OMG I did NOT notice it was supposed to be Ningning at the near end portion of the analysis instead of Giselle. on the bright side, ya'll can truly know that I'm not being biased whatsoever cause i even forget the members' names😭 edit: omg last time i checked this has 3k views and it's 4x that already tysm guys~!
winter has a great musicality and understands very well the conection between music and choreography! she's a great rookie and I hope she works on dancing and not only vocals in the future, besides being one of the best vocalists in the group too
I don't get it when they say Winter didn't have any charisma or stage presence. When I literally followed their beginning till now, even she is not the center she shined at their performance and nailing their choreography. That why she became my bias she really lived up as the ace of aespa.
Not entirely on topic but It really baffles me why stylist puts Karina in high heels when she’s the tallest and the main dancer, why not give her some comfortable shoes so she can focus on her dancing.
I love how opposite karina and winter is. Karina is the same as irene known for their graceful, clean movements while winter is the same as seulgi known for that poppin lockin powerful strict moves
switch, karina is seulgi's descendant: power, fluidity, and energy, girlie got it the chill, sometimes inconsistent projection of energy, but fluidity is also very good is irene and winter
@@peachesarepeachestoo2654 Idk about Karina and Irene comparison But Winter and Seulgi has the same style, they are both good at inner pop. Difference is Seulgi is more powerful, hopefully Winter can add power to her style. But her style right now is already amazing
As you could see every Savage performance karina always did the lock right and the glide and the break down right especially this part 3:29-3:31 right it seem like she have the most stamina to me and you could also see the squid game outfit dance practice also and check that part also cause the difference is huge between the others
This is what I learnt from this video about the Main and Lead Dancers in this group. Karina = elegant, graceful movements probably due to her ballet training. This makes her neck, arm, and foot work to be great, along with her angles. Her movements are the most clean in the group. Winter = her pops and isolation, along with her hip movements are the best in the group. Her background is hip-pop so that makes sense. She slightly lacks energy but her dancing is precise.
I've always felt Winter's lack of energy while dancing, but that voice and the punch and vibe she has, just makes me feel in awe everytime I see her (in such a good way, she's powerful). 🤧💜 *Edit:* Karina and NingNing's dancing are the ones I enjoy the most and then Winter's, she's super elegant along with NingNing imo
In my opinion I prefer winters dancing, its not messy and it gives of that elegant vibe, as if she doesn't even break a sweat, I also like ningnings fluid moves and ofcourse main dancer karina is amazing.
The way karina dances is the reason I hit so many small beats when I’m just playing around doing this dance. Her staggered pull backs on the bent arms love is something I copy a lot and could only do so because she made it noticeable it was being done
Indeed Winter deserved to be the lead dancer. I was so in love with her dance in SAVAGE. If I didn't know Karina is the main dancer, I would have thought Winter is the main dancer. Winter's dance is like her body is moving on her own but so flexible. She never misses a beat and her visual😍😍. Her vocal is so damn amazing. She proved she's not only a visual but a lead dancer and vocal too😎
Can we all appreciate the fact that karina and winter knows their job when it comes to dancing? After all theyre the main and lead dancer. They really understand the assignment given to them
im not a fan YET but based on my observations, here is how i rank them: dance: 1. karina 2. winter 3. ningning 4. giselle vocal: 1. ningning 2. winter 3. karina 4. giselle rap: 1. giselle 2. karina 3. winter 4. ningning (it’s amazing how winter doesn’t have first place but is always at rank 2/3!! this shows that every member is good at everything) overall: 1. karina 2. winter 3. ningning 4. giselle so gonna stan them soon :)
I think winter should really balance her popping and energy because she just lets her popping carry the performance when the moves aren’t even centered on popping in the first place. The pop should be a nice bonus to add flavor and not the only thing you’re doing
What I actually like about these choreography is that they add their own spices and dance styles to it especially in this song where they said was the most difficult for them. But then as for Winter grown to be used with pop, she just flow with it and doesn't just act like she just need to do it bcoz that's her own dance style. In short, she's so natural with it. As per her energy, she obviously always not the best in letting it out but she know where to put it. She know what part it should be added and when not, bcoz she's got amazing body control. She's not being so laid-back nor she's over dancing, she's just balanced.
This is good. I just don't agree with the Karina's part on the head isolations on the chorus. The head isolations were obviously done properly by Giselle then Ningning
Winter slays the main chorus, she makes it really catchy! Ning Ning does the kinda hip roll part while walking Chorus part great in my opinion. Karina movements are very clean and pretty, and Giselle is very stable and I liked her first part rap movements. The reason I liked savage the most was because of its dance and pre chorus. And the rap parts and the bridge lmao.
I'm just know noticing Karina is the only one in heels- *a bit odd considering she's the tallest, but okay* Also, idk why but at 0:22 I'm always obsessed with the way Winter just pops like that.... it just seems so cool and effortless to me
i would agree but note that karina have different choreo as she is in the center and this video is to compare between who does the moves best meaning i need two or more members to execute the same moves to compare. hope that clears this up😊
Just my opinion but I think Winter is a very technically good dancer (and of course incredible singer), her dancing is not based in strength but that’s not a problem. The reason she doesn’t necessarily stand out as much is a lack of stage presence. I just don’t really feel much from her. You don’t have to have strength to have great stage presence.
Winter lacks energy but her pops and locks and isolations and her fluidity are so good and satisfying. Imagine her dancing with more power and energy, ahhhh
karina has good energy, she doesnt overdances (maybe she does but doesnt look like it) or looks overdance (she might be cleaner but doesnt look overdance at all) . More energy for Winter, Ningning and Giselle still slayed through out.
*Not gonna lie this girl group is not that hard to choose a bias between them all because as long as you review and appreciate all of their performance and knowing them one by one ur gonna start to love them all*
Next level and savage concepts were really winter’s forte she slayed the dance and vocals too sadly all the netizens hated on her for her expressions but didn’t appreciate the concept she was embodying She has drastically changed her stage performances and now i wonder where the haters at
I would love if you could make an analysis why a lot of people think Karina is such a wonderful dancer but there's just something awkward about her dance style. Is it the choreography? Her body proportions? Maybe just bc of her outfit 🤔
i think it’s her facial expressions, it really makes her look like she’s bored. don’t get me wrong tho, she’s my bias in aespa and i love her to bits, it’s just what i notice in her fancams 😭
@@fubuki5990 It's not her facial expression at all actually. As someone who stans SM groups, I think she has the standard SM artists facial expression which I often see it as not overexaggerated and focused. I've been thinking about it, and I think it's just the choreography and her dancing style aren't matching. Some dance reactors had said that there's something different and awkward about aespa's choreography, and it's confirmed by BoA herself. Idk, I hope whether it's her expression or choreography, it'll get better in the future. She's amazingly talented
@@spaceships.s344 i agree, karina is such an amazing dancer and i actually think she bodied step back the best out of anyone. and now that i think about it, i agree with you. she doesn’t look bored, she looks very focused on executing her steps perfectly. anyway, karina’s dancing is definitely something interesting to talk about.
it looks like she's an energetic dancer from the rest of the video. it might be a stylistic choice, but it's quite out of place when the rest do it with much more energy. her pops are very satisfying tho haha
@@KateSparkle I watched their perf of Savage at the K Culture Festival and Winter seemed to be more energetic there. It's so frustrating because she is so inconsistent with the whole energy thing lol maybe she is one of those idols who during their first performances try to watch their steps carefully therefore don't pay attention at projecting power?
Winter's dance has no strength, precisely because of her choice. The main thing about her dance is detail and precision! It's amazing and unique the way she dances, it's very surprising especially her popping and footwork. I love her dance style more than Karina's
Can we talk about how they get hate for the dancing a strange presence even though they have the most nuancey and intricate dances in Kpop right now? Like, I see a lot of ITZY fans say the girls can’t dance and that simply just isn’t true
I don’t know the girls but based of the video here are my positions Winter- Main Dancer (visual) Karina- main rapper (visual) Ningning- main vocalist (or winter) Giselle- lead rapper and lead vocalist Edit: i could be wrong Edit : I just searched the positions lol
@@kia4162 yea I know I looked up the positions sorry. It’s because I saw 2 videos of the same type and it looks like winter danced most of the parts better than the other members. Sorry for the confusion haha I just didn’t know them
@@222alexis haha yes,just time ago I didn't know the positions either is because I saw her fancam for next level and now this and in my conclusion she lacks energy and expression to be main sorry If it bother you either
As a dancer myself i find them to be average dancers. But they have beautiful vocals, so is ok. I'm talking about Ning Ning, Winter and Karina. They still lack a lot of stage presence.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG I did NOT notice it was supposed to be Ningning at the near end portion of the analysis instead of Giselle. on the bright side, ya'll can truly know that I'm not being biased whatsoever cause i even forget the members' names😭
edit: omg last time i checked this has 3k views and it's 4x that already tysm guys~!
146k now this blew up
@@ohhi6313 147k+ now..
@@IamAhooman 166k+ now.
@@nuraa7 169k+ now...
@@IamAhooman 174k+ now..
Really liked Winter here. Her body control and pops are super satisfying.
I don't know. Winter is actually pretty stiff here
@@saving_graciela9203 nah
@@saving_graciela9203 you sound insecure tho
@@kimjnkruby you talk aboutbeing insecure when it's you who hates Twice in every twice's video😂 How embarrassing 😂 Hypocrite much?😂
@@saving_graciela9203 omg when did I hate on twice?😭 I don't even check out their music videos😭
Things I learned:
- Winter’s pops and locks are amazing and I need to keep an eye out in the future
- Giselle’s strength is in her fluidity
she can’t pop
@@alishaoop2676 she can
Winter might lack power, but her elegance, precision is a standout.
Karina: 22 moves (main dancer)
Winter: 17 moves (lead dancer)
Giselle: 4 moves
Ningning: 9 moves
What does that mean? Like, can you explain in detail? What do you mean by moves?
@@Cut50ForOverActing. it means the times they were highlighted in the video
@@tupichi8995 You mean like when they are centre.
@@Cut50ForOverActing. no, it's who did each part of the dance the best:)
@@bornpink3069 oh, ok, thanks
winter is so good at poplocking so satisfying
1:40 can we just appreciate winter’s pops here like OMG IT HITS DIFFERENT
Like, really… how she does that??!
Yess!!! My fave part of the choreo because of her pops
@shizianthea it is possible to learn how to pop
@shizianthea it's a dance style that many people learn and many kpop idols learns the basics of it and all. it's not only a 'skill'
what is pops
winter has a great musicality and understands very well the conection between music and choreography! she's a great rookie and I hope she works on dancing and not only vocals in the future, besides being one of the best vocalists in the group too
00:18 karina owned this choreo✨
I love winters dancing the way she moves and executes every move is so precise and satisfying to watch, also I’m in love with her popping 😍❤️
I don't get it when they say Winter didn't have any charisma or stage presence. When I literally followed their beginning till now, even she is not the center she shined at their performance and nailing their choreography. That why she became my bias she really lived up as the ace of aespa.
i think winter's gime gime now part was literally the best part of the whole dance🤔
I agree! she owns that part!
Not entirely on topic but It really baffles me why stylist puts Karina in high heels when she’s the tallest and the main dancer, why not give her some comfortable shoes so she can focus on her dancing.
I love how opposite karina and winter is. Karina is the same as irene known for their graceful, clean movements while winter is the same as seulgi known for that poppin lockin powerful strict moves
It must be the contrary, winter does it very sharp and robotic like Irene
@@moonlightespt3818 robotic irene? no, not really no
switch, karina is seulgi's descendant: power, fluidity, and energy, girlie got it
the chill, sometimes inconsistent projection of energy, but fluidity is also very good is irene and winter
@@peachesarepeachestoo2654 exactly
@@peachesarepeachestoo2654 Idk about Karina and Irene comparison
But Winter and Seulgi has the same style, they are both good at inner pop. Difference is Seulgi is more powerful, hopefully Winter can add power to her style. But her style right now is already amazing
thats why karina and winter in dance line🔥
KARINA IS ON POINTY HEELS EVERYONE BUT SHE SLAYED THIS CHOREO AS ALWAYS
HOLY SHIT I DIDN'T NOTICE THAT
@@silverhours right? KARINA ACE
Honestly, I would like to see her dance with stilettos 😩😩😩 But I think she’s still at a point in her career where that would be too risky
@@aquaaria3489 yes let's wait for her beb, we all want that for karina.
Ofc it's Karina
Respect to Karina for doing this entire dance so well while also wearing high heels!!
Ok but Karina nailing this choreo in high heels just screams main dancer material
As you could see every Savage performance karina always did the lock right and the glide and the break down right especially this part 3:29-3:31 right it seem like she have the most stamina to me and you could also see the squid game outfit dance practice also and check that part also cause the difference is huge between the others
oh i already adressed on why i didnt use the dance practice in the description😊
This is what I learnt from this video about the Main and Lead Dancers in this group.
Karina = elegant, graceful movements probably due to her ballet training. This makes her neck, arm, and foot work to be great, along with her angles. Her movements are the most clean in the group.
Winter = her pops and isolation, along with her hip movements are the best in the group. Her background is hip-pop so that makes sense. She slightly lacks energy but her dancing is precise.
Karina must be the main dancer the way she dances is really great ❤️ I'm in love 😍😍
@PinkBP they meant that she must be not that she shouldve been
I've always felt Winter's lack of energy while dancing, but that voice and the punch and vibe she has, just makes me feel in awe everytime I see her (in such a good way, she's powerful). 🤧💜
*Edit:* Karina and NingNing's dancing are the ones I enjoy the most and then Winter's, she's super elegant along with NingNing imo
In my opinion I prefer winters dancing, its not messy and it gives of that elegant vibe, as if she doesn't even break a sweat, I also like ningnings fluid moves and ofcourse main dancer karina is amazing.
The way karina dances is the reason I hit so many small beats when I’m just playing around doing this dance. Her staggered pull backs on the bent arms love is something I copy a lot and could only do so because she made it noticeable it was being done
Karina in heels never disappoints
Winter's dance is my favorite.
It's because Winter wants to bring it inwards. ❄️
Indeed Winter deserved to be the lead dancer. I was so in love with her dance in SAVAGE. If I didn't know Karina is the main dancer, I would have thought Winter is the main dancer. Winter's dance is like her body is moving on her own but so flexible. She never misses a beat and her visual😍😍. Her vocal is so damn amazing. She proved she's not only a visual but a lead dancer and vocal too😎
winter is just a queen no caps
Can we all appreciate the fact that karina and winter knows their job when it comes to dancing? After all theyre the main and lead dancer. They really understand the assignment given to them
Y’all forgetting karina n her being the best dancer in aespa she literally has the best energy the best technique the best footwork the best details
I don't know what else to say, I can only say Winter she did a great job, in every way❤️
Karina is a really good dancer. She has perfected this choreography that no one else can.
im not a fan YET but based on my observations, here is how i rank them:
dance:
1. karina
2. winter
3. ningning
4. giselle
vocal:
1. ningning
2. winter
3. karina
4. giselle
rap:
1. giselle
2. karina
3. winter
4. ningning
(it’s amazing how winter doesn’t have first place but is always at rank 2/3!! this shows that every member is good at everything)
overall:
1. karina
2. winter
3. ningning
4. giselle
so gonna stan them soon :)
❤️❤️❤️
Winter is balanced its what make her the strongest
Vocal : 1. Winter
@@lovelyR7 def not
@@user-jo5vv3wz9d its their opinion, let it be
even to a non dancer audience karina's movements are clean and satisfying.
For me winter is the best in this song 🔥🔥🔥
Winter really slayed.
karina so pretty perfect n dances so good that she looks like a robot sometimes in a good way
I think winter should really balance her popping and energy because she just lets her popping carry the performance when the moves aren’t even centered on popping in the first place. The pop should be a nice bonus to add flavor and not the only thing you’re doing
but it looks good 😩
I actually like and agree to this input. Well said.
kev私 it might look good but it can also look out of place since she’s the only one actually doing it
I'm not a dancer, but i thought that they were dancing in their own style
What I actually like about these choreography is that they add their own spices and dance styles to it especially in this song where they said was the most difficult for them. But then as for Winter grown to be used with pop, she just flow with it and doesn't just act like she just need to do it bcoz that's her own dance style. In short, she's so natural with it. As per her energy, she obviously always not the best in letting it out but she know where to put it. She know what part it should be added and when not, bcoz she's got amazing body control. She's not being so laid-back nor she's over dancing, she's just balanced.
karina and winter they like the machine dance
This is good. I just don't agree with the Karina's part on the head isolations on the chorus. The head isolations were obviously done properly by Giselle then Ningning
can you pinpoint the timeline?
@@alexistudion3709 all of the head isolations in the chorus were done by Ningning and Giselle, esp Giselle, the best
@@alexistudion3709 2:28 the " zsu zsu zsu " part
Karina did it good too
@@dhirajkarkera7548 I didn't say she didn't do good. I was only talking about who did it best
the fact that karina did this in heels.......sharp pointed heels that hurt even when you're just walking regularly.....
And Karina is wearing high heels 😮
WINTER IS THE ISOLATION QUEEN
Winter slays the main chorus, she makes it really catchy! Ning Ning does the kinda hip roll part while walking Chorus part great in my opinion. Karina movements are very clean and pretty, and Giselle is very stable and I liked her first part rap movements. The reason I liked savage the most was because of its dance and pre chorus. And the rap parts and the bridge lmao.
thank God finally a DANCER doing a critique. not dancers-wannabe.
as expected karina our main dancer
Karina ate this choreography 👑
The fact that Karina dances with a pointed hills is a statement
WInter has very good pops, and is very good on beat
Actually Winter dance the chorus main dance part better than Karina.
Winter definitely
when you mentioned winter lacks energy, I think that's where I can see people say they lack stage presence
I love you Karina.
I'm just know noticing Karina is the only one in heels-
*a bit odd considering she's the tallest, but okay*
Also, idk why but at 0:22 I'm always obsessed with the way Winter just pops like that.... it just seems so cool and effortless to me
3:30 3:37 I think Winter do it better than Karina because Winter’s move cleaner
imo ningning has the best stage presence. my eyes always go to her
Same
1:40 Karina owns that step
i would agree but note that karina have different choreo as she is in the center and this video is to compare between who does the moves best meaning i need two or more members to execute the same moves to compare. hope that clears this up😊
@@alexistudion3709 I respect your perspective. For me it was Karina who owns that part.
@@shatakshimishra7400 of course! no problem at all~❤️
Frrr
just now , realising that karina danced this in heels !
and a fitted outfit too!! Dancing with those are hard af
In my opinion, Winter moves were sharper and clean than Karina in the chorus part
Just my opinion but I think Winter is a very technically good dancer (and of course incredible singer), her dancing is not based in strength but that’s not a problem. The reason she doesn’t necessarily stand out as much is a lack of stage presence. I just don’t really feel much from her. You don’t have to have strength to have great stage presence.
I think my ranking
1.karina
2.winter and ningning
3giselle
ning ning is my bias but omg winter is slowly making her way up to my heart~~
And thats why Sm hide Winter until the very last minute
Winter lacks energy but her pops and locks and isolations and her fluidity are so good and satisfying. Imagine her dancing with more power and energy, ahhhh
karina has good energy, she doesnt overdances (maybe she does but doesnt look like it) or looks overdance (she might be cleaner but doesnt look overdance at all) . More energy for Winter, Ningning and Giselle still slayed through out.
Giselle is doing great for an idol that only trained 8 months before debuting!
*Not gonna lie this girl group is not that hard to choose a bias between them all because as long as you review and appreciate all of their performance and knowing them one by one ur gonna start to love them all*
Ningning is my fave (!!) but Karina really did slay the whole dance
should've used the dance practice for the analysis. Karina's outfit looked quite uncomfortable to dance in, she couldn't give her best here
please read my description hehe :))
savage has a lot of popping which is something winter is good at
Next level and savage concepts were really winter’s forte she slayed the dance and vocals too sadly all the netizens hated on her for her expressions but didn’t appreciate the concept she was embodying
She has drastically changed her stage performances and now i wonder where the haters at
I would love if you could make an analysis why a lot of people think Karina is such a wonderful dancer but there's just something awkward about her dance style. Is it the choreography? Her body proportions? Maybe just bc of her outfit 🤔
i think it’s her facial expressions, it really makes her look like she’s bored. don’t get me wrong tho, she’s my bias in aespa and i love her to bits, it’s just what i notice in her fancams 😭
@@fubuki5990 It's not her facial expression at all actually. As someone who stans SM groups, I think she has the standard SM artists facial expression which I often see it as not overexaggerated and focused. I've been thinking about it, and I think it's just the choreography and her dancing style aren't matching. Some dance reactors had said that there's something different and awkward about aespa's choreography, and it's confirmed by BoA herself. Idk, I hope whether it's her expression or choreography, it'll get better in the future. She's amazingly talented
@@spaceships.s344 i agree, karina is such an amazing dancer and i actually think she bodied step back the best out of anyone. and now that i think about it, i agree with you. she doesn’t look bored, she looks very focused on executing her steps perfectly. anyway, karina’s dancing is definitely something interesting to talk about.
karina in heels..
ningning is haechan of aespa
Karina is the main dancer once again made sure of it, her style of dance is not typical and that fascinates me so much
Κarina did that on heels...
Omg Karina's shoes though. 💯
1:40 I really agree with the lack of energy you pointed out. i'm wondering if this was a stylistic choice or she is just not an energetic dancer?
it looks like she's an energetic dancer from the rest of the video. it might be a stylistic choice, but it's quite out of place when the rest do it with much more energy. her pops are very satisfying tho haha
@@KateSparkle I watched their perf of Savage at the K Culture Festival and Winter seemed to be more energetic there. It's so frustrating because she is so inconsistent with the whole energy thing lol maybe she is one of those idols who during their first performances try to watch their steps carefully therefore don't pay attention at projecting power?
Her facial expression is blank in that part
But, i don't know why? I love that winter's "lack of energy" like she didn't do her best but still can slaying on the stage 🤩
It's not the first time that Winter is like that you can clearly notice it in her next level fancam from studio choom
2:29 NINGNINGS MOVEMENT HELLOOO ITS SO GOOD
Winter's dance has no strength, precisely because of her choice. The main thing about her dance is detail and precision! It's amazing and unique the way she dances, it's very surprising especially her popping and footwork. I love her dance style more than Karina's
I just realized how tiring this choreo is 😳😳 and karina with heels? oh my
I think WINTER 😚
Can we talk about how they get hate for the dancing a strange presence even though they have the most nuancey and intricate dances in Kpop right now? Like, I see a lot of ITZY fans say the girls can’t dance and that simply just isn’t true
Those mic are false advertising when they just lip sync the whole thing.
Let's see you dance and sing
@@bubbles3117 You don't need to dance or sing to have an opinion about it.
1:43 Winter's torso pop though, I've seen it. Did anyone noticed?
i don't agree with 1:43 one, especially in the "and my ae" part, that move just requires energy which Karina definitely slayed
I don’t know the girls but based of the video here are my positions
Winter- Main Dancer (visual)
Karina- main rapper (visual)
Ningning- main vocalist (or winter)
Giselle- lead rapper and lead vocalist
Edit: i could be wrong
Edit : I just searched the positions lol
definitely winter is not main dancer
@@kia4162 yea I know I looked up the positions sorry. It’s because I saw 2 videos of the same type and it looks like winter danced most of the parts better than the other members. Sorry for the confusion haha I just didn’t know them
@@kia4162 although I wouldnt be surprised if she was
@@222alexis haha yes,just time ago I didn't know the positions either
is because I saw her fancam for next level and now this and in my conclusion she lacks energy and expression to be main sorry If it bother you either
@@kia4162 no im good haha I was just trying to see if I could guess the positions before searching them up
Savage may look simple and some people find it boring but some moves are so hard and confusing to execute
My biased in AESPA is Gisele
winter never fails to bore me
As a dancer myself i find them to be average dancers. But they have beautiful vocals, so is ok. I'm talking about Ning Ning, Winter and Karina. They still lack a lot of stage presence.
Winter main dancer era
At the end:
*points camera at ningning*
Giselle is doing great
I love how you keep calling ningning giselle
from now on ningning is giselle /j 😌
How thin can winter be omg amazing....
ah this was cool keep making more of these !
i will~! thank you for watching uwuw
Love this evaluation. I noticed that winter's moves are actually very smooth and clean she just lacks energy!
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Karina 💓
I think you meant Ningning in 3:10 but that's finee. I really love Karina's dancing although my bias is Giselle!
SM se la re rifo con Winter