Gamers react to Shiho's Suicide Attempt (Vol. 2) | Persona 5
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Behold! Installment 2 of the Persona 5 reaction compilations with all of your requests and more!
Before you ask: yes I am doing this for the new parts of Persona 5 Royal. Do NOT put P5R spoilers in my comments unless you mark it as such and hide it under the "read more" button. I will delete your comment and you will be blocked, meaning you will be unable to comment again. If you want to request a scene from Royal, think about this: If it’s a major scene, it’s 100% guaranteed going to be a compilation. To prove this, I currently have 80+ scenes from Royal in que to be made.
Here’s a new compilation of new gamers reacting to Shiho's suicide attempt.
Gamers in order of appearance:
1. Shenpai ( / @shenpaistreams )
2. Kagato the Final Boss ( / kagatoth.. )
3. The NyanCave ( / @thenyancave )
4. Sirlionhart ( / sirlionhart )
5. Ezekiel III ( / @ezekieliii )
6. Joseph Anderson ( / @josephandersonchannel... )
7. ZeRo ( / zero )
8. So Whack! ( / @sowhack )
9. BigBrickPlays ( / @brickyep2 )
10. Alyska ( / @alyska )
11. psychadelicsnake ( / pyschadelicsnake )
12. KarateChopsticks ( / joshccolson )
13. RETRO ( / theretromanny )
14. Kirshar ( / kirshar )
15. MaxofFewTrades ( / @maxoffewtrades )
Follow my social medias!
Twitter: br...
Instagram: / brandpiano1900
MuseScore for music stuff: musescore.com/...
Drop a like and subscribe for more if you enjoyed this compilation!
Let's be honest: THIS is when everyone went from just despising Kamoshida to TRULY hating him.
16:33
They Probably hate him to the point where they want too kill him or see him in painful agony considering what he’s done
Foster Deck ya I started yelling at Ann for not killing kamoshida
@@Oracle_nav death is too good for him, better for him to be publicly shamed and sent to prison. also Ann is the only one who had the right to say what happens to him
If a Adult teacher is molesting and trying to groom a student doesn't make truly hate him you have a problem lmao
What's crazy is that Suzui just straight up jumped. She didn't wait for anyone to come talk or anything. She truly found no other options.
When Shiho explained that there was another her that told her to jump, it all clicked. It was Shadow Shiho. In real world that would just be an metaphor, but in P5 universe that inner self would literally be a shadow. And through her recovery she overcame it - much in the same way Mishima overcame his.
Which means Shiho probably had the potential to become a persona user, if the story allowed her to be after Ann's confidant arc. Shadow Shiho would have turned into her persona, much like Futaba's did.
@@aohige actually it was a part of her that wanted to die, it wasn't her shadow. that's why when you do Ann's social link to rank 9 you find out whoever was compelling her to jump is gone, given that Shiho is still okay that wasn't her shadow, the Jungian concept used to design how the world works would have had her still in a coma in that case. you can't function without your shadow
Shiho does have the capacity to be one, and I would have liked her to be one and join the team. but it's not because of what happened on the roof, it's because no matter who you are as long as you face what you run from and accept it you can use it to your advantage
It's so much worse in the Manga. Ann was screaming at Suzui and begging her not to jump.
Suzui then said sorry Ann and jumped
@@aohige Uh, that's not how shadows work at all. Also, "P5 universe"?? You know Persona is a SERIES of SEVERAL games, right?
Everyone goes from "lol funny cat in desk" to "oh shit she's gonna sewerslide" real quick
Let's be honest, the game whiplashed like that, too.
Shit, I can't believe Royal just went ahead and added more to this scene with the crowd's reactions to the jump too...
And then what they added to the Shadow Kamoshida boss fight. Man, that escalated my hatred of him to another level I didn't even think was possible.
If you pay close attention, you can hear someone on the background commenting about her leg. That adds an extra point of gore to this scene.
I honestly think that the teachers were absolutely correct in trying to make students stay in class when this happened, speaking as someone who witnessed very similar situation in school. Witnessing a suicide attempt potentially traumatizes young students, and may also potentially encourage people with debilitating mental health problems to do the same.
On the other hand, if you let all students walk freely when this happens, you get exactly what's happening here: people shamelessly taking pictures of the person that's attempting or committing suicide.
The teachers told them to stay put in their classrooms to protect the students, and the one that attempted.
Oh definitely. Additionally, all of them being crowded in the courtyard could slow the emergency responders, and all of them taking their phones out was just them using someone else's trauma as an excuse to post something on social media. It's much better to not have all the students getting in on the scene.
Yeah, under the "if you aren't helping, get the hell out of the way" principle. Of course, at this point in the game, all the teachers have been flaming assholes and we've been giving quite a few reasons not to trust their motives.
@@dumbmonkey1313 At this point all we know is she's seems irresponsible and clearly wants nothing to do with the player
Well, as I somewhat agree with you Chi Zhang, I gotta have to disagree partially. The first intend to ignore this might be good but as soon as everyone witnessed it, I wouldn't think of attempting to continue for that same day. It's even scarier to think that a teacher would force you to attempt school after watching (an attempt) suicide. It feels like teachers want you to work and don't care for others like you're just worth something if you work and everything else such as having depression and people that struggle to continue their lives seem worthless.
I was in college and one of my classmates had a seizure and collapsed in the middle of class. My teacher did the appropriate thing; called for medical aid for the student, didn't bother continuing the class, and focused on keeping everyone calm while the paramedics took care of her.
Once I calmed down, I thought of something that made me shiver even more. In Japan, before committing suicide, you take off your shoes. It's a cultural thing, with various different reasons given as to why it's done. But Shiho was wearing shoes when she jumped. They even took the time to do a close-up of her feet right before she jumped. That got me thinking; did she really want to die? Or did she jump thinking that she had to, but she didn't really want to? Was she desperately praying that she'd survive all the way down? The thought makes my stomach turn.
if you do ann’s confidant, at rank 9 you have a talk with shiho on the roof. she says that she did t actually want to die
I think it's implied a part of her was having second thoughts as she jumped down.
Yo, I didn’t pick up on that!!
you know what terrified about this scene, this is literally what happens in real life and I had experienced it first hand in high school
When I was a first year's high school student, basically around the same age as Ryuji and Akiren, while I was in the middle of a class a senior year's student drop from my school 5th-floor balcony. At the time I didn't know what just happen because my classroom was on the blind side of the place she falls and there wasn't anything happen prior, there was a blur of something fall and them someone scream that someone just fall.
Our teacher asked us to stay in class but that didn't stop other students to run up the balcony to see what happened, I did try to run out to see what happen but I barely got past the sea of people taking pictures and gossiping about who just die or awing about witnessing someone just died
By the time the paramedic arrives, she had already died and the crown started to disperse, the only thing I could see was that the paramedic and police cover her body. She died on impact, broke her spinal column and her leg
According to the new, she had been depress for half a year and had started to go to the hospital for about a month or so, that day she asked her mother to bring her to school to say hi to her friends
and then went to the 5th floor and jump.
And that is just 2013, 3 years before the event of this game
Man , i still can't believe how disgusting some people can be.
Most of the Palace lords and crimes they committed were directly based on real life high-profile cases in Japan. Heck, even most of the Mementos targets were.
Some of the iconic scenes in the game were directly lifted from real news in Japan in the past decade, especially the press conferences.
Game goes from: ''Talking silly cat trying not to get caught'' to ''Look at this depressed and possibly sexually abused girl attempt suicide''.
How many people do you think realize the true reason why Shiho try to commit suicide after Ann rejected Kamoshida’ss sexual advances from the previous day?
Because I knew from first watching this scene what truly happened
I think after talking to Mishima it's pretty apparent what happened. How he describes Kamoshida being extra pissed and calling Shiho by herself even though she did everything correctly.
If it wasn't obvious by the time you find her shrine in his palace, maybe it's better that way.
Because Kamoshida can’t have Ann and Ann refuses his advances, he decides to settle for Shiho instead.
I knew.
Spoilers
I knew it and playing P5R just further confirmed it. But it also confirmed that he was also pining over Shiho who was easily more complacent compared to Ann. I remember when I saw Shiho in Kamosida’s palace and felt grossed out and wanted to protect her with all my might.
Everyone: "Meh she wont really jump"
Shiho: *Falls*
Everyone: "AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH"
I think.... I think that is the QUIETEST I've ever heard Kagato.
25:44
Listen to what he says:
"CAT GET IN THE BAG WE GOT SHIT TO DO."
I remember showing my friend Persona 5 for the first time and we got to this point. She was sitting in front of me while I was playing and when we got to Shiho’s attempted suicide she physically jumped because of how shocking it was.
"She physically jumped because of how shocking it was"... Poor choice of words...
@@danielcole3508oh nooooooooo 😂
Pretty sure what happened to Shiho was the last straw. What Kamoshida did to her is what drove everyone to hating him and wanting him to suffer.
I feel bad for what Shiho has to go through! Even reality today, many high school students has tried to commit suicide cuz they cannot handle the pain anymore. Only difference is that many have suffered cyber-bullying than physically punishment.
Sadly, it's not just cyber bullying, it's physical abuse. Kamoshida and his volleyball team are actually based on former Japanese basketball coach Hajime Komura and his high school athletes who he would physically abuse until the captain of the team committed suicide. After the court case that followed, an investigation was conducted in across Japanese schools that found nearly 7000 teachers across over 4000 schools physically abusing students. Basically, the disclaimer that the events in this game aren't based on real world events or people is only true in that things turn out happier in the game than real life.
Not to mention there are actually like teachers like Kamoshida in real life, that abuse..and even sexually harass their students. :( sad but true.
"Boy, that escalated quickly" This is like 5 hours in, isn't it?
There are some games shorter than the time it took for this game to get this dark
18:30 THE EXPRESSION CHANGE
This moment was when you knew shit was gonna get darker from here.
the VA for Shiho is fucking amazing when he spoke to Ann I could FEEL the despair!
Fun fact: that's the voice actress for Madoka Kaname
Just wanna let you know CrystAAHHL's reaction is one of the best.
She’s great
Thanks!
I was so shocked at this moment, I was very afraid that I would have to talk to her and stop her from comiting suicide, in the end, we don't even have the chance but it's still a frigtening moment
People are truly hopeless. In real life, this is what kids would be doing too at the sight of an attempted suicide I bet. Have all their phones out and everything =/ But I think that's what makes this game great as well, it shines a light on today's society. Every villain in this game..real people like that exist in real life...of course minus the metaverse. I think everyone can relate to some character in this game, and what they're going through, and that makes it amazing
That’s exactly how I feel Adam Block.
I honestly wish sometimes that we can make people have a change of heart considering how corrupt and evil they are
Unfortunately, statistically speaking, as much as you might like to think otherwise, you’d probably do the exact same in a situation like this. It’s a well studied behavioral psychological phenomenon known as “the bystander effect”. Basically, in situations where it would be stressful, or awkward, or socially unacceptable to step in and help someone, we typically.....will just stand by and watch. The reason for this is basically that social pressures make it very difficult for us to initiate helping someone if no one else around us does so first. No one wants to be the first to stand out and speak up.
So happy that you're back making these montages. These were the only things getting me by from my post Persona 5 and Persona 5 R playthrough sadness. I appreciate the vids, keep up the awesome work! Super super excited that you're going to be doing some P5R reactions toooooo!
Ryuji: What the hell`s wrong with these people?
Bricky: No, this is about how it would happened.
sadness...
When I first played this game, I saw the scene and thought for sure we’d take her down. I was literally thinking “They don’t have the balls to do th-“ and then she fell and I almost dropped the controller.
I don't know if enough people saw it, but a "The Cake Knight Rises" reaction compilation would be really funny
That’d probably be hard to do, since it can happen at any point in the game. Same with any confidant scene.
Heroshii15 Yeah that’s true. It would be a loooot of work to find it for everyone.
I’m CAKEMAN.
I mean, yes it’d be hard but it’s doable as the scene plays out for like 3 - 4 months? So you can knock out some of the other months.
Joseph Anderson
Is there a chance you can do “Gamer’s reaction to what happened to Joker.”
The scene where Joker was arrested and framed by our favourite pain in the ass politician.
Surprised there isn't one for the scene where they find out about her being in a coma by Kamoshida.
there was
GeT bacK tO YouR SEaAAts The BRRRRAOOORGH CLasS sStill In SeSsionn bRRRUARGH
1:58 "For real!?!?"
13:49 What ZeRo is saying here is really scary jeez
as a person in a wheelchair i have a few problems with what he is saying here, he says being disabled is worse than dieing wtf. Atleast you are alive and can still live and even enjoy life. Even if you cant walk. WTF is up with the streamer.
Sorry if i sound harsh but fuck that streamer.
it's true though... :( at least about not succeeding in take your own life. It'd be painful. But I think being alive is still better than dying =/ hands down!
@@Zero86Sk the streamer ur refering to is the number one super smash bros for Wii u player and he went on a 56 tournament winstreak. that's who you're talking about. anyways, he was just stating what he thought, you don't have to take what he said so seriously
@@kabula9214 How is his Smash Bros record at all relevant to someone being upset about his comments regarding being disabled?
Pavol Almassy but here’s the thing though, being disabled CAN be worse than death but it depends on the person. Disabled people in school or in the adult life could be bullied or experience worse things in life and feel like they’d rather die than live. Why’d u think suicide attempts exist? They’re people who’d rather die than live. Life doesn’t matter to some people cuz they feel like they suffer too much and would rather die than enjoy whatever they can do in life. Either way u or ZeRo are not wrong. But we can agree that Kamoshida got what he deserved and if he died then so be it.
For anyone doesn't read manga persona 5 before shiho do suicide Ann and shiho have a little talk before she do the suicide
I can't wait to see those people who are not featured in the video and shame them for making jokes during this scene
Yes how dare they make a joke while playing a game they bought
@@inediblemoon941 Suicide is serious and shouldn't be joked about, what an awful take.
@@JadeAndTofu I think it can be joked about in certain ways but straight up laughing about it is wrong
Aaron Haskins it’s a game. You don’t get to decide what people can and cannot joke about.
Inedible Moon it’s not the fact that’s it’s a game it’s the fact that real or fake someone tried to take their own life that’s not a fucking matter you can joke about would you make jokes if someone you knew tried to take their life I hope not
I did not expect Retro to react like that
Allways a sad part of the game and shiho never got a confidont
Shiho: *is gonna jump*
Kirshar: PogChamp
It's weird seeing Zero swear
And so it begins
day 1 of asking
Make a reaction of when Ann discovered the metaverse
time to see who is missing in this video
I haven’t seen Retro break down like that since Connie died in Promised Neverland.
I consider myself an edgy scumbag but I REALLY did not want too see this happen, If I get Isekaied too Persona 5 I will do everything in my power too save Shiho... Yes It might be a coin flip if I get Ann and her as a Phantom Thieves or not but damnit, If I can stop it I will!
The date matches my birthday
.... Go figure.
i dont know if it would be enough reactions for this but i think that Ryuji getting taxi before going into Kaneshiro place would be good to add too
or maybe making Kaneshiro place reactions go back there if there is interesting reaction
All of these reactions are from Royal right? Also, @krystalogytv had a good reaction to this scene too.
All these reactions are from the original game. Look at the date it was uploaded, royal wasn’t out yet
Shenpai has seen this scene before?
Um you skipped #5 Ezekiel lll
Morgana jumpscare lol
React to Showtimes! pLz
I’m confused I’d this persona 5 Royal or what
This is not persona t the royal
This is original P5. I’m not doing Royal until much later
Well the scene is pretty much exactly the same in both versions.
@@OMGUKILLKENNY2 Plus Royals would only really consist of either people who didnt play the original, or the new royal stuff
Yeahhhhhh boiiiiiiiiiii
Fiiiiiiirrrrrrssssttttt
@Joaquim Floyd screw you to @##jole
retro dude is cringe af