Scott Galloway On Why America Is A Nation 'Adrift' | One-on-One With Stephanie Ruhle
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2022
- Author, professor and podcast host Scott Galloway argues America is a nation “adrift.” Stephanie Ruhle sits down one-on-one with him to find out why and how to fix it.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
Follow the MSNBC Midterms Elections guide to the important races across the United States as Americans prepare to cast their votes.
Countdown to the Midterms: on.msnbc.com/3KlULq8
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersRUclips
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#msnbc #scottgalloway #america
I like this guy. I think he really knows what's really happening!
He might be able to chart what is happening but he has no clue as to why unless you consider the fact he commingles it with politics that are decidedly far left wing and fascist
@@terrific804 lol he seems to have a lot more knowledge than you. You’re probably one of those incels he’s referring to, living in your mom’s basement.
He literally said people need to set politics aside, so no, he’s not a far left ‘fascist’. The far right seems to be the ones trying to overthrow democracy, by the by.
@@terrific804 It's obvious that you don't have a clue what fascism is! It's definitely not left wing! Hitler & Mussolini were not leftist liberals! You need to go back to history books and re-educate yourself!
@@zdk1099 What is left...what is right...lol. I'll bet you can't even tell me what a woman is😳
@@zdk1099 What is left...what is right...lol. I'll bet you can't even tell me what a woman is😳
If I was attending his University, I would take every class Scott Galloway taught.
Lots of thought provoking insights. I could watch a whole hour of this.
He is simply documenting facts. But then he uses them in an attempt to legitimize a radical left wing agenda at the same time proposing both sides need to talk it out. Of course we need to talk and that's where he should leave it, not try for example tell you that young men who may have become isolated from the brainwashed are now climate change deniers. 😴
Love me some Galloway.
Been a follower for years. Great mind and soulful individual.
Clearly a fascist
He really caught my attention with this conversation, listen to this man. He is absolutely right, its common sense. He's very smart, and I agree, Qualified!! Thank you!! Mic'22
What an enlightening interview. We need to see more of Galloway.
PIVOT, worth a ✔️
No, we don't.
he's already everywhere 🤣
@@gustavbrinkel5489 Yes, much like that lonely voice crying out in the wilderness - Jordan Peterson.
Right here - 4 days out of 7 - 52 weeks a year.
The poor shrinking violet.
Danged cancel culture is always drowning out his urgently needed, selflessly offered wise counsel.
🙄
@@MrVonBastardBaseless opinion noted.
Thank you for your book. As a mother of a son that felt that he slipped through the cracks, my heart aches for our boys snd young men. In his mid thirties my son is getting excellent counseling after trying to take his own life several times. Thank you again for using your voice to illuminate the decline of our middle class.
Really hoping your son gets the help he needs and may he find happiness and get better soon
" Think and Grow Rich "
Napolean Hill 1933.. ...
Ain't about Money.
Spiritual...and the Money Flows to you..
David Thomas . " Dave's Way. " . 2 books.
I knew Dave Thomas.
The problem is women hypergamy, not decline of middle class. I haven't seen recent data but 5-10 years ago, middle shrunk by 11%, 7% of them moved up a class and 4% went down a class so statistics can be misleading.
@Scott
Fun fact: Men prefer dating “down” . Something to do with hierarchy and being the decider at home.
The disappearance of the middle class has to do with inflation and taxation mainly, because wealth is built overwhelmingly with real estate in the US. Stocks second. So you might want to reinterpret that data
@@AgeOfGoldenSilence I think there is some truth to men dating down but that would be for mostly non college males and it doesn’t change the fact that most women are still dating up and the combination of the two is a problem. Also majority of women prefer their male partner to be confident and a leader. This is where their feminist has them with one foot in past and one in present. Lots of preference on both genders need to be adjusted to fit current equality.
The decline of the the middle class is a misnomer that politicians push. My stats are correct and facts are more people moved up a class than went down. Doesn’t matter how they did it. Not saying we shouldn’t try to build up numbers of middle class but cannot do it via gov money.
What an amazing man. More please.
Wow! This is a very important interview. I didn't agree with everything said, but that's OK too! This needs thousands more views on RUclips!
Nor I yet it was informative.
Wow we're doing what he was telling us to do loll, focus less on disagreements and more on the person! I didn't agree with everything either, but those were just details. It's fine. Overall, I really enjoyed the interview. :)
What DID you disagree with? 🧐 Curious.
Outstanding interview, Stephanie! Scott Galloway's insights and conclusions right on the money. Hope to see more of him.
Well he was wrong about his nephew who died from COVID.
@@leagarner3675 Because a vaccine could save him how was he wrong? Are you an anti-vaxer?
Scott is brilliant, love hearing him interviewed
I completely agree. This was an excellent segment!
I did a bicycle trip across the mid west and I found Americans to be the friendliest in the world. You are good people. Thanks to all of the people who showed your love to strangers.
As long as you praise their moronic leaders and propagandistic media.
This is true. We have many great people here. Strange though, how smart nice people make terrible political decisions, and fall for ridiculous propaganda. It all comes back to capitalism, IMO. At the root of so many problems here, when you look deeply into it
Where are you from? That has ALOT to do with how "nice" Midwestern people present themselves.
@@jtcali2086 Canada. I crossed the border at the Soo in Michigan and cycled to Boulder Colorado. I met a lot of very nice people.
:)
(MN here)
Love her voice, intellect, and genuine presence. She's not just reading a monitor.
Galloway says so much so quickly
Scott is very Bright unfortunately most of society are the complete opposite many Americans are proud of lack of knowledge.
This interview sold me on this book! Great last question btw 👍 He wasn't expecting it and it hit him right in the feels 🥲
This is truly a rare take on
Society as it is!
Not only Eloquently expressed, but Stephany was Amazing!
And
So was Mr. Galloway.
This interview seemed absolutely unscripted and Fabulous!
Like 2 best Friends speaking with the same wave link
With a Unique Questions from
Stephanie, followed with Eloquent Answers by
Mr.Galloway.
I have observed many interviews, yet have rarely
Seen one so natural as this one.
I Definitely enjoyed it!
I will buy
Mr. Galloway Book
And
Focus more Attention on Stephanie Ruhle.
Thank you both!
"AMAZING, REALLY"! 👍🙋💜
1-K 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
I’m 😮
America should start by choosing a leader that holds up those values, and not some lunatic that wants to be a dictator and does nothing but lie to pump up his ridiculous ego. How about not choosing criminals or racists for senators, how about choosing people that actually will work for the people???! Mr. Gallaway seems like a decent, caring person, I hope his book helps for people to understand. VOTE BLUE 💙💙💙💙💙
Buyden has to go
This fellow needs to be shown more as he uses critical thinking skills and calling a spade a spade.
He’s working with the Government.
@@karenburns9952Lol! What on earth are you talking about?!?
I really appreciate how Scott Galloway views problems in our society...so real, but also hopeful. Stephanie Ruhle is such a great interviewer...she tells it how it is!!
Mr. Galloway is more than impressive. Wow! I would like to add one phrase to his statements, one that I heard lately, and that should end all politization of science: "Science is NOT an opinion."
As Neil DeGrasse Tyson has pointed out, unlike religion, science is true, whether you believe it or not.
Science can be weaponized though. Remember when Fauci said, “If you question me, you question science.” That’s what is meant by the politicalization of science. No man is above reproach and certainly transparency is key to science.
@@freefastinflippinfun4606 Transparency is not key to science, transparency is intrinsic to science. There is no such thing as non transparent science.
@@chrissaris6869 what? Science relies on replicable experiments. That is by definition transparency. Holy Christ I’m terrified you don’t know the most basic aspect of science.
@@freefastinflippinfun4606 Now what is your point? you state exactly wat I say. By the way, I actually AM a scientist.
Thanks for this, Stephanie. I was not familiar with Scott Galloway until I saw this brilliant interview. I will be paying attention to him from now on. So many things stood out to me in this thought provoking piece, but the downward spiral of young men really jumped out at me. As a therapist, I've always said that the worst (and cruelest) social crime perpetrated by society on boys (who eventually become men) was convincing them that emotions were the enemy and they should not ever acknowledge them or show them because it made them weak. It's a social norm that's been around for generations and the chickens are now coming home to roost. It was only a matter of time before it began to seriously affect men's functioning because they've been denying and repressing a huge part of themselves. Nobody can function in that state indefinitely. I am saddened but not at all surprised by these findings. The question is, what are we gonna do about it?
How come the chickens are only now coming home to roost and not centuries or millennia ago? Why particularly this generation and mostly in the West?
@@Lerian_V I'm not sure if this is a sincere question or an attempt at being defensive; hard to tell on the internet, so I'll just suggest that you really think about your question, break it down into its component parts, and see if you can't answer it yourself.
@@SaddleInTheRain I was trying to understand the comparison between men in the past and today's men.
@@Lerian_V A sincere question then; my apologies. The simplest and shortest answer is that raising boys to be tough and emotionless is a modern/post modern phenomenon. It just wasn't a societal issue prior to the Industrial Revolution. Norms and social mores change over time, and prior to the Industrial Revolution, the occupation of many was farming and the whole family was involved. Families were focusing on their farms and making enough money each season to make it to the next season. The socially proscribed roles and behaviors that we are just beginning to get past simply didn't exist or at least weren't touted by society. As to why this generation and why mostly in the west, I think this generation is recognizing how wrong it is on a fundamental level, but doesn't know what to do with those feelings of anger, confusion, resentment. They're just overwhelmed and don't know how to process it all and we're seeing the psychological fallout from that. It does seem to be a western character trait and I really don't know why (something for me to research). I will say, however, that compared to other developed countries, we lag behind in so many areas (no universal healthcare, no real programs that support families, a substandard educational system, elevated child poverty, the list goes on and on) so it's not really a surprise that we would be dysfunctional in this area too. Also, it's hard to claim that women are overly emotional - and therefore somehow inferior (another long standing, if erroneous, norm) - if you allow men to also show their emotions.
@@SaddleInTheRain Are you saying that men are tougher and more stoic today than they were under the [Holy] Roman empire?
Scott is the real deal!
Cant wait to read his book
What an encouraging guest! Really enjoyed this talk!
Brilliant interview, I was blessed growing up in a middle class Family, Most our Parents Grandparents Uncles served during WW1 and 2, peaceful loving People, need to do more in this life
Refreshing to see people at least trying to have a reasonable conversation!
That time is over. You don't get to have your president call half the nation racist because we have different political philosophies... Especially when democrats policies are clearly failing.
Because you are a man
What a fantastic interview!
that was fantastic. incredible interview.
I watch you often Stephanie. You always make sense out of what is being said. Mostly, it's real reporting and the news and truths of what goes on daily. Thank you.
Stephanie has one of the best Cable shows in Air, what a gem if diversity. Fan since the finance days, great interview, PIVOT a ✔️ out!
Excellent interview. Scott Galloway is so articulate and brilliant
Scott Galloway is a great scholar, and a truly good man. Thanks for this terrific interview
I don't know if he wants to run for office, but he is a unicorn: he speaks about building up the middle class and he supports issues that might be perceived as Republican (like strengthening families, young men, clamping down on tech companies) but he does so while also supporting immigrants, being an East Coast business professor, and wanting to eliminate polarization. He can appeal to Dems, Republicans, and independents. More importantly: he states exactly what is ailing the country. SOME politician needs to take their cue from this man.
I’m tearing up. I love you two so much. Thank you for helping us.
Thank you for this amazing discussion.
It saddens me that a large portion of our country continues to miss out on content such as this.
This is democratic propaganda
@@marjoriebreslin2995 perhaps. I mostly vote Democrat and I think this guy is talking bunk. In fact, if you only listen without watching it's worse. He sounds fake. He's taken old tropes and tried to wrap them in newer language to sell his book. He sounds like another person saying if we would all be good little kiddies and follow his "expert" guidance we will have roses and sunshine - He's just trying to wrap it up differently. I agree with you, tho not necessarily that its Democrat, but definitely propaganda. I don't trust him partly bc I've heard other interviews w him and he says different things in different interviews - he's certainly good at telling people what they want to hear. Taking advantage of divisions in our country to sell his book.
How did I miss this!? This interview captured a lot of how I feel about the US. I’ll check out the book for sure.
That was enlightening.
Big thank you to Scott Galloway for appreciating the people of the US government. Yes, there are many goofs and mismanagers, but it’s mostly good people that care about our country and that keep the machine working, a machine the world benefits from in many ways.
I'm glad I met you tonight Scott Galloway, thank you
"Fascism came to America wrapped around the FLAG carrying a Holy Bible upside ⬇down." Joe ROGAIN
So it's your "truth" that defines fascism😂
What a title for a book ‘ Adrift ‘. That just sums up the USA at the moment. He should have added ‘without an anchor’
Great talk show,looking forward to read this book .Thank you.
Thank you!!! I'm going to share this with my family!
Prof Scott G is phenomenal at presenting facts in an engaging, level and 'cool' way that makes you want to listen and absorb what he is speaking about. You should check out his pod cast, really great listen.
Such a great guest, thank you
Thank you for a very enlightening interview Stephanie you asked the right questions thank you and Professor Galloway your answers were very enlightening thank you
So as an American, born from Vietnamese War refugees, I feel because things are so good here:
Running water, relative ease of access to food, paved roads...
We find things to be angry about.
Yes...... We have to build each other up and respect others.... Stop this democratic and republican who's better who worst....We all can grow Change do Better bring back the Respect, Love Integrity
Hi Rita EVERYTHING you spoke of is exactly what is desperatly needed. PLEASE get involved it's a serious life & death matter!!
I can’t say enough positive things about Scott Galloway. So smart and so articulate. And so right on with everything he’s saying. The Pivot and Prof G podcasts, are absolutely worth listening to.
Exceptional interviewer. And exceptional interviewee. Well done!
He says "we are producing too many broke males" then he says "college educated women do not want an economically unviable partner" then she practically yells " why are they so mad at successful women? when the roles were reversed, we weren't mad at them" I'm like "uhhh duh he just told you and men and women are different and play different gender roles. You can have exceptions to the rules but a lot of liberal ideology is flying against millions of years of human evolution. You cant frack with the hardwiring
It's called evolution. We're not living in caves.
this is a fabulous interview and she is so digging what he is talking about
Great interview.
Wow .,.,.. that was some set of heels that Stephanie was wearing. How do women even walk in heels that high?
Bravo PATAGONIA! 👏👏👏👏👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Great book. Thank you. We need problem solvers, not lawyers and celebrities creating illusions.
Thank you Scott. We definitely need more affinity in America. We must love each other and make this boat a forever floating boat. An invictus. If Christinianity doesnt make it to happen, then common sense must do it.
What a great guy. When the interview turned to his cousin, he clearly knew whereof he speaks.
Scott Galloway is our new Michael Lewis and Malcolm Gladwell all in one. Him tearing up @ 13:39 over his cousin is everything.
Looking forward to reading this book
Watching from New Zealand. Brilliant interview. Scott is one hundred percent correct. Smart man!
Glad I live in Auckland, I have three retirement options.
@@gregnz1 Lucky you. Some folk have no choice at all.
America can never expect to be considered as a true democracy when the whole world has witnessed the true facts of how you work. Thank you Donald.
While Biden hands billions, tens of billions to Big Business, the left says that's not fascism😂😂😂😂😂😂 he shuts down our energy production and cripples are food production, causes double digit inflation and leads us to World War 3
Blame it on Putin..... 😂😂😂😂😂
We aren't a democracy. We are a Republic of 50 different, unique, states. Stop trying to create a federal totalitarian government.
LoL I suppose you think nailing Hunter for tax evasion leaves Joe off the hook🙈
How does American democracy not work?
The end of that interview was so touching.
A part of Science is making judgements, finding mistakes from those judgements, and revising new judgements. Science Deniers only focus on the “mistakes” part
Thanks For The Upload, Great Info^^
Sociology is my thing. I have pondered this young white male thing for years. I have my theories on the future being female also. I saw Mr. Galloway on Bill Maher and he was brilliant and speaking to me. Can't get enough.
Excellent discussion.
Very provocative.
A great outfit, Stephanie!
I love listening to this guy! Connections
Excellent conversation
Wonderful interview!
Scott Galloway, brilliant as usual
Good interview, important book.
He truly loved his cousin he still feels the pain.
What a smart guy. My congratulations to the hostess for those intelligent questions!
Very Interesting ❤️
Great host and mindset.
Love Stephanie’s interviews. Why can’t she be on prime time?
Yea! This was good!
7:06 wait, which college is that? 😂
Excellent ...
I will purchase your book!
The Biontech Pfizer vaccine was developed in Europe, and production and distribution were scaled up so fast that it was accessible to every adult within about 8 months from approval by the EMA. This rah-rah "all the brightest people want to come here" patriotism is really getting old.
@@Matt-1147 because his book is about America. Why would he talk about something the isn't in his book?
Well I think his statement was correct twenty years ago but it's becoming less true with each passing year. And that general trend is what his book is about.
@@randal_gibbons He stated in the Interview - to which I'm replying - in context with the scientific success of the COVID-19 vaccines that the best and brightest want to come to the US. That is a unreflected talking point of a lot of US American intellectuals, journalists and commentators. I'm pointing out that it might be debatable, as science and logistics successes are not restricted to the US by a long shot. If he makes anything like a comparable argument in the book, so much worse for him, it makes his stances so much harder to take seriously.
@@nina1608 There are plenty of smart people and great companies and institutions all over the world. However, the US is only about 4% of the world population. Yet it is probably a fact that the US produces far far more than 4% of almost everything ... new research, dominant companies, charitable giving, world leaders, etc. So his overall points and broad trends are probably generally correct. Can you show us any significant area of any kind whatsoever where the USA does not contribute far more than 4% of whatever that area is?
@@coreyham3753 How about social justice?
excellent program.
This guy should write a book on incels and what to do to help them!
Man, I think I love this guy. I’m late to the party on him, but I can’t wait to read more by him.
Amen Scott Galloway!! Preach !!
Good interview.
Good talking points by the host 🏆👍
I want my own Stephanie Ruhle. 🔥
You Are Not Alone There^^
I love listening to this man because he is spot on.
Galloway is a gift to those who listen and consider.
What an interesting take on storytelling.
Stephanie Rule i like your guess Scott how he framing middle class
I have read his book.....
A glass half full. . . what a concept!
love this man
Scott Galloway is very enlightening
I love u Scott!
Great interview. Ruhle is so into him ,I thought she was going to jump on him on camera.
I first heard about Galloway back in 2018 when I read about him for yelling and swearing at a student who entered his class late. I immediately respected him for it and have been a follower since. 😅
LOL...That reflects on why your society is so messed up....
We were in fact lining up for a german vaccine. Developed by international teams, based on internationally developed science. Hello America! Drift into our common harbour in the western world. And Scott is talking sense! That's for sure!
I’m sorry for your loss, @scott
What both of these participants forget, or are unconscious of, is that males are culturally denied full acces to their feelings!
Males are consciously and unconsciously told explicitly or implicitly by both men and women that fear and sadness are unmanly, but anger is OK!
Men’s consciousness-raising, their enhanced self-awareness, will not be possible until they too have their liberation!