No doubt is Jacky Cheung! He aged like fine wine. His vocal is great, there’s sense of depth(layering) & sensation which were lack in other singers. For me in Asia, Jacky Cheung & Koji Tamaki are the best.
Tiger Hu was the guest singer at JJ Lin's concert in Suzhou 2 months ago. They sang 2 songs together - '53 Dawns' composed by JJ + 'Karaoke Men' composed by Tiger. Kindly request Rozette to review these 2 beautiful songs. Thanks a lot.
Jacky Cheung is the best. Nothing beats the original. Foreigners didn't grew up listening to this type of style and they don't understand the lyrics, so it's hard for them to relate. The original came out a long time ago so that's why most people who just listen to the song would prefer the newer version from Tiger Hu.
I first heard this song when it was released in 1996. I liked that album but this song never worked for me. Surprising since it was arranged by one of my favorite musicians, Goh Kheng Long. It never registered in my memory until I heard Tiger's version decades later. I was hooked. His version is incredibly fun to listen to and sing to. No other version has come close since.
You can't really find the one that can sing the songs into audiences' hearts quite like Jacky Cheung. It's not about his legendary achievement but the way he can deliver. It's a bit harder for foreigners to get that as Cantonese is a bit complicated and ancient for non native people, and hence why they feel difficult to relate to that. But for real, as a native speaker, he delivers the context the best amongst all. and hey i'm in Canada too!
很高興老師也喜歡胡彥斌~順便說一下,之前老師很喜歡周深唱的那首月光,就是胡彥斌寫的喔(I'm glad that the teacher also likes Hu Yanbin~ By the way, the teacher liked the song "Moonlight" sung by Zhou Shen very much before, which was written by Hu Yanbin.)
Nothing's wrong with showing the rest three of the four heavenly kings. They each have their own characteristics performance-wise and they have improved a lot as time goes by. At least they are a lot better than some current artistes.
So funny😂 This is my first time to watch the whole episode without subtitle and it did bring me more different flavour compared to that polished edited one(have Chinese subtitle)❤
I think some of the sloppiness comes from the fact that they are both very theatrical singers individually, so when combined, its almost like they're having a rifting battle, cool to themselves, but quite squirmy to the audiences' ears.
這首的意境還是歌神最能傳達了!不是每首歌都需要唱得很現代感的...
爱了学友哥好多好多年,一直到现在,心里有个角落永远属于他。
Jacky Cheung 張學友👍🏼唱歌不單只是技巧,要能唱得能感動人心才最重要。現在很多人唱歌都很好聽,很有技巧。但唱得能感動人的沒幾個,這不是上音樂課能學的。就算是老師唱的也未必能感動人,就只是有顯示技巧和好聽。各人意見,無須回覆。
@@steventay-bj3jw 我个人也是觉得现在很多歌手的技巧都很好… 就是缺少了歌曲的感动… 当然也是有年轻的歌手技巧声音感情都很好…
@@caibaosei7286最直觀的例子林志炫,他以前唱歌就被評不夠感人,技巧滿分
其实唱得感人也是一种技巧,就像这里经常说到的脆弱感,就是利用声音似是不够但又连绵的效果,用快断裂的声音来表现脆弱。所以你说的感动人都是经过设计的,但就像是有些演员演起来就是更让人感动一样,里面的技巧是一致的,只是有些人的表现技巧的方式更强。
No doubt is Jacky Cheung! He aged like fine wine. His vocal is great, there’s sense of depth(layering) & sensation which were lack in other singers. For me in Asia, Jacky Cheung & Koji Tamaki are the best.
張學友唱的最有感情,胡彥斌的唱法比較多在歌曲的唱法變化多,兩個都很棒,其他都平淡無奇
完全认同。
张学友的情感表现最触动人心,胡彦斌的改编丶唱功最令人赞赏。
胡是改編鬼才,而且他改的歌其他人很難駕馭,這就是為什麼他紅,但又不到天王那種地位
我是真的希望老師有機會可以好好看一場Joker謙謙的歌..幾乎老師評過的,不是新年搞笑的,就是這種XDDD無法言喻的
@@christina870929 非常認同
歌神始终是歌神,一个传奇❤
超喜歡胡彥斌!!! 終於聽到老師的講評了 好開心😂
非常推薦胡彥斌在2019年在《夢想的聲音》舞台上翻唱的《你冷的像風》 整首曲子從頭到尾就只有一把吉他做伴奏 但是卻有非常豐富的層次 每個段落都有截然不同的聽感 真的很想看老師的reaction❤!!!
Tiger Hu was the guest singer at JJ Lin's concert in Suzhou 2 months ago. They sang 2 songs together - '53 Dawns' composed by JJ + 'Karaoke Men' composed by Tiger. Kindly request Rozette to review these 2 beautiful songs. Thanks a lot.
They are good friends! I love both of them, Tiger n JJ. Tiger respected JJ alot in one of the program ..
被張學友感動
Jacky Cheung is the best. Nothing beats the original. Foreigners didn't grew up listening to this type of style and they don't understand the lyrics, so it's hard for them to relate. The original came out a long time ago so that's why most people who just listen to the song would prefer the newer version from Tiger Hu.
Everything will go perfect when a song sang by Jacky Cheung 🥰🥰🥰
胡彥斌十幾歲已經出道,有看過他的表演,他還會創作,很有才華,唱歌也很有特色👍
張學友在我心中永遠是第一,他表達情感是最好
老师通常不会喜欢张是因为
1) 张的唱法当然是有些岁月了.
2) 张擅长的感情投入,而老师是不会中文,也不明白歌曲的意义和表达但这却是张最打动歌迷的点.
3) 张的很多比较久的歌曲当然没有现代的那么多曲风的多变.
音乐还是有国界的,只不过这个是文化国界,不是地图国界
喉咙碇歌神,是动听的。 唱功吗 当你见的越来越多 有更多的选择。 这种震喉管唱法 不能代表粤语 起码之前公认唱功好的罗文甄妮不是这样唱的
I first heard this song when it was released in 1996. I liked that album but this song never worked for me. Surprising since it was arranged by one of my favorite musicians, Goh Kheng Long. It never registered in my memory until I heard Tiger's version decades later. I was hooked. His version is incredibly fun to listen to and sing to. No other version has come close since.
張學友可能表示.....有一點情何以堪, 一代歌神, 還跟Michael Jackson同台過..........
我覺得老師大多數會極賞的歌手, 大概都有一個脈絡
1. 咬字在華人聽起來算有一點不清的, 簡單說就是完全不看歌詞, 大概只能聽出勉強五六成歌詞(我說第一次聽), 代表人物例如周杰倫, JJ...等等。
2. 要嘛走獨特氛圍的情感派, 代表人物例如陳奕迅,孫燕姿, 龔琳娜, 譚維維...等等。
3. 要嘛走英文歌曲演唱技巧的, 就是把中文歌有點當成英文歌來唱, 把某些西方代表歌手的技巧完全融入到自己的中文歌曲表達, 代表人物例如 JJ, 胡彥斌也算, 陶喆....等等。
4. 要嘛走極特殊聲線的, 即使在西方歌手也很少聽見的, 代表人物如周深, 或某些民族風歌手的嗓音....等等。
簡單說, 華人所熟知的很多唱將, 只要是傳統型唱將, 就是嗓音音色除外的話, 歌唱技巧不屬於任何一個西方歌手路線, 也聯想不到任何同質性的西方歌手, 這樣的情況最多是覺得唱的不錯, 但沒太多的興趣, 這類代表人物太多了, 幾乎包含了整個70,80,90,甚至2000初期的七成以上歌手, 例如鄧麗君,甄妮,鳳飛飛,葉倩文,鄭秀文,費玉清, 譚詠麟,張宇,蔡琴, 張國榮, 李克勤, 羅文, 梅艷芳....太多了, 舉例不完。
不過我個人非常有好奇想知道, 例如像楊宗緯,李宗盛,伍佰,王菲,王傑, 陳淑華, 陳昇, 楊乃文, 張信哲, 蘇芮, 張雨生,張清芳, 順子, 莫文蔚, 蔡健雅, 陳珊妮, 戴佩妮 .....類似這種型的歌手, 舉例不完, 反正這些歌手就是一個原則, 他們的唱法, 在當年就比較不那麼老派感, 再講更簡單一點, 就是不是波浪型的大顫音啦, 或者是聲線和曲風比較跨時代一點, 雖然我覺得老師應該可能也不會有太多的激賞, 因為他們的另一個特色是, 他們身上也沒有太多西洋歌手所熟悉的技巧運用在歌曲上, 但不管如何我個人覺得非常好奇, 無奈這類的歌手非常少看到老師評論, 實在很希望能多有這種類型的, 滿足個人好奇心(不過我相信...應該也很多人想看吧)。
想看
老師被那合唱嚇著的動作表情好好笑😅😂
@@soamy1108 真的!老師的反應我超愛的,超精彩
張學友還是最好的,最能感動人
喜歡張學友唱歌的精緻和優雅
Jacky.....forever my god of songs !
Tiger Hu is one of the most under rated singers in China
Totally agree🎉
10:08 老師太可愛了啦!!!!!我也跟著一起大笑~~
11:46 我非常贊成Flo的眼光 XDDDDDD
老師有機會評論薛之謙嗎?
我很喜歡他在其他現場的表現~
這場真的....難以言喻 XDDDDD
@@賽麗巫姬 對...這場發揮得真的比較差,希望可以評一下薛金曲撈唱的任何一首!每一首都很好聽,我最喜歡獨角戲!
非常有綜藝效果的結論,聽不懂中文的完全以個人喜好決定,聽的懂的粉也附和。
You can't really find the one that can sing the songs into audiences' hearts quite like Jacky Cheung. It's not about his legendary achievement but the way he can deliver. It's a bit harder for foreigners to get that as Cantonese is a bit complicated and ancient for non native people, and hence why they feel difficult to relate to that. But for real, as a native speaker, he delivers the context the best amongst all. and hey i'm in Canada too!
建议老师多听张学友的歌,一位专辑总销量达1.2亿的歌手。
橘老师不太喜欢学友的颤音唱法
哈哈哈哈听得出来flo还挺喜欢薛之谦的,一直在为谦谦说话
声乐老师对于音乐表达的认知还是在线的,确实笔笔这首歌的细节更多,表现力更丰富。 期待未来有很多周笔畅的声乐评测❤
jacky cheung is the best
想聽老師評胡彥濱跟林俊傑合唱的黑夜問白天
❤期待老師欣賞coco李玟在我是歌手全部的演出
不行耶,我張學友中毒,其他我都覺得差點,這種歌還是不太喜歡過於花俏的
我也是❤
赞同~
只是比赛现场就是这样,现场观众需要那种冲击力~
問題是她覺得用最多多餘技巧的是張學友😂😂
@@ednlbbo 没关系听听就好,世界那么大,一个人的评价不代表所有人的评价~
在黑神話悟空狂掃世界的當下
我突然覺得我得感謝老師
很認真沈浸在亞洲流行樂裡❤
二段中間開場老師說我聽過
結果一秒發現是上一首歌😂
這團隊嗑了什麼請再來多一點
張學友是我年少時到現在最喜歡的歌手,但周深是我更加最最喜歡的歌手了❤❤❤
我年少时没有最喜欢的歌手,现在只听单依纯😀😀😀
年少时无数优秀歌手我都很喜欢,谭咏麟张学友齐秦周华健张信哲为最,但现在对周深的每首歌都觉得超有感。
我20幾年前,在台北大安森林公園聽的現場才是學友的最強版本😊
despacito还真的有中文版
林俊杰跟luis fonsi的合作😏
不叫慢慢 但叫缓缓😌😝
跟这首慢慢一样,都是an字辈的
哈哈哈哈 橘老師讓我笑翻🤣
抱歉了 只有學友才是我only one
感覺之前的評論都還專業,這場怎麼完全以自己喜好來定論,說好的專業呢?還是要改變風格為綜藝節目。
老師什麼時候說她專業,她就是做自己有什麼問題嗎
10:00
老師被自己金魚腦笑到也太可愛!
nowadays i think i enjoy watching 3 of them chatting more…
很高興老師也喜歡胡彥斌~順便說一下,之前老師很喜歡周深唱的那首月光,就是胡彥斌寫的喔(I'm glad that the teacher also likes Hu Yanbin~ By the way, the teacher liked the song "Moonlight" sung by Zhou Shen very much before, which was written by Hu Yanbin.)
只愛張學友❤
Nothing's wrong with showing the rest three of the four heavenly kings. They each have their own characteristics performance-wise and they have improved a lot as time goes by. At least they are a lot better than some current artistes.
沉默的羔羊 周深
Love jacky chan version
胡諺斌和周深河唱過 一首【 賊】。很精彩。
請問是戴佩妮的賊嗎?
还有很多歌星呢!!也没看评论过。。蔡健雅,黄明志,光亮,戴佩妮,梁静茹,Dear Jane (乐队),阿杜,曹格,张智成,萧闵仁,蓝亦邦,许美静,萧煌奇,动力火车,张敬轩,薛凯琪,丁当,彭佳慧,王诺琳,张碧晨等等。。还有最近蛮红的菲道丝 Firdaus
我也想多看一些大陸以外的歌手評論
那老師好。
哈哈哈
我當然支持我們香港代表張學友啦!
感覺唱慢慢應該就要抒情 歌詞就這樣 胡彥斌唱雖然好聽動感 但是歌詞就不合 張學友+1
把一首哀傷的歌曲認為是熱鬧性感的舞曲,然後說這是最好的版本……😅
如果告訴老師張學友今年63歲,不知道她會否理解張為何仍要使用顫音
个人看法,老师不懂中文,隐藏在字里行间的意义,通过声音的表达,老师不能体会,所以她只能专注在声音和技巧方面的展现,很多时候,评语显得得很片面。另外,她也太有自己的个人偏爰,不是太能接受其他的唱法,这个倒是无可厚非,但对于自己不欣赏的东西,我觉得是不需要带着嘲笑的心态是对自己在音乐上的专业的一种尊重。
另外,在播着歌的时候又同时讲着其他与歌评没有关系的话题,这也是个人不太苛同的地方,尤其是旁边哪位女生的夸张笑声,是让人有点反感。
无论如何,基本上还是蛮感谢老师的视频,也会点赞,毕竟还是让我们学到更多东西,感恩,🙏。
学友唱的是我们的青葱岁月,那歌里有我们自己的故事,没法从技术里去比较了😂😂😂
伴唱的張學友(藍雨)粵語有歌詞版本 非常好聽
離開以後 也可以
推薦給老師
雖仍然女生有修音。但是有了感情渲染力。當然也很不錯。讚同妳說法
胡彥斌真的是改編鬼才...又很少人能駕馭他改編的歌
薛志謙跟譚晶想營造一種撕心裂肺的感覺,結果變成濕心累肺
張學友是越老越有味道的,年輕時大鼻子讓他顏值不加分😂
哇!老胡!!!獲得老師讚賞!!開心!!
竟然批评张学友唱法,张学友是华语乐坛唯一真神,他完全有能力把别人认为极为垃圾的歌曲唱的深入人心,就是一种化腐朽为神奇的能力。
喜歡學友、Bibi
more Jacky please
建議可以聽Tiger的月光
張學友不管唱甚麼,我通通買單,抱歉了橘老師~
嗨!bibi粉丝在这里❤开心看到您的乐评~期待您看更多bibi的歌曲,以前是很多年前的影片,而且是她在比赛里,平时她的风格是很不同的哟!
@@jingruteh9471 本Bi粉在💚💚
ファントムシータ『キミと✕✕✕✕したいだけ』(Vocal Recording - Behind The Scenes) , 這是Ado 擔當製作的女團PhantomSiita 在錄音室現場親自指導教唱成員的影片花絮 , 有機會也能老師看看
這種從當年一路愛到現在的大愛歌,很抱歉我沒有辦法代入其他任何人的聲音。
翻唱的諸位不論好壞,都是他們的慢慢,不是我珍藏的「慢慢」。
橘子老師片尾的演唱好有感情 I am touched
oh i know this song 超可愛 我大聲笑出來了XDDDD
這個比較要先聽原版的再看胡彥斌的才會比較震撼😅
张学友能唱到人心底,不知道作为另一种语言的以技巧为主的赏评,能否get到
居然有這首歌了! 我好愛這首 可惜老師不喜歡 也許這首歌真的需要跟中文的語感有點連結會比較容易喜歡吧..XD
敲碗 張碧晨!!!
我完全理解那個男主持人!走過那個年代的,哪個不會學他們唱歌的技巧啦?人人都在KTV狂練顫音,因為那時候就超流行這種唱法的!一抖還有一抖抖!🤣
推介胡彥斌近年節目上唱自己16歲創作的《超時空的愛情》,二胡真的很好聽很絕~感覺老師可能會喜歡❤ ruclips.net/video/N-3JQLqAcvA/видео.htmlsi=8c2c6JB28lyzhkyi
什么时候re胡彦斌系列呀❤❤期待
Can consider listening to Kit Chan from Singapore if you are looking for vocalist.
So funny😂 This is my first time to watch the whole episode without subtitle and it did bring me more different flavour compared to that polished edited one(have Chinese subtitle)❤
好好奇 跟老師對話的二人是誰哦哈哈 他們都好有趣
Yes!! Love JJ Lin's (中文版)Despacito!
i'm very sad teacher doesn't like it, because this song is my favorite
I think some of the sloppiness comes from the fact that they are both very theatrical singers individually, so when combined, its almost like they're having a rifting battle, cool to themselves, but quite squirmy to the audiences' ears.
JKAI偷渡愛歌,FLO整個好委屈XDDD(橘老師表示愛莫能助)
建议顺序原唱先,后听翻唱。可惜老师把胡彦斌r&b当成标准来评。后面节拍突然都是慢歌。老师都困了。😅😅
不討論技巧和能力,單論質感和音樂氣質
Rosette的偏好到一個閾值之後就驚人的叫人難以相信😂
胡彥斌能力沒話說,但唱法土又俗
Rosette喜歡的音樂有時候真的是帶有西洋土味
瑕不掩瑜啦,Rosette解釋音樂和演唱的細緻程度實在超好,超深刻
或是審美到極致上的差異
亞洲音樂中的老氣他不喜歡,他喜歡的西洋土味我聽著難受😂
胡太求表現太匠氣了
老師喜愛的周深在時光機唱的月光,就是第一個演唱者寫的,不過胡彥斌參加的那個節目當初就是一直要人飆高音的感覺😅
Have you heard JJ’s collab with Fonsi 😂 Chinese Despacito
可以讓老師聽張學友的jazz!!! Private corner
Coach is so funny when she was taken aback by the female singer .. too kind to say that she is npt prep, Flo
想看更多筆筆近期舞台點評❤🎉
音樂果然是主觀沒辦法客觀的也許了解歌詞歌曲年代意義可能無法更自由講評可能受限只能說沒有對錯
胡彦斌和黄龄合唱谢谢
胡彦斌的月光和周深的翻唱版都很好听
More Tiger, Ai Mei, and Jolin please!
对胡来说是不公平比对因为他是因为节目需求去做改编而且要完全与原版不一样的风格
Bibi Zhou is pretty awesome. Love her show.
希望老师评逝去的爱,李安
又是慢歌.....................
(我覺得張學友是四大天王中最帥的
胡彥斌無疑技巧很高,但只有張學友既有技巧,亦唱出了詞中深情,這位講評者不懂歌詞,難怪只留意歌唱技巧,這樣的評斷太流於表面和沒意思
請多一點筆筆~ 感恩
我倒覺得胡後段有些油😅竟然與橘子老師所見略同
Lol. You can tell from the timbre it's a soprano sax not a clarinet. Surprised the 2 saxophonists couldn't tell the difference.
可以建意做郁可唯的專集嗎?