Key is holding his tears 😢 I feel so happy when they perform this song even that it's not a new one but just for jjong .. just for shawols .. for all the people who say that they forgot about him!
Jo Nyu time is just passing really heavily.. I still feel the same pain whenever I remember him or see anything for shinee .. I don't think time could heal that
Jo Nyu Jjong is a legacy he can't be forgotten by us his songs are immortal .. I just hope new kpoppers would try to find who was JH and listen to his music
taemin will forever go down as a legend. he somehow went from tonedeaf to legitimate main vocalist. also... i miss you jonghyun. i hope you're resting well.
I was once thinking how taemin voice getting similar to jonghyun that I can't really tell which one's singing sometimes. And thinking how he can cover up jonghyun part well when he can't perform. and now I wish I never had such thought if it turns out to be forever... :"((
The improvement in Taem’s voice quality is insane. If you go back to 2013 live performances, you can feel that he was tiny bit struggling then…. And compare it to now. Most hardworking maknae. Missing him even moreeeee
I AM IN TEARS 😭😭😭 The pain that is still showing on their faces and most likely on the inside also. You did well my boys. ❤😭 Jjong you are missed so dearly 😭😭
Today I was in a listening spree of Shinee's songs. Because I miss them and I know their songs are beautiful. After Jjong's rest in peace, I could not listen to Shinee or Jonghyun's song for a year. Then after that, started little by little to listen again, because I was getting bored with today's Kpop. They are gems. Literally. After my listening spree today, I thought: "now I guess I can listen to them again freely and in peace". But then I watched this. i legit cried watching this. I could not hold back. I miss him. So much. And I'll forever miss him.
The fact that Jonghyun became Taemin's vocal coach and really , Taem's voice has a similarity to Jjong. We can see through their eyea that they are still hurt,especially Jinki. I wanna hug them
다들 이때는 얼마나 힘들었어 그럼에도 책임감으로 자리 지켜줘서 고맙기도 하고.. 지켜보는 사람들 또한 많이 힘들었던.. 연대의기억이 난다
오늘 바라던바다에서 온유가 선우정아씨와 부른걸 듣고 잠이 오지 않아 여기까지 왔어요.
가장 아프던 시기에 힘겹게 눌러가며 이 노래를 불렀던 멤버들 얼굴에 가슴이 아리네요. 우리 모두 행복해지면 좋겠네요.
오늘 노래가 하늘나라에 종현이에게 닿았길 바랍니다.
지금도 이노래가 너무 좋지만 노래부르면서 울컥하는 멤바들을 보니까 ....하..
같이 감정이입되서 눈물만나네 .....
샤월도 아닌데 하루도 안빠지고 매일 듣는곡
재연과 함께 진짜 명곡 .....
온유가 늘 이 노래를 가장 좋아한다했었지
왜 이노래를 가장 좋아한대요? 저도 가장 조아하지만..
@@비니-n5s 이유는 딱히 말안했지만 종현이가 작사해서 인거 같아요
Selene 6 23.. a beautiful song written by our beautiful Jjong.. (i miss him so much and it hurts)
*hugs* 💕
I miss him too. Everyday 😭😭😭😭
행복했으면 좋겠어 모두...
온유보는데 왜이렇게 가슴이 아리냐...
MINHO VOICE SO UNDERRATED OMG ITS ACTUALLY REALLY BEAUTIFUL
Syafira Maulidia it is. his vocals have always been this amazing ever since debut days.
더 더 밝게 오래 빛나게 해줄게. 영원히 사랑해 샤이니💎
영원히 다섯명의 빛나는 샤이니...항상 응원할게요...
혹시 삶의 끝에 네가 서있다면
조금 더 가까워 질 수 있다면
민호 음색 너무 좋다 ..
WHOEVER SAYS MINHO CAN'T SING I'M FIGHTING THEM MY BABYYY IS SO TALENTED
IT WOULD BE NICE IF THEY GAVE HIM MORE LINES TO SING.
I see minho is covering jjong's line wen they did view....
im with you. let's create an army for minho😅😅
@@veiamae3787 i'm in! He sings amazing!
애들도 이노래 부르면서 종현이 생각 많이 난듯.. ㅠㅠ 오늘도 보고싶다.
Looks like the boys thought of Jonghyun while singing this.. I miss you still. ❤️
너와나의거리 중 제일 마음아픈 무대
이곡 진짜 제 최애곡,,,
Key is holding his tears 😢
I feel so happy when they perform this song even that it's not a new one but just for jjong .. just for shawols .. for all the people who say that they forgot about him!
we all are all holding in our tears.. for a half a year now so...
Jo Nyu time is just passing really heavily.. I still feel the same pain whenever I remember him or see anything for shinee .. I don't think time could heal that
hyunjin kim no, you are right. This scar is forever. I hope i never forget those perfect years of innocence..
Jo Nyu Jjong is a legacy he can't be forgotten by us his songs are immortal .. I just hope new kpoppers would try to find who was JH and listen to his music
우리 샤이니 다섯명 모두 너무너무 사랑해 ❤
대박 이걸 스케치북에서 불렀었네 ㄷㄷ
This is literally my favourite SHINee song :'(I am so emotional now. Kibummie's face... I just want to give him a big hug rn...
언제나 노래 너무 잘불러 근데 쪼금 슬프다
사랑해 내 빛돌이들 너무 예뻐
이 노래 샤이니 노래중 제일 좋아하는 노래. 달을 떠오르며 가사 썼다고 들었던것 같은데, 지금쯤 달나라에서 잘 살고 있으려나? 모두가 행복했으면 좋겠다 정말로
온유님.. 진짜 목소리 너무 좋다ㅜㅜ 꿀보이스❤
This song is a masterpiece of kpop... Best Kpop idol's ballad I dare to say
맨날 오인버전만 듣다가 사인버전 처음들었는데 눈물나서디질것같음... 너무 선물같은 노래
This is beautiful 💕
Jjong never left their side, his voice can heard through his members’ voices 💎 he’ll never stop shining on them!
It's true ;')
영원히 다섯
우리 5이니 평생 행복하자
샤이니라는 이름 반짝반짝 지켜줘서 너무 고마워❤️
눈물난다..........고생했어 수고했어....힘내세요 오빠들...사랑해요❤️
너와나의거리 에서 너가 달이라고 하던데 진짜 종현이 생각나는 노래네
내가 진짜 좋아하는 노래ㅠㅠ
민호 목소리 너무 좋다
너와나의거리, 재연 왠지 더 애정이가는 곡들
The lyrics of this song are so beautiful
To our rap line, GOOD JOB!! 😭💚
이 노래만 들으면 마음이 따듯해져요🍃🌸
you can see on key and onew's face how much they've missed jonghyun when taemin was singing.
taemin will forever go down as a legend. he somehow went from tonedeaf to legitimate main vocalist. also... i miss you jonghyun. i hope you're resting well.
WOW! I'm crying😭 woooww
Me too
샤이니 명품발라드넘버3
너와 나의 거리, 방백, 재연
종현이 없는 4명이서 또 계속해서 명품 발라드가 나오겠지만,
종현과 함께 한 곡들이라 더 애정이 가는 너와나의거리,방백,재연
발라드를 좋아하는 나로서 이 3곡 만으로도 샤이니의 평생팬이다
샤이니 모두 행복하길
they lowered the key from the original song to make it more comfortable for them to sing. it feels right.
All of them are main vocal now :)
고마워요 ㅠㅠ
종현아 생일축하해❤
이제 내가 너의 누나가 됐네🎉🎉
사랑해❤
아 너무 슬프다
Watching this I feel like they bare their souls in this performance. Such an honor when artists share a part of themselves with audience like this.😢 😍
so much eargasm in just one video❤
An Encore will always have a special place in every SHINee fans heart ❤
0:43 기범이 진기 걱정돼서 곁눈질하는거 같아서 짠하다 ㅠㅠ
저도 그렇게 느꼈어요. 이날 따라 진기가 너무 고개 푹숙이고 있어서 ㅠㅠ 이날 멤버들이 많이 힘들어 보였던거같아요
I was once thinking how taemin voice getting similar to jonghyun that I can't really tell which one's singing sometimes. And thinking how he can cover up jonghyun part well when he can't perform. and now I wish I never had such thought if it turns out to be forever... :"((
Girl i agree with you 100%
Omg i thought im the only one that hear taem's voice as jong's.. but only in shinee's song.. its weird but it doesnt happen in taem's solo
For me, Taem’s voice is softer compared to Jong’s powerful voice. But Taem’s range is really getting there. I bet his hyung is so proud 🥲
노래 너무 잘부른다
수고했어 얘들아
너무 보고싶다
내가 너무 사랑해
Selene 6.23 and Quasimodo are my favorite SHINee's favorite songs💕😗😗
샤이니 다 잘부르네 ..
The improvement in Taem’s voice quality is insane. If you go back to 2013 live performances, you can feel that he was tiny bit struggling then…. And compare it to now. Most hardworking maknae. Missing him even moreeeee
온유 목소리는 정말 좋아요
종현아 넘 보고싶다ㅠㅠ
You wont know how precious he is until moment became memories 💔 miss you forever, jonghyun 😢 love you guys 💙
I AM IN TEARS 😭😭😭
The pain that is still showing on their faces and most likely on the inside also. You did well my boys. ❤😭
Jjong you are missed so dearly 😭😭
So beautiful 💙
Today I was in a listening spree of Shinee's songs. Because I miss them and I know their songs are beautiful. After Jjong's rest in peace, I could not listen to Shinee or Jonghyun's song for a year. Then after that, started little by little to listen again, because I was getting bored with today's Kpop. They are gems. Literally. After my listening spree today, I thought: "now I guess I can listen to them again freely and in peace". But then I watched this. i legit cried watching this. I could not hold back. I miss him. So much. And I'll forever miss him.
원래 다 잘 하지만
종현이의 빈자리는 여전히..
찾게되고 종현이가 나오길 기다려진다ㅠㅠ
종현이가 작곡 작사 한 곡들이
너무 좋다는 게 매순간 느껴지고 그래서 더 보고싶어지고ㅠㅠ
보고싶다 종현아
SHINee's back😍
Minho voice 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
It’s so beautiful..
I can hear Jonghyun singing with them.. throughout the song through their voices..
5HINee JJANG!!!!
jonghyun, we miss you so much :') we hope you are happy now and not in pain anymore :')
좋다..
Jonghyun ah i miss you
온유 음색은 대체불가 ㅠㅠ
Onew cant hide his feelingsㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ Selene 6.23 is so meaningful. I always cry whenever hear this song. SHINee be strong, we love you ㅠㅠ😭❤
저때가 종현이 떠난지 얼마 안됐을때인데 원래는 샤이니 그만할라하다가 종현어머니가 영원했으면 좋겠다고 샤이니 계속해달라고 해서 지금 16년째 계약은 2명만 스엠계약하고 나머지2명은 솔로로 다른데로 계약했지만 샤이니는 여전히 스엠.
I miss you so much☝️♥️
민호 이렇게 노래 잘하는데 누가 못한다 그랬냐구ㅠㅠㅠ
Taemin's voice is so soft, gentle and beautiful❤
SHINee fighting!!!
어떻게 참고 불렀을까
I can't hold my tears when i see kibum...it's hurts...i just wanna hug him...kibummieeee...😭😭😭😭😭
i just cant stop my tears everytime i hear selene 6.23 it would forever be the best SHINee ballad ever
우리 샤이니,,울고싶을땐 마음껏 울어..참지마
온유야....목소리 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Selene 6.23 and Quasimodo are still the best SHINee ballads for me. They make me so emotional and this performance was so touching.
VOCAL KINGS. This makes me so freaking emotional. Sending my love to SHINee forever.
SHINee sing with their hearts
The fact that Jonghyun became Taemin's vocal coach and really , Taem's voice has a similarity to Jjong.
We can see through their eyea that they are still hurt,especially Jinki. I wanna hug them
They have such beautiful faces, voices and hearts 💞
Bu hissi unutmayacağım...
민호는 또 왜이렇게 잘부르는건데ㅠㅠ
Shinee5 forever 💎💎💎💎
This song is so full of beautiful memories 💕
앉아서 노래 부르기 힘든건데 잘 한다.^^
It sounds really sad yet somehow it's so beautiful as well..
Burst of tears...😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
How beautiful their voice 😍😍😍
Proud of my boys💙
I love you SHINee. The most beautiful. The most strong.
종현아 지금도 생각난다.23.2.18
lovely, they made me more proud.
My favorite Shinee's ballad
The hurt in their voices... the pain I feel it, you did well Jonghyun
Сердце разрывается когда вижу их в таком составе 😢😢😢