@@LAURA-oz8lsI concur, way before this interview when I first saw the name popped up, it's like freakin alarm bell ringing like nuts. Despite myself trying very hard to stay impartial, I remain very much doubtful for her being genuinely pledging allegiance to The King, to the UK... and through this interview, I think I was right, should have trusted my gut right at the very beginning. Distrust and verify, now more distrust...and very likely won't even bother verifying again.
How can one not admire Yuan Yang immediately?!?! Admittedly, her Financial Times background and Labour Party membership made her instantly electable - undoubtedly intelligent, decent and reasonable, concerned for others - then we hear what she has to say. Fantastic!
Mr Vines, pls ask the following question when you interview her again , “Would you condemn Beijing’ s deed on HK publicly?” Most HONGKONERS want to know.the answer.
What's the point? Whatever your stance is, "condemnation" does not achieve anything. International relations rely on diplomacy, and diplomacy relies on compromise. No matter how much you like or want to defend certain political characters from HK, this British MP's "condemnation" will impact neither the UK's high-level diplomatic goals, nor China's.
@@canto_v12 China talks others listen is China's diplomacy. This MP represents the people she serves It is only right she expresses her views on the revisionist CCP and their desires to reshape the world
Thank you to Green Bean for arranging this interview and allowing us to know more about the first Chinese-born UK MP, Yuan Yang. However her response to the question regarding shutting down the Confucius institutes is extremely disappointing. There is absolutely no room for a direct arm of foreign state-owned propaganda being a part of UK, especially in academia that has so much direct access and influence to UK higher education. We want Confucius institutes across the UK shut down, full stop. There are no redeeming qualities for keeping them open other than funding for universities, but honestly the fees shouldn't be coming from the CCP in the first place. The Tories broke their promise and it looks like Labour is also ignoring the growing influence of China in the UK.
Totally agree with you. "Distrust and verify". She needs a much tougher position towards the Confucius institute. Confidence and trust could only be built on what Miss Yang will do in the future.
whatever has happened to freedom of speech, association etc the west has advocated all along? if there is any element of crime, prove it & let the authority deal with it
No, all three are very different. Alice Guo is different - she's an identity thief. Linda Sun has been acused of working for China but that's yet to be proven. Nothing against Yuan Yang. Speaking of being China-born and now residing in the UK, Nathan Law is like that too: he was born in Shenzhen China to a Chinese mum and Hong Kong Chinese dad.
What this Ms. Yang said in the interview was very very suspicious. She said “ and we need a proper graduation of what is the most important to look at, because there cannot be an approach where we just say, we are going to be afraid of everything that comes from China” As an ex-journalist who had worked onsite and upfront in Beijing, she definitely won’t be so native to give such remarks. We definitely need to be afraid of (and be cautious of) everything come from China now, including her!
@eruketo3969 You clearly hold a contemptuous view of uk democracy are you here disrespecting your host country by insinuating china controls the local populace or our democracy and put her in power??
I may not 100% agree on political views etc but it's good to see diversity in Parliament. Like she says, someone of south east Asian heritage who is looks like me makes people feel less alone
I hate to be judgmental but anyone who spent a long period of time in China should be approached with suspicion. She sounds very British here with a very British upbringing but sorry i gotta take my time to observe her actions before making my mind up about her
After watching many videos being made by people travelling to or living in China.. I think their leaders must be doing something right. A country of billions with almost no crime, murders, druggies or homeless, a country where the people have the freedom and the confidence to walk alone on their streets and feel perfectly safe day or night, and has raised millions out of poverty is a country I wish I was living in. I wish we had their kind of leaders.
@@georgelei12 well, it seems to me that 你個 abusive comment got removed 😂. 不過 allow me to extend my courtesy, 照 respond to 你個 peculiar comment. 1. My actions / comments can't represent BNO holders, 因為我從來都唔係. 2. BNO holders 搵到工 or not, 同咁講野irrelevant. 3. 我嘅國家 has been a free country for hundreds of years, so long as 唔係offensive / abusive, 點 express comments entirely up to individual 😌 再講丫, 你唔會係因為 using Vpn to access here, 又要用 translation software 先覺得 the way I wrote, upset you 😌
It seems no question asked of her long term ambition. She was a well-established FT journalist, why jumped into the muddy political arena, with one example - first Chinese MP Allen Mak in an ultra conservative seat still languishing as a backbencher years later? Such is not something aspiring young professionals chose to do normally! What is her real motivation? To change the society for the better, to better herself, or for any other more dubious reasons?
Listening to this conversation, I still preserve "concerns" having someone whose background is related to China involve in politics ..... Take heed!!! People can be bought with a price!!! Humans are fallible and can be tempted !!!
So could you then? and so could anyone else from any background. You've contradicted yourself in one comment. You can't just mistrust someone based on their ethnicity and family background... that's not what Britain's about. She must have become an mp based on merit, there are no token chinese mps, you can bet on that.
@@alexandershing You are wrong! Ethnicity and family background are close related: Families transmit culture as they socialize its members by teaching them how to behave , speak, and feel.They TRANSMIT ETHNICITY as they teach children their histories and who they are! Through the family, children learn ethnicity- related norms like marriages, religious values, dress and diet etc.The family's role in communicating cultural practices and traditions had a great influence on young adults' exploration of their.... In conclusion: Your ethnicity refers to your background heritage, culture, religion, ancestry . Your family shapes who are! Each human being receives a random mix of DNA from his or her parents, which means that person will inherit the parents' ethnicities! Your family of origin helps to shape your world view, determines how you relate to and interact with others! $$$$ is the source of all evil! Please refer to The Holy Bible 1 Timothy 6: 10
A smart person will change their view if new information contradicts their belief. An indoctrinated person lacks this ability. They are conditioned to dismiss facts
Mike Pompous also confessed to the world that while he was Director of CIA "we cheat, we steal, we lie" , and the CIA has a school to train their agents to do that "professionally ". He says it all for the terrorist rogue state Banana Republic of America (BRA) as well as the whole collective west ! 😂🎉😂
Interesting points of view. Obvious that responses on social media are quite uninhibited. Some downright aggressive too. Ms Yuan will have to work hard to break through such walls... All the best.
In contrast, I really appreciate the fact that Ms Yang certainly did her homework before the interview knowing what the issues the Hongkongers are focusing on. However, I do hope she understands nowadays it's normal for people being sensitive and extra cautious when it comes to politics for whoever with a Chinese origin and more importantly to sustainably cast their confidence votes for Ms Yang eventually. I don't doubt her understanding of what has happened and happening in Hong Kong with her journalism experience in Financial Times Bejing before, but perhaps to prove to all Hongkongers or even overseas Chinese "diaspora" that you're geniunely representing the interest of them, not just merely their interest "in the UK", but including to voice out and protect them from any form of threats from the China government if you know how intimadating that would be, we definitely deserve more than those beautiful words in the air in this interview.
@@Comte_de_Lorenzo you just don't understand living as a minority within a minority. Your points are valid on the the history of hk but have no comparison to this topic. No mp came out against increased racism and attacks against chinese over here because it doesn't matter to them not their problem.
After listening to Ms Yang’s uncleared reply on certain issues, I am surprised she got elected as a labour MP in Reading considering there are many Hongkongers living there.
Why do you care? BNOs now living in the UK should try hard to integrate and blend into the British society. You are a foreign agent and can't be trusted if you are still liviing your whole life aorund what's happening in HK China.
Thank you Green Bean Media . Thank you Steven. Thank you Yuan Yang. 毋忘831太子站 🚅 5th Anniversary of 831, . Town Hall (Sydney) & Victoria State Library ( Melbourne ) 🇦🇺 有相、有片、有義工們....... 歡迎 帶埋/介紹 任何國藉,任何語言的人🙏🙏🙏 仲有2套電影在澳洲同日放映 🎥 香港本色 Black Bauhinia (以英語為主，中英字幕 ) 墨爾本 Deakin Univerity 放映 記錄片澳洲首映 (英、美、韓、台、加、德、芬、的不少電影節中共得了12個奬項) 🎥 寧化飛灰 Rather Be Ashes Than Dust 珀斯上映 UWA Glory to Hong Kong . 讓全世界遍地開花 🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼 為未能發聲的，繼續發聲 📣📣📣
@@LAURA-oz8ls diaspora 的唯一負面是如聖經所說猶太人逃離本土而群集於本土以外的地方，這正是同香港人離港去英國有類似，很多外謀都用這說法，說者並设不見得別有用心。Diaspora有別於一般emigrants who left their homeland mainly by choice, not necessarily compelled to do so.
Her election to Parliament speaks volumes about the multicultural Britain of today. Britain should be proud of this and of her achievement. We need more Asian British citizens to help bridge the gap between East and West.
Precisely, it's such a positive step.. yet all I see in the comments are bitter Hong Konger comments pushing the notion that she cannot be trusted (simply based on the fact she was born in China over 2 decades ago). Sad. Also ironic how they're critical of the CCP being insecure about hong kong activists, yet they're doing the very same thing with ordinary Chinese people.
@@radiobeat1so all the foreigners who had experiences living in Beijing more than 6 years are suspicious? or Only British ethic Chinese? you are using as the same logic as CCP!
@@radiobeat1so all the foreigners who had experiences living in Beijing more than 6 years are suspicious? or Only British ethic Chinese? you are using as the same logic as CCP!
I would say that she gave quite reasonable answers. Of course I would have liked her to be more direct about confuscius institutes, but perhaps this not something she has looked into. Since she is already fluent in mandarin, and her mother was a Chinese history scholar, she was unlikely to have attended any Confucius institute events. If she were a CCP spy I think she would have held back a lot comments about things like protests all over China during 1989, as that is a narrative the CCP heavily suppresses even to this day. They like to paint it as a singular event in Tiananmen Square with violence that was appropriately handled. She does seems to understand the issues of HKers coming to the UK. I would say that she passes the bare minimum checks, and that we should see how she operates as an MP.
Well said, just give her some time as she's relatively " green" in the political circle,I wouldn't jump into conclusion.. I trust MI5 is not sleeping on the job?😶
There are a lot of comments decrying the fact she doesn’t outwardly say she supposed Taiwan independence- well most Labour MPs oppose self determination and independence for Scotland or Irish unity under any circumstances so it’s not that different - people in the UK love boasting and going on about other countries but ask them about the SNP and they will meltdown and say things they’d never say about another national group abroad. So unless you beleive in self determination at home you can wheeesht about China.
Has she familiy still in China & Hong Kong. Are any of them in the CCP what are her views on China regarding Trade, Taiwan, Phillipines, HK & Uighurs? She gives pragmatic answers rather than views. I agree the Institutes are not as big a threat as the self-censorship of some universities and the surveillance on Chinese students and others is. She doesn't agree with the sanctions on CCP individuals - that is the CCP narrative. She does a good talk at chartwellspeakers where she give good analysis but very little of her own opinion.
I hope this lady sees herself as MP representing all her constituents and not principally fellow ethnic Chinese. At a local Councillor level ethnic capture is a risk, where a major proportion of the representative's time is taken up with "case work" problems brought by their fellow ethnics to an extent that they do little else.
Good interview and interesting to hear from an MP with a very unique background which perhaps informs on her perspectives that many commentators here understandably have concerns about. She has a difficult job walking a very fine line. She seems like an articulate and intelligent person. Look forward to her work for her constituents.
🌱 greenbean.media Stripe / PayPal 付費支持 bit.ly/3NvZjud
題目 是否 應該 改為 China-born 會清晰得多 ?
@@LAURA-oz8ls直接寫Chinese啦😂
Steven, I love the way you do interviews. Hope to see more videos from you.
她在雷丁的集會（選舉）我們問了她一個問題［你支持自由民主，你誠認臺灣是否一個國家］，她不敢答，只帶遊花園，其他候選人都直答臺灣是個獨立國家，一個問題正實她是鬼，各位睇路。
講其他無用，用照妖鏡一照便現形
事實上，臺灣（Taiwan）絕非國家。毋庸置疑！
完全同意，全世界最了解他們真面目是香港人，當聽到其背景時，已經很有保留，不是歧視，而是大家裝理性地公平地對待他們之前，拜託不要低估洗腦教育的巨大深遠影響。。明白某組織不代表中國人，但不好意思洗腦教育已摧毀了中國人原本傳統的文化，起碼四代人的思維是完全某組織，即使他們在其他地方居住，但這種根深蒂固小動作思維是不會刪除到，大家要緊記這點，某組織是魔鬼，他們唯一做到很棒的事是完全破壞一個正常人的智慧及良知，這正正解釋為甚麼他們永遠只能抄西方國家的科技。。。
臺灣絕非國家。
臺灣非國家。
@@CWong-tp8gs 得罪一下，你根本不了解共產黨洗腦的禍害程度，甚至不知道洗腦教育是甚麼。。以香港為例，我認識絕不少在香港出世的藍絲，原來他們的父母是某國人，一個人成長過程是某國思維的氛圍下，一樣是容易變成小粉紅。。你亦不夠細心地觀察她的表達方式，在全世界討厭某國時，她明顯是有所保留。。我認識不少所謂外國長大的華人（父母非某國人），他們很明顯表達對某國的不安，甚至討厭。。難道你覺得間碟會跟你說自己是間碟嗎?😑🙄😐
Thank you green bean for arranging this
之前仲見到佢呀媽係中超拉票。仲有佢有出席雷丁區小粉紅嘅新年聚會。會唔會幫香港人真係令人懷疑😂
香港人過份幻想，自細受媽媽的共產思想影響，怎會對香港及英國有貢獻？？？做到議員，更能了解英國內政，是否會出賣英國？？？存疑？？？個人對她絕不相信！
幫唔幫 hongkongers 係其次, 有冇可能係李精駒進階版先係 something to be afraid of for the entire British society.
An undercover agent or proxy of PRC? That's the job of MI5 to find out?
關鍵在於身為英國公民兼國會議員的她，是否當眞為英國效忠，並為人民的公僕？
@@hinhangsiu6783 絕對不相信她會為英國入民服務，她為中共做間碟，賄賂英國議員。
Warm welcome again to Steve. Thank making such a nice program and looking forward to this series
如果我係佢個區，我一定唔會投佢。佢答嘢就住就住，當然我明投佢嘅唔止香港人，佢重要睇住‘’在英僑民‘’呀嘛。左右做人難，最後就係會咩都唔做，但權利在佢手，佢可以做好多其他嘢。所以我唔會take 呢個risk。
條女 係有問題㗎。
正直嘅人 好簡單，問一唔會答二，唔會兜圈。
我自己未必會去投票，但一見有中国人參選 就一定會去， 投俾其他族裔人。
@LAURA-oz8ls
Just proves you have no idea about the british culture 🤭, you should watch parliament more.
係中國人嘅意識裡面呢個就係“高情商”，即左右逢源，兩邊討好。價值觀是很難改變的，除非你因為價值觀離開中國
英國好多MP都係咁，答問題唔會答到無彎轉，如果認真知MP 能不能代表自己，就要睇佢在下議院講發言。
Don't forget she has to follow her Party's policy
A very good start. A long lost but still familiar voice of (the softly spoken) Steven. Of course, RTHK is now beyond recognition, sadly.
照抄自片中字幕，佢講：「我認為孔子學院已經成為憤怒和抗議的焦點，我認為有時候這種焦點放錯了地方。它們是中國政府資助大學中最顯眼的部分，但事實上我認為中國政府在大學中更具破壞性的影響並不那麼明顯，這可能體現在，比如說一些中國大陸的學生在學術討論或課堂上感到無法自由發言，因為他們擔心聽眾中，可能有人會告密。我認為，我們應該關注更嚴重的威脅是通過情報員、外國代理人、間諜等在英國的監視根源，我提到這一點因為在中英關係中存在許多不同的風險和威脅，同樣也有很多機會和好處，我們需要對最重要的議題進行適當的分類，因為我們不能採取一種對於來自中國的一切，都保持恐懼的態度。」
佢對孔子學院態度絕不含糊：我認為孔子學院已經成為憤怒和抗議的焦點，我認為有時候這種焦點放錯了地方。
依我理解，佢認為英國政府不能同一時間處理孔子學院及外國代理人、間諜問題，需要對最重要的議題進行適當的分類。
滲透採用多種形式進行，點會容許「不能同一時間處理」呢啲想法㗎。
總之，對任何來自中国的政客，都必須採取的態度是 Distrust, and verify.
連菲律賓都踢爆有中国人冒充 fake filipino 成為議員，中国滲透世界處心積慮，可以用幾十年去經營一個人。英國就更差，學生到移民，政客到律師，廚師到理髮師，各行各業 周身瘡癬疥癩。有朝發作 真係唔得佢死。
@@LAURA-oz8lsI concur, way before this interview when I first saw the name popped up, it's like freakin alarm bell ringing like nuts.
Despite myself trying very hard to stay impartial, I remain very much doubtful for her being genuinely pledging allegiance to The King, to the UK...
and through this interview, I think I was right, should have trusted my gut right at the very beginning.
Distrust and verify, now more distrust...and very likely won't even bother verifying again.
回帶去記反起2017年的『中華人民共和國國家情報法』。孔子學院是最直接玩國家情報法的地方~
作为一个在UCL的硕士生，我的感觉是这一点她没说错。多数时候压力并不直接来自和中国有关的机构，而是中国同学之间。当然，审核孔子学院和保障大陆学生在英国的学术自由应该是相互促进而不是互相矛盾的，这是我不同意她的地方。
@@jude3288 楊議員認為比孔子學院更具威脅的是一些中國大陸的學生在學術討論或課堂上感到無法自由發言，因為他們擔心聽眾中，可能有人會告密。但楊議員所屬的工黨剛上台就廢除《高等教育（言論自由）法案》。是否講一套做一套呢？
針對孔子學院，楊議員就認為是放錯焦點；針對學術言論自由，楊議員的工黨就廢除《高等教育（言論自由）法案》。即是甚麼中共的都不應亦不能針對啦！
I really like the interview, thank you Green bean
How can one not admire Yuan Yang immediately?!?!
Admittedly, her Financial Times background and Labour Party membership made her instantly electable - undoubtedly intelligent, decent and reasonable, concerned for others - then we hear what she has to say.
Fantastic!
Mr Vines, pls ask the following question when you interview her again , “Would you condemn Beijing’ s deed on HK publicly?” Most HONGKONERS want to know.the answer.
Great question
What's the point? Whatever your stance is, "condemnation" does not achieve anything. International relations rely on diplomacy, and diplomacy relies on compromise. No matter how much you like or want to defend certain political characters from HK, this British MP's "condemnation" will impact neither the UK's high-level diplomatic goals, nor China's.
@@canto_v12 China talks others listen is China's diplomacy. This MP represents the people she serves It is only right she expresses her views on the revisionist CCP and their desires to reshape the world
有所保留，全家已入籍英國，在英教育長大，玩遊戲除了吃其後也冇正面答。。。可圈可點。。。最怕是棉裡針笑臉虎。😅
很多基本立場問題都想含糊其詞不得罪兩邊，太滑頭滑腦了，我不相信這個MP真心為英國為民主自由。希望她能做出實際行動令我改觀
Worrying about the safety of her relatives in PRC? So, she cannot speak out the truth?
@@rlam8867If she can’t even speak because of it, then how could she act as a MP without interference from communist China?
@@rlam8867I think this is the main reason why she can’t say anything harmful to the Chinese government and the U.K. at the same time.
@@rlam8867 If that is true, then PRC can control her.
@@rlam8867 In that case, do not join politics in a Western country.
Always happy to see Steve Vines. The Pulse was such a good show
孔子學院，答咗等於冇答，含糊其詞！
same thought...
你細讀下面詳細節錄該段說話，已有答案：大陸學生在大學不能蜴所欲言，怕被監控和告密？（但她所講的大學並不是孔子學院）。暗示中英政府各自有更大的利益問題去處理，即係孔子學院無須理會。
我個人對她絕對不相信。
@@isabellawun 信者失救！
絕對會講好中國故事，一如姓金的女教授
welcome back steve. Great to see you around again
Thank you to Green Bean for arranging this interview and allowing us to know more about the first Chinese-born UK MP, Yuan Yang. However her response to the question regarding shutting down the Confucius institutes is extremely disappointing. There is absolutely no room for a direct arm of foreign state-owned propaganda being a part of UK, especially in academia that has so much direct access and influence to UK higher education. We want Confucius institutes across the UK shut down, full stop. There are no redeeming qualities for keeping them open other than funding for universities, but honestly the fees shouldn't be coming from the CCP in the first place. The Tories broke their promise and it looks like Labour is also ignoring the growing influence of China in the UK.
Totally agree with you. "Distrust and verify". She needs a much tougher position towards the Confucius institute. Confidence and trust could only be built on what Miss Yang will do in the future.
I agree with your remarks. At the moment I don't have much trust and confidence in miss Yang
@@CC-kx9jg I agree with your comments. Miss young was avoiding a direct response to the question.
文革時還批孔，中共卻以孔子為品牌！
whatever has happened to freedom of speech, association etc the west has advocated all along? if there is any element of crime, prove it & let the authority deal with it
I love that there’s English programs .Thx!👍
Nice to see Mr Vines doing the program for Green Beans
Great. Thank you.
佢提到小時候去到英國之後經常搬家、令我聯想到日本人被派到海外長駐工作、好多時「收通知」之後就會移到另一個地區工作。
Thank you for interviewing this Miss Yang. We know more about her now.
Yuan Yang, Alice Guo and Linda Sun they have similar background.
No, all three are very different.
Alice Guo is different - she's an identity thief. Linda Sun has been acused of working for China but that's yet to be proven. Nothing against Yuan Yang.
Speaking of being China-born and now residing in the UK, Nathan Law is like that too: he was born in Shenzhen China to a Chinese mum and Hong Kong Chinese dad.
Wish her the best of luck.
What this Ms. Yang said in the interview was very very suspicious.
She said “ and we need a proper graduation of what is the most important to look at, because there cannot be an approach where we just say, we are going to be afraid of everything that comes from China”
As an ex-journalist who had worked onsite and upfront in Beijing, she definitely won’t be so native to give such remarks.
We definitely need to be afraid of (and be cautious of) everything come from China now, including her!
中國投放間諜過去也試過用上20,30年。😂😅
係最好個幾年去咗北京做記者，全身而退，返英國即刻從政。唔會信呢個背景囉。
How did she get to MP is what needs to be afraid of in the first place.
@eruketo3969
You clearly hold a contemptuous view of uk democracy are you here disrespecting your host country by insinuating china controls the local populace or our democracy and put her in power??
racist
She is excellent -I wish her all the best!
I may not 100% agree on political views etc but it's good to see diversity in Parliament. Like she says, someone of south east Asian heritage who is looks like me makes people feel less alone
佢答孔子學院o個段好可疑
I hate to be judgmental but anyone who spent a long period of time in China should be approached with suspicion. She sounds very British here with a very British upbringing but sorry i gotta take my time to observe her actions before making my mind up about her
英國人有一句話Wolf in sheep's skin 😂
Your logic would extend to HKers as well since HK is now under complete Chinese control
答左等於冇搭 不如唔好接受訪問😅😅😅
多謝！
謝謝你
After watching many videos being made by people travelling to or living in China.. I think their leaders must be doing something right. A country of billions with almost no crime, murders, druggies or homeless, a country where the people have the freedom and the confidence to walk alone on their streets and feel perfectly safe day or night, and has raised millions out of poverty is a country I wish I was living in. I wish we had their kind of leaders.
indeed. That is what the state controlled media report.
@@Andy-P I live in China. I think everything he said is pretty much true, although the country isn't perfect.
@@michaelodonovan3732 Happy for you. China is still the enemy.
Only because CCTV everywhere and AI facial recognition
If you live there, you won't know about there @@michaelodonovan3732
I am rather relieved that seems 大部份 left comments 嘅 hongkongers 警覺性高 👍🏻
@@ricchrono5907
something that only hongkongers will understand
Can you write a proper sentence in either Cantonese or English?
@@georgelei12 depends 😌 點解呢 ? 有 issue?
@@ricchrono5907 no wonder many BNOs can’t find jobs in the UK. Pathetic
@@georgelei12 well, it seems to me that 你個 abusive comment got removed 😂.
不過 allow me to extend my courtesy, 照 respond to 你個 peculiar comment.
1. My actions / comments can't represent BNO holders, 因為我從來都唔係.
2. BNO holders 搵到工 or not, 同咁講野irrelevant.
3. 我嘅國家 has been a free country for hundreds of years, so long as 唔係offensive / abusive, 點 express comments entirely up to individual 😌
再講丫, 你唔會係因為 using Vpn to access here, 又要用 translation software 先覺得 the way I wrote, upset you 😌
Great interview, thanks Green Bean!
👍 Love your interesting interview with open mind, positive and no geopolitics involved.
This is a great episode
It seems no question asked of her long term ambition. She was a well-established FT journalist, why jumped into the muddy political arena, with one example - first Chinese MP Allen Mak in an ultra conservative seat still languishing as a backbencher years later? Such is not something aspiring young professionals chose to do normally! What is her real motivation? To change the society for the better, to better herself, or for any other more dubious reasons?
Listening to this conversation, I still preserve "concerns" having someone whose background is related to China involve in politics .....
Take heed!!! People can be bought with a price!!! Humans are fallible and can be tempted !!!
So could you then? and so could anyone else from any background. You've contradicted yourself in one comment. You can't just mistrust someone based on their ethnicity and family background... that's not what Britain's about. She must have become an mp based on merit, there are no token chinese mps, you can bet on that.
@@alexandershing You are wrong! Ethnicity and family background are close related: Families transmit culture as they socialize its members by teaching them how to behave , speak, and feel.They TRANSMIT ETHNICITY as they teach children their histories and who they are!
Through the family, children learn ethnicity- related norms like
marriages, religious values, dress and diet etc.The family's role in communicating cultural practices and traditions had a great influence on young adults' exploration of their....
In conclusion: Your ethnicity refers to your background heritage, culture, religion, ancestry .
Your family shapes who are!
Each human being receives a random mix of DNA from his or her parents, which means that person will inherit the parents' ethnicities!
Your family of origin helps to shape your world view, determines how you relate to and interact with others!
$$$$ is the source of all evil! Please refer to The Holy Bible 1 Timothy 6: 10
@@alexandershingmaster時收ccp獎學金返北京交換，唔係族裔家庭背景啦啩？正常學生都唔會返出世祖國做交換，我喺臺灣大學畢業，佢哋有條文禁止外國學生返祖國交換的，即係香港交換計劃我唔可以申請。
A smart person will change
their view if new information contradicts
their belief.
An indoctrinated person lacks this ability. They are conditioned to dismiss
facts
@cryptorenegade1406 I agree. No idea what Lorenzo said.. wish it was in English so I could understand.
Cool af❤
有算素的訪問！👍💪🙏🥰
多謝綠豆！🙏🙏🙏
謝謝你
謝謝你支持
咁都叫有質素，綠豆班友越黎越左。最戇鳩搵工黨。
希望下次有機會訪問鄧蓮茹爵士， 她對香港故事有深厚認識。
佢唔會講嘢
唔會在公開發表啦
一嚟上面已經講過佢唔會講嘢 二嚟其實佢認識嘅issue大多係已成歷史嘅議題 現代時事嘅話佢已退隱多年基本應該係無乜嘢好分享😅😊
Like Pompeo said, " Distrust, and verify". Let's wait and see.
she's a ccp spy in no doubt !
Pompeo also said that they themselves "lie and deceit all the time"
Mike Pompous also confessed to the world that while he was Director of CIA "we cheat, we steal, we lie" , and the CIA has a school to train their agents to do that "professionally ". He says it all for the terrorist rogue state Banana Republic of America (BRA) as well as the whole collective west ! 😂🎉😂
Interesting points of view. Obvious that responses on social media are quite uninhibited. Some downright aggressive too. Ms Yuan will have to work hard to break through such walls... All the best.
綠豆你給她帶著走，小心呀
事實上，楊緣是在中共政權支配下的中國大陸（Chinese Mainland）出生的。
千萬不要低估洗腦教育的摧毀性，無論他們待在西方國家多久，這種“你笨，我聰明”的小動作思維是極難改掉。。她對某國的看法極度有保留已經說明了。。
@@stardust_car0908最讓我憂慮的就是大陸人即使移民至發達國家多年，兼且早已歸化入籍，可是依舊愚忠於中共政權！
@@stardust_car0908共諜大都是來自中國大陸，並已歸化入籍發達國家的大陸人。
Great interview, Steve. More like this please.
Loving it! Thank you!
In contrast, I really appreciate the fact that Ms Yang certainly did her homework before the interview knowing what the issues the Hongkongers are focusing on. However, I do hope she understands nowadays it's normal for people being sensitive and extra cautious when it comes to politics for whoever with a Chinese origin and more importantly to sustainably cast their confidence votes for Ms Yang eventually.
I don't doubt her understanding of what has happened and happening in Hong Kong with her journalism experience in Financial Times Bejing before, but perhaps to prove to all Hongkongers or even overseas Chinese "diaspora" that you're geniunely representing the interest of them, not just merely their interest "in the UK", but including to voice out and protect them from any form of threats from the China government if you know how intimadating that would be, we definitely deserve more than those beautiful words in the air in this interview.
Thank you ❤
Great job Green Bean.
無論說話內容，肢體語言，背景行為， E 條女都係 完全 信唔過。
Chinese population over here is heavily under represented.
@@gmanlee575一定要華裔血統黃皮黑毛先可以為香港人發聲？19年起幾多自民黨、保守黨議員為香港奔走過？自民黨甚至連粵白文宣都出埋，全部無一個係華裔嘅。你咁變相逆向歧視其他種族喎仁兄。
@@Comte_de_Lorenzo you just don't understand living as a minority within a minority. Your points are valid on the the history of hk but have no comparison to this topic. No mp came out against increased racism and attacks against chinese over here because it doesn't matter to them not their problem.
@@gmanlee575 你自己都話咗港僑係minority within minority，即係港僑本質上係同華僑有分別係唔同群體，咁所以港僑睇嘢梗係以hk history香港本位角度嚟諗嘢，而唔係用你嗰套大中華racist attack睇嘢。當年武漢肺炎時共匪咪有操弄過你嗰套racism attack論述搞遊行，最尾咪又係港僑團體聯同埋我之前講嗰班愛港英國政客出嚟正本清源。
不要立场先行， 抵触他人，要合作，理解与包容。
After listening to Ms Yang’s uncleared reply on certain issues, I am surprised she got elected as a labour MP in Reading considering there are many Hongkongers living there.
楊緣，中英文都掂，繼續加油，為華人爭光💪
與江旻憓係同類，面上善良，其實內裏係想踩喺香港人上邊，掩蓋香港人嘅能力，然後就會掩蓋咗香港人嘅意見。
Why do you care? BNOs now living in the UK should try hard to integrate and blend into the British society. You are a foreign agent and can't be trusted if you are still liviing your whole life aorund what's happening in HK China.
Thank you Steve.
Thank you Green Bean Media .
Thank you Steven.
Thank you Yuan Yang.
毋忘831太子站 🚅
5th Anniversary of 831, .
Town Hall (Sydney) &
Victoria State Library ( Melbourne ) 🇦🇺
有相、有片、有義工們.......
歡迎 帶埋/介紹 任何國藉,任何語言的人🙏🙏🙏
仲有2套電影在澳洲同日放映
🎥 香港本色 Black Bauhinia (以英語為主，中英字幕 )
墨爾本 Deakin Univerity 放映 記錄片澳洲首映 (英、美、韓、台、加、德、芬、的不少電影節中共得了12個奬項)
🎥 寧化飛灰 Rather Be Ashes Than Dust
珀斯上映 UWA
Glory to Hong Kong .
讓全世界遍地開花
🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼
為未能發聲的，繼續發聲 📣📣📣
仲有個消息，候鳥月餅又俾人搞，之前訂了海外的已經寄出，不受影響。
佢係整個訪問中 4 次用 diaspora (僑民) 形容在英中國人、香港人。
Chinese Diaspora in Britain = 在英華僑，首先還是中國人。(聯想到時任中國外交部長王毅回應銅鑼灣書店李波是英國公民的時候，特別指出李波根據《基本法》及《中國國籍法》，首先是中國公民。入咗英籍依然當你係華僑！)
British Chinese = 華裔英國人，首先是英國人。
當然，大部份 BNO 港人仍未入英籍，佢講法無錯，還是中國人/香港人。只係好少聽到其他族裔用 diaspora 形容自己族群而已！
就算BNO未入籍，個國籍都係英藉。所以要諗清楚佢咁小心用一個咁特別嘅字係咪別有用心。
@@eruketo3969絕對別有用心，入到英國政壇，為中共服務，更方便。
BNO 係華裔英國人，唔係中國/中国人，唔好搞錯。
Diaspora 在希臘字源本身已經有負面意思，簡單易明既 Immigrant 唔用，而要用Diaspora 係非常有問題。 最好笑佢自己本身就係。
@@LAURA-oz8ls diaspora 的唯一負面是如聖經所說猶太人逃離本土而群集於本土以外的地方，這正是同香港人離港去英國有類似，很多外謀都用這說法，說者並设不見得別有用心。Diaspora有別於一般emigrants who left their homeland mainly by choice, not necessarily compelled to do so.
Diaspora是族群的意思。比如首相苏纳克属于是British Indian diaspora，奥巴马属于African American diaspora.
It was a great interview and it was great to see a Chinese born MP working in parliament.
Her election to Parliament speaks volumes about the multicultural Britain of today. Britain should be proud of this and of her achievement. We need more Asian British citizens to help bridge the gap between East and West.
Precisely, it's such a positive step.. yet all I see in the comments are bitter Hong Konger comments pushing the notion that she cannot be trusted (simply based on the fact she was born in China over 2 decades ago). Sad. Also ironic how they're critical of the CCP being insecure about hong kong activists, yet they're doing the very same thing with ordinary Chinese people.
楊議員認為比孔子學院更具威脅的是一些中國大陸的學生在學術討論或課堂上感到無法自由發言，因為他們擔心聽眾中，可能有人會告密。但楊議員所屬的工黨剛上台就廢除《高等教育（言論自由）法案》。是否講一套做一套呢？
針對孔子學院，楊議員就認為是放錯焦點；針對學術言論自由，楊議員的工黨就廢除《高等教育（言論自由）法案》。即是甚麼中共的都不應亦不能針對啦！
Thank you Green Bean❤
睇完。尼位女士吾係好掂。冇乜準備就來接受訪問。更加冇政治智慧可言。
You could have done better I'm sure. Can you even speak English?
High quality interview
謝謝你
❤🎉😊繼續做好每個訪問
謝謝你
@@greenbeanmediaofficial Thanks for selling out our country.
Lot of thanks Steve☝️👍
The fact that there are so many shills for the Chinese government in this comments section is worrying.
Congratulations. Great to have a Chinese born M.P. It will surely help in World Foreign Politics.
Keep up green beans media 😊
Thx you all of you. 🙏🙏
Thanks
謝謝你
Dr J piano solo - made in Hong Kong - NOT china - ruclips.net/video/m5bVt0DFBoc/видео.html - Thanks Green Bean Media to clarify this new MP
中共駐英代理人，鑒定完畢！
Thank you Green Bean. She is China born. Hopefully in the not too distant future, we will have a Hong Kong born MP.
*was
Wow, still no HK born MPs ? In Canada, there has been a HK born Governor-General, a Premier and a Mayor...
很好的訪問，見識資深傳媒人的功力，期待Steve更多訪問。
對楊小姐有初步認識，日久見人心，楊小姐努力，不要令選民失望。
14:00,完全係在「兜圈回答」。😅
Was a great answer. What did you want to hear
@@alexandershingWould be a great answer to you if you're a CCP spy
Disappointing... 已經是英國人了，對孔子學院的問題居然這樣回答。
Where.? I dont have time to watch the whole video
六年駐京記者....算罷啦～
六年卧底政治特務訓練
我都覺，喺中國出世真係唔係問題，但有得揀嘅情況下仲去中國長駐六年就真係好可疑
@@radiobeat1so all the foreigners who had experiences living in Beijing more than 6 years are suspicious? or Only British ethic Chinese? you are using as the same logic as CCP!
@@radiobeat1so all the foreigners who had experiences living in Beijing more than 6 years are suspicious? or Only British ethic Chinese? you are using as the same logic as CCP!
美国的副总统候选人Tim Waltz也去过中国30多次，包括在中国支教1年。你要不要也说他是间谍？
From your readers comments it’s obvious they cannot accept the return of Hk to China. Work hard and compete .
As long as she has families in CCPLand she's at risk
She should never get clearences to our secret stuff.... but I think she will
I would say that she gave quite reasonable answers.
Of course I would have liked her to be more direct about confuscius institutes, but perhaps this not something she has looked into.
Since she is already fluent in mandarin, and her mother was a Chinese history scholar, she was unlikely to have attended any Confucius institute events.
If she were a CCP spy I think she would have held back a lot comments about things like protests all over China during 1989, as that is a narrative the CCP heavily suppresses even to this day. They like to paint it as a singular event in Tiananmen Square with violence that was appropriately handled.
She does seems to understand the issues of HKers coming to the UK.
I would say that she passes the bare minimum checks, and that we should see how she operates as an MP.
Well said, just give her some time as she's relatively " green" in the political circle,I wouldn't jump into conclusion.. I trust MI5 is not sleeping on the job?😶
❤❤
我只希望她會遵守承諾，履行職務。再者這個世界為錢名利食言的人實在太多了！
我唔會選佢、佢話我無知都係咁話
There are a lot of comments decrying the fact she doesn’t outwardly say she supposed Taiwan independence- well most Labour MPs oppose self determination and independence for Scotland or Irish unity under any circumstances so it’s not that different - people in the UK love boasting and going on about other countries but ask them about the SNP and they will meltdown and say things they’d never say about another national group abroad. So unless you beleive in self determination at home you can wheeesht about China.
I would say that Miss Yang's parents were very successful in bringing up their daughter in an apolitical environment.
💪🏻💪🏻⛽️⛽️
Support class
👏👏👏👏👏
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
HONG KONG ALWAYS LIKE THEIR OWN WAY.
What does she think of Sinophobe Iain Duncan Smith and his interparliamentary anti China hawks?
I wonder what Tugendhat thinks of her? I shudder to think because he has an unnatural hatred for anyone Chinese.
She doesn't articulate her personal views. With her background she should never get clearences to our secrets.
@@Andy-P Britain's secret is laighable at best.
Has she familiy still in China & Hong Kong. Are any of them in the CCP what are her views on China regarding Trade, Taiwan, Phillipines, HK & Uighurs? She gives pragmatic answers rather than views. I agree the Institutes are not as big a threat as the self-censorship of some universities and the surveillance on Chinese students and others is. She doesn't agree with the sanctions on CCP individuals - that is the CCP narrative. She does a good talk at chartwellspeakers where she give good analysis but very little of her own opinion.
好紅…… 我指佢件衫，仲有响國會發言果件都係好紅。
I had attended renming hall conference as provincial representative
Poor girl, she gets the most hate from the hong kongers, I guess
I hope this lady sees herself as MP representing all her constituents and not principally fellow ethnic Chinese. At a local Councillor level ethnic capture is a risk, where a major proportion of the representative's time is taken up with "case work" problems brought by their fellow ethnics to an extent that they do little else.
士py
Good interview and interesting to hear from an MP with a very unique background which perhaps informs on her perspectives that many commentators here understandably have concerns about. She has a difficult job walking a very fine line. She seems like an articulate and intelligent person. Look forward to her work for her constituents.
👍👍🙏🙏