dir. Martin Scorsese_ (1993)
3:31 / 3:51 - *THE RED SHOES* _dir. Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger_ (1948)
We don’t need you to do a list. Part of the fun is being surprised by the picks.
@@chriswright4677 My list is for impatiently curious people, but you have a point there.
@@PentameronSV apologies if I was rude, but I stand by my point. Long days and pleasant nights to you.
@@chriswright4677 Pleasant wishes to you too!
"There aren't enough years in a life"
I felt that
All the jazz 1979 dir Bob fosse
8½ 1963 dir Federico Fellini’s
La strada 1954 dir Federico Fellini
Bad timing 1980 dir Nicolas roeg
The age of innocence 1993 dir Martin Scorsese
The red shoes 1948 director Michael Powell and emeric pressburger
You just won a place in heaven. Much respect 🙏
One of Martin Scorsese's favorite modern directors!
I'm beginning to see why. Almost a kindred spirit.
His opinions are very trust worthy
I love watching these. At 3:44 Joanna talks about watching films for the first time as opposed to re-watching favorites. I've noticed that the guests to the Closet almost always pick out old favorites -- you rarely hear, "What's this? It looks interesting, I'll take it."
Something tells me The Souvenir is about to get released on Criterion.
omg, for the british this would be massive.
Part II is on the way so could see them being released as one pack
great news, then
A24 on Criterion? that's some surrealistic shit
@@ghostramen3768 Already happening with Uncut Gems
The Age of Innocence was certainly one of the very best films of the 1990s. Extraordinary performances and remarkably done!
2:59 She seems to be a bit off when it comes to the release dates or production of "New York, New York" (1977), "All that Jazz" (1979) and "One from the heart" (1982). Nice choices, though, I should check out her work.
3:31 Tell me about it...
I thought the exact same thing when I heard her say that.
Your're right about the numbers but it's a long time ago. Nostalgia and memory are a big part of her work.
You see, it's because she likes Bad Timing...
@@boltzmannbrayn 😂
GET PTA IN HERE !
And more of his films in the collection.
@@southendonseaarts Hell, just make a PTA box set
YES and make it more then 4mins long right
One of the best closet pick selections I've seen yet.
I like how this series introduces me to new films and new directors at the same time
Loving the constant All that jazz appreciation from so many director's who's been on the channel, truly a masterpiece
Honestly so fucking good
One of the trippiest movies about mortality
_The Red Shoes_ 👠. The "film above all".
Hogg is not incorrect.
Felt pain every time she grabbed a dvd over blu
So many of them do it! 🤷♂️
they know the pain of buying Blu-ray
And you wonder why CC is still not releasing 4Ks!
Same. What’s the point when the BR is right there?
I myself prefer dvds over blu rays.
am going absolutely hog wild for Joanna’s picks.
Bad Timing is amazing & needs a BluRay upgrade, as does The Bad Sleep Well, Face Of Another & Mafioso please Criterion.
This is my sign that I still need to watch The Red Shoes.
Did you get around to watching it?
Love her voice/accent. Lovely to listen to and when she grabs the cases the sound of the shrink wrap sounds lovely too. Yeah, I’m weird, sue me.
There should be a Souvenir and Souvenir Part II Criterion box set. Oh, it’s already in the works you say? Cool! Can’t wait! 😉
it is ? i would love to see them in as a criterion release
More closet picks videos please, I'm loving all these!! :D
It sucks when you realize that you've watched every one.
i LOVE this channel so much , as it introduce me to many great films i had no idea about 🙏🏾
how cool that she nods to mainstream and Marty and all. and the bit about "if there IS a best film"--very philosophical.
Reassuringly heavy is what I thought about whilst picking up the criterion Mirror
"Reassuringly heavy" is fantastic and I think I'll start using that phrase.
All that jazz is one of the best movies of all time
I just picked up the dekalog and right away thought of this episode when i saw the booklet
As of this date, I have watched 25...twenty five!...different "criterioncollection " videos. And what fascinates me, is I am noticing patterns. There are a fistful of REPETITIVE recommendations. I now have to see and see what all the excitement is about of : Bicycle Theives, 8 1/2, Weekend, and a couple of films of Cassavettes and a Fellini film. Still waiting for more recommendations.
All That Jazz gets picked hella lot, including this video. Possibly the most picked title in the series. 8 1/2 is up there
Yes finally Joanna Hogg! I was right there with her stretching to nab The Red Shoes!
criterion should do a tour of the closet and the hallway leading to it so we can visualize ourselves inside
Is there a closet video where someone doesn't pick All That Jazz?
@Randy White dude you should do stand up
love her, love her films. wonderful you guys got her.
every time I clicked on new picks here, «bad timing» in my mind!!! and what I seeeee
All That Jazz was 79. New York, New York was 77. One from the Heart was 82. So fired. I’d like a crack at that Criterion closet please 😁
She needs a Blu-ray player.
red shoes, la strada, somebody called Pausol (director?). Some films in India.
there's a really cool quick aside she drops in here - "...if there's such a thing as "the best" film" - I like the idea of pushing back on our need to rank and categorize every film along the absolute terms like "best," "greatest," or "worst."
God bless your channel. ❤️
I'm still quite new to watching non-mainstream cinema, so I watch these to help me choose what to watch next haha I'm definitely going to look up some Fellini films later
I would totally be taking the Statler and Waldorf along with my movies.
My favourite film maker of all time !
Can't wait to watch The Souvenir Part II.
Really like this woman and love her picks. I am unfamiliar with her work, but will check it out because I really liked her. I remember the year All That Jazz was up for an Oscar and didn't win. I thought it should have won. But some great movies were made in 1979-1980.
Archipelago was as good as any of the films she selected f... blew my mind when I saw it. It was pure excruciating tension. And very accurate of the upper middle class. Didn't know she had a period piece produced by Scorsese coming up?
It bugs me that these people always grab the DVD version and not the Blu. You’d think they would want the best possible viewing experience
Imo the red shoes is the bext british film ever, a complete masterpiece
Great director. Saw a bit of Archipelago late one night on telly, then went to see Exhibition on my own in the cinema and fell in love right there. My favourite, though, might actually be her debut film, Unrelated...would love to see Criterion pounce on that.
Would not have guessed any of the picks , they are so the opposite to her profoundly subdued works of authenticity and psychological portraits, really surprised, love her works.
Love her work
She picked four of my deeply loved films. We are related now.
Great to hear Criterion is finally going 4k
Hopefully we get The Tree of Life on 4K.
I could watch THE SOUVENIR every day for the rest of my life
Criterion, please release New York, New York.
I thought that the student film sequence in The Souvenir Part 2 was the best homage to The Red Shoes that I’ve ever seen. Not surprised at all to see her pick it
My colleagues and I want to see Tarantino in this closet, but with a strict 10-minute time limit.
The Red Shoes is a gift to anyone who watches it and forgets who they are during the viewing and never forget its better to be stolen from....
I love La Strada.
The ending is unforgettable!
i sometimes asked myself if some of these filmmakers have a bluRay player because i've seen several grab the DVD version, but i'm pretty certain i have the bluRay version in my collectin....
Haha I just thought to myself as I watched this video, if the people behind the camera ask the participants if they have a blu-ray player; "you know, this edition is actually better..."
Criterions are US region locked. DVDs are only software locked so not a big deal, blu-rays are hardware locked, so you need an expensive hooky chipped player for them in the UK. I invested in one to watch Criterion blu-rays but I can see why many would just stick with the DVDs. That may be why.
Could this be the first time someone has taken All That Jazz from the Criterion Closet?
I love that film.
it's been picked quite a few times. Deservedly.
I feel like many people love All That Jazz more than Cabaret. But Cabaret is a much better film and more entertaining, too.
I feel like "La Strada" and "Down By Law" are the most frequently snatched titles in this series. Anyone keeping score?
I know it as nothing to do with the video but criterion if its possible could you please bring Hitokiri (1969), Goyokin (1969), Samurai Wolf (1966), Samurai Wolf 2 (1967), The Secret Of The Urn (1966), The Wolves (1972), Fireflies In The North (1984), 226 Four Days Of Snow And Blood (1989) and Violent Streets (1974) all directed by Hideo Gosha.
Some of the best choices yet, esp. love Bad Timing and Age of Innocence
Man, everyone who steps in the closet loves 8 1/2.
Honestly i liked la dolce vita much much better. I'll be stepping in the closet one day of course
Who doesn't love it?
it's pretty damn amazing, still.
THE RED SHOES!!!
It pains me every time I see the DEKALOG in the frame, and it bypassing Directors. An absolute masterpiece by Krystov Kieslowski.
At least Barry Jenkins took it. He knew what was up.
For my money Dekalog is the best Criterion has to offer when you consider quality of the film and Criterion packaging.
It's 10hrs long, and only made it to the collection a few years ago. Not everyone's going to have seen it yet.
@@nfb4027 not everyone wants to pick stuff they've seen
@@lukess.s True. And not everyone has the same tastes in film. Trite observations are fun; no?
New York New York - 1977
All That Jazz - 1979
One from the Heart - 1982
I like to read the Criterion booklets too.
all that jazz is wonderful just a delight
So will anybody acknowledge the doll sitting on the shelf?
They stole your doll? Awww poor thing
What I love about "All That Jazz" is how the airline musical number in it feels erotic and horrifying at the same time. And the film did also have shades of "8 1/2". There was a scene of Scheider in a nightclub that kind of echoed the sequence of Mastroianni in his harem of women.
I could’ve watched this for hours
Right out of the gate with All That Jazz...
Will Inland Empire be a part of the Criterion Collection some day?
Now see..this...THIS IS an intelligent woman. I value her advice, the analysis of movies, film, and thoughts and criticism. JOHN CAMPEA AND GRACE RANDOLPH AND Heroes Reforged are NOT HOTCRAP movie critics who know ANYTHING about making a film great! I get tired of hearing the excuse from movie fans and excited fan boys of Marvel, DC and science fiction fans who think that YOU CAN'T compare their movies with what Joanna Hogg's choices are. BULLSHIT. Some sci fi films CAN be made great, classic. Proof" 2001 Space Odyssey, modern The Joker, Blade Runner [the original ], The Andromeda STrain [the original] and Shatner's Star Trek: The Wrath of Kahn. Even Wandavisions Elizabeth Olson did a great portrayal of a woman's tragic pain and loss of those she loved.
That hurt to read
What are you doing grabbing dvd’s???
Only negative thing about these videos is they are not long enough in my opinion
Please can we have beat Kitano in here already
THE RED SHOES ♥️
new york new york getting the love it deserves
CRITERION, every beat for cinema 👏👏👏👏👏🇨🇱🙏
I was surprised to hear her say that she loves New York, New York
Get Scorsese in here and release it uncut!
Scorcese has already written articles for Criterion, which showcase his taste for what what's in the closet.
He's gonna need a ladder.
I’m glad she picked ‘BAD TIMING’ it’s such a masterpiece
Love Bad Timing so much. Theresa Russell is sensational.
beeeeeest
Waiting for Mia hansen-løve closet pick
A living legend
Denis Villeneuve's closet picks? When?
I believe if Maelstorm gets in the Criterion Collection someday
All That Jazz YESSSS!!!!!
*sneaks in copy of Frances Ha*
this is a store?
New York New York was my first Scorsese film.
I saw it age 7 and it felt like a pile of cocaine made a film.
I rewatched it last year and it still felt like a pile of cocaine made a film
It’s bad?
@@bigboss-yv2nr not a total write-off but not Scorsese's best. Imagine, the first film you make after Taxi Driver, and it's...this
She has good tastes! 😁😁😁
How do I get invited to do a video of my picks from the closet? I wrote to criterion asking to be invited to do a video for my closet picks but I never got any reply from them. I hope the criterion powers that be see this comment and invite me to do a video. I have a list of titles ready to go so that I don’t waste any time putting them in my bag
At this point I honestly don't know if it's a bit or not
these movies she picks are great. And..she explains her reasoning why they are great. HERE ARE A LIST OF MOVIES AND SHOWS that ARE not great, but young, emotional, undisciplined "youtubers" fanboys and fangirls of sci fi and Marvel and DC think are "great" and hotcrap. BUT THEY ARE NOT folks, its about PERSPECTIVE! ITS easy to call things "great". But once you have to COMPARE movies, once you have to compare any movie to a gold STANDARD...then the flop is exposed. Not great: Loki, the Marvel Disney plus series. Ironfist series, Catwoman, the modern woman Doctor Who series, Birds of Pray (harley quinn movie), CAPTAIN MARVEL, Dark PHoenix, Teen Titans, Doom Patrol, Star Wars, the Force Awakens, the Last Jedi, Wonder Woman 84.
blu-ray players are very inexpensive nowadays :-(. This one hurt a little, great picks though.
Please Critereon can I pick some titles out
Sure
She comes to the Criterion Collection to find something to read.
Thats fair
She will be heartbroken to discover that the "notebooks" era was over long long time ago...