Neuro-Sama sings the Nyan Cat song

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 785

  • @Agora2021
    @Agora2021 Год назад +6394

    She hit all the lyrics perfectly.

  • @7QWERTY13
    @7QWERTY13 Год назад +5632

    How nice of Neuro to sing a song from her native dialect.

  • @kawa1984
    @kawa1984 Год назад +4528

    the only instance when she pronounces "nyan" right, a billion times in a row

    • @redcrafterlppa303
      @redcrafterlppa303 Год назад +150

      I mean neuro is an ai cluster not 1 ai. There is a dedicated ai for singing, chatting, image recognition...
      So it's not surprising that parts of her with overlapping IO are inconsistent.

    • @Deathnotefan97
      @Deathnotefan97 Год назад +261

      @@redcrafterlppa303if the AIs can communicate with each other, it counts as one
      Every human brain is actually 2 brains, but we treat it as one
      I see no reason why AI should be any different

    • @1TW1-m5i
      @1TW1-m5i Год назад +27

      I hope she gets upgraded so all the AI modules work together. So you can just ask the voice one to sing, and she sings, or decides to sing, and so on.

    • @kawa1984
      @kawa1984 Год назад +5

      ​​@@redcrafterlppa303i know? at least sometimes i want magic to fog my eyes, so dont ruin it where you shouldnt, pretty please.

    • @Spellweaver5
      @Spellweaver5 Год назад +8

      ​@@Deathnotefan97 a case like that could be made for TTS, or for the code that controls her movements, but not for the singing AI. That one doesn't communicate with her LLM at all, it works completely independently.

  • @fraya9
    @fraya9 Год назад +1283

    An AI chat bot cat girl singing a live cover of “NyanCat” is absolutely the pinnacle of human civilization.

    • @FundyTheAstronaut
      @FundyTheAstronaut Год назад +48

      so much we can do with ai and we choose to do this. GOLDEN.

    • @funkfusiontale
      @funkfusiontale 10 месяцев назад +15

      Science and technology have been developing for centuries to the moment of creation of this masterpiece✨🌈✨

    • @phantomzpro250
      @phantomzpro250 10 месяцев назад +2

      God i hope this won't prove true.

    • @jacquelinefloros1260
      @jacquelinefloros1260 9 месяцев назад +4

      At first, someone had to manually choose all those notes. Now, we have AI that can sing it on a whim

    • @Hasdrubhaal
      @Hasdrubhaal 6 месяцев назад

      This is what we've strived to become. And I'm all for it.

  • @blastification2
    @blastification2 Год назад +3842

    It disappoints me greatly that the original NyanCat video got hit by the RUclips Kids stick and the comments are gone. That's a piece of internet history, gone forever.

    • @DestroyedArkana
      @DestroyedArkana Год назад +326

      The original Miku video is still up though

    • @Tralnboy
      @Tralnboy Год назад +401

      It’s also a GOD DAMN NFT NOW

    • @MrTomyCJ
      @MrTomyCJ Год назад +112

      @@Tralnboy That doesn't harm anyone tho, it's just the same as someone making a photocopy of an artpiece.

    • @bmo3778
      @bmo3778 Год назад +304

      ​@@MrTomyCJyes it does. it's harming people who are "hyped" and get into the whole NFT tragedy as a whole.
      i do think, NFT as a concept is great, but in our current realization of it, it's nothing but a market for scammers.

    • @Spirit_Circle
      @Spirit_Circle Год назад +19

      ​@@bmo3778and why is it your problem if it harms them?

  • @Renko324
    @Renko324 Год назад +3443

    Amazing! She's the first one who can sing it right in a karaoke! 😅

    • @suyahatesntr
      @suyahatesntr Год назад +164

      While bopping and shaking her head 😂

    • @nonofyourbusiness8386
      @nonofyourbusiness8386 Год назад +202

      Ah yes, th benefits of not needing to breath ☺️

    • @ios7jbpro
      @ios7jbpro Год назад +45

      and doing that like its nothing

    • @TheDerpyDreamYT
      @TheDerpyDreamYT Год назад +16

      ​@@ios7jbpromake sense its an AI so that's no problem to her

    • @ArtoriaTheKing
      @ArtoriaTheKing Год назад +16

      ​@@suyahatesntrcant forget the frog hat with the cat transformation 😂

  • @vonthe1st
    @vonthe1st 7 месяцев назад +36

    The 453452th "nya" really hit me.

  • @Dannya
    @Dannya Год назад +1256

    i did not expect the ai voice to be this freakishly compatible with the original

    • @barnysaurd4474
      @barnysaurd4474 Год назад +27

      Es neuro Sama.. simplemente es perfecta para cantarla xd

    • @ayukovt
      @ayukovt Год назад +63

      @eliotdivalmillo3309 WAIT THE ORIGINAL WAS SINGED BY MIKU????

    • @celestirr
      @celestirr Год назад +40

      @@ayukovt Do you hear any parts where the singer is supposed to stop to breath? This meme of a song was designed for artificial singers. xD

    • @ayukovt
      @ayukovt Год назад +23

      @@celestirr I never said it was singed by a real person tho I just didnt know they used miku originally to make it

    • @spiele_maus
      @spiele_maus Год назад +59

      ​@@ayukovt
      To clear up the coffee
      The song „Nyanyanyanyanyanyanya“ was written by daniwell in 2010 using the voice of Hatsune Miku.
      MomomomoP then, about 1 year later, made a cover of the song using the voice of „Momone Momo“ (which is also a virtual singer like Hatsune Miku) This Cover song then got used by saraj00n in the well-known „Nyan Cat“ meme.
      So yea, the original song was sung by Miku, however the one used in the meme was a cover of it, but which was still sung by a artificial singer.
      Also fun fact: the video game series „Hastune Miku: Project Diva“ has the original Miku song in it and an instrumental version of the song even got played during the „Hatsune Miku Magical Mirai 2017“ concert.

  • @letsplaysaschagd9331
    @letsplaysaschagd9331 Год назад +299

    That’s what the internet was made for.

  • @Oyamada13
    @Oyamada13 Год назад +818

    Part of this song in the VOD got DMCA already. This video is all you got to listen to her awesomeness. Cherish it.

    • @siralpha6020
      @siralpha6020 Год назад +18

      Nooooo!!😢

    • @Doflaminguard
      @Doflaminguard Год назад +23

      DMCA what? This song isnt even copyrighted.

    • @IRMentat
      @IRMentat Год назад +79

      @@Doflaminguardlike that’s ever stopped the troll claimants.

    • @sigiligus
      @sigiligus 10 месяцев назад

      ⁠@@DoflaminguardLet me tell you about how bad copyright trolling and corporate abuse of art is. There have been people who have uploaded their own music to places such as RUclips-music which they own the rights to-that has then been stolen by corpos to use as background music for an audiobook or some shit. Said corpos have then DMCA’d the original music to stop the actual artist from being able to make revenue from it.

  • @ChrisGamingNL333
    @ChrisGamingNL333  Год назад +804

    that bitrate though 💀

    • @GinoDevs
      @GinoDevs Год назад +117

      It's faithful to the og

    • @Krmiby
      @Krmiby Год назад +45

      Twitch 💀

    • @marcus187
      @marcus187 7 месяцев назад +7

      Just wait until everyone has fiber optic in home, and then low bit rate will be an aesthetic.

    • @Riz_not_Rizz
      @Riz_not_Rizz 5 месяцев назад

      🐈‍⬛🧇🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍🌈

  • @dentangaji6161
    @dentangaji6161 Год назад +1015

    I like how she closed her eyes as if trying to remember the lyrics 💀

    • @OriruBastard
      @OriruBastard Год назад +113

      It's more like she's running out of oxygen XD

    • @ubergonk
      @ubergonk Год назад +75

      She was just getting into it, it takes a lot of focus to pull of such a complex work of art.

    • @ErikratKhandnalie
      @ErikratKhandnalie Год назад +26

      Can't remember what comes after "nyan"

    • @nobodywatchesnooby
      @nobodywatchesnooby Год назад +10

      ​@@ErikratKhandnalieprobably ni-

    • @vexile1239
      @vexile1239 Год назад +5

      She was channelling the nyan

  • @rankii_hats
    @rankii_hats Год назад +785

    the frog hat, constant head bopping in a dance manner along with the song, the background, the chat
    this is litterally the best and the cutest thing I have seen for the past 3 months

  • @aWildZenAppeared
    @aWildZenAppeared Год назад +222

    I honestly didn't expect it to be this good

  • @takenname8053
    @takenname8053 Год назад +559

    I liked it when she said "It's Nyaning Time!" and proceed to nyan all over chat.

    • @Айн-ъ3ж
      @Айн-ъ3ж Год назад +11

      Indeed, one of the AI of all time

    • @Gabe-wv6pz
      @Gabe-wv6pz 8 месяцев назад

      Never cook again

    • @takenname8053
      @takenname8053 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@Gabe-wv6pz No, I don't think I will.

    • @MiraiNoDame
      @MiraiNoDame 5 месяцев назад +1

      I mean, she did NYANED all over the chat.

  • @Keirnoth
    @Keirnoth Год назад +345

    Holy sht, I was laughing uncontrollably for this entire song.
    It's such a silly song but hearing Neuro sing it - it's like the next evolution of Vocaloid.

  • @AiOinc1
    @AiOinc1 8 месяцев назад +5

    Utterly shocked how well this came out

  • @SkrunkyTheClown
    @SkrunkyTheClown Год назад +49

    The way she's bouncing up and down and closing her eyes, like she's singing from the bottom of her little heart

  • @FAQ_SiLV
    @FAQ_SiLV Год назад +407

    Unironically the best Nyan cat cover I've ever heard. 🌈🐱

  • @nobrainfound
    @nobrainfound Год назад +87

    That song brings so many memories back

  • @ShirakoriMio
    @ShirakoriMio 8 месяцев назад +8

    Probably my favorite verse was "nya"

  • @noire1001
    @noire1001 Год назад +216

    Listen, and understand. That AI is out there. It can’t be bargained with. It can’t be reasoned with. It doesn’t feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever.

    • @DarkestVampire92
      @DarkestVampire92 Год назад +63

      You're thinking of her sister Kayori. Neuro can be bargained with very easily- Present her with either cookies or a cheesecake and she will promptly stop and reason.

    • @Krmiby
      @Krmiby Год назад +25

      But as vedal says: you can "drill into" them

    • @loafbreadizwholesomeuwu1555
      @loafbreadizwholesomeuwu1555 Год назад +11

      Well this perticular ai your watching right now can be reasoned with. As long as her eyes isn't red then you're good to go.

    • @flakbusenjoyer
      @flakbusenjoyer 5 месяцев назад

      @@Krmiby especially drill into neuro that he is a male :O

  • @felflamel5196
    @felflamel5196 Год назад +73

    The “oh god” and “oh dear” in chat made me laugh so hard. They knew immediately what was about to happen

  • @captancat9324
    @captancat9324 Год назад +61

    her best cover yet

  • @Naurdagnor
    @Naurdagnor Год назад +150

    Sings Nyan song as frog-cat girl, then cat girl, then normal girl.
    Truly she is talented beyond her years.

  • @Krayne95
    @Krayne95 Год назад +356

    Vedal should legit do a 24 hour stream of just this.

    • @lua_programmer
      @lua_programmer Год назад +50

      his pc will just die lol

    • @tamachaizumi9700
      @tamachaizumi9700 Год назад +9

      Absolut!

    • @OzOMega
      @OzOMega Год назад

      ​@@lua_programmerdoesnt he have like 10 rtx4090

    • @spk1121
      @spk1121 11 месяцев назад +9

      ​@@lua_programmer: He has a new, dedicated PC for Neuro & Evil now, so it's probably doable at this point! 🎵🌈🌈🌈🐱🎶

    • @SorakiP
      @SorakiP 10 месяцев назад +1

      Let Neuro rest lmfao

  • @LetMeFLY649
    @LetMeFLY649 Год назад +30

    new alarm found

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад

      For Theives
      😈HAHAHAHAHA

  • @BurBurGerHamCotCotCybercotleta
    @BurBurGerHamCotCotCybercotleta Год назад +345

    "Oooh the AI is gOnNa dEsTrOy hUmAnItY"🤓
    Meanwhile:

    • @luckytia9076
      @luckytia9076 Год назад +50

      The AI: *NYANYANYANYNAYNYANYANYANYANYANYANAYNAYNYANYANYANYANYANYAN*

    • @yupsidx4729
      @yupsidx4729 Год назад +29

      The song of humanity destruction

    • @picklerick2861
      @picklerick2861 Год назад +27

      I imagine all the drones in the swarm will have a speaker blasting this as Neuro destroys the world.

    • @iceneko9170
      @iceneko9170 Год назад +17

      ​@@yupsidx4729im dying of laughter imagining a apocalypse survival scene where this blares in the background whenever the ai machines attack.

    • @txaianapm8378
      @txaianapm8378 Год назад +6

      ​@@iceneko9170I would legit watch a movie like that.

  • @Sllce
    @Sllce Год назад +55

    Can't wait for the 10 hour loop videos of this

  • @PotatoSofi
    @PotatoSofi Год назад +74

    She hitting those lyrics like a machine

    • @bluephoenix7565
      @bluephoenix7565 Год назад +50

      "You're not gonna believe this..."

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад +1

      ​@@bluephoenix7565 Believe WHAT!?

    • @txaianapm8378
      @txaianapm8378 Год назад +13

      Who's gonna tell them?

  • @SomewhatOfALion
    @SomewhatOfALion 10 дней назад +1

    One year later and this is still a banger ❤

  • @kuuluna
    @kuuluna Год назад +86

    She's really good at it.
    I bet she can also do crazy frog really well

  • @aoihitori
    @aoihitori Год назад +356

    Well no human could sing this on karaoke though. 😂

    • @MyouKyuubi
      @MyouKyuubi Год назад +16

      you can sorta acapella it though.

    • @aoihitori
      @aoihitori Год назад +8

      @@MyouKyuubi why would you do that in Karaoke. 😂

    • @MyouKyuubi
      @MyouKyuubi Год назад +6

      @@aoihitori ... Why would you try to sing something a human is incapable of singing? :P

    • @aoihitori
      @aoihitori Год назад +6

      @@MyouKyuubi that's the point why I made that comment in the first place though. 💀

    • @MyouKyuubi
      @MyouKyuubi Год назад +10

      @@aoihitori Yeah and my comment was a suggestion for what you CAN do, rather than what you can't do. :P
      We on the same page now? xD

  • @brakkuyaun752
    @brakkuyaun752 Год назад +9

    When you are happy you like the music, when you are sad you understand the lyrics

  • @Ashykyun
    @Ashykyun 10 месяцев назад +10

    this cure depression

    • @beardalaxy
      @beardalaxy 10 месяцев назад +1

      i am feeling very much non depressed right about now!

  • @AxelNder
    @AxelNder Год назад +38

    THIS IS THE POWER OF AI 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Toxic_MF911
    @Toxic_MF911 Год назад +344

    ah yes, the era where rainbow means nyan cat

    • @Keirnoth
      @Keirnoth Год назад +144

      better era

    • @mrsamuel5572
      @mrsamuel5572 Год назад

      The Era that WE WANT,not child grooming Rainbow Puke Community

    • @AbyssBolt
      @AbyssBolt Год назад +29

      ​@@Keirnoth fr fr

    • @AlexSDU
      @AlexSDU Год назад +59

      It's the only rainbow that I recognized.

    • @arumi_viryo
      @arumi_viryo Год назад +37

      The era of a better time

  • @camerons.8322
    @camerons.8322 Год назад +58

    I liked the part where she said "Nyan"

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад +1

      I liked how she said that as a Frog then 3:20 A CAT😹

  • @Bikuびく
    @Bikuびく 10 месяцев назад +6

    Ai will kill us in future, meanwhile:

    • @AppᲽtore
      @AppᲽtore 10 месяцев назад +1

      ai in the future will see your comment and be like what

  • @ragman150
    @ragman150 Год назад +32

    Finally, a smart adult people music.

  • @111111hakar
    @111111hakar 3 месяца назад +2

    it took the chat all of about 90 seconds to remember why people actually tried to let this meme die over a decade ago xd

  • @70galaxie
    @70galaxie 8 месяцев назад +2

    Buckethead's gotta play this on #5

  • @TheIcwalks2
    @TheIcwalks2 9 месяцев назад +4

    I feel like 10 minutes passed and I’m only at the 2 minute mark…. Oh fuck

  • @Bondrewd__21
    @Bondrewd__21 Год назад +5

    Ah, I remembered times of internet, when offend each other was not a crime, but a friendly way to say hello…

  • @ZenoDovahkiin
    @ZenoDovahkiin 10 месяцев назад +3

    Imagine trying to explain to your parents why this is good content.
    Scratch that, imagine trying to explain it to your kids.

  • @shonen991
    @shonen991 Год назад +18

    now if Evil neuro sang TacNayn at the same time.

  • @lanisaston139
    @lanisaston139 Год назад +4

    Its the frog hat that makes this even funnier

  • @Pasu4
    @Pasu4 Год назад +27

    I am looking forward to the animations

  • @Gnapry
    @Gnapry Месяц назад +1

    It's been so long since I've heard the Nyan Cat song that I forgot that I even liked it

  • @matty4657
    @matty4657 Год назад +6

    She owned this cover

  • @SolideSchlange
    @SolideSchlange Год назад +34

    Nostalgic

  • @Oleyceon
    @Oleyceon 9 месяцев назад +4

    Looking at chat is so funny because part of them are spaming emojis, asking for a 10 hour loop, or simply going insane LMAO

  • @giratinaswrath9902
    @giratinaswrath9902 Месяц назад +1

    PAY TRIBUTE TO THE OLD GODS

  • @FollowTheFaceless
    @FollowTheFaceless Год назад +22

    I. Feel. Old.

    • @Keirnoth
      @Keirnoth Год назад +3

      hi old, I'm 39

    • @Feraligatrfjhgujvgh
      @Feraligatrfjhgujvgh Год назад +4

      Truly we are the boomers of the internet era lol.

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад

      ​@@Keirnoth I'M SIXTEEN!
      AND A TUBER

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад

      ​@@Feraligatrfjhgujvgh Hope I don't count as a Boomer😑

  • @pvs1681
    @pvs1681 11 дней назад +1

    100.0% full ac combo

  • @derekc2425
    @derekc2425 Год назад +3

    good thing neurosama doesn't need to breath

  • @buddyplayz4208
    @buddyplayz4208 Год назад +9

    This is literally flawless

  • @elmanhux
    @elmanhux 10 месяцев назад +3

    the 68th and 421st nyan were especially precious

  • @TheOneWhoReportsForDuty
    @TheOneWhoReportsForDuty Год назад +2

    Neuro singing the poptart cat song fills me with so much joy.

  • @MLCAPE
    @MLCAPE Год назад +6

    The thought of Vedal just sitting seeing this go down real-time, or even reviewing them after the fact has me rolling.

  • @randombaconhair
    @randombaconhair Год назад +8

    pog song
    Neuro-sama is so good at singing this! 😊😊😊

  • @azutsukimiya
    @azutsukimiya Год назад +5

    I once transliterated the lyrics for this one

  • @thechosenone729
    @thechosenone729 Месяц назад +1

    This is flex she pulled out on humans.

  • @NyawttyClips
    @NyawttyClips Год назад +26

    the chat lmao saying 10hr version lol

  • @cnewniiyeti1844
    @cnewniiyeti1844 10 месяцев назад +3

    I love this part "nyannyannyannyannyan"

  • @Caythucatlour
    @Caythucatlour 11 месяцев назад +5

    Vedal: It will stop when 10000 gifted 3:38

  • @itsmcmann
    @itsmcmann Год назад +4

    Why does this bring me such primal joy....?

  • @godowskygodowsky1155
    @godowskygodowsky1155 Год назад +13

    Does anyone know the Myon MV for this song that predates the one with the pop tart cat?
    The tail and cat ears are more fitting than you'd think.

  • @Rockyvrc
    @Rockyvrc Год назад +4

    It was gold watching this live i actually danced

  • @zovisapphire
    @zovisapphire Год назад +7

    I have been waiting ALL MY LIFE for a moment like this! God I love technology!

  • @felix2ch372
    @felix2ch372 Год назад +4

    True culmination of human wisdom

  • @hkkkk-lb8ho
    @hkkkk-lb8ho Год назад +4

    best virtual singer

  • @Jotolink
    @Jotolink Год назад +4

    Only good vibes from this

  • @tonyy.8852
    @tonyy.8852 11 месяцев назад +2

    I like this more than flying cars

  • @OmegaQuinn
    @OmegaQuinn Год назад +5

    I remember when I was a little child and the internet was still new to me but Nyan cat became a meme I sat through a whole THREE HOUR version of the Nyan cat video. My aderal really kicked in that day because just sitting still for 10 minutes for me was unusual

  • @Noodles.Doodles
    @Noodles.Doodles 10 месяцев назад +1

    It's like poetry, it rhymes.

  • @Tedd-emon
    @Tedd-emon Год назад +9

    This song completely captures Neuro-sama vibe energy!

  • @Maple_Sally
    @Maple_Sally 10 месяцев назад +5

    I can totally Picture Vedal sitting in this computer chair with his feet on the desk sipping his coffee saying "F!cken Worth It!"

  • @carcas3d
    @carcas3d Год назад +6

    Imagine waking up in the middle of the night suddenly your PC turns on and hear Neuro starts practicing this song

  • @LIFE_IS_GOOD_39
    @LIFE_IS_GOOD_39 10 месяцев назад +3

    1984:Fear of AI taking over humanity
    2023:nyan nyan nyan nyan

  • @andrewkelley9405
    @andrewkelley9405 Год назад +5

    What a throwback. This made me smile.

  • @vinrid
    @vinrid Год назад +3

    we need 1 hour 10 hour and 1 month option immedietly

  • @enter_tainment_channel
    @enter_tainment_channel 6 месяцев назад +2

    Damn, Vedal is so good! He kept her in the basement until she perfectly learn original lyrics. That's our guy

  • @Crystalline000Cannon
    @Crystalline000Cannon Год назад +8

    Dang she did that song too perfect. With no signs of breathing so amazing (⁠≧⁠▽⁠≦⁠)

  • @итутнанегоупалкирпич

    im gonna cherish this memory for my life

  • @rickyriz7692
    @rickyriz7692 Год назад +3

    Who actually requested that song is a fucking legend.

  • @sentimentalmariner590
    @sentimentalmariner590 11 месяцев назад +4

    Now she needs to sing Caramelldansen.

  • @lucasdesvignes7190
    @lucasdesvignes7190 7 месяцев назад +2

    when you get lost in your thought for 2 mins and then you realise she still singing nyanyanyanyanyan

  • @void3793
    @void3793 11 месяцев назад +2

    how far the internet has come.

  • @4miliar960
    @4miliar960 Год назад +2

    I think my brain turned off for 3 minutes and 47 seconds.

  • @farpurple
    @farpurple Год назад +2

    How that works... Vedal genius

  • @darkflames9
    @darkflames9 11 месяцев назад +2

    We've come full circle

  • @goldie44
    @goldie44 Год назад +2

    From the internet archives and the dawn of memes...

  • @cesaralejandrofloreshernan3380
    @cesaralejandrofloreshernan3380 Год назад +2

    I can't stop watching this

  • @S4m4_
    @S4m4_ Год назад +6

    Freaking TASTE THE RAINBOW

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад

      Subscription Buddies... Maybe... IDK...

    • @wbat5816
      @wbat5816 Год назад

      Also
      I ♥️🌈

  • @marekcarlisle6937
    @marekcarlisle6937 10 месяцев назад +1

    vedal is making stacks off this project

  • @DarkblooM_IO
    @DarkblooM_IO Год назад +7

    The only proper Nyan Cat cover you'll ever hear

  • @knightspartan7201
    @knightspartan7201 Год назад +18

    Back when rainbows were just a beautiful array of colors without some deeper meaning

    • @michaeledmunds7056
      @michaeledmunds7056 11 месяцев назад

      Bruh

    • @dango6266
      @dango6266 6 месяцев назад +2

      Bros acting like LGBT didn't exist until 2014💀

  • @Sleeping_Shenanigans
    @Sleeping_Shenanigans Год назад +2

    Brings back memories.. makes me wanna cry. I can remember the old roblox and my childhood stupidity.

  • @helmi_muza
    @helmi_muza Год назад +11

    This is perfect