Lipped or not, IT’S HER VOICE! Stop complaining. I Challenge EVERYBODY who’s saying bad things about her to COME UP ON STAGE WITH A MIC ON AND SING!!!! Sing it out! I challenge you to pre-record any friggin’ song. I can guarantee nobody would ever pay to even listen to. Get a life haters!!!
From someone who has been following MC from the start of her career, my opinion is this - when she began facing vocal challenges and unpredictability with vocal range, all she needed to do was take the much-needed vocal rest, make the adjustments to her songs into the lower keys that would better suit her current voice, and be confident in the fact that she still is and always will be one of the most creative, gifted, and talented singers of all time. Remember, she is A SKILLED VOCALIST, A REAL SINGER - not an entertainer like some they refer to as "singers" today.
❤❤❤❤From the PHILIPPINES MARIAH FOREVER.... If you are a REAL LAMBS YOU MUST ACCEPT THAT MARIAH CAN'T DO LIVE SING ANYMORE... LIVE OR LIPSYNCH WE MUST LOVE MARIAH... SHE IS THE ONE❤❤❤❤❤
Nevermind she lipped at a private event. But I doubt she'll keep lipping forever, Mariah is not the type of gal to keep doing the same thing forever without some type of variation.
@@przemekpuciennik3263 Well... We still got that Brazil concert in September to look forward. She dropped some of I'll Be There's playback in Aruba, but I think she'll keep this formula for all of the Vegas residence.
Don't think it matters. Lol Gone are the days when the artist sounds so much different live than on the tv. It's not like the videos are dubbed these days.
This is not a hate post for Mariah because I am a lamb for life. But a lot of songs she sang at her Christmas concert just last year are now completely lipped in this residency. I understand her wanting to preserve her voice, but this is way less stress on her voice than a tour not as many dates back to back. I still love her, but would love to see her give us some live. I know she has it still.
I don't understand why all her team agree on her doing so much. It's like they are all just waiting for her to royally fuck up on stage or trip over and just make an ass of herself. Who in their right mind would let her go out night after night with a voice that is ridiculously unpredictable, then the fact she can't really dance at all, then wear a stupid full on wig that looks so obvious. Heels she and everybody else in the world knows she cannot walk in them no matter how pretty they may be. Pick 7 intimate songs she is comfortable singing live. Call it an intimate night with MC. No full on glamour! Job done!
*wow she has NEVER lipped this song .. or lipped this much in her career ever.. tragic just like the wigs.. MARIAH PLZ PRACTICE AND GIVE US UR REAL VOICE, not recordings!*
she started lipped even more than usual these few years and we get it.. but at least now she is using new playback instead of the cd version for the past few year. good and bad. but still love my queen mimi
Thankfully the people that pay to see her don’t care. I think it’s fair to say that a lot of people wouldn’t pay to see her though, especially knowing the whole thing is lipped
I disagree. You can see at 2:13 that she is struggling a little bit and she doesn't fully complete that run. I hereby conclude that she is singing live here and, I dare say, she is singing most of the track live.
@@hejiranycSadly, the whole sound was identical to night 1. You know Mariah always adlibs but since this was all pre-recorded, she didn't do adlibs. That's how people know it's lipped
@@ESPIE.OFFICIAL I am the biggest skeptic of them all, but I could not see a single telltale sign of lipping in this clip. Even the whistle notes at the end were just a tiny little bit off the beat and a micro-tone off pitch with varying volume. And there are some adlibs, but yes, I can see how the consistency can lead one to assume lipping. All I can say is that if this was actually lipped all the way, she is the second greatest lip syncer to ever exist (only behind drag queen Lypsinka).
@@hejiranyc greatest lipsyncer? is that a compliment to her? cause we know she is one of the worst, she lacks convincing even if most of her audios (before) were straight up from the studio albums which makes it so obvious. There's a video here on youtube that you can search on how to spot her lipsyncing. Try that 🙂
@@hejiranyc It's not consistency too. This sound that she had was taken from STEMs of her Christmas show last year and I checked the audio from Night 1, it is identical. Knowing MC, you know she can never do the exact thing twice because she always improvises but you can see no improvising here. It's all planned in her in-ear monitors. Plus, lip syncing the whole sound mostly can be good cause it shows consistency especially if you're at the back, the only downside is... she couldn't make it convincing cause she keeps a relaxed face on notes above C#5 which ain't possible cause her lives recently showed she struggled over a C5. Even her recent promotion of it on Instagram reels, isn't sounding smooth. So... I really can't tell if it's sarcasm or compliment cause she is one of the worst lipsyncers ever. If she's great, she wouldn't have been caught up in this issue of lipsyncing since 97.
Haters gonna hate. Clearly not lip syncing. Her voice/vocal octave rang is clearly different as she matures(in the best way possible). This isn’t 1994 people. Lip syncing and backup vocals are COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. She sounds amazing as always. Even with her matured vocals.
Mariah is live and her mic is on! Vocals on fleek! I’m in awe! She is showing out!!! Feeling it!🎉🙌🙌🙌🙌
Lmao mic might be on but she isn't singing lol
Her mic is on-- in the studio.
Wow identical vocals as the first night. 10000% live queen 🙏♥️
Going to see her in November, can’t wait to hear her reaching the highest notes 🎶 😀
Mariah still got it go girl. Can't anyone sing like her 😊
Love you Matiah🎉
She seems happy now
Lipped or not, IT’S HER VOICE! Stop complaining. I Challenge EVERYBODY who’s saying bad things about her to COME UP ON STAGE WITH A MIC ON AND SING!!!! Sing it out! I challenge you to pre-record any friggin’ song. I can guarantee nobody would ever pay to even listen to. Get a life haters!!!
I'm stuck at 1:24 part. She's amazing!
God continue to bless you Matiah🎉🎉🎉
Go Mimi ❤🎉 0:29
Damn how is she still able to do it after all these years…well she does have good technique …you are awesome mariah
From someone who has been following MC from the start of her career, my opinion is this - when she began facing vocal challenges and unpredictability with vocal range, all she needed to do was take the much-needed vocal rest, make the adjustments to her songs into the lower keys that would better suit her current voice, and be confident in the fact that she still is and always will be one of the most creative, gifted, and talented singers of all time. Remember, she is A SKILLED VOCALIST, A REAL SINGER - not an entertainer like some they refer to as "singers" today.
She needed vocal therapy
❤❤❤❤From the PHILIPPINES MARIAH FOREVER.... If you are a REAL LAMBS YOU MUST ACCEPT THAT MARIAH CAN'T DO LIVE SING ANYMORE... LIVE OR LIPSYNCH WE MUST LOVE MARIAH... SHE IS THE ONE❤❤❤❤❤
❤😂😂😂😂❤❤❤🇨🇵🇨🇵🇨🇵🙏🙏🌻🦋🐑🌈❤️ Sandrine chendo fans Mariah Carey love love love love love you
She’s live with live back ground singers she has nothing to prove at this age she’s a legend I’m just happy to see her she sounds amazing
So, she’ll never sing live again? 😭
If she's going to sing, I hope so...
Probably at small or private events
Nevermind she lipped at a private event. But I doubt she'll keep lipping forever, Mariah is not the type of gal to keep doing the same thing forever without some type of variation.
@@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242 today she was in Vegas.
So far all is lipped with same prerecorded stuff as at the beginning of the year
@@przemekpuciennik3263 Well... We still got that Brazil concert in September to look forward. She dropped some of I'll Be There's playback in Aruba, but I think she'll keep this formula for all of the Vegas residence.
Haters will hate while Mariah has millions to make 🤟🏻
1:23 - 1:51 like the original ❤
Me watching every Mariah video to hear her pre-recorded musi😂
Lipped or not, it’s her voice. She’s not from the Bronx who gets an orange drink.
Correct dahlin ❤❤❤❤From the PHILIPPINES
Hey KingAlex.. were the songs performed differently?
If Mariah read these comments she would laugh and take the compliment. Y’all think the majority is lipped. Clean your ears.
Y’all we know that she has nodules so reaching high belting notes is not easy but she’s smiling, walking while belting notes that cant be 😂😂😂
The inconsistent volume of her voice says it's "on".
No it's not
It’s a shame that majority of this is lipped.
Don't think it matters. Lol
Gone are the days when the artist sounds so much different live than on the tv. It's not like the videos are dubbed these days.
@@la-saint1798 this show is boring
@@CautionRiahthen don't watch it. 🤷🏻♀️
The whistles were live no?
@@raihanrahman4687 No 😭 She is using the same track for every show!
This is not a hate post for Mariah because I am a lamb for life. But a lot of songs she sang at her Christmas concert just last year are now completely lipped in this residency. I understand her wanting to preserve her voice, but this is way less stress on her voice than a tour not as many dates back to back. I still love her, but would love to see her give us some live. I know she has it still.
I don't understand why all her team agree on her doing so much. It's like they are all just waiting for her to royally fuck up on stage or trip over and just make an ass of herself.
Who in their right mind would let her go out night after night with a voice that is ridiculously unpredictable, then the fact she can't really dance at all, then wear a stupid full on wig that looks so obvious. Heels she and everybody else in the world knows she cannot walk in them no matter how pretty they may be.
Pick 7 intimate songs she is comfortable singing live. Call it an intimate night with MC. No full on glamour! Job done!
I look at Trey Lorenz and I think, surely you must be looking and listening and thinking, damn her voice for these songs is done.
@@la-saint1798what.
Read it again
*wow she has NEVER lipped this song .. or lipped this much in her career ever.. tragic just like the wigs.. MARIAH PLZ PRACTICE AND GIVE US UR REAL VOICE, not recordings!*
Did she had her nodules fixed? She sounds 100000x better!!
It's called lipsync
A maior vocalista de todos os tempos ! Mariah Carey ❤❤❤❤
Stop the entire performance is lipped it’s the exact same as night 1
face the reality. Be an honest person.They want real side of you
Pre-recorded vocals? well, her voice is very unpredictable and unreliable in live performances. So we just have to understand.
Yes is playback 😢
She didn’t do that last Christmas or during her Dubai performance but this residency.. at least the general public doesn’t know 😂
@@RyanlovesTh she did both. It's live + pre-recorded ( in some parts )
she started lipped even more than usual these few years and we get it.. but at least now she is using new playback instead of the cd version for the past few year. good and bad. but still love my queen mimi
Thankfully the people that pay to see her don’t care.
I think it’s fair to say that a lot of people wouldn’t pay to see her though, especially knowing the whole thing is lipped
The main vocal seems live, but the whistles are lipped.
I disagree. You can see at 2:13 that she is struggling a little bit and she doesn't fully complete that run. I hereby conclude that she is singing live here and, I dare say, she is singing most of the track live.
@@hejiranycSadly, the whole sound was identical to night 1. You know Mariah always adlibs but since this was all pre-recorded, she didn't do adlibs. That's how people know it's lipped
@@ESPIE.OFFICIAL I am the biggest skeptic of them all, but I could not see a single telltale sign of lipping in this clip. Even the whistle notes at the end were just a tiny little bit off the beat and a micro-tone off pitch with varying volume. And there are some adlibs, but yes, I can see how the consistency can lead one to assume lipping. All I can say is that if this was actually lipped all the way, she is the second greatest lip syncer to ever exist (only behind drag queen Lypsinka).
@@hejiranyc greatest lipsyncer? is that a compliment to her? cause we know she is one of the worst, she lacks convincing even if most of her audios (before) were straight up from the studio albums which makes it so obvious.
There's a video here on youtube that you can search on how to spot her lipsyncing. Try that 🙂
@@hejiranyc It's not consistency too. This sound that she had was taken from STEMs of her Christmas show last year and I checked the audio from Night 1, it is identical. Knowing MC, you know she can never do the exact thing twice because she always improvises but you can see no improvising here. It's all planned in her in-ear monitors. Plus, lip syncing the whole sound mostly can be good cause it shows consistency especially if you're at the back, the only downside is... she couldn't make it convincing cause she keeps a relaxed face on notes above C#5 which ain't possible cause her lives recently showed she struggled over a C5. Even her recent promotion of it on Instagram reels, isn't sounding smooth. So... I really can't tell if it's sarcasm or compliment cause she is one of the worst lipsyncers ever. If she's great, she wouldn't have been caught up in this issue of lipsyncing since 97.
100% lip....
How many times are you going to point out?
Jealous much?
Only the first and first part of the sencond whistle is lip
Yes, and????
Haters gonna hate. Clearly not lip syncing. Her voice/vocal octave rang is clearly different as she matures(in the best way possible). This isn’t 1994 people. Lip syncing and backup vocals are COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. She sounds amazing as always. Even with her matured vocals.
When she sings a song the same way, when she sounds smooth, some people think she is lip syn…
She’s clearly lipping. Wake up.
@@Newhorizons4uyeah she is, this is same pre recorded a first night
It is lipped pls stop spreading lies
She even missed her queue 😭 you haven't seen it?