People who commented that you can't do that are probably not actual swordfighters. When using a two handed weapon, you usually want to strike with the tip of your blade, which is weak, and can be easily blocked with the strong part of a weapon, even a one-handed one. Shorter blade also meant that it was already way closer to the strong of the blade if it blocked the attack in the first place. One thing that can hardly be blocked, on the other hand, would be a two handed strike to the legs with a polearm, because only the weak part of a blade can reach this low, and can't block very well...
Agreed but to expand on the polearm comment, it's very difficult to block below the waist with a sword as most of the blocks require putting the wrist in a terrible position so the block itself is generally quite weak. Better to just not be standing there anymore.
Even that would probably be possible if the Odachi user wasn't so close that they're hitting with their strong of their blade and you're shanking them with your Tanto in the same breath :D
In Modern Arnis, I was taught that in order to reinforce a block with a single-handed weapon, the off-hand should press against the main hand's wrist. The original intent was to assist blocks done with a machete (which have thin blades), but it works with any single-handed weapon.
The most important thing is that when you block that you block with the strong of the blade (the part closer to the hands). If you block with the part closer to the tip of the blade, the leverage is bad. Otherwise it just comes down to how much force your joints can take.
In Niten Ichi Ryu, the only form of "block" is when you use two sword at the same time against a downward blow, so it's two against one. Besides that, it's all side step or step backward combined with beats and displacement the opponent sword while it's swinging. Also in European traditions, the author Di Grassi said you can stop a cut from a cut from 2 handed sword with a rapier if your body structure is solid and your technique is correct.
3 месяца назад
not just any two handed sword, I saw sparring where guy regulary parried heavy 2.5kg greatsword with his rapier... Just had to catch it with strong in good position
not necessarily the case. in the chudan kata and the gedan kata of niten ichi ryu you parry the opponent's blade by a punching-like motion to their sword with the short sword.
Yeah and notice that is SPRING STEEL. Traditional katanas are deferentially hardened, not spring steel, so they're far more likely to snap if they're put under a high force like this (if they're not properly made anyway). Really, don't try this at home with a cheap imitation.
Tbh, I would argue that rather than blocking, it would be harder to build the necessary strength to attack. Styles like niten also combine their body strength, but makes me wonder if their arm strength is more developed compared to more traditional styles.
Of course you can parry a twohanded sword with a onehanded. It is about physics, they strength and weak of the blade as it is said in western swordsmanship. The closer you parry to the hilt/handle, the lesser leverage has the bigger sword. Even with a static block. Simple. Combined with footwork and evasion movements to take away the impact power, you can even manage to use an absorbing or deflecting parry or let The opponent‘s blade glide of your own.
Untrained people can't even grasp the concept of simple geometry in swordsmanship. Another content creator made a video talked about cutting the leg is further than attacking the head, with proper demonstration and alot people can't even understand that
Alright, I love you guys, but there's a pretty big issue with this test. Mr. 70kg (I didn't see/hear his name) might be a good kendoka, but a kendo swing is far different from swings/cuts in actual combat. It's a little complicated to explain, but it's illustrated in the sort of flip his sword performs, leading it to be nearly vertical. This type of strike lacks a good half of the power of an actual, powerful strike. I would have way preferred to see this done with an actual kenjutsu or hema practitioner. That said, I'm under the notion that a sword wielded in one hand CAN still block against a two-hander, but proper technique and placement are critical. And there are obvious limitations to that, too; not just in the defender's strength, but in the integrity of the weapon, too.
hello weaponism.I would like to ask you if it is possible to make a video with spartan shield and spear.I would love to see a fight bitween a 'samurai' and a 'spartan warrior'
For people inexperenced with swords this would very good in formation. Swords like a gun need to be respected, and one shouls be trained inproper usage these weapons, or any weapon for that matter.
I have a question, can you use a katana to get past the guard of a large/big shield and sword? What techniques would they use? It would be an interesting video
"Japanese bandits only attack with katana two or three times, but People often cannot prevent it. ”You should know the ingenuity of their katana sword technique. " 明 何良臣 阵纪 军中诸技，惟刀剑法少传。若能滚入，使长短兵不及遮拦，便为熟矣。如日本刀不过三两下，往往人不能御，则用刀之巧可知耳。 Chinese Ming Dynasty General Qi Jiguang (1528-1588) "My soldiers' short weapons cannot withstand katana's attacks, and pole weapons are less agile than katana. Many people who encountered Japanese people had their bodies cut in half. This is because their long katana is sharp and powerful as they are used with both hands. ” 戚继光说：“我兵短器难接，长器不捷，遭之者身多两断，缘器利而双手使用，力重故也”可见倭刀锋利，对此茅元仪评价“长刀倭奴之制，甚利于步，古所未备。”
The two handed sword striker was not using good form. The hands should twist inward on the grip just before the strike - because this puts the wrists over the hilt and puts the persons weight into the strike. The striker in the video allowed his wrists to bend downward, which means the sword only hits with its own momentum.
Also he was not striking to the head, but into the sword. We practice this often in my hema school that once in 5 strikes you randomly not block and if the attacker misses head, he has to do 10 pushups. 😄 Plus longsword weighs 1,5kg, which is totally different than 0,6kg. It is still possible to block with one hand tho, if u use strong part of the blade.
There was no follow through with the attackers swing. His arc ended at the blocking sword and therefore it wasn't a full strength swing--he basically pulled his swings. Poor test.
3 месяца назад+1
Did it ever occur in your mind, that it did not follow through because it was straight on blocked? That sword just met a solid object in its path, what follow through lol?
He did follow through, just not like you do when you swing a baseball bat. Look at the slow-mo and you'll see that he's using a technique that resembles cracking a whip. Yes, his arms slow prior to impact, but he uses that to snap his wrists forward and accelerate the strike. It might not be the kind of follow-through you were expecting, but it's certainly not "pulling the swing," and it also makes it a whole lot easier to deal with the hand-shock and a whole lot faster to bring the sword back into a position to defend or make a follow-up attack. However, even if it truly _isn't_ possible to block a two-hander with a one-hander, swinging for the fences is still a great way to lose a fight 99% of the time, and _not_ just because it's slow and highly telegraphed. Here are two other reasons I can think of off the top of my head: 1) Even if you manage to blow through your opponent's guard, the strike is going to land with terrible edge alignment and robbed of most of its force, so the injury is unlikely to be incapacitating ... unlike the counter-attack you're going to eat because your sword is so far out of position. 2) As evidenced by Matthew Jensen's destructive sword reviews, such a blow will either break your sword or damage it enough that it will break shortly thereafter, particularly if it's differentially hardened, as virtually all historical Japanese swords were. Thus, even if you were lucky enough to disable your opponent, if he's got buddies nearby, you're going to be disarmed and utterly screwed.
@@irrelevantfish1978 I've always liked Weaponism because they're not sparring for points, but for actual hits against their opponent. The attacker in this was attacking the blocking sword, not the defender, that makes this exercise useless for question asked.
I realize this is the safe and ideal situation. Would have been more of a test if the one-hand defender started facing side-ways or with back turned to the two-handed sword user. Even having both of them moving around in a circle would have been nice to mix up the one-hand distance defense and timing. I think, if both are facing each other, the one-hand defender should start with their sword sheath to see if they can draw and defend successfully. With that said, great demonstration and keep up the great work ! ~ From Nashville, Tennessee USA
I can understand blocking a sword with another sword. I don't know whether a pike or some other large, staff-type of weapon could be blocked as easily with one hand. I'm trying to remember whether your glaive versus sword videos included that scenario. If one deflects the force to one side, I think the block could be made.
Military saber in 19th century was made sturdy enough to parry blows from bayonet attached to rifles. Not as heavy as medieval polearms but I'm sure it's just as heavy as a spear
@@jaketheasianguy3307 The weight of a bayonetted rifle might be similar to that of a spear, but the distribution would be different. A rifle has much of the weight towards the butt of the rifle. I think a heavy pike, halberd, or glaive coming down on a sword would be more difficult to stop.
3 месяца назад+2
@@VTPSTTU Yes, I saw video (skallagrim maybe?) where he tried to block quarterstaff blow. It is HIGHLY NOT RECOMMENDED to try block heavy wooden shaft at full speed with measly sword, definitely not one handed unless you catch it perfectly with strong near guard.
This has been explained before in the comments by many, but to add to the pile, the reason you can block a two handed weapon with a one handed sword has to do with blade mechanics. The part of the sword blade closest to the hilt and therefore your hand is the strongest part of the blade when blocking a strike, but the further the blade is from the hand the weaker the blade is at blocking or parrying and opponents weapon, therefore it is advantageous when trying the block a weapon with one hand that you catch their blade on the strong part of your own, and likewise it is advantageous for the two handed sword user to attack the weakest part of the blade when attempting to overpower and opponents block. However, as is demonstrated in the video a sword user who is prepared to receive a strong blow can redirect the energy from the opponents blade into an effective countercut. This is not to say that one handed weapons necessarily have an advantage over two handed, but that there are options one with a one handed blade can do to make the fight easier on themselves.
It's in military European saber. You stop dead the opponent cut with your forte and hand guard and riposte with an appropriate cut to their newly created opening. Of course, doing deflects and beats while stepping sideway is also advisable when there's opportunity but in saber fencing, it's always hard block and retaliate with your own cut and thrust. That's why you can see so many long 3 4 cuts parry riposte back and fourth exchanges in saber. Doesn't have to look far, look at the saber instructional video in this channel.
People who commented that you can't do that are probably not actual swordfighters. When using a two handed weapon, you usually want to strike with the tip of your blade, which is weak, and can be easily blocked with the strong part of a weapon, even a one-handed one. Shorter blade also meant that it was already way closer to the strong of the blade if it blocked the attack in the first place.
One thing that can hardly be blocked, on the other hand, would be a two handed strike to the legs with a polearm, because only the weak part of a blade can reach this low, and can't block very well...
Agreed but to expand on the polearm comment, it's very difficult to block below the waist with a sword as most of the blocks require putting the wrist in a terrible position so the block itself is generally quite weak. Better to just not be standing there anymore.
People in that video were speaking as if you were blocking an Odachi with a Tanto...
Even that would probably be possible if the Odachi user wasn't so close that they're hitting with their strong of their blade and you're shanking them with your Tanto in the same breath :D
In Modern Arnis, I was taught that in order to reinforce a block with a single-handed weapon, the off-hand should press against the main hand's wrist.
The original intent was to assist blocks done with a machete (which have thin blades), but it works with any single-handed weapon.
The most important thing is that when you block that you block with the strong of the blade (the part closer to the hands). If you block with the part closer to the tip of the blade, the leverage is bad. Otherwise it just comes down to how much force your joints can take.
We used to spar with Bokken which had layers of tape that made them even heavier and I could still block with one hand.
In Niten Ichi Ryu, the only form of "block" is when you use two sword at the same time against a downward blow, so it's two against one. Besides that, it's all side step or step backward combined with beats and displacement the opponent sword while it's swinging.
Also in European traditions, the author Di Grassi said you can stop a cut from a cut from 2 handed sword with a rapier if your body structure is solid and your technique is correct.
not just any two handed sword, I saw sparring where guy regulary parried heavy 2.5kg greatsword with his rapier... Just had to catch it with strong in good position
not necessarily the case. in the chudan kata and the gedan kata of niten ichi ryu you parry the opponent's blade by a punching-like motion to their sword with the short sword.
Yeah and notice that is SPRING STEEL. Traditional katanas are deferentially hardened, not spring steel, so they're far more likely to snap if they're put under a high force like this (if they're not properly made anyway). Really, don't try this at home with a cheap imitation.
Please return making videos! I love this channel!
Tbh, I would argue that rather than blocking, it would be harder to build the necessary strength to attack. Styles like niten also combine their body strength, but makes me wonder if their arm strength is more developed compared to more traditional styles.
Of course you can parry a twohanded sword with a onehanded. It is about physics, they strength and weak of the blade as it is said in western swordsmanship. The closer you parry to the hilt/handle, the lesser leverage has the bigger sword. Even with a static block. Simple. Combined with footwork and evasion movements to take away the impact power, you can even manage to use an absorbing or deflecting parry or let The opponent‘s blade glide of your own.
Untrained people can't even grasp the concept of simple geometry in swordsmanship. Another content creator made a video talked about cutting the leg is further than attacking the head, with proper demonstration and alot people can't even understand that
Thank you all for the video 👍🏻
Alright, I love you guys, but there's a pretty big issue with this test. Mr. 70kg (I didn't see/hear his name) might be a good kendoka, but a kendo swing is far different from swings/cuts in actual combat. It's a little complicated to explain, but it's illustrated in the sort of flip his sword performs, leading it to be nearly vertical. This type of strike lacks a good half of the power of an actual, powerful strike.
I would have way preferred to see this done with an actual kenjutsu or hema practitioner.
That said, I'm under the notion that a sword wielded in one hand CAN still block against a two-hander, but proper technique and placement are critical. And there are obvious limitations to that, too; not just in the defender's strength, but in the integrity of the weapon, too.
He is not good at kendo. Watch his wrists hyperextend, that is how one injures oneself and still fail to generate any power, smoothness, or crispness.
hello weaponism.I would like to ask you if it is possible to make a video with spartan shield and spear.I would love to see a fight bitween a 'samurai' and a 'spartan warrior'
Blocking like that is also suicidal since the attacker can shift stance and deflect strike elsewhere. The best is just to deflect, counter.
For people inexperenced with swords this would very good in formation. Swords like a gun need to be respected, and one shouls be trained inproper usage these weapons, or any weapon for that matter.
Hagan un sparring de un hombre utilizando una katana a una mano y otro que use la katana a dos manos porfavor
I have a question, can you use a katana to get past the guard of a large/big shield and sword? What techniques would they use?
It would be an interesting video
"Japanese bandits only attack with katana two or three times, but People often cannot prevent it. ”You should know the ingenuity of their katana sword technique. "
明 何良臣 阵纪 军中诸技，惟刀剑法少传。若能滚入，使长短兵不及遮拦，便为熟矣。如日本刀不过三两下，往往人不能御，则用刀之巧可知耳。
Chinese Ming Dynasty General Qi Jiguang (1528-1588) "My soldiers' short weapons cannot withstand katana's attacks, and pole weapons are less agile than katana. Many people who encountered Japanese people had their bodies cut in half. This is because their long katana is sharp and powerful as they are used with both hands. ”
戚继光说：“我兵短器难接，长器不捷，遭之者身多两断，缘器利而双手使用，力重故也”可见倭刀锋利，对此茅元仪评价“长刀倭奴之制，甚利于步，古所未备。”
Will there be practices or sparring sessions related to montante?
The two handed sword striker was not using good form. The hands should twist inward on the grip just before the strike - because this puts the wrists over the hilt and puts the persons weight into the strike. The striker in the video allowed his wrists to bend downward, which means the sword only hits with its own momentum.
Also he was not striking to the head, but into the sword. We practice this often in my hema school that once in 5 strikes you randomly not block and if the attacker misses head, he has to do 10 pushups. 😄 Plus longsword weighs 1,5kg, which is totally different than 0,6kg. It is still possible to block with one hand tho, if u use strong part of the blade.
Average one handed and two handed swords are not that different in length and weight, not every scenario is like a Mihawk vs Zorro type of situation 😂
There was no follow through with the attackers swing. His arc ended at the blocking sword and therefore it wasn't a full strength swing--he basically pulled his swings. Poor test.
Did it ever occur in your mind, that it did not follow through because it was straight on blocked? That sword just met a solid object in its path, what follow through lol?
He did follow through, just not like you do when you swing a baseball bat. Look at the slow-mo and you'll see that he's using a technique that resembles cracking a whip. Yes, his arms slow prior to impact, but he uses that to snap his wrists forward and accelerate the strike. It might not be the kind of follow-through you were expecting, but it's certainly not "pulling the swing," and it also makes it a whole lot easier to deal with the hand-shock and a whole lot faster to bring the sword back into a position to defend or make a follow-up attack.
However, even if it truly _isn't_ possible to block a two-hander with a one-hander, swinging for the fences is still a great way to lose a fight 99% of the time, and _not_ just because it's slow and highly telegraphed. Here are two other reasons I can think of off the top of my head:
1) Even if you manage to blow through your opponent's guard, the strike is going to land with terrible edge alignment and robbed of most of its force, so the injury is unlikely to be incapacitating ... unlike the counter-attack you're going to eat because your sword is so far out of position.
2) As evidenced by Matthew Jensen's destructive sword reviews, such a blow will either break your sword or damage it enough that it will break shortly thereafter, particularly if it's differentially hardened, as virtually all historical Japanese swords were. Thus, even if you were lucky enough to disable your opponent, if he's got buddies nearby, you're going to be disarmed and utterly screwed.
@@irrelevantfish1978 I've always liked Weaponism because they're not sparring for points, but for actual hits against their opponent. The attacker in this was attacking the blocking sword, not the defender, that makes this exercise useless for question asked.
@ You attack the defender, not his sword. It looked more like staged sword choreography in a movie rather than an actual sparring situation.
認同此測試不完備，以傳統武術的整勁概念來看，攻擊方上段斬擊太隨便了
Beautiful fencing 👍👌🙏
刀で受けるとき、そのような受け方をするのは良くないです。鎬で受けるのが正しいです。あなたは刃で受けてます。
Well done
I realize this is the safe and ideal situation.
Would have been more of a test if the one-hand defender started facing side-ways or with back turned to the two-handed sword user.
Even having both of them moving around in a circle would have been nice to mix up the one-hand distance defense and timing.
I think, if both are facing each other, the one-hand defender should start with their sword sheath to see if they can draw and defend successfully.
With that said, great demonstration and keep up the great work !
~ From Nashville, Tennessee USA
어.. 영문채널도 있으셨네
I can understand blocking a sword with another sword. I don't know whether a pike or some other large, staff-type of weapon could be blocked as easily with one hand. I'm trying to remember whether your glaive versus sword videos included that scenario. If one deflects the force to one side, I think the block could be made.
Military saber in 19th century was made sturdy enough to parry blows from bayonet attached to rifles. Not as heavy as medieval polearms but I'm sure it's just as heavy as a spear
@@jaketheasianguy3307 The weight of a bayonetted rifle might be similar to that of a spear, but the distribution would be different. A rifle has much of the weight towards the butt of the rifle. I think a heavy pike, halberd, or glaive coming down on a sword would be more difficult to stop.
@@VTPSTTU Yes, I saw video (skallagrim maybe?) where he tried to block quarterstaff blow. It is HIGHLY NOT RECOMMENDED to try block heavy wooden shaft at full speed with measly sword, definitely not one handed unless you catch it perfectly with strong near guard.
Why can't we buy the katana that you are using
thanks
This has been explained before in the comments by many, but to add to the pile, the reason you can block a two handed weapon with a one handed sword has to do with blade mechanics. The part of the sword blade closest to the hilt and therefore your hand is the strongest part of the blade when blocking a strike, but the further the blade is from the hand the weaker the blade is at blocking or parrying and opponents weapon, therefore it is advantageous when trying the block a weapon with one hand that you catch their blade on the strong part of your own, and likewise it is advantageous for the two handed sword user to attack the weakest part of the blade when attempting to overpower and opponents block.
However, as is demonstrated in the video a sword user who is prepared to receive a strong blow can redirect the energy from the opponents blade into an effective countercut. This is not to say that one handed weapons necessarily have an advantage over two handed, but that there are options one with a one handed blade can do to make the fight easier on themselves.
How about nodachi?
Your guest's left hand is hyperextending on his suburi. Please develop his tenouchi to a level appropriate for a shodan.
Not really using his whole body to strike
🙂
호구커플 엄청 좋아해용😊
You never block, you deviate the incoming attack. There is always someone faster and stronger, blocking straight it's never advisable.
It's in military European saber. You stop dead the opponent cut with your forte and hand guard and riposte with an appropriate cut to their newly created opening. Of course, doing deflects and beats while stepping sideway is also advisable when there's opportunity but in saber fencing, it's always hard block and retaliate with your own cut and thrust. That's why you can see so many long 3 4 cuts parry riposte back and fourth exchanges in saber. Doesn't have to look far, look at the saber instructional video in this channel.
massa
You need to prove he's swinging at full power