I'm 52 and I'm beginning to understand this song and the video more and more and it touches every generation. It gave me as goosebumps and tears as did Lana del Rey's "Ride" despite it was sang from a female perspective.
This video hits even more when you realize June, Johnny's wife who is seen in the video, died 3 months later and Johnny died 4 months after her. The closing of the piano at the end, to me, symbolizes the end of life, like closing a coffin lid. The song itself, even Trent's version, is so powerful, but the video is heart wrenching.
Thank you for being so honest about this song and about the personal impact it has had on you. This broke me. It always breaks me. I have had no substance abuse problems, but I have ongoing mental health problems. These are problems that others cannot deal with and everyone goes away in the end! Everyday I struggle to find a reason to live with depression and borderline personality disorder.
Thank you for sharing this - I appreciate how difficult it can be talking about this stuff (mostly because I too struggle with mental health a lot). This song is absolutely gutting. I don't think I never really appreciated it until going through certain events. Honestly - at first I kinda hated these reactions. They were a fun bit of content at first, but then felt like a cheap grab at views. But the tide has turned a bit - listening to songs like this, sharing thoughts - it feels different now. More personal, more REAL. Anyway, I've gone on a bit there. It's quite hard having so many comments - which sounds odd. I mean, I've had an online presence for a while, whether on here or through streaming on Twitch, but after losing my best friend I've regressed a bit socially. So it can be quite overwhelming seeing SO many comments (I'll never complain though!), but seeing comments like this always make me feel a bit emotional. I appreciate always seeing your comments, the few who leave regular comments truly mean the world.
Young man, I’m in my 50’s and have watched this exact video HUNDREDS of times and I still get extremely emotional when I see it(including yours)so no need to apologize for what you feel. I can’t explain it exactly and I’ve watched many reaction videos of it to see if they pick up on something that can help explain why I react as I do. Thank you for doing this reaction. Someday I’ll have my answer. Peace
This is one of the most honest, visceral, and devastating performances I've ever seen. I'm gutted every time I watch it. Eva Cassidy is another artist whose singing will both amaze you and rip your heart out. She passed away in her early 30s, so there's not a lot of videos available. Check out the Live from Blues Alley videos. They're all amazing, but start with Somewhere Over The Rainbow. You won't be disappointed.
Can you believe that a 20 year old Trent Reznor pinned this masterpiece? It just blows my mind every time I hear this! How this very gifted kid back in the 90's could write a song that would be so profound in the life of Johnny Cash at the end of his life in 2004.
He died several months after this vid. His wife died 4 months before he did. He never opened the piano cover again from what I understand. His wife came down the stairs to check on him when the vid was made. So they kept that part in.
Thankyou, Very strong and very powerful piece of music its hard to keep a dry eye and you should never apologise for feeling emotional. there are a a number of pieces of music I feel which trigger strong catharsis and it is something I like in some of the music in my collection. For example coldplays album Parachutes such as Sparks and Trouble; Radio Heads Bends Album High and Dry, and Fake Plastic trees; Bright Eyes by Art Garfunkel; Sparklehorses Album Its a wonderful life: eyepennies and Sea of teeth; The Seatbelts/ Yoko Kanno: No Reply and Call Me Call Me; There was a single Called Meteorology by Mathew Jay
I agree - his final album is absolutely heartbreaking honestly. "Aloha Oe" always felt like his goodbye to the world, I can't listen to it without shedding a tear or two.
Excellent reaction to a very moving performance Could you react to Johnny cash When the man comes around one of his later songs and very powerful message about Judgement day
You sound like you know some of Johnny Cash’s history. It would be impossible to go through his body of work and not know that he believed in in the inescapable reality of Jesus. The song echoes the reality, though not intended in the original, the old saying that “Only one life, it will soon be passed, only what’s done for Christ will last.“ I believe he clearly knew, as all Christians do, and the video portrayed, that it was the sin of all who would believe in Jesus, including Cash, that he paid for with every strike of the hammer that nailed him to the cross. Thanks for the excellent commentary and heartfelt reaction.
We all have to let it out. If you want to be pointed toward a beautiful album, check out Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds Ghosteen ruclips.net/video/GwlU_wsT20Q/видео.html and also "Carnage" (why not all of them?) If you know Johnny Cash's American Recordings, then you have heard him sing The Mercy Seat, written by Nick. And they did a duet also "I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry".
I'll definitely check out that album! That's really cool that it's Nick Cave. I'm a big, big fan of The Mercy Seat! A beautiful song, and Johnny's deliverance is beautiful too. I also enjoyed I'm so Lonesome, not quite as much as Hank's recording - I was somewhat thrown off by Nick's vocals but not in a bad way - its hard to explain! I'll check it out :)
Many visual juxtapositions ... but the younger images interspersed with the old man at the end of his life are absolute stabs to the heart, especially as you yourself age. Watching your vital parents age, weaken mentally and physically and then seeing it begin in your own face in the mirror. The what-ifs, the hurts you have inflicted on others that can't be mended. Feeling like you have it all and then finding out that you have cancer at 42 as the universe laughs and laughs at your *plans*. This is a humbling song that calls you to task for every wrong decision you've made and reminds you to keep your priorities straight. Use it wisely and make the changes you need to make so the pile of regret doesn't get higher. It's quite a deep song and will hit everyone differently, depending on where you are in life. I think the images in the video are probably more relatable to those dealing with the aging and mortality issues, whether yours or someone close to you, but honestly? The "old souls" see it, even when they're young. However it hits for you - use it. Great analysis and thank you for sharing your emotion. ❤️
You seem somewhat young to have the kind of regrets that a singer does who used his time to build his music career only to release personal relationships are all that matters.
I'm 69...I'll tell you, the older you get, the more relevant the song becomes
........
I'm 52 and I'm beginning to understand this song and the video more and more and it touches every generation. It gave me as goosebumps and tears as did Lana del Rey's "Ride" despite it was sang from a female perspective.
Beautiful reaction. Thank you so much
Beautiful heartfelt reaction! ❤️
Can never listen to this without crying too. Thank you for your very personal response.
This video hits even more when you realize June, Johnny's wife who is seen in the video, died 3 months later and Johnny died 4 months after her. The closing of the piano at the end, to me, symbolizes the end of life, like closing a coffin lid. The song itself, even Trent's version, is so powerful, but the video is heart wrenching.
I am a 59 year old man who looks like cross between a Viking and Gandalf and this version of this song brings me to tears every time without fail
Thank you for being so honest about this song and about the personal impact it has had on you. This broke me. It always breaks me. I have had no substance abuse problems, but I have ongoing mental health problems. These are problems that others cannot deal with and everyone goes away in the end! Everyday I struggle to find a reason to live with depression and borderline personality disorder.
Thank you for sharing this - I appreciate how difficult it can be talking about this stuff (mostly because I too struggle with mental health a lot). This song is absolutely gutting. I don't think I never really appreciated it until going through certain events. Honestly - at first I kinda hated these reactions. They were a fun bit of content at first, but then felt like a cheap grab at views. But the tide has turned a bit - listening to songs like this, sharing thoughts - it feels different now. More personal, more REAL.
Anyway, I've gone on a bit there. It's quite hard having so many comments - which sounds odd. I mean, I've had an online presence for a while, whether on here or through streaming on Twitch, but after losing my best friend I've regressed a bit socially. So it can be quite overwhelming seeing SO many comments (I'll never complain though!), but seeing comments like this always make me feel a bit emotional. I appreciate always seeing your comments, the few who leave regular comments truly mean the world.
@@mr.smithgnrsmith7808 being a cunt isn't a good look.
Young man, I’m in my 50’s and have watched this exact video HUNDREDS of times and I still get extremely emotional when I see it(including yours)so no need to apologize for what you feel. I can’t explain it exactly and I’ve watched many reaction videos of it to see if they pick up on something that can help explain why I react as I do. Thank you for doing this reaction. Someday I’ll have my answer. Peace
This is one of the most honest, visceral, and devastating performances I've ever seen. I'm gutted every time I watch it.
Eva Cassidy is another artist whose singing will both amaze you and rip your heart out. She passed away in her early 30s, so there's not a lot of videos available. Check out the Live from Blues Alley videos. They're all amazing, but start with Somewhere Over The Rainbow. You won't be disappointed.
Very good and empathetic reaction!
I cried....
To fit all that emotion into a 5 minute video is absolutely amazing
Can you believe that a 20 year old Trent Reznor pinned this masterpiece? It just blows my mind every time I hear this! How this very gifted kid back in the 90's could write a song that would be so profound in the life of Johnny Cash at the end of his life in 2004.
He died several months after this vid. His wife died 4 months before he did. He never opened the piano cover again from what I understand. His wife came down the stairs to check on him when the vid was made. So they kept that part in.
It's heartbreaking that this was the last time he closed the piano. It's even more heartbreaking to hear that he died of a broken heart.
great song. Love to you
Thankyou,
Very strong and very powerful piece of music its hard to keep a dry eye and you should never apologise for feeling emotional. there are a a number of pieces of music I feel which trigger strong catharsis and it is something I like in some of the music in my collection. For example coldplays album Parachutes such as Sparks and Trouble; Radio Heads Bends Album High and Dry, and Fake Plastic trees; Bright Eyes by Art Garfunkel; Sparklehorses Album Its a wonderful life: eyepennies and Sea of teeth; The Seatbelts/ Yoko Kanno: No Reply and Call Me Call Me; There was a single Called Meteorology by Mathew Jay
...Hard... hard!
Thank you for sharing your reaction.
Great reaction ❤️
I think it was his gift to us at the end of his life. A warning to take care of addictions as soon as possible don't let it grow. Cheers
I agree - his final album is absolutely heartbreaking honestly. "Aloha Oe" always felt like his goodbye to the world, I can't listen to it without shedding a tear or two.
Nice review.
If this video ever fails to choke me up, just bury me.
Thank you for taking my recommendation! So many emotions in this song and video.
"13" by Johnny Cash written by Glen Danzig. Live video
I am a new sub and I really like your channel and how you present your thoughts and reactions. Continue to keep it real! Thank you.
Excellent reaction to a very moving performance
Could you react to Johnny cash When the man comes around one of his later songs and very powerful message about Judgement day
Absolutely! I love a good song relating to Judgement Day. I'll get to it ASAP!
@@alsvinylcollection
thx Al this song is based on the Book Of Revelations I'm sure you will love this
You sound like you know some of Johnny Cash’s history. It would be impossible to go through his body of work and not know that he believed in in the inescapable reality of Jesus. The song echoes the reality, though not intended in the original, the old saying that “Only one life, it will soon be passed, only what’s done for Christ will last.“
I believe he clearly knew, as all Christians do, and the video portrayed, that it was the sin of all who would believe in Jesus, including Cash, that he paid for with every strike of the hammer that nailed him to the cross.
Thanks for the excellent commentary and heartfelt reaction.
Try James Blunt “Monsters” Beautiful song and story behind it.
We all have to let it out.
If you want to be pointed toward a beautiful album, check out Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds Ghosteen ruclips.net/video/GwlU_wsT20Q/видео.html and also "Carnage" (why not all of them?)
If you know Johnny Cash's American Recordings, then you have heard him sing The Mercy Seat, written by Nick. And they did a duet also "I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry".
I'll definitely check out that album! That's really cool that it's Nick Cave. I'm a big, big fan of The Mercy Seat! A beautiful song, and Johnny's deliverance is beautiful too. I also enjoyed I'm so Lonesome, not quite as much as Hank's recording - I was somewhat thrown off by Nick's vocals but not in a bad way - its hard to explain! I'll check it out :)
Many visual juxtapositions ... but the younger images interspersed with the old man at the end of his life are absolute stabs to the heart, especially as you yourself age. Watching your vital parents age, weaken mentally and physically and then seeing it begin in your own face in the mirror. The what-ifs, the hurts you have inflicted on others that can't be mended. Feeling like you have it all and then finding out that you have cancer at 42 as the universe laughs and laughs at your *plans*. This is a humbling song that calls you to task for every wrong decision you've made and reminds you to keep your priorities straight. Use it wisely and make the changes you need to make so the pile of regret doesn't get higher. It's quite a deep song and will hit everyone differently, depending on where you are in life. I think the images in the video are probably more relatable to those dealing with the aging and mortality issues, whether yours or someone close to you, but honestly? The "old souls" see it, even when they're young. However it hits for you - use it. Great analysis and thank you for sharing your emotion. ❤️
The smashed Columbia record on the floor represents them dropping Cash from their label.
Janis Joplin "work me lord" Stockholm 1969
He did Glastonbury. Watch that.
Can you do Nirvana at some point?
Nirvana are a group I'm really interested in learning about! Teen Spirit is the only song of theirs I know, so it would be cool to hear the others :)
@@alsvinylcollection Their Man Who Sold The World cover might be a good place to start before diving into the really grungy stuff
You seem somewhat young to have the kind of regrets that a singer does who used his time to build his music career only to release personal relationships are all that matters.
Im so glad..i.found your reaction like you i no ..the pain and loss.keep.strong.zDebra.WalesUk
you should check out a band called yes very talanted band one of thebest that ever was