I will have to agree on that her voice needs more time to develop she doesn’t have a strong voice yet and needs more confidence in her singing ability.
I agreed with Lionel she wasn't quite there, she needs a few more years then I think she'll be ready, her dad I think was surprised the judges voted her through.
Look do you remember just Sam who won American Idol she basically had that ace in the pocket OK what do you want that screaming loud noise like you know that whatever they nowadays singers what all do OK her voice sounds pure and innocent. OK it’s not all about hitting those high notes, OK what do you want to be like Miley Cyrus or whatchamacallit? It’s about being one not being a clone of some motherfucker so she’s unique and also she got Ace in her pocket which is the Spanish
I feel like she was nervous and it came through but she has a nice tone and with the extra vocal training, she could really develop that. she’s only 14 and I think some in the comments are being a little harsh. plus the coaches gave her good criticism/feedback as well. it’s not like they were dishonest w/ her or just gave her positive praise.
Exactly she is NOT ready, cute, mature but her voice is not mature and it's to young sounding she needs breath control, work on her range , they did not do her a favor.
Well , it's a yes for now..but.., she'll probably won't make it to the next round ofc. She's young and needs to practice more. Maybe the dad helped a lil bit😂
Viewers should be reminded that Camila sang on camera during Juan Pablo's season, when J.P. and Nikki attend Camila's dance recital with J.P.'s family. She had chops then (at age 4!) and she has chops now!
She looks just like him. Hard for me to tell exactly how good her voice was because she was singing in Spanish. And agree with judges that she doesnt seem to have the power notes the other contestants will have.
It doesn't matter what language someone sings in. Some people may like or dislike a song for various reasons but it doesn't determine if they can sing or not.
Camila has grown up so much since the last time her father Juan Pablo was on the Bachelor! I had no idea she could sing until last night! I’d like to hear her do a cover of one of Shakira’s songs since I think she sounds like her!
A yes was given because her famous dad was in the room. The young girl has an ordinary voice and definitely not competitive. Sweet girl, but this is not a competition of sweetness.
She was given a yes for ratings. She's cute. She has a sweet voice. But definitely not competition worthy. But, whatever. She'll gain from the experience and hopefully she'll appear on The Voice in a couple of years. 🤷🏻♀️ By that time hopefully she'll be a lot better.
@@1Hope4All Like I said, I disagreed with the "rating"🙄🙄She does not belong in this competition and she won't last. it was a WOKE rating, done to get Spanish speaker veiwers for ratings.
just a little tentative to start but closed her eyes and got comfy, singing to her dad. She's so young but feels older than her years. Parts were a bit clunky. Just Ok for me, dawg.
Apart from the backlash and stigmas that Juan Pablo took with him from his Bachelor season, and, in turn, his overall character being a question mark, at least he is there for his daughter as a dedicated father. So, we can give him that! ❤
and by the way...what happened to this rule " there is an age limit for American Idol and it is a pretty strict one. You can only enter American Idol if you are 15-years-old or above, but no older than 29-years-old at the time of your audition."?
I'm fairly certain they changed the minimum age to 14 a few years ago. I remember it being a big deal for another young person. I think it was because the Voice has a minimum age of 14. I could be wrong tho...
@@DiamondBodyHealing I'm guessing that maybe you've deleted it, but in regard to your comment where you said, " if that's true then how did this person enter? You make no sense." It's quite simple. Rather than discussing it with me on RUclips why don't you just go look up American Idol qualifications that clearly states and I quote "contestants must be between 15 to 29 years old" It's not that hard to make sense out of that. It was clear to most people here that the only reason she was on the show period was because of her dad. There are some incredibly talented people trying out for this show that meet the qualifications. She does not. Other shows, such as The Voice, AGT etc. do not have age restrictions, but American Idol does.. Those are facts. Now imo...she's too young, her voice was not where it needs to be for this level of competition, and just to add to the age requirement, this was also on American Idols list of rules. "5. Language Requirement: While the show doesn’t explicitly state that contestants must sing in English, it’s implied since the show is conducted in English and aired in the United States. So, yes, singing in English is an essential part of the American Idol audition process!" Clearly, she didn't have to follow these, but ONLY because of her dad. That's actually sad for her. It's better that she try out and become successful knowing she was good enough to be selected without him being in the room
I'm actually shocked by some of the comments.. I mean I have no idea what she was saying, but I thought her vibrato and tone was very unique. Random, but I would like to hear her sing something by Camila Cabello. I feel like her voice would fit her songs well. Edit: I'm not arguing whether she should or should not have went through, but I didn't think she done a bad job. Interested to see what she does in Hollywood.
You’re supposed to be 15 and up to audition but I think when they found out who her dad is they let her audition and let her through bc they were star struck when they saw her dad.
Ummm. There were some people who should have gone through…. Julia Davo who I now follow on Spotify, so to let her in shows they let stories in over the voices a lot of times.
She's young but I don't think her voice is ready for the level of competition from AI. I feel like the only reason she got a yes is because of who her dad is.
Thing is, if you do it for one then they should do it for all. Normally in this instance, they wouldve asked the contestant to either sing a second song or come back in a few years once they get more experience. There are many professionals out there willing to train/teach music to willing students.
Mmmm... no. I don't think she deserved to go through when better voices have been cut. But the show needs fodder to cut. She won't last. But appreciate her confidence and just follow her dream
Wait... she is underage? The age limit is 15-28. Why wasn't she deemed ineligible to compete? Why is she allowed to participate and not other 14 year-olds?
Love music in foreign language, iam tongi (if you havent checked out his official channel, mr iam does have some songs in his hawaiian polynesian/tongan/samoan language absolutely stunning!), celtic women, il divo, andrea bocelli, shakira, celine dion, selina, j lo, & so many more. There's a fluidity of their timber, language & accents, that unfortunately was lacking here. I wish they would've asked for another song in english to see if she did the same habit. She can sing, has the notes but lacks fluidity of words that chop off abruptly.
I don't think she's ready bc her voice lacks maturity, but I like her confidence. The competition is fierce this season but I don't think she's gonna be rattled by it.
Was never a fan of Juan Pablo. But watching him look at his daughter, it is beautiful to see that he loves. She is clearly his world. ❤
You can see her father teary-eyed 🥺 proud father ❤
The bachelor dad did help a little bit for the backstory. If she was just another random girl, no chance she would have made it
I will have to agree on that her voice needs more time to develop she doesn’t have a strong voice yet and needs more confidence in her singing ability.
helped alot!
I agreed with Lionel she wasn't quite there, she needs a few more years then I think she'll be ready, her dad I think was surprised the judges voted her through.
Look do you remember just Sam who won American Idol she basically had that ace in the pocket OK what do you want that screaming loud noise like you know that whatever they nowadays singers what all do OK her voice sounds pure and innocent. OK it’s not all about hitting those high notes, OK what do you want to be like Miley Cyrus or whatchamacallit? It’s about being one not being a clone of some motherfucker so she’s unique and also she got Ace in her pocket which is the Spanish
I feel like she was nervous and it came through but she has a nice tone and with the extra vocal training, she could really develop that. she’s only 14 and I think some in the comments are being a little harsh. plus the coaches gave her good criticism/feedback as well. it’s not like they were dishonest w/ her or just gave her positive praise.
Luke wrote down no, but the voice in his earpiece said, "yes"
Exactly she is NOT ready, cute, mature but her voice is not mature and it's to young sounding she needs breath control, work on her range , they did not do her a favor.
SHe was clearly not ready.
Well , it's a yes for now..but.., she'll probably won't make it to the next round ofc. She's young and needs to practice more. Maybe the dad helped a lil bit😂
This is a hard one. Bad song choice where she doesn't show her long notes.
Her speaking voice is very mature....😮
Yeah, her whole demeanor is quite mature. I thought she was somewhere around 17.
Not her singing voice. It's very immature.
@@SagebrushRamblesshe had no signing voice
@@HeartChannelInsightsme too
Same. I find it hard to believe that's a 14 y.o. she even looks a lot older than that. @@HeartChannelInsights
Viewers should be reminded that Camila sang on camera during Juan Pablo's season, when J.P. and Nikki attend Camila's dance recital with J.P.'s family. She had chops then (at age 4!) and she has chops now!
She looks just like him. Hard for me to tell exactly how good her voice was because she was singing in Spanish. And agree with judges that she doesnt seem to have the power notes the other contestants will have.
It is quite bad
It doesn't matter what language someone sings in. Some people may like or dislike a song for various reasons but it doesn't determine if they can sing or not.
They should have requested her a short song in English. Good quality voice if coached
Camila has grown up so much since the last time her father Juan Pablo was on the Bachelor! I had no idea she could sing until last night! I’d like to hear her do a cover of one of Shakira’s songs since I think she sounds like her!
A yes was given because her famous dad was in the room. The young girl has an ordinary voice and definitely not competitive. Sweet girl, but this is not a competition of sweetness.
She was given a yes for ratings. She's cute. She has a sweet voice. But definitely not competition worthy. But, whatever. She'll gain from the experience and hopefully she'll appear on The Voice in a couple of years. 🤷🏻♀️ By that time hopefully she'll be a lot better.
@@1Hope4All Like I said, I disagreed with the "rating"🙄🙄She does not belong in this competition and she won't last. it was a WOKE rating, done to get Spanish speaker veiwers for ratings.
Watching Dad and loving and understanding how he's so proud of his daughter. She's 14.
She has a Good voice, nerves threw it off ! ❤
Missed opportunity for Juan Pablo to ask Katy to accept this rose 🌹
She’s married.
@@chienpo672 I think she's been engaged to Orlando but I don't think they are married, are they?
Seems like something influenced Luke to change his mind. He definitely was gonna say no…
YOOOOOO THATS MY COUSINNNN 🎉🎉🎉🎉CAMI TE AMO BELLA
came here RIGHT after ,, she’s SO amazing and sings BEAUTIFULLY💓💓
If her famous dady wasn't in the room and they didn't know who he was they wouldn't give her a ticket at all
I’m glad she went through. This wasn’t the best song to show what she can do … but I thought she did a great job.
She’s good and her dad is handsome really really handsome
He was a bad boy on The Bachelor. Cute! Big time charmer.
just a little tentative to start but closed her eyes and got comfy, singing to her dad. She's so young but feels older than her years. Parts were a bit clunky. Just Ok for me, dawg.
Apart from the backlash and stigmas that Juan Pablo took with him from his Bachelor season, and, in turn, his overall character being a question mark, at least he is there for his daughter as a dedicated father. So, we can give him that! ❤
Juan Pablo was one of the most controversial bachelors on the franchise.
and by the way...what happened to this rule " there is an age limit for American Idol and it is a pretty strict one. You can only enter American Idol if you are 15-years-old or above, but no older than 29-years-old at the time of your audition."?
That’s what I’m thinking as well!
I'm fairly certain they changed the minimum age to 14 a few years ago. I remember it being a big deal for another young person. I think it was because the Voice has a minimum age of 14. I could be wrong tho...
@@DiamondBodyHealing It started out at 16 and they lowered it to 15
If thats true then how did this person enter? You make no sense. @@777tage
@@DiamondBodyHealing I'm guessing that maybe you've deleted it, but in regard to your comment where you said, " if that's true then how did this person enter? You make no sense."
It's quite simple. Rather than discussing it with me on RUclips why don't you just go look up American Idol qualifications that clearly states and I quote "contestants must be between 15 to 29 years old"
It's not that hard to make sense out of that. It was clear to most people here that the only reason she was on the show period was because of her dad. There are some incredibly talented people trying out for this show that meet the qualifications. She does not. Other shows, such as The Voice, AGT etc. do not have age restrictions, but American Idol does.. Those are facts. Now imo...she's too young, her voice was not where it needs to be for this level of competition, and just to add to the age requirement, this was also on American Idols list of rules. "5. Language Requirement: While the show doesn’t explicitly state that contestants must sing in English, it’s implied since the show is conducted in English and aired in the United States. So, yes, singing in English is an essential part of the American Idol audition process!" Clearly, she didn't have to follow these, but ONLY because of her dad. That's actually sad for her. It's better that she try out and become successful knowing she was good enough to be selected without him being in the room
I remember his daughter on his season of the bachelor 😮 she was a child 😮 he looks the same too ❤ such a cutie
You can see in her dad's face that he is so proud of his daughter.
This makes me feel old.
Knocked out in first round. Luke did not do her a favor.
Muy bella, canto muy lindo!!
Too young needs a little work. Lovely girl. Gorgeous dad.
He was on the Bachelorette and then became the Bachelor for a season. Everyone hated him. He's actually a huge scumbag
He may be good looking but he's not a good man.
Omg that’s Juan Pablo’s daughter!!!?! Crazyyyy!!!!
Happy they put her through
I'd have asked her to sing another song to determine if she's good to go.
Beautiful! I love her!
I'm actually shocked by some of the comments.. I mean I have no idea what she was saying, but I thought her vibrato and tone was very unique. Random, but I would like to hear her sing something by Camila Cabello. I feel like her voice would fit her songs well.
Edit: I'm not arguing whether she should or should not have went through, but I didn't think she done a bad job. Interested to see what she does in Hollywood.
Yeahhhhhhhh
The dad got a "yes" from me LOL
She's only here because of the TV show crossover. Next!
Typical hater with a horrible life😂
Camila Galavis from VENEZUELA 🇻🇪
Camila Cabello from CUBA 🇨🇺🤔💭😄
Love what I hear ❤❤❤❤
Is this the same Juan Pablo that was considered one of the most hated Bachelor's?
Yes.
I just looked it up he is #1
Yes. But it's the bachelor so take that with a grain of salt.
I thought the youngest one could be on this show was 15??!!
You’re supposed to be 15 and up to audition but I think when they found out who her dad is they let her audition and let her through bc they were star struck when they saw her dad.
Ummm. There were some people who should have gone through…. Julia Davo who I now follow on Spotify, so to let her in shows they let stories in over the voices a lot of times.
When Juan Pablo was born an hour from me 😮
Her journey will end sunday for sure.
She is good as Spanish speaker I tell you people she sounded good she is got potential not perfect but good enough for the show.
No way she sux !
she 14? Damn STARGIRL
For her language it's actually good
14 going on 20 😮
She's young but I don't think her voice is ready for the level of competition from AI. I feel like the only reason she got a yes is because of who her dad is.
Its a miracle that Katy “Can You Sing Louder?” Perry was not activated here.
No hablo espanol but her voice is so good rooting for her love from the Philippines!!!!
She looks just like him!!!
Congratulations!
Let her through for the vocal training
Thing is, if you do it for one then they should do it for all. Normally in this instance, they wouldve asked the contestant to either sing a second song or come back in a few years once they get more experience. There are many professionals out there willing to train/teach music to willing students.
Or...let her Dad continue to pay for that.
Mmmm... no. I don't think she deserved to go through when better voices have been cut. But the show needs fodder to cut. She won't last. But appreciate her confidence and just follow her dream
So pretty ❤️🙏🏻
She pretty good ngl
Her voice is so beautiful
Luke saw something !❣️ muchos éxitos pequeña, lo vas a lograr 🙏
Woah the youngest to audition?! 😱 I’m shocked to hear she’s 14
❤❤❤ beautiful voice and she is adorable
En el juego de las citas, tan pronto como nos vamos, los recuerdos se desvanecen lentamente y surgen nuevos coqueteos.
I don’t care cannot understand her singing Spanish or Latin pop but important is very good voice with feelings 🤔💭🇻🇪👩🏼🗣️🔊👂👍
Definitely needs a few more years under her belt. Sweet Girl was terrified, understandably.
So many other contestants that didnt make it though that were so much better than this girl!
I agree with you!
I like her ☺️
Sorry she took a spot from someone who deserves it. She got in because of her dad! She is not good
Wait... she is underage? The age limit is 15-28. Why wasn't she deemed ineligible to compete? Why is she allowed to participate and not other 14 year-olds?
Great job, Camila! 👏👏👏👏
There's something about the Spanish language and people which I just love.
Ese algo se lleva en la sangre
Y si el idioma y las personas ❤
I like her voice.
She's really good! Her voice isn't super strong, but that will come with age and coaching.
Is this the same Juan Pablo from fuller house? If so I love him
Love music in foreign language, iam tongi (if you havent checked out his official channel, mr iam does have some songs in his hawaiian polynesian/tongan/samoan language absolutely stunning!), celtic women, il divo, andrea bocelli, shakira, celine dion, selina, j lo, & so many more. There's a fluidity of their timber, language & accents, that unfortunately was lacking here. I wish they would've asked for another song in english to see if she did the same habit. She can sing, has the notes but lacks fluidity of words that chop off abruptly.
Dad's handsome
She has natural talent and a beautiful tone
Came here for the comments. There are literally ten year olds out there who sound so much better. We love nepotism though
#facts
How’s it nepotism? She isn’t a friend or relative of Lionel, Katie or Luke !!!! Show us your ten year old you know who are better?
@@fast800journeylifebeyond5 Literally every 10 year old on The Voice Kids... And AGT has had a few.
Get some Q Tips and clean the wax out of your ears!!! You wouldn't recognize talent if it hit you on the face!
No disrespect, but how the hell did she get through? Someone knows someone?
Katy only said yes because she wants to hit on Juan again.
But they didn’t let Julia Davo go to Hollywood? BYE!!! 😂
Facts I'm still mad about it
Julia was bad too.
Katie gave a yes to the girl because she wanted the bachelor’s number. 😂
This is American idol.She needs to sing a song in english!
Dale sigue adelante
The performance es okay!
Shes gonna be like Michelle Susette🤭❤️ Lets gooo
Gosh she sings well with spanish soul
omg luke face
Look one of the judges expression.....
Did anyone notice when she was done katy said he’s got a good voice lmao
Venezuela ❤❤❤
I don't think she's ready bc her voice lacks maturity, but I like her confidence. The competition is fierce this season but I don't think she's gonna be rattled by it.
She is so young… maybe a few more years.
I mean Wow🤩
I love you 3 has judges Katy don’t leave
Give her some more year😊
14 years old? She’s not old enough to be here right now!
She better bring her game next time !!
She gonna be out in first day of Hollywood
But they told the 15 year that wrote her own great song and could sing that she was too young? Luke was clearly led in his decision.