yeah you can. You base it on 3 categories. The players impact, The players ability to perform when its needed most and the consistency with talent of the player. :)
Gotta say that that clip was brilliant. A truly hard comparison. Both work so hard, Dusty is a better mark, in fact I was a better mark but Buddy is 6'6 tall. That is a huge advantage. Before you argue I love Buddy & am a Swans fan. Buddy is the best long goal freak probably even including Peter Hudson. Yeah I'm that old, in fact I used to watch Sergio Silvagni play. Both are incredible ground ball players but Dusty wins this one by a small amount. That Buddy is that good down low considering his height is a feature of his freak. I was 6'1, Dusty size but in those days the main tap ruck. I had leap factor but my ground skills sucked so I can only admire it in others. Dusty is in his prime, Buddy isn't so young anymore. I wondered if he should be playing in 2019. Management of injuries as you get older as they play havoc in your life after footy is not fun. Both of them are also very difficult to snag,
Mids and mid/forwards will probably pick dusty, key backs and forwards will pick franklin. Can't compare them, both one of a kind players that are definitely in the GOAT conversation
@@stealerknob3658 Are you Joking by even saying Joking. Buddy Franklin!!!! Watched the Game lately 😂😂😂 have you not seen 1000 GOALS HOMIE 😏😏😏😏😏 WE Aren't JOKING!!! Buddy a Living Legend 😊
Respect to buddy but there’s been a lot of finals where he has gone missing or not performed up to his regular season performance that just isn’t the case with dusty because dusty gets better in finals
Dusty the best in the big games that matter no doubt. But there are plenty of better home and away players (for consistency). Buddy being one of them, Danger another example
Both have different playing styles. Dusty plays as a centreman and also plays as a forward pocket. Dusty nullifies taggers and small defenders. Buddy plays CHF and FF and can also play the flanks and wings as he can do things that a man nearly 2 metres tall has no business doing. Both players are freakish, fearless and fearsome.
@@noahvaneck3949 Yes but Dusty didn't burst onto the scene like bud did he. Bud was a superstar the moment he started Dusty wasn't and don't give me drivvle about midfielders have to mature it takes a long time blah blah. It's the exact same with forwards.
Dustin Martin as Gary Ablett said not many people can beet him one and one. Dusty is just better that buddy thing of those goals and don’t argues he done. Dustys more powerful than buddy if there’s a game on the line.
Cmon. U can’t compare em. If I was picking at the moment, I’d say dusty, but overall careers, definitely buddy. Besides, Dangerfield is better than dusty anyway.
@@samscarlett6959 oh gawd another Disney 🤢 Danger has been electric since 2012. Dusty has been electric since 2017. Besides, it isn’t about the bloody accolades. And anyway, danger has 7 AAs, wheras dusty has had 3.
So if we are counting stuff here to decide who's greater. 3 + 3 + 1 equals 7. Hmmm, Buddy just accomplished 1000 Goals 12 days ago 😏😏😏😏 My intelligence is screaming buddy is the 🐐 no 🧢 bruh
an uninjured buddy franklin iseasily the best plsyer in the afl (maybe a few years ago). dusty definitely has weaknesses, its been shown this year that he can be tagged and practically made useless. there are tons of incredible midfielders, maybe not as good as dusty, but there arent enough incredible full forwards.
2017 grand final, adelaides whole game plan was dusty, they failed. Deboar tagged dusty in 2019, no one could break his tag and he just destroyed them. 2020 v geelong, you can see the attention he brings, they're all thinking about dusty every stoppage etc and he still dominated. He breaks tags..
Can we say that again please, a little louder over the SCG grounds. I can still hear that Sweet Sound of a thousand goals being Celebrated today even this fine morning 🤣🤣🤣 , Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
Dusty by a country mile. Franklin can mark and goal like a machine but not much better than Dusty. On the other hand Dusty’s speed, handling, football sense, ability to change an entire game on his own and ability to read play is superior to every other player in the AFL today by a long, long way. Dusty is easily better than Franklin.
@@sup5378 but i thought franklin was the almighty? Dusty has been top 7 in brownlow for 5 seasons straight plus the browblow got the most votes ever in the 3 2 1 format. Franklin is nothing compared to dusty he gets goals thats it?
In two years time, one of these players have barely played and the other has broken history and put his name in the conversation for the best player of all time.
Says the one sitting in an actual Ocean 😳 Girl bye# You'd be lucky to touch the boots of Buddy Franklin, but Actual I'd stand in your way because no way am I letting a left over meal like you get even close to a king's Shoes. You shouldn't be calling a GOAT washed up , when you actually need to get washed up you filthy af
Dustin Martain Over Rated. He is a superstar because he snaps right in front of goal and fends off. Franklin hooks too much. But he actually does a normal footy set shot! So Buddy Franklin
@@sup5378 pretty sure that's Dangerfield that gets all the clangers. 2017 Qualifying Final is a perfect example. Dusty tearing the game to shreds, whilst Danger can't even hit a target properly
@@sup5378 Dusty may average the most clangers, but the stats website says that Lance Franklin has THE most clangers in the history of Australian Rules Football
De Goey? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!! To mention De Goey in the same breath as Dusty is very disrespectful, considering De Goey isn't even half the player Dusty is
Franklin the most overrated player in in AFL history. I saw Peter mckenna , Peter Hutson , Lockett and Jason Dunstall play and Franklin doesn't come close to them. Even Ablett senior was much better. Modra was probably better as well.
Спорт
Both of them are good, Buddy the best forward in the last 20yrs, Dusty the best Midfielder/Forward in finals series of all time!
Hodge
@M 5-9 shush
Dustys good but not best finals player of all time lol
@@mattstudd1998 Cramps hey 🤣🤣🤣, sorry tho. But Buddy is the best Player of ALL TIME
You can’t have a answer for it because dusty is a on baller and buddy is a forward
Exactly. U could say dusty is better at contested footy and buddy is better at goal kicking.
Dusty is better
yeah you can. You base it on 3 categories. The players impact, The players ability to perform when its needed most and the consistency with talent of the player. :)
You can say dusty with Strength but buddy big contested mark forward and then go to bang with a goal
dusty is probably still a better forward
What cover of Paint it Black is this playing in the background?
the one from westworld
Gotta say that that clip was brilliant. A truly hard comparison. Both work so hard, Dusty is a better mark, in fact I was a better mark but Buddy is 6'6 tall. That is a huge advantage. Before you argue I love Buddy & am a Swans fan. Buddy is the best long goal freak probably even including Peter Hudson. Yeah I'm that old, in fact I used to watch Sergio Silvagni play. Both are incredible ground ball players but Dusty wins this one by a small amount. That Buddy is that good down low considering his height is a feature of his freak. I was 6'1, Dusty size but in those days the main tap ruck. I had leap factor but my ground skills sucked so I can only admire it in others. Dusty is in his prime, Buddy isn't so young anymore. I wondered if he should be playing in 2019. Management of injuries as you get older as they play havoc in your life after footy is not fun. Both of them are also very difficult to snag,
BUDDY ALL DAY
Dusty and it dosent matter how long the players have been playing for
Your mum's Chest Hair!!!
Dustin Martin
🤭🤣🤣🤣🤣 nooooo
Can’t chose great video and editing tho
Buddy
Mids and mid/forwards will probably pick dusty, key backs and forwards will pick franklin. Can't compare them, both one of a kind players that are definitely in the GOAT conversation
they are both unique both Sydney and Richmond need them but if i was to pick a favourite i would probably pick Buddy
Buddy Franklin
Nah dusty
Nah Buddy
Buddy one of the all time greats hard to go past his highlight real dustys still a freak though
Both good I would choose Buddy and every swans player would and every tigers player would choose Dusty
I believe that they are just as good as each other. Both can impact the game and help their teams win matches, especially Buddy.
After last week’s grand final, Dusty without a doubt.
After 12 days AGO. Buddy ALL CENTURY !!!
Or should I say , all millenium 🤗♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
Dusty 3 out of 4 grand finals plus 3 norm smith medals
Buddy for dayssss!!!
Ue joking?
@@stealerknob3658 Are you Joking by even saying Joking. Buddy Franklin!!!! Watched the Game lately 😂😂😂 have you not seen 1000 GOALS HOMIE 😏😏😏😏😏 WE Aren't JOKING!!! Buddy a Living Legend 😊
@@gladysugle8922 okay? by stats and achievments dusty is better
@@stealerknob3658 You're joking
Respect to buddy but there’s been a lot of finals where he has gone missing or not performed up to his regular season performance that just isn’t the case with dusty because dusty gets better in finals
Franklen every day
Buddy easy!
He plays like he’s playing rugby lol must be a kiwi in him ✊
His father is a Maori
Buddy all the way
Levi Calcott you are stupid
Buddy sucks
Dusty Sucks
Lance franklin to great
Commenting after the 2020 GF and I don't reckon this is even a valid question anymore. Martin has eclipsed every other player, both past and present.
Dusty the best in the big games that matter no doubt. But there are plenty of better home and away players (for consistency). Buddy being one of them, Danger another example
@Rhodes Manakis how so?
This is ridiculous 🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 you can't be serious can you🤭😳 🙏🏽 Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
Buddy. Obviously!
Both have different playing styles. Dusty plays as a centreman and also plays as a forward pocket. Dusty nullifies taggers and small defenders. Buddy plays CHF and FF and can also play the flanks and wings as he can do things that a man nearly 2 metres tall has no business doing. Both players are freakish, fearless and fearsome.
DUSTY ALL THE WAY, BUDDY CAN ONLY KICK GOALS 🖤💛🖤💛
The problem with that is there different players. Buddy is the best forward and Dusty is the best Midfielder
Wrong
Dusty isn’t the best midfielder
Dusty unstoppable
Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
Both of them..?
Dusty is the best AFL player hard to takel and don’t forget the don’t argue
"Lance Franklin been the most dominant force for the last 14 years " roughy. Can you say that about Dusty don't think so.
@The Man From Snowy River. in what way buddy is pretty fast 6 foot and moves like a midfielder.
yeah because dustys a midfielder 😂 if he played 100% of game time forward he would kick 50+ every season minimum
@@noahvaneck3949 Yes but Dusty didn't burst onto the scene like bud did he. Bud was a superstar the moment he started Dusty wasn't and don't give me drivvle about midfielders have to mature it takes a long time blah blah. It's the exact same with forwards.
Has lance won 3 norm smith medals ?
Case closed. Dusty is the GOAT
@@mandomercs7 has Dusty kicked 100 in a season ? Case closed
Buddy don't @ me
J Cole @
Nat Fyfe
Dustin Martin as Gary Ablett said not many people can beet him one and one. Dusty is just better that buddy thing of those goals and don’t argues he done. Dustys more powerful than buddy if there’s a game on the line.
🤔 *coughCough* Bs
I would be tom lynch
Dusty is more consistent :)
No buddy is
buddy
Now the best has to be bontenpellie
Dusty is the best 🖤💛🖤🖤💛🖤💛🖤💛
Dusty of course
Dusty best big game player for sure. September specialist
buddy takes by storm dusty has time off so but buddy has all of it long range and more
1 buddy 2 selwood 3 dusty 4 danger
Dusty for sure
Prime Buddy was a Demigod.
What about tippa
He is shit
He’s not very consistent
Tippa? Pops up once a year for a rundown tackle and a special goal (kind of like Eddie Betts). A massive downhill skier at best
Cmon. U can’t compare em. If I was picking at the moment, I’d say dusty, but overall careers, definitely buddy.
Besides, Dangerfield is better than dusty anyway.
Do you have severe brain damage because Dusty is so much better than Dangerfield it isn't even funny
@@mikeoxlong7959 this must be disneychannel18’s backup account 😂
@@sup5378 hhahahhah no way mate, wheres dangerfields premierships and normsmiths
@@samscarlett6959 oh gawd another Disney 🤢 Danger has been electric since 2012. Dusty has been electric since 2017.
Besides, it isn’t about the bloody accolades. And anyway, danger has 7 AAs, wheras dusty has had 3.
@The Man From Snowy River. Yes haha
Dustin
Buddy 100%
Dusty
Dusty no competition he is an all rounder not just a forward.
Buddy no competition
Buddy has no competition 😹😹😹 lol, The greatest of ALL TIME!! There will be no other ,
Dusty all the way 🖤💛🖤💛
Buddy by a bloody mile
Buddy easily
Dusty definitely
😂🙏🏽 Pffffffffft!!! BUDDY ALL DAY ALL WEEK ALL YEAR ALL MILLENIA
@@gladysugle8922 surreee believe what you want to believe
@@larakerr6421 Duh, why would I
Dusty everyday of the week....EAT EM ALIVE!!!
dast
I dont go for tigers but Dusty 🥇🏆🏅🎖🏈🏋️♀️😊🤙👍
Dusty any day
This topic is utterly redundant. 3 Normies, 3 Flags, 1 Brownlow, Dusty is the only reasonable and intellegent choice here.
So if we are counting stuff here to decide who's greater. 3 + 3 + 1 equals 7. Hmmm, Buddy just accomplished 1000 Goals 12 days ago 😏😏😏😏 My intelligence is screaming buddy is the 🐐 no 🧢 bruh
Nat Fyfe is good and young so that's great
He’s not that young haha
Bob the Builder
Damian Hardwick don,t coach Sydney swans
Every one says BUDDY FRANKLIN 😅😂🤣 GO SWANS
That’s like picking between my wife or girlfriend..........I’d say my girlfriend 🤔😂. If my wife’s reading this I don’t have a girlfriend bbz jokes mun
dusty matin
Martin way better
an uninjured buddy franklin iseasily the best plsyer in the afl (maybe a few years ago). dusty definitely has weaknesses, its been shown this year that he can be tagged and practically made useless. there are tons of incredible midfielders, maybe not as good as dusty, but there arent enough incredible full forwards.
2017 grand final, adelaides whole game plan was dusty, they failed. Deboar tagged dusty in 2019, no one could break his tag and he just destroyed them. 2020 v geelong, you can see the attention he brings, they're all thinking about dusty every stoppage etc and he still dominated. He breaks tags..
@@sebastianmacaulay5351 🤣🤭
@@sebastianmacaulay5351 please Bonnie. Take a seat now, Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
@@sebastianmacaulay5351 you're clearly not clear on the Fact that Buddy is the BEST PLAYER OF ALL TIME
Martian a god franklins good
Buddy Franklin is better
Dusty all the way
I would be eddie betts go crows
Still Eddie?
They all good player but come on people no body is better than buddy at goal kicking.
Buddy's done nothing in the last 2 years tbh I think he's past his prime
He’s been injured
Can we say that again please, a little louder over the SCG grounds. I can still hear that Sweet Sound of a thousand goals being Celebrated today even this fine morning 🤣🤣🤣 , Buddy the 🐐 no 🧢
Dusty Easley
I think Dustin Martin is the best player
Dusty is the GOAT
I'm sorry but Buddy has one of the best AFL moments of ALL TIME, you can't say anyone soon will ever top that not even Dusty.
Buddy Franklin the 🐐 no 🧢
Nic nat all the way...
Tammy Maskiell most overrated, overpaid & injury prone spud in the AFL
@@Drixa0 He is actually a very good player, he just got unlucky with 2 knee injuries.
Nic Nat is shit
old comment but if nic nat wasnt so injury prone he wouldve been so scary, when he was on and able to play he was a beast
Dusty by a country mile. Franklin can mark and goal like a machine but not much better than Dusty. On the other hand Dusty’s speed, handling, football sense, ability to change an entire game on his own and ability to read play is superior to every other player in the AFL today by a long, long way. Dusty is easily better than Franklin.
No way. Dusty has had 1 good season. Buddy has had like 10 good seasons
@@sup5378 where is his brownlow?
@@stealerknob3658 Brownlow is a midfielders award
@@sup5378 but i thought franklin was the almighty? Dusty has been top 7 in brownlow for 5 seasons straight plus the browblow got the most votes ever in the 3 2 1 format. Franklin is nothing compared to dusty he gets goals thats it?
@@stealerknob3658 U really have no clue. Most bias supporter ever.
Dustin martin
dusty by far
buddy needs to go back to the hawks
In two years time, one of these players have barely played and the other has broken history and put his name in the conversation for the best player of all time.
Mmm interesting
dusty has more in his locker he can kick goals and set up goals and run and carry. Dusty is better and Franklin has injury problems
And there was josh Kennedy
But buddy anyday dusty still good as it gets and im a Geelong supporter i should be supporting tomahawk
Buddy is washed up
Says the one sitting in an actual Ocean 😳 Girl bye# You'd be lucky to touch the boots of Buddy Franklin, but Actual I'd stand in your way because no way am I letting a left over meal like you get even close to a king's Shoes. You shouldn't be calling a GOAT washed up , when you actually need to get washed up you filthy af
Dustin Martain Over Rated. He is a superstar because he snaps right in front of goal and fends off. Franklin hooks too much. But he actually does a normal footy set shot! So Buddy Franklin
Dusty misses easy shots and averages the most Clangers per game OUT OF ANY PLAYER IN HiSTORY!!!
@@sup5378 pretty sure that's Dangerfield that gets all the clangers. 2017 Qualifying Final is a perfect example. Dusty tearing the game to shreds, whilst Danger can't even hit a target properly
@@mabiorcholappreciationpage that’s 1 game idiot
@@mabiorcholappreciationpage also, on the stats website, it even says dusty averages the most
@@sup5378 Dusty may average the most clangers, but the stats website says that Lance Franklin has THE most clangers in the history of Australian Rules Football
Dusty as much as I hate to say it I mean 2 brownlows 2 norm Smith's and 2 premierships
Premierships r a team thing. Would u seriously say Alex Johnson is better than Patrick Dangerfield because he has a premiership and danger doesn’t?
de goey new best player in the comp
De Goey? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!! To mention De Goey in the same breath as Dusty is very disrespectful, considering De Goey isn't even half the player Dusty is
@@mabiorcholappreciationpage ya legit got a vag
@@xmacmcintyre1262 De Goey's overrated, and that's a fact
For me I think Dusty Martin
No
Franklin the most overrated player in in AFL history. I saw Peter mckenna , Peter Hutson , Lockett and Jason Dunstall play and Franklin doesn't come close to them. Even Ablett senior was much better. Modra was probably better as well.
He’s still a bloody legend and he’s wayyyyy better than modra
Martin, he's more consistent in finals.
I’m a Sydney supporter and I still think Dustin martin is a lot better as buddy gives away too many frees and is always getting suspended
👎
Buddy
Buddy all the way
Dustin Martin
Dusty
Dusty all the way