This is the first Judge Judy that made me feel like weeping. She doesn't understand how hard it is for a guy like him to rise above his past. I gotta say, when she said he had an open container of alcohol, I pictured a guy finishing a gutter job, sweaty and dirty, cracking open a cold one. That sounds like a blue collar American thing to do. A big thank you to Judge Judy for helping this guy, I wish him nothing but the best. Stay the path brother, my heart goes out to you
Shit doesn't fly with Judge Judy. She loves helping ex cons if she can. She knows people make mistakes. I have a Judge that live across the street from me and she only hires ex cons to do handy work around her house.
Agreed. She is probably used to lying and being believed so expected to get away with it again. She lied repeatedly. Why come on international tv with such blatant silly lies. Some people are just so used to getting their own way that they lose touch with reality. So glad JJ humiliated her globally. Pity he didn’t sue for more, he might have got it.
@@bobscratchett5346 IKR. I hope he gets a lot of work just from these videos. People will now know the truth about her, and that’s he’s a decent guy trying to turn his life around. This reminds me of the _karen_ in the park with a dog not on a leash. When a dude pointed out the signs and asked her to put a leash on him, she called 911 screaming hysterically that: _a black man is attacking me in the bushes. I’m all alone. Please send ALL your police!_ She got charged.
@Cody Grant She is the quintessential _karen!_ A lying beast who’s fooled no one watching this, and I sincerely hope this ghosts her for the rest of her life. This young man was clearly trying to turn his life around. And for no reason whatsoever she tried to destroy him. Shame on her!
I really feel good about this ending. The defendant was reasonable, and the plaintiff was quite dishonest, and took advantage of the legal system. If this man is (or was) on probation, having to go back for a restraining order hearing is terrible for him, if he's trying to get his life back on track, and do honest odd-jobs for people as a day labourer that's wonderful on him, and it's awful to try and tear him down while he's picking himself up.
She probably goes to church every Sunday. I know a few hypocrites like that. They love to stomp on people when they're down to make themselves feel superior .
She's such a nice looking, old & responsible lady... we all know she'd never lie or exaggerate. And he's just an X-felon with a gunshot womb. Of course, the judge will never side with him (so she thought). Very satisfying indeed.
Hope this experience has taught him to keep his professional life separate from his private life. A true professional would never flirt with a --teenage-- customer.
I have watched this several times and the level of satisfaction has increased every time. I wish nothing but the best for this man. He was respectful, humble, and truthful. It is so hard to rebuild your life once you’ve been incarcerated and/or have struggled with addiction, even when you have the love and support of family, friends, and community… we all face hardship, others judging us.. but this lady clearly did not see this man as an equal, she figured she could take advantage of his situation and make him do these jobs for a fraction of what it would normally cost.. and then when things didn’t turn out the way she wanted, she figured “oh I’ll get the law involved, no one is clearly going to take him seriously”…. She looks like a fool and I am so happy this was televised for all to see. Matthew, I absolutely hope you are doing well and thriving.
Yeah, I felt so bad for him...all over $100. She wanted cheap work and she thought, "Oh, I can pull one over on this guy who has a past." I have worked with prior felons and others who went through the system and are working to get past what they have done. It is hard because of the stigma they have. She tried to have a pity party. Also, she said her daughter said he lifted his shirt. Not ONCE did she say HER DAUGHTER hated it or felt weird, she implied it did based on her perception as her daughter is not there to attest to anything said...hearsay. She is probably used to getting her way because she plays the role of a weak vulnerable old lady and people just believe her boohoo sob way of talking. JJ caught her in her own game of lies and called her out and she realized she done goofed and now she needs to make sure she seems like she did everything right.
If someone done me bad for that amount, I'd feel bad but for a couple of hours. I wouldn't stew on it enough to take out a restraining order or take him to court.
She was upset at her own foolishness for thinking she could get the job done for 1/6th the money and when she found out that things were getting worse in terms of the money required to repair, she tried to take it out on him.
That women thought she could take advantage of someone in a tough spot. I guarantee you the thought "Whose going believe him over me?" went through her mind. What a despicable "Karen", good on you JJ!!
I am more than Outraged by the plaintiff's actions toward this man! He deserved $5,000., for the lies and false charges made against him by the plaintiff. She used his past against him, filed a false restraining order, smeared his name on Facebook, then lied about him to Judge Judy, and right to her face, and to top of it off, she's suing him for the work he was going to finish but had a professional do, and she wants the money she paid someone else. *The Audacity of some people and she looks like an innocent lady, as sweet as can be, and the lies she said were insane!*
She’s so used to doing this throughout her life, lying comes easy to her. Everything she’s done needs to be re-examined. Glad he won, and glad jj saw past her lies.
He was humble and honest that he only sued for what the labor for what time missed would have been. I hope he's still doing well and doesn't ever come across someone like this again.
@@lcam9241 He can, takes time for the legal system to approve it, but eventually he can have a full business. I hope he can regain the trust of people for the hard work he does to be an honest worker. He clearly is working hard and deserves the second chance life is giving him. I takes a lot of willpower and guts to push back with integrity to those that only look at your past and not root for his future.
This is what I love about Judge Judy. She’s incredibly intelligent and observant, and she’s fair. She doesn’t care about someone’s age, race, background, or anything else. She makes judgements based on facts, evidence, and honest testimony.
For real and those be the people that are telling the truth that go for the lowest amount. It’s the ones that sue for large amounts, lying hence that lady $1200 for a $100 job 😂 she is nuts
In her deposition to JJ in part 1 she said she saw the defendant cleaning the neighbours gutters and approached him to do the same for her. In the restraining order she claimed he was doing the neighbours gutter then came to her looking for work. So she lied on at least one legal document.
The defendant is an excellent example of someone with a bad past, who turned his life around. And he was so calm and polite during the whole case here. And the plaintiff is a perfect example of someone who is rich, and thinks herself "perfect citizen" but is untrustworthy and a liar.
To quote Oscar Wilde, “every saint has a past and every sinner has a future”. The defendant seems calm and reasonable. Seems like he’s cleaned up his act since getting out of jail and now he’s trying to work and earn an honest living. Good for him, I hope he continues that. As for the plaintiff, she seems crazy and is an obvious liar.
Wilde was a sexual degenerate, and a dope fiends. His quotes are cliche garbage. The quote you just used was a catty attack on the church, not some deep, propfound, insight on the struggles of man. No one gave a damn about Wilde outside of other degenerates until the 1960s when hippies used his garbage to help springboard the counter culture. It's annoying to no end, when people quote, without knowing the context, or the person, who said said quote.
The neat ponytail is a total dead giveaway for reformed criminal. And I'm only saying that because I see them in my 12 step meetings all the time.Glad she got exposed for the shyster she was.
2:25 underappreciated moment. JJ slamdunked the case when she explained there was no way the guy could know about the daughters surgery unless what he said was true.
I literally clapped when this case was over. I am so glad JJ saw right through the plaintiff's malicious intentions. Proud of the young man keeping his composure, being respectful and honest, and for working towards turning his life around. Great case!
That was so satisfying to watch. Instead of 100, she ended up paying 900, plus she was exposed for being a lying con artist trying to keep a man down. Sweet justice
This is why I love Judge Judy. She does not let someone's troubled past or the fact that he's a felon, sway her judgement on the facts of the case in front of her. This woman probably thought she could come to court with the Sweet Grandma act and a judge would of course side with her because he's a felon. Well that doesn't work in JJ's court. She didn't have a case and JJ saw right through her.
She's a bitch, totally agree with that. Calling her a "Karen" is totally unfair to all the women named Karen who are NOTHING like this woman. It's time to stop this crazy trend. A person's name is part of their identity, and it's time to stop judging people you don't even know by making their name an insult. It's hurtful to people who don't deserve it. What if it was YOUR name?
The defendant is a very nice, respectful man. I'm glad he was awarded $$$ but he should have gotten more because that plaintiff's conduct is outrageous.
JJ can see that the Defendant took responsibility for his past and was honest. The Plaintiff couldn’t keep her story straight and was nodding to every lie thatJJ exposed… weird. JJ was right on this case.
She really tried to sink this man because of his past... unbelieveable! So glad JJ saw straight through that perfect old lady card she was trying to pull
I think her daughter likes the man, and the mother wasn't having any of it. Why else would the daughter show her leg to him. That is why prompted the mother to research him online. Glad she lost the case. Now she has to pay him $800. She should have paid him that much from the beginning. What a loser!
I had surgery done on my knee when I was literally one week old. I still have a deep (healed of course) scar on my knee 23 years later. There's no way you can't have a scar from something like that😅
When judge Judy sees through women like this it makes me want to stand up and cheer. This lady is so accustomed to lying her way into being a victim she's probably been torturing people like this her whole life
The saddest thing is, she seems to have trained her daughter to do the same thing. Her daughter told her that this guy practically flashed her. She left out the part about the conversation they were having about scars and flashing her Ankle at HIM.
@@tanyapoulin5880 I bet she wasn’t even in the military. I BET she’s one of those military wives that’s like “you have to respect me cuz my husband is (rank) and call me by that (rank) too”.
Let's be real, he accepted the job and thats all that matters. Zero excuse to do a poor job. She's trying to milk the situation but it's very likely he did actually do a shoddy job and broke things. Not sure why everyone just assumes he didn't do anything wrong. He seems like an opportunist.
I work at floor and decor vanity’s are kinda expensive and the cheapest I saw the instal team was for $500 and if they had to come back it was $200 a day
Exactly. Yet he agreed to do it? Because he knew he wasn't skilled and was taking a chance desperate for money. He likely did partially stuff up. Not sure why everyone is defending him. He seems like a chancer. And so does she.
Well, if the supplies is already there and it's just a plug in I'd do it for $100.. The parts he was missing take only 10 minutes to install. She just plain didn't like his work. And for a $100 I'll set that vanity and hook it up but I ain't redoing the whole bathroom.
The plaintiff was about to destroy the defendants life over an underpaid $100 job. Hes going door to door offering to do gutter cleaning which is a dirty job most dont like to do especially if you dont have a shopvac with a long hose and doing it with your hands and a bucket. The whole daughter with the knee scar, im believing the daughter only gave her mom half the story and she ran with it to the police for that restraining order. This whole daughter showing him her scar and him showing her his scar leading up to the mother seeking a restraining order reminds me of a friend who told me their company forbids men of entering a home to perform any HVAC maintenance unless there was an adult male at home as it puts an end to false claims against the technician being inappropriate. At the time I thought he was full of BS, but as years went on and more stories started showing up on social media, I understood why. Good outcome on this case and hopefully the defendant bounces back to find more work.
What made me angry about that scar situation was that he was clearly trying to make the daughter feel better about her scar, and Karen twisted it into him being inappropriate. It's yet another example of her framing a situation (with lies) to construct the narrative that suits her best. It's a carbon copy of the cracked granite (to Home Depot: "it was cracked when I got it" so they'd replace it, but to JJ: "he dropped it" to make him look bad) & the way he ended up working for her (to JJ: "I approached him as the work he did for my neighbour was good" so she'd look less of an idiot, but on the restraining order: "he cold-called, whilst drinking, and demanding cash" so he'd look bad). Makes you wonder how many times she's pulled the "sweet old white lady" routine to get her own way and get others in trouble...
The worst .. she asked him to do her gutters ... he didn't knock her door .. she came to him .. and brought all the nastiness .. but I am so proud of him for not allowing this nasty woman drag him lower in life .. I truly wish him all the best.
@@georgina-a that woman is a monster. I'm sure she's gone her whole life lying on people and everyone just automatically believing her. I worked with an office manager like that. They are horrible like Amber Heard.
Hope the defendant was able to turn things around after this. That lady should be ashamed of herself for slandering this poor guy when he was just trying to make an honest living. I hope he’s ok now…
Love this case!!! Being self-employed, I have to deal with people like this, but I immediately walk away when I notice how they are. Thankfully, I can choose my customers.
That poor guy. I know exactly who this woman is. She wanted cheap labour and so she got someone who was looking to rebuild his life after a troubled past. Once she found out that the guy had a past, she got snobby and tried to ruin him again. What a horrible old woman.
She was told she didn't have to appear for the restraining order cuz they knew it'd be dismissed and they probably told her that too, but keep on with your story lady. This man has paid his debt to society and is knocking door to door looking for work, putting in the effort. I hope life has gotten better for this man.
Clearly she's a Karen... expected the man to do all that work, plus commute to and from her place over at least 2 days, all for $100. And then has the gall to sue him?! All because how dear a ex-con do HER any wrong? Absolutely loved that JJ decided in favour of the defendant. I think this is only the second time I've seen a countersuit win
This is one of the best Judge Judy's I have seen (and I appeared before her in Bronx Family Court decades ago). The plaintiff is in La-la Land. So happy justice was done.
The defendant was honest, articulate, and intelligent. I wish him a lifetime of peace, love, and prosperity. Stay away from people who want to bring you down. The negativity and dishonesty were mind boggling. God bless all of you.❤
Wow! This just goes to show how some people will smile in your face while they try to bury a knife in your back. She’s literally standing there with the wide eyed doe look giving her Oscar worthy performance of the innocent victim while she’s actually the evil witch. SMH
The defendant is obviously trying to get his life straight and I hope he stays right… and this lady tried to destroy his character and lied about him to ruin everything he’s been trying to do… Ugh 😑
I can't stand the plaintiff. She's as dishonest as it gets, but has the entitlement to have 0 awareness how twisted she is. Sounds to me like he did too much for that $100 and really doesn't owe her anything else.
The lady’s face when asked about her daughter’s surgery and scar 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Busted and she knew it!!
A deer caught in headlights 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
A pig in a blanket.
She was lying right amd left... But looked so simcere and kind with her big eyes 😂😂😂
This is the first Judge Judy that made me feel like weeping. She doesn't understand how hard it is for a guy like him to rise above his past. I gotta say, when she said he had an open container of alcohol, I pictured a guy finishing a gutter job, sweaty and dirty, cracking open a cold one. That sounds like a blue collar American thing to do. A big thank you to Judge Judy for helping this guy, I wish him nothing but the best. Stay the path brother, my heart goes out to you
Might have even been offered the beer by the guy who he worked for before he went to her
I agree, u can see he is trying, stay strong brother
"blue collar" stands for a by the book, office kind of guy.
Usually works for corporate.
@@arekay6014 No, white collar are the corporate, office people. Blue collar is a manual laborer
Plaintiff thought she had a case only because Defendant had a criminal past. So glad he actually won.
Shit doesn't fly with Judge Judy. She loves helping ex cons if she can. She knows people make mistakes. I have a Judge that live across the street from me and she only hires ex cons to do handy work around her house.
Agreed. She is probably used to lying and being believed so expected to get away with it again. She lied repeatedly. Why come on international tv with such blatant silly lies. Some people are just so used to getting their own way that they lose touch with reality. So glad JJ humiliated her globally. Pity he didn’t sue for more, he might have got it.
Sooooo glad he won....against
"Those big eyes" as Judge Judy mentioned a couple of times🤣🤣🤣
@@bobscratchett5346 IKR. I hope he gets a lot of work just from these videos. People will now know the truth about her, and that’s he’s a decent guy trying to turn his life around.
This reminds me of the _karen_ in the park with a dog not on a leash. When a dude pointed out the signs and asked her to put a leash on him, she called 911 screaming hysterically that:
_a black man is attacking me in the bushes. I’m all alone. Please send ALL your police!_
She got charged.
@Cody Grant She is the quintessential _karen!_ A lying beast who’s fooled no one watching this, and I sincerely hope this ghosts her for the rest of her life.
This young man was clearly trying to turn his life around. And for no reason whatsoever she tried to destroy him.
Shame on her!
Occasionally, there is something quite satisfying when you hear *_“Judgement for the defendant on the counterclaim”._*
I really feel good about this ending. The defendant was reasonable, and the plaintiff was quite dishonest, and took advantage of the legal system. If this man is (or was) on probation, having to go back for a restraining order hearing is terrible for him, if he's trying to get his life back on track, and do honest odd-jobs for people as a day labourer that's wonderful on him, and it's awful to try and tear him down while he's picking himself up.
Exactly, no wonder he asked for so little to do a job like that. It's hard to get work as an ex-con.
She's definitely a Karen 🙈, albeit a sweet grandma looking one.
I feel sorry for him too. He’s handsome though
She probably goes to church every Sunday. I know a few hypocrites like that. They love to stomp on people when they're down to make themselves feel superior .
@@HungVu-vs3dv very handsome.
This lady knew exactly what she was doing. She used this man's past against him.
That was one of the most satisfying things I've ever watched. Seeing this poor guy win his countersuit was completely awesome!!
I actually clapped :)
👏🏽👏🏽Yesss!!!
👏👏👏👏
Me too... how do you expect someone to turn their life around when someone is laying in the weeds waiting for a hiccup! Yeah JJ!
She's such a nice looking, old & responsible lady... we all know she'd never lie or exaggerate. And he's just an X-felon with a gunshot womb. Of course, the judge will never side with him (so she thought). Very satisfying indeed.
ONE OF BEST JUDGE JUDY CASES EVER,,,,, THE YOUNG MAN IS A HUMBLE HUMAN BEING.........
"She had surgery but there was no scar" I'm sorry, did the doctors use magic to fix her knee lol
Exactly! Any surgery that is required to cut through the skin will always leave a scar.
Not true!!!! Her surgeon disarmed Dumbledore and now has the Elder Wand.
#Surgery
#LookMaNoScars!
@@MrVoltage69 😅🤣👍
Super glue.
Lol
JJ is really amazed at the irony of the plaintiff big innocent eyes and how outrageous she really is. Good lesson, don't judge a book by its cover.
That is a Karen for you.
Looks like he has had a troubled past but he's trying to rebuild his life.
And then he bumps into the Charles Manson of little old ladies.
I believe him...This woman is crazy
Hope this experience has taught him to keep his professional life separate from his private life. A true professional would never flirt with a --teenage-- customer.
@@TheKomentor I am not sure if he was flirting with her...I looks like just a conversation
@@TheKomentor and how did you get that he was flirting
I have watched this several times and the level of satisfaction has increased every time. I wish nothing but the best for this man. He was respectful, humble, and truthful. It is so hard to rebuild your life once you’ve been incarcerated and/or have struggled with addiction, even when you have the love and support of family, friends, and community… we all face hardship, others judging us.. but this lady clearly did not see this man as an equal, she figured she could take advantage of his situation and make him do these jobs for a fraction of what it would normally cost.. and then when things didn’t turn out the way she wanted, she figured “oh I’ll get the law involved, no one is clearly going to take him seriously”…. She looks like a fool and I am so happy this was televised for all to see. Matthew, I absolutely hope you are doing well and thriving.
Yeah, I felt so bad for him...all over $100. She wanted cheap work and she thought, "Oh, I can pull one over on this guy who has a past." I have worked with prior felons and others who went through the system and are working to get past what they have done. It is hard because of the stigma they have. She tried to have a pity party. Also, she said her daughter said he lifted his shirt. Not ONCE did she say HER DAUGHTER hated it or felt weird, she implied it did based on her perception as her daughter is not there to attest to anything said...hearsay. She is probably used to getting her way because she plays the role of a weak vulnerable old lady and people just believe her boohoo sob way of talking. JJ caught her in her own game of lies and called her out and she realized she done goofed and now she needs to make sure she seems like she did everything right.
If someone done me bad for that amount, I'd feel bad but for a couple of hours. I wouldn't stew on it enough to take out a restraining order or take him to court.
This lady is insane. What do people get out of trying to make other people's lives miserable? I cannot fathom it.
She was upset at her own foolishness for thinking she could get the job done for 1/6th the money and when she found out that things were getting worse in terms of the money required to repair, she tried to take it out on him.
Insane and mean. What right does she have to try and destroy his reputation and take out a restraining order against him?
They have nothing better to do with their lives other than ruminate on how they were "wronged".
She must be bored. Who knows
She’s rotten
I wish with all my heart Mr. Lewis is doing a lot better and living his life happily! 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
That women thought she could take advantage of someone in a tough spot. I guarantee you the thought "Whose going believe him over me?" went through her mind. What a despicable "Karen", good on you JJ!!
Captain Crunch You hit a homer with that comment. Exactly.
Also, I dont understand the princess Diana 1984 haircut..
A special kind of Karen: a Cynthia
You are absolutely correct. 💯
Heard and Depp in mind
I am more than Outraged by the plaintiff's actions toward this man!
He deserved $5,000., for the lies and false charges made against him by the plaintiff.
She used his past against him, filed a false restraining order, smeared his name on Facebook, then lied about him to Judge Judy, and right to her face, and to top of it off, she's suing him for the work he was going to finish but had a professional do, and she wants the money she paid someone else.
*The Audacity of some people and she looks like an innocent lady, as sweet as can be, and the lies she said were insane!*
You can see it in his eyes man
He wants to move on from his past and make a honest living ❤
exactly! and she was trying to use his past to destroy him!
Absolutely!!
@@Elle-xf8mw For... money, dirty o'l money! 👎👎👎
yes, everyone can change and he genuinely sounds like he's trying
And all you could see from her were EYES!!!
He’s trying to turn his life around and it’s people like her that makes it hard. There was NO reason for her to do this to him.
She’s so used to doing this throughout her life, lying comes easy to her. Everything she’s done needs to be re-examined. Glad he won, and glad jj saw past her lies.
And her big eyes 👁👄👁
@@wadilotus she’s a wolf in sheeps clothing.
@@wadilotus L😂L
1 million % correct. with the fake look of innocence and bewilderment on her face. jjj is truly truth serum.
AND - she's getting her daughter to lie, too!
One of the most wholesome and satisfying decision. Felt very happy for the guy. He is trying to turn his life around working hard and honestly.
Glad he got paid. That boy was trying to clean gutters to make money. He'll own his own company one day if not already.
*IF* he can get licensed with his record that is. Hopefully he can!
He should sued her the max of $5k
He was humble and honest that he only sued for what the labor for what time missed would have been. I hope he's still doing well and doesn't ever come across someone like this again.
@@lcam9241 He can, takes time for the legal system to approve it, but eventually he can have a full business. I hope he can regain the trust of people for the hard work he does to be an honest worker. He clearly is working hard and deserves the second chance life is giving him. I takes a lot of willpower and guts to push back with integrity to those that only look at your past and not root for his future.
Yes, he could make good money cleaning gutters. All it takes is a leaf blower and a ladder. It only takes an hour and not much can go wrong
This is what I love about Judge Judy. She’s incredibly intelligent and observant, and she’s fair. She doesn’t care about someone’s age, race, background, or anything else. She makes judgements based on facts, evidence, and honest testimony.
Dude could've sued for more from that false restraining order. That lady was terrible
Definatley missing a 0 on that judgment
Yeah JJ does not like false restraining orders.
For real and those be the people that are telling the truth that go for the lowest amount. It’s the ones that sue for large amounts, lying hence that lady $1200 for a $100 job 😂 she is nuts
In her deposition to JJ in part 1 she said she saw the defendant cleaning the neighbours gutters and approached him to do the same for her. In the restraining order she claimed he was doing the neighbours gutter then came to her looking for work. So she lied on at least one legal document.
She bet it all on playing the poor old lady. Bet it all and lost magnificently.
The defendant is an excellent example of someone with a bad past, who turned his life around. And he was so calm and polite during the whole case here.
And the plaintiff is a perfect example of someone who is rich, and thinks herself "perfect citizen" but is untrustworthy and a liar.
To quote Oscar Wilde, “every saint has a past and every sinner has a future”. The defendant seems calm and reasonable. Seems like he’s cleaned up his act since getting out of jail and now he’s trying to work and earn an honest living. Good for him, I hope he continues that. As for the plaintiff, she seems crazy and is an obvious liar.
Wilde was a sexual degenerate, and a dope fiends. His quotes are cliche garbage.
The quote you just used was a catty attack on the church, not some deep, propfound, insight on the struggles of man.
No one gave a damn about Wilde outside of other degenerates until the 1960s when hippies used his garbage to help springboard the counter culture.
It's annoying to no end, when people quote, without knowing the context, or the person, who said said quote.
The neat ponytail is a total dead giveaway for reformed criminal. And I'm only saying that because I see them in my 12 step meetings all the time.Glad she got exposed for the shyster she was.
👌great quote
love the quote!♡
Love the Oscar Wilde quote. I quote him at times as well, as he was so brilliant.
Right now, I just want to hug JJ. This is the best verdict ever. Feel so sorry for the young man.
She filed a restraining order and sued him in court.... ? Over $100. Dear lord this lady was nuts
it's even crazier to think that filling a suit actually costs money. Depending on where you live it can be $25-150 or so...
@@journeywithrosie wow! This lady needs Jesus
She did it because her daughter probably thought he was cute 🥺
@@marylyn3081lmaooo
2:25 underappreciated moment. JJ slamdunked the case when she explained there was no way the guy could know about the daughters surgery unless what he said was true.
Judy Judge is a sharp lady. She always find the truth
Every time JJ mentioned the big eyes and her looking at her with those big eyes it had me dying 🤣
Me too 😁😂
Same 😂😂😂😂
The look of "I can't believe she is siding with the criminal and not me".
Lady was a piece of work. Glad he won
I know! To quote the Eagles, those “Lying Eyes” got under her skin! Too funny!
Me too, 😂 It’s the eyes for me, lol
I literally clapped when this case was over. I am so glad JJ saw right through the plaintiff's malicious intentions. Proud of the young man keeping his composure, being respectful and honest, and for working towards turning his life around. Great case!
I love the poetic justice of this case!! She's the real liar and shady character.
I love this phrase Poetic Justice. You seem romantic in nature.
Imagine having her as a mother-in-law.
@@katerinapatiniotis5598 naughty girl
God bless this man, honest, hard working, organized and trying to get his life back on track.
This is another perfect example of why I respect Judge Judy so much. She's never judgmental and always more than fair. All hail the Queen! ❤
Matthew, we're all rooting for you!
That was so satisfying to watch. Instead of 100, she ended up paying 900, plus she was exposed for being a lying con artist trying to keep a man down. Sweet justice
He always said "your honor". Clearly been in front of a judge before, as we know. I found him to be honest, and respectful.
This is why I love Judge Judy. She does not let someone's troubled past or the fact that he's a felon, sway her judgement on the facts of the case in front of her. This woman probably thought she could come to court with the Sweet Grandma act and a judge would of course side with her because he's a felon. Well that doesn't work in JJ's court. She didn't have a case and JJ saw right through her.
JJ’s memory and recap ability is just outstanding
She may be more mild tempered, but she is *definitely* a Karen.
👍My thoughts exactly!!!
Old drama queen Karen with the big wide eyes!
I was thinking the same!
More like insane
Thats just because shes in front of a judge. Imagine what she's like behind closed doors. Yikes.
She's a bitch, totally agree with that. Calling her a "Karen" is totally unfair to all the women named Karen who are NOTHING like this woman. It's time to stop this crazy trend. A person's name is part of their identity, and it's time to stop judging people you don't even know by making their name an insult. It's hurtful to people who don't deserve it. What if it was YOUR name?
This was very satisfying to watch. I'm so glad Judge Judy saw through those big eyes 👀
The defendant is a very nice, respectful man. I'm glad he was awarded $$$ but he should have gotten more because that plaintiff's conduct is outrageous.
JJ can see that the Defendant took responsibility for his past and was honest. The Plaintiff couldn’t keep her story straight and was nodding to every lie thatJJ exposed… weird. JJ was right on this case.
Her nodding was extremely odd...she comes off as a very nasty person.
She didn't seem to comprehend how she was being caught in lies
Judge Judy was priceless here.
She really tried to sink this man because of his past... unbelieveable! So glad JJ saw straight through that perfect old lady card she was trying to pull
I think her daughter likes the man, and the mother wasn't having any of it. Why else would the daughter show her leg to him. That is why prompted the mother to research him online. Glad she lost the case. Now she has to pay him $800. She should have paid him that much from the beginning. What a loser!
This was a great episode. Justice is truly supreme. What a great ending.
It's more than that❤❤
Lol 😂 backfired on the plaintiff! How do you have knee surgery and not have scars?
Exactly. How else would have he known about the surgery if she hasn't mentioned it.
I had surgery done on my knee when I was literally one week old. I still have a deep (healed of course) scar on my knee 23 years later. There's no way you can't have a scar from something like that😅
I feel so bad for him. She tried to take advantage of a man with a tough past. Shame on her!
When judge Judy sees through women like this it makes me want to stand up and cheer. This lady is so accustomed to lying her way into being a victim she's probably been torturing people like this her whole life
The saddest thing is, she seems to have trained her daughter to do the same thing. Her daughter told her that this guy practically flashed her. She left out the part about the conversation they were having about scars and flashing her Ankle at HIM.
“she’s had surgery but there’s no scar” 😂
this lady is crazy. expecting a professional job for $100
Facts! I wish JJ had called her on this. Sure she had surgery, but there's no scar...because...it's so dumb.
Not even. She expected all this work for 100 professional or not. She isn't right and I think it said she was in the military of sorts? Yikes.
Maybe she sued the surgeon too for the scars! Who knows? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@tanyapoulin5880 I bet she wasn’t even in the military. I BET she’s one of those military wives that’s like “you have to respect me cuz my husband is (rank) and call me by that (rank) too”.
Let's be real, he accepted the job and thats all that matters. Zero excuse to do a poor job. She's trying to milk the situation but it's very likely he did actually do a shoddy job and broke things. Not sure why everyone just assumes he didn't do anything wrong. He seems like an opportunist.
I love Judge Judy best case ever
She's insane! No one in their right mind would do all that work for $100. She's so unfair!
I work at floor and decor vanity’s are kinda expensive and the cheapest I saw the instal team was for $500 and if they had to come back it was $200 a day
Exactly. Yet he agreed to do it? Because he knew he wasn't skilled and was taking a chance desperate for money. He likely did partially stuff up. Not sure why everyone is defending him. He seems like a chancer. And so does she.
Well, if the supplies is already there and it's just a plug in I'd do it for $100.. The parts he was missing take only 10 minutes to install. She just plain didn't like his work. And for a $100 I'll set that vanity and hook it up but I ain't redoing the whole bathroom.
Righteous justice. Thank you Judge Judy!
Was waiting at the door for part 4 😂
Me too! Im so happy lol
Good ending!
Why wait at the door?😂😂😂
@@peacheskong2245 lol i had to wait like 30 mins in between parts. When part 3 ended, i had to wait for them to upload part 4 😂 and i was waiting!
Say what you want about judge Judy, but she cares about the facts.
The plaintiff was about to destroy the defendants life over an underpaid $100 job. Hes going door to door offering to do gutter cleaning which is a dirty job most dont like to do especially if you dont have a shopvac with a long hose and doing it with your hands and a bucket. The whole daughter with the knee scar, im believing the daughter only gave her mom half the story and she ran with it to the police for that restraining order. This whole daughter showing him her scar and him showing her his scar leading up to the mother seeking a restraining order reminds me of a friend who told me their company forbids men of entering a home to perform any HVAC maintenance unless there was an adult male at home as it puts an end to false claims against the technician being inappropriate. At the time I thought he was full of BS, but as years went on and more stories started showing up on social media, I understood why.
Good outcome on this case and hopefully the defendant bounces back to find more work.
What made me angry about that scar situation was that he was clearly trying to make the daughter feel better about her scar, and Karen twisted it into him being inappropriate. It's yet another example of her framing a situation (with lies) to construct the narrative that suits her best. It's a carbon copy of the cracked granite (to Home Depot: "it was cracked when I got it" so they'd replace it, but to JJ: "he dropped it" to make him look bad) & the way he ended up working for her (to JJ: "I approached him as the work he did for my neighbour was good" so she'd look less of an idiot, but on the restraining order: "he cold-called, whilst drinking, and demanding cash" so he'd look bad).
Makes you wonder how many times she's pulled the "sweet old white lady" routine to get her own way and get others in trouble...
@@georgina-a amen to everything you wrote!
The worst .. she asked him to do her gutters ... he didn't knock her door .. she came to him ..
and brought all the nastiness .. but I am so proud of him for not allowing this nasty woman drag him lower in life ..
I truly wish him all the best.
Hope he gets plenty of work.
@@georgina-a that woman is a monster. I'm sure she's gone her whole life lying on people and everyone just automatically believing her. I worked with an office manager like that. They are horrible like Amber Heard.
Hope the defendant was able to turn things around after this. That lady should be ashamed of herself for slandering this poor guy when he was just trying to make an honest living. I hope he’s ok now…
I enjoyed seeing the stress on the Plaintiff's face as JJ tore her lies apart and threw them back at her. What a terrible person. Shame
Imagine having her as a mother-in-law.
Love Judge Judy.. This lady should be ashamed of herself!
Love this case!!! Being self-employed, I have to deal with people like this, but I immediately walk away when I notice how they are. Thankfully, I can choose my customers.
One of the best verdicts ever....well done Judge Judy👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🤗🤗👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
That poor guy. I know exactly who this woman is. She wanted cheap labour and so she got someone who was looking to rebuild his life after a troubled past. Once she found out that the guy had a past, she got snobby and tried to ruin him again. What a horrible old woman.
Best outcome EVER!! Plaintiff was beyond ridiculous!!
Hands down one of my favorite cases. Way to deliver justice, JJ!
Agreed. That women is an example of what's wrong with our society. Unfortunately there are many more like her who get away with abusing their power
Wow, she's a scary piece of work. (and that's putting it nicely)
She was told she didn't have to appear for the restraining order cuz they knew it'd be dismissed and they probably told her that too, but keep on with your story lady. This man has paid his debt to society and is knocking door to door looking for work, putting in the effort. I hope life has gotten better for this man.
They probably felt bad for the guy after reading her retarded complaint and said oh you don't need to be here. lol
Judge Judy did a great job on this case!
I wish I could get in contact with this guy. He seems to be a good guy that needs a break. I’d bring him on without hesitation!
Wow! Justice was served!!👏
I love how Judge Judy ruled on this case. The liar had to pay the man $800.
SO GLAD ABOUT THIS VERDICT
Her “deer in the headlight” look wasn’t fooling anybody.
This is one of Judge Judy's very best. God bless her.
Clearly she's a Karen... expected the man to do all that work, plus commute to and from her place over at least 2 days, all for $100. And then has the gall to sue him?! All because how dear a ex-con do HER any wrong?
Absolutely loved that JJ decided in favour of the defendant. I think this is only the second time I've seen a countersuit win
They often win but this one was special
she thought she was entitled lol
This is one of the best Judge Judy's I have seen (and I appeared before her in Bronx Family Court decades ago). The plaintiff is in La-la Land. So happy justice was done.
Imagine how many lies this woman may have told on others over the years
I'm thinking, like every day
10000000000000000000000............. still continute till her death........
The plaintiff’s “deer in the headlight” look after every question JJ asks followed by a pause resembling a focal seizure is ridiculous. JJ is sharp.
It appears she thought she could win just by appearing to be a better person.
That is exactly right .
Because usually it works well. Just didn't work today
The defendant was honest, articulate, and intelligent. I wish him a lifetime of peace, love, and prosperity. Stay away from people who want to bring you down. The negativity and dishonesty were mind boggling. God bless all of you.❤
Damn, judge let her know she was wrong
The nerves of that woman! How dares she? I’m so happy for that young man.
"Those Big Eyes" in JJ voice...
She's a big eyed liar! Wish he could have sued for more.
I really like Judge Judy!! people looks and past doesn't affect her decisions
I’d be hard pressed to pick a favourite episode but this one is up there! Way to go Judge Judy!
One of my favorite episodes. More power Judge❤👍
Same, I've already come back to rewatch it twice. This one and Roughed Up In a Vegas Hotel Room are my favorites.
This lady has to feel so stupid She sued him and ends up having to pay him and she looked crazy on TV 💀
Poetic justice
No…she will never learn. She is the type of person who will now try to sue Judge Judy for the case not going her way.
2:28 I love their smiling in the background at JJ’s brilliance.
Satisfying to watch towards the end. Serves her (plaintiff) right. You're the best Judge Judy!
I love it when the plaintiff loses to a counter claim!
What's fair is fair and JJ is awesome!
Wow! This just goes to show how some people will smile in your face while they try to bury a knife in your back. She’s literally standing there with the wide eyed doe look giving her Oscar worthy performance of the innocent victim while she’s actually the evil witch. SMH
omg! this is the first time i enjoyed outcome of a case so much! this guy showed more respect than any other!
The defendant is obviously trying to get his life straight and I hope he stays right… and this lady tried to destroy his character and lied about him to ruin everything he’s been trying to do… Ugh 😑
One of the best 4 parters I’ve seen on here in a while. I love when an outrageous Karen gets what she deserves.
I can't stand the plaintiff. She's as dishonest as it gets, but has the entitlement to have 0 awareness how twisted she is. Sounds to me like he did too much for that $100 and really doesn't owe her anything else.
Congrats to the defendant and I pray that he has good health and a prosperous future with all he has endured.
OMGosh, I think this was one of the best Judge Judy's I've seen!
Awesome JJ...What a happy ending 😂😂
I'm glad she didn't say "i want to talk to your manager!" 😂🤣
She's a trouble maker and a sinister individual, if I were him I'd take her to court for defamation & IIED
Wish him all the best!