@@eleanneblandon7935 Huh? Yeji & Chaeryeong better then Giselle? Yeji and Chaeryeong are not bad vocalists. But Giselle was definitely better. If I'm honest, Yeji is just a smattering of Great Sub Vocalist in overall KPOP standards. Even Chaeryeong is only a Great Sub Vocalist even if it's for the 4th Generation Group standard even though we all know it's far below other generations. Vocals is ITZY's biggest weakness. The True Singer on ITZY only Lia. Other then her only can singing but with no technique. Meanwhile, Giselle will very easily become the Lead Vocalist even for the standard Vocals of the 3rd Generation though. And Giselle can show that only with the song Forever. She became Sub-Vocalist just because she is SM's Idol. That's it.
For dance chaer yeji & ryujin are definitely top 3, their dances are neat & energetic, even yuna too, karina’s move arent really sharp/clean yet, or maybe cause chaer yeji ryujin has had more experience in dancing
Giselle is better than Chaer but not Yeji. Yeji voice is really stronger than Lia (not better but strong than Lia) and she can even sing A5, how high note her voice. I thing her voice is even better than Karina. Listen to Want it or this video ruclips.net/video/mJl9eVw_1jI/видео.html
Aespa be like dream on if you want to be compared to our main vocal then 1st you have to go through me Not the lead vocal Me the MAIN RAPPER LMAO HAHAHAH
Hey buddy. I do not agree with ur Vocal ranking. This should be 1. NingNing 2. Winter 3. Lia 4. Giselle 5. Karina 6. Yeji 7. Chaeryeong 8. Yuna 9. Ryujin
@@notsus3698 Voice is subjective but Karina actually has better technique and supports more frequently than Giselle does. It’s okay to prefer Giselle’s tone, but I think Karina has proven she’s objectively a more talented vocalist.
@@aura-bj4wr I agree with this. Some will say "Giselle is not above ______" you just had to say that because that's what you want to believe~ but look at this, Giselle has the least line in all of theit releases atm (except for NL) and in shows, she's usually asked to rap rather than sing because that's what most people knows her about.
I don’t like these kind of Videos bc mostly ppl are like „this group is better than this one“. Itzy is my ult gg but I see that they are kinda lagging next to aespa and that’s really frustrating bc everyone is like „see aespa is better“ and I think we should accept every group.
@@aeriiel well vocal pedogogy says something else. Lia has a better and wider breath support so she is better than karina and giselle. If she were to be in aespa she would either be a second lead vocalist or a sub vocalist (depends on how many lead vocalist they would have)
@@ilychu2203 lol who vocal pedog? ok she "might" can better vocalist karina (i still think karina better) but giselle obviously better than lia. since giselle has just debuted, she hasn't shown her best potential yet but if you check her predebut, you'll see. she was also in the church choir. lia has been an idol for over 2 years and still struggles to sing live. her voice is good but not enough
@@aeriiel lmao vocal pedogogy is not a person 🤣🤣🤣 it's the Study of vocals and the voice. Amd based on vocal pedogogy lia is better than giselle amd karina since she supports her voice better. And karina is better than giselle
heres my opinion: vocals (top 5) 1 ning ning 2 winter 3 karina 4 lia 5 giselle rap (top 5) 1 giselle 2 karina 3 ryjin 4 yuna 5 yeji dance(top3) 1 chaeryoung 2 yeji 3 karina Visual ( in my opinion) 1 winter 2 karina 3 ning ning ( her visual is really underrated she is gorgeous) 4 Giselle ( she is underrated too in visual) 5 yeji before u say im being biased im not i like all members of aespa visual better than itzy ( they ll are pretty tho) i just persoanlly think yeji is prettier than yuna and that i just dont find yuna and lia THAT pretty compared to thers i also think that ning ning and giselle are REALLY pretty and underated in visual
Giselle vocal , visual , stage presence we should appreciate it she tried her best so let's be more supportive And my bias is Giselle and winter but I like Giselle alittle better so pls like it and also be supportive to idol especially Giselle 🙂🖤💚🌙🌙
@@minholic We'll I am not an idol. But I can give you idols who can do that. And to tell you even if itzy and aespa are not dancing, people can tell who's better.
Meanwhile mbc released a list of artists who sang live and itzy performance is pre recorded lol, aespa along with skz performed live. Also aespa themselves says they sang live
Hi, for me: Vocal: 1. NingNing 2. Winter 3. Giselle/Lia (Giselle can sing very well and do higth notes plus she's very stable) Dance: 1. Chae/Yeji 2. Ryujin 3. Karina Rap: 1. Giselle 2. Ryujin 3. Karina Visual: 1.Karina 2. Winter 3. Yuna
If these girls debuted as a group their positions will be as it follows: Karina - leader, main dancer, lead vocalist, sub rapper, visual, center Yeji - main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper Lia - lead vocalist, visual Giselle - main rapper, sub vocalist Winter - main vocalist, lead dancer, face of the group Ryujin - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist Chaeryeong - main dancer, sub vocalist Ningning - main vocalist Yuna - lead dancer, lead rapper, sub vocalist, visual, maknae Lia would never be main vocalist if they debuted together. Winter and Ningning are far better than her, but I'm not hating on Lia. She's a good singer, but she's not a strong main vocalist like Ningning.
Here's My Opinion VOCAL 9.Ryujin of Itzy 8.Yuna of Itzy 7.Giselle of Aespa 6.Chaeryeong of Aespa 5.Yeji of Itzy 4.Karina of Aespa 3.Lia of Itzy 2.Winter of Aespa 1.Ning Ning of Aespa DANCE 9.Giselle of Aespa 8.Lia of Itzy 7.Ning Ning of Aespa 6.Winter of Aespa 5.Yuna of Itzy 4.Ryujin of Itzy 3.Karina of Aespa 2.Yeji of Itzy 1.Chaeryeong of Itzy RAP 9.Ning Ning of Aespa 8.Lia of Itzy 7.Winter of Aespa 6.Chaeryeong of Itzy 5.Yeji of Itzy 4.Yuna of Itzy 3.Karina of Itzy 2.Ryujin of Itzy 1.Giselle of Aespa Visual (My Opinion) 9.Ryujin of Itzy 8.Giselle of Aespa 7.Chaeryeong of Itzy 6.Yeji of Itzy 5.Ning Ning of Aespa 4.Lia of Itzy 3.Yuna of Itzy 2.Karina of Aespa 1.Winter of Aespa
@diyana shujaat And who's biased now? You can say that Lia is better that Ningning how much you want but no one is gonna believe you lol. In dance Itzy are better, not gonna complain. In rap Ryujin should be second but Giselle deserves the first place. Visual is subjective. Stage presence? I think Itzy is better by now, Aespa needs to gain more confidence. Overall Itzy isn't better in all.
@@mony3241 bruhhhhh Yeji is fine but chaeryeong is not stable and ain't better than Giselle and you are literally so biased calling Giselle weak when u can't sing so stfu
@@kimlk4313 I hope someday Ryujin covers a rap song just like Giselle to really see she can rap herself or she just read the lines that the company gives her ^^
Dream on and btw Singing isnt only based using ones supported range there are a lot of factors From Techniques, transition, etc...... Fun fact every sm artist rappers and main dancers are well versed they are very technical , they have great techniques, they know how to sing efficiently and that is one of the reason why the rappers ,dancers can harmonize with everyone Cause harmonies aint easy
![When Two Besties Bump Into Each Other by Chance | Jisoo & Jung Hoyeon [SELF-ON KODE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fL2lOgISr0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
For me Chaeryeong is the best dancer 😊💜🇧🇷
Up to you, but according to ITZY member's and skz, they said Yeji is the best dancer and top dancer
But still everyone got different opinions~
Na minha opinião também
For me both
‼️MINE‼️
Vocal :
1. Ningning aespa
2. Winter aespa
3. Lia ITZY
4. Karina aespa
5. Giselle aespa
6. Yeji ITZY
7. Chaeryeong ITZY
8. Yuna ITZY
9. Ryujin ITZY
Dance :
1. Chaeryeong ITZY
2. Yeji ITZY
3. Karina aespa
4. Ryujin ITZY
5. Winter aespa
6. Yuna ITZY
7. Ningning aespa
8. Giselle aespa
9. Lia ITZY
Rap :
1. Giselle aespa
2. Ryujin ITZY
3. Karina aespa
4. Yeji ITZY
5. Yuna ITZY
6. Winter aespa
7. Chaeryeong ITZY
8. Lia ITZY
9. Ningning aespa
Visual (My Preferences) :
1. Karina aespa
2. Winter aespa
3. Yuna ITZY
4. Lia ITZY
5. Giselle aespa
6. Ryujin ITZY
7. Ningning aespa
8. Yeji ITZY
9. Chaeryeong
Stage Present :
1. Ryujin ITZY
2. Yeji ITZY
3. Karina aespa
4. Yuna ITZY
5. Ningning aespa
6. Chaeryeong aespa
7. Winter aespa
8. Giselle aespa
9. Lia ITZY
Giselle 7 chaeryeong y yeji son mejores
@@eleanneblandon7935 Huh? Yeji & Chaeryeong better then Giselle? Yeji and Chaeryeong are not bad vocalists. But Giselle was definitely better. If I'm honest, Yeji is just a smattering of Great Sub Vocalist in overall KPOP standards. Even Chaeryeong is only a Great Sub Vocalist even if it's for the 4th Generation Group standard even though we all know it's far below other generations. Vocals is ITZY's biggest weakness. The True Singer on ITZY only Lia. Other then her only can singing but with no technique.
Meanwhile, Giselle will very easily become the Lead Vocalist even for the standard Vocals of the 3rd Generation though. And Giselle can show that only with the song Forever. She became Sub-Vocalist just because she is SM's Idol. That's it.
Agree, i think so
For dance chaer yeji & ryujin are definitely top 3, their dances are neat & energetic, even yuna too, karina’s move arent really sharp/clean yet, or maybe cause chaer yeji ryujin has had more experience in dancing
Chaeryeong aespa😐
I just think Giselle it's better as a singer than Yeji and Chaeryeong
Same!! 😭
She's a former choir member so what did u expect, she has a good vocal. And her hobby is reaching high notes.
its not a opinion its a fact🥴
@@nico-xt9dg Yes!!!
i agree
Personally I think ningning has the best stage presence in aespa 😂
Same man she may not be the best dancer but her stage presence is very good ❤️
Yes
Is Giselle in my opnion
Ning ranked 8 at visual is a scam while there's an article where she is mentioned for having a Model vibe aura among 4th gens
exactly HAHAH
My opinion:
Vocal:
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Lia
4 Karina
5 Giselle
6 Yeji
7 Chaeryeong
8 Yuna
9 Ryujin
Dance:
1 Yeji
2 Chaeryeong
3 Karina
4 Ryujin
5 Yuna
6 Winter
7 Ningning
8 Giselle
9 Lia
Rap:
1 Giselle
2 Ryujin
3 Karina
4 Yuna
5 Yeji
6 Chaeryeong
7 Lia
8 Winter
9 Ningning
Visual:
1 Winter
2 Karina
3 Yuna
4 Ningning
5 Yeji
6 Giselle
7 Lia
8 Ryujin
9 Chaeryeong
Stage presence:
1 Yeji
2 Ningning
3 Karina
4 Yuna
5 Ryujin
6 Winter
7 Chaeryeong
8 Giselle
9 Lia
My bias:
1 Ningning/Winter/Yeji
2 the rest
Try watching itzy's naver: tennis, surf, and be in love, trust me.
love this but i would say that winter is higher on the dance category and ningning is higher on stage presence for me
itzy members are more experienced when it comes to dancing
@@hhana5190 yeah they are
agree
I think Giselle is a better vocalist than Yeji and Chaeryeong.
She is
Giselle is better than Chaer but not Yeji. Yeji voice is really stronger than Lia (not better but strong than Lia) and she can even sing A5, how high note her voice. I thing her voice is even better than Karina. Listen to Want it or this video ruclips.net/video/mJl9eVw_1jI/видео.html
@@bang21cong19 yes
not better than Yeji , Yeji is a good vocalist
Aespa be like dream on if you want to be compared to our main vocal then 1st you have to go through me
Not the lead vocal
Me the MAIN RAPPER
LMAO HAHAHAH
ruclips.net/video/rraavymu2S0/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/B8uMOuEIi78/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/1rAseoyUPLM/видео.html
Hey buddy. I do not agree with ur Vocal ranking. This should be
1. NingNing
2. Winter
3. Lia
4. Giselle
5. Karina
6. Yeji
7. Chaeryeong
8. Yuna
9. Ryujin
Well Giselle isn’t above Karina so you’re automatically wrong
@@notsus3698 Voice is subjective but Karina actually has better technique and supports more frequently than Giselle does. It’s okay to prefer Giselle’s tone, but I think Karina has proven she’s objectively a more talented vocalist.
@@aura-bj4wr giselle have best vocal bitch
@@ezracarino7466 chill
@@aura-bj4wr I agree with this. Some will say "Giselle is not above ______" you just had to say that because that's what you want to believe~ but look at this, Giselle has the least line in all of theit releases atm (except for NL) and in shows, she's usually asked to rap rather than sing because that's what most people knows her about.
Giselle ranks at 7 in vocal is such a joke
So true
For me she has the 6th but she is better than chaeryeoung
my opinion:
VOCAL:
9. Ryujin
8. Giselle
7. Yuna
6. Chaeryoung
5. Karina
4. Yeji
3. Lia
2. winter
1. ningning
DANCE:
9. lia
8. giselle
7. ningning
6. winter
5. yuna
4. ryujin
3. yeji
2. karina
1. chaeryoung
RAP:
9. winter
8. ningning
7. lia
6. yeji
5. chaeryoung
4. yuna
3.karina
2. ryujin
1. giselle
VISUAL:
9. chaeryoung
8. giselle
7. ningning
6. yeji
5. karina
4. lia
3. ryujin
2. winter
1. yuna
Yeji is "The choice of real dancers and ttaibers" as the best
In here it us video making's openion BUT She is the REAL best as reality🔥
I don’t like these kind of Videos bc mostly ppl are like „this group is better than this one“.
Itzy is my ult gg but I see that they are kinda lagging next to aespa and that’s really frustrating bc everyone is like „see aespa is better“ and I think we should accept every group.
yes, me too :(
all members of aespa better vocalist than any itzy member
Nope lia is better than karina and giselle and giselle is better than chaeryeong and yeji
@@ilychu2203 for me she is not. lia is great for her group but if she was in aespa she would be sub vocalist 😭
@@aeriiel well vocal pedogogy says something else. Lia has a better and wider breath support so she is better than karina and giselle. If she were to be in aespa she would either be a second lead vocalist or a sub vocalist (depends on how many lead vocalist they would have)
@@ilychu2203 lol who vocal pedog? ok she "might" can better vocalist karina (i still think karina better) but giselle obviously better than lia. since giselle has just debuted, she hasn't shown her best potential yet but if you check her predebut, you'll see. she was also in the church choir. lia has been an idol for over 2 years and still struggles to sing live. her voice is good but not enough
@@aeriiel lmao vocal pedogogy is not a person 🤣🤣🤣 it's the Study of vocals and the voice. Amd based on vocal pedogogy lia is better than giselle amd karina since she supports her voice better. And karina is better than giselle
heres my opinion:
vocals (top 5)
1 ning ning
2 winter
3 karina
4 lia
5 giselle
rap (top 5)
1 giselle
2 karina
3 ryjin
4 yuna
5 yeji
dance(top3)
1 chaeryoung
2 yeji
3 karina
Visual ( in my opinion)
1 winter
2 karina
3 ning ning ( her visual is really underrated she is gorgeous)
4 Giselle ( she is underrated too in visual)
5 yeji
before u say im being biased im not i like all members of aespa visual better than itzy ( they ll are pretty tho) i just persoanlly think yeji is prettier than yuna and that i just dont find yuna and lia THAT pretty compared to thers i also think that ning ning and giselle are REALLY pretty and underated in visual
Ning has the best stage presence in aespa
I agree with your ranking but Ning ning have the best stage presence in aespa. Winter the worst. And giselle is better singer than chae.
Stage presence
1.Ryujin Itzy
2.Yeji Itzy
3.Yuna Itzy
4.Chaeryeong Itzy 5.Ningning Aespa
6.Lia Itzy
7.Karina Aespa
8.Winter Aespa
9.Giselle Aespa
I think 🙏🏻
dance; 1.Chaer 2.Yeji 3.Ryujin
vocal; 1.Ningning 2.Winter 3.Lia
rap; 1.Giselle 2.Ryujin 3.Karina
stage; 1.Ryujin (v obv) 2.Yeji 3.Karina
visual; 1.Karina 2.Yuna 3.Winter
Vocals: Aespa
Visuals: Aespa
Rap: Aespa
Itzy: Dance
Itzy: Stage Presence
Vocals: Aespa
Dance: Itzy
Visual: (Subjective)
Rap: (you can't deny all itzy members can rap)
@@jrenzstuv9749 and all aespa members can rap.
@butterfly giselle and karina better than ryujin and yuna
Giselle vocal , visual , stage presence we should appreciate it she tried her best so let's be more supportive
And my bias is Giselle and winter but I like Giselle alittle better so pls like it and also be supportive to idol especially Giselle 🙂🖤💚🌙🌙
Vocal ,rap,visual : aespa
But i love itzy to aetzy 👑
IMO
VOCAL
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Lia
4.Karina
5.Yeji
6.Giselle
7.Chaeryeong
8.Yuna
9.Ryujin
Dance
1.Chaeryeong
2.Yeji
3.Ryujin
4.Karina
5.Yuna
6.Winter
7.NingNing
8.Giselle
9.Lia
Rap
1.Giselle
2.Ryujin
3.Karina
4.Yuna
5.Yeji
6.Winter
7.Chaeryeong
8.Lia
9.NingNing
Visual ( Biased)
1.NingNing
2.Karina
3.Lia
4.Chaeryeong
5.Winter
6.Yuna
7.Yeji
8.Ryujin
9.Giselle
Visual (Korean Beauty standar)
1.Yuna/Karina/winter 80
2.Yeji 70
3.Lia/Ryujin/Chaeryeong 60
4.NingNing/Giselle 50
Stage presence
1.Yeji
2.Ryujin
3.Yuna
4.NingNing
5.Karina
6.Winter
7.Chaeryeong
8.Giselle
9.Lia
My opinion:
Vocals:
9)Ryunjin
8)Yuna
7)Chaeyoung
6)Giselle
5)Karina
4)Yeji
3)Lia
2)Winter
1)Ningnig
Dance:
8)Lia
7)Giselle
6)Ningnig
5)Winter
4)Yuna
3)Karina
2)Ryunjin
1)Yeji/Chaeryeong
Rap:
9)Ningnig
8)Winter
7)Lia
6)Chaeryeong
5)Yeji
4)Yuna
3)Karina
2)Ryunjin
1)Giselle
Visual:
5)Ningnig/Chaeryeong
4)Yeji/Ryunjin/Giselle
3)Lia/Karina
2)Winter
1)Yuna
Stage precence:
9)Lia
8)Ningnig
7)Giselle
6)Karina
5)Chaeryeong
4)Winter
3)Ryunjin
2)Yuna
1)Yeji
vocal
1: Ningning
2:Winter
3:Lia
4: Karina
Dance
1: Chaeryeong
2 : yeji
3: ryujin
4:yuna
Visual
1: Karina
2: Winter
3: Yuna
4:Lia
Rap:
1:Giselle
2: ryujin
3:karina
4: yeji
BYE❤️
VOCAL
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Yeji
4 Karina
5 Lia
6 Chaeryeong
7 Giselle
8 Yuna
9 Ryujin
DANCE
1 Chaeryeong
2 Yeji
3 Ryujin
4 Karina
5 Winter
6 Yuna
7 Ningning
8 Giselle
9 Lia
Rap
1 Giselle
2 Ryujin
3 Karina
4 Yeji
5 Yuna
6 Ningning
7 Winter
8 Lia
9 Chaeryeong
Visual
1 Winter
2 Yuna
3 Ryujin
4 Karina
5 Yeji
6 Ningning
7 Lia
8 Giselle
9 Chaeryeong
Stage Presense
1 Ryujin
2 Yeji
3 Karina
4 Ningning
5 Yuna
6 Winter
7 Chaeryeong
8 Giselle
9 Lia
Just my opinion
Yuna rank 8 in vocal, means they're all good in vocals
itzy 100% live
aespa 100% pre recorded
And?
Aespa is from sm.....r u fool? You can't find the difference between their sing live and pre recorded
This midzy is used to crack voices from itzy. So for his/her, crack voices is the standard. 😂😂😂 poor midzys.
@@minholic We'll I am not an idol. But I can give you idols who can do that. And to tell you even if itzy and aespa are not dancing, people can tell who's better.
Meanwhile mbc released a list of artists who sang live and itzy performance is pre recorded lol, aespa along with skz performed live. Also aespa themselves says they sang live
Yeji best dancer
Vocal
1.ningning
2.winter
3.lia
4.karina
5.yeji
6.Chaeryeong
7.giselle
8.yuna
9.ryujin
Dance
1.Chaeryeong
2.yeji
3.ryujin/karina
4.yuna
5.winter
6.ningning
7.giselle
8.lia
Rap
1.giselle
2.ryujin
3.yuna
4.yeji
5.karina/Chaeryeong
6.lia
7.ningning
8.winter
Visual
1.winter karina
2.yuna
3.lia
4.ryujin
5.ningning
6.yeji
7.Chaeryeong
8.giselle
Dance
1. Chaeryeong
2. Yeji
3. Ryujin
4. Yuna
5. Karina/winter
6. Ningning
7. Giselle
8. LiA
visual:
9-Chaeryeong
8-Giselle
7-Nigning
6-Ryujin
5-yeji
4-Lia
3-yuna
2-Karina
1-winter
aespa
itzy midzy
Joke of the day
@diyana shujaat Joke of the day
Hi, for me:
Vocal:
1. NingNing
2. Winter
3. Giselle/Lia (Giselle can sing very well and do higth notes plus she's very stable)
Dance:
1. Chae/Yeji
2. Ryujin
3. Karina
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Ryujin
3. Karina
Visual:
1.Karina
2. Winter
3. Yuna
Your video was really cool, it's very difficult to analyze the aespa with only 3 songs. But you did a good job!
Vocal:
1-NINGNING
2-WINTER
3-LIA
4-KARINA
5-YEJI
6-GISELLE
7-CHAERYEOUNG
8-YUNA
9-RIUYIN
DANCE:
1-CHAERYEOUNG
2-YEJI
3-KARINA
4-RIUYIN
5-YUNA
6-WINTER
7-NINGNING
8-LIA
9-GISELLE
RAP:
1-GISELLE
2-RIUYIN
3-KARINA
4-YUNA
5-YEJI
6-CHAERYEOUNG
7-LIA
8-WINTER
9-NINGNING
VISUAL:
1-KARINA
2-YUNA
3-WINTER
4-LIA
5-RIUYIN
6-NINGNING
7-YEJI
8-GISELLE
9-CHAERYEOUNG(ALL GIRLS ARE PRETTY)
STAGE:
1-RIUYIN
2-YEJI
3-KARINA
4-YUNA
5-CHAERYEOUNG
6-WINTER
7-NINGNING
8-LIA
9-GISELLE
If you listen to itzy that’s a nono yuna rap she will change your mond
I already listened to that song but she isn't better than Giselle or karina
@@doyoucopy7710 did you listen to “#twenty” by itzy?
@@mony3241 My opinion can't be changed. Giselle & Karina are better
I think she is better than Karina though
@@mony3241 yes twenty
If these girls debuted as a group their positions will be as it follows:
Karina - leader, main dancer, lead vocalist, sub rapper, visual, center
Yeji - main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper
Lia - lead vocalist, visual
Giselle - main rapper, sub vocalist
Winter - main vocalist, lead dancer, face of the group
Ryujin - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist
Chaeryeong - main dancer, sub vocalist
Ningning - main vocalist
Yuna - lead dancer, lead rapper, sub vocalist, visual, maknae
Lia would never be main vocalist if they debuted together. Winter and Ningning are far better than her, but I'm not hating on Lia. She's a good singer, but she's not a strong main vocalist like Ningning.
Vocal ranking:
1)ningning
2)winter
3)giselle
4)Karina
5)lia
6)yeji
7)yuna
8)chaeryoung
9)ryujin
visual my opini
1.karina
2.yuna
3.winter
4.ryujin
5.lia
6.giselle
7.chaeryeong
8.yeji
9.ningning
Here's My Opinion
VOCAL
9.Ryujin of Itzy
8.Yuna of Itzy
7.Giselle of Aespa
6.Chaeryeong of Aespa
5.Yeji of Itzy
4.Karina of Aespa
3.Lia of Itzy
2.Winter of Aespa
1.Ning Ning of Aespa
DANCE
9.Giselle of Aespa
8.Lia of Itzy
7.Ning Ning of Aespa
6.Winter of Aespa
5.Yuna of Itzy
4.Ryujin of Itzy
3.Karina of Aespa
2.Yeji of Itzy
1.Chaeryeong of Itzy
RAP
9.Ning Ning of Aespa
8.Lia of Itzy
7.Winter of Aespa
6.Chaeryeong of Itzy
5.Yeji of Itzy
4.Yuna of Itzy
3.Karina of Itzy
2.Ryujin of Itzy
1.Giselle of Aespa
Visual (My Opinion)
9.Ryujin of Itzy
8.Giselle of Aespa
7.Chaeryeong of Itzy
6.Yeji of Itzy
5.Ning Ning of Aespa
4.Lia of Itzy
3.Yuna of Itzy
2.Karina of Aespa
1.Winter of Aespa
vocal
1. ningning
2. winter
3. lia
4. karina
5. giselle
6. yeji
7. chaeryeong
8. yuna
9. ryujin
dance
1. chaeryeong
2. yeji
3. ryujin
4. karina
5. yuna
6. winter
7. ningning
8. giselle
9. lia
rap
1. giselle
2. ryujin
3. karina
4. yuna
5. yeji
6. lia
7. ningning
8. winter
9. chaeryeong
visual
1. karina
2. yuna
3. winter
4. lia
5. ryujin
6. yeji
7. giselle
8. ningning
9. chaeryeong
stage presence
1. yeji
2. ryujin
3. yuna
4. karina
5. ningning
6. chaeryeong
7. winter
8. giselle
9. lia
My uncommon visual preference:
1. Lia
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Yuna
5. Ryujin
6. Yeji
7. Ningning
8. Chaeryeong
9. Gisselle*(not sure in my spelling)
My rank
Vocal
9 Ryujin
8 Yuna
7 Giselle
6 Chaeryeong
5 Yeji
4 Karina
3 Lia
2 Winter
1 NINGNING
aespa WINS
Dance
09.Giselle
08.Lia
07.Ningning
06.Yuna
05.Winter
04.Ryujin
03.Karina
02.Yeji
01.CHAERYEONG
ITZY WINS
Rap
09.Ningning
08.Winter
07.Lia
06.Chaeryeong
05.Yeji
04.Yuna
03.Karina
02.Ryujin
01.GISELLE
ITZY WINS
Bias
09.Lia
08.Giselle
07.Chaeryeong
06.Ningning
05.Winter
04.Yuna
03.Ryujin
02.Karina
01.Yeji
ITZY WINS
Group Rank(Title Tracks)
10.ICY
9.Forever
8.Black Mamba
7.Not Shy
6.DALLA DALLA
5.LOCO
4.Mafia In The Morning
3.Next Level
2.Wannabe
1.Savage
ITZY WINS
ITZY:4
aespa:1
ITZY WINS(My Opinion)
Vocal : ningning /winter /lia /karina/ giselle /yeji /chae / yuna / ryujin
Rap : giselle/ karina / ryujin / yuna /chae/ yeji/
Dance : chae /yeji/ karina &ryujin /winter/ yuna/ ningning /giselle /lia
visual : winter karina yuna lia ryujin yeji giselle ningning chae
Present stage : ofc aespa are another level all the membet can be center in another group
@diyana shujaat And who's biased now? You can say that Lia is better that Ningning how much you want but no one is gonna believe you lol. In dance Itzy are better, not gonna complain. In rap Ryujin should be second but Giselle deserves the first place. Visual is subjective. Stage presence? I think Itzy is better by now, Aespa needs to gain more confidence. Overall Itzy isn't better in all.
My ranking :
Vocal :
1= ningning
2= winter
3= lia
4= karina
5= yeji
6= chae
7= yuna
8= giselle
9= ryujin
Dance :
1=chae
2=yeji
3= karina
4 =ryujin
5 =yuna
6 =winter
7 =ningning
8 = giselle
9 = lia
Rap :
1= giselle
2= ryujin
3= karina
4= yuna
5= yeji
6= chae
7=ningning
8= lia
9= winter
Mine is
Vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Lia
4. Karina
5. Yeji
6. Giselle
7. Chaeryoung
8. Yuna
9. Ryujin
Dance
1, chaer - smooth, fluidity
2. Karina- versatility, sharpness
3. Yeji- energy, power, sharpness
4. Ryujin
5. Yuna
6. Winter
7. Ningning
8. Giselle
9. Lia
Rap
1. Giselle-flow, clear projection
2. Ryujin- color, speed
3. Karina
4. Yuna
5. Yeji
6.lia
7. Chaer
8. Ningning
9. Winter
Visual
All
Itzy
Mines
Vocals :
1.ningning
2.winter
3.lia
4.karina
5.giselle
6.chaeryeong
7.yeji
8.yuna
9.ryunjin
Dancer :
1.chaeyeong
2.yeji
3.ryujin
4.karina
5.yuna
6.winter
8.giselle
9.lia
Rap
1.giselle
2.ryujin
3.yeji
4.karina
5.yuna
6.chaeryeong
7.winter
8.lia
9.ningning
Visual :
1.yuna
2.winter
3.lia
4.chaeryeong
5.yeji
6.karina
7.ningning
8.ryujin
9.gieselle
Stage present :
1.ryujin
2.yeji
3.yuna
4.chaeryeong
5.lia
6.karina
7.ningning
8.winter
9.giselle
It's my opinion
Yes but it my opinion all members are beautiful
Visual for me
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Yuna
4. Ningning
5. Yeji
6. Ryujin
7. Giselle
8. Lia
9. Chaeryeong
Jyp artists is always dance machines
And Sm is always kings and queens of Vocals
@diyana shujaat Joke of the day
@@kpopstan8195 he or she is talking about dancing not vocals
jyp artist look like dancefs.not singers...
@@hihi-po2tb not every
like whole nmixx are really good singers especially lily and haewon
I’m sorry but every lead dancer and main dancer in Itzy is better karina, she would be the worst dancer on itzy besides lia
stfu Karina is way better than all of them and I don't get why midzys always brag about their dances like bruhhhhh
@@kpopstan8195 Karina isn’t even better than yuna….
True
@@mony3241 yes Karina is not that good dancer
As a professional dancer myself yeji and chae is definitely better than Karina but Karina is really better than yuna and ruinjin in dance
4 Queens Aespa 👑👑👑👑
yesss
AESPA QUEENS OF 4TH GEN
Visual ranking in my opinion:
1.Yuna Itzy
2.Winter Aespa
3.Karina Aespa
4.Ryujin Itzy
5.Yeji Itzy
6.Lia Itzy
7. Ningning Aespa
8.Giselle Aespa
9.Chaeryeong Itzy
the fact that visual is Yuna number 1 in itzy and aespa with KBS 98%, Karina and winter are under Yuna you know☺️
How I rank them
Vocals : Aespa
Dance : Itzy
Rap : Izty
YES
Yes in rap i chose itzy cause of their song Twenty
For me:
Vocal💖
9) Ryujin
8) Yuna
7) Chaeryeong
6) Yeji
5) Giselle
4) Lia
3) Karina
2) Winter
1) NingNing
Rap💖
9) Lia
8) Chaeryeong
7) Yeji
6) Yuna
5) Winter
4) NingNing
3) Ryujin
2) Karina
1) Giselle
Dance💖
9) Lia
8) Giselle
7) NingNing
6) Yuna
5) Winter
4) Chaeryeong
3) Ryujin
2) Karina
1) Yeji
Visual💖
9) Chaeryeong
8) Giselle
7) Yeji
6) Ryujin
5) Lia
4) Yuna
3) NingNing
2) Karina
1) Winter
Stage Presence💖
9) Giselle
8) Lia
7) Chaeryeong
6) Yuna
5) Winter
4) Yeji
3) NingNing
2) Karina
1) Ryujin
So pretty ITZY and aespa
Aespa vs ae-aespa a better competition
I don’t know how people think Gisselle is better than yeji or Chaeryeong, she sounds weak to me
@Aespa Once Stole Nævis's Wig🌠 bruh, aespa is literally in your name how can you call me baised..
@@mony3241 bruhhhhh Yeji is fine but chaeryeong is not stable and ain't better than Giselle and you are literally so biased calling Giselle weak when u can't sing so stfu
@@kpopstan8195 how is chae not stable…
Winter's dance skill is below Yuna???? not right at all and Ningning should be appreciated more for visuals
Winter and Yuna destroyed your rap ranking lol 😂
I really love this ranking
Vocal : aespa
Visual : both
Dancer : itzy
Raper : both
Stage present ofc itzy
Rapper giselle is butter..
@diyana shujaat itzy flopp
Aespa are aces they're the best!
they're "Trash" hehe 🚮
@@kimlk4313 who flopzy💀
@@kimlk4313 😂😂🥺🥺you saw them when you were in trash bin?
@@scropwsanct2059 aesflop flopping since debut with 0 win LMAO
@@thugb2696 Haaa is it a joke? let me laugh ahahahahahahahahahahaha
I think chaeryeong should be no.8 Atleast in terms of visuals and idk how giselle is above Ning Ning lol. I can clearly see bias here
Wouldn't any visial ranking be biased though? You preferring ningning is biased lmao. I agreed with the video maker
@@regularpotato good for you enjoy the video
Giselle and Karina are even better vocalists than Lia
ryujin best dancer and controling body than karina
ryujin won first place in a show she better at rapping
With a not so talented competitors
@@reggiemagdura877 aespa who? are they even in a show battle like ryujin HA!
@@kimlk4313 I hope someday Ryujin covers a rap song just like Giselle to really see she can rap herself or she just read the lines that the company gives her ^^
Aespa and only aespa!
@diyana shujaat Everyone can like who they like
@diyana shujaat You’re the joke here. Alpot ka
Giọng của Yuna rap rất hợp sẽ hay hơn khi tập luyện về rap sẽ rap tốt
giọng Yuna rap hay cực luôn
Whatever shin ryujin oppa better than anyone. My crush
itzy
Funny how whenever there's a ITZY vs Aespa, Aespa stans always bragged about Aespa Vocals only😂
and itzy stans brag about their dances
only
Aespa visuals
Aespa rap
Aespa vocals
itzy dance only🤣
@@kpopstan8195 👍
@@kpopstan8195 Nah ITZY is better at Rapping, Stage Presence, Facial expressions, Live Vocals with complicated choreo
I think this video should be updated 🤗
Chaeryeong is the best dancer
Love the hair @ 3:23
Chaeryeong is a better rapper than yeji technically, not to mention that she used to be a lead rapper
I prefer Ryujin on dance no3
Lia ningning is same level
Lia supported range a4
Ningning supported range a4
ningning has C5
Dream on and btw
Singing isnt only based using ones supported range there are a lot of factors
From
Techniques, transition, etc......
Fun fact every sm artist rappers and main dancers are well versed they are very technical , they have great techniques, they know how to sing efficiently and that is one of the reason why the rappers ,dancers can harmonize with everyone
Cause harmonies aint easy
lia technique is a bit lacking
Dance ranking should be:
1. Chaeryeong/Yeji
3. Yuna
4. Ryujin
5. Karina/Winter/NingNing
6. Giselle/Lia
Joke of the year🥺✨
Someone pls tell me what song is the intro?
Dance 3Ryujin 4Karina
What song is the intro?
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Lia
3. Winter
4. Giselle
5. Karina
6. Yeji
7. Chaeryeong
8. Yuna
9. Ryujin
Dance
1. Yeji
2. Chaeryeong
3. Ryujin
4. Karina
5. Yuna
6. Winter
7. Giselle/Ning
8. Lia
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Ryujin
3. Yuna
4. Karina
5. Yeji
6. Lia
7. Charyeong
8. Ning
9. Winter
Visual
1. Karina
2. Yuna
3. Lia
4. Winter
5. Yeji
6. Ryujin
7. Giselle
8. Ningning
9. Charyeong
Stage Presence
1. Karina
2. Yeji
3. Yuna
4. Ryujin
5. Ningning
6. Lia
7. Giselle
8. Charyeong
9. Winter
Winter is better vocalist than lia
@diyana shujaat sorry but winter is better vocalist than lia
Yeji has better stage presence than karina
Aespa
Itzy