I read a joke in Khushwant Singh's joke book : During Military rule in pakistan , Three people were brought before a Judge for beating up a military officer . Judge asks : why did you beat up this officer ? First man : Sir , he was trying to harass my daughter . As a pakistani father , it is my duty to protect the honour of my daughter Judge: OK , you get bail . Next person , why did you beat up the officer ? Second man : Sir , the woman he was harassing is my sister . As a pakistani brother , it is my duty to protect my sister . Judge: ok , you also get bail . Next person , why did you beat up the officer ? Is that lady also your relative ? Third man : oh no Sir , I was just passing by when I saw these guys beating up a Military officer . So I thought maybe Military rule is over , so I decided to join in
@@ThePakistanExperience Why are Pakistanis crying. They got exactly what they wanted. They take pride in idolizing what Muslim rulers did to they to sanatanis, but cry when the same thing happens to them. Pakistan is a perfect example of "Choose your idols carefully". Ab gaznavi ko idolize karoge to Zia ul haq hi milega. Congratulations Pakistanis. May your leader keep following example of gaznavi.
Shehzad i am a typical desi housewife and your videos are very eye opening. You taught me how to unlearn for good. Now i try to think rational in every situation and try to face and accept reality as i was living in delusion like most of the Pakistanis. Lots of respect from USA and please wish me luck as I am starting college in fall and resuming education after 15 years
you are one of the few intellectual of the pakistan who are on the right path by standing against the so called civil millitary establishment of pakistan who ruled pakistan for 77 years for thier own benifits and neglected the rights of comman people, keep it up we are with you, supporting you from the Sukkur, Sindh.❤❤
@@ThePakistanExperience Why are Pakistanis crying. They got exactly what they wanted. They take pride in idolizing what Muslim rulers did to they to sanatanis, but cry when the same thing happens to them. Pakistan is a perfect example of "Choose your idols carefully". Ab gaznavi ko idolize karoge to Zia ul haq hi milega. Congratulations Pakistanis. May your leader keep following example of gaznavi.
So beautifully described "Democracy is like sampling planted"...you need to nurture it to grow up strong with deep roots...and just after 5 years shout ..."why the tree is not giving fruits"... Couldn't be explained better ...kudos Shahzad
Recently saw u on Zara hut kay loved it. Hear you and watch Zara hut kay regularly. Other than the content I love humility, honesty and inherent decency in both programs
❤lajawab love from PURA SUCH TV 📺 by Ahmed Azizi Canada 🇨🇦. In this age and environment the way u have the in-depth knowledge and analytical skills is adorable.
It can be difficult to tell the difference between true and false news. Your yesterday's post about Noam Chomsky's death demonstrates that even people in the online world, such as yourself, can be victims of false information. By the way, you're doing excellent work. Keep it up. Greetings from cloudy but warm Italy.
@ThePakistanExperience Bhai, what I don't understand is, Why the People of Pakistan are silent for the last 75+ Years, Even after they know that the ESTABLISHMENT is CORRUPT & Elite Centric. They know that Pakistan ARMY 🇵🇰 is the cause of current Economic situation & ALL OTHER UNCERTAINTY....... Make a video on this ❤️❤️
shivampatil23 Same reason why BJP supporters are blind to their crony capitalism, washing powder, communal rhetoric, lies, corruption, sex scandals, trying to change constitution, treatment of farmers, treatment of journalist, media takeover, assinating dissidents on friendly nations soil. most Pakistanis just like most BJP supporters are ideologically driven and care only about personal benefit and not what is best for all citizens. They both lack critical thinking or their ideology blinds them to overlook own flaws.
Shehzad, I love your discussion, The constitution is a living dynamic document which needs to evolve with changing times. It should protect the poor who do not have the resources to fight their oppressors.
And just to add my blah blah... 95 + percnt of the population doesn't know what the 'constitution' means. The others maybe have heard of it! But, I applaud your effort for trying to inform and communicate . People like you and Muzammil... Big respect.. Satark raho(crime patrol) 😉, jaan hai toh jahan hai mister🙏🇮🇳
Mortal Kombat mayn Hadoouke us tarha se nhi hota. 😀 Man, I love how detail oriented and nuanced you are. That's the only quality which is the most appealing to me in a person. Jeetay Raho bro. I wish whoever wrote that on your car, goes through a stroke of enlightenment and starts to think neutrally about stuff. 🤗
@@ThePakistanExperience Please keep calling Dr. Hoodhbhoy, Dr. Salman Hameed, Amber Shamsi, Uzair Younas, Syed Muzammil and the last guy you had with whom you made the AllTime 11 (he looks like a smart guy, I would like to see you talk to him about stuff other than Cricket as well). Also, please do less of those Tamkeenat, etc stuff. I think those folks are bad company for you. That's not your league.
@@ThePakistanExperience I think a podcast on South Punjab and History of Baloch in Pakistan could be good and informative for the public who don't know much like that Balochs wanted a Independent Nation in 1920 and in 1922 published there idea of a islamic consitutional Baluch Nation in Hamdard
Shehzad bhai next video shoukd be about forced Disappearances of dissidents, its historical context , current situation and future impact for pakistan. Thank you .
The brain washing is so real that even my parents told me that musharaff was a hero and ran the economy better than pmln,ppp. Later i got to know, it was the Dollars and also how he did kargil and abandoned his own jawans by declaring them mujahideen.
I wish I knew all of this 24 years ago. Unfortunately i was raised under the regime of Musharraf who took my rights as a Pakistani and provided a media circus in return. But thanks my man 🙏
Pakistan is a security state. Western nations create Pakistan. Extremism's religious mindset destroys Pakistan one day. Baluch students are missing from college but no one protest. Pakistan military doing business in Pakistan market not outside. No democracy only army rules in Pakistan. Pakistan crying for Gaza not for Afghani refugees Muslim. Ahmadiyya community face discrimination in Chakwal Punjab. Chiristan Church buring . Blasphemy law Blasphemy law Blasphemy law
Totally agree to you on lip service in case to Islamising Pakistan because it was usually done by people who had no knowledge on Islam or no knowledge on the relevant subject they wanted to Islamise i.e here the banking system. Few yrs ago i did the gender training program along with a Malaysian gender expert who was well read on Quran. It was amazing and i took that tip from and read Quran, hadith and variety of literature on Islamic history before my gender training and my communication improved. Like Islam we as a nation have not understood our constitution not even our basic fundamental rights.
19:00 I appreciate your summary of this dense book, but I can't stand by and let you confuse fighting game franchises. Ken and Ryu are from Street Fighter, not Mortal Kombat.
7:23 You forgot to mention that Z.A. Bhutto was the foreign minister of the very same dictator Ayub Khan... surely must have just slipped your mind 😉...
If constitution is a piece of paper then what is a religious book? Same logic applies there too. Bhai tumhe kaheen utha na le jaen😅......take care and always be alert.
@@apurvabhide2860 all muslims of Indian subcontinent are effectively Pakistanis, as Pakistan got independence before India, the British India declared Pakistan as a land for Muslims
Shehzad some indian people treat constitution like a sacred book bcz founder of constitution was from their community. Their is no possibility to bring positive changes in constitution... Whats your thaught about it.. Should we follow constitution religiously? Or it should be reformed time to time?
Not really..the basic structure of constitution couldn't be changed as made clear by keshwananad bharti case...we aren't thaught about it..apart from it everything is there
6:47 " Democracy gorey logon ki hoti hai " Similar to some politicians in India who used to say " yeh IT YT kya hai , India mein computers ki kya zaroorat , yeh America nahi hai "
This book is quickly climbing up my must read wishlist, thanks to your constant plugging.But, if I may nitpick, (and you might totally think this to be beyond the ambit of the topic at hand), nevertheless one feels that if we must take the help of the 'State of nature' argument to emphasise the need for a Constitution, we must also touch upon(however briefly), the very problematic, racist and exploitative context in which these theories were first conceptualized by these so-called enlightenment thinkers be it Hobbes, Locke or Mill, and the subsequent havoc these theories wreaked on the lives of the native populations of not just America and Australia but to some extent India and Africa as well. The idea is not to simply shit on these enlightenment philosophies, pat ourselves on the back for decolonising our minds and call it a day, but rather to critically engage with these ideas, contexualise them, and while being appreciative of the benefits of an idea like 'the social contract', also recognise and warn against the patterns of disenfranchisement that repeat themselves in more or less similar ways even today, as they did back then, once these ideas get translated on the ground; be it in the form of dispossession of the fishermen of Gwadar or Karachi, the displacement of kacchi-aabaadi dwellers in cities like Delhi and Islamabad ,or the permanent expulsion of the indigenous people from their ancestral lands simply because they don't fit into the narrow idea of citizenship defined by that Nation-State. Apologies for the long rant.Great explainer as always. Loved the Hindustani Bhau reference in there. Stay safe 💗
The military establishment in Pakistan has maintained a dominant role in the country's politics for several decades, often intervening in civilian governance and even directly ruling the country through military coups. There are a few key reasons for this: Perception of civilian weakness: The military sees civilian institutions and political leaders as lacking the ability to effectively govern and manage the country's affairs. This has led the military to view itself as the sole savior of the nation, justifying its interventions in politics. Lack of civilian control over the military: Civilian leaders have been unable to fully institutionalize democratic control over the armed forces, allowing the military to maintain autonomy and influence over key policy decisions. Military's economic and political interests: The military has built up extensive business interests and a powerful role in the economy, giving it a vested interest in maintaining its influence. It has also forged direct foreign policy ties, further entrenching its political power. Constitutional ambiguity: The constitution of Pakistan has been repeatedly amended, with provisions that allow the military to intervene in politics under the "doctrine of necessity." This has provided legal justification for military coups and rule. However, the current army chief, Gen. Asim Munir, has stated that the military is "well aware" of its constitutional limits and expects others to "uphold the constitution." This suggests an acknowledgement that the military's political dominance may face challenges, especially if civilian institutions can assert their constitutional authority. The strength of Pakistan's democratic institutions will be crucial in determining the future civil-military relationship.
You forgot the most important reason which Mr Pervez Hoodbhoy has mentioned : Hostility with India and obsession with Kashmir that allows the army to scare the pakistani people
A bad document with good leadership is a lot better than a good document with bad leadership. As a constitution can be amended but loyalty to country and good intentions cannot be changed or amended .
good doc leads to good system in place and it will automatically flushes out bad apples but depending upon just personalities k 'aik banda aaye ga aur sub theek ho jaye ga' is just a child thinking and it doesn't work like this especially in modern world
At least your research is inthe right direction but i would like to hear a bit positive about the particular time you talking about along with critical lense.
Dear Shahjad Sheikh ji, Majority Muslim public in our subcontinent became a victim of The British Rulers' interests of post independence period coupled with ego & selfish interests of pseudo muslim Late Baba Jinnah. There was no sympathy to the idea floated for separate nation for muslims & Two Nations Theory till elections of 1937. Even during 1940 there was no demand for Pakistan in the resolution passed by muslim league at annual conference at Lahore, only reference for more autonomy for muslim majority states of North & North Western states was made. After that at the behest of Governor General Linlithgo backed by former PM of UK Late Winston Churchill, muslim league led by Jinnah floated the Two Nations Theory & separate nation for muslims. No doubt The Britishers wanted to weaken the freedom movement of The Congress Party, because being quite engaged in second world war, utterly in need of British India army & brave fighting soldiers from India, also under huge disturbed economic conditions. The Congress Leadership too failed to anticipate the dirty process of conspiracies for which The British Rulers were quite expert. Though Gandhiji had twenty one meetings with late Jinnah after release from jail at Jinnah's residence Malabar Hills Bombay, but Jinnah being backed & assured by The Britishers refused to budge & amend his Two Nations Theory. After partition & assassination of PM Late Liaquat Ali Khan, all leaders of muslim league lacked patriotism, spirit of sacrifice, bankrupt with vision for progress, economic development of Pakistan, her public indulged in leg pullings of each other for selfish interests which gave a pretext to military leadership to step in & enforce dictatorship which ignorant public of Pakistan too welcomed by distributing sweats in cities. Cunning persons like Zulfikar Ali Bhutto became advisers, close confidents of the dictator. Even journalists of whole mainstream media of Pakistan too became psycophants. As per custom evolved, mullah mafia too became psycophant of dictators. Please take care of yourself as ruling elite of Pakistan may not like your words & podcasts. Thanks.
I don't agree with this sentiment. Constitution isn't the supreme authority to determine morality. Slavery was once constitutional in the US and so was everything that the Nazis did. The constitution is nothing but a formalization of the state and for any revolution or a people's movement ,the state will try to use constitution to suppress any uprising. After the communists took over,they introduced a new constitution because China was now a new state. Same with Pakistan. The constitution of the Islanic republic of Pakistan can NEVER be a source of justice or moralirty because it serves a state created on the basis of a hateful religious theory(two nation theory). Much like how you can never expect the Israeli constitution to ever deliver justice to the Arabs.
Hey Shehzad bhai...any chance that you may become a 'part' of Mr Khaqaan Abbasi's new party? It seems to be good avenue/platform for brains like yourself to atleast start rubbing shoulders with the decision makers!!!
Shahzad bhai, me apko sunnta ho kafi achy se bhai but ek eltija hai me janta ho ap flow me bolty hein but kindly ya to urdu me continue kr lein ya English me. Mix up ho jata hai bhai bat samhajny me. Baki shukria ap aese hi kam karty rahein we love you and JazakAllah.
People come and break pak constitution...people just take it without reacting....and this will continue in Pakistan because people power has been curtailed badly
I read a joke in Khushwant Singh's joke book :
During Military rule in pakistan , Three people were brought before a Judge for beating up a military officer .
Judge asks : why did you beat up this officer ?
First man : Sir , he was trying to harass my daughter .
As a pakistani father , it is my duty to protect the honour of my daughter
Judge: OK , you get bail . Next person , why did you beat up the officer ?
Second man : Sir , the woman he was harassing is my sister . As a pakistani brother , it is my duty to protect my sister .
Judge: ok , you also get bail . Next person , why did you beat up the officer ? Is that lady also your relative ?
Third man : oh no Sir , I was just passing by when I saw these guys beating up a Military officer . So I thought maybe Military rule is over , so I decided to join in
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience 🤗❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience Why are Pakistanis crying. They got exactly what they wanted. They take pride in idolizing what Muslim rulers did to they to sanatanis, but cry when the same thing happens to them. Pakistan is a perfect example of "Choose your idols carefully". Ab gaznavi ko idolize karoge to Zia ul haq hi milega. Congratulations Pakistanis. May your leader keep following example of gaznavi.
😂😂😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😂😅
Shehzad i am a typical desi housewife and your videos are very eye opening. You taught me how to unlearn for good. Now i try to think rational in every situation and try to face and accept reality as i was living in delusion like most of the Pakistanis. Lots of respect from USA and please wish me luck as I am starting college in fall and resuming education after 15 years
Best of luck..didi..🎉🎉from🇮🇳
All the best for a new and progressive chapter in your life!! Keep growing
🙌
Good luck!
@@abhaypatel4292 thank you ☺️
you are one of the few intellectual of the pakistan who are on the right path by standing against the so called civil millitary establishment of pakistan who ruled pakistan for 77 years for thier own benifits and neglected the rights of comman people, keep it up we are with you, supporting you from the Sukkur, Sindh.❤❤
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience Why are Pakistanis crying. They got exactly what they wanted. They take pride in idolizing what Muslim rulers did to they to sanatanis, but cry when the same thing happens to them. Pakistan is a perfect example of "Choose your idols carefully". Ab gaznavi ko idolize karoge to Zia ul haq hi milega. Congratulations Pakistanis. May your leader keep following example of gaznavi.
So beautifully described "Democracy is like sampling planted"...you need to nurture it to grow up strong with deep roots...and just after 5 years shout ..."why the tree is not giving fruits"...
Couldn't be explained better ...kudos Shahzad
🙌
Yet another master piece. Please share it with youngsters so they know their history and understand the importance of reading books.
🙌
Salute 🫡 Thank you for this. People like you give me hope in Pakistan
🙌
Recently saw u on Zara hut kay loved it. Hear you and watch Zara hut kay regularly. Other than the content I love humility, honesty and inherent decency in both programs
❤️
Glad to see you're still with us after the last episode 😂😂😂
😅
❤lajawab love from PURA SUCH TV 📺 by Ahmed Azizi Canada 🇨🇦.
In this age and environment the way u have the in-depth knowledge and analytical skills is adorable.
It can be difficult to tell the difference between true and false news. Your yesterday's post about Noam Chomsky's death demonstrates that even people in the online world, such as yourself, can be victims of false information. By the way, you're doing excellent work. Keep it up. Greetings from cloudy but warm Italy.
I trusted the Jacobin. They were wrong. My bad. Thank youu
Tazaad: With a shortened first “a” like “kharaab” (bad), not like “taalaab” (pond).
Great show. Very informative!
🙌
@ThePakistanExperience Bhai, what I don't understand is, Why the People of Pakistan are silent for the last 75+ Years, Even after they know that the ESTABLISHMENT is CORRUPT & Elite Centric. They know that Pakistan ARMY 🇵🇰 is the cause of current Economic situation & ALL OTHER UNCERTAINTY.......
Make a video on this ❤️❤️
shivampatil23 Same reason why BJP supporters are blind to their crony capitalism, washing powder, communal rhetoric, lies, corruption, sex scandals, trying to change constitution, treatment of farmers, treatment of journalist, media takeover, assinating dissidents on friendly nations soil.
most Pakistanis just like most BJP supporters are ideologically driven and care only about personal benefit and not what is best for all citizens. They both lack critical thinking or their ideology blinds them to overlook own flaws.
Bro the reason is same as why North Koreans don't raise their voices against Kim Jong Un. Did you ever ask this question to North Koreans?🤔
@@shazaib.ali34 No, because there RUclips is banned in north Korea..
Majority of us have been fooled for 75 years, it has only been a year since the masses have started recognizing the root of all problems.
@@shivampatil23 Can you question Modi's credibility in India? You get labeled as desh drohi for that.
Thanks betta ❤may Allah protect you Ameen 🙏 proud of you standing with the truth and justice son of our soil💕
❤️
mere bhra mere veer apna khyal rkhi. waheguru hmesha mehr rakhe tere te. india punjab ton bhut bhut pyar
❤️
Important conversation.
Love the way u talk…… and your knowledge is amazing
🙌
Mashallaha
Reasoning science is very important in Islam and every society
Boom just nailed it. Such an amazing concept of which we were kept deprived
🙌
opposed to Pakistan, India got a group of very able people to write a Constitution and that has made the difference in their development.
Yes
Shehzad, I love your discussion, The constitution is a living dynamic document which needs to evolve with changing times. It should protect the poor who do not have the resources to fight their oppressors.
❤️
Beautiful, Beautiful analysis.
🙌
And just to add my blah blah... 95 + percnt of the population doesn't know what the 'constitution' means. The others maybe have heard of it! But, I applaud your effort for trying to inform and communicate . People like you and Muzammil... Big respect.. Satark raho(crime patrol) 😉, jaan hai toh jahan hai mister🙏🇮🇳
Mortal Kombat mayn Hadoouke us tarha se nhi hota. 😀 Man, I love how detail oriented and nuanced you are. That's the only quality which is the most appealing to me in a person. Jeetay Raho bro. I wish whoever wrote that on your car, goes through a stroke of enlightenment and starts to think neutrally about stuff. 🤗
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience Please keep calling Dr. Hoodhbhoy, Dr. Salman Hameed, Amber Shamsi, Uzair Younas, Syed Muzammil and the last guy you had with whom you made the AllTime 11 (he looks like a smart guy, I would like to see you talk to him about stuff other than Cricket as well). Also, please do less of those Tamkeenat, etc stuff. I think those folks are bad company for you. That's not your league.
20 sec in, hears the cr story
Allah hifazat frmaye apki
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperience I think a podcast on South Punjab and History of Baloch in Pakistan could be good and informative for the public who don't know much like that Balochs wanted a Independent Nation in 1920 and in 1922 published there idea of a islamic consitutional Baluch Nation in Hamdard
Shehzad bhai next video shoukd be about forced Disappearances of dissidents, its historical context , current situation and future impact for pakistan. Thank you .
The brain washing is so real that even my parents told me that musharaff was a hero and ran the economy better than pmln,ppp. Later i got to know, it was the Dollars and also how he did kargil and abandoned his own jawans by declaring them mujahideen.
Yes
It's not Constitution vs Establishment. It's Constitution vs Islam.
Islam lives rent free in your minds and I like it.
@@BilalHussain-dx8fx
Hahaha. Best line.
It used to live rent free in my brain too but I got it evicted. Life is good now (Alhamdulilah 😜😜)
@@Muawiyah7866 i will wave at you from heaven.
@@BilalHussain-dx8fx
InshAllah brother
@virajprabhu1153:😂🤣 TheaRSSeGbbrrrrChhddzzz were screaming 400 paar for what?? #ConstitutionVsTheaRSSeChhdzz😂
Thanks Sir
🙌
We in India refound our love for the constitution and democracy on 4th June.
I wish I knew all of this 24 years ago. Unfortunately i was raised under the regime of Musharraf who took my rights as a Pakistani and provided a media circus in return. But thanks my man 🙏
🙌
Thank you.
🙌
Very important subject chosen.Thanks. watching from India.
🙌
One leg in Islam other leg in Nuclear Bomb 😅😅😅 And they need constitution 😂😂😂
You are really very brave and your assessment is always balanced and impartial
🙌
Pakistan is a security state.
Western nations create Pakistan.
Extremism's religious mindset destroys Pakistan one day.
Baluch students are missing from college but no one protest.
Pakistan military doing business in Pakistan market not outside.
No democracy only army rules in Pakistan.
Pakistan crying for Gaza not for Afghani refugees Muslim.
Ahmadiyya community face discrimination in Chakwal Punjab.
Chiristan Church buring .
Blasphemy law
Blasphemy law
Blasphemy law
When jews paid jajia tax for centuries to rulers, why should not they impose JAJIA in Israel 😅
Totally agree to you on lip service in case to Islamising Pakistan because it was usually done by people who had no knowledge on Islam or no knowledge on the relevant subject they wanted to Islamise i.e here the banking system. Few yrs ago i did the gender training program along with a Malaysian gender expert who was well read on Quran. It was amazing and i took that tip from and read Quran, hadith and variety of literature on Islamic history before my gender training and my communication improved.
Like Islam we as a nation have not understood our constitution not even our basic fundamental rights.
Free market instead of state law is real way to peace and prosperity
Shehzad you talk about system within sutyem runes the first one well done.
What would say about demand of sharia law in uk?
19:00 I appreciate your summary of this dense book, but I can't stand by and let you confuse fighting game franchises. Ken and Ryu are from Street Fighter, not Mortal Kombat.
🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈
Sir... Bravo.. Subscribe you on your courage
❤️
Transiting through an airport but can’t miss Shehzad’s upload. Big cheers bro!!! Sanvidhan and the latest elections in India. Do check related news.
🙌
Please, young man, be safe . Can you come to the US or UK for some time ? Or maybe Dubai 😊. Stay safe 🙏
❤️
Dear Shahzad!
Ken and Ryu are not from Mortal Kombat 😅
RIP Street Fighter 19:19...
Whoops
Jaldi jaldi mai kafi Bari ghalti kardi ye toh
Not at all given the context and quality of the content within the video...kudos and more power to you 🙏
🙌
May Allah bless you and keep you safe based upon your intentions from the ruling Pakistani Goons.
🙌
7:23
You forgot to mention that Z.A. Bhutto was the foreign minister of the very same dictator Ayub Khan... surely must have just slipped your mind 😉...
Stay safe Shahzad! You're doing God's work. Praying for your safety!
❤️
More power to you brother. May god bless you
🙌
Good analytical podcast.....keep it up!!!!
🙌
Zabardast
Ek hi dil he, kitni bar jeeto gy. ❤
❤️
If constitution is a piece of paper then what is a religious book? Same logic applies there too. Bhai tumhe kaheen utha na le jaen😅......take care and always be alert.
Shehzad, mere bhai, mere dost, sambhal ke raho yaar. Love from India.
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperienceaap yaad aayenge humko, Army now knows your location 😂
Which author 9 37 u were quoting??
he didn't say " TO BE thrown in the dust bin" he said " COULD BE thrown in the dust bin"
Semantics
✒️👀✒️
اے ذوقؔ دیکھ دُخترِ رَز کو نہ مُنہ لگا
چُھٹتی نہیں ہے مُنہ سے یہ کافر لگی ہوئی
✒️👀✒️
As a citizen of india your videos gave us practical lessons on what not to do with our democracy.
🙌
But don't elect for freebies and wokeism 😂😂
Bangladeshi spotted
@@apurvabhide2860 all muslims of Indian subcontinent are effectively Pakistanis, as Pakistan got independence before India, the British India declared Pakistan as a land for Muslims
Stay safe. I appreciate ur content and arguments
🙌
Shehzad some indian people treat constitution like a sacred book bcz founder of constitution was from their community. Their is no possibility to bring positive changes in constitution...
Whats your thaught about it..
Should we follow constitution religiously? Or it should be reformed time to time?
Not really..the basic structure of constitution couldn't be changed as made clear by keshwananad bharti case...we aren't thaught about it..apart from it everything is there
judgments.ecourts.gov.in/KBJ/?p=home/intro#:~:text=The%20Supreme%20Court%2C%20in%20a,cannot%20be%20amended%20by%20parliament.
@ThePakistanExperience are you an ISI agent how can a Pakistani access Supreme Court of India website
Thank you for being objective and brave..
🙌
Dont agree with you on your religious views but I am on board for democracy all the way.
6:47 " Democracy gorey logon ki hoti hai "
Similar to some politicians in India who used to say " yeh IT YT kya hai , India mein computers ki kya zaroorat , yeh America nahi hai "
Idiots
@@ThePakistanExperience and today even poor people have a mobile in their pocket .
Excellent sir.
🙌
Wonderful podcast 👍
🙌
This book is quickly climbing up my must read wishlist, thanks to your constant plugging.But, if I may nitpick, (and you might totally think this to be beyond the ambit of the topic at hand), nevertheless one feels that if we must take the help of the 'State of nature' argument to emphasise the need for a Constitution, we must also touch upon(however briefly), the very problematic, racist and exploitative context in which these theories were first conceptualized by these so-called enlightenment thinkers be it Hobbes, Locke or Mill,
and the subsequent havoc these theories wreaked on the lives of the native populations of not just America and Australia but to some extent India and Africa as well. The idea is not to simply shit on these enlightenment philosophies, pat ourselves on the back for decolonising our minds and call it a day, but rather to critically engage with these ideas, contexualise them, and while being appreciative of the benefits of an idea like 'the social contract', also recognise and warn against the patterns of disenfranchisement that repeat themselves in more or less similar ways even today, as they did back then, once these ideas get translated on the ground; be it in the form of dispossession of the fishermen of Gwadar or Karachi, the displacement of kacchi-aabaadi dwellers in cities like Delhi and Islamabad ,or the permanent expulsion of the indigenous people from their ancestral lands simply because they don't fit into the narrow idea of citizenship defined by that Nation-State.
Apologies for the long rant.Great explainer as always. Loved the Hindustani Bhau reference in there.
Stay safe 💗
Fair point
Thank you ❤️
Kya bhai TV pe interview chal raha hai aapka , bataya nahi ???
Mai bhi subah utha toh Pata chala 🤣
ملک کے تین دستور توڑے گئے اور یہ گناہ کبیرہ کسی سیاستدان نے نہیں کیا
C'mon Kid ! Give it up and Run ! You are a misfit in the place you call home !! Just RUN!!
The military establishment in Pakistan has maintained a dominant role in the country's politics for several decades, often intervening in civilian governance and even directly ruling the country through military coups.
There are a few key reasons for this:
Perception of civilian weakness: The military sees civilian institutions and political leaders as lacking the ability to effectively govern and manage the country's affairs. This has led the military to view itself as the sole savior of the nation, justifying its interventions in politics.
Lack of civilian control over the military: Civilian leaders have been unable to fully institutionalize democratic control over the armed forces, allowing the military to maintain autonomy and influence over key policy decisions.
Military's economic and political interests: The military has built up extensive business interests and a powerful role in the economy, giving it a vested interest in maintaining its influence. It has also forged direct foreign policy ties, further entrenching its political power.
Constitutional ambiguity: The constitution of Pakistan has been repeatedly amended, with provisions that allow the military to intervene in politics under the "doctrine of necessity." This has provided legal justification for military coups and rule.
However, the current army chief, Gen. Asim Munir, has stated that the military is "well aware" of its constitutional limits and expects others to "uphold the constitution."
This suggests an acknowledgement that the military's political dominance may face challenges, especially if civilian institutions can assert their constitutional authority.
The strength of Pakistan's democratic institutions will be crucial in determining the future civil-military relationship.
You forgot the most important reason which Mr Pervez Hoodbhoy has mentioned :
Hostility with India and obsession with Kashmir that allows the army to scare the pakistani people
Is pak army good or currupt?
❤.....Eevery Bit ... Every Word so true ....
❤️
Excellent informative video
🙌
Courageous voice of pakistan
❤️🙌
you are making me wana read this book so bad XD
You should
A bad document with good leadership is a lot better than a good document with bad leadership. As a constitution can be amended but loyalty to country and good intentions cannot be changed or amended .
good doc leads to good system in place and it will automatically flushes out bad apples
but depending upon just personalities k 'aik banda aaye ga aur sub theek ho jaye ga' is just a child thinking and it doesn't work like this especially in modern world
Leadership comes late , constitution comes first
finally the first one to view
🙌
❤ Brilliant 👏
❤️
What you calling a constitution in pakistan is not constitution but its saria
can u do a video on how indonesia became more democratic; bringing in an indonesia guest...i think some learnings for pakistan too from there
Excellent.
Jazakallah!
🙌
At least your research is inthe right direction but i would like to hear a bit positive about the particular time you talking about along with critical lense.
Hello Shehzad be careful from 'software update'
IsI prepare to software update of some democratic in pakistani😅😮😢😂😂😂😂
Dear Shahjad Sheikh ji,
Majority Muslim public in our subcontinent became a victim of The British Rulers' interests of post independence period coupled with ego & selfish interests of pseudo muslim Late Baba Jinnah. There was no sympathy to the idea floated for separate nation for muslims & Two Nations Theory till elections of 1937. Even during 1940 there was no demand for Pakistan in the resolution passed by muslim league at annual conference at Lahore, only reference for more autonomy for muslim majority states of North & North Western states was made. After that at the behest of Governor General Linlithgo backed by former PM of UK Late Winston Churchill, muslim league led by Jinnah floated the Two Nations Theory & separate nation for muslims. No doubt The Britishers wanted to weaken the freedom movement of The Congress Party, because being quite engaged in second world war, utterly in need of British India army & brave fighting soldiers from India, also under huge disturbed economic conditions. The Congress Leadership too failed to anticipate the dirty process of conspiracies for which The British Rulers were quite expert. Though Gandhiji had twenty one meetings with late Jinnah after release from jail at Jinnah's residence Malabar Hills Bombay, but Jinnah being backed & assured by The Britishers refused to budge & amend his Two Nations Theory.
After partition & assassination of PM Late Liaquat Ali Khan, all leaders of muslim league lacked patriotism, spirit of sacrifice, bankrupt with vision for progress, economic development of Pakistan, her public indulged in leg pullings of each other for selfish interests which gave a pretext to military leadership to step in & enforce dictatorship which ignorant public of Pakistan too welcomed by distributing sweats in cities. Cunning persons like Zulfikar Ali Bhutto became advisers, close confidents of the dictator. Even journalists of whole mainstream media of Pakistan too became psycophants. As per custom evolved, mullah mafia too became psycophant of dictators. Please take care of yourself as ruling elite of Pakistan may not like your words & podcasts. Thanks.
I don't agree with this sentiment. Constitution isn't the supreme authority to determine morality.
Slavery was once constitutional in the US and so was everything that the Nazis did.
The constitution is nothing but a formalization of the state and for any revolution or a people's movement ,the state will try to use constitution to suppress any uprising.
After the communists took over,they introduced a new constitution because China was now a new state.
Same with Pakistan.
The constitution of the Islanic republic of Pakistan can NEVER be a source of justice or moralirty because it serves a state created on the basis of a hateful religious theory(two nation theory). Much like how you can never expect the Israeli constitution to ever deliver justice to the Arabs.
Street fighter (game) not mortal kombat.
Rest good englihtening episode.
More power to you!
🙌
Unfortunately the zia generation if not all but most of them are our parents and relatives to parents.
Waise yeh toh classic case hai. Pahale anda ya pahale murgi. Constitution pahale ya free and fair elections pahale.
Hey Shehzad bhai...any chance that you may become a 'part' of Mr Khaqaan Abbasi's new party? It seems to be good avenue/platform for brains like yourself to atleast start rubbing shoulders with the decision makers!!!
No
@@ThePakistanExperience 😞
I can see that Pakistan is in advanced stage of the game India is playing. We shall meet you eventually in heaven.
Shehzad ghiaz be like - maut ko tak se chhu k wapas aa jata hu😂
🤣
It is very easy to criticize Establishment but very difficult to criticize religion of Islam which is the root cause of all the problems of Pakistan.
@@virajprabhu1153 i am indian
@@humbledtechie7731 So what ???
Shahzad bhai, me apko sunnta ho kafi achy se bhai but ek eltija hai me janta ho ap flow me bolty hein but kindly ya to urdu me continue kr lein ya English me. Mix up ho jata hai bhai bat samhajny me. Baki shukria ap aese hi kam karty rahein we love you and JazakAllah.
Koshish karta hoon Urdu mai but flow mai English hee bahar ajati hay 😭
People come and break pak constitution...people just take it without reacting....and this will continue in Pakistan because people power has been curtailed badly
Your stand on Palistine/Israel is subjective and most of the people may differ on this matter.
Bro take care of yourself 😉💖 🙋
❤️
Boss pahale free and fair elections toh karo. Constitution toh bahoot door ki cheez hai. Tum lok toh abhitak form 45 aur form 47 mein hi fase ho.
Glad to see you still trying to diss Israel despite the fact that your own country has the constitutional oppression of minority rights.
Nice talk, why not invite Wajahat Masood for a discussion?
Endless problems of Pakistan 😮
Kyu bichare Noam Chomsky ko maar rahe the. 😅😂
Jacobin kee ghalti hay. I trusted rhem
after all the cricket videos thought you really have left this anti-est path but seems shahzad is braver than our expectations
🙌