Don't ignore this Remove Tool flaw | A Remove Tool in Photoshop How-To
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июл 2024
- All about the Remove Tool in Photoshop, AKA the Sparkly Tool - and no I will never stop giving these tools ‘Jess names’. Photoshops Remove Tool is amazing and will work absolute wonders for getting rid of dog eye bogeys, unwanted hairs, pieces of dust, and leash removal when working on editing your images.
However, there is one HUGE downside to this fabulous tool, which I'll go through in detail in this video and show you exactly how to fix it to make your images seamless.
🔗 Blog post on this topic: thattogspot.com/how-to-use-th...
🔗 Membership Info because I totally failed: thattogspot.com/become-a-member
🔗 Photoshop for Beginners Online Course - Remastered for PS 2024: thattogspot.com/photoshop-for...
Timestamps for scrubbing:
00:00 Intro
00:35 About the remove tool
01:30 The example image
01:51 The membership
02:38 Back to the tutorial
02:44 Photoshop set up
03:20 Action the remove tool
03:29 Making selections
04:10 Leash removal
05:07 Removal tool good and bad life choices
05:29 The biggest issue with the removal tool
07:19 How to fix the fingerprint
09:00 The final image outcome
🙏 Be sure to subscribe to our channel for weekly content on all things photography 🙏
________________________________________________________________________________________
Membership
The highly popular Membership is available here
www.thattogspot.com/become-a-...
Members get everything you get now here on RUclips plus exclusive access to the following:
❖ A private VIP Community
❖ 1 x in-depth individual monthly critique (+ only)
❖ 1 x extended webinar per month (at least 1!)
❖ 1 x quarterly magazine delivered to your door twice per year
❖ Monthly Q&A time with Jess
❖ Minimum of 10% off all TPS shop items
❖ Lifetime access to any enrolled courses
❖ PS Actions/LR Presets of any technique covered
❖ Bonus videos for personal & professional growth
❖ Access to scaling certifications (the BTog, STog & GTog)
❖ Membership & certification badges for marketing
________________________________________________________________________________________
Our other social channels are:
❖ Instagram - / thattogspot
❖ Facebook Group - / thattogspot
❖ TikTok - / thattogspot
For more information on us, what we do, and what we offer visit us at www.thattogspot.com
Check out these:
❖ FREE Community Resources - www.thattogspot.com/community...
❖ Professional ONLINE one-to-ones - www.thattogspot.com/online-ph...
❖ ONLINE courses - www.thattogspot.com/online-ph...
________________________________________________________________________________________
My Core Kit
❖ Sony A1
❖ Sony A7riii - geni.us/A3zFah
❖ Camera Bag - uk.tenba.com/tenba-axis-v2-24...
❖ Camera Strap - geni.us/TgjAme
❖ My Mac - amzn.to/2TdEhGF (mine is custom but this is close)
❖ BenQ ScreenBar - geni.us/screenbarTPS
❖ Hard Drives - geni.us/gvip
My Top Lenses
❖ Sigma Art 105 1.4 - geni.us/aZAAi2
❖ Sony GM 135 1.8 - geni.us/aA7Xu1l
❖ Sony GM 24-70 2.8 - geni.us/9GGieI
❖ Sony GM 70-200 2.8 OSS II
Shooting Bits
❖ Universal Lens Cap - geni.us/2ffmm
❖ Lens Cleaning Kit - geni.us/L8AT
❖ Memory Cards - geni.us/YE5eM
❖ Datacolor SpyderCheckr Photo - geni.us/checkr
Studio Kit •Thanks to Pixapro for 10% off using 10OFFTPSJM•
❖ Studio Strobes - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Soft Box Pick - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Light Stands - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Backdrop Stands - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Sand Bags - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Boom Arm and Stand - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
❖ Paper Backgrounds - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/cate...
❖ Reflector - www.essentialphoto.co.uk/prod...
I really appreciate these bite-sized video 'snack' tutorials that are easy to consume and quickly incorporated into the own workflow with the new features in Photoshop. Once the 'sparkling tool' ignites the enthusiasm about the possibilities, it's important that it you also shed light on the importance of maintaining appropriate quality control. Thank you for providing these helpful videos. Cheers …
I am glad that you enjoy these bite-sized tutorials and that they prove useful for you 🤓
In situations where the ‘Sparkle Tool’ does not deliver acceptable results and Content-aware Fill neither, I usually do the deletions via “Generative Fill” because I have come to like the three options it offers.
Problem with that is that generative fill only produces low resolution output, which is as obvious as the patterning of the remove tool, unless you do your work in very small tiles or you're using a very low resolution camera. And too, apart from the pattern generation in place of noise issue, the remove tool usually does a better job than gen fill for removal. With the files out of my R5, the gen fill tool output looks awful.
I don’t use generative tools at the moment, so this would not be an option I would take. Maybe one day this will change, but at the moment I’d rather the replacement pixels come from my own image rather than the ether of firefly. Glad you have a workflow that works for you though!
Thanks for taking the time to help us.
super helpful as usual Jess, thanks for taking the time to help all of us.
thank you so much 🙏
Peanut! She is such a great dog model! ❤
She so is, 10/10 for this sweetheart!
You rock, thanks Jess!
Thank you for yet updating the remove tools in Photoshop, cause they have evolved so much !!
Funny enough I had an ad for Topaz Denoise AIA before this video 😂😂
Cool. What I do in my workflow is I create a new blank layer above and use the 'sparkly tool' to edit onto that, therefore if goes a bit wrong I've got it on its own layer and is not distructive on the original layer.
Super Gary!
Omg, I literally stopped using it for that exact reason. I thought I was going mad and you're absolutely right now the remove tool doesn't work properly anymore. 😞I really want to go back to an older version that didn't have this as it's so frustrating. 😭
It sure can be frustrating and tempting to go back to a previous version of PS for sure
Great video Jess. I haven't been using it for removals because of the fingerprint and healing brush not working but didn't think to use the clone stamp! Will give that a go but still find your line removal process works better than most PS source thingies haha!
Thank you 🙏 Awww I am glad you like my line removal process so much 🤓
Tank you
Spot on Jess.
thank you 🙂
Sparkly tool: Bugger; never going to get that out of my head now. In any case, the sparkly tool gives substantially better results if you do all your noise reduction first, since the 'fingerprint' is its inability to model randomized noise, and it just makes patterned texture instead.
For sure! Though it can still crop up in other situations too, for example, fabrics with high detail, so it’s worth having a triple check to make sure 🤓
@@ThatPhotographySpot never thought of the pattern in fabrics; good point.
You might see it performs better if you apply noise program like topaz on noisy inages first before using the remove tool and you likely won't see this artefact.
I’m brand new to this channel and this is the first video I’ve watched. My question is: why not use lasso and generative fill?
AI generated pixels are banned for most competitions. I don’t retouch with generative ai at the moment, everything is created via the pixels in the image only.
@@ThatPhotographySpot I see. Is it safe to say you edit with the end goal of submitting your work to competitions? Thanks for your reply.
Not every image no, but my workflows stay compliant anyway just to keep it simple 😊
Because of the fingerprint I started cheating on the "Sparkly Tool" with the lasso tool and generative fill. I think remove tool is mostly good with the small stuff (though I always have cmd z at the ready for when it makes "bad life choices"), but I've always had issues with the leads and generative fill does a better job, at least for my purposes
I don’t use generative tools at the moment, so this would not be an option I would take personally (maybe one day this will change, probably when non-generative options just don’t exist anymore, but at the moment I’d rather the replacement pixels come from my own image rather than the ether of firefly). Glad you have a workflow that works for you though!
@@ThatPhotographySpot I hear you! It's a debate I've had with myself and I definitely respect the position. Thank you for sharing your awesome tips and perspective, it's always a great day when you post a video!
Adobe giveth, and Adobe taketh away.
The sparkly tool puts hash tags everywhere 😫
It is something we have to be careful of and can be so frustrating 😠
So... what you are saying is Adobe failed to properly test this tool.
Kinda, yes. 🫣