CA Anuj Goyal on Competency of CS, CMA fraternity | Whole Controversy Explained |

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 янв 2025

Комментарии • 20

  • @ShivHelps-Always
    @ShivHelps-Always Месяц назад +5

    #DTC 2025#
    Power of Tax Audit in Income Act, 1961 is unfortunately given to CA only even if its proper learned, studied & interpreted by CMA and CS students & Members,
    Now honorable FM & DT Committee realised that.
    CAs have statutory audit power under Companies Act(as CAs are expert in Statutory Audit),
    CS has Secretarial Audit power under Companies Act(as CSs are experts in Secretarial Audit) and
    CMA has Cost Audit Power under Companies Act(as CMAs are expert in Cost Audit)
    So the power of Tax audit should be shared with CS and CMA for better competition, Equally opportunity, Timely filing of Tax Audit report without every time asking for extension, For better Economy and Eeasy Access for Clients. 🙏
    || Pls write to the government for your right ||

  • @sandeeppatankar8020
    @sandeeppatankar8020 17 дней назад +1

    Even CA is not at all competent for not only tax audit but any work

  • @renganathanthangadurai7451
    @renganathanthangadurai7451 4 часа назад

    CMA is equally an accountant. In the current context, return filing has been computerised. what that CA can do in return filing that CMA cannot do. CAs are already irritated because their ambligal guard with tax authorites have been cut off. If CMA can play a role in GST, why not in Income tax ? CAs are trying to make IT as a rocket science. Even rocket launching to day is handled by People with humble beginning.

  • @carajeevjha8890
    @carajeevjha8890 Месяц назад +2

    Everyone is having their own specialisation - doctors work can be done by nurse?

    • @pawanshukla4129
      @pawanshukla4129 Месяц назад +1

      Mujhe nhi pata kis nase me rhte ho ap log
      Dr Dr bolte rhte ho
      2500 me audit karte ho or at last ek form bharne ko specialization bolte ho audit me
      Or vo form bhi article bharta hai
      Pata nhi konsa sa sasta nasa karte hai CA members 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @rahulbhagat2580
      @rahulbhagat2580 18 дней назад +1

      2500 jyada ho gya...2000 me upload karte hai.....hahaha

    • @carajeevjha8890
      @carajeevjha8890 13 дней назад

      More than 90% of the chartered accountants are capable of flying and flying the Indian colours globally. When the question is coming to face global professionals like CPA, ACCA etc everyone's eyes on CA only Front line professional worries of India - घर में बिल्ली म्याऊं म्याऊं, होमवर्क कर लो भाई अपना प्राइस ही 2500/- रख रहे हो।

  • @akking__07
    @akking__07 Месяц назад +2

    No one has power to tax audit other than ca 😂😂

    • @ShivHelps-Always
      @ShivHelps-Always Месяц назад

      @@akking__07 #DTC 2025#
      Power of Tax Audit in Income Act, 1961 is unfortunately given to CA only even if its proper learned, studied & interpreted by CMA and CS students & Members,
      Now honorable FM & DT Committee realised that.
      CAs have statutory audit power under Companies Act(as CAs are expert in Statutory Audit),
      CS has Secretarial Audit power under Companies Act(as CSs are experts in Secretarial Audit) and
      CMA has Cost Audit Power under Companies Act(as CMAs are expert in Cost Audit)
      So the power of Tax audit should be shared with CS and CMA for better competition, Equally opportunity, Timely filing of Tax Audit report without every time asking for extension, For better Economy and Eeasy Access for Clients. 🙏
      || Pls write to the government for your right ||

    • @SuyogPatil-xd5bj
      @SuyogPatil-xd5bj Месяц назад +1

      Haaa CA having ethics but they don't know what it is, aajate hai compare karne!
      😂😂

    • @akking__07
      @akking__07 Месяц назад

      @SuyogPatil-xd5bj I don't have words to say you anything

    • @ShivHelps-Always
      @ShivHelps-Always Месяц назад +1

      @@akking__07 look at history, many power has been shifted to other professional

    • @akking__07
      @akking__07 Месяц назад

      @ShivHelps-Always but tax audit and statutory audit can't take any other profession