If Gaga ever wants to release ACT 2 then I hope its because she wants it and not because her fanbase is forcing it on her, at the end of the day her life was like a living hell back then, that era was traumatic and I don't think it would be a good idea for her to go back and experience that now when she seems like she's in a much better place.
Worry less about her fans "forcing" things on her and worry more about the economic powers above her head that force things on her. Her fans loving her work and wanting more is not harming Gaga in any way shape or form, it gives her her power.
Nobody not forces her making music videos, write new songs for artpop 2.0, perform with these songs, immerse herself in this era. She can just to release a collection of unreleased songs, for example, the song Tea, which was not included in the final track list. It would be a gift in honor of the 10th anniversary.
@@jc9mc1rd1d her record label literally tried to stop her from releasing ARTPOP. people need to understand these mainstream pop stars have signed away much of their artistic freedoms. they are contractually obligated to obey their label. they can not just do whatever they want to do. also, i don't think gaga even cares about making pop music anymore. she seems to focused on acting exclusively.
I completely agree about the themes of duality and ‘2 sides of the same coin’ throughout ARTPOP, with the way all the tracks are placed too. Like you said with Mary Jane Holland and Dope being the highs and lows of addiction, but also Donatella and Fashion! being the positives and negatives of the fashion industry, G.U.Y. and Sxxx Dreams with the control vs the recklessness of lust, ARTPOP and Swine showing the calm beauty and the rage of channeling your life through art
I agree with the fact that she will never release it and to be honest, I don’t want it if she doesn’t feel comfortable putting it out. However, for the tenth anniversary I think it would be cool if she put Brooklyn Nights and maybe another unreleased fan favourite on streaming as bonus tracks.
Even though it's not officially the case, I personally kinda see 'Chromatica' as an ARTPOP ACT II. Maybe not really an ACT II, but as a sister-album. I can definitely see some connections between the two albums. -Chromatica in general is basically the planet Venus she wanted to take us to. -Alice is basically the Aphrodite she wanted to represent -Rain On Me, Fun Tonight, 911, Replay, Sine From Above and 1000 Doves are about any kind of pain/trauma/mental issue she's going through, just like MANiCURE, Do What U Want, Swine or Dope. -Enigma and Babylon are the catwalk-songs just like Donatella and Fashion! -Free Woman reminds me of the independence she represented in the G.U.Y. (an ARTPOP-Film) -music video, where she took back what's rightfully hers like a boss. At first, when 'Chromatica' was revealed as the name for the album in the Stupid Love mv, DJWS was talking about ARTPOP's "little sister" around that time. Although it may left some fans disappointed that it wasn't that much of the case as they've expected, I think he was right about it. Even 'Joanne' felt like a folk-/country-pop sister-album of 'ARTPOP', as well as the 'Cheek To Cheek' and the tributes-era from 2014 - 2016 felt like an extension of 'ARTPOP'; literally the art-side of ART and POP, at least to me. Thank you for making this video. ❤️👌🏻
I kinda see your point because they're both pop and dance music, but ARTPOP is more versatile when it comes to vocal interpretation and genres. I love both albums but comparing them is silly from my point of view because you can also compare The fame monster with Born this way, 'cause both records have a dark aesthetic, very similar sounds, etc but in general they are completely different, the thing with each Gaga album is that is different, and that's the reason why some people prefer The fame, or Joanne..., etc, and it's okay
I'm just really glad we were able to make it go viral +stream and buy the hell out of ARTPOP, to show her that it wasn't her music that failed back in 2013. We truly love that album and many of us just wanted Gaga to see how appreciates it is.
I really enjoyed hearing your detailed and thoughtful take on ARTPOP and ACT II. I agree with you! I also love ARTPOP so much and I think we (the fans) are lucky to have this beautiful, mysterious universe that Gaga created with this album. We get to revisit it, analyze it, and celebrate it whenever we want. It feels so special and now, I think it is meant to live on its own as an individual beautiful creation. At this point, I think adding another act would take away from or change the special legacy of ARTPOP. It’s already perfect and it doesn’t need to change or be added to!
ARTPOP ACT 2 is already released in 2014, but it was not an official release, she just leaked songs and snippets, and i make ACT 2 tracklists/variations since then🔵💖
I LOVED Artpop. The only Lady Gaga concert I have been to was the ArtRave. Still one of the best concerts I've ever been to in my life! Plus my partner and I have a deep connection to the Artpop album as it was the first album we bought together ❤
Gaga's music has helped me a lot, the metaphors and the way I feel very related to her lyrics make me feel not alone, not the only one struggling to fit in or to satisfy people. Gaga has been part of my childhood ever since I was around 6 till my current age which is 15, I understand if Gaga does not want to release ARTPOP Act II because she had a really hard time during that era and the least I would like is to make her look back on all the bad stuff. Gaga has been more like a friend who has not only healed my traumas or hard times but has made me someone a little bit stronger and confident what on what I do, with her songs. Greetings From Mexico!!
i know i wasnt alone in loving Chromatica and it being one of my goats, while i wont lie I'd love to have gotten the pre-bloodpop version sound to go along with the dark lyics, like for real the lyirical contents of chromatica is very dark and horrid if you look at them at more than a surface level. and the fun hot pink dance track doesn't detach from that I believe. as I believe that just because something is dark, full of pain and traumatic it doesn't mean you can't experience the catharsis with a fun healing sound. this is also why i appreciate artists like Robyn, who can produce some of the most breaking words but able to dance your heart out to it to channel your pain..
Make your own Act 2 - there's enough songs from that era to piece together a short album out of the available demos/live-versions and songs she didn't put on the album.
Gaga was very enthusiastic and positive in those recent tweet adressing act 2, Gaga said in 2014 that there was actually an almost finished act 2 that she listens on her own and her friends and are not any of the songs leaked at the time, so i have hope, also didn't she just shared brooklyn nights through the ARTPOP app? it was a gift to the fans it wasn't really leaked she just shared it for free without the necessity of purchase or product treatment, she even sang a part in the artrave
I think we will always long for the OG ARTPOP plans because they sounded SO exciting - personally I would've loved to see all the plans for the app come to life
Your absolutely right!! I love the album so so much (bro I litro have the tattoo on my arm) we have to accept that ARTPOP is done and dusted and the only thing we can do is value it, appreciate it and keep streaming it :))) let’s not put pressure on anyone because that album was so impactful for her. So much love for it tho :))
I know what you mean and I agree! I just think the thing for me is that I LOVE the sound of ARTPOP so I generally crave act II because I would love more of Gaga's voice with that EDM crazy sound of that era... and honestly I'm kind of OK that it is never coming out... If only I could have TEA... Like I'm genuinely obsessed with that song... and it doesn't help that I ADORED the intro of the song that DJWS played in the Joanne Tour!! and I loved the lyrics that she tweeted back in the day... If I could just hear what the real song was.. even in an unfinished demo state I don't care... it would make me so happy I could die... I just want a sip of that TEA T_T haha
the first song i listen in my life was Applause in 2013 when i was 6, i become a little monster in 2020 and i remember follow the release of Chromatica, i love that album even back in the day when everyone hate it, i remember say that ARTPOP was my fav album and people hate me for that. I always wanted ARTPOP Act. Ii but youa re right and i never think about this, she say this was a traumatic era and she doesn't want to live all of that again, so now I'm trying to grow up and learn that people have feelings and even if i want something i have to feel empathy for the pain of others. I love Lady Gaga, I love ARTPOP and Chromatica and I will respect her desicionts even when the whole fandom hates her.
First of all LOVE the collages!! 🥰🥰🥰 And I have to say I remember when Chromatica came out and I said to myself it sounded like ARTPOP after she grew up and went to college. It feels like it’s what ARTPOP couldn’t be, and it honestly makes ARTPOP look like the “experimental” Act II and Chromatica is the “radio friendly” Act I. 😂😂😂 I think you got it spot on. I’m really hoping for a special edition release of the album, I don’t see Act II ever actually happening. She is the artist, we are the public, and she will tell us what we get. It doesn’t work the other way around.
I completely agree w you in all that you said. I love ARTPOP w all my heart, it’s my favorite album by Gaga in terms of sound, it’s so magical, spiritual & a shoot of energy & inspiration for me I really love him so much, but I agree w you that the leak songs of ACT II don’t make sense w Gaga now image & growing, sound etc. I truly love the leaks ACT II supposed songs especially Stache & Brooklyn Nights, I listen to it all the days on my Apple Music library💙 & it’s all what I need💓
The ONE thing that I think could happen (under extreme optimism) is a re-release of ARTPOP with Brooklyn Nights replacing DWUW and maybe I Wanna Be with You as a bonus track.
Dj white shadow literally announced on his Instagram that he's having a "surprise" for the artpop 10th anniversary this year. Let's keep our fingers crossed🤞
Figure it would be fine for the audience looking for an Act 2 or something resembling it to continue entertaining their theories for a bit longer and once the anniversary comes around and nothing big occurs they can start slowing down. A free chocolate replica of the Artpop statue to whoever ends up being proven wrong as a consolation prize.
At this point I feel like this anniversary has really cemented the first major era of gagas career from the fame to now, I feel she might reinvent her image and sound again, but who knows
I'm still waiting for Act 2 until it's 10th anniversary.After that, if we don't receive anything, I'll eventually gave up.She actually said in 2014 that she has a whole act of ARTPOP that she and her friends listen to.
There are many loose ends of Artpop, there are also rumors. After what DJWS said, I got discouraged, but then it was very strange, because Artpop entered the itones list, I don't know in what position but it entered, it gave me hope. There are things about Artpop act2 that we don't know. In fact, I feel a lot of Artpop references in the past Chromatica concert, especially the dark crystal ball.
i do agree that this is lady gaga’s best album for a lot of reasons, but honestly the era itself was what ruined the experience. a lot of fans say this, but the treatment of the album and of gaga herself during the era was horrible. i remember being so excited for everything
“bc Gaga is not doing much at the moment” what a TOXIC commentary. Just because shes not doing what YOU want her to do, doesn’t mean shes “not doing much”. This is why Gaga got tired of her own fans.
![MY EYES HURT - Lady Gaga's 2019 Met Gala Makeup Tutorial/Attempt! [Last Minute Costume]](/img/1.gif)
If Gaga ever wants to release ACT 2 then I hope its because she wants it and not because her fanbase is forcing it on her, at the end of the day her life was like a living hell back then, that era was traumatic and I don't think it would be a good idea for her to go back and experience that now when she seems like she's in a much better place.
Worry less about her fans "forcing" things on her and worry more about the economic powers above her head that force things on her. Her fans loving her work and wanting more is not harming Gaga in any way shape or form, it gives her her power.
Nobody not forces her making music videos, write new songs for artpop 2.0, perform with these songs, immerse herself in this era. She can just to release a collection of unreleased songs, for example, the song Tea, which was not included in the final track list. It would be a gift in honor of the 10th anniversary.
@@jc9mc1rd1d her record label literally tried to stop her from releasing ARTPOP.
people need to understand these mainstream pop stars have signed away much of their artistic freedoms. they are contractually obligated to obey their label. they can not just do whatever they want to do. also, i don't think gaga even cares about making pop music anymore. she seems to focused on acting exclusively.
I completely agree about the themes of duality and ‘2 sides of the same coin’ throughout ARTPOP, with the way all the tracks are placed too. Like you said with Mary Jane Holland and Dope being the highs and lows of addiction, but also Donatella and Fashion! being the positives and negatives of the fashion industry, G.U.Y. and Sxxx Dreams with the control vs the recklessness of lust, ARTPOP and Swine showing the calm beauty and the rage of channeling your life through art
This is a really interesting take - I guess also Gypsy and Applause fit here too with her love of performing but how lonely touring can be!
I agree with the fact that she will never release it and to be honest, I don’t want it if she doesn’t feel comfortable putting it out. However, for the tenth anniversary I think it would be cool if she put Brooklyn Nights and maybe another unreleased fan favourite on streaming as bonus tracks.
Even though it's not officially the case, I personally kinda see 'Chromatica' as an ARTPOP ACT II. Maybe not really an ACT II, but as a sister-album. I can definitely see some connections between the two albums.
-Chromatica in general is basically the planet Venus she wanted to take us to.
-Alice is basically the Aphrodite she wanted to represent
-Rain On Me, Fun Tonight, 911, Replay, Sine From Above and 1000 Doves are about any kind of pain/trauma/mental issue she's going through, just like MANiCURE, Do What U Want, Swine or Dope.
-Enigma and Babylon are the catwalk-songs just like Donatella and Fashion!
-Free Woman reminds me of the independence she represented in the G.U.Y. (an ARTPOP-Film) -music video, where she took back what's rightfully hers like a boss.
At first, when 'Chromatica' was revealed as the name for the album in the Stupid Love mv, DJWS was talking about ARTPOP's "little sister" around that time. Although it may left some fans disappointed that it wasn't that much of the case as they've expected, I think he was right about it.
Even 'Joanne' felt like a folk-/country-pop sister-album of 'ARTPOP', as well as the 'Cheek To Cheek' and the tributes-era from 2014 - 2016 felt like an extension of 'ARTPOP'; literally the art-side of ART and POP, at least to me.
Thank you for making this video. ❤️👌🏻
Chromatica wasn’t anything like artpop, it’s a pop disco album, and artpop is pop/edm
Chromatica was very weak and sounded very generic for Gaga.
I kinda see your point because they're both pop and dance music, but ARTPOP is more versatile when it comes to vocal interpretation and genres. I love both albums but comparing them is silly from my point of view because you can also compare The fame monster with Born this way, 'cause both records have a dark aesthetic, very similar sounds, etc but in general they are completely different, the thing with each Gaga album is that is different, and that's the reason why some people prefer The fame, or Joanne..., etc, and it's okay
I'm just really glad we were able to make it go viral +stream and buy the hell out of ARTPOP, to show her that it wasn't her music that failed back in 2013. We truly love that album and many of us just wanted Gaga to see how appreciates it is.
I really enjoyed hearing your detailed and thoughtful take on ARTPOP and ACT II. I agree with you! I also love ARTPOP so much and I think we (the fans) are lucky to have this beautiful, mysterious universe that Gaga created with this album. We get to revisit it, analyze it, and celebrate it whenever we want. It feels so special and now, I think it is meant to live on its own as an individual beautiful creation. At this point, I think adding another act would take away from or change the special legacy of ARTPOP. It’s already perfect and it doesn’t need to change or be added to!
ARTPOP ACT 2 is already released in 2014, but it was not an official release, she just leaked songs and snippets, and i make ACT 2 tracklists/variations since then🔵💖
I LOVED Artpop. The only Lady Gaga concert I have been to was the ArtRave. Still one of the best concerts I've ever been to in my life! Plus my partner and I have a deep connection to the Artpop album as it was the first album we bought together ❤
Gaga's music has helped me a lot, the metaphors and the way I feel very related to her lyrics make me feel not alone, not the only one struggling to fit in or to satisfy people.
Gaga has been part of my childhood ever since I was around 6 till my current age which is 15, I understand if Gaga does not want to release ARTPOP Act II because she had a really hard time during that era and the least I would like is to make her look back on all the bad stuff.
Gaga has been more like a friend who has not only healed my traumas or hard times but has made me someone a little bit stronger and confident what on what I do, with her songs.
Greetings From Mexico!!
I agree with chromatica being the 2nd artpop. They both saved my life ❤
i know i wasnt alone in loving Chromatica and it being one of my goats, while i wont lie I'd love to have gotten the pre-bloodpop version sound to go along with the dark lyics, like for real the lyirical contents of chromatica is very dark and horrid if you look at them at more than a surface level. and the fun hot pink dance track doesn't detach from that I believe. as I believe that just because something is dark, full of pain and traumatic it doesn't mean you can't experience the catharsis with a fun healing sound. this is also why i appreciate artists like Robyn, who can produce some of the most breaking words but able to dance your heart out to it to channel your pain..
Make your own Act 2 - there's enough songs from that era to piece together a short album out of the available demos/live-versions and songs she didn't put on the album.
THIS VIDEO IS PHENOMENAL ! completely agreed with your insights. LOVE the collages 🔵💖
yayyy thank you!!
Gaga was very enthusiastic and positive in those recent tweet adressing act 2, Gaga said in 2014 that there was actually an almost finished act 2 that she listens on her own and her friends and are not any of the songs leaked at the time, so i have hope, also didn't she just shared brooklyn nights through the ARTPOP app? it was a gift to the fans it wasn't really leaked she just shared it for free without the necessity of purchase or product treatment, she even sang a part in the artrave
I can still see an ARTPOP II release, against all odds.
I did give up, but deep deep in my hart I’m still hoping for an act ii.
I think we will always long for the OG ARTPOP plans because they sounded SO exciting - personally I would've loved to see all the plans for the app come to life
Your absolutely right!! I love the album so so much (bro I litro have the tattoo on my arm) we have to accept that ARTPOP is done and dusted and the only thing we can do is value it, appreciate it and keep streaming it :))) let’s not put pressure on anyone because that album was so impactful for her. So much love for it tho :))
Also I watch the artRave every other day 🤣🤣
Artpop is my fave
I know what you mean and I agree! I just think the thing for me is that I LOVE the sound of ARTPOP so I generally crave act II because I would love more of Gaga's voice with that EDM crazy sound of that era... and honestly I'm kind of OK that it is never coming out... If only I could have TEA... Like I'm genuinely obsessed with that song... and it doesn't help that I ADORED the intro of the song that DJWS played in the Joanne Tour!! and I loved the lyrics that she tweeted back in the day... If I could just hear what the real song was.. even in an unfinished demo state I don't care... it would make me so happy I could die... I just want a sip of that TEA T_T haha
the first song i listen in my life was Applause in 2013 when i was 6, i become a little monster in 2020 and i remember follow the release of Chromatica, i love that album even back in the day when everyone hate it, i remember say that ARTPOP was my fav album and people hate me for that.
I always wanted ARTPOP Act. Ii but youa re right and i never think about this, she say this was a traumatic era and she doesn't want to live all of that again, so now I'm trying to grow up and learn that people have feelings and even if i want something i have to feel empathy for the pain of others.
I love Lady Gaga, I love ARTPOP and Chromatica and I will respect her desicionts even when the whole fandom hates her.
First of all LOVE the collages!! 🥰🥰🥰 And I have to say I remember when Chromatica came out and I said to myself it sounded like ARTPOP after she grew up and went to college. It feels like it’s what ARTPOP couldn’t be, and it honestly makes ARTPOP look like the “experimental” Act II and Chromatica is the “radio friendly” Act I. 😂😂😂 I think you got it spot on. I’m really hoping for a special edition release of the album, I don’t see Act II ever actually happening. She is the artist, we are the public, and she will tell us what we get. It doesn’t work the other way around.
thank you so much!! I'm sure we'll get something closer to November💓
you worded this really beautifully. thank you for this video! i really love the collages ❤
thank you so much!!!!!
I completely agree w you in all that you said.
I love ARTPOP w all my heart, it’s my favorite album by Gaga in terms of sound, it’s so magical, spiritual & a shoot of energy & inspiration for me I really love him so much, but I agree w you that the leak songs of ACT II don’t make sense w Gaga now image & growing, sound etc.
I truly love the leaks ACT II supposed songs especially Stache & Brooklyn Nights, I listen to it all the days on my Apple Music library💙 & it’s all what I need💓
I remember when she asked us to piece the instrumental and vocal of Stache together 🥺 thanks so much!
The ONE thing that I think could happen (under extreme optimism) is a re-release of ARTPOP with Brooklyn Nights replacing DWUW and maybe I Wanna Be with You as a bonus track.
Dj white shadow literally announced on his Instagram that he's having a "surprise" for the artpop 10th anniversary this year. Let's keep our fingers crossed🤞
Gaga's ex-team members announcing things for clout is probably the least surprising thing ever
Didn't he like say that he's done with the whole Artpop thing and that he'd ignore any inquiries about it going forward? Something along those lines.
I'll always be desperate for ARTPOP Act II no matter what
Figure it would be fine for the audience looking for an Act 2 or something resembling it to continue entertaining their theories for a bit longer and once the anniversary comes around and nothing big occurs they can start slowing down. A free chocolate replica of the Artpop statue to whoever ends up being proven wrong as a consolation prize.
At this point I feel like this anniversary has really cemented the first major era of gagas career from the fame to now, I feel she might reinvent her image and sound again, but who knows
I'm still waiting for Act 2 until it's 10th anniversary.After that, if we don't receive anything, I'll eventually gave up.She actually said in 2014 that she has a whole act of ARTPOP that she and her friends listen to.
it's not coming I'm afraid angel
Chromatica is an amazing album but its not ARTPOP ACT II for real
There are many loose ends of Artpop, there are also rumors. After what DJWS said, I got discouraged, but then it was very strange, because Artpop entered the itones list, I don't know in what position but it entered, it gave me hope. There are things about Artpop act2 that we don't know. In fact, I feel a lot of Artpop references in the past Chromatica concert, especially the dark crystal ball.
Gaga her self Said that chromatica isn't the artpop act 2 or artpop little Sister
pd: I love ur look & collage💗
She didn’t fire her manager, her manager left :/
Somehow you look like Gaga, Tara Savelo, and Sarah Tanno all in the same time.
ARTPOP APP 2 WILL COME, AS WELL AS ARTPOP ACT 2. LADY GAGA WILL REIGN AGAIN.
i do agree that this is lady gaga’s best album for a lot of reasons, but honestly the era itself was what ruined the experience. a lot of fans say this, but the treatment of the album and of gaga herself during the era was horrible. i remember being so excited for everything
Love this video but Chromatica was NOT Artpop Act 2. Not in any way.
I LOVE ART POP BUT I BELEIVE IF SHE WAS TO REALEASE PART 2 IT WOULD RUIN ITS AESTHETIC AND IT WOULD RUIN THE MEANING OF THE ALBUM
i rebuke this video in the name of ARTPOP
"if only fame had an IV baby could I bare"
- applause
SHE SHOULD MAKE THE FAME IV IF SHE WOULDN'T AGREE WITH ARTPOP ACT 2
“bc Gaga is not doing much at the moment” what a TOXIC commentary. Just because shes not doing what YOU want her to do, doesn’t mean shes “not doing much”. This is why Gaga got tired of her own fans.
Gaga didnt break her hip she just needed time to do a nose job and reconstruct her face