@@kittikovari4322 theres nothing wrong with surgeries. stop invalidating people who had surgeries in their life. not to mention surgeries is pretty normalized in kpop industry so shut up already
I had no idea who she was, but always liked seeing her dance with Taemin, since Taemin is one of my fave artists. She is really talented, you can see she has been practicing hard! 🙂
I felt bad towards Karina. The comment section is filled with hateful comments like let her debut peacefully tho 🥺 And about her dance? SM will never let the main dancer be stiff or lacking, they know what to do just like Taeyong for example. SM trained him like everyday nonstop and now look at that boy. I believe her and the girls. Go aespa 🥺💜
people do be throwing nonsense and yet they don't even have enough or any evidence to support their statements. just let them and we can just let SMEnt. sue them.
ruclips.net/video/-Q2L-qGk9hQ/видео.html Here is the live version in his concert, you will see how the choreography fits in. At that time SM wanted to push Karina so they let her in. And after 2 years I'm sure she has a huge improvement that was different from the past.
i feel like this girl will be the jennie of blackpink. to be clear i'm not starting anything by saying that, i simply mean i think she will be the ace and face of aespa
Ikr. Yes for now she doesnt get the most attention but neither the less. But I have this feeling that Karina will be the ACE. A TRUE TOTAL PERFORMER . VOCAL, DANCE, RAP AND VISUAL. You can do it all but only few people can do it good.
Funny how they judged karina’s skill in this saying she’s lousy or stiff. Like what do u want her to do in here, do hiphop which clearly doesn’t match with the beat? People really be saying anything just to hate
She is a great vocalist and dancer too, I heard her singing if ningning wasn't the main vocalist karina would be the main vocalist of the group! But I guess winter is the lead vocalist not Karina
Ppl commenting KARINA IS SO LUCKY SHE GOT TO DANCE WITH KAI AND TAEMIN need to understand the fact that......She might be lucky....but she worked fkin hard and is really talented that's why she got into SM and we all know how tough it is to get into SM and guys let this girl breath she just debuted and ppl are bashing her! she seemed so nervous during the interview :( everyone have their right to shine LET HER SHINE !♡☆ + guys saying she is a rich kid that's why she got into aespa is totally ridiculous. These hypocritical ppl support another group 🖤💖 where everyone is fkin rich but no one is bashing them ? Huh ! Is it a crime to be rich when you are fkin talented wow sometimes jealousy can make ur mind stop working properly
@@rhenz4745 ig you dont really know what is happening in the comment section and it's not just about calling her lucky.. many of the ppl are calling her privileged blahnlah...but the thing is that it's not easy to become a kpop idols and they are calling her lucky because they are jealous of her as she is living their dream..the life they want so it's not me who is being delusional but the people who are bashing her as ig only Asian ppl can become a kpop idol not everyone and there is a certain age at which you start training. The thing is that YOU WILL NEVER KNOW WHAT SHE WENT THROUGH UNLESS YOU WALK IN HER SHOES.periodt.
Karina only debuted this week and she’s already proved how talented and amazing she is. Lay off guys shes only a rookie and let’s be honest who wouldn’t be nervous dancing with this guy? I’m sure she was but she still did amazing
omg i remember wondering who the girl in this video was before æspa was even announced. i thought that she was so pretty and good at dancing. and now we have her in æspa as a main dancer!
Personally I felt that she was lacking and I knew that she was going to be a trainee. Looking at it now, I still think the same but Jimin is my bias and I absolutely love her! I really support all of the girls hehe
ppl fail to realise she was young here, probably nervous since this was her introduction as a trainee and its taemin so like dont give her shit, im also pretty sure she deserves title as main dancer as ive heard and analysed that she is more of a ballet, contemporary dancer which is visible here, so really no one who trashes her dance skills has any reason too since she hasnt even had time to showcase her full potential
WHAAAAAT that was HER?! Wow, when I first saw her, not knowing who she was I was literally thinking in my mind that she looks like and dances like she should be a Kpop star..and now aespa comes along..daebak
I saw a surprisingly silly comment about Taemin's choreo: "i feel like choreographer really gave up, like the dance doesn't make sense and it's make Taemin look awkward just standing here" IF YOU THINK SO LET ME SAY TOO: Most people thought that Karina didn't fit into the video, that she looked awkward (it's not only the shawols who think so, but also the dancers) and Taemin had to stand aside and give her time on orders from above bc he could just randomly take any girl from his dancer who would represent the concept much better. Karina dances well, but she is not even half of Taemin's level. Taemin didn't get any benefit by giving Karina a spot in his "want", she was given the opportunity for free, be grateful damn it. (I like Karina, but I will not tolerate such comments towards Taemin and his chic choreo).
Look at ruclips.net/video/th_3IpbIQOc/видео.html Taemin gave Karina time in his vid and performance, although she is not needed at all, but now her fans are saying things like that lol. So this is what they mean when say: a Newborn is really not afraid of a tiger. It's so mad.
@@saint7511 nct controversy, irene controversy, seulgi controversy, jaemin controversy, exo controversy, snsd controversy, etc So no wonder mnet used to boycotted sm lol
Well, they apologized didn't they so if accepting apologies is hard for you then I have nothing to say cz they already apologized . But netizens like you still attacked them
그녀는 뻣뻣하다...she is from SM but her dancing is stiff.. like she thinks before she moves.. Not a professional dancer but watching tons of idols and trainees dancing.. i can tell she is not main dancer material. I've expected high because SM produces idols who's skilled in dancing..
@neolovesneoThere's a freedom of opinion here honey and I'm just telling the thruth. Yes, this vid is a year ago.. but I've watch her recent dance video and she's still no fluid at all.. we're no blind and just telling the thruth. Maybe her dancing is only good for group but for solo? Nah.. Another thing if you're debuting you should have a skill on lock... especially you're under big 3. Her sunbaenims set the standard high so we expected something.
@neolovesneo Alright. This "don't say anything if you can't do better" argument is not valid at all. By this logic, we weren't allowed to criticise or have certain expectations when it comes to idols (note that I'm saying 'to criticise', bluntly hating is not what I mean). Now, speaking as a dancer: You can choose to put intentional tension in your movement, but that shouldn't be confused with stiffness. You can easily tell if someone's shaping their movement as they wish or if they're just being stiff. To make it clear: Karina isn't a "bad" dancer, as whatever you may want to classify that. Judging by what we've seen now, she isn't absolutely incredible either, but honestly, in my opinion that's not much of a big deal. I'm sure that she improved over the course of the last year a lot and will continue to improve. Let's not judge too quickly, but let's also not blindly "defend" her skill when OP wasn't even really attacking her.
Wait that was her? I was like "who this random chick" and ppl were saying its a trainee, and i wasn't sure about that, not knowing that it turns out to be aespa karina 💀😭
@neolovesneo bruh i was agreeing about how even great dancers look stiff when dancing with taemin bc the guy's like jelly when he dances edit: and im sorry if it sounded like i was demeaning her skills
If she A main dancer Will be Big mistake Because these generation there's to Many Good dancer than him So maybe She is The main vocalist or main visual
@@yvonnecastillo1620 main vocalist is Ningning, while main rapper is rumored to be Giselle. i think she'll be the center and the FOtG since SM push her the most.. and maybe she's the main dancer.
Sorry but it’s may be because of her dad . She did bad things but SM protected her while SM didn’t protect about Irene while she didn’t make that mistake ( I mean Irene also human , so she can make that kind of mistake but Karina’s mistake is really a thing ) And I really hate SM ! Look how they did SM rookies girls, who waited 10 years for debut. I hate it so much
@@yangyang1909 u know that money can make everything. Most of the Koreans know that Sm is protecting her and the case was actually truth. Just international fans didn’t know the truth
Damn first she dance with KAI now its TAEMIN! GURL u lucky one, LOOKING FORWARD FOR AESPA's debut! Since SM is hyping us and partnering a member even before debut to kai and taemin means a goodnews!
People saying she is really stiff, they need to see her smooth moves. Actually in her solo teaser she portrayed very powerful moves and it somehow turned into a bit of stiffness. But no SM main dancer is untalented!
love how suddenly everybody in this comment section is specialized in dancing... karina just debuted and she's getting so much hate and "criticism" (according to y'all) for no reason, give her a damn chance it's not the same thing to perform in front of trainers than a crowd she could be nervous bc she's not used to it ffs also, many of these so-called "opinions" are plain rude and disrespectful, i swear people love to call it like that to get away with being rude nowadays
also i'm sure she's still a better dancer than most of the people commenting things like this :')) like she wouldn't be a trainee if she was perfect from the beginning, so what do they want?
Just here to see all the old comments claiming she's not a main dancer based off a 30 sec clip. Lol. Karina is a main dancer y'all. Go look at anyone of her fancams and stages. Y'all had such a hate boner for this girl. Anyway she's pretty and talented and will be successful~bye💜 Stan aespa. Stan Karina. Stan main dancers.
Not comparing, but she has a Jennie vibe 👀 like Giselle and her both have a YG vibe idk, maybe its because of their charisma and innocent baby faces but imitating look 😂
@@Denise-lg4mx When a company favors a member, you'd know they would be big when they debut. Looking at her visuals, she might be the next IT girl like Jennie 😊 4th gen best gg!
That looks like the girl from that new SM girl group . . . . . . I feel like I shouldn't have to say I'm joking, but there will definitely be that one person who actually thinks I'm not
ㅈㄴ 추하다 얘들아.. 니들은 스엠들어가지도 못하는데 왜 멀쩡히 있고 열심히 하는 카리나만 못물어뜯어서 난리냐ㅋㅋ 회사에서 하겟다는데 뭘 각상을 해라 꼴보기 싫다 ㅇㅈㄹ.. 얘네들도 홍보하고 알려야하는데 기존 있던 그룹이랑 같이 하는게 젤 무난하고 쉬운 방법아니겟냐? 진짜 회사 경영책가지고 남 물어뜯지좀마셈
I don’t get why they only promote her and when you look at their positions she got like ok of them she might be an all rounder for them but i don’t see the hype in her she looks like someone who might have talent but only would get far in life with the help of the right people and that’s what sm does she wouldn’t make it in a smaller company..yea they didn’t debut yet but I was never wrong with my assumptions towards idols and they always turned out to be right so..
yeah no I get you. She's not a good dancer AT ALL. This was awhile ago but her AESPA teaser with her solo dance and the promo vid with Kai was.... yeah not much improvement lol. Seeing her pre-debut singing videos, she does seem to have strong vocals. But then Winter is supposed to be a strong vocalist too and you have Ning Ning who's phenomenal as well.. so maybe that's why SM is trying to push her as the "dancer." Which I think is a terrible move considering she can't really "dance." In all, she DEFINITELY caught the eye of Lee Soo Man somehow and that's why they're pushing exposure for her the most. It's very obvious that LSM plays favorites. It was the same/is the same for Kai for EXO and Taeyong for NCT. But at least those 2 can actually dance (particularly Kai). If anything, they should have made AESPA 5 members, with the 5th being a main dancer and Karina being the "visual center." (although IMO Ning Ning and Winter are prettier). Idk, this is going to be hard for Karina too because in no time, she is going to get more and more criticism for her dancing as SM keeps pushing her to be a dancer. So so strange though... SM usually finds great dancers like Kai, Taemin, Yunho, Eunhyuk, Seulgi, Hyoyeon, Yuri, Ten, etc... very peculiar why they are doing this lol.
@@minachoi1042 you are pressed asf.. and for what lmfao??? why don't you go do something with your obviously very miserable life, you're pathetic asf dude sorry to break it to you.
SM gave their male artists like Kai, Mark and Taeyong more promo than their other members during predebut and yet they got no hate for it. Heck, Taeyong was even featured in a Red Velvet music video and no one got mad ffs. But now that they're doing the same thing to a woman it's suddenly favoritism? lol no they're doing it because she has the best stage presence in Æspa (whether you like it or not) and she'll probably be the center and/or face of the group. Just say y'all hate women and go
@@minachoi1042 lol she was dancing IN HEELS while dancing with Kai. Do you realize how hard it is to dance in heels while trying to keep up with Kai (arguably one of Kpop's best veteran dancers) at the same time? Probably not cause all you do is sit on the couch all day trying to discredit talented women in the internet. Not even the best dancers of Kpop (like Hyo and Seulgi) can dance all out in heels during their debut era. Dancing in heels take years to perfect. And it's even harder to try and dance in heels just as good as you'd dance without them. You haven't even seen Karina in her best yet and you're already writing whole ass essays about why she's "nOt ThAt TaLeNtEd" and how "sM iS bIaSeD tOwArDs HeR". Imagine being that bitter and talentless lmao
For those people who is saying that karina shouldn't be the main dancer, why is she so stiff? I know you guys loves to discriminate others but i just want to tell you that bashing other people doesn't make you great it only make you a horrible person, and for the issue about the conversation of karina and her friend* it is fake y'all. Well haters gonna hate lol. oh i forgot to say that i can clearly see why Karina is the main dancer.
Subscribe and support us pls!!
For more kpop related content turn on notifications ❤️ We upload daily aespa and other kpop related videos ✨
We well
🧱🧱🧱🧱
Didn't debut yet and already dance with taemin and Kai ....ooo I am jealous.:-):-)
No
That girl is yoo jimin
@@oumaimaguesmi9965 wut? Yoo jimin is karina
@@casamera4063 make sense :)
@@casamera4063 oooohhh and i thought she is from a poor family ..hhh she is talented with her everything not because of her father..
@@oumaimaguesmi9965 Karina is Jimin's stage name
She is not lucky its called talent u guys 😌
Your right
It's not talent, it is passion and practice ✨
@@younglittlejae Which can also make it a strong point 😄
Ikr MashaAllah
@@younglittlejae it is MashaAllah and hardwork too
Karina is so TALENTED. She already danced with two of Kpop's best dancers before even debuting. I'm very proud of her.
Yes Im army too
sm is very lucky to have someone like karina. she’s very talented and not to mention absolutely drop dead gorgeous. she looks like a living doll
SM literally are so lucky for almost everyday idol they have
Yeah her look is because of surgeries
@@kittikovari4322 she’s been pretty…look at her predebut. surgery or not my point still stands, she’s gorgeous.
@@kittikovari4322 theres nothing wrong with surgeries. stop invalidating people who had surgeries in their life. not to mention surgeries is pretty normalized in kpop industry so shut up already
@@kittikovari4322 she didn't even get surgery.. 😭 those photos were of another random girl but twitter made yall believe it was karina
I had no idea who she was, but always liked seeing her dance with Taemin, since Taemin is one of my fave artists. She is really talented, you can see she has been practicing hard! 🙂
Karina singing predebut ruclips.net/video/8VBoWcrkZ-o/видео.html
I knew she was a trainee!!!!. This part always felt a little forced. They were trying to introduce her 😅😅😅
Yeah marketing technique to gain attention to the group but who cares the group’s nice ❤️
Other companies do that too
You must be new to kpop then. Most of the companies do it. Yoona -> Suju, Bp-> Big bang, svt -> nu’est, twice -> got7...just to name a few
@Aadesh Urmi yoona didn't dance with suju she just started in them mv..and same with Victoria and Krystal with shinee
You must be newbie in kpopers xixixixixi
Ok but karinas body proportions are out of this world
Everyone: Karina dances so nice!!!
Me: looking at Taemin's every move
I’m finding this comment💙
Samee
Karina do be collecting SM male idols lolol so cute
she is not lucky she is just talented enough to dance with sm legends
I felt bad towards Karina. The comment section is filled with hateful comments like let her debut peacefully tho 🥺 And about her dance? SM will never let the main dancer be stiff or lacking, they know what to do just like Taeyong for example. SM trained him like everyday nonstop and now look at that boy. I believe her and the girls. Go aespa 🥺💜
Can u believe before ppl knew her they were complimenting her and now that they know who is NOW she’s getting hate....makes no sense
@@Josodivine lol she has a horrible personality tho.
@@koo-core7274 which was proven false by the company and is taking action
@@slayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyed and we all know that it is only public relation strategy
people do be throwing nonsense and yet they don't even have enough or any evidence to support their statements. just let them and we can just let SMEnt. sue them.
I feel like the choreographer really gave up, Like the dance doesn't make sense with the song and it makes taemin look awkward just standing there 🤦
I think so too
i think his live vocals at that part make the just standing there more like
No,the choreo in karina part its about aespa,even the lyrics this song about aespa
ruclips.net/video/-Q2L-qGk9hQ/видео.html
Here is the live version in his concert, you will see how the choreography fits in. At that time SM wanted to push Karina so they let her in. And after 2 years I'm sure she has a huge improvement that was different from the past.
@@winterisssace1385 I'm 100% sure that the choreo is not about Aespa. If you think Taemin will let SM do that in his song then you are wrong.
i feel like this girl will be the jennie of blackpink. to be clear i'm not starting anything by saying that, i simply mean i think she will be the ace and face of aespa
Im a Karina bias and she is the face of the group but so far, Winter is looking like the fan favorite and the ace of Aespa
But Jennie isn't the ace or face of BP tho
Ikr. Yes for now she doesnt get the most attention but neither the less. But I have this feeling that Karina will be the ACE. A TRUE TOTAL PERFORMER . VOCAL, DANCE, RAP AND VISUAL. You can do it all but only few people can do it good.
@@Ryan-wq9te it’s not stated, but according to many fans, they deem Jennie as the face of the group and Lisa, as the ace.
Oh you've done saying it now Minnie... hahahaha
She debuted and she's SOO GREAT SO PRETTY SO TALENTED 😍
엥 존나 뜬금없이 등장하고 나가버리네
Shinee members also featured in girls generation mvs. SM does this a lot.
Kai and Taemin?!Oh girl u r so lucky!!!
No she has someone behind her lol
@@mimr316 lmao hahhaaha
kai and taemin are also lucky to meet a tremendous goddess
@@xlenbbi1430 YES
Nah i dont think she's lucky, she's just talented
Karina's dance moves is so satisfying
Taemin just out here looking like Steve Jobs
BRUH 💀💀
Lol
Funny how they judged karina’s skill in this saying she’s lousy or stiff. Like what do u want her to do in here, do hiphop which clearly doesn’t match with the beat? People really be saying anything just to hate
i was always obsessed with how stunning she is
Karina collecting all the SM boys😂😂😂🔥
imagine not debuting but already being the dancer of the legend lee taemin woah that's pure talent, beauty and charm
Didn't debut just yet and Karina danced with Taemin and Kai!! She must be the luckiest girl in the world!!! I LOVE YOU KARINA!!! 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
She is a great vocalist and dancer too, I heard her singing if ningning wasn't the main vocalist karina would be the main vocalist of the group! But I guess winter is the lead vocalist not Karina
your profile picture is an absolute masterpiece
@@rosywinx thank you! 🥰
애초에 이 파트가 왜 있는지도 모르겠고 이파트에 왜 하필 유지민이 맡은지도 모르겠다
저실력이 메댄이라니....왜 준비도안된상태에서 데뷔할라함 스엠 ㄹㅇ이해안가
씨발 안티 꺼져 카리나 넘 예뻐 썅 ㄴ ㅕㄴ 아
@@JH-bb8in 팬이 가수 욕 다 먹인다
@@누누귀여워 대깨들 달려들어 악플다는 꼴 좀. 문통만 빠는 시끼들 ㅎㅎ
@벤토리 메댄 윈터임
존나잘하는데? 왜 욕해씨발
She's so pretty omg
Jeno and jaemin xd
@@moonxinsan9281 YES HAHAHA plus a "No jaem" for Jeno xD
Now she's even more prettier she grew up well💕
I didn't know that it was her, so many yeaarss!!
She seemed so nervous omg y’all lay off her
I hate those people who are accusing her for no reason whatsoever.
Ppl commenting KARINA IS SO LUCKY SHE GOT TO DANCE WITH KAI AND TAEMIN need to understand the fact that......She might be lucky....but she worked fkin hard and is really talented that's why she got into SM and we all know how tough it is to get into SM and guys let this girl breath she just debuted and ppl are bashing her! she seemed so nervous during the interview :( everyone have their right to shine LET HER SHINE !♡☆
+ guys saying she is a rich kid that's why she got into aespa is totally ridiculous. These hypocritical ppl support another group 🖤💖 where everyone is fkin rich but no one is bashing them ? Huh ! Is it a crime to be rich when you are fkin talented wow sometimes jealousy can make ur mind stop working properly
i am veryyyyyy jealous rn but she deserves it.
lol y r u being delusional, what's wrong with saying "lucky", they didn't insult her????? 😂 LOL ISTG KPOP STANS ARE CRYBABIES
@@rhenz4745 ig you dont really know what is happening in the comment section and it's not just about calling her lucky.. many of the ppl are calling her privileged blahnlah...but the thing is that it's not easy to become a kpop idols and they are calling her lucky because they are jealous of her as she is living their dream..the life they want so it's not me who is being delusional but the people who are bashing her as ig only Asian ppl can become a kpop idol not everyone and there is a certain age at which you start training. The thing is that YOU WILL NEVER KNOW WHAT SHE WENT THROUGH UNLESS YOU WALK IN HER SHOES.periodt.
아 진짜 하나부터 열까지 다 좋은데 저 부분만 좀 어떻게 뜯어고치고 싶다 ^^
걍 존나 스엠 세계관 가오같음ㅠ 그동안 맞춰온건 있어서 여돌 내야하는데 애들은 없고 그래도 가오는 있으니깐 웅앵웅ㅇ앵 하면서 내는 느낌..ㅠ
Karina only debuted this week and she’s already proved how talented and amazing she is. Lay off guys shes only a rookie and let’s be honest who wouldn’t be nervous dancing with this guy? I’m sure she was but she still did amazing
omg i remember wondering who the girl in this video was before æspa was even announced. i thought that she was so pretty and good at dancing. and now we have her in æspa as a main dancer!
Personally I felt that she was lacking and I knew that she was going to be a trainee. Looking at it now, I still think the same but Jimin is my bias and I absolutely love her! I really support all of the girls hehe
Karina's face looks like both a doll and an avatar. I'm jealous of her perfect body shape:"
ppl fail to realise she was young here, probably nervous since this was her introduction as a trainee and its taemin so like dont give her shit, im also pretty sure she deserves title as main dancer as ive heard and analysed that she is more of a ballet, contemporary dancer which is visible here, so really no one who trashes her dance skills has any reason too since she hasnt even had time to showcase her full potential
TO THOSE STUPID PEOPLE WHO HATE ON HER WITHOUT KNOWING THE TRUTH MAKING ME LAUGH- LIKE STOP EMBARASSING YOURSELF
WHAAAAAT that was HER?! Wow, when I first saw her, not knowing who she was I was literally thinking in my mind that she looks like and dances like she should be a Kpop star..and now aespa comes along..daebak
Its hard seing people living my dream
Lol same
Same
why is this me loool
I saw a surprisingly silly comment about Taemin's choreo: "i feel like choreographer really gave up, like the dance doesn't make sense and it's make Taemin look awkward just standing here" IF YOU THINK SO LET ME SAY TOO:
Most people thought that Karina didn't fit into the video, that she looked awkward (it's not only the shawols who think so, but also the dancers) and Taemin had to stand aside and give her time on orders from above bc he could just randomly take any girl from his dancer who would represent the concept much better. Karina dances well, but she is not even half of Taemin's level. Taemin didn't get any benefit by giving Karina a spot in his "want", she was given the opportunity for free, be grateful damn it.
(I like Karina, but I will not tolerate such comments towards Taemin and his chic choreo).
Look at ruclips.net/video/th_3IpbIQOc/видео.html
Taemin gave Karina time in his vid and performance, although she is not needed at all, but now her fans are saying things like that lol. So this is what they mean when say: a Newborn is really not afraid of a tiger.
It's so mad.
She is so talented!
Karina is getting hate for no reason. I LL guarantee something to Haters. Aespa will be shinning stars like NCT,Red Velvet,and other SM idols.:)
Hope they'll not be problematic like their seniors..
Hey their seniors are not problematic!!.I guess You're a HATER
@@saint7511 nct controversy, irene controversy, seulgi controversy, jaemin controversy, exo controversy, snsd controversy, etc
So no wonder mnet used to boycotted sm lol
Well, they apologized didn't they so if accepting apologies is hard for you then I have nothing to say cz they already apologized . But netizens like you still attacked them
@@annanana9453 isn't it the opposite? Didn't sm boycott mnet coz mnet was being dirty?? Idk much details bt it sounded like that
개인적으로 저 부분 마음에 안들음.
그런건 속으로만 생각하셈
SM REALLY SEEK FOR TALENTS
그녀는 뻣뻣하다...she is from SM but her dancing is stiff.. like she thinks before she moves.. Not a professional dancer but watching tons of idols and trainees dancing.. i can tell she is not main dancer material. I've expected high because SM produces idols who's skilled in dancing..
I agree
@neolovesneoThere's a freedom of opinion here honey and I'm just telling the thruth.
Yes, this vid is a year ago.. but I've watch her recent dance video and she's still no fluid at all.. we're no blind and just telling the thruth. Maybe her dancing is only good for group but for solo? Nah..
Another thing if you're debuting you should have a skill on lock... especially you're under big 3. Her sunbaenims set the standard high so we expected something.
@neolovesneo Alright. This "don't say anything if you can't do better" argument is not valid at all. By this logic, we weren't allowed to criticise or have certain expectations when it comes to idols (note that I'm saying 'to criticise', bluntly hating is not what I mean).
Now, speaking as a dancer: You can choose to put intentional tension in your movement, but that shouldn't be confused with stiffness. You can easily tell if someone's shaping their movement as they wish or if they're just being stiff. To make it clear: Karina isn't a "bad" dancer, as whatever you may want to classify that. Judging by what we've seen now, she isn't absolutely incredible either, but honestly, in my opinion that's not much of a big deal. I'm sure that she improved over the course of the last year a lot and will continue to improve. Let's not judge too quickly, but let's also not blindly "defend" her skill when OP wasn't even really attacking her.
@Nia i didn't mean being rude. i'm just being honest.
@Nia i didn't mean being rude. i'm just being honest.
Taemin is a legend and her working with him so young just shows how even more phenonenal she will be in a few years
와 팬들 진짜 무섭고 역겹고 추하다.. 어리고 연습생이던 카리나가 이 영상에서 무엇하나 자기가 정할수 있는게 있었을까?? 하나하나 소중한 기회일때 소속사에서 시킨일 열심히 하는 죄로 카리나 욕하는거 진짜 너무 역겨움ㅋㅋ;;
나도 여기 댓글보고 아직도 90년대인줄 알았음ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋ
태민 팬 아님...난 샤이니 팬인데 너무 좋았는데...잘만하는데 왜...스엠에서 오랜만에 공개한 연습생이니까 관심 많이 받고 부러워서 안티들 생긴거임..샤이니 팬들은 별 말 없다고ㅠㅡㅠ
Her hair is lookin healthy even before debut❤️
에스파 카리나 짱! Congrats on your brand ranking rise in Feb! SM truly knows how to pick their centre.
Sehun in ur pfp what a king
Taemin you're so handsome
Gay
이분만 나오게 영상 편집하고 이분이름만으로 홍보하세요
4's generation dance machine, i really like this girl
So Karina had paired to the best of friends already (Kai and Taemin) What a lucky girl
Wait that was her? I was like "who this random chick" and ppl were saying its a trainee, and i wasn't sure about that, not knowing that it turns out to be aespa karina 💀😭
Karina y / n lives her life
AND NOW I CANT WAIT TO RELEASE AESPA EP 2 SMCU LIKE AAAAH
Is she a main dancer? She's not that really smooth or I'm just a little confused since she's dancing with Taemin?
Yeah she is and I am starting to doubt
i had the exact same thought omg
@neolovesneo bruh i was agreeing about how even great dancers look stiff when dancing with taemin bc the guy's like jelly when he dances
edit: and im sorry if it sounded like i was demeaning her skills
If she A main dancer Will be Big mistake Because these generation there's to Many Good dancer than him So maybe She is The main vocalist or main visual
@@yvonnecastillo1620 main vocalist is Ningning, while main rapper is rumored to be Giselle. i think she'll be the center and the FOtG since SM push her the most.. and maybe she's the main dancer.
I think those who hates her are the jealous ones, cause she is dancing with two kings and killing it. I know I'm right haha.
Agree!
They promote her the most why???
Cause she’s the face of the group.
Cause she's the "full-packaged" one? Just like how SM promoted RV's Seulgi & EXO's Kai.
Sorry but it’s may be because of her dad . She did bad things but SM protected her while SM didn’t protect about Irene while she didn’t make that mistake ( I mean Irene also human , so she can make that kind of mistake but Karina’s mistake is really a thing ) And I really hate SM ! Look how they did SM rookies girls, who waited 10 years for debut. I hate it so much
@@minniechu the issue about Karina was proven false tho.
@@yangyang1909 u know that money can make everything. Most of the Koreans know that Sm is protecting her and the case was actually truth. Just international fans didn’t know the truth
QUEEN
KARINA
It’s already killing
Damn first she dance with KAI now its TAEMIN! GURL u lucky one, LOOKING FORWARD FOR AESPA's debut! Since SM is hyping us and partnering a member even before debut to kai and taemin means a goodnews!
@Taelented oh i see ahaha thanks for the info
and now Aespa is very successful 🥰😍
This girl is a legend i love him
Omg queen KARINA
I'm just here for taemin no shade ❤❤❤
then go and watch his dance practice, you weirdo.
@@nonfiction7668 lol
Karinaaaaaaa ❤️❤️❤️❤️
People saying she is really stiff, they need to see her smooth moves. Actually in her solo teaser she portrayed very powerful moves and it somehow turned into a bit of stiffness. But no SM main dancer is untalented!
Her facial expression while dancing is so mesmerizing
Damnnnnnn she’s lucky, she danced with Kai and Taemin!!
So proud
love how suddenly everybody in this comment section is specialized in dancing... karina just debuted and she's getting so much hate and "criticism" (according to y'all) for no reason, give her a damn chance it's not the same thing to perform in front of trainers than a crowd she could be nervous bc she's not used to it ffs
also, many of these so-called "opinions" are plain rude and disrespectful, i swear people love to call it like that to get away with being rude nowadays
also i'm sure she's still a better dancer than most of the people commenting things like this :'))
like she wouldn't be a trainee if she was perfect from the beginning, so what do they want?
@@taenykook exactly!! sm wouldn't add her to the debut lineup if she wasn't well-trained
I think so Karina loves to dance with boys more,than girls ...👏😂🤣
bl0nk
Just here to see all the old comments claiming she's not a main dancer based off a 30 sec clip. Lol. Karina is a main dancer y'all. Go look at anyone of her fancams and stages. Y'all had such a hate boner for this girl. Anyway she's pretty and talented and will be successful~bye💜 Stan aespa. Stan Karina. Stan main dancers.
I kind of ask myself why does the cameraman did not focus on taemin but on Karina ???
but I still support Karina 😍😍
His hairrrrrrr 😍😍😍
Not comparing, but she has a Jennie vibe 👀 like Giselle and her both have a YG vibe idk, maybe its because of their charisma and innocent baby faces but imitating look 😂
They have kinda YG vibe but not that much..yeah Giselle has a swig vibe..I like YG songs and I am YG stan bcs of their swag rap and live singing..
Yeah, I hear ppl saying she’ll be the next IT girl like Nini. Not to mention it appears that SM favors her too, can’t wait for her debut
@@Denise-lg4mx When a company favors a member, you'd know they would be big when they debut. Looking at her visuals, she might be the next IT girl like Jennie 😊 4th gen best gg!
Definitely think she was a new version of Jennie ... but that's not a positive thing in my opinion. Dont like pouting, gloomy face expression.
@@shryseaauthornim454 Idk but karina looks cold
damn taemin danced with karina he's so lucky
What? 🤣 It's the other way around!!
@@safabn4528 i did it on purpose bc i'm a my HAHAHAHA
@@yjmnbluu your right he is lucky 🤭 look at her=😭 what she is like somehow was drawn and then made . She is pretty
That looks like the girl from that new SM girl group
.
.
.
.
.
.
I feel like I shouldn't have to say I'm joking, but there will definitely be that one person who actually thinks I'm not
ㅈㄴ 추하다 얘들아.. 니들은 스엠들어가지도 못하는데 왜 멀쩡히 있고 열심히 하는 카리나만 못물어뜯어서 난리냐ㅋㅋ 회사에서 하겟다는데 뭘 각상을 해라 꼴보기 싫다 ㅇㅈㄹ.. 얘네들도 홍보하고 알려야하는데 기존 있던 그룹이랑 같이 하는게 젤 무난하고 쉬운 방법아니겟냐? 진짜 회사 경영책가지고 남 물어뜯지좀마셈
쌉인정...너무 잘나서 안티가 많나...잘만하는데 왜...제니도 초반부터 지금까지 욕 오지게 먹고...그 칼군무 명가 스엠에서 메댄으로 세운 이유가 있겠지...
this is the dance practice room where aespa shoot their techwear ver of black mamba
I don’t get why they only promote her and when you look at their positions she got like ok of them she might be an all rounder for them but i don’t see the hype in her she looks like someone who might have talent but only would get far in life with the help of the right people and that’s what sm does she wouldn’t make it in a smaller company..yea they didn’t debut yet but I was never wrong with my assumptions towards idols and they always turned out to be right so..
yeah no I get you. She's not a good dancer AT ALL. This was awhile ago but her AESPA teaser with her solo dance and the promo vid with Kai was.... yeah not much improvement lol. Seeing her pre-debut singing videos, she does seem to have strong vocals. But then Winter is supposed to be a strong vocalist too and you have Ning Ning who's phenomenal as well.. so maybe that's why SM is trying to push her as the "dancer." Which I think is a terrible move considering she can't really "dance."
In all, she DEFINITELY caught the eye of Lee Soo Man somehow and that's why they're pushing exposure for her the most. It's very obvious that LSM plays favorites. It was the same/is the same for Kai for EXO and Taeyong for NCT. But at least those 2 can actually dance (particularly Kai). If anything, they should have made AESPA 5 members, with the 5th being a main dancer and Karina being the "visual center." (although IMO Ning Ning and Winter are prettier). Idk, this is going to be hard for Karina too because in no time, she is going to get more and more criticism for her dancing as SM keeps pushing her to be a dancer. So so strange though... SM usually finds great dancers like Kai, Taemin, Yunho, Eunhyuk, Seulgi, Hyoyeon, Yuri, Ten, etc... very peculiar why they are doing this lol.
@@minachoi1042 Seulgi auditioned to be a main vocalist though but her vocal chords had some problems thats why they push her into dancing
@@minachoi1042 you are pressed asf.. and for what lmfao??? why don't you go do something with your obviously very miserable life, you're pathetic asf dude sorry to break it to you.
SM gave their male artists like Kai, Mark and Taeyong more promo than their other members during predebut and yet they got no hate for it. Heck, Taeyong was even featured in a Red Velvet music video and no one got mad ffs. But now that they're doing the same thing to a woman it's suddenly favoritism? lol no they're doing it because she has the best stage presence in Æspa (whether you like it or not) and she'll probably be the center and/or face of the group. Just say y'all hate women and go
@@minachoi1042 lol she was dancing IN HEELS while dancing with Kai. Do you realize how hard it is to dance in heels while trying to keep up with Kai (arguably one of Kpop's best veteran dancers) at the same time? Probably not cause all you do is sit on the couch all day trying to discredit talented women in the internet. Not even the best dancers of Kpop (like Hyo and Seulgi) can dance all out in heels during their debut era. Dancing in heels take years to perfect. And it's even harder to try and dance in heels just as good as you'd dance without them. You haven't even seen Karina in her best yet and you're already writing whole ass essays about why she's "nOt ThAt TaLeNtEd" and how "sM iS bIaSeD tOwArDs HeR". Imagine being that bitter and talentless lmao
Here fir karina ♥️
OMG , SO MANY JEALOUSY HERE!
For those people who is saying that karina shouldn't be the main dancer, why is she so stiff? I know you guys loves to discriminate others but i just want to tell you that bashing other people doesn't make you great it only make you a horrible person, and for the issue about the conversation of karina and her friend* it is fake y'all. Well haters gonna hate lol. oh i forgot to say that i can clearly see why Karina is the main dancer.
C'mon SM, drop the TAEYONG X KARINA collab!
What song?
Karina perfect body
이때랑 지금이랑 얼굴 ㅈㄴ다름ㅋㅋㅋ
안다른 연예인이 어디있어요 다 관리 받는거죠 기분 나쁜댓글 달지마세요 이것도 다 악플입니다
어우 여기도 안티 잼민이가;;;
Taemin 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😤💖
Taemin looks so good
피지컬이랑 골격이 졷나구린데 왜데뷔시킴
존나 굽있는 하이힐신겨야지 비율 괜찮아질듯
엥 오늘뜬 무대영상 비율 미쳤던데 인간적으로 피지컬로는 까지말고 인성을 까자.... 피지컬로는 못깔거같음 태민옆에있으니까 키 작아보이는걸듯
@@user-dh8yw9eo5l 진심ㅇㅈ.. 이거보고 엥?? 이랬는데 뮤뱅뜬거보고 역시 스엠이구나 했음
에휴 ㅋㅋㅋ 깔 거로 까라 저 영상에도 좋기만 하구만 별 병신같은게 어유
선넘네 진짜 댓글들 ㄷㄷ
검은 사막 캐릭터 같이 비현실적으로 생겼는데 구리다니
yalls jealousy is showing
She's so lucky
Karina is a goddess
The fact this is only 36 seconds and garner 1M views.
YESSSS AESPA IS ALSO IN MY STAN LIST
KARINA QUEEN,TAEMIN KING
We saw it coming, this girl is a star
Months later. I feel like a clown