What they teach us in school pakistan won 65 war and our army is the greatest army zinda bad etc from early age they start teaching us hate and war. Bastards army ruling us for past 70 years
Excellent 👏👏👏 I taught history at different levels and now im a section officer. But I never came to know the bitter truth of our unfortunate history. Hats off dear you are the man's man.
Wow! This vlog is amazing! We always study history of Pakistan in our books but no one really gives us the lesson and such deep analysis of the mistakes that were done at the very foundation of a country! Thank u so much ♥️ Waiting for the next part
کمال کردیا سر آپ نے یہ سب کچھ ہم کو بلکل بھی معلوم نہیں تھا اور نہ ہی آج تک کسی نے بتانے کی زحمت کی،جس کو اپنی تاریخ ہی نہیں پتہ اسے اور کیا معلوم ہو گا،شکریہ فیصل واڑئچ
One of Faisal's best video ever. France has decades of revolution, England had their own struggle ending in Magna Carts, Us had their own civil war of 1863. Pakistan is going through its own problems trying to find its identity on the world map. It's a long dark tunnel in the quest to find her identity, but things will only get worse before anything concrete comes out. I just hope it doesn't take long but things have to get worse (like France, UK, US, Turkey, Saudi, Iraq etc) before any light appears at the end of this tunnel but what comes out will insha'Allah be very strong and clear, and at that point only will we find our true identity as a nation
Rich class and middle class don't bring revolution it's not a fashion symbol like we have been taught and romanticized by the West in the form of French and Bolshevicks revolution and poetry of Faiz Ahmed Faiz. The poor class always bring revolution and when the poor will not have anything to eat that day will be the revolution day until there will be no revolution so let the Pakistanis sleep.
wonderful effort! I request you to make video series on "comparative economical reforms" by different countries and their contrast with Pakistan's economy. Furthermore, I humbly request you to make comparative video series on misdoings/mismanagements of current and previous governments number wise. It will help a lot students.
I faced the same situation when visiting to Mongolia in June 2022, My stay at Istanbul Airport was for 30 Hours and the Turkish Airport Authority did not provide me a hotel because i hold a Pakistani Passport. They told me sorry we don't provide hotel accommodation on this passport. Then i realize the value of Green Passport and stayed at Airport for 30 Hours.
I think that's not regarding passport ranking, but hotel management and financial deals between governments. Pakistan might not have made that deal for its passengers.
جب اقوام میں ہر سطح پر افراد ذاتی مفادات کو اجتماعی مفادات پر ترجیح دینے لگیں تو پھر یہی کچھ ہوتا ہے اور یہ ہوتا رہے گا کیونکہ ہمارا عمومی مزاج ہی یہ ہے
It's like a bike mechanic analysing the law of gravity. Quaid e Azam knew far better, what he was doing, than an internet geek and a RUclipsr. Don't be so excited 🙂
Its a shame that a country who was founded on Islam, had a greed and power culture from day1. Politician, Judges, Molvi and Military everyone got their agenda to gain power and we only just made our religion bad. I think its a repeat of history, how Imam Hussain R.A was martyred after Islam and power and greed prevailed over Islam. May Allah open our eyes and we see the difference between country politics and religious beliefs. Let us improve our moral standards, so that everyone can lead an independent life as Islam taught us.
Hello Fasial Bhai I started watching you a year ago and I wanted to tell you in love your works 🌹🌹🇮🇳 I have a request... Bhai please can you make a video on DENMARK , its history ,war , how it become top free corruption country in the world , why and how we can start business there so easily ........... Once more time thank you ..☺️
brilliant work as usual. Giving a true perspective regarding history, which clearly shows we were directionless right from the word go. The uncertainty and clueless approach gave unprecented power to the rouge elements.
It took 30 years,to me,to realize the root causes of instability in my country. Before that I thought it would just begin in 1999 with a coup. Thanks for telling us the harsh beginning of the beginning.
Good video. There is one mistake. Sir Rajagopalachari popularly known as Rajaji was the last governor general of India not lord Mount Batten. Babu Rajendra prasadji took over as president from Rajaji.
As Maulana Abul Kalam azad said " The partition would be disastrous for the subcontinent and the most affected community would be "the muslims", the indian muslims who will make their own state are doing an experiment which i highly doubt would succeed because a nation requires a foundation and such a synthetic state made just on the basis of " ISLAM" doesnt have a foundation. The eastern and western wings of this new founded nation are bound to become two seperate entities after a certain period of time because even tho muslims there cultures are alien to each other if we ignore the indianess that connects them and for the muslims who choose to stay in india , these muslims whose families had lived here for centuries would become strangers to this land within a day.. They will be villified and most wont trust them in a post-partition india .."
the culture of south India and north India are alien to each other, and that reason was never enough to break India as a country. why? northeast India and Nepal have many cultural similarities, how come they are not one country?
@@qurratulainzehra8760 cus They r connected by their indianess. Same goes for majority of the northeast. The remaining few were integrated through force, negotiations and circumstances
Well said. Indeed, we should learn from the mistakes of our ancestors and try to avoid those things in the future. While doing so, one shouldn't call someone "Ghaddar" and anti-Pakistani. Love ❤️ and respect 🙏 Faisal 👍
Yesssssss ....brother ap great hen Ap ki vedios or analysis 100% based on reality Main kashmiri hun ..ap janty hen k pakistan india main kashmir conflict bht ahmiyet ka hamel h To is pa aik series bna lain ta k log haqeeqt ko jan sakin
@@vantagehistory1813 ohh gatia insan tum jasay putwario ko wasat bhi kuch nazar ni anna ab jo halat kr de h mulk ke is py mu q band keya h bolo? Ab halat dakhi h apnay mulk ke 😏bss kechar pakna h us py pahlay apnay gerban my jank ky dakh😏
We will accept one day that "ego" is our only problem since start. We always thought that we are better than everyone else in the world & still ,Unfortunately, think the same.
YES ... iski ek misaal 'LAHORE , LAHORE AEY' hai ........ k jb LAHORE hai hi best ,,, to phr chahy jitni mrzi Ghurbat aur Pollution etc ho ,,,,,,,,, kia farq parta hai ........... aur yehi overall QOMI RAWAYYA hai
Faisal bhai shukria aap ka hame sahi ilm Dene ke liye dil se shukria karte haj ki aap ne hame dharm ka ainak utar ka dekhne wala insan bana diya hai love from 🇮🇳 i am watching your videos for the last 1 year
You are right with an exception, ap ne aik interview me theoretical state hona aik mistake kaha tha, lekin Pakistan ki history ki major mistakes religion ki wajah se nahi balke idiotic decisions ki wajah se thi jo foolish leaders ne li thi, agar koi religious state hone ki keemat Pakistan ko jhukani pari to wo thi molvio ka power me a jana jo phir awam ko use ker ke mulk me further division paida karte hein, per ye mistake to religious leaders ki thi religion ki nahi, hopefully my point is understandable
Probably the one of the best vlog made faisal bhai which gave new and very important information that why there is ambiguity about the way how to run the PAKISTAN....
A couple of questions ... Yes there are confusions in what Muhammad Ali Jinnah quoted for the state's system, theocratic, secular (with muslims and non muslims living with their customs) , these are the technical details.. what was the general campaign and narrative of muslim league ? Please quote that too "Pakistan ka matlab kya ? La ilaha illah Allah" what does this show ? Quaid e Azam gatherred all the muslims from Peshawar to Bengal over the slogan and name of "Islam", the separate homeland for practicing islam to implement islam .. The speech of Quaid e Azam clearly says about Pakistan, describing it as "bulwark of Islam", I am stating exact words. We can say that MA Jinnah was not a hypocrite to use Islam for gaining political popularity .... Yes the legislation was important , but more important was the foundation of state, its mechanism, the funds that Reserve bank of India did not give at that time, the flux in immigrants, looted, murdered, a big human crisis ... these were the issue MA Jinnah was dealing with,.. Secondly, Liaqat Ali Khan had passed the Objective Resolution, I am pretty sure we know it, if not, can read it to remember that preamble of constitution of Pakistan was decided to facilitate muslims, to implement Islamic way of life for muslim population and to encourage islam in the state.... The issue of secular state was raised by the people who were the remains of british colonialism and they started debating it at the very state of foundation of Pakistan...
@shakil ahmad well, even if that was the case,( I don't believe it because what did Jinnah earn from this state? Many Muslims landlord left their wealth for Pakistan.) , muslim league gathered the masses in the name of Islam, so if Pakistan demand Islamic system in politics or society, its totally justifiable because they sacrificed all for what? Yes for Islam.. were Muslims dying with hunger in British India? No. Yes they needed the land for themselves to be called an Islamic state
The problem with our society is that, anyone can gather them in the name of Islam but they won't gather for their own rights or any serious issues and the worse problem is that they takes Islam to a extreme level where its really not...
@@shahzaib8922 religion of islam was and is the part of life of general public. some follow it in its true spirit , others do not follow but give it value in any way... can't impose the perception and opinion of a few people who do not want islam or islamic social system over those who , still today, wish to reshape their culture and society according to their faith and religion
I learned Balochistan forced to join Pakistan in 27 march 1948. Kindly share your knowledge about Balochistan princely states relationship with eachother and with British empire. Because I heard from my grandfather that Baloch tribes were strictly against British empire they never allowed them enter in Balochistan.
Your videos satisfy my knowledge appetite. Best of luck to all team especially Faisal Sahab. Your edge is your unbiased attitude, so, never forget to deviate. Best wishes
Who told u Gandhi was not against cast system.. He literally said removing cast system is more important than removing British government.. U could not make a more wrong statement
@Anthony De Mello yes we literally abolish caste system♥️ but caste system was different from Varna system but it was British propaganda to introduce caste system to divide India. But now just few states and cases caste system is no where to scene today.
What a beautiful and detailed analysis. We must rise above the personalities but i don't think we can achieve this in next 2 decades. Million Dollar question is that, do we have such liberty of Time?????
I understand what you mean, but there are many countries doing better than us and there those personalities are worshipped. Take gandhi in India for example. Their liberals do not make his views controversial, most of them are unaware of what he thought of dalits or hat he did with young women, they call it whatsapp university propaganda, and here we see hoodhboy and others deliberately making jinnah's idea of Pakistan controversial. Instead of weighing in on his secular statements (there's abundance of them) they undermine him as much as they can and limit his secular views to just the 11th August speech. PS: I exclude Faisal warraich from the list of such people just so you know, he explains everything logically and does not exaggerate.
@@qurratulainzehra8760 Thanks for the reply. I dont support liberals as well as fundamentalist because both are standing on extreme sides and not helping the country. i dont say that we must hate Quaid e Azam or any other personality. my point is to rise above personality. appreciate them as they did a fantastic job when it was needed but now we must move on without hurting their image or without worshipping them as immortals or perfect ones.
Even the recommendations proposed by the Constitution Commission under Justice Shahabuddin were not accepted in their entirety by Ayub. Ayub had already appointed a Cabinet sub-committee with Manzoor Qadir, the Foreign Minister, as its chairman and Mohammad Shoaib, Z.A Bhutto, A.K. Khan and Ibrahim as its members to prepare a parallel constitution according to his wishes. The Constitution Commission under Shahabuddin had been appointed only to endorse a plan already decided upon.
When Jinnah was asked what will be the constitution of Pakistan, he replied that Pakistan's constitution was written 1400 years ago. There is no problem in Slavery, because it has been permitted by Allah SWT. Islam allows muslims to have slave. But slaves should be treated with Dignity.
Coming from someone, whose society promotes the caste system your comment, even if it were remotely true is rejected due to its stench of hypocrisy. FYI, I am not Pakistani, or from your wretched ancestry place either.
Your analysis is absolutely right and reality based. Thanks for this informative video. Now at present how and who will set the right the initial mistakes . A wise and sharp leader can set the right mistakes with the help of public leaders....But such persons are not available in Pakistan up till now. This video is also proving that Pakistani politicians and bureaucracy are not capable , honest and trustworthy because the Pakistani elite class did not take any initiative for the interest of the common man.They are greedy and selfish..... They became mafias and mafias are ruling in Pakistan...
The only mistake is when he said "for unknown reasons" they didn't prepare a document. They didn't prepare a doc because Jinnah had lied to practically everyone he had spoken to and promised them contradictory things in order to get them to agree to support Pakistan. Writing down the structure of the country would have led to parts of his support base revolting.
One of the finest brief informative video from Faisal Mian....! Yes, this analysis is true that perhaps the idea of democracy has settled in the larger population of India.....as the period of emergency of 21 months saw stiff resistance from certain groups.... Perhaps, this is the reason why a sizable number of people who vote for Mr. Modi ( For reasons strictly other than religious polarisation) come to his open opposition when he tends to centralise more powers....though the same people may AGAIN VOTE FOR HIM ....If he only doesn't try to become an autocratic authority. The reasons for his success are complex but it is CERTAINLY NOT HINDUTVA ALONE AS THERE ARE NOT EVEN HALF OF ITS TAKERS AMONG HIS VOTERS IN MY OPINION....!
پاکستان کی آزاد ہونے کے فوراً بعد ہی اس ملک پر کچھ لوگ قابض ہو گئے جنہیں انگریز ناریل کہتا تھا یہ ان سرداروں زمینداروں چوہدریوں وڈیروں اور سجادہ نشینوں کی اولادیں تھیں جن کے ساتھ مل کر انگریزوں نے اس خطے پر قبضہ کیا اور حکومت کی ان کے بچوں کو انگریزوں نے اپنے اسکولوں میں پڑھا لکھا کر فوج بیوروکریسی اور سیاست میں لائے 75 سال سے ان کا ہی قبضہ ہے جن میں ملٹری بیوروکریسی سول بیوروکریسی سیاست دان شامل ہیں
Dear Warraich sb This is eye opening effort to know about the beginning of our history. Pl also upload links and reference of sources you have got this information. Thank you
Faisal Bhai I want to know a reality as you know Pakistan 🇵🇰 always say that India support terrorist attacks in Pakistan while India 🇮🇳 say that Pakistan support terrorist attacks in India. Can you please tell me the reality? It's the biggest question❓in my brain theses days.
@@Ragnarhsb BLA is a spreatist organization not a terrorist organization.. and jahan tak baat hai TTP usko b khada Pakistani army and government ne hi kiya tha jiska phal aaj bugat rahe hain. History padh lo buchy.
QA, a disturbed saddist person owing to family issues, was equally responsible alongwith neutrals in putting country to wrong direction. Pakistan is a hell gor reasonable people.
بہت زبردست اور معلوماتی ویڈیو ھے لیکن ساتھ دل بھی جلتا ہے کہ اس وقت کے عالی شان راہنماؤں کو کھرے کھوٹے کی پہچان نہیں تھی۔ لگتا ایسے ھے کہ یہ ریاست پہلے ہی دن سے ناکام ہو گئی تھی
فیصل بھائ آج کی ویڈیو بہت ہی فائدہ مند ہیں ۔۔ پاکستانیوں کی سوچ بدلنے کیلئے ۔۔۔
This thing should be taught to us in schools. Because learning from mistakes is real success
What they teach us in school pakistan won 65 war and our army is the greatest army zinda bad etc from early age they start teaching us hate and war. Bastards army ruling us for past 70 years
they instead tell us to cram 14 points of jinnah
They only tell you which is going in the favor of the state wether it is fabricated or something else...
Bhai you all have to understand India mein bhi bohot problems thi
But after Modi came in 2014 our situation started improving
Ha ha ha !
Excellent 👏👏👏
I taught history at different levels and now im a section officer. But I never came to know the bitter truth of our unfortunate history. Hats off dear you are the man's man.
Lo kr lol baat!
Wow! This vlog is amazing!
We always study history of Pakistan in our books but no one really gives us the lesson and such deep analysis of the mistakes that were done at the very foundation of a country! Thank u so much ♥️
Waiting for the next part
Excellent video. Wish Pakistan will learn from the past mistakes. Love from India 🇮🇳
Pleasure ❤️
😊
Their is no mistakes
تم لوگ کہا ں چاند پر فوہنچ چکے ہو ۔بوزدلو
Bundle of Thanks
Btao bhai India se pakstan kya seekhe, ye k
کمال کردیا سر آپ نے یہ سب کچھ ہم کو بلکل بھی معلوم نہیں تھا اور نہ ہی آج تک کسی نے بتانے کی زحمت کی،جس کو اپنی تاریخ ہی نہیں پتہ اسے اور کیا معلوم ہو گا،شکریہ فیصل واڑئچ
You and ' The Wide Side ' are the only channels who told the true history with logic.
ویڈیو کے شروع میں جو تمہید آپ نے باندی وہ بہت ہی زبردست اور لا جواب ہے
We don't need any political Maseeha in Pakistan we need people like you. Faisal you are best.
Yes I m waiting for this I think after watching your vlog people can easily understand what's the game. Thanks sir weldon
One of Faisal's best video ever. France has decades of revolution, England had their own struggle ending in Magna Carts, Us had their own civil war of 1863. Pakistan is going through its own problems trying to find its identity on the world map. It's a long dark tunnel in the quest to find her identity, but things will only get worse before anything concrete comes out. I just hope it doesn't take long but things have to get worse (like France, UK, US, Turkey, Saudi, Iraq etc) before any light appears at the end of this tunnel but what comes out will insha'Allah be very strong and clear, and at that point only will we find our true identity as a nation
✌️✌️✌️✌️ you summed up my thoughts 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️
Rich class and middle class don't bring revolution it's not a fashion symbol like we have been taught and romanticized by the West in the form of French and Bolshevicks revolution and poetry of Faiz Ahmed Faiz. The poor class always bring revolution and when the poor will not have anything to eat that day will be the revolution day until there will be no revolution so let the Pakistanis sleep.
pakistan is a failed experiment, nothing else
No culture
No language
No identity
InshAllah, may Allah Subhan WaTallah support and be with us. Ameeen 🤲
Thanks sir .
so great .
اللہ آپ کو لمبی زندگی صحت اور تندرستی دے
wonderful effort! I request you to make video series on "comparative economical reforms" by different countries and their contrast with Pakistan's economy.
Furthermore, I humbly request you to make comparative video series on misdoings/mismanagements of current and previous governments number wise. It will help a lot students.
Love your vlogs!! History always needs an introspection and at multiple levels. You are doing a wonderful job of it.
Bht hi level faisal bhai .
Jeety rahiye 👍🏻
Ye bhi mention krty k Pakistan ny capitalism block ka sath diya jab k India neutral raha
ماشاء اللہ آپ نے بہت ہی عقلمندی دانش اور قابلیت کے ساتھ بہت ہی عمدہ بیان کیا
I faced the same situation when visiting to Mongolia in June 2022, My stay at Istanbul Airport was for 30 Hours and the Turkish Airport Authority did not provide me a hotel because i hold a Pakistani Passport. They told me sorry we don't provide hotel accommodation on this passport. Then i realize the value of Green Passport and stayed at Airport for 30 Hours.
What if u had an Indian passport 🤨
@@Travel_Junkie007 I don't know about that bro
I think that's not regarding passport ranking, but hotel management and financial deals between governments. Pakistan might not have made that deal for its passengers.
@@Travel_Junkie007 It's better than Pakistan's passport, but i doubt the situation would have been any different.
@@eatlikethelocals93 The typical reply was that on this passport we can't accommodate you.
Faisal bhai zbrdst .apki har video bht he ziada informative aur haqiqat pe mabni hoti he .ALLAH ap jesy logo ko hamesha qaim aur daim raky.
Make more videos about what are the real problems of the current situation in Pakistan. Our youth needs to be educated.
Great Faisal Bhai Pakistani Awaam ko Shaoor dene ka boht shukrya Allah Ap ko seht or imaan wali Zindgi de.🌹
Amazing 👌. Glad to view some indepth analysis and information on Pakistan politics.
Faisal Bhai.....
Thank You So Much ✌️ Sharing it with friends & family....
بہت اعلیٰ فیصل بھائی ۔۔۔زرا احتیاط ۔۔
سافٹویئر نہ اپڈیٹ ہو جائے ۔۔۔
گریٹ فیصل بھائی
Most relevant, informative & best so far Vlogs out of the so many other excellent ones.
Three cheers 👋👋👋
جب اقوام میں ہر سطح پر افراد ذاتی مفادات کو اجتماعی مفادات پر ترجیح دینے لگیں تو پھر یہی کچھ ہوتا ہے اور یہ ہوتا رہے گا کیونکہ ہمارا عمومی مزاج ہی یہ ہے
Great. These type of critical and unbiased analysis are required. And obviously, these type of analysis don’t hit prestige of anyone.
It's like a bike mechanic analysing the law of gravity.
Quaid e Azam knew far better, what he was doing, than an internet geek and a RUclipsr.
Don't be so excited 🙂
Waiting for KHALID BIN WALID(R.A) series... ❤❤
Its a shame that a country who was founded on Islam, had a greed and power culture from day1. Politician, Judges, Molvi and Military everyone got their agenda to gain power and we only just made our religion bad. I think its a repeat of history, how Imam Hussain R.A was martyred after Islam and power and greed prevailed over Islam.
May Allah open our eyes and we see the difference between country politics and religious beliefs. Let us improve our moral standards, so that everyone can lead an independent life as Islam taught us.
I think this video should be played at every pakistani home , so we learn from our mistakes.
Hello Fasial Bhai I started watching you a year ago and I wanted to tell you in love your works 🌹🌹🇮🇳
I have a request...
Bhai please can you make a video on DENMARK , its history ,war , how it become top free corruption country in the world , why and how we can start business there so easily ...........
Once more time thank you ..☺️
brilliant work as usual. Giving a true perspective regarding history, which clearly shows we were directionless right from the word go. The uncertainty and clueless approach gave unprecented power to the rouge elements.
It took 30 years,to me,to realize the root causes of instability in my country.
Before that I thought it would just begin in 1999 with a coup.
Thanks for telling us the harsh beginning of the beginning.
Good video. There is one mistake. Sir Rajagopalachari popularly known as Rajaji was the last governor general of India not lord Mount Batten. Babu Rajendra prasadji took over as president from Rajaji.
this man deserve million subs. for his insane efforts
Sir ap bht acha kam kr rhy hyn..
apki yh struggle Pakistan kbhi ni bholy ga
What an amazing conversation skills. this video could become very controversial but you managed and explained in a very beautiful way.
زبردست۔ بہت خوب۔ اگلی ویڈیو کا انتظار ہے
19:34 This news headline and image always makes me proud.
As Maulana Abul Kalam azad said
" The partition would be disastrous for the subcontinent and the most affected community would be "the muslims", the indian muslims who will make their own state are doing an experiment which i highly doubt would succeed because a nation requires a foundation and such a synthetic state made just on the basis of " ISLAM" doesnt have a foundation. The eastern and western wings of this new founded nation are bound to become two seperate entities after a certain period of time because even tho muslims there cultures are alien to each other if we ignore the indianess that connects them and for the muslims who choose to stay in india , these muslims whose families had lived here for centuries would become strangers to this land within a day.. They will be villified and most wont trust them in a post-partition india .."
the culture of south India and north India are alien to each other, and that reason was never enough to break India as a country. why? northeast India and Nepal have many cultural similarities, how come they are not one country?
@@qurratulainzehra8760 cus They r connected by their indianess. Same goes for majority of the northeast. The remaining few were integrated through force, negotiations and circumstances
Well said. Indeed, we should learn from the mistakes of our ancestors and try to avoid those things in the future. While doing so, one shouldn't call someone "Ghaddar" and anti-Pakistani.
Love ❤️ and respect 🙏 Faisal 👍
You just nailed it bro,
I wish we knew all this in our schools.
Yesssssss ....brother ap great hen
Ap ki vedios or analysis 100% based on reality
Main kashmiri hun ..ap janty hen k pakistan india main kashmir conflict bht ahmiyet ka hamel h
To is pa aik series bna lain ta k log haqeeqt ko jan sakin
Hm haqiqt janty hain but hmari imported government dekh kr b andhii bnai hui h lots of respect from Punjab for our kashmiri people ❤️🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️
@@aminazahid2141 there is no imported government..... Please watch video again imran Khan is similar to others or may be worst
@@vantagehistory1813 lol bhai Imran Khan ky upper kechar paknay sy pahlay 2 chor partia bhi dakh lo 😏 Imran Khan is great leader all time
@@abdullah.wajid_ at least pmln chor nhi bcs imran Khan 4 year me fail rha
@@vantagehistory1813 ohh gatia insan tum jasay putwario ko wasat bhi kuch nazar ni anna ab jo halat kr de h mulk ke is py mu q band keya h bolo? Ab halat dakhi h apnay mulk ke 😏bss kechar pakna h us py pahlay apnay gerban my jank ky dakh😏
Man! Excellent analysis 🧐, hat’s off
Great Analysis....Brilliant
Bhtt zbrdst new series. I hope you'll start series on current affairs like what is going on in pakistan politics at the moment.
We will accept one day that "ego" is our only problem since start. We always thought that we are better than everyone else in the world & still ,Unfortunately, think the same.
This is actually arrogance which is most hated in Islam.
YES ... iski ek misaal 'LAHORE , LAHORE AEY' hai ........ k jb LAHORE hai hi best ,,, to phr chahy jitni mrzi Ghurbat aur Pollution etc ho ,,,,,,,,, kia farq parta hai ........... aur yehi overall QOMI RAWAYYA hai
1947
Correct
@@kodvavi150 It is Islam that teaches you to feel superior to non Muslims
Masha Allah warraich sahib , thanks for enlightened video . Remain blessed
Video presented in a good way to learn from the mistakes of our heroes!💯💯👌
Faisal bhai shukria aap ka hame sahi ilm Dene ke liye dil se shukria karte haj ki aap ne hame dharm ka ainak utar ka dekhne wala insan bana diya hai love from 🇮🇳 i am watching your videos for the last 1 year
You are right with an exception, ap ne aik interview me theoretical state hona aik mistake kaha tha, lekin Pakistan ki history ki major mistakes religion ki wajah se nahi balke idiotic decisions ki wajah se thi jo foolish leaders ne li thi, agar koi religious state hone ki keemat Pakistan ko jhukani pari to wo thi molvio ka power me a jana jo phir awam ko use ker ke mulk me further division paida karte hein, per ye mistake to religious leaders ki thi religion ki nahi, hopefully my point is understandable
Please provide link to part 2.
And kindly educate us all with similar topics.
JazakAllah Bhai, so very kind of you!
Really i appreciate your deep knowledge in pakistan affairs.
Sir aapka ka buht shukrya aap ny buht malomat di yahi wajah hy aaj Pakistan itna kamzor hy
Thanx alot this episode was much needed.❤️
فیصل صاحب
بہت مبارک ہو زبردست V Log کرنے پر
اگلے V Log کا شدت سے انتظار رہے گا
I am from India and really love your analysis research and your presentation
Probably the one of the best vlog made faisal bhai which gave new and very important information that why there is ambiguity about the way how to run the PAKISTAN....
Very very very nice video
Wonderful, one of the best vlogs of Faisal Waraich, thank you so much ❤❤❤
You're My History Teacher ❤
Faisal bahi isi sa related videos mazeed banha shukriya
A couple of questions ...
Yes there are confusions in what Muhammad Ali Jinnah quoted for the state's system, theocratic, secular (with muslims and non muslims living with their customs) , these are the technical details.. what was the general campaign and narrative of muslim league ? Please quote that too "Pakistan ka matlab kya ? La ilaha illah Allah" what does this show ?
Quaid e Azam gatherred all the muslims from Peshawar to Bengal over the slogan and name of "Islam", the separate homeland for practicing islam to implement islam ..
The speech of Quaid e Azam clearly says about Pakistan, describing it as "bulwark of Islam", I am stating exact words.
We can say that MA Jinnah was not a hypocrite to use Islam for gaining political popularity ....
Yes the legislation was important , but more important was the foundation of state, its mechanism, the funds that Reserve bank of India did not give at that time, the flux in immigrants, looted, murdered, a big human crisis ... these were the issue MA Jinnah was dealing with,..
Secondly, Liaqat Ali Khan had passed the Objective Resolution, I am pretty sure we know it, if not, can read it to remember that preamble of constitution of Pakistan was decided to facilitate muslims, to implement Islamic way of life for muslim population and to encourage islam in the state....
The issue of secular state was raised by the people who were the remains of british colonialism and they started debating it at the very state of foundation of Pakistan...
And still, there are the dog's licking the west zionists boots
@shakil ahmad well, even if that was the case,( I don't believe it because what did Jinnah earn from this state? Many Muslims landlord left their wealth for Pakistan.) , muslim league gathered the masses in the name of Islam, so if Pakistan demand Islamic system in politics or society, its totally justifiable because they sacrificed all for what? Yes for Islam.. were Muslims dying with hunger in British India? No. Yes they needed the land for themselves to be called an Islamic state
The problem with our society is that, anyone can gather them in the name of Islam but they won't gather for their own rights or any serious issues and the worse problem is that they takes Islam to a extreme level where its really not...
@@shahzaib8922 religion of islam was and is the part of life of general public. some follow it in its true spirit , others do not follow but give it value in any way...
can't impose the perception and opinion of a few people who do not want islam or islamic social system over those who , still today, wish to reshape their culture and society according to their faith and religion
Kaun sa pahad ukhaad liya Islamic state bana ke....aaj bhi to bheekh hi maang rhe ho
Thank you for opening our eyes to the facts.
God bless you. InshAllah the path of truth will throw away the stones from our path.
Best topic ever 👌
خوبصورت الفاظ ، متوازن لب و لہجہ اور نہایت معقول تجزیاتی مطالعہ ۔
شاباش چوہدری فیصل وڑائچ صاحب!
آپ کی انگلی ویڈیو کا انتظار رہے گا
I learned Balochistan forced to join Pakistan in 27 march 1948. Kindly share your knowledge about Balochistan princely states relationship with eachother and with British empire. Because I heard from my grandfather that Baloch tribes were strictly against British empire they never allowed them enter in Balochistan.
British claim they ruled us but about 40% land was under the princely states ....
Including Baluchistan
Your videos satisfy my knowledge appetite. Best of luck to all team especially Faisal Sahab. Your edge is your unbiased attitude, so, never forget to deviate. Best wishes
پاکستان کا آئین کیو معلوم نہیں پاکستان کا آئین پہلے دن سے ہی قرآن و سنت ہیں
Acha tu apply kijya
Never heard this information before...... Well done Faisal Warraich 👍
Who told u Gandhi was not against cast system..
He literally said removing cast system is more important than removing British government..
U could not make a more wrong statement
@Anthony De Mello yes we literally abolish caste system♥️ but caste system was different from Varna system but it was British propaganda to introduce caste system to divide India. But now just few states and cases caste system is no where to scene today.
عمدہ ترین ویڈیو.... کیپ اٹ اپ
مزید کا انتظار ہے...
اور یہ بھی بتائیں کہ کیا پاکستان میں جمہوریت کے علاوہ کوئی نظام کامیاب ہو سکتا ہے.
What a beautiful and detailed analysis. We must rise above the personalities but i don't think we can achieve this in next 2 decades. Million Dollar question is that, do we have such liberty of Time?????
I understand what you mean, but there are many countries doing better than us and there those personalities are worshipped. Take gandhi in India for example. Their liberals do not make his views controversial, most of them are unaware of what he thought of dalits or hat he did with young women, they call it whatsapp university propaganda, and here we see hoodhboy and others deliberately making jinnah's idea of Pakistan controversial. Instead of weighing in on his secular statements (there's abundance of them) they undermine him as much as they can and limit his secular views to just the 11th August speech. PS: I exclude Faisal warraich from the list of such people just so you know, he explains everything logically and does not exaggerate.
@@qurratulainzehra8760 Thanks for the reply. I dont support liberals as well as fundamentalist because both are standing on extreme sides and not helping the country. i dont say that we must hate Quaid e Azam or any other personality. my point is to rise above personality. appreciate them as they did a fantastic job when it was needed but now we must move on without hurting their image or without worshipping them as immortals or perfect ones.
I have two great teacher on social media the first is engr Muhammad Ali merza and the second is faisal bhae. You both are unique
Even the recommendations proposed by the Constitution Commission under Justice Shahabuddin were not accepted in their entirety by Ayub. Ayub had already appointed a Cabinet sub-committee with Manzoor Qadir, the Foreign Minister, as its chairman and Mohammad Shoaib, Z.A Bhutto, A.K. Khan and Ibrahim as its members to prepare a parallel constitution according to his wishes. The Constitution Commission under Shahabuddin had been appointed only to endorse a plan already decided upon.
Great sir
Looking forward to next one..
Respected sir thanks a lot ♥️🔥
You share a lot of information with us.
I am a very big fan of you.
Love you ❤️✨
سر، اپسے بہت کچھ سیکھنے کو مل رہا ہے، اللہ آپ کو لمبے عمر عطاء فرمائے آمین۔
Make video on Russian Soviet defectors
No words on this analysis. I have no idea to give a complement on your analysis or to cry on our failure.
When Jinnah was asked what will be the constitution of Pakistan, he replied that Pakistan's constitution was written 1400 years ago.
There is no problem in Slavery, because it has been permitted by Allah SWT.
Islam allows muslims to have slave. But slaves should be treated with Dignity.
Go away
Coming from someone, whose society promotes the caste system your comment, even if it were remotely true is rejected due to its stench of hypocrisy. FYI, I am not Pakistani, or from your wretched ancestry place either.
@@Stimmevon70 lol nice joke hindus have wored a hell lot on that caste system, we r all open to reform unlike a priimitive desert cult
@@Stimmevon70 yea
Vashir, Ha ha ha right
I Love your intro, It is difficult topic that you explained very well. Thanks :)
Your analysis is absolutely right and reality based. Thanks for this informative video.
Now at present how and who will set the right the initial mistakes .
A wise and sharp leader can set the right mistakes with the help of public leaders....But such persons are not available in Pakistan up till now.
This video is also proving that Pakistani politicians and bureaucracy are not capable , honest and trustworthy because the Pakistani elite class did not take any initiative for the interest of the common man.They are greedy and selfish.....
They became mafias and mafias are ruling in Pakistan...
The only mistake is when he said "for unknown reasons" they didn't prepare a document. They didn't prepare a doc because Jinnah had lied to practically everyone he had spoken to and promised them contradictory things in order to get them to agree to support Pakistan. Writing down the structure of the country would have led to parts of his support base revolting.
Want to hear the truth
They don't had a plan for Pakistan
They were just throwing darts 🎯 and
Ek dhoke se sahi jagaj lag Gaya that's it
@@_kartik_chauhan Tukka maar ke desh ko baat diya, ab tukka maar kar mulk chala rahe hain
Shandar Fasal .
One of the finest brief informative video from Faisal Mian....!
Yes, this analysis is true that perhaps the idea of democracy has settled in the larger population of India.....as the period of emergency of 21 months saw stiff resistance from certain groups....
Perhaps, this is the reason why a sizable number of people who vote for Mr. Modi ( For reasons strictly other than religious polarisation) come to his open opposition when he tends to centralise more powers....though the same people may AGAIN VOTE FOR HIM ....If he only doesn't try to become an autocratic authority.
The reasons for his success are complex but it is CERTAINLY NOT HINDUTVA ALONE AS THERE ARE NOT EVEN HALF OF ITS TAKERS AMONG HIS VOTERS IN MY OPINION....!
Well!
I hope you are right!
You're right, your observation is spot on
Opening Sequence was up to the mark for the point you wanted to make. Tremendous Work
sir u missed Balochistan.
please make a video on the mergence of Balochistan.
Outstanding
I was waiting for your vlog on this issue.
پاکستان کی آزاد ہونے کے فوراً بعد ہی اس ملک پر کچھ لوگ قابض ہو گئے جنہیں انگریز ناریل کہتا تھا یہ ان سرداروں زمینداروں چوہدریوں وڈیروں اور سجادہ نشینوں کی اولادیں تھیں جن کے ساتھ مل کر انگریزوں نے اس خطے پر قبضہ کیا اور حکومت کی ان کے بچوں کو انگریزوں نے اپنے اسکولوں میں پڑھا لکھا کر فوج بیوروکریسی اور سیاست میں لائے 75 سال سے ان کا ہی قبضہ ہے جن میں ملٹری بیوروکریسی سول بیوروکریسی سیاست دان شامل ہیں
💕 🌃 FEEL BLESSING
💕experienced experience
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Very informative video,sir.Desperatly waiting for the next.
Make video on last defender of socialism Marshal Ustinov
Dear Warraich sb This is eye opening effort to know about the beginning of our history. Pl also upload links and reference of sources you have got this information. Thank you
Corruption free Pakistan... And immediately justice for all only solution of Pakistan..!
What a mind blowing analysis I must say.. 👍🏻You are such a true history's student.. 👍🏻
Faisal Bhai I want to know a reality as you know Pakistan 🇵🇰 always say that India support terrorist attacks in Pakistan while India 🇮🇳 say that Pakistan support terrorist attacks in India. Can you please tell me the reality?
It's the biggest question❓in my brain theses days.
India is globally declared terror supporting country. Who was first suicide bomber? Hindu.
India supports ttp and BLA in pakistan
Both countries use the word terrorism for their politics bro
@@Ragnarhsb BLA is a spreatist organization not a terrorist organization.. and jahan tak baat hai TTP usko b khada Pakistani army and government ne hi kiya tha jiska phal aaj bugat rahe hain. History padh lo buchy.
@@Ragnarhsb yes and now india increase the speed to get more advantage in your poor economic condition
بہت اعلیٰ
QA, a disturbed saddist person owing to family issues, was equally responsible alongwith neutrals in putting country to wrong direction. Pakistan is a hell gor reasonable people.
Yeah he was saddist who gave country to people like you fools
My favorite topic......
Thank you sir for making this!
2:49
Here you gave wrong information, Gandhi Ji fought for the rights of the low caste people, he gave them the name Harijan ( children of God).
He just gave them name tag. He didn't fight for them. It was Ambedkar who really fought for low caste.
@@banksterkid5930 you are wrong keep study Gandhi book
@@girirajrathore8067 are you serious? You think Gandhi did more than ambedkar for lower caste??
بہت زبردست اور معلوماتی ویڈیو ھے
لیکن ساتھ دل بھی جلتا ہے کہ اس وقت کے عالی شان راہنماؤں کو کھرے کھوٹے کی پہچان نہیں تھی۔ لگتا ایسے ھے کہ یہ ریاست پہلے ہی دن سے ناکام ہو گئی تھی