Ernst Busch performs "The Secret Mobilisation" by Hans Eisler

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @gintozlato1880
    @gintozlato1880 Год назад +234

    Just to note, those tiny imperfections in the crowd singing is intentional

    • @noctawny3
      @noctawny3 3 месяца назад +14

      They are singing together. All workers should work together to bring eternal peace to the world.

  • @konig9027
    @konig9027 2 года назад +244

    you can hear the emotion in the singers voices which makes the song almost scary

    • @aka99
      @aka99 6 месяцев назад

      The face of this dude is scary because it is full of hate for everything non-socialist

  • @erkanunlu189
    @erkanunlu189 3 года назад +255

    Wonderful song and very meaningful. I salute the memory of Ernst Busch.

  • @ЕленаАлексеева-р1с
    @ЕленаАлексеева-р1с 6 лет назад +291

    Как сейчас в России не хватает певца рабочего класса такой же силы и смелости как немецкий коммунист и певец Эрнст Буш. Песни пролетариата помогают сплотиться и бороться за свои права, за право быть человеком, а не рабом.

    • @VzKst
      @VzKst 6 лет назад +24

      Согласен !

    • @VzKst
      @VzKst 6 лет назад +28

      Великий человек Эрнест Буш ! За Рабочий класс !

    • @PATACHENREN
      @PATACHENREN Год назад +3

      👍👍🏽🎯👏🏼🙏🎯⛩ Bien dit!…

    • @PATROColito
      @PATROColito 10 месяцев назад +9

      ДенаZифицируйте россию!

    • @My-name-is-user-tx6ow1ss3b
      @My-name-is-user-tx6ow1ss3b 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@PATROColitoДля этого нужен нацизм, а его нет.

  • @keykey9095
    @keykey9095 6 лет назад +118

    Такого певца, как Эрнст Буш, никогда не было не только в России, но и во всем мире. Его песни пели такие певцы, как Пит Сигер, Поль Робсон, Стинг и многие другие, но Эрнст Буш остается непревзойденным. Великий певец и великий человек - ЭРНСТ БУШ!

  • @kerstind3710
    @kerstind3710 Год назад +92

    Das Lied hat mich vor 50 Jahren so beeindruckt und ist so aktuell

    • @aka99
      @aka99 6 месяцев назад +4

      Ja in RuSSland so aktuell

    • @Bartnuschler
      @Bartnuschler 4 месяца назад

      @@aka99 Gorbatschow hat die Sovietunion ins Grab gelegt, Jeltzin hat in den Sarg gepisst und Putin hat die Erde ins Grab geschaufelt (und nochmal drauf geschissen).
      Ist mir ein Rätsel wie Menschen denken können das diese Faschoregierung im Kreml als Nachfolger der Sovietunion zu sehen ist.

    • @tortepasti2
      @tortepasti2 3 месяца назад +3

      @@aka99 Also das heutige Russland hat mal ganz wenig mit Sozialismus zutun, da müssen wir uns nichts vormachen. Auch wenns heute edgy und cool ist alles böse als links zu verdammen, würde ich da doch zum Differenzieren aufrufen.

    • @Kaiserohnepurpur
      @Kaiserohnepurpur 2 месяца назад

      @@aka99 The distance between today's Russia and yesterday's Soviet Union is about the same distance between your "keen" observations and the truth.

    • @aka99
      @aka99 2 месяца назад

      @@Kaiserohnepurpur Russia is the victim and defending against the NATO-Aggressor, you mean?

  • @sebastianb5036
    @sebastianb5036 Год назад +276

    I wish my colleagues at work where that class conscious and organized. Out of around 80 co-workers around 4 are Union members. Liberal ones.
    I try to imagine being a factory worker in the 1920s. Having comrades. Acting in solidarity. Organizing. Striking. Protesting. Maybe even singing communist songs while doing so. Having a clear understanding of what their role is and how the relationship towards your boss is.

    • @patrickholt2270
      @patrickholt2270 Год назад +32

      You begin with what you have. Stick with it. More will join. Solidarity requires human compassion and fellow-feeling, and you have to build that however you can, including in yourself. Historically the prevalence of the Biblical faiths helped. A continuous theme in anti-union campaigns is undermining community spirit and civic mindedness, including the denigration of religion.

    • @justus8420
      @justus8420 Год назад +30

      Nobody is born as a communist. We have to organize them. Its the task to do yo. solidarity from germany to all the comrades. long live lenin!

    • @yuty0428
      @yuty0428 3 месяца назад

      Simple as that all communist attempts failed. The ideology is too ideal and can't be implemented.

    • @sebastianb5036
      @sebastianb5036 3 месяца назад

      ​@@patrickholt2270Feels like it is impossible. Capitalist indoctrination is hard. And then there is their fear of conflict and tendency to swallow everything. They don't fight back because out of the fear to lose and get into more trouble.
      I tried to get them to join a Union at least for legal representation and not having to fight on their own, but somehow paying 30 Euro monthly is too expensive.
      They atomized us workers. Destroyed class consciousness. Individualized our problems and made us afraid of losing priviliges (that might not be even there).
      I'm afraid to move forward things have to become much, much worse.
      It is indoctrination from childhood on. You can't get people to snap out of it with compassion and reasoning. Just like you can't convince religios people that evidence points in the way there is no god and the probability of their chosen religion being wrong is very likely.
      And I'm from central Europe. In other places things might be much worse.
      Anyway. My plan is to be a candidate for the next election of the workers council and try at least to push back against management.

  • @AntifaschistischeAktion8
    @AntifaschistischeAktion8 9 месяцев назад +321

    When your boss lowers ur wage:

    • @Daisy_95341
      @Daisy_95341 4 месяца назад

      LoL XD

    • @高俊逸-l8o
      @高俊逸-l8o 3 месяца назад +1

      But it only happens in Europe, it's impossible in Asia

    • @topgangmannotrelated
      @topgangmannotrelated 2 месяца назад +1

      @@高俊逸-l8o Unfortunately, China has been infiltrated with market capitalist Collaborators :(((

    • @Revolutionary_Fish
      @Revolutionary_Fish Месяц назад

      In Europe they lowers your wage,
      In half of Southeast Asia they just fire you :(
      @@高俊逸-l8o

    • @threatbear
      @threatbear 10 дней назад +1

      ​@@高俊逸-l8oIn Mexico too, they call you "naco" and stupid

  • @emrecanarduc4378
    @emrecanarduc4378 4 месяца назад +16

    dude this is epic

  • @elenamakarova5317
    @elenamakarova5317 7 месяцев назад +16

    Низкий поклон и вечная память!

  • @CiceroMarcus
    @CiceroMarcus Год назад +51

    This song is masterpiece for every proletariats

  • @guntugakgun1924
    @guntugakgun1924 4 года назад +102

    "Arbeiter, hörst du sie nicht?"

  • @MasontheRedman
    @MasontheRedman 4 года назад +123

    0:34 what's your opinion on gun control

    • @hi_im_elli
      @hi_im_elli 3 года назад +14

      One can get guns without the government noticing

    • @gabrielegenota1480
      @gabrielegenota1480 2 года назад +28

      Marx was famously in favor of arming the proletariat.

    • @leroyschmitt9680
      @leroyschmitt9680 2 года назад +6

      Make sure the weapon is firmly held to reduce recoil?

    • @kavky
      @kavky 2 года назад +3

      @@gabrielegenota1480 His disciples were famously against it.

    • @gabrielegenota1480
      @gabrielegenota1480 2 года назад +3

      @@kavky nice. i didnt know that.
      (who exactly are his disciples?)

  • @biswadipdasgupta4204
    @biswadipdasgupta4204 Год назад +5

    The great Hans Eisler!

  • @narwhallord
    @narwhallord 3 месяца назад +6

    im a simple man, I see anti fascism, I click

  • @outernothingness1177
    @outernothingness1177 Год назад +32

    Marvellous. Which year was this recorded? (But surely it's not the "only known film-recording of Busch". Just take a look around RUclips.)

    • @maxgowland1670
      @maxgowland1670  Год назад +21

      You're right, I've just been doing some further reading on the subject and it turns out this is not the only known film of Busch singing this song -- there is one other, filmed some years earlier. He first recited it on film In 1931, at the end of the anti-war movie HELL ON EARTH. The film was revised in 1938. That's the version which you see projected on the screen in the background of the concert presented in my video upload. This concert itself was recorded sometime shortly before 1995, when the documentary SOLIDARITY SONG: THE HANNS EISLER STORY was made. The original mono music recording heard on the film soundtrack is enhanced, and to an extent drowned out, by the stereo overlay of the modern concert orchestra, though Busch's vocal is allowed to come through loud and clear in the mix.

  • @charlietheron8947
    @charlietheron8947 2 года назад +23

    Is there anywhere I can access this film? I would very much like to see it but I cannot find an available copy

    • @maxgowland1670
      @maxgowland1670  2 года назад +9

      I have found a website called ArtFilms-Digital where you can view the entire movie online. Only drawback is that you need to subscribe to the website first, then watch the movie. Full title of the movie is SOLIDARITY SONG: THE HANNS EISLER STORY. Address for it on the ArtFilms website is: www.artfilms-digital.com/item/solidarity-song-the-hanns-eisler-story

    • @charlietheron8947
      @charlietheron8947 2 года назад +2

      @@maxgowland1670 Thanks👍

    • @Angela-Merkel
      @Angela-Merkel 6 месяцев назад +1

      @@maxgowland1670 it there any way i can only watch the concert? is there any recording of just that or was it specifically made for the films? i already watched the hanns eisler story.

  • @novik2040
    @novik2040 3 года назад +62

    Рот фронт, товарищ!
    Rot front, comrade!
    Rot front, Genosse! ✊

    • @ДанилаПитин-н8з
      @ДанилаПитин-н8з Год назад +1

      Red front*

    • @DavdDz-fc9hu
      @DavdDz-fc9hu 6 месяцев назад

      Это немецкий ​@@ДанилаПитин-н8з

    • @Japxnchik
      @Japxnchik 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@DavdDz-fc9hu ну тут же еще на английском перевод, а тут слово с немецкого не берется.

    • @asnekboi7232
      @asnekboi7232 4 месяца назад

      Glory to the Great Eusan Nation
      Glory to the Supreme Revolutionary and her daughter

  • @ОлегПронин-ь7я
    @ОлегПронин-ь7я 2 месяца назад +4

    So based

  • @MegreliLazi1991
    @MegreliLazi1991 5 лет назад +25

  • @sebastiantigani2720
    @sebastiantigani2720 10 месяцев назад +151

    Social democrats will see this and go: literally 1984

    • @jeffmousebeans5055
      @jeffmousebeans5055 4 месяца назад

      I mean advocating for a violent socialist takeover of the ENTIRE WORLD is pretty much 1984

    • @VLKYRII
      @VLKYRII 4 месяца назад +11

      And anarchists

    • @shukshinite
      @shukshinite 4 месяца назад +12

      Big Busch is always watching..

    • @jeffmousebeans5055
      @jeffmousebeans5055 4 месяца назад

      i said this before and the comment got removed
      advocating for a socialist takeover of the world under a single "socialist world republic" is kind of very similar to 1984

    • @peopleskingdomofwolcottia
      @peopleskingdomofwolcottia 3 месяца назад +1

      I am not a social democrat, but now I understand where they got the scene for 1984 in that movie. I know that East Germany was a huge inspiration for Big Brother's Oceania, and even one of their patriotic songs became a patriotic song of this country

  • @huntress_9441
    @huntress_9441 3 года назад +29

    Is this from an East German TV broadcast or something? The internet says the song is featured at the end of a 1931 film about WWI, but this clip is in colour.

    • @maxgowland1670
      @maxgowland1670  2 года назад +36

      The clip comes from the 1996 documentary film SOLIDARITY SONG: THE HANS EISLER STORY, which featured fresh recordings of several Eisler songs and anthems, including "Secret Mobilisation". During the 1996 performance, the 1931 film-clip was projected onto the wall behind the orchestra, allowing the documentarians to combine Ernst Busch's original 1931 recital with the newly recorded 1996 orchestra and chorus.

  • @ДанилСталкер-р5ъ
    @ДанилСталкер-р5ъ 2 месяца назад +3

    Да здравствует Единый Рабочий Фронт, ура товарищи!!!!

  • @ryebreadthewhite3392
    @ryebreadthewhite3392 4 года назад +824

    The wrong Germany got power after reunification

    • @narratorjack7868
      @narratorjack7868 3 года назад +9

      the one who would shoot you for just trying to leave the place? the one with the whole "we spy on every part of your life"? Oh yeah man it should have gotten power! you know with how much of a shithole it was.

    • @ryebreadthewhite3392
      @ryebreadthewhite3392 3 года назад +130

      @@narratorjack7868 the majority of former DDR citizens want a return to the DDR

    • @narratorjack7868
      @narratorjack7868 3 года назад +4

      @@ryebreadthewhite3392 Ah so they have stockholm syndrome

    • @ryebreadthewhite3392
      @ryebreadthewhite3392 3 года назад +145

      @@narratorjack7868 Stockholm syndrome is when you want to go back to free housing and Medicare, full rights for ethnic, gender, and sexual minorities as well as lots of laws against discrimination, and one of the lowest crime rates in history.

    • @SOPPI_srn
      @SOPPI_srn 3 года назад +80

      @@ryebreadthewhite3392 also majority of soviet citizens doesn't want the union to collaspe in the vote
      but the USSR was still divided

  • @gintozlato1880
    @gintozlato1880 Год назад +1

    play around with speed a bit, its quite fun

  • @Bacya239polk2
    @Bacya239polk2 Год назад +21

    Как жаль, что молодое поколение в большинстве своём не видят истинной сути коммунизма и осуждают его. Капиталистская пропоганда, Хрущевизм и перестройка свое дело, к сожалению, сделали. Теперь коммунистам на свой страх и риск придётся не считаться с общечеловеческим мнением, чтобы спасти человечество. Вот такой парадокс

    • @VisibleLeon
      @VisibleLeon Год назад +1

      You know after the second world war most of the nations OCCUPIED by the Soviet Union didn‘t want to become communist DICTATORSHIPS they wanted to have the right to freely decide their future.

    • @VisibleLeon
      @VisibleLeon Год назад +1

      Communism itself is definitely not a good system because it can get so easily corrupt that it doesn’t matter what the PROPAGANDA feeds them through STATE RUN TV they know that conditions of living were far better in the West than in the Commie Block. „Democracy isn‘t perfect, but we never had to build a wall to keep our people IN.“

    • @rrlmusic92
      @rrlmusic92 4 дня назад

      We still have China which is causing the
      Hegemonic decline of US imperialism

  • @BUNG_DARREN
    @BUNG_DARREN 2 года назад +41

    glory to he DDR

  • @aerospaceenjoyer
    @aerospaceenjoyer 4 дня назад +1

    america 2025 theme song

  • @Generalissimo_David-B
    @Generalissimo_David-B Год назад +4

    Me and the Boys Getting Ready to Free Nick and Judy and all the Other Fandom-People From New Jersey Concentration-Camps :
    No Wait, They Already Escape Last Saga, But Who Cares, This Song's a Bop.

  • @kaiserwilliam1755
    @kaiserwilliam1755 8 месяцев назад +22

    Reminds me of 1984

    • @joaquinvideo2959
      @joaquinvideo2959 8 месяцев назад +17

      Said Kaiser William.

    • @kaiserwilliam1755
      @kaiserwilliam1755 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@joaquinvideo2959 1984

    • @Aufderr
      @Aufderr 2 месяца назад +1

      It's the screen, it looks just like that one scene with the three minutes of hate

  • @onlymatus5420
    @onlymatus5420 3 месяца назад +1

    Instructions unclear, I freed my neighbours property from his capitalist hands

  • @something1600
    @something1600 Год назад +6

    Just found out that there were two Ernst Busch, an anti-Fascist one and a fascist one.

  • @Generalissimo_David-B
    @Generalissimo_David-B Год назад +4

    the Eroican Military System In a Nutshell :

  • @keykey9095
    @keykey9095 4 года назад +9

    Жаль, что коммунисты уничтожили многр пленок с записями Эрнста Буша, когда он был на пике формы. Пришлось много переписывать на лейбле Аврора уже в 60-е, когда ему было уже за 60, и голос был уже немного не тот.

    • @ДанилаПитин-н8з
      @ДанилаПитин-н8з Год назад

      За такие плëнки в Германии в 30тые-40вые поплатился и жизнью

    • @ЕленаАлексеева-р1с
      @ЕленаАлексеева-р1с 5 месяцев назад

      В 1933 году в Германии Гитлер пришёл к власти, нацисты жестоко расправлялись с коммунистами и евреями.

    • @Noah_sig40
      @Noah_sig40 4 месяца назад

      ​@@ЕленаАлексеева-р1сIls le méritent.

  • @sagui8761
    @sagui8761 4 месяца назад +7

    This reminds me of the Eurasian alliance from the book 1984.

  • @Mwraf
    @Mwraf 15 дней назад

    "I won't get political."
    3 drinks later:

  • @epicduck3719
    @epicduck3719 2 года назад +58

    1984 Eurasia

  • @person4436
    @person4436 Год назад +6

    1984

  • @Sdogu123
    @Sdogu123 4 месяца назад +6

    1984 simulator

  • @Aero3435
    @Aero3435 7 дней назад

    Reminds me of 1984.

  • @Schiggyyy0495
    @Schiggyyy0495 3 месяца назад +1

    o7

  • @Der_Zwergen_Kaschperle
    @Der_Zwergen_Kaschperle 7 месяцев назад +2

    HahahAHAHAHAHAAhahaha🤣🤣🤣🤣
    A flying face😂😂😂😂

  • @user-cvbnm
    @user-cvbnm 7 месяцев назад +9

    1984 vibes?

  • @davidmay273
    @davidmay273 3 месяца назад

    Fuckin A! Great!

  • @mick.tecorrptfiustbot1785
    @mick.tecorrptfiustbot1785 10 месяцев назад +9

    literally 1984

    • @joaquinvideo2959
      @joaquinvideo2959 8 месяцев назад +8

      Songs will literally say "And then there will be peace on earth" and you just go "gorg or well!"

    • @belgianfried
      @belgianfried 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@joaquinvideo2959 gorg or well!

  • @rustyshackleford6849
    @rustyshackleford6849 8 месяцев назад +6

    1984 if it took place in Eurasia instead of Oceania

  • @anglo-frenchroyalist1726
    @anglo-frenchroyalist1726 10 месяцев назад +13

    Big brother no?

  • @oun-upa1929
    @oun-upa1929 Год назад +7

    Literally 1984...

    • @mojowwwav4357
      @mojowwwav4357 11 месяцев назад +15

      black and white projector = 1984, nevermind the fact the song is against facism.

    • @moad5771
      @moad5771 11 месяцев назад +8

      the song is about empowering the people to fight against fascism and war u donut

    • @МойКанал-с3м
      @МойКанал-с3м 9 месяцев назад

      Ты ж меня обнамула, ты ж меня подвела

    • @oun-upa1929
      @oun-upa1929 9 месяцев назад

      @@МойКанал-с3мО фанат Red Flood.

  • @Tagesbrecher
    @Tagesbrecher Год назад +24

    Literally 1984

    • @Benetkabc2nd
      @Benetkabc2nd Год назад +3

      Holy shit another one that see this! It is actually meaningful. But it very much reminds me of Consul from Half-Life 2 Beta

    • @goodbyetoromance9320
      @goodbyetoromance9320 11 месяцев назад +19

      ​@@Benetkabc2ndbut this song is about fighting against fascist......

    • @guitaras1323
      @guitaras1323 7 месяцев назад +13

      long live ddr and soviet union, true damocracy and frendship in labour will one day return :)

    • @coatofarms4439
      @coatofarms4439 7 месяцев назад +2

      Fascism is socialist. This song is just another example of socialism killing itself.

    • @Yankee_Smoker1917
      @Yankee_Smoker1917 5 месяцев назад

      Politics is just aesthetics at this point huh?

  • @DonnaLee-g8q
    @DonnaLee-g8q 3 месяца назад

    Thomas Thomas Young Carol Johnson Helen

  • @fabovondestory
    @fabovondestory 3 месяца назад +1

    Meanwhile the regime when the workers actually take up arms:
    You weret supossed to to that 🍊

    • @lild1ckgirl666
      @lild1ckgirl666 Месяц назад +4

      Natoid

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 17 дней назад

      Just wait until you find out that they do so because they want more socialism not less.

  • @Redoctopus07
    @Redoctopus07 4 месяца назад +2

    When Mrbeast Won't Respond To The Allegations and deletes every comment about it:

    • @Mmmmmmmm19084
      @Mmmmmmmm19084 4 месяца назад +7

      Hey let’s not talk about modern events that have no relevance to this whatsoever.

    • @Japxnchik
      @Japxnchik 4 месяца назад +4

      ​@Mmmmmmmm19084 yeah and this analogy is cringe

  • @kayyy5034
    @kayyy5034 5 месяцев назад +4

    Wunderschöne Propaganda

  • @jamesshepard2672
    @jamesshepard2672 5 месяцев назад +2

    Now Socialists/Communists hate Workers and Farmers. Cringe.

    • @Finsteral
      @Finsteral 5 месяцев назад +12

      Lies

    • @SwedishDrunkard5963
      @SwedishDrunkard5963 4 месяца назад +6

      what the fuck are you one abouy

    • @getthehelloffmyproperty
      @getthehelloffmyproperty 4 месяца назад +3

      SOME do, some online lefties, real socialists can handle reactionary ideas from the working class and anyone who cannot is not a leftist

    • @SwedishDrunkard5963
      @SwedishDrunkard5963 3 месяца назад

      what the fuck are you on about

    • @MouldMadeMind
      @MouldMadeMind 17 дней назад

      Pretty sure they think joe biden is a communist.

  • @internuf5754
    @internuf5754 5 лет назад +27

    NEVER AGAIN!
    NEVER AGAIN!
    NEVER AGAIN!
    FOR THE UNITED EUROPE
    THE ONE THAT IS NOT COMMUNIST
    AND NEVER WILL

    • @kurtberliner7049
      @kurtberliner7049 5 лет назад +126

      You are in the wrong place then. This isn't even about a united europe. this is a United World. Now go back to the reactionary corner you crawled from.

    • @bruhmachine7946
      @bruhmachine7946 5 лет назад +104

      You have been arrested by the united front in the suspicions of being a reactionary

    • @user-vs6oe8fl3m
      @user-vs6oe8fl3m 5 лет назад +2

      X D

    • @YaBoiKeith
      @YaBoiKeith 5 лет назад +72

      Communism will win

    • @mapache69.
      @mapache69. 5 лет назад +22

      Neviditelná Profilovka ironic as it’s the communists that kept Europe traditional and homogeneous while the west turned its portion into a melting pot of 3rd world scum. The communists were never the enemies...it was the Imperialists

  • @jonathandasilva3893
    @jonathandasilva3893 5 месяцев назад +2

    1984