Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Whole India is swayed over the movie 'The Kashmiri Files'. Please make a video on this movie. The Movie, it seems will break all box-office records. Even many countries are taking note of this movie. The movie is based on true events. It is directed by Atul Aghnihotri. Please do an extensive research on this movie. This movie will have great influence on the Politics and power struggle of KASHMIR.
Biggest war crime of Saudi excuted 81 people in mass execution in a day with fair trial... and shamefully UK pm visited Saudi ... UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet and UN HRC condemn Saudi war crime
Another similar incident that was very tragic was when Gujarat CM Balawantrai Mehta was killed by Pakistan Airforce while his unarmed civil plane was still in Indian air space.
It was not a stray missile but was launched intentionally to take out the civilian plain which was mistaken as a war plane ….and at that time india and Pakistan were already engaged in the war ……
@@123xyzabccba Yes it was during the 65 war, but like you said, a civil aircraft was shot down by PAF "by mistake" and it resulted in loss of lives too.
We hit Pakistan But the sad part is Our netizens are so proud of this which explains alot about our public’s mentality. Our online nationalism is cringy to say the least.
Like wise on that side too, and their media is nuts😂😂, I wish Pak media to be more mature and let their people know the real thing rather immature way of dealing India.
This episode of CTC is indeed for everyone to take careful note of, it cuts through ideologies of people and provides insight to an impending doom if negligence goes hand in hand with dangerous weapons. The snippets from the past incidents around the world are very profound in establishing the fact that none of us want these weapons to be used for what they were made.
You are talking in a loose manner . Do u think if there were life losses then Pakistan don't retiliate ? Obviously Pakistan would have retiliated . This retiliation may lead to serious war and who will suffer most ? The civilians offcourse
@Sharma It is half relief. Full would have been there after having been responded. So luckily sense of responsibility prevailed that you Rundian don’t have it.
They knew everything, it was to give a message before Talks with Chinese. Within two days Chinese foreign minister announced visit. Pakistan pissed in pants it was a high value target which got eleminated too it had war heads.
Scenario : Indian unarmed Missile lands "by mistake" in Pakistan and totally evades Chinese supplied Air defence systems the day before India and China meet for the 15th time to resolve border dispute ?? Kill the chicken to scare the monkey ?? Clue 1 : note the number of assorted missile tests India has done since Galwan .. Clue 2 : Why the Philippines chose this system ??
May the neurons play their part... Brother have your own world and play this drama over there... You can discuss the strengths but never the readiness for war on both sides... Gupta sir has made so much efforts to bring some sense in thinking and you are again hunting clues
@@armaanoona He is admiring the pakistanis for handling the situation maturely. The truth is that the only reason they are calm recently is because their economy is struggling. The way the missile reached pakistan is intentional. Airspace is full of aeroplanes but they travel in a fixed corridor and height.
@@deepakthirdreich well this is all open to debate but I think Pakistan is in far better economic conditions than at times when PAF shot down MiG-21. The point is only to talk objectively, beyond personal buildups.
If one understands game theory and MAD concepts, it becomes obvious as to how that neither side is in a position to use it. Tactical nukes are nukes too. No one can pretend they are not.
But I don't understand how this Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) systems achieves anything when destruction takes place on both sides. If the war takes place the winner grieves secretly and the loser grieves openly . But grieving is imminent on both sides!!!!
Little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Game theory does not apply here. MAD concept only applies to Russia and USA which are large countries. Countries like Pakistan can be totally destroyed by India's first attack. Small countries with nuclear weapons cannot use nuclear deterrence. Even for countries like Russia MAD does not apply that well because it lacks credible 2nd strike capability. This is why Russia is fighting in Ukraine.
@@ppen8359 it's a very risky gamble to assume that your enemy will lose its second strike capability. A decimal percentage error in your estimates will have a nuclear winter ahead. It's a stupid gamble. It's soothing to see that Pakistan acted as a mature party here
@@ppen8359 well Pakistan surely have more nukes than India. In 2006-2007 at the end of Musharaf era Pak had around 600 warheads some reports even claimed that Pakistan has the fastest growing nuclear arsenal and coz of tactical nukes no one was even criticizing it. Now Pak have more better technologies to deliver those warheads as Pak already have MIRVs in Ababeel Missile so any miscalculation can result in nuclear winter and that will not end with just the strikes and their immediate impact but radiation and famine. And that means no one will be able to enjoy a victory.
A fine and sober analysis. Many thanks. The accidental launch of BrahMos is a big embarrassment for India. It is positioning itself as an exporter of arms, especially missiles. It has entered into contract for supplying BrahMos to Philipines, and is negotiating similar contracts with Vietnam and a few SE nations. This kind of accident will cast serious doubt on the reliability of India's defence products. India should do a lot more to assuage the misgivings in the minds of these nations. India is being mocked at. I feel bad about it. When 1998 nuclear test was done, Western press mocked India as nuclear boys, and pointed out that nuclear men have systems for delivering nuclear wapons, which India did not have. During the last two decades, India has developed and manufactured large varieties of missiles. Probably, between the USSR and the US many more such accidents have happened. That is no consolation. They were geographically far apart, which gave some time for analysis of situation. Between India and Pakistant, the time available will be a matter of minutes for deciding whether some such similar event is an accident, or false alarm, or indeed an attack. Far greater caution is required in the matter.
Well narrated , this is something that warrants our army technical teams to scrutinise the flaws and come up with remediation measures . Also Kudos to both parties for their mature handling of the issue .
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance. Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ?
Sir, you are absalutly correct... We have heard about the aftermath result of Hiroshima and Nagasaki Nuclear attack during 2nd world war.But those are mild doses... Now the countries pose with nuclear weapons 1000 times powerful than those 2... We don't want genarations getting vaporised in any part of the world... The most greusome thing is that the survivors will dye slowly due to radiation 😪🥺...
Honestly, whatever people say about each other….no one wants a nuclear war on either side. When people die on any side, it’s human beings who suffer and loose lives. Politicians don’t suffer as much but nuclear attack won’t even leave anyone. I hope it was just a mistake and it won’t happen again.
When we fully enter Kaliyuga in hundreds of years there will be acid rain which will damage natural resources and poor nations will perish and gradually humans will fight among themselves leading to end of the world after Kalki has ruled for 1000 years.
Would love to hear your thoughts on Saudi's looking to ditch Petro dollar deal as they're hinting to begin trading in Yuan with China. What could be the opportunities and threats for India if this happens. Thanks in advance.
finally a mature commentry on this incident it is not that we are afraid of counter attack from Pakistan, but this kind of mistakes should not be done by nuclear countries specially when your enemy is also nuclear country.
We are also not afraid of India such stupid mistakes by a a nuclear armed country with other nuke armed country is stupid. Pakistan could react strongly like the europian countries did.
Sir, I admire you for sticking to the actual verified facts about any incident or story that you cover. I may not always agree with your interpretation but you still are one of the news channels that have my respect. Somehow all other channels tend to willfully omit facts to suit their own narration of an incident which leads to confusion
My analysis - 1. What Pakistan Got from missile in their land ? a. Don’t have to take sides anymore of Ukraine or Russia . Easily they will abscond that and will say they themselves are under attack . b. It might save Imran Khan projecting himself a strong leader and his country under attack 2. What China Got ? a. Lot of questions about their defence capabilities. 3. What ASEAN got ? a. A dependable missile that can attack precisely. 4. What India got ? a. New buyers from ASEAN b. Understanding that Chinese defence is weak. c. Safeguarding herself from Russia Ukraine issue This missile was nothing but a Cold War between India and China which happened in Pakistan. Same like Russia and US have done for years .
The consequences for Indians would have been dire. Thanks to Pakistan, you and your loved ones are not vapors right now….wondering what just happened. It was an extreme risk, putting the lives of so many Indians in danger, if it wasn’t a mistake.
Accidental fire seems like a lie. * Missiles will not have self destruction capabilities? If so Why it was not brought down? * Path through which it went was barren. It feels like it was carefully chosen. * It did a 90^ turn and went inside Pakistan. How's this possible without any guidance? * Was it done to demonstrate ineffectiveness of chinese air defence systems and advertise brahmos globally? * If it was accident, India had the option of reporting it to pak but not accepting it publicly. Why India accepted it?
@@prachetmakwana6011 i dont think so, every modern missiles has self destruction capabilities. Brahmos is flagship missile. I'm sure it will have. Even if it doesn't then they could have atleast maneuvered it inside indian territory.
@@ujwalmokashi6702 A weapon placed secretly to be use during war with nuclear warhead dnt have self destruction feature .. I they have then what is use of it during war ... So cruise dnt have self destruction feature... Brahmos range is approx 400 km so any ocean or sea if far away to be maneuvered in its range & missile with hitting policy already come with enemy targets pre installed ... So missile went were it was targeted deep in enemy territory.... Most important it's not once in century mistake several times by many nations this technical fault has taken place no system is 100 % secure ... faults do occur... Government has accepted it publicly in parliament ... Government must have denied it even not told Pakistan but stand was taken....remember only man with brave character have courage to accept its mistake... we have shown that....
@@SandeepSingh-fb1zq Our responsibility is to inform Pakistan and apologize. Not to media and public. The brahmos does have self destruction capabilities( IE explained article )
@@ujwalmokashi6702 yes and we have done that before going to media we told pakistan but it was pakistan who went to media first.... they done media briefing not us....
"...may be Pakistanis tracked it FROM SIRSA.....i dont know...." It is a missile that we are talking about, not a passenger train or bus ! .Missile dont take stops like trains do. If the Pakistanis did track it for a sufficient amount of time they would have computed its trajectory and the possible launch location but that would have been hard because the Brahmos is a cruise missile and can have deceptive trajectory
This is not important. What is important is that, Pakistan could have retaliated to this attack. The consequences could have been deadly. No one wants to vaporize into thin air, on either side.
A day after the Balakot air strike, as fighter jets of India and Pakistan were engaged in a dogfight near the LoC, an Mi-17V5 crashed in Budgam shortly after take-off from Srinagar killing its personnel onboard and a civilian on the ground. The Court of Inquiry confirmed that it was shot by an Israeli-origin Spyder surface-to-air missile system of the IAF.
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
SG Sir , Here in London I was mentioned this much earlier by a Pakistan friend and my knees shook . I disagreed initially spoke and smiled until I watched Raksha Mantri on LS. Scary scenario with civil aircrafts . I only wish India - Pakistan relationship improved . Common citizens ought to travel openly. Alas !
Mr. Majumdar actually The missile was not misfired. If you study it deeply then you will find that it was a planned missile fire to test the capabilities of Pakistan defence system and also
No need for it. The Northern pipe dream of Akhanda Bharatham wrapped in a fake peace process is bound to fail and be counter - productive. Cold peace with no relations is the best way to go.
*You missed a huge point - India has at least 5 layers of strong air defense systems in place, including but not limited to S-400, BARAK-8, and SPYDER. So, one nuke attack towards India from Pakistan might not even reach India properly (air interception) but the retaliatory nuke attack from India towards Pakistan would totally remove them from the world map.*
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance. Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ? The current regime makes policies, strategies and war-games with help of professionals. So let media-experts keep making all guesses.
Sir you analysis is quite neutral . I am also a Pakistani . But I think PAF Air Defense system showed a quite mature behavior. They didn't target Passenger plane like Iran did and also Indian defense system targeted their helicopter during Combat with PAF. Some people are making jokes over Pakistan's air defense system but they don't image what would happen if Pakistan lauches a missile equipped with warhead . ?
@Ghulam Mohammad Khudadad Sarwar You are talking like a child . U must know that if a missile is detected than it's not a rocket science to destroy it . Director General Interservice public relations have explained the path of missile completely
@@ranadeepkundu5357 let's not get into pointing fingers at each other as we have fanatics and poverty on both side. We cannot move a country from one region to another, only viable choice is peace.
That's what you think pak detected it from its origin and had babar missiles locked and loaded India did communicate that is isn't armed and malfunction PAF deduced the same too didnt shoot it down as there were commercial airliners in the way
In September 1965, as the Indo-Pak war was drawing to a close, a Pakistani fighter jet shot down a civilian aircraft with the then chief minister of Gujarat, Balwantrai Mehta, on board. All eight people including Mehta and his wife, three aides, a journalist and the two pilots were killed. Pakistani controllers mistook the civilian aircraft as reconnaissance aircraft. Pakistan also claimed that the Indian aircraft had strayed into Pakistani territory.
The pilot of that jet apologized to the family decades later after he'd retired from PAF. He also explained the reasons behind shooting the jet which are complicated but still admitted that the plane shouldn't have been shot down.
million $ question is why a cruise missile was flying at an altitude of 40000 feet in its entire flying path when it is supposed to fly on low altitude to evade enemy radars.
on a more serious note it was fired to give pakistan and the world a message that chinese air defences are incapable of intercepting brahmos cruise missiles
well India's military is much superior to pak's, but when it comes to nukes the two have roughly the same amount of them that's what makes it a dangerous game.
@@yuvi9119 I don't think India and Pakistan Have the same number of nukes by the end of Musharaf era it was reported that Pakistan have nearly 600 warheads and it was one of the fastest growing nuclear arsenal but as most of them are tactical nuclear weapons no one criticize it. Even if we believe those reports then Pakistan is miles ahead of India in numbers and in delivering tactics as Pakistan have MIRVs capabilities.
@@Ehsan870 I said roughly, and reports are exaggerated most of the time. Okay every major nuclear power has some hidden bombs which are not on the official declared list, but to finish the main military & strategic positions of pak not many nukes will be needed if there's a nuke attack. Even if Pakistan launches 10 or 15 missiles at once towards India in the next 15-18 minutes there'll be no paxtan in the world map.
@@yuvi9119 won't be easy for India as well coz unlike USA and their rivals China Russia and North We aren't on the opposite ends of the world any strike on either side and the aftermaths can easily reach the other as well as most of the big cities of Pakistan are near borders And it's not as small as North Korea so completely destroying Pakistan will need more than 5-10 nukes still there will be parts left enough to launch a second strike. Which India can't afford as it's more densely populated and loses will be even greater on indian sides states like UP, Bihar, Maharashtra and west Bengal can easily be the one most suffering in any Nuclear conflict.
Ab yes but pakistan also get the data of brahmos path and it's manuver's and the 1 thing is it's signature on chinese radar's pakistan will give this info to china so it will make some anti brahmos weapon
These are the negative impacts of arms race in South Asia. People of both countries do not want war. It’s the time to work on relationships and leadership of both countries need to focus on the same
Read comments. People of india are seriously craving for war. If this goes on, they will get what they want and then they will regret it while being melted away slowly and painfully.
IMHO .... Pakistan Army know that they NOT dealing with Indian army in 90s BUT much more powerful enabled by powerful govt SO they have all reasons to first assess the situation before reacting. This could be purely accidental ( There were many misfires like these in the past from USA, China ....etc). So don't be too enthusiastic to give credit to Pakistan BUT FWIW, they are not senseless and clearly knows strengths of Indian Army.
Can anyone teach me...are the missile launch are just like firework of dewali..that someone mistakenly ignited it.. There must be some protocol and mechanism to launch.. I dont think there is only one on/off switch to launch. Brahmos is not defensive missile that could be fired mistakenly due to malfunction of radar detection. It could be human error or some personal hate against pakistan of an operator Why india took three days to even accept it
Even if that incident was a genuine accident, it 'successfully', tested air- defence 'unpreparedness' of Pakistan and ' incapability' of Chinese AWACS. The saying 'whatever happens, happens for good' comes true.
Yes... May be ... But now the Pakistanis now know their air defense unpreparedness .. It would have been better if they were unaware about their shortcomings ... Don't you think ? 🤔
@Ismail Khanha ha ha. You can check hunger index and dream your life, while your PM goes all over the world begging..Yes. there was a time, our thought process revolved around pakistan. We now slowly started understanding that pakistan is just a nuisance rather than a competitor, a coalition of rogue people who trains terrorists and sends them all over the world rather than a Nation. A puppet of usa before 2020 and now a puppet of china. A safe haven for terrorists. Yes. We still talk about pakistan whenever there is a terrorist attack in the world.
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
@@rext8949 ha ha China is already a laughing stock in the world with their technology, which is cheap but always a failure. So are you saying that India also joins China ? Nope..
We regret for this action to our Pakistani friends. Thanks to Russia action in Ukraine timing such things go lightly, otherwise it would have become a big issue.
U apologist cabal act too naive knowing that Pakistan backed terrorists attacked Indian Parliament, 26/11, Pulwama, Balakot was done. They keep training terrorists and fund them. That is why they in FATF grey list Apart from this over 5 lakhs Kashmir Hindus genocide, exodus was done by radical Islamist supported by Pakistan. Tell Pakistan to hand back PokGilghit Baltistan and stop cross border terrorism.
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance. Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Gabbars => Pak, USA, EU, China. Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ? TTP thook rahe hai na Pakiyo ko, unki army himmat nahi kar paa rahi TTP ko rokane ki. They are waiting for some signal for USA support.
Some unanswered and unexplained questions 1). Does the indian missile have self destroying system ? If yes, why was it not destroyed mid air once malfunctioned ? 2). Why did the Pakistanis did not (or could not) destroy it ? They had not even engaged it. 3). If India immediately told Pakistan , why did Pakistan took 24 hours to react ? 4). Can Pakistan reverse engineer missile?
Answer 1) no, any missile carrying nukes no. Even for USA, RUSSIA AND CHINA missile 2) I can't say why. Only Pakistan military but most probably they couldn't detect because lest assume a missile is coming towards india and if it shows in radar then we destroyed it we will not wait and see if it carry war head or not. 3) Pakistan don't know how to say in public because they couldn't destroyed it so it raises questions on defence system ( my perspective again only Pakistan military can answer). 4) No. But Pakistan has capabilities just like AMERICAN Tomahawk missile Pm nawaj accepted publicly that Pakistan military got a missile which didn't explode and they reverse engineered. But they need Brahmos missile in good condition but this missile blasted and no Engineer in world can reverse engineered in this situation. So they can't reverse. We don't need to worry.
A day after the Balakot air strike, as fighter jets of India and Pakistan were engaged in a dogfight near the LoC, an Mi-17V5 crashed in Budgam shortly after take-off from Srinagar killing its personnel onboard and a civilian on the ground. The Court of Inquiry confirmed that it was shot by an Israeli-origin Spyder surface-to-air missile system of the IAF.
What are the chances of secret tech falling into the hands of Pakistanis? These missiles have super-advanced tech deployed on them, even the composition of the metal itself is very important information.
It's like you get a portion of the pie that got burnt. The only thing you can possibly extract is maybe what ingredients could used in it, not even close to how to make one.
Missile launched possibly wasn't Brahmos....it was most probably Prithvi 3 SS-BSM, reasons are that Brahmos don't cruise at 40000 feet but mostly at in between 15-20 thousand feet. Second fact is that Brahmos is mated with warhead and stored in launching tubes in ready to launch mode.....so the missile launched should have a warhead (unexploded one in this case) if it was a Brahmos
it was a Brahmos, it's been confirmed by multiple sources, not least of which is the OSINT images ... the exhaust nozzle and mesh grating matches Brahmos..
Thank you,Sekhar Ji for talking on Arun Shourie Ji's new Book -Commissioners of new challenges. I ordered the book today. Arun Shourie Ji along with Yuval Noah Harari & Late Nobel Laureate V.S.Naipaul are my favorite writers. I also watched your 'Walk the Talk' with Naipaul.
What I don't understand is that Pakistan didn't shoot down the missile because it thought that it's air defence system might end up hitting a civilian aircraft. I don't buy this because by this logic what if tomorrow Pakistan decides to shoot a nuclear capable missile or just a regular missile towards India and India will not shoot it down just because a civilian aircraft might get hit in the process. That doesn't sound right to me. I am pretty sure that the Pakistani air defence system was actually incapable of detecting and countering the missile.
Sir, news from totally unreliable sources is that the unarmed missile was launched at the request of Pakistan, to enable them to check their missile detection systems. India will be billing Pakistan for missile 1 no., Launching expenses, plus GST.
I bet this was intentional. Brahmos or I think all cruise missiles have a self destruct button which can be triggered if it goes out of track.. No one would watch a missile go into enemy territory and travel for 4 minutes and do nothing.
Whatever the reason was It did two things 1.Proved Brahmos's capability to dodge air defense & Radars system. 2. Exposed Pakistani air defence insufficiency.
I personally believe that it is made deliberately to show the power of Brahmose and to check the attemptivness of Pakistan's Chinese bought Anti missile / air defense systems...
I find it strange that Pak said there were tracking it since it's launch in India, but was there an attempt to intercept it whether through SAM or by trying to shoot it down using ATA missiles?, it's weird that for a long time they said did not know what it was and after many hours it was reveled that it was a supersonic missile that went a hundred or so odd kms into Pak, which might explain the lack of some panic, if India had informed them using hotline they would've known and tried to intercept it. no idea what to make of this, if there is issues with the missile system this needs to be rectified ASAP.
The missile was at 40000 ft altitude so attempting to shoot down without having war situations can be dangerous. Even US would have not tried to shoot down
That brahmos was gen 3 of old stock and newer versions are much faster because of composite materials.. the talk around the defence analystis is we know their air defence , radar and communication network cos our missiles are integrated into our network 😆
@@ms4050 war with a rougue radical islamic pakistan is inevitable.. Only question is when ?? they will use a tactical nuke but will be followed by indias thermo nukes
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
Something is wrong in IAF. This incident, General Rawat's helicopter crash, shooting down own helicopter after uri, recent fighter jet crashes etc. IAF is surely lacking in maintenance of these high tech weapons.
I agree specially something with General Rawat helicopter crash doesn't seems right how can the highest ranking officer in arms forces have such Incident!
Who would be held responsible for the nuclear holocaust had Pakistan fired a nuclear war head ? We call ourselves a responsible nuclear nation. How can a Brahmos missile be launched without protocol and checks? Also it lands in a neighbouring nuclear country with whom we have a history of wars. And whose Air defense system has just a minute to decide wether the incoming missile is nuclear powered. And the had they launched their nuclear missile because they have reserved the right to first use of nuclear war. How utterly irresponsible and shameful when there are such high stakes.
Cut the clutter - really like Mr. Shekar style of speak. The content is slight tilt to India (natural expectation) when speaking on Pakistan issues, however superbly balanced and great presentation always.
India can't say irresponsibly that missile was triggered into Pakistan territory by mistake. Rather, our side should have informed Pakistan of the mishap forthwith and apologized for the same. Anyhow, this incident is highly condemnable.
@@rameshchandra-qg9sw brilliant. So India risked a nuclear counter strike and the start of a nuclear holocaust to show how capable their missile is. I tip my hat to you.
How could Indian air force make this silly mistake? It's either done intentionally or our our air force is too weak to handle it's own missiles. Both the cases of course not acceptable by any civilized society.
Pakistan is IMPLODING...No need of missiles. Woh kissi aur key liye hai ....agar un ho ne batameesey ki !!! This would have been a controlled experiment to fine tune the capabilities of Bramhos. No drama...though Pakistan will jump up and down and try to exaggerate without success.
Why wasn’t espionage angle not being brought up. A compromised person with authentication can use this to fire this missile to a safe location. The technology recovered from the missile will be the aim of the whole debacle .
I wish themedia and the majority population were as mature as both the armies involved. Mistakes happen and we gotta learn from them and get better. The mistake was on our side so there are no 9pm news debates constantly pushing for war, cursing Pakistan and presenting over 100s of conspiracy theories, but if it was the other way around, god I can only imagine.
So according to you Pakistan backed terrorists attacked the Indian Parliament,26 11, Pulwama, Balakot are all myth or propaganda. Pakistan has to hand over Pok, Gilghit Baltistan and stop across the border terrorism. Apologist cabal stop supporting Pakistan
paks probably were informed immediately on the hot channel....but the point is pak got to know from us..this is important...its matter of 4 mins...make no mistake ....paks were caught pants down....
As SG said that's not how communication between nuclear powers work. ' Pakistan was caught pants down ' stop reading commando comics and live in the real world for once. Hell even a underdeveloped country like the Congo can also detect almost immediately if a missile lands in its country. It was a failure from our side but there is nothing to be ashamed of it. Sometimes mistakes do happen.
@@orkkojit you enjoy with your and SGs thought promotion ... whether one reads comic or not is irrelevant ....the reality will remain a reality .....whatever message needed to be passed on has hit the bulls eye....a bit of some deeper understanding capacity would have helped here .
@@Abhi-ph9fz yes you, a random unemployed person on RUclips, are more knowledgeable than Shekhar Gupta sir who has been an editor and one of India's top most journalists for 30 years having reported from 97 different countries and having interviewed almost all political leaders in the Indian Subcontinent
@@orkkojit your immediate habit of assuming things and thinking that as real makes me feel your level of unemployable probability is very high.....you can shout scream and think whatever you like, it's ur perception and I am not bothered to waste time on that.....and on knowledgeability , which organization had set the standard that whatever Mr Shekhar Gupta says is the gospel.....I hv my views , I do not ride on others ...whether you like it or not is your problem...
@@Abhi-ph9fz Well if those views were logical I would have no problem this is not about opinions you are spreading misinformation and false facts about what happened and instead of trying to know what actually happened, it seems you are more interested in pursuing puffed up chest nationalism against Pakistan
India must stop aggression against Pakistan. Pakistan will also equip it's self with hypersonic missile. This kind of aggression is not right for peace in region.
Both India and Pakistan were born in 1947? get your fact, straight sir! India was and has been there for millennia India through the British out in 1947. Pakistan was created in 1947 subject to Partition. This mistake is unacceptable!
Pakistan leadership indeed showed great maturity in dealing with this issue, imagine it happening other way round the Modi bhakts wld hv gone hysterical and confused Modi into pressing the nuclear button…..
@@123xyzabccba the steps are being taken in getting back pok,gb. Baluchistan will be freed from Pakistan rule. with regards to getting Abhinandan go and listen to what was told in Pakistan assembly where Asad Sadiq said that Gen Bajwa was trembling out of fear, his legs were shaking, Ur foreign minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi who was also in the meeting said to let go wing commander Abhinandan if not India will attack Pakistan at 9pm. Ur PM got so scared he didn't even attend the meeting. LOL
@@123xyzabccba that day will also come when kulbhusan will be brought back to India. Just as Pok, Gilghit Baltistan will be taken back from Pakistan. How was the missile u got on 9 th
To my mind it is really an accidental launch for three reasons 1. Prior to launching a missile the country needs to issue a NOTAM (notice to air missions) to ensure that no civilian aircraft is in that region because if it gets hit by the same it would result in huge casualties and as we know 7:00pm is a peak hour for air traffic in both the countries so why would India take such a heavy risk..it's only when you do it accidentally 2. There were chances of that missile hitting many high value targets in the region which could have led to retaliation from the Pakistani side and hence escalate into a conflict. 3. No country wants their adversary to be able to reverse engineer their missile technology so they keep their precious missiles incognito unless needed in a war And plz note that India tests it's missiles in the Bay of Bengal region i e on the east coast not in a heavily inhabited sirsa region. Plus there are heavily militarized international borders in that region. So only a fool would test missile there. So these reasons suggest that what happened was purely unintentional and a mistake. There's no hidden agendas behind it.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month.
ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Wow...CTC SG has powerhouse of defence/constitutional law/ foreign geopolitics 😍
What do you think about nato missile locations near russia borders with flight times of a few minutes?
Whole India is swayed over the movie 'The Kashmiri Files'. Please make a video on this movie. The Movie, it seems will break all box-office records. Even many countries are taking note of this movie. The movie is based on true events. It is directed by Atul Aghnihotri. Please do an extensive research on this movie. This movie will have great influence on the Politics and power struggle of KASHMIR.
Biggest war crime of Saudi excuted 81 people in mass execution in a day with fair trial... and shamefully UK pm visited Saudi ... UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet and UN HRC condemn Saudi war crime
@@mastmalakpet This is according to the Sharia law, they say. But anyway, I would like to know more about missile hacking. Seems an interesting topic.
Another similar incident that was very tragic was when Gujarat CM Balawantrai Mehta was killed by Pakistan Airforce while his unarmed civil plane was still in Indian air space.
Iske bare mai bat nhi krega ye bkl
Thanks for letting us know
@@prabhatsingh7577 get well soon
@@anshagrawal6289 Get a life.
It was not a stray missile but was launched intentionally to take out the civilian plain which was mistaken as a war plane ….and at that time india and Pakistan were already engaged in the war ……
@@123xyzabccba Yes it was during the 65 war, but like you said, a civil aircraft was shot down by PAF "by mistake" and it resulted in loss of lives too.
We hit Pakistan
But the sad part is Our netizens are so proud of this which explains alot about our public’s mentality. Our online nationalism is cringy to say the least.
One thing I hate more than shrill nationalism is self flagellation. 🤔
Like wise on that side too, and their media is nuts😂😂, I wish Pak media to be more mature and let their people know the real thing rather immature way of dealing India.
@@AliImran-kd8mx u serious bruh
cringy nationalism is still better than antinational propagandas
@@AliImran-kd8mx lmao committed genocide against own countrymen and calling us warmongers..go get a life.
This episode of CTC is indeed for everyone to take careful note of, it cuts through ideologies of people and provides insight to an impending doom if negligence goes hand in hand with dangerous weapons. The snippets from the past incidents around the world are very profound in establishing the fact that none of us want these weapons to be used for what they were made.
So basically even if iBrahmos is misfired, it still goes toward the right target... That is a relief.
Lol
Haha nice one.
You are talking in a loose manner . Do u think if there were life losses then Pakistan don't retiliate ? Obviously Pakistan would have retiliated .
This retiliation may lead to serious war and who will suffer most ? The civilians offcourse
@Sharma
It is half relief. Full would have been there after having been responded. So luckily sense of responsibility prevailed that you Rundian don’t have it.
🤣
The only journalist in this entire world that states that, "We didn't show this, because we didnt know enough". Just love ThePrint!
They knew everything, it was to give a message before Talks with Chinese. Within two days Chinese foreign minister announced visit. Pakistan pissed in pants it was a high value target which got eleminated too it had war heads.
Print has substantially changed from narrative based channel to facts based channel in recent time period
Bull shit anchor
Pakistan supportive Anchor
Scenario : Indian unarmed Missile lands "by mistake" in Pakistan and totally evades Chinese supplied Air defence systems the day before India and China meet for the 15th time to resolve border dispute ?? Kill the chicken to scare the monkey ?? Clue 1 : note the number of assorted missile tests India has done since Galwan .. Clue 2 : Why the Philippines chose this system ??
Well... Your theory is interesting but it also sounds like a big gamble 🙁
May the neurons play their part... Brother have your own world and play this drama over there... You can discuss the strengths but never the readiness for war on both sides... Gupta sir has made so much efforts to bring some sense in thinking and you are again hunting clues
Illuminati 🙈
@@armaanoona He is admiring the pakistanis for handling the situation maturely. The truth is that the only reason they are calm recently is because their economy is struggling. The way the missile reached pakistan is intentional. Airspace is full of aeroplanes but they travel in a fixed corridor and height.
@@deepakthirdreich well this is all open to debate but I think Pakistan is in far better economic conditions than at times when PAF shot down MiG-21. The point is only to talk objectively, beyond personal buildups.
If one understands game theory and MAD concepts, it becomes obvious as to how that neither side is in a position to use it. Tactical nukes are nukes too. No one can pretend they are not.
yes but game theory assumes the worst in your opposition
But I don't understand how this Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) systems achieves anything when destruction takes place on both sides. If the war takes place the winner grieves secretly and the loser grieves openly . But grieving is imminent on both sides!!!!
Little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Game theory does not apply here. MAD concept only applies to Russia and USA which are large countries. Countries like Pakistan can be totally destroyed by India's first attack. Small countries with nuclear weapons cannot use nuclear deterrence. Even for countries like Russia MAD does not apply that well because it lacks credible 2nd strike capability. This is why Russia is fighting in Ukraine.
@@ppen8359 it's a very risky gamble to assume that your enemy will lose its second strike capability.
A decimal percentage error in your estimates will have a nuclear winter ahead.
It's a stupid gamble. It's soothing to see that Pakistan acted as a mature party here
@@ppen8359 well Pakistan surely have more nukes than India. In 2006-2007 at the end of Musharaf era Pak had around 600 warheads some reports even claimed that Pakistan has the fastest growing nuclear arsenal and coz of tactical nukes no one was even criticizing it. Now Pak have more better technologies to deliver those warheads as Pak already have MIRVs in Ababeel Missile so any miscalculation can result in nuclear winter and that will not end with just the strikes and their immediate impact but radiation and famine. And that means no one will be able to enjoy a victory.
BrahMos is so good that even if it looses it's mind...it knows where to land!
A fine and sober analysis. Many thanks. The accidental launch of BrahMos is a big embarrassment for India. It is positioning itself as an exporter of arms, especially missiles. It has entered into contract for supplying BrahMos to Philipines, and is negotiating similar contracts with Vietnam and a few SE nations. This kind of accident will cast serious doubt on the reliability of India's defence products. India should do a lot more to assuage the misgivings in the minds of these nations. India is being mocked at. I feel bad about it.
When 1998 nuclear test was done, Western press mocked India as nuclear boys, and pointed out that nuclear men have systems for delivering nuclear wapons, which India did not have. During the last two decades, India has developed and manufactured large varieties of missiles. Probably, between the USSR and the US many more such accidents have happened. That is no consolation. They were geographically far apart, which gave some time for analysis of situation. Between India and Pakistant, the time available will be a matter of minutes for deciding whether some such similar event is an accident, or false alarm, or indeed an attack. Far greater caution is required in the matter.
It was not a misfire,india did it purposely ly
Yes
As if Pakistanis care about Indian lives when they send in terrorists to target our soldiers,civilians and cities
It was not misfire, misfired cruise missile never turn 90° by itself and there was no nuclear warhead in it intentionally
Well narrated , this is something that warrants our army technical teams to scrutinise the flaws and come up with remediation measures . Also Kudos to both parties for their mature handling of the issue .
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance.
Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ?
Sir, you are absalutly correct... We have heard about the aftermath result of Hiroshima and Nagasaki Nuclear attack during 2nd world war.But those are mild doses... Now the countries pose with nuclear weapons 1000 times powerful than those 2... We don't want genarations getting vaporised in any part of the world... The most greusome thing is that the survivors will dye slowly due to radiation 😪🥺...
Honestly, whatever people say about each other….no one wants a nuclear war on either side. When people die on any side, it’s human beings who suffer and loose lives. Politicians don’t suffer as much but nuclear attack won’t even leave anyone. I hope it was just a mistake and it won’t happen again.
Not thousand
Russia has 5crore kg bomb
@@ms4050 India doesn't have 100x weapons
When we fully enter Kaliyuga in hundreds of years there will be acid rain which will damage natural resources and poor nations will perish and gradually humans will fight among themselves leading to end of the world after Kalki has ruled for 1000 years.
There is no colourisation caused by nuclear explosions - slow or otherwise. This is something new.
Actually India was testing Chinese HQ9 air defence 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
Well i don't think Indian army has any doubts about Chinese weapons otherwise wouldn't show meek response to chinese aggression
could also be testing was of agni but brahmos got fired. lol .. i hope u will get this one... and its depth lol
@@shahrukhanwar9065 not all Chinese weapons. This is just about the air defence system.
Would love to hear your thoughts on Saudi's looking to ditch Petro dollar deal as they're hinting to begin trading in Yuan with China. What could be the opportunities and threats for India if this happens. Thanks in advance.
Wasn't it debunked as fake news?
I think India started this few years back w/ some middle eastern country
@bhargav I think india settels it's petro bill with iran in Rupees
Good topic ..
Would love to hear the pros and cons !
@@anshagrawal6289 வ்
Sadly Indian military lacks the capability to operate their arms. They should better train their forces. Such incompetence could start a real war.
Pakistan deserves appreciation for mature handling of this issue.
I think yours is the most informative and enriching journalistic work in entire India. Keep it up.
finally a mature commentry on this incident it is not that we are afraid of counter attack from Pakistan, but this kind of mistakes should not be done by nuclear countries specially when your enemy is also nuclear country.
Pretty stupid to not be afraid of a nuclear missile attack.
I'd be afraid of any country counter attacking my initial aggression with nuclear missiles
We are also not afraid of India such stupid mistakes by a a nuclear armed country with other nuke armed country is stupid. Pakistan could react strongly like the europian countries did.
Thanks
I'm contributing to print only bcoz you said you didn't have information to show. I love this candor.
This is amazing information. Well done. Well presented episode
I hope journalism schools teach this as a virtue
Sir, I admire you for sticking to the actual verified facts about any incident or story that you cover. I may not always agree with your interpretation but you still are one of the news channels that have my respect. Somehow all other channels tend to willfully omit facts to suit their own narration of an incident which leads to confusion
My analysis -
1. What Pakistan Got from missile in their land ?
a. Don’t have to take sides anymore of Ukraine or Russia . Easily they will abscond that and will say they themselves are under attack .
b. It might save Imran Khan projecting himself a strong leader and his country under attack
2. What China Got ?
a. Lot of questions about their defence capabilities.
3. What ASEAN got ?
a. A dependable missile that can attack precisely.
4. What India got ?
a. New buyers from ASEAN
b. Understanding that Chinese defence is weak.
c. Safeguarding herself from Russia Ukraine issue
This missile was nothing but a Cold War between India and China which happened in Pakistan. Same like Russia and US have done for years .
The consequences for Indians would have been dire. Thanks to Pakistan, you and your loved ones are not vapors right now….wondering what just happened. It was an extreme risk, putting the lives of so many Indians in danger, if it wasn’t a mistake.
kukurmutte ki tarah geopolitical expeert paida ho rahe iss desh me
@@pranjalipranjali2751 Haan aur har jagah faltu ke comments karke hagne wale log bhi
@@23Elixir ha bhai pehchaan to gaey khud ko...thank god
@@pranjalipranjali2751 nahi bhai Main to apne ko pehchanta hun … ….. kuch log ko aaina dikhata hun .
Accidental fire seems like a lie.
* Missiles will not have self destruction capabilities? If so Why it was not brought down?
* Path through which it went was barren. It feels like it was carefully chosen.
* It did a 90^ turn and went inside Pakistan. How's this possible without any guidance?
* Was it done to demonstrate ineffectiveness of chinese air defence systems and advertise brahmos globally?
* If it was accident, India had the option of reporting it to pak but not accepting it publicly. Why India accepted it?
Cruise missiles do not self destruct option....ballistic missiles do
Brahmos is a cruise missile
@@prachetmakwana6011 i dont think so, every modern missiles has self destruction capabilities. Brahmos is flagship missile. I'm sure it will have.
Even if it doesn't then they could have atleast maneuvered it inside indian territory.
@@ujwalmokashi6702 A weapon placed secretly to be use during war with nuclear warhead dnt have self destruction feature .. I they have then what is use of it during war ... So cruise dnt have self destruction feature... Brahmos range is approx 400 km so any ocean or sea if far away to be maneuvered in its range & missile with hitting policy already come with enemy targets pre installed ... So missile went were it was targeted deep in enemy territory.... Most important it's not once in century mistake several times by many nations this technical fault has taken place no system is 100 % secure ... faults do occur... Government has accepted it publicly in parliament ... Government must have denied it even not told Pakistan but stand was taken....remember only man with brave character have courage to accept its mistake... we have shown that....
@@SandeepSingh-fb1zq Our responsibility is to inform Pakistan and apologize. Not to media and public. The brahmos does have self destruction capabilities( IE explained article )
@@ujwalmokashi6702 yes and we have done that before going to media we told pakistan but it was pakistan who went to media first.... they done media briefing not us....
Excellent. Enjoyed so much. Thanks The Print.
ruclips.net/video/ZWaUaemWv4k/видео.html
"...may be Pakistanis tracked it FROM SIRSA.....i dont know...."
It is a missile that we are talking about, not a passenger train or bus ! .Missile dont take stops like trains do. If the Pakistanis did track it for a sufficient amount of time they would have computed its trajectory and the possible launch location but that would have been hard because the Brahmos is a cruise missile and can have deceptive trajectory
This is not important. What is important is that, Pakistan could have retaliated to this attack. The consequences could have been deadly. No one wants to vaporize into thin air, on either side.
@@ms4050 what retaliation lol
@@narutohenaruto The retaliation that you would not even have realized….as a vapor. This is not a joke.
A day after the Balakot air strike, as fighter jets of India and Pakistan were engaged in a dogfight near the LoC, an Mi-17V5 crashed in Budgam shortly after take-off from Srinagar killing its personnel onboard and a civilian on the ground. The Court of Inquiry confirmed that it was shot by an Israeli-origin Spyder surface-to-air missile system of the IAF.
@@narutohenaruto retaliation which ends with "Fantastic tea" :)
Thank you Sir for making us realize the magnitude of destruction which many warmongers and keyboard warriors see as a cricket game ❤🇵🇰
😂 I didn't think This much a missle makes in a country diplomacy! This is something important..one single missile.. engaged everything 😂😂😂
You wouldn’t be laughing like that had it hit an air India flight
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
@@rext8949 we are laughing on HQ9 air defence system which was provided by China to Pakistan to save themselves from missile like these 😂🤣
Compelled chinese foreign minister to visit India within two days.
@@ericme5715 Extremely sophisticated technology which detected that the missile was a dud unlike the IAF missile which shot IAF chopper down.
SG Sir ,
Here in London I was mentioned this much earlier by a Pakistan friend and my knees shook .
I disagreed initially spoke and smiled until I watched Raksha Mantri on LS.
Scary scenario with civil aircrafts .
I only wish India - Pakistan relationship improved .
Common citizens ought to travel openly.
Alas !
CIA hackers behind this
Mr. Majumdar actually The missile was not misfired. If you study it deeply then you will find that it was a planned missile fire to test the capabilities of Pakistan defence system and also
No need for it. The Northern pipe dream of Akhanda Bharatham wrapped in a fake peace process is bound to fail and be counter - productive. Cold peace with no relations is the best way to go.
@@SurajYadav-qk6xo it's not planned one.. it was hacked as per it's travel direction, changed 3 to 4 times.
One think I notice sekhar Gupta avoid to make video on Kashmir file 😂😂😂😂😂
If there is anytime I appreciated Pakistan for acting as mature and responsible nation…. It is now
*You missed a huge point - India has at least 5 layers of strong air defense systems in place, including but not limited to S-400, BARAK-8, and SPYDER. So, one nuke attack towards India from Pakistan might not even reach India properly (air interception) but the retaliatory nuke attack from India towards Pakistan would totally remove them from the world map.*
A nuclear attack would be like Cutting off one's nose to spite one's face
@Ashwin Varghese No one sends 100 nukes at first strike, and India has a strict "no first use" policy.
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance.
Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ? The current regime makes policies, strategies and war-games with help of professionals. So let media-experts keep making all guesses.
Sir you analysis is quite neutral . I am also a Pakistani . But I think PAF Air Defense system showed a quite mature behavior. They didn't target Passenger plane like Iran did and also Indian defense system targeted their helicopter during Combat with PAF.
Some people are making jokes over Pakistan's air defense system but they don't image what would happen if Pakistan lauches a missile equipped with warhead . ?
@Ghulam Mohammad Khudadad Sarwar
You are talking like a child . U must know that if a missile is detected than it's not a rocket science to destroy it .
Director General Interservice public relations have explained the path of missile completely
Clear and informative as always. We appreciate the amazing work, SG and team!
@@trueindiantrueindian2038 kya phookte ho ? :)
@@trueindiantrueindian2038 andh bhakt spotted💩💩
@@trueindiantrueindian2038 itni si baat ka bura maan gaya tu to bhai. Biwi/ GF deti nahi hai kya? 😆
We can only hope for peace, both countries have made blunders but now time has come to sit down and resolve our issues.
India does not talk to beggars like pakistan
It's always peaceful until some pakistani start war . Everytime it's pakistan who starts misadventures .
Stop sending terrorists, propaganda, arms, drugs, counterfeit currency notes, etc into India first. Talks can happen after that.
Why discuss peace now and not 30 years ago ? Because your country is getting bankrupt?
@@ranadeepkundu5357 let's not get into pointing fingers at each other as we have fanatics and poverty on both side. We cannot move a country from one region to another, only viable choice is peace.
iMRand : We could have responded !!
Air Defense system : Really ? Really?? Even I could not identify.
Chinese defence system was useless in intercepting India's misile to Paxtan n now Wang Yi is coming with the old slogan , Hindi Chini bhai bhai ! ✌🤣✌
That's what you think pak detected it from its origin and had babar missiles locked and loaded India did communicate that is isn't armed and malfunction PAF deduced the same too didnt shoot it down as there were commercial airliners in the way
@@MohammedShafiq-id5ov 😂😂
Sir, the Indian government did not say that the missile which was misfired is Brahmos. Correct me if I am wrong 🙏
I think 1st time Pakistan handled this situation with maturity. Good Pakistan brothers 👍🏻 🇮🇳 🤝 🇵🇰
Cowardness can't be equated with Maturity, Ouch 😆😆
In September 1965, as the Indo-Pak war was drawing to a close, a Pakistani fighter jet shot down a civilian aircraft with the then chief minister of Gujarat, Balwantrai Mehta, on board. All eight people including Mehta and his wife, three aides, a journalist and the two pilots were killed.
Pakistani controllers mistook the civilian aircraft as reconnaissance aircraft. Pakistan also claimed that the Indian aircraft had strayed into Pakistani territory.
The pilot of that jet apologized to the family decades later after he'd retired from PAF. He also explained the reasons behind shooting the jet which are complicated but still admitted that the plane shouldn't have been shot down.
million $ question is why a cruise missile was flying at an altitude of 40000 feet in its entire flying path when it is supposed to fly on low altitude to evade enemy radars.
it was on a patiala peg veerji
@manjit exactly cruise missile flies in terrain hugging mode not at 40,000ft.
on a more serious note it was fired to give pakistan and the world a message that chinese air defences are incapable of intercepting brahmos cruise missiles
@@anandkhanduja12 so that they can deploy more potent defence systems. funny your answere
@@saikrishnabandi8736 thats why i am saying why it was flying on such a high altitude
Very realistic talk. Peoples who thinks Pakistan is a weak state, they live in the fool paradise. Very balance annalist, thank you
well India's military is much superior to pak's, but when it comes to nukes the two have roughly the same amount of them that's what makes it a dangerous game.
@@yuvi9119 I don't think India and Pakistan Have the same number of nukes by the end of Musharaf era it was reported that Pakistan have nearly 600 warheads and it was one of the fastest growing nuclear arsenal but as most of them are tactical nuclear weapons no one criticize it. Even if we believe those reports then Pakistan is miles ahead of India in numbers and in delivering tactics as Pakistan have MIRVs capabilities.
@@Ehsan870 I said roughly, and reports are exaggerated most of the time. Okay every major nuclear power has some hidden bombs which are not on the official declared list, but to finish the main military & strategic positions of pak not many nukes will be needed if there's a nuke attack. Even if Pakistan launches 10 or 15 missiles at once towards India in the next 15-18 minutes there'll be no paxtan in the world map.
@@Ehsan870 that's why India's not bothered about increasing no. of nukes. and pak miles ahead in delivering capabilities mirv etc.?😂😂😅😅😅
@@yuvi9119 won't be easy for India as well coz unlike USA and their rivals China Russia and North We aren't on the opposite ends of the world any strike on either side and the aftermaths can easily reach the other as well as most of the big cities of Pakistan are near borders And it's not as small as North Korea so completely destroying Pakistan will need more than 5-10 nukes still there will be parts left enough to launch a second strike. Which India can't afford as it's more densely populated and loses will be even greater on indian sides states like UP, Bihar, Maharashtra and west Bengal can easily be the one most suffering in any Nuclear conflict.
The Brahmos Missile performed all the test requirements and Parameters Successfully.
Vietnam is now finally buying Brahmos.
Ab yes but pakistan also get the data of brahmos path and it's manuver's and the 1 thing is it's signature on chinese radar's pakistan will give this info to china so it will make some anti brahmos weapon
These are the negative impacts of arms race in South Asia. People of both countries do not want war. It’s the time to work on relationships and leadership of both countries need to focus on the same
Read comments. People of india are seriously craving for war. If this goes on, they will get what they want and then they will regret it while being melted away slowly and painfully.
@@uatiger1 World needs people like you to wage wars… what people like you do not understand that it takes more effort to bring peace than go to war
There shouldn't be any war but there shouldn't be any relationship with Pakistan as well.
@@pkgp7056 And why should there be no relationship between two countries?
IMHO .... Pakistan Army know that they NOT dealing with Indian army in 90s BUT much more powerful enabled by powerful govt SO they have all reasons to first assess the situation before reacting.
This could be purely accidental ( There were many misfires like these in the past from USA, China ....etc).
So don't be too enthusiastic to give credit to Pakistan BUT FWIW, they are not senseless and clearly knows strengths of Indian Army.
Great episode as always. SG gave details from 1950’s which is what makes CTC unique. Thank You 🙏🏻
Can anyone teach me...are the missile launch are just like firework of dewali..that someone mistakenly ignited it..
There must be some protocol and mechanism to launch..
I dont think there is only one on/off switch to launch.
Brahmos is not defensive missile that could be fired mistakenly due to malfunction of radar detection.
It could be human error or some personal hate against pakistan of an operator
Why india took three days to even accept it
Even if that incident was a genuine accident, it 'successfully', tested air- defence 'unpreparedness' of Pakistan and ' incapability' of Chinese AWACS. The saying 'whatever happens, happens for good' comes true.
Yes... May be ... But now the Pakistanis now know their air defense unpreparedness ..
It would have been better if they were unaware about their shortcomings ... Don't you think ? 🤔
@Ismail Khan poor guy. Pakistan does not matter any more for India or the world. But you can always live in your dreams..
@Ismail Khanha ha ha. You can check hunger index and dream your life, while your PM goes all over the world begging..Yes. there was a time, our thought process revolved around pakistan. We now slowly started understanding that pakistan is just a nuisance rather than a competitor, a coalition of rogue people who trains terrorists and sends them all over the world rather than a Nation. A puppet of usa before 2020 and now a puppet of china. A safe haven for terrorists. Yes. We still talk about pakistan whenever there is a terrorist attack in the world.
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
@@rext8949 ha ha China is already a laughing stock in the world with their technology, which is cheap but always a failure. So are you saying that India also joins China ? Nope..
We regret for this action to our Pakistani friends. Thanks to Russia action in Ukraine timing such things go lightly, otherwise it would have become a big issue.
U apologist cabal act too naive knowing that Pakistan backed terrorists attacked Indian Parliament, 26/11, Pulwama, Balakot was done. They keep training terrorists and fund them. That is why they in FATF grey list
Apart from this over 5 lakhs Kashmir Hindus genocide, exodus was done by radical Islamist supported by Pakistan.
Tell Pakistan to hand back PokGilghit Baltistan and stop cross border terrorism.
I think it could be a deliberate technology demonstration rather than accidental incident.
What ever SG is saying is for all to believe. But do you really think India army has such a poor command-n-control struct that it can fire a supersonic missile during routine maintenance.
Indian-army did it deliberately, "dekhe to sahi Gabbar kya kar lega". Gabbars => Pak, USA, EU, China. Modi-Shah is silently preparing for PoJK, and they will move somewhere in 24 ~ 29 with Modi still in Power. No one could guess their move on Art 370, and they revoked it. Was SG ever guessed Modi's move on Art 370 ?
TTP thook rahe hai na Pakiyo ko, unki army himmat nahi kar paa rahi TTP ko rokane ki. They are waiting for some signal for USA support.
The 3 curses of modern world. Nuclear weapons. Religion . Climate crisis.
Some unanswered and unexplained questions
1). Does the indian missile have self destroying system ? If yes, why was it not destroyed mid air once malfunctioned ?
2). Why did the Pakistanis did not (or could not) destroy it ? They had not even engaged it.
3). If India immediately told Pakistan , why did Pakistan took 24 hours to react ?
4). Can Pakistan reverse engineer missile?
Answer 1) no, any missile carrying nukes no. Even for USA, RUSSIA AND CHINA missile
2) I can't say why. Only Pakistan military but most probably they couldn't detect because lest assume a missile is coming towards india and if it shows in radar then we destroyed it we will not wait and see if it carry war head or not.
3) Pakistan don't know how to say in public because they couldn't destroyed it so it raises questions on defence system ( my perspective again only Pakistan military can answer).
4) No. But Pakistan has capabilities just like AMERICAN Tomahawk missile Pm nawaj accepted publicly that Pakistan military got a missile which didn't explode and they reverse engineered. But they need Brahmos missile in good condition but this missile blasted and no Engineer in world can reverse engineered in this situation. So they can't reverse. We don't need to worry.
@@rukw2x Are you an engineer from DRDO??
A day after the Balakot air strike, as fighter jets of India and Pakistan were engaged in a dogfight near the LoC, an Mi-17V5 crashed in Budgam shortly after take-off from Srinagar killing its personnel onboard and a civilian on the ground. The Court of Inquiry confirmed that it was shot by an Israeli-origin Spyder surface-to-air missile system of the IAF.
@@esotericdork1 you just have to go and Google and read USA military report. I think you can do at least this rather than bark
@@rukw2x 🤣🤣🤣🤣LOL.
Awesome episode Sir! Thank you
What are the chances of secret tech falling into the hands of Pakistanis? These missiles have super-advanced tech deployed on them, even the composition of the metal itself is very important information.
Nhi hoga.
Ese to unke pass f16 bhi hai. India philipines ko de raha missle, vo khud nhi bana lein. It's not that easy.
Seeing the destruction, barely anything will be left in the missile to do any reverse engineering.
It's like you get a portion of the pie that got burnt. The only thing you can possibly extract is maybe what ingredients could used in it, not even close to how to make one.
Well we copied tomahawk so what is chamces we cant copy this and reduce the time with chinese help
Missile launched possibly wasn't Brahmos....it was most probably Prithvi 3 SS-BSM, reasons are that Brahmos don't cruise at 40000 feet but mostly at in between 15-20 thousand feet. Second fact is that Brahmos is mated with warhead and stored in launching tubes in ready to launch mode.....so the missile launched should have a warhead (unexploded one in this case) if it was a Brahmos
it was a Brahmos, it's been confirmed by multiple sources, not least of which is the OSINT images ... the exhaust nozzle and mesh grating matches Brahmos..
Thanks for calling it Subcontinent. Always loved it being used during cricket commentary.
You can also call it.... Akhand Bharat
Mistake is a Mistake. Accepted and forgiven and forgotten. Have a big ♥️. We are humans 😊
Thank you,Sekhar Ji for talking on Arun Shourie Ji's new Book -Commissioners of new challenges. I ordered the book today. Arun Shourie Ji along with Yuval Noah Harari & Late Nobel Laureate V.S.Naipaul are my favorite writers. I also watched your 'Walk the Talk' with Naipaul.
Very insightful. Thank you :)
Conclusion: Pakistan radars failed to identify incoming missile
Lol that just show your lack of understanding how air defense system works
One think I notice sekhar Gupta avoid to make video on Kashmir file 😂😂😂😂😂
A very fair and mature analogy of the incident sir. Hope similar maturity should prevail on both sides having the power to order a launch sequence.
An apt ending to the video - With great power comes great responsibility!
What I don't understand is that Pakistan didn't shoot down the missile because it thought that it's air defence system might end up hitting a civilian aircraft. I don't buy this because by this logic what if tomorrow Pakistan decides to shoot a nuclear capable missile or just a regular missile towards India and India will not shoot it down just because a civilian aircraft might get hit in the process. That doesn't sound right to me. I am pretty sure that the Pakistani air defence system was actually incapable of detecting and countering the missile.
Sir, news from totally unreliable sources is that the unarmed missile was launched at the request of Pakistan, to enable them to check their missile detection systems. India will be billing Pakistan for missile 1 no., Launching expenses, plus GST.
18% ?
What a joke.
😂😂🤡🤡
Wonderful, Educative & class apart 👏👌👍❤
“ India should have immediately informed Pak of its inadvertent missile launch - Pak NSA - Reuters.” Is this not a UNSC & IAEA notification matter ?
Finally he agrees he speculates a lot!! But it's good to see many perspectives
I bet this was intentional. Brahmos or I think all cruise missiles have a self destruct button which can be triggered if it goes out of track.. No one would watch a missile go into enemy territory and travel for 4 minutes and do nothing.
you are correct. they wont reveal why they did it....
No they dont have self destruct button just like our 2000 rupee note does not have a GPS chip.
No its a nuclear cruise missiles and it doesn't have a self destruct button
@@Valkyri3Z true 😂
@@adarshbiswas7099 Its non nuclear
Whatever the reason was
It did two things
1.Proved Brahmos's capability to dodge air defense & Radars system.
2. Exposed Pakistani air defence insufficiency.
ab ? kya kerna hai ? itna dam hai to china per test kero ? fight someone of your own size ? no ?
I personally believe that it is made deliberately to show the power of Brahmose and to check the attemptivness of Pakistan's Chinese bought Anti missile / air defense systems...
I find it strange that Pak said there were tracking it since it's launch in India, but was there an attempt to intercept it whether through SAM or by trying to shoot it down using ATA missiles?, it's weird that for a long time they said did not know what it was and after many hours it was reveled that it was a supersonic missile that went a hundred or so odd kms into Pak, which might explain the lack of some panic, if India had informed them using hotline they would've known and tried to intercept it. no idea what to make of this, if there is issues with the missile system this needs to be rectified ASAP.
The missile was at 40000 ft altitude so attempting to shoot down without having war situations can be dangerous. Even US would have not tried to shoot down
That brahmos was gen 3 of old stock and newer versions are much faster because of composite materials.. the talk around the defence analystis is we know their air defence , radar and communication network cos our missiles are integrated into our network 😆
@@TheKing-xp7lq You mean the faulty system that makes such big mistakes….that could lead to a nuclear war.
@@ms4050 war with a rougue radical islamic pakistan is inevitable.. Only question is when ?? they will use a tactical nuke but will be followed by indias thermo nukes
So much for India's much vaunted technological superiority and brilliance. India has become the laughing stock of the world. The Chinese leadership has yet to recover from the laughing fit that they have been suffering from in the past few days . They will have to recalibrate their defence policy and strategy based on the latest events. Even Kim is worried - India is now a greater threat to world peace than his country.
Something is wrong in IAF. This incident, General Rawat's helicopter crash, shooting down own helicopter after uri, recent fighter jet crashes etc. IAF is surely lacking in maintenance of these high tech weapons.
I agree specially something with General Rawat helicopter crash doesn't seems right how can the highest ranking officer in arms forces have such Incident!
It seems the missile can make an auto search of terrorist hideout and target .
😂😂😂😂😂
This guy is the best journalist in India.
Informative and narrated beautifully
he is a real journalist
Wow.. one of the best episodes
Who would be held responsible for the nuclear holocaust had Pakistan fired a nuclear war head ? We call ourselves a responsible nuclear nation. How can a Brahmos missile be launched without protocol and checks? Also it lands in a neighbouring nuclear country with whom we have a history of wars. And whose Air defense system has just a minute to decide wether the incoming missile is nuclear powered. And the had they launched their nuclear missile because they have reserved the right to first use of nuclear war. How utterly irresponsible and shameful when there are such high stakes.
Thank you Mr. Gupta for such an episode
At least they can now study what kind of missile it was and the technology it was made of.
Thanks for the amazing analysis of the missile test issue by Indiia.
Cut the clutter - really like Mr. Shekar style of speak. The content is slight tilt to India (natural expectation) when speaking on Pakistan issues, however superbly balanced and great presentation always.
Bull shit anchor and it's fake news the print wasted it's time and energy in helping our enemies
Very nice Analysis... 😎
Very clear cut analysis. Restraint showed by both sides is commendable and is a sign of maturity not weakness
@@ms4050 😂😂😂😂😂pakistan would've been mere dust in 2 mins bud, none of your missiles can actually penetrate inside Indian territory.
There was a book published in America called---Fail-Safe -- A novel written on dangers of accidental nuclear War
India can't say irresponsibly that missile was triggered into Pakistan territory by mistake. Rather, our side should have informed Pakistan of the mishap forthwith and apologized for the same. Anyhow, this incident is highly condemnable.
Dear Librandu. There was no mistake. It was a demo to show the capability of China's missile defense capability. Pakistan uses that.
@@rameshchandra-qg9sw brilliant. So India risked a nuclear counter strike and the start of a nuclear holocaust to show how capable their missile is. I tip my hat to you.
@@namaan123 Dude. We had enough of this nuclear bs. We have decisively called their bluff multiple times in the last 5 years. so cool it
@@namaan123 these bhakt types have very low IQs
@@rameshchandra-qg9sw What bluff? no country wants to escalate to a full blown nuke war.
Uncle ji the Kashmir files per ek video banao...
EVEN AFTER ACCIDENTALLY FIRED THE MISSILE DID NOT FORGET WHERE TO HIT!!
What a headless Rundian you are?
@@EngrzView Oh! You are talking about your mother!
Yes. it was programmed to not mistakenly hit in China.
How could Indian air force make this silly mistake? It's either done intentionally or our our air force is too weak to handle it's own missiles. Both the cases of course not acceptable by any civilized society.
Sometimes missile misfires just like Russian missile hit the Bangladeshi cargo ship...
This guy is amazing! 👏
This kind of journalism needed on both sides.respect from a Pakistani
Ye Indian side hai Uncle 😅😅
Aap apne side dekhi ye
ruclips.net/video/ZWaUaemWv4k/видео.html
Pakistan is IMPLODING...No need of missiles.
Woh kissi aur key liye hai ....agar un ho ne batameesey ki !!!
This would have been a controlled experiment to fine tune the capabilities of Bramhos.
No drama...though Pakistan will jump up and down and try to exaggerate without success.
Aik aur cup chai, Mr responsible!
Why wasn’t espionage angle not being brought up. A compromised person with authentication can use this to fire this missile to a safe location. The technology recovered from the missile will be the aim of the whole debacle .
I wish themedia and the majority population were as mature as both the armies involved. Mistakes happen and we gotta learn from them and get better. The mistake was on our side so there are no 9pm news debates constantly pushing for war, cursing Pakistan and presenting over 100s of conspiracy theories, but if it was the other way around, god I can only imagine.
So according to you Pakistan backed terrorists attacked the Indian Parliament,26 11, Pulwama, Balakot are all myth or propaganda.
Pakistan has to hand over Pok, Gilghit Baltistan and stop across the border terrorism.
Apologist cabal stop supporting Pakistan
Very informative and sensible analysis
paks probably were informed immediately on the hot channel....but the point is pak got to know from us..this is important...its matter of 4 mins...make no mistake ....paks were caught pants down....
As SG said that's not how communication between nuclear powers work. ' Pakistan was caught pants down ' stop reading commando comics and live in the real world for once. Hell even a underdeveloped country like the Congo can also detect almost immediately if a missile lands in its country. It was a failure from our side but there is nothing to be ashamed of it. Sometimes mistakes do happen.
@@orkkojit you enjoy with your and SGs thought promotion ... whether one reads comic or not is irrelevant ....the reality will remain a reality .....whatever message needed to be passed on has hit the bulls eye....a bit of some deeper understanding capacity would have helped here .
@@Abhi-ph9fz yes you, a random unemployed person on RUclips, are more knowledgeable than Shekhar Gupta sir who has been an editor and one of India's top most journalists for 30 years having reported from 97 different countries and having interviewed almost all political leaders in the Indian Subcontinent
@@orkkojit your immediate habit of assuming things and thinking that as real makes me feel your level of unemployable probability is very high.....you can shout scream and think whatever you like, it's ur perception and I am not bothered to waste time on that.....and on knowledgeability , which organization had set the standard that whatever Mr Shekhar Gupta says is the gospel.....I hv my views , I do not ride on others ...whether you like it or not is your problem...
@@Abhi-ph9fz Well if those views were logical I would have no problem this is not about opinions you are spreading misinformation and false facts about what happened and instead of trying to know what actually happened, it seems you are more interested in pursuing puffed up chest nationalism against Pakistan
India must stop aggression against Pakistan. Pakistan will also equip it's self with hypersonic missile. This kind of aggression is not right for peace in region.
ruclips.net/video/ZWaUaemWv4k/видео.html
Both India and Pakistan were born in 1947? get your fact, straight sir! India was and has been there for millennia India through the British out in 1947. Pakistan was created in 1947 subject to Partition. This mistake is unacceptable!
Pakistan leadership indeed showed great maturity in dealing with this issue, imagine it happening other way round the Modi bhakts wld hv gone hysterical and confused Modi into pressing the nuclear button…..
Stop ur support to Pakistan as always u support ur religion.
Tell Pakistan to hand back Pok, Gilghit Baltistan & stop across border terrorism
@@vm3306 : just as u got the pilot back try to get the other things also ….
@@123xyzabccba
the steps are being taken in getting back pok,gb. Baluchistan will be freed from Pakistan rule.
with regards to getting Abhinandan go and listen to what was told in Pakistan assembly where Asad Sadiq said that Gen Bajwa was trembling out of fear, his legs were shaking, Ur foreign minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi who was also in the meeting said to let go wing commander Abhinandan if not India will attack Pakistan at 9pm. Ur PM got so scared he didn't even attend the meeting. LOL
@@vm3306 : just try to get Kulbhushan jadhav back n than talk about trembling etc …Pakistan also fed cake to Modi
@@123xyzabccba that day will also come when kulbhusan will be brought back to India.
Just as Pok, Gilghit Baltistan will be taken back from Pakistan. How was the missile u got on 9 th
Salute Pakistan for being mature. Sometimes.we have media like Republic TV and its insane anchor who gun Sabre like kindergarten kids.
😂😂😂
Amazing depth and breadth of information. Thanks🙏
To my mind it is really an accidental launch for three reasons
1. Prior to launching a missile the country needs to issue a NOTAM (notice to air missions) to ensure that no civilian aircraft is in that region because if it gets hit by the same it would result in huge casualties and as we know 7:00pm is a peak hour for air traffic in both the countries so why would India take such a heavy risk..it's only when you do it accidentally
2. There were chances of that missile hitting many high value targets in the region which could have led to retaliation from the Pakistani side and hence escalate into a conflict.
3. No country wants their adversary to be able to reverse engineer their missile technology so they keep their precious missiles incognito unless needed in a war
And plz note that India tests it's missiles in the Bay of Bengal region i e on the east coast not in a heavily inhabited sirsa region. Plus there are heavily militarized international borders in that region. So only a fool would test missile there.
So these reasons suggest that what happened was purely unintentional and a mistake. There's no hidden agendas behind it.
One of the finest CTC in recent times. 👍🏻👍🏻😌