I was in the audience for this and was extremely shocked, because I had no idea that she has a beautiful singing voice. Her father can sing, her mother isn’t known to sing, so there was no reason to assume she would be born with a great singing voice. She also is clearly comfortable performing in front of thousands of people, and she has something else that can’t be taught: a magnetic stage presence.
The importance of a dad can never be overestimated. How precious is this??? I don't know how he could keep it together after that song. Bless them both!
Little credit to Christie too ..having good relations with a Ex who she apparently never bad mouthed. Lesson to others...it does impact your off spring..Bless you guys! ❤️
@@forget3817 What a ridiculous statement. What does that have to do with anything? That is his daughter no matter how old she is. Nevermind the fact that she will always be a child in his eyes. You must be a child or not have any children yourself..
I buried my dad last Friday. Officer of the law among many other things. He worked with children and families. His first priority was everyone's safety. Terry Chinn is a legend where we are. Hes priceless. Im the luckiest girl in the world ❤❤❤ love you dad. RIP Hey boy! Ill see you soon. 💙💙💙
We lost our parents young. My dad was a well known race car mechanic for various clubs, police mechanic and union president. Our mom was a great lady too. I can understand how you miss your dad very much. I was daddy's little girl too. Alexa sings lovely. That's an old song from my mom's oldies channel.
A beautiful tribute! If you've never seen the move 'To Sir, with Love' (1967) with Sidney Poiter - and Lulu singing this famously iconic song - you owe yourself a treat!
The brings back a fond memory of Billy Joel and Alexa. In 2006, my wife and I stopped late one night to say hello to Norman, the long-time bartender and fixture at the Ritz in NYC. While sipping a drink at the bar, my wife asked me to ask the pianist to play "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" (a favorite request of hers). The piano was behind a column so I couldn't see the pianist. When I went to ask, I realized why we were hearing a lot of Billy Joel tunes, it was Billy sitting at the piano playing with Alexa on the bench with him. I went back to explain to my wife that it was Billy Joel playing and she said, well, he's a piano player, marched over and asked him to play it. Sure enough, he did with my wife sitting on the bench with him and Alexa. Of course, this left me with the question "what do you tip Pianoman?" Needless to say, we (and everyone else) stayed for more than one drink as Billy played for over an hour.
She needed autotune. Do you know what autotune is, and how it works? Did you know that many artists have used it before it became such a bandwagon comment on YT? Many of your favs used an auto tuner in the studio before it was called auto tune. Artists have used tools just like auto tune for over 50 years.
Billy Joel is a very lucky man to have his daughter sing that song for him. That was Amazing. I’m a father and it just for a moment, wished my daughter was still here with me.❤
what a beautiful tribute to her father. !! I am stunned at all he negative comments. She loves and adores her father ....and sang to him to show her love for him. And sang in front of thousands of people to boot. Give her a break and just enjoy the tribute for what it is. Isn't it nice to see LOVE in the world instead of hate????? Alexa....you go girl.....and thanks for the memories......
@@wagu7003 you have to read more than the first few comments.......the negative comments were more about her clothes and shoes she was wearing... not her singing.....
I just started reading so I. have not seen negative yet. But, it there is shame on them. They obviously are just trolls who hate everyone and are miserable little no ones. They need attention because no one will pay attention to their sorry selves.
I'll never forget the response I received from the beautiful Alexa Ray Joel, when I left a comment on her Facebook page several years ago. She was truly humble and appreciative and I'll always treasure her reply. So, Alexa Ray, if you read this, what a priceless gift and memory you shared with your Dad. Thank you for doing that.
It’s so rare to see genuine loving and respectful relationship between a young celebrity millennial and a father these days. So heart warming to see this.
My dad died last year also, aged 93.. he hasn't gone anywhere just shifted into a different frequency and has no trouble making his presence felt.. 🤍🕊NZ
This Beautiful young Lady has been singing, playing the piano and just entertaining for YEARS. Absolutely stunning and talented she is. You gotta know she made Papa proud with this song by LuLu. I was proud for them both just watching. And, of course, I cried 😢!!❤❤❤❤❤
So beautiful. Billy Joel has always been one of my favorite singers. He is so lucky to have such a beautiful relationship with his daughter. She shows that she loves him very much.
I can’t believe a lot of these comments here. Just shaking my head. She’s very talented. Sings beautifully. It seems like she’s singing live without a back track, which is rare now, and which means she’s a very talented vocalist.
They are mostly just trolls that are paid to try and divide us, many aren’t even American. Ignore the lowlifes. Yes, she sang beautifully. He must be proud to have such a lovely daughter.
She’s a star and doesn’t realize she is. It has nothing to do with who her father is. This girl has had mountains to climb to get to this stage. I applaud her for her dedication to her dream, and her talent goes far beyond what we see here. Bravo! 🙏🌸❤️
She sings circles around Taylor Swift...and writes much better music as well. For the life of me I still cannot understand how Alexa is not as popular as Taylor. SMH.
Let's see-sang from the heart- was respectful to thr audience- didn't bombard the songs lyrics with the profane and modern day perversity- and kept her clothes on for the song! How entertainment used to be. She is already golden!
I love this song, SO much. Since I was a kid too. It's beautiful and sweet. I lost my father to cancer when I was sixteen. I'm so happy this young woman has her father here to do this.
So sweet. I always liked her. She was always her own person. She has both Christie Brinkley and Billy Joel in her. Her voice is wonderful and her happiness made me smile the whole time she sang.
As my face is soaked in tears..I can just imagine this is the best gift any dad could ever hope for...Guess you did good mr.joel..cuz she sure loves you!
This was just absolutely beautiful. I don't think I've ever seen Billy Joel as emotionally involved in anything more than this. I know he's proud of her and I know how much he loves his children.
The apple does not fall far from the tree /Billy Alexa is amazing because she has an amazing dad. I look forward to many more years of entertainment thank you a million times
Why do all the haters expect an American Idol or X-Factor caliber performance? As if any of you could have done better? Her performance was filled with raw emotion, and she still kept it together without her voice cracking or having to stop. I say she did an amazing job! To those saying she's flat, listen to it with headphones and you'll realize she's perfectly on key. The distortion comes from a loud live performance being recorded on a cell phone. If you haven't noticed, any concert recorded on a cell phone will have distortion between the band and the singer, that's just how it is!
@@jmark7390 She's a lot better. You have to take into consideration the emotions and sentiments at the time. I am sure it is not the easiest thing to pull off, trying to sing a song like that in front of 18,000 people to your father who has tears in his eyes.
This was lovely and heart warming. What a beautiful woman Alexa has grown up to be, and she has a lovely singing voice! This is a moment they'll never forget, and it's what life is all about. Letting those who mean everything to you KNOW how precious they are! Billy Joel is a legend with his music and he must have been an equally wonderful dad, because his daughter adores him! Bless you both!
I’m crying too! I miss my Dad!!! Watching movies together was our jam!!! He was a decorated US Army Vietnam war combat veteran and a sky soldier with the legendary 173rd /101st Airborne brigade!!! What a lucky daughter and dad to be able to share this. Very moving! Great song!!!!
Billy Joel is the Spirit Animal of my youth. How his music makes me feel is beyond words God Bless him and his sweet daughter. Beautiful family love. ❤️
I’ll never forget the first time I heard The Stranger was flowing across the quads near my dorm at Penn State. It was haunting and I had to go and get it right away. Later when we had our children it was my oldest son’s favorite singer. He’d always clamor for “Billy Joel!” Such happy times.
Met Billy when he came to my college to play one evening. It was snowing and only three people showed up. We all sat at the piano. He said he had a record coming out. We never knew him before that. That was back in the seventies. He played piano man. We all said it was a hit. I don’t know if any of us would have dreamed it became such a big hit. I glad it did. Who knew we would still be talking about after having adult children of our own.
So many musicians and performers and stars have to deal with so much controversy. Obviously Billy Joel did a great job raising his daughter. He has been a National Treasure for the music industry and the performing arts. God Bless you Billy Joel and your daughter has a lovely voice.
Absolutely gorgeous in every possible way. That retro-look fits the song perfectly and Alexa Ray looks and sounds simply stunning. Thank you for posting this! Made my heart melt. 😭🥰
Beautiful voice, lovely daughter; made my eyes tear up at the end when she sand, "To Dad, with Love." Sweet. You done good, Billy. Thank you for all of your memorable music, too, from back in the day--the 1970s!! 💖💖
She is an oddly beautiful blend of her parents, and a solid talent in her own right. Also, it is kinda crazy how that place has such a unique acoustic signature that is even captured on cell phone video. Thanks for sharing.
I will never forget the first time I heard piano man in the back of a VW bug with my friends, incredible. Alexa is so beautiful!! Her voice incredible!!
I’m so glad to see that Alexa is apparently close to her dad. If I had been her I would have never been able to get through that. I didn’t understand her outfit at first, but once she started the song it made perfect sense. Billy deserves whatever kind of retirement or slowing down he has in mind for himself whenever he is ready. Thank you Sir, for 50+ years of wonderful music! I do hope it’s not over yet.❤️
Beautiful, my daughter rest in peace had a beautiful voice and wanted to be a opera singer. But didn't get the chance. I would give anything to hear her sing again. God bless you 🙏
That was BEAUTIFUL!! Alexa is so talented!! How perfectly sweet she is! She is dressed as sweet as she sang that song to her daddy. What a gift to Billy Joel. I cried! Great job, Alexa! 💗
WOW. Alexa Joel has some damn good pipes! This recording is a true tribute to her father, mother and to Lulu. I'm looking forward to hearing more from her!
Truly the father CHERISHED THE MOMENT! Splendid indeed. Wonderfully done.❤ we all saw her when she's just a baby ..NOW she sings to her dad. Great feelings ❤
Makes me cry. We watched her grow up from a tiny baby girl. She loves her daddy. Can't believe she's 38 already. You did good, Billy. You did good. 😎😎🎹🎹👏👏😭😭🤗🤗♥️♥️💃💃
I was in the audience for this and was extremely shocked, because I had no idea that she has a beautiful singing voice. Her father can sing, her mother isn’t known to sing, so there was no reason to assume she would be born with a great singing voice. She also is clearly comfortable performing in front of thousands of people, and she has something else that can’t be taught: a magnetic stage presence.
She has been a performer for many years. I have one of her jazz CDs. Google her.
She doesn’t just sing, but she also plays the piano like her dad. She has recorded at least one EP.
Yes! She's sung in some cabaret settings and had a beautiful voice and stage presence.
Yes she does have a beautiful voice and she has recorded music
She tried some time ago to launch a singing career but wasn’t very successful. Shame, she has a great voice !
The importance of a dad can never be overestimated. How precious is this??? I don't know how he could keep it together after that song. Bless them both!
Little credit to Christie too ..having good relations with a Ex who she apparently never bad mouthed. Lesson to others...it does impact your off spring..Bless you guys! ❤️
It's easier to keep it together when the person singing to you is a middle-aged woman.
Love the fact that she is really real, no plastic surgery, not a string bean, just very talented and sweet. Love her! 🫶🌟😇
My mom was a wonderful woman, but my Dad was my main support growing up! His love has kept me single and happy❣️❣️
@@forget3817 What a ridiculous statement. What does that have to do with anything? That is his daughter no matter how old she is. Nevermind the fact that she will always be a child in his eyes. You must be a child or not have any children yourself..
I buried my dad last Friday. Officer of the law among many other things. He worked with children and families. His first priority was everyone's safety. Terry Chinn is a legend where we are. Hes priceless. Im the luckiest girl in the world ❤❤❤ love you dad. RIP Hey boy! Ill see you soon. 💙💙💙
We lost our parents young. My dad was a well known race car mechanic for various clubs, police mechanic and union president. Our mom was a great lady too.
I can understand how you miss your dad very much.
I was daddy's little girl too.
Alexa sings lovely. That's an old song from my mom's oldies channel.
I am so, so sorry for your loss. Please take care. You'll miss him forever. Love does that.
So sorry for your loss
Billy Joel is talented, but the real heroes are people like your dad!
GOD Bless him and you! ❤️
This young woman obviously inherited dad's musical ability. No auto tune or computer tricks. Just pure singing talent.
And this kid has talent
Her voice is nasally and off key. Sorry, just because she’s Billy’s kid that doesn’t automatically make her like him.
It is definitely off key. It's embarrassing for her.
Diane Lake, you must be kidding.
Not her mom's beauty 😮
@@and4all706..❤ She's Trying..
A beautiful tribute! If you've never seen the move 'To Sir, with Love' (1967) with Sidney Poiter - and Lulu singing this famously iconic song - you owe yourself a treat!
Agreed. My mom got me into that movie and song.
Best movie!!
Lulu's was an innocent version of the song, and her voice was perfect for it.
Thanks Paul, couldn't think it was Lulu
Agreed!!!! Great movie and great song. ❤
The brings back a fond memory of Billy Joel and Alexa. In 2006, my wife and I stopped late one night to say hello to Norman, the long-time bartender and fixture at the Ritz in NYC. While sipping a drink at the bar, my wife asked me to ask the pianist to play "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" (a favorite request of hers). The piano was behind a column so I couldn't see the pianist. When I went to ask, I realized why we were hearing a lot of Billy Joel tunes, it was Billy sitting at the piano playing with Alexa on the bench with him. I went back to explain to my wife that it was Billy Joel playing and she said, well, he's a piano player, marched over and asked him to play it. Sure enough, he did with my wife sitting on the bench with him and Alexa. Of course, this left me with the question "what do you tip Pianoman?" Needless to say, we (and everyone else) stayed for more than one drink as Billy played for over an hour.
@jirimondo- that’s a heartwarming and amazing story! Lucky night for sure! Love how your wife didnt hesitate to ask him to play! 😊
Precious and unique moments can happen in NYC. Love that you experienced this!
Had the same experience in Vegas. He bought us a bottle of champagne, it was our honeymoon😊
All the autotune and performers who can’t actually sing…Alexa Rae…you nailed it. No autotune and a full, rich delivery of that iconic song.
Also, the bass player so so underestimated and unappreciated (another mandatory meaningless comment apparently).
How can you tell? There was way too much distortion, but I was a beautiful father daughter moment.
@@beverly9 Absolute troll.
She needed autotune.
Do you know what autotune is, and how it works?
Did you know that many artists have used it before it became such a bandwagon comment on YT?
Many of your favs used an auto tuner in the studio before it was called auto tune.
Artists have used tools just like auto tune for over 50 years.
@@beverly9 She cant sing, but thats okay. The moment was great.
Billy Joel is a very lucky man to have his daughter sing that song for him. That was Amazing. I’m a father and it just for a moment, wished my daughter was still here with me.❤
Ahhhh❤
what a beautiful tribute to her father. !! I am stunned at all he negative comments. She loves and adores her father ....and sang to him to show her love for him. And sang in front of thousands of people to boot. Give her a break and just enjoy the tribute for what it is. Isn't it nice to see LOVE in the world instead of hate????? Alexa....you go girl.....and thanks for the memories......
She's doing better than me at least she can carry a tune She did great
I've only seen tons of positive comments. She's really wonderful!!
@@wagu7003 you have to read more than the first few comments.......the negative comments were more about her clothes and shoes she was wearing... not her singing.....
I just started reading so I. have not seen negative yet. But, it there is shame on them. They obviously are just trolls who hate everyone and are miserable little no ones. They need attention because no one will pay attention to their sorry selves.
So moving!❤ I'm sure he's blubbering!
I'll never forget the response I received from the beautiful Alexa Ray Joel, when I left a comment on her Facebook page several years ago. She was truly humble and appreciative and I'll always treasure her reply. So, Alexa Ray, if you read this, what a priceless gift and memory you shared with your Dad. Thank you for doing that.
Lol
Nice comment @Sandra! 🫶🌟🙌
Same here! She is a class act!
Love it!!! ❤
A multi millionaire has staff to respond to facebook comments & fan letters .
One of the sweetest living tributes to a father that I have ever seen.
Dad's going to cry if he looks at her. Beautiful. He must be so proud!
If i could have sang to my father, he would have been so proud and cried, my Dad loved me so. Miss you Dad❤
❤💔
Great comment! I miss my Dad too.
Just Sing. He's listening ❤
💝🌟🌈
You still can he can still hear you he’s alive
You can't put a price on that. A daughter's love is priceless. Well done, Alexa!
It’s so rare to see genuine loving and respectful relationship between a young celebrity millennial and a father these days. So heart warming to see this.
It's not rare, you!
Is she his daughter with Christie Brinkley? Or with his third wife??
@@vetsai8199with Christie
Yes, with Christie @@vetsai8199
A celebrity? What is she "celebrated" for, being carried for 9 months in the womb of a supermodel?
Today would have been my dad’s 97th birthday. He died last year. It was so special coming across this today. Miss you Dad.
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
What a long life yet never long enough! Thank God for eternal life.
My dad died last year also, aged 93.. he hasn't gone anywhere just shifted into a different frequency and has no trouble making his presence felt.. 🤍🕊NZ
The amount of love & pride that he has on his face is priceless. She truly is talented & sings beautifully❤❤
Her shoes make me nervous.
This Beautiful young Lady has been singing, playing the piano and just entertaining for YEARS. Absolutely stunning and talented she is. You gotta know she made Papa proud with this song by LuLu. I was proud for them both just watching. And, of course, I cried 😢!!❤❤❤❤❤
@@lovesdogs8616 I do give her credit for wearing. They looked VERY hard to walk in but she did great
One of my most beloved songs ever
She nailed it! ❤️
Beautiful
My daughter is an oldies fan! This song is one of her very favorites! She named her baby girl Lulu! One of my favorite songs too!
I never imagined Billy being anything, but the star he’s always been. This father sitting on the piano bench brings tears.🙏🏾
So beautiful. Billy Joel has always been one of my favorite singers. He is so lucky to have such a beautiful relationship with his daughter. She shows that she loves him very much.
She's a legitimate talent. She's not just getting by on her Father's name.
😅😅😅😅😅😅
Sorry, she is okay.
They've been trying to push her for years, she needs to do something else.
I can’t believe a lot of these comments here. Just shaking my head. She’s very talented. Sings beautifully. It seems like she’s singing live without a back track, which is rare now, and which means she’s a very talented vocalist.
They are mostly just trolls that are paid to try and divide us, many aren’t even American. Ignore the lowlifes. Yes, she sang beautifully. He must be proud to have such a lovely daughter.
@@carblarson8868 she is lovely and has so much poise.
I went quite a way down this list did not see any negative comments.
@@paulm.6591 They were probably deleted.
What are you on about? I've scrolled down more than 30 comments and they are all praising her.
She’s a star and doesn’t realize she is. It has nothing to do with who her father is. This girl has had mountains to climb to get to this stage. I applaud her for her dedication to her dream, and her talent goes far beyond what we see here. Bravo! 🙏🌸❤️
She sings circles around Taylor Swift...and writes much better music as well. For the life of me I still cannot understand how Alexa is not as popular as Taylor. SMH.
This song has always given me chills. How special to have your own child sing it to you. Nothing in the world can equal that! Beautifully sung!
She has stage presence.
Just charming.
Dad is so proud.
Voice is average. Listen to Lulu sing this.
She shines like a star!
I agree. She can't sing a round tone.
If you think you can judge a voice by this horrible recording, then you crae crae
Let's see-sang from the heart- was respectful to thr audience- didn't bombard the songs lyrics with the profane and modern day perversity- and kept her clothes on for the song! How entertainment used to be. She is already golden!
I think she sounded beautiful
I love this song, SO much. Since I was a kid too.
It's beautiful and sweet.
I lost my father to cancer when I was sixteen.
I'm so happy this young woman has her father here to do this.
💕💕💕💕
So sweet. I always liked her. She was always her own person. She has both Christie Brinkley and Billy Joel in her. Her voice is wonderful and her happiness made me smile the whole time she sang.
This was my sister's father-daughter dance at her wedding. It was perfection.
It was my father-daughter dance as well. I randomly found this video today too. My dad passed away in 2020. I miss him so much.
@@irenehoagso sorry for your loss. My dad passed away in 2020 also. I miss him every day.
@@irenehoag Our dad also passed, in 2007.
@@kittensanddaisies5615 I am so sorry for your loss too.
@@beingkitschroeder2507 I'm sorry you lost your dad too.
As my face is soaked in tears..I can just imagine this is the best gift any dad could ever hope for...Guess you did good mr.joel..cuz she sure loves you!
Seriously
She's just a doll! Beautiful and talented and I love how he looks at her! I legit had tears! ♥️♥️♥️
She's his baby girl he's so proud as any parent would be 💙
can we all just applaud her platform with her father - I think she did great but the look of pride on Billy's face makes me happiest!
This was just absolutely beautiful. I don't think I've ever seen Billy Joel as emotionally involved in anything more than this. I know he's proud of her and I know how much he loves his children.
Daddy s girl..let her have a moment in her home town..peace *
The apple does not fall far from the tree /Billy Alexa is amazing because she has an amazing dad. I look forward to many more years of entertainment thank you a million times
For a "non-professional," she is far better than I expected! Remember... this is a tribute. And it's very special to its intended audience (her dad).
She tried to be a music career since the mid 2000s
@@ultraviolettas Tried, maybe. As a vocalist she wouldn’t make it. Sorry to say.
@@AudioVile tried and rightfully failed
Alexa Ray is a professional. She has performed for years.
@@lisamarielund6292 Okay, that IS interesting. I've never heard anything she has done on any platform or medium.
To Sir, With Love is one of my favorite movies. Her singing is so touching.
Today 4/30 is the 17th anniversary of my father’s sudden death….he was USAF and we are Texan so he was always Sir to me - beautiful song and tribute❤
Why do all the haters expect an American Idol or X-Factor caliber performance? As if any of you could have done better? Her performance was filled with raw emotion, and she still kept it together without her voice cracking or having to stop. I say she did an amazing job! To those saying she's flat, listen to it with headphones and you'll realize she's perfectly on key. The distortion comes from a loud live performance being recorded on a cell phone. If you haven't noticed, any concert recorded on a cell phone will have distortion between the band and the singer, that's just how it is!
Are people not aware she is a professional singer?
She sang okay,. She is mediocre at best. I am a 72 year old lesbian woman had hoped she would have been better.
@@jmark7390 She's a lot better. You have to take into consideration the emotions and sentiments at the time. I am sure it is not the easiest thing to pull off, trying to sing a song like that in front of 18,000 people to your father who has tears in his eyes.
Why does your age or sexual preference matter? When was the last time you performed at MSG?
@@jmark7390
I agree with Chicagocat so your a lesbian no reason you had to include that in your comment.
Trust me no one cares!!!
Alexa your father will remember this time forever. That was so sweet of you to sing to him.😊
This was lovely and heart warming. What a beautiful woman Alexa has grown up to be, and she has a lovely singing voice! This is a moment they'll never forget, and it's what life is all about. Letting those who mean everything to you KNOW how precious they are! Billy Joel is a legend with his music and he must have been an equally wonderful dad, because his daughter adores him! Bless you both!
This is the tenth anniversary of my father's death, I came upon this video at random ❤.
❤💔
❤💔❤️❤️❤️💕💕💕
Awwwwww ❤😢
I'm sorry for your loss. Your dad is near trying to send you a hug.
It was definitely not random ❤🙏
A most beautiful moment in time for this father and daughter. Great tribute Alexa!!! ❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏
A beautiful tribute by a daughter to a father. It just so happens that this is Billy and Alexa Ray Joel. How absolutely lovely.
Gorgeous, Talented Woman with Such Class and How Lovely to Honor Her Beloved Dad! JUST BEAUTIFUL IN EVERY WAY!!!!
A perfect tribute to her father!!!
I’m crying too! I miss my Dad!!! Watching movies together was our jam!!! He was a decorated US Army Vietnam
war combat veteran and a sky soldier with the legendary 173rd /101st Airborne brigade!!! What a lucky daughter and dad to be able to share this. Very moving! Great song!!!!
Right there with you. My dad served 69-70 in the A/3/17 CAV as a pilot for the Army. We lost him in 1999 and he loved this movie/song as well.
He just adores her!
Billy Joel is the Spirit Animal of my youth. How his music makes me feel is beyond words
God Bless him and his sweet daughter. Beautiful family love. ❤️
I’ll never forget the first time I heard The Stranger was flowing across the quads near my dorm at Penn State. It was haunting and I had to go and get it right away. Later when we had our children it was my oldest son’s favorite singer. He’d always clamor for “Billy Joel!” Such happy times.
Beautiful daughter, beautiful singer. Made me want to cry making me think of my own dad. Love it!
What a nice song to sing to her father. I have ALWAYS loved this sing. Alexa Ray, did a wonderful job singing it. 🥰
Wow, she's got a great voice!! Wonder why she hasn't gone further. She's better then alot of other singers that people idiolize...
she is an absolute sweetheart 💖💖
So nice to see Billy’s daughter singing to him with such compassion❤️❤️
I didn’t know that Alexa Ray Joel has a wonderful singing voice! She is definitely very talented! Like father, like daughter!
Wow!!!! Wasnt expecting it to be this good. Love that song since the 60s
She’s the best part of him ❤ Her sweet voice is classic musical theatre 😊 Beautiful and always stylish 🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸
Met Billy when he came to my college to play one evening. It was snowing and only three people showed up. We all sat at the piano. He said he had a record coming out. We never knew him before that. That was back in the seventies. He played piano man. We all said it was a hit. I don’t know if any of us would have dreamed it became such a big hit. I glad it did. Who knew we would still be talking about after having adult children of our own.
So many musicians and performers and stars have to deal with so much controversy. Obviously Billy Joel did a great job raising his daughter. He has been a National Treasure for the music industry and the performing arts. God Bless you Billy Joel and your daughter has a lovely voice.
One of my favorite song, and she’s a very good singer and beautiful!🥰
Beautiful version! What a lovely voice and tribute to her father.
Saw this movie for my 8th graduation. In 1974. Ill never forget it or that song.
Extremely beautiful, very touching and brilliantly done.
Beautiful girl with a beautiful voice. I know her dad is so proud. It takes a lot of guts to sing to a crowd that big. You go girl! 👏👏🌹
Absolutely gorgeous in every possible way. That retro-look fits the song perfectly and Alexa Ray looks and sounds simply stunning. Thank you for posting this! Made my heart melt. 😭🥰
She sings beautifully. He’s looking away not to cry. He’s a marshmallow in his daughter’s presence.
She really can sing, this is really well done.
Beautiful voice, lovely daughter; made my eyes tear up at the end when she sand, "To Dad, with Love." Sweet. You done good, Billy. Thank you for all of your memorable music, too, from back in the day--the 1970s!! 💖💖
She is an oddly beautiful blend of her parents, and a solid talent in her own right. Also, it is kinda crazy how that place has such a unique acoustic signature that is even captured on cell phone video. Thanks for sharing.
That’s Madison Square Garden for you.
She is adorable, what a lucky Dad❤
Wonderful. What poise and courage she has to get up and sing in front of huge crowd. And she did it well!
If you are not aware she is a professional singer.
This is so sweet. I wish I still had my dad to sing to. He transitioned 4 years ago.
What he became a female???
@@gaga140012 I think that’s what the word “transition” means, these days. You know it, too. Insensitive question.
@@tamaramorton8812Not intrusive,they shared it so fair question.
@@tamaramorton8812I thought they meant that their dad died. Strange way of saying it but I have heard it before.
A beautiful and extraordinary tribute to her dad!
I will never forget the first time I heard piano man in the back of a VW bug with my friends, incredible. Alexa is so beautiful!! Her voice incredible!!
Ur daddy is surely surprised.U nailed that song.Father & daughter moment
Beautiful tribute to your father love it ❤❤❤❤
I’m so glad to see that Alexa is apparently close to her dad. If I had been her I would have never been able to get through that. I didn’t understand her outfit at first, but once she started the song it made perfect sense. Billy deserves whatever kind of retirement or slowing down he has in mind for himself whenever he is ready. Thank you Sir, for 50+ years of wonderful music! I do hope it’s not over yet.❤️
She made him cry, he was so proud of her!
What a lovely tribute to Billy Joel from his beautiful, charming & talented daughter Alexa Rae. Check out those rocking shoes too.
That gave me goosebumps and tears!!!!
Well that made me get misty eyed ❤️ Such a great song & Alexa sang it beautifully to her Dad. It must have been very emotional for him ❤️ xx
lol
Beautiful, my daughter rest in peace had a beautiful voice and wanted to be a opera singer. But didn't get the chance. I would give anything to hear her sing again. God bless you 🙏
Love this girl! Dad's a hard act to follow for sure and shadow to live in, she has talent, beauty and a really fine voice
Sweet & Priceless to be serenade by your daughter. What I’d give to sing, see, touch my dad one more time. ❤️💜🧡
The time spent being a good parent are so rewarding in time. This was an excellent gift.
Beautiful daughter and tribute
Got me tearing up! God Bless you!
That was BEAUTIFUL!! Alexa is so talented!! How perfectly sweet she is! She is dressed as sweet as she sang that song to her daddy. What a gift to Billy Joel. I cried! Great job, Alexa! 💗
Her voice fits this song really enjoyed it
WOW. Alexa Joel has some damn good pipes! This recording is a true tribute to her father, mother and to Lulu. I'm looking forward to hearing more from her!
Truly the father CHERISHED THE MOMENT! Splendid indeed. Wonderfully done.❤ we all saw her when she's just a baby ..NOW she sings to her dad. Great feelings ❤
Wow…Very impressive. She’s got a beautiful voice and is very comfortable on stage. Thanks for sharing this special performance.
Im not crying, youre crying!!! 🤥😭. That was so beautiful. 🙏🏾❤️
Beautiful ❤
She has an incredible voice!!
Those shoe scare me. Great song well done❤
I know! I was just hoping she wouldn’t trip and sprain her ankle.
🍃🌺🍃 Hugs to both-
Happiness 🍃🌺🍃
Makes me cry. We watched her grow up from a tiny baby girl. She loves her daddy. Can't believe she's 38 already.
You did good, Billy. You did good.
😎😎🎹🎹👏👏😭😭🤗🤗♥️♥️💃💃
Really lovely hearing her sing. Beautiful! One of my fave oldies 🎶🎶👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 love the shoes, Alexa.
WOW. If this doesn’t bring tears to your eyes, then there’s something wrong with you. They’ve raised a sweet,respectful daughter 😊
You go, Girl!!
She's amazing.