11 Ways to Raise Titanic but Only 1 May Work
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 июл 2021
- How can the Titanic be reached? 🛳 How to raise the Titanic? This emblematic ship would be a great museum if we managed to but it on solid ground. Many schemes have been proposed to raise the Titanic: huge magnets, an enormous hook, even millions of Ping Pong balls to fill it in. What else? Recovering the Titanic isn't easy but might be possible...🤩
Read more:
brightside.me/articles/11-way...
#brightside #titanic
Animation is created by Bright Side.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music by Epidemic Sound www.epidemicsound.com/
Subscribe to Bright Side : goo.gl/rQTJZz
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our Social Media:
Facebook: / brightside
Instagram: / brightgram
5-Minute Crafts RUclips: www.goo.gl/8JVmuC
Stock materials (photos, footages and other):
www.depositphotos.com
www.shutterstock.com
www.eastnews.ru
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For more videos and articles visit:
www.brightside.me/
Our App bit.ly/3a4dTr5 - Хобби
Hey there! When was the last time you watched the movie ‘Titanic’?
Always
Titanic is a Legend that will wither away with time its a graveyard of the sea
3 days ago
Mop
Today
From what I have heard the Titanic is so delicate from being underwater so long that any tricks to raise it would probably cause it to fall apart.
Yeah if there was any chance to raise it that was within the first few decades it sunk and best case scenario it would have been seen as a lost cause as scrapped
Hi I love you
@@SuperGamefreak18 thank you so much for your reply. It was already broken in half when they first found it, so I don’t think that they would have been able to lift it up even after it happened.
@@fortnight8406 thank you so much for your reply and kind words. 👍
@@SuperGamefreak18 could they raise the britannic?
Two problems: First, it’s a mass grave. Second, it’s been down there for more than a century. It’s very nearly reclaimed by nature at this point. You try to move it, it could very well fall apart. Memory serves, there have been incidents where well-meaning tourist expeditions have in fact damaged the wreck.
Most of these ideas are silly anyway.
that's stilll ok. they can be joined back once they are at the surface
I dont think there are any well meaning tourist expeditions . Damage to the mainmast was almost certainly done by a submarine hitting it whilst trying to get to the crows nest telephone .
yeah thats why bright side kept saying “mission failed” as there would be no way you can bring the ship up
Whats the problem of it being a mass grave? I mean We are literally stepping on soil that has once had the presence of our anscestors not to mention people spread ashes in the Ocean.
Just a pile of rust at this point, no way It can be recovered, and not worth It, still nIce to see the many items being currently saved
This titanic task keeps getting more and more unlikely. I think Robert Ballard in the 90’s q(the man who discovered the wreckage) was asked if the ship could be brought up. He said the ship was in bad shape and decades of being underwater didn’t help. Couldn’t imagine over a hundred years later after the sinking would help.
You're right, the 2019 expedition to the wreckage showed that it was decaying at a much faster rate than before. The ship would entirely crumble if they even attempted any of these.
Ballard did not find it alone -- he had help
@@Chuck0856 do tell.
@@Znop yes but it will anyway because the microorganisms at that dept are quickly eating away the steel.
it was discovered in '85 not the 90s
"The ship is its own memorial. Leave it there."
-- Eva Hart, Titanic survivor
Also the ship is too deteriorated to raise even if we could work around the moral problems with raising her
Exactly, it's a grave yard. Idk why people would want to take a graveyard
@@TheRockefellas I agree
@@MilesModelWorks agreed. lets raise britannic instead
But if we leave it there, bacteria will make it disappear and there won’t be any wreck site left to act as a grave.
And there won’t be anymore graveyard
It's no doubt too rotten to withstand being moved around, especially with all the water pressure in it and around it
Ya...
That is probably true, I believe it will be entirely gone in 15 years
The bacteria is eating the ship
Why can't they just rebuild it
@@ReaderDokja why should they?
These theories are, in theory, possible. They’re just not possible in practice 😂
But seriously, they’re really cool
Lol u said theories and possible 2 times
Bruh get a profile picture
@@begula3922 leave him alone
@@begula3922 that person maybe doesnt want to change it ur not his boss to say what he/her needs to do
@@Daanish_YT you're correct
It didn’t sink right next to the iceberg like that. It actually went about two miles at a steady pace before sinking, and the forecastle was way more submerged. Plus, it didn’t snap in half like that, the front end was so submerged that the pressure pulled it apart, the front half fell incredibly fast pulling the back down with it almost vertically, the front snapped off of the back leaving it there to bob for about 30 seconds before it started flooding and sank, once the ship snapped in half, it only took around 2 minutes for the whole titanic to be underwater, leaving most passengers to float in their life vests and die from hypothermia, they drowned and froze together in a big group in the pitch black, middle of the sea. Absolutely terrifying
You’re kidding!!! We all thought the titanic sank in one piece and everyone was inside. 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
There no concrete evidence that supports that but some witnesses stated and testified that the ship split at the surface and no matter if it did or didn't because witness testimony is all the best information we have.
@@insertnamehere313 what about the deep sea subs that found and photographed the two sections?
@@insertnamehere313 yah I agree it split in half in the surface
What do you expect it’s brightside
I think the best option is the most obvious one (and the simplest). Build a floating donut-shaped island (not as difficult as you might think) and attach many many strong cables to the most sterdy parts of the ship, spreading them out across as much of the surface area of the ship as possible. Then slowly turn winches to pull it to the surface. Now, the problem with this is the ship is likely fragile from being under water for over a century and may break apart. But barring that likelihood, this is probably the best option.
The theory of ice an millennium sounds like the best idea tbh
One thing I WISH to happen but will probably never happen is to see the wreck of the titanic wreak raised and preserved in a museum
Maybe if they mapped out the wreckage and brought it up in pieces, then reassembling it later. Could be the only possible way to preserve it, since it’s quickly being eaten away by the sea, if not it’ll be gone within the next couple decades maybe less
@@sueydakillaboo you said the same comment twice.
Imagine how large the museum would have to be
Unfortunately the best way to do so would be to make a exact 1 for 1 size and scale replica of the ship JUST to make a museum.
@@Orcaluv26 a guy in Australia is having one commissioned in China called titanic 2 set to sail from America to England this year
Salvagers: Raising the Titanic is impossible!
Bright side: *step aside nubs*
The Titanic won't be brought back ... because its sinking was part of an insurrance scheme ... and the authors grabbed a few billions (in today's money). So, their succesors are powerful enough ... in order to keep the "mistery" intact. 😏
you do know this is a joke
Sery
@@laurentiutrifan8173 lol prove it 40 year old who still lives with there mum while playing League of legends
Haha🤣
4:15 "3, 2, 1, stahp."
That honestly killed me
As cool as it would be to raise the Titanic and save it, but we have to remember that the wreckage is also a grave site. So many people died inside of it.
But if we leave it there, bacteria will make it disappear and there won’t be any wreck site left to act as a grave.
@@swigglyforce5215 So, let it be. It's the same when we put our family members coffins after they die. After a while, they turn into dust. Are we going to disturb it? No.
@@mattbernabe Eh, I must ask, are you okay with us digging up King Tuts grave?
@@QuanxSolutions My point is people don’t seem to make it that big of a deal when ancient Egyptian remains are dug up.
@@bryananthony8822 u feel like they shouldn't raise it either since it's disrespectful
Bright side : 11 Ways We Can Raise Titanic
Scientist's : OH WRITE THAT DOWN WRITE THAT DOWN!!!!!!!
Nice one bruv
Yeah I’m a scintest I just writed down
@@elmundoderobinyloslegos1863 Scientist*
scientists would probably say that the IQ of the writers at bright side are below that of a goldfish
It will be historic if it is possibly happens.
Yeah
Indeed
Indeed
All of these theory’s wouldn’t work, don’t you know the state of the titanic?
💯💯
My idea was to build a giant dome around the titanic and filter the water out.
Cool but how do you dig undert Titanic?
@@bartosz7706 it would be more of a half dome that holds an air pocket
@@legodeathstarproductions5513 Hello, with all the respect, but how do you prevent it from imploding?
I don't think the makers of this video don't really realise how deep the wreckage actually is.
they know, they just want the add revenue.
@@Dani-xz1uw Correct, and they probably don't even care about research either. lol
12,500 feet according to my knowledge maybe a little more than that!
@@SurroundedByClowns1926nearly 4km beneath Ocean surface
It’s more than a couple miles deep for sure.. This video was absolutely ridiculous😂 and pretty much pointless
The only solution is to build a time machine to travel back in time and save the titanic with everyone in it.
I just got back from the pass
They already have that technology. But there is no point in doing that. It could do untold damage to the Future beyond The Day of the sinking. It could change the lives of people all over the world in our present time..
@@MrCyclejay1967 yeah it's very impossible
@@edricblight4388 . Yes I agree with you.
Ronald Mallett can do that he is building a time machine
Love the comments but here’s the thing. Whether maritime law applies or not is pointless to argue because as the video shows, it’s difficult and none of these ideas would work. Second, someone commented someday someone will think of a way for it to be raised, but it might not even last that long. The 2019 visit to the wreckage showed that the sea life is eating and corroding the wreckage at a fast rate. The estimated that in 30 years, the wreckage would be completely gone. So if someone does think of something, they need to do it quick before the wreckage disappears.
Actually they said that it would last probably 20 years
coudl they raise the britannic instead
It will never happen.
They will never be able to save the titanic
That’s not according to Parks Stephenson. He was quite surprised to see she looked the same for the most part other than the Marconi rooftop is in bad shape along with the captains quarters. Other than that there’s not been a great deal of change to the wreck I since 2010
I think that physically, the most realistic way to raise the Titanic is to dismantle it, deck by deck and retrieve individual steel pieces to the surface so they can be treated chemically and reassembled somewhere else with the help of a separate supporting structure, like the bones of a dinosaur.
It's not possible. Dismantling rusted ship is huge manual work. If you get out of your submarine somehow, you will be killed by the water pressure
@@neog3461They could deploy underwater robots for this task
For goodness sake leave her alone.
Does anyone remember the 1970's movie, "Raise the Titanic", where they supposedly did just
that and towed it to New York Harbor? Unfortunately, at that time, they were not aware that
the Titanic had broken into two pieces and could not have been brought to port intact! It's
a great idea, but no longer practicable! p.s.( I have touched one of the steel plates of the
ship when it was on display in Atlantic City & also own a piece of anthracite from the ship!)
Long live Dirk Pitt! The novel by Clive Cussler was printed in 1976 and the movie made in 1980. You're right that the premise being the ship was intact.
I love both of them there awesome I own them both
I saw that movie when i was a kid i thought it was real
What's interesting is that they had ignored surviving witnesses for so long who said they saw the ship breaking in half.
That probably wasn't based on true story.
One or the other day, a technology will come and Titanic will be raised
True
@@jaydenfrom7124 Might be but before 2100
but it shouldn't and can't out of respect for the died
@@jaydenfrom7124 Yes ur correct
@@jaydenfrom7124 do u play roblox
I think the titanic deserves its own under water museum 🤔
Gud idea instead of messing up and taking it the best idea
I agree with u
nice idea.. unfortunately its just to far down.. .and the cost would be astronomical... not to mention how incredibly dangerous and costly a visit would be.
That ship is huge, it's not going anywhere. But the next best thing would be to preserve it where it's at.
Terraform the whole area around it. Perhaps in the future we can bring it up from the depths.
If anyone does this I want full credit.
There was a point and click adventure game with this exact same concept except they built a huge museum around it with the ship being the centerpiece. You werent allowed to enter it due to it being super unstable but they cleaned the rusticles off it so it wouldnt deteriorate further. A possibly feasible concept in reality
Due to rust bacterias, in a few decades there is no more ship left
Sadly that won't happen the ship will last for only 20 more years
I've always thought the one way to do it would be to manufacture a large box like container. It could be lowered in 2 sections & placed on either side of the wreck. Then once in place could somehow be attached at the top & bottom, allowing the ship to remain intact on the trip up.cables, airbags whatever would attach to the outside of the box. This way nothing would be lost during ascension
A large box container about 600mx600m (1800 ft) in size you mean? You would need a large number of big freight containers, like the Evergreen or Maersk, that would be able of carrying such huge containers, and to such a depth of 3.8km (2.5 miles). Not to forget, to carry that large amount of water and sediment too. Unless, you're able to drain the box and keep the ship, remains and sediment it is stuck in intact.
It could maybe be a cage type of box but yes highly unlikely
Hm. Still, the problem of water pressure remains.
@@clarab6092 I'm not sure that would be a factor as no oxygen would be present inside the box or outside since it captures the water that would currently be surrounding the ship.
This of course would be slowly drained once the box that captures the ship reaches the surface. There may be however a temperature variation which causes an imbalance in pressure as the cold water from the ocean floor reacts to the warmer water close to the surface.
I think BRIGHT SIDE is titanic obsessed .. just like me ❤️
And me
And meh
Same when i was 6
@@trungmaximlowqualitygaming9427 wow
And me haha
Solution:
We just cut into pieces that are salvageable. We use sub drones to pick up each piece. And then we capsulize each piece so that way it is protected from the water pressure upon the ascent to the surface. It would cost ALOT of time and money but it is honestly the easiest and most time efficient way of recovering the ship.
I think(!) the Cussler book suggested using basically liquid urethane foam, carried in pressure-stable containers to the wreck, nozzle inserted directly into spaces that weren't structurally compromised but very vented to let water escape, and open the foam tank valve. Do that in EVERY resealable space, attach the inflatable aluminum tanks on the outside of the hull, and plant the charges in the mud and silt to break the Horrendous suction. That was "supposedly " enough the break her free and the foam inside, with the floatations bags outside, would raise the wreck.
But now, with the hull in three major pieces, plus enough minor chunks that even a metal detector couldn't find them all, and the rusticles competing with the iron-eating bacteria for who will digest the hulk first - she's down, she's staying down, and it doesn't matter, because Byzanium isn't real anyway.
Unlike the titanic Constantinople will be retaken
Rusticles are the visible results of the iron eating bacteria down there. I noticed that Bismark does not have rusticles since she is made of steel.
This person is smarter than people trying to find it-
Ikr
I think they found new ways Nd he told them here just for information.
@Mb yea it’s a team
he really isnt though..
@@fjdiiekenrososiejjrjdkd he just googled lol I mean the team
We bigfoots never get on ships designed by humans
Bigfoots?
@@Daanish_YT It would only be big feet if I was talking about my feet specifically
The Red Army 7th division is coming to show The bigfoots who's The boss
“11 ways to raise titanic but only one may work” *doesn’t tell us which one will might work*
The Titanic is impossible to raise. The HMHS Britannic, her sister ship, however...
The titanic can’t be raised legally, even if was possible, due to international maritime law as it’s a protected maritime graveyard / resting place of the deceased.
Smart
@@Kitty-dt2fl yes
@@Kitty-dt2fl He just googled it.
@@shamekh5 lol
That’s right
Nothing is impossible, we thought going to mars was impossible shortly after the moon
True but they need to build a space station there first there is no form of oxygen there what there is is water so there could possibly be creatures we will never know until they do more research cuz what they done now is only send a robot there but they didn’t explore it themselves
Titanic deterioration and state(health adding to the bacteria, rusticles.. the only way to truly get it out is by pieces.
@@alan_decker yea
Yeah....but we still haven't gone to Mars and the Apollo landings were 52 years ago!!
@@anthonylowder6687 you here after a month this video is here XD But it is possible maybe not in the time u expected but could be anytime
If it's even possible I'd love it if they could take a massive wide angle shot of the ship/wreckage site. It'd be cool to see a full picture of the ship at the bottom of the ocean.
There are full pictures of its wreck
@@adilmuneer3135there’s none
😢😮❤❤❤❤❤😢😢😢
By the time there's a viable option that could actually bring it up, it will have already be far beyond being worth the trouble. It will be gone within 2-3 decades anyway from now. People also theorize that there may still be bodies kept preserved inside deeper parts of the ship such as the engine room and inside the radio room where there hasn't been any animals able to eat the bodies and extremely cold water has kept the remains preserved like a freezer which is why the wireless radio was never recovered, as it's possible as soon as you open the door you would find remains. Leeave the ship alone, film what you want while she's still here, and let it go.
Not animals but bacteria can enter any closed spaces and rot away the bodies.
The bottom of the ship would be deep into the seafloor. It'd be like a huge suction as it was being pulled up, plus the weight of the water over it. Much of it is rotting away, and it is in two halves. Both would have to be raised to complete the ship. And where would it be taken to, if both halves were successfully raised? It sure wouldn't look as it did in 1912.
But it would really be interesting to try and see the damage done by the iceberg.
But it isn't just two pieces. It actually broke into 3 sections, the middle section scattered over the debris field.
@@daviniarobbins9298 yah
Well, of course it would be in several parts, but you could put them together in one place (with small gaps in between) in a museum, rather than placing them 600 metres away, as they are now on the sea bottom. But that's only an academic question, because there seems to be no reasonable raising technology and option. But it would be great to have a complete 1:1 copy of the Titanic in a museum, which would be in like new shape.
Make air bags that can withstand the pressure tie them around the titanic and wait for it to come up
I have one more Idea: You know how the pillars of bridges are made? The place Pillars will stand is covered with Concrete blocks and then water is pumped out, same can be done here, but the pressure will be the issue
Kevlar bags 50 meters long? Air should be pumped from top to bottom.
you cant do that its in to bad of a state
I have an idea just leave it be
Well you have to cover the holes numb nuts
We would probably have to test it first. Maybe build a scale model of the wreck site to be as realistic as possible. Then use different methods of raising it to see which one is feasible.
The only problem is the tests would be tedious... After we raise the model it might fall apart (if we make it as realistic as possible) so to test it again we would have to stick it back together like when James Cameron was filming the ships breakup scene.
this is more an issue of not that we can't do it but why should we? think about it it's like digging up a corpse why would you want to do such a thing?
@@raven4k998 I never said we should, actually. Raising the titanic would be a bad idea, as almost a thousand people died on the ship. I was merely stating how we'd do it, which is basically "we don't know so better test ways first". Raising the titanic is also impossibly impractical
Wont work because the model need to be down there for 110years before to test it
And you need to simulate water pressure at those depths (12,700ft) which is enough to turn a freight train into an aluminum foil sheet...
@@ayoutubecommenter1827 I guess the problem with testing raising the titanic is that we'd have to do it at the bottom of the ocean which defeats the purpose of testing it
Hey bright Side,for the ping pong ball idea,you might need titanium for the outside of the ping pong balls+titanium is a type of metal that has a ton of lightweight but is really strong.
None of it will work. As soon as the wreck is lifted it will disintegrate into pieces. All metal has been gnawed at by metal eating bacteria for a century. Raising it would have been possible before 1940, but no longer now.
Bro, leave that grave yard alone. Leave those souls to lie in their final resting place. Its not necessary to raise that vessel. leave em be!
She will dissapear in a few years if She's left alone, something must be done to either raise or preserve the Titanic
It would be easier to recover britannic 🙄
@@thezootopiahusky Let those who perish be left alone..
@@karlohaze5304 Hey dude, how do you get the emogees on your replies?
@@free-birdrocker8809 then in just a few years, the last proof of Titanic's existence will disappear, and in a few decades or centuries they would begin to question if the Titanic disaster was real or just a legend that was spread to everyone.
Something must be done to either raise or rescue the titanic
I got a better idea, how about if we drain the entire Atlantic Ocean and then just take a big crane to pull the ship up?
😀😀😀😀😀😀😸😸😸😸😸
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌👌
Almost all talk about titanic but almost nobody talk about her sister ship who suffered the same fate 😔
the HMHS was sunk by a mine over four years later in November 1916, two differences being 1.The Britannic is only 400 feet down and two she's in the Aegean Sea off of Kea Island
The big problem is that the water pressure down at the bottom of the ocean is extreme. Also, Titanic is buried in sand and in very poor shape as it is being eaten by bacteria called rusticals, so if we tried to lift it, Titanic would fall apart. Since we cannot lift Titanic, if only we could find a way to preserve her before she is gone
Would love to see a "If the world didn't use money" video!!
I wish
@@reesetube Yeah haha!!
You must be just as broke as I am.
how about we temporary remove all the waters in the ocean?
better leave the wreck where it is but find ways to clean it with under water robots that would clean the hull and paint it with an anti fouling paint so it preserves it for longer, find ways to support the deck for it collapsing further. keep it as a underwater memorial to those who died on it don't take anything up from the site again.
Whats amazing is for me to see Bright Side using 3D animation throughout the entire video.
Who else wants to go in titanic for all the loot over there😂
Count me in 🤣
After 8-10 seconds of consideration my answer is yes
Only Loki fans will get it
Lol
And my answer is yes and loot some piece of wood and sell it for 1.1 Septillion dollars
@@arjun2302 ok im a loki fan but dont get it?
Pirate.
I would try using multiple hooks around the perimeter of the ship's bottom, then thread steel cables from one side to the other then use a fleet of hot air balloons to raise it up. Its easier to manage things from the surface. If it takes adding another balloon each month to get enough lift then do it. But the process can be slow and methodical so you can get it out without damaging the ship.
What makes people think the ship wouldn't fall apart if you tried to move it?
It is not a matter of "Can we raise the Titanic", but rather "If we should raise the Titanic."
I remember hearing (and agree) that the Titanic is like a grave site or last resting place for all those who did not survive.
Exactly. I wouldn't want to bother with those poor souls
People who died in a car crash or a plane did they leave the planes or vehicles there because it’s like a grave site for all those who did not survive?
@@melb.1906
What I'm implying is that the souls that died in the Titanic have been laying there for over a century.
So, how I see it, raising the Titanic would be like up-earthing an entire grave yard.
The reason why car and plane wrecks are cleaned up and bodies are taken away is because; the wreck is usually a hinderence for everyday life, and the family of the deceased person usually would want to bury them.
@@melb.1906 yup
I hope this happens in real life I’m a big titanic fan
Haha i can tell
Me too
it could be so large but not so large than cruise ships for our time
“11 ways to raise the titanic, but only one way is even remotely close to being a way to raise the titanic”
No one should even consider raising Titanic! She would crumble if an attempt was made to raise her!! Leave her where she is, resting peacefully at the bottom of the Atlantic ❤️
Great video, love your facts bright side😍🤗
I'm just fascinated of how frequent they upload
It's a massive company 2ith tons of people working on lots of video s at once
Now if they wanted to bring it up they should have thought about that back in 1912
The technology wasnt the same 110 years ago like it is today. There wasnt any thing around then of what is here now. I agree in theory.
I love your channel keep up the great stuff!
Not to sound rude or start an argument but I dont understand why scientists and explorers keep messing with history. That ship is the final resting place of the deceased. So y'all just need to leave that ship alone and stop giving people ideas. Just like how people thought it was okay to take mummified pharaohs out of their tombs, this is not okay.
Very true so basically what ur trying to say is the past is the past
In Titanic case.. its going to disappear soon,.,., Raising the Titanic is a great idea... Titanic obsessed people like me... Why wouldn't u raise it .. u be crazy.. but anyway its impossible
So true even Dora wouldn't be that much of a explorer
Even tho she is blind pro max 🤣🤣🤣
U know if someone take Titanic out and put it in museum next hundreds of generations can witness it and they make billions out of it
@@nagasai5029 all y'all trying to do is make money off of this like leave it alone.
Please do a face reveal! I’ve been watching you for like 3 years now, and I’ve always wondered how you looked like
Type into Google: " brightside face reveal " and you will see his face ... he looks a little bit like bill gates... hope this helps
The account is run by a company, not one person
Wait a minute! What if we put a giant plate under the seafloor where the ship is and then lift it up?
the plate would have to be incredibly strong with multiple layers. a ship pulling up this weight would need to be strong enough to hold a large slab and what's left of the titanic. you'd have to push a colossal surface area (probably in km) up to the surface, which the very high pressured water will definitely resist; there might not be any ship strong enough to carry out this task. also, if your slab lists too much, titanic would fall off. let's not forget the incredibly high pressures of water you are building in, and these pressures that you'd pull the slab through would probably cause implosions. theres no way this could work
So, I’m other words, it’s impossible. I like the freezing idea. The Titanic is too rusted and fragile to lift. The question is why would anyone want to?
I wish I could be smart like him but I luv him he knows everything almost
No he Doesn’t he just says things he googled everyone can do that
He did an intensive research about the topics.
@@Daanish_YT probably
@@nikobellicph1978 maybe who knows
It's soo hard to rise the Titanic due to the international law
And the deterioration of the titanic.
It would be like raising a wet paper maché.
hey! i have an idea!
leave it alone. its literally a maritime graveyard.
it'd just be easier to build a replica as a floating hotel or something.
To be honest, it won't be raised, sadly, it's just to big,heavy,and weak because it's to damaged and bulky, it would be better to just not risk breaking the wreck
(My opinion)
It's been down there so long that it would disintegrate as soon as it hit the air
For all of them, The R.M.S Titanic is way to delicate.
It’s not possible guys .No way this ship can be brought up after being under water for 100+ years . It’s obviously so delicate that just by moving it slightly from the ocean floor it’ll fall apart . Or by the time it reached the surface it’ll look like a pile of dirt. Crumbling like a wet cookie in a cup of milk. But it would be cool to see if it was possible
No. Bring it up
This is quite a fascinating topic for a video ngl
I have a great idea which probably is the most realistic one. They should bring down a huge pipe / tube that consist of 60 sections which every section has a diameter of at least 200 meters and a length of 50 meters totalling 3km reaching down the bottom and surrounding the ship. The tube can be made out of thick aluminium, steel or even glass. As its round it would hold the extreme water pressure. After its sealed at the bottom they can start pumping out the water. After that you will have a 3km deep and dry hole with the ship at the bottom.
It would have to be a very very thick tube
I really like this idea
any pressure put on that ship will make it crumble like wet cardboard.
There are so many poor and hungry people in this world
Use all those salvage money to help them
Use it for better hospitals
Leave Titanic alone
Respect that place
It's a sea grave for 1500 people
The Titanic is so rusted and weak due to being under the water for over a century, that it is meant to dissapear by 2030. It's like attempting to recover a paper-ship, it just sort of melts.
we all know that it’s impossible to raise the titanic since it’s been underwater for so long
I wonder if it would be possible to build a metal sarcophagus around the wreck. Like completely around it essentially cutting and enclosing a chunk of the seafloor and titanic inside. The water could then gradually be pumped out and air pumped it and it would raise on its own. The box would have to be made out of a durable material and have support so it would not implode once the water is pumped out and air is pumped in and have tow mounts on it so it could be moved once it floats to the surface. Then once it is moved to where it needs to be they can just disassemble the sarcophagus and recycle the material they used to make it or turn the sarcophagus structure itself into a museum
who's gonna build it....there are 380 + atmospheres of pressure on the TITANIC....
With how deep down it is adding the immense water pressure at that depth and how big the sarcophagus would have to be I don't think we will have that kind of advanced technology for decades, by then the titanic will have long since been gone.
They can barely get a tiny sub down there without it being crushed..... so NO
The only method that would probably work is to pump the water out of the Atlantic Ocean, raise the Titanic, and then pump all the water back xD
Hey!!! Just replace the main engine under water and it will start automatically using petrol etc👍👍👍
It’s been confirmed that it’s Impossible it could be raised but on the trip up the pieces would slowly break off until it’s nothing.
The ice way is the only way to raise it other than cutting it up and bringing individual pieces up. If you adjust the ice idea a bit it would work. You wouldn't release the liquid nitrogen instead you would have multiple hollow loops filled with watter to stop them from collapsing under the pressure. You affix these loops all over the ship. In the areas where it seems the mist structurally sound. Next you apart pumping liquid nitrogen from the surface down through the loops and back up to the surface. This will cause ice to start to form on the loops keep pumping the liquid nitrogen through as more ice starts to form on the loops eventually the ice will start to form on the surfaces of the ship as well. Keep doing it until the entire ship starts to be coated in ice from the underside. You don't want a cage arround the ship you want the ship it self to become ice. Next if you can't find a ship large enough to bring it to the surface go find a large ice berg in the area tow it above the wreck and afix machinery onto the iceberg. Use it to lift the ship. You don't need enough ice to lift the ship on it own you just need enough to take some of the stress off the structure while cranes lift it.
Use big ballast tanks that were used to raise the Concordia and use cranes on a floating oil rig. They’re pretty sturdy
The only time the titanic will ever be brought up is in conversation. 🎤 🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤
Attach dozens of large rubber bladders, each 40 ft x 20 ft which attach to the hull with grapple hooks through the ship's portholes, therefore no need to put anything under the hull. The bladders are then filled with air from above. Each bladder will need a pressure relief valve since as the ship rises, the water pressure is less, the bladders expand and otherwise would explode. More bladders the better, too few means too much lift in limited areas and the ship would break apart. All said and done, the Titanic now is probably too fragile to do anything with, leave it alone. I'm a naval architect and that's my solution to lifting Titanic.
That has already been done to a piece of the hull but they used diesel because air compresses and diesel doesn't and still lighter than water.
As much as many people would love to see this once stunning ship raised I'm afraid it's far to gone, it would also just simply crumble to bits, personally myself I would also love to see her raised but I'm sure it's impossible and right now even with today's technology we just don't have the resources
No. They should bring it to the surface
Historic Travels needs to see this
You could probably build an exact working replica of the titanic for less than half the price of raising the original
Hi can you please make the video of the Life of Carpathia ship , the ship that rescued the Titanic surviers
It sunk in 1918
survivors*
I’m gonna do those when I grow up
Amazing!
I did have an idea a few years ago that wouldn’t work but thought I’d say it anyway, if the wreck was covered in a strong material like an object in a display case, drain the water, construct a elevator to go up and down, and maybe find a way to attach a base to the “display case” and bring it up
I personally think the best way to bring the Titanic up from the ocean floor would be to very slowly over very many years construct a water-tight cylinder wall around the two large pieces, and once it has reached the surface, drain the water inside the cylinder back out into the ocean. Once the water is drained, we could again very slowly lift the Titanic up the shafts... I don't know if this would actually work or not or be too expensive, but hey, its just an idea lol.
I thought of this as well
Would be too late by then
Mate, it's 2.4 MILES under the ocean surface 🤣
It’s not completely impossible, it’s just they don’t want it to be expensive lol I’m pretty sure they know that can work but again it’s too expensive
Three foot thick transparent aluminum walls box in the Titanic an all sides, creating an aquarium. The water is slowly pumped out, and replaced with air. An electrolysis system is then set up to clean the ship of as much rust as is reasonable possible and the ship is reassembled in the "aquarium". Once reassembled, water is slow reintroduced to float the ship and the ship and "aquarium" are slowly raised together to the surface. Cost? Multiple trillions of dollars. Hope it was worth it.
You will have to hire Scotty as chief engineer.
it will work but they must be really careful while removing the rust cuz the ship may collapse while they do this.
some pieces of the ship are supported by almost nothing but rust
Transparent aluminium???? If you try to clean it from rust, you will probably remain with a mountain of rust and small pices of metal. Stop watching so many retorations, it's not the same thing.
The magnet part would even make any sense because we don’t have wires that could go at least 3000 m into the water which is how deep the titanic is
I imagine taking a giant platform and digging it underneath the ship and raising it slowly
The best way to test any ideas out beforehand would be to practice on the Titanic's sister ship The Britannic. It's in alot shallower waters.
britannic is also a grave site though, albeit having much less deaths. we can't use the grave of another beautiful ship as a mere labrat.
@@tastethedifferencecheese nah we shoudl still do it
@@tastethedifferencecheese not its not
I don’t really think it’s possible to raise the Titanic, it’s in a very fragile state so moving it might break it down.
Absolutely correct, it would
moving it.. even disturbing it would make it crumble.
I heard of one method that involved building a giant wall encircling the Titanic all the way up to the surface, and then draining the water. Once the water is gone you could essentially use a winch to lift it up
It's 3800 meters deep. It's too tall, it needs a lot of consolidation to remain strait and you can't make it waterproof.
😄😄😄😄
On one hand I'd love to see it preserved in a museum. On the other hand it's a gravesite for so many people so should be left be
I don't think it will work out as the frame of the ship is old enough and it crumbles if you lift it.