Very impressive Usman bhai. Mai ny recently yeh book parhi hai. Dr sahab ny bohat hi achay sy history ko brief kia. Or ap ny bhi bohat acha review dia. Keep it up.
In my opinion, the state of Pakistan is a masterpiece of the British Military establishment especially General Montgomery. It shows the farsightedness of the Bririshers that they wanted to use the state of Pakistan as a buffer state between communism and capitalism and that's what we did in the cold war and the Afghan war. 2ndly I think Dr. Sab 1st wrote his thesis and then he researched and wrote the book.
Events, statements, involvement of leaders, their thought process, and world affairs around that country, create a narrative... Pro. Ishtiyaq ahmed is not runway Or fly by might intellectual...
I have tremendous respect for the author of this book. I am familiar with Dr Ishtiaq’s intellectual work and this book as well. Unfortunately he already had the conclusions before he started writing this book. This is evident in his talks and interviews over the years. When end has to be justified that means conclusions have already been drawn. Then all you have to do is start connecting different events and facts to this conclusion. This makes the intellectual work & conclusions tainted with bias!
ڈاکٹر اشتیاق احمد نے خود بھی اپنی کتاب پر بڑی ڈیٹیل سے اس پر بات کی ہے وہ ڈسکشن بلیک ہول کے پلیٹ فارم سے یو ٹیوب پر موجود ہے ۔ شوقین حضرات وہ بھی سن سکتے ہیں
Really very impressive review in this channel so far. need these kind of books review and we usually don't find much that kind review in pak you tube. aside from novel and fiction books review also these kind books. thank you sir
I have read his JINNAH.. and after going through your podcast my take on this ( Garrison state) subject is that, he had already a script in his hand/head, and he has to just add something and make a another narrative... Anyway I feel Pakistan is having problem, certainly, of ARMY, by ARMY, and for futur of /for ARMY ..
If it is clear that the British wanted to make a separate homeland in the North East then why did he write a book about Jinnah? Did Jinnah really want Paksitan?
I have heard Dr. sb who was not sincere with the creation of Pakistan. His background is from Khaksar and Harar groups. I am sure you know a similar critique then tried to stab Quad e Azam too. So I think he is out with same flag to deny the creation of Pakistan. I think present situation in India must be a time for him to correct himself. Now how Pakistan came in being what were the motives or intrigues behind it and who were the front men or leaders antecedents to creation of Pakistan. Why Dr sb is adamant to deny creation of Pakistan. Whatever was the reasons behind British worked out strategy for a separate country. It came into being as an independent country free to adopt any system willed by the people. I failed to understand Dr sb what he wanted to bring out of it once state is in existence for so many years. His views after creation is alright and debatable.
At one side in ur review u said that the foreign policy of gen zia was aggressive while at the same time u said that gen.zia failed in bargaining with USA In pak interest at. event on 9/11
I don't recall what I said exactly, but Zia did some great things at foreign policy front, but his policies and vision only lasted until he was around..
Pakistan was built by the type writer of quid e Azam, who collected feuds to protect their awarded lands from nationalization program of nhru. Encashed by liaquat to capture big cities of Sindh by his people in place of Hindus who migrated after Sukkur mosque dispute murders of Hindu leaders Bhagat kanwar and professor pamnani. Quid and other Muslims had no program for Pakistan to be implemented after independence so it creat vacuum for big powers to include army in power for their motives.
Rename Pakistan Army. There used to be another very similar organisation called East India Company. They too were a profit orientated very large business, with lots of armed men, and a country to exploit. Let us show hands. Who is for the name change?
Your argument certainly looks very compelling at the moment, but I think we have to look at the situation as whole starting pre-partition... I also argue Pakistan army as an institution needs to undergo through an evolution process otherwise they may not able to sustain their empire for long.
yes doc sb write good book but due to country situation in early stage country was security issue likt 47 48 65 71 at that time country need army and in that there role is good but noe a days need economy no one is specialist like pti change 6 finance min and pdm was having 110 min where will go only army sahara
I am shocked after looking the viewcounts on this video, Nobody in Pakistan wants to learn there history. In my opinion Pakistani's are hujoom instead of quom
Best book review and Doc Ishtiyaq Ahmed totally had told the truth 100%
Thx a lot!
The insight situation by the English Military was good and appropriate. Pakistan always done in favor of others and against the interest of state ..
Usman bhai intezar tha apky review ka! جزاک اللہ
Shukria! Do share along with others..
Very impressive Usman bhai. Mai ny recently yeh book parhi hai. Dr sahab ny bohat hi achay sy history ko brief kia. Or ap ny bhi bohat acha review dia. Keep it up.
Buhat shukria Waqas! I also took his interview, it will be out next Sat, so lookout for that also..
In my opinion, the state of Pakistan is a masterpiece of the British Military establishment especially General Montgomery. It shows the farsightedness of the Bririshers that they wanted to use the state of Pakistan as a buffer state between communism and capitalism and that's what we did in the cold war and the Afghan war.
2ndly I think Dr. Sab 1st wrote his thesis and then he researched and wrote the book.
The word is hypothesis. It always precedes any research.
Applause in standing posture towards my side for ur effective way of expressing the chronicles of history such a keen manner .
Much Appreciated! I have been reading Glimpses of World History by Nehru sahib, I hope you will like its review.
Impressive. We really need these kind of reviews. Appreciated and Enjoyed.
Buhat shukria yaar!
Events, statements, involvement of leaders, their thought process, and world affairs around that country, create a narrative... Pro. Ishtiyaq ahmed is not runway Or fly by might intellectual...
Surely not undermining his intellectual abilities; he has immensely contributed towards partition literature.
Good sir
Thanks
What a great method of delivering knowledge
Much appreciated! Plz do share along as well.
آپ نے عمدہ ریویو لکھا ہے۔ہم بھی اردو کتابوں کو ریویو اور اسکی ویڈیو تیار کرتے ہیں۔ امید ہے آپ کو ہمارا کام پسند آئے گا۔
Share a link of one of two book reviews if you don't mind..
Thanks for sharing ❤
Thank you!
I have tremendous respect for the author of this book. I am familiar with Dr Ishtiaq’s intellectual work and this book as well. Unfortunately he already had the conclusions before he started writing this book. This is evident in his talks and interviews over the years. When end has to be justified that means conclusions have already been drawn. Then all you have to do is start connecting different events and facts to this conclusion. This makes the intellectual work & conclusions tainted with bias!
Nice one.. i had this book... But haven't read yet.... IA soon i ll complete it.
Worth reading, loads of information..
@@ReviewswithUsman thank you ...🙂
ڈاکٹر اشتیاق احمد نے خود بھی اپنی کتاب پر بڑی ڈیٹیل سے اس پر بات کی ہے وہ ڈسکشن بلیک ہول کے پلیٹ فارم سے یو ٹیوب پر موجود ہے ۔ شوقین حضرات وہ بھی سن سکتے ہیں
very well described
Buhat shukria! Plz do share as well.
Really very impressive review in this channel so far. need these kind of books review and we usually don't find much that kind review in pak you tube.
aside from novel and fiction books review also these kind books.
thank you sir
Much Appreciated! Will definitely do more iA.
thanks sir
Appreciate it!
I enjoyed it alot, Great efforts MA SHAA ALLAH
Glad you liked it! Plz also share along as well.
Shabash
Shukria!
Boht aaaala usman shb
Thank you sir g!
Very impressive and informative
Much Appreciated! Plz do share along as well.
Very impressive information
Plz share this book in pdf
Thx! I will have to check, but provide your email ID.
Sir plz share pdf notes
nice
Thx!
❤ very informative
Appreciate it!
I have read his JINNAH.. and after going through your podcast my take on this ( Garrison state) subject is that, he had already a script in his hand/head, and he has to just add something and make a another narrative... Anyway I feel Pakistan is having problem, certainly, of ARMY, by ARMY, and for futur of /for ARMY
..
That's what my argument was that he had thesis in mind prior to writing this book.
❤❤❤❤
Thx!
Good one!
Thx!
If it is clear that the British wanted to make a separate homeland in the North East then why did he write a book about Jinnah? Did Jinnah really want Paksitan?
Haven't read that book but the premise of that book is completely different.. that's more on the life and works of Jinnah sahib.
سر بانو قدسیہ کے ناول حاصل گھاٹ پر بھی تبصرہ پیش کریں شکریہ
Will keep in mind, I haven't read yet!
I like so much your all videos and your books review
Buhat shukriya. Please share bhi karye ga.
Ji bilkul sir thanks
I wish Pakistan could do good! But unfortunately it has failed
It certainly falls short up until now, but we still hold the chance.
Good job bro.
Much Appreciated!
Sir please instead of making reviews on novels, make reviews on books like these that are helpful for students 🙏❤❤❤❤
Sure why not, but one can't underestimate the significance of Urdu classical literature in our historical/social discourse.
National identity per quote kia thasmkh ni aya???
I have heard Dr. sb who was not sincere with the creation of Pakistan. His background is from Khaksar and Harar groups. I am sure you know a similar critique then tried to stab Quad e Azam too. So I think he is out with same flag to deny the creation of Pakistan. I think present situation in India must be a time for him to correct himself. Now how Pakistan came in being what were the motives or intrigues behind it and who were the front men or leaders antecedents to creation of Pakistan. Why Dr sb is adamant to deny creation of Pakistan. Whatever was the reasons behind British worked out strategy for a separate country. It came into being as an independent country free to adopt any system willed by the people. I failed to understand Dr sb what he wanted to bring out of it once state is in existence for so many years. His views after creation is alright and debatable.
Salam sir! sir can yu tell me how to read urdu novels free at internet?
I sometimes used these website:
rspk.paksociety.com/novels-by-author-name/
kitaabghar.com/
@@ReviewswithUsman thanks alot sir
At one side in ur review u said that the foreign policy of gen zia was aggressive while at the same time u said that gen.zia failed in bargaining with USA In pak interest at. event on 9/11
I don't recall what I said exactly, but Zia did some great things at foreign policy front, but his policies and vision only lasted until he was around..
Pakistan was built by the type writer of quid e Azam, who collected feuds to protect their awarded lands from nationalization program of nhru. Encashed by liaquat to capture big cities of Sindh by his people in place of Hindus who migrated after Sukkur mosque dispute murders of Hindu leaders Bhagat kanwar and professor pamnani. Quid and other Muslims had no program for Pakistan to be implemented after independence so it creat vacuum for big powers to include army in power for their motives.
Rename Pakistan Army. There used to be another very similar organisation called East India Company. They too were a profit orientated very large business, with lots of armed men, and a country to exploit. Let us show hands. Who is for the name change?
Your argument certainly looks very compelling at the moment, but I think we have to look at the situation as whole starting pre-partition... I also argue Pakistan army as an institution needs to undergo through an evolution process otherwise they may not able to sustain their empire for long.
Politicans e corrupt ha mulk bach dange shukr ha foj ha bacha hua a pak
Sorry to say but this is like living in a fool's paradise.
میرے خیال میں آپ کسی نتیجے پر پہنچانے میں ناکام رہے۔ تجزیہ اور سمری میں فرق ہوتا ہے۔
ڈاکٹر صاحب ناراض نہ ہو جاتے اس لئے میں نے اپنی راۓ کو حذف رکھا اور لوگوں سے کہا کے وہ اپنی راۓ دیں
yes doc sb write good book but due to country situation in early stage country was security issue likt 47 48 65 71 at that time country need army and in that there role is good but noe a days need economy no one is specialist like pti change 6 finance min and pdm was having 110 min where will go only army sahara
I am shocked after looking the viewcounts on this video,
Nobody in Pakistan wants to learn there history.
In my opinion Pakistani's are hujoom instead of quom
Thanks Kuldeep for watching! We as a nation has a long way to go...
@@ReviewswithUsman I hope Pakistan also Prosper .