I'm pretty sure you just saved me from failing my literary honors course! Thank you! You explain psychological criticism in a quick and simple way for me to understand, and your enthusiasm helps me stay engaged with the content! You're amazing!
My essay is due in a few hours and... I still have to write it. I focused very much on the psychology of the story, but don’t feel confident enough to apply it but thank you for lightening my mood a little :)
Wow, ang video na ito ay talagang nakakatulong sa akin! Matagal na akong interesado sa paksa na ito, at ang iyong paliwanag ay talagang nakatulong sa akin na mas maintindihan ito. Pinapahalagahan ko ang iyong kahusayan at pagkahilig sa paksa na ito. Ako rin ay isang content creator, at nag-eexplore rin ako ng mga katulad na tema sa aking channel. Gusto ko makipag-ugnayan at magpalitan ng mga ideya sa mga taong may parehong interes. Keep up the good work!
Wow, your videos on Literary Criticism are really helpful! I am taking Ap Lang & Comp this year and I have an exam tomorrow on a bunch of the different criticisms and how they are used. The reading we were assigned didn't really provide much clarity, but your videos did. Thank you very much!
Crystal clear! Just as it needs to be!! Whoever can't explain something simply hasn't understood it completely either. That's a general comment for all these professors who make our lives harder...
Thanks for the very informative lecture. I have a couple of questions about this approach. Why? in helping a reader understand these texts? Why? to help in your explication of texts? Why? I really benefited from your lecture and I hope you have good answers to those questions. I really appreciate your time.
Hello, I am a graduate student from Taiwan. This video is really helpful. Thank you! But I'm studying on Michel Foucault recently, and I can not find any videos relates to him on your channel. I'm really looking forward to the subsequent videos. (:
Thank you. I don’t currently have any videos on him specifically, but I’ve had a few requests, so I’ll keep it in mind. I want to get back to making literary criticism videos, but I’ve had trouble finding time.
Yes. I would say psychological criticism is generally using psychology to study literature, whereas psychoanalytical crit is specifically using psychoanalysis to study the subconscious of the characters. It's more specific and related to the balance of the Id, Ego and Superego, as discussed by Freud. This video only introduces the use of psychology generally.
Thank u so much ❤ u literally save me . U have a great potential in teaching and I do like your style , which helps me a lot in my study. Criticism is interesting and u make it way more fun 🥰 thanks again.
Thank you so much for this. I need to do a power point applying a type of criticism to a play and chose psychological criticism, this makes the way it's used clear and gives me a good starting place!
Hi! Thank you so much for your awesome videos. I am taking a class right now on Theories and Teachings of Literature and we are reading about all of these different theories including Psychoanalysis. I am a bit confused though since you did comment on someone that psychoanalysis is different to psychological criticism...Because what I read in my book is similar to what you're saying in the video...But my main question is that I currently have to write a research paper on any literary/critical theory on any literary text and I have chosen to write about "Frankenstein" using psychoanalysis. Would you have any tips as to how I could approach this? I don't even know my thesis yet either, so therefore am quite lost, to be honest. Any help would be appreciated! Thank you!
I suppose psychoanalysis as you're seeing it means simply applying psychoanalysis to a character in a book, which I would consider a subcategory of psychological criticism, but could I guess be used somewhat interchangeably. Are you intending to psychoanalyze Frankenstein or the monster? Both are interesting because each has complex and even conflicting motives for their actions. You could focus on Victor's obsessive work habits, or the desire for love and the complexity of relationships. How about Oedipal complexes stemming from being rejected by a father? Or, of course, you could blend a little historical criticism in and psychoanalyze Mary Shelley. How much of the monster story is a reaction to her deteriorating relationship with her husband? There are many options. A good place to start would be to list all the possible psychological issues you see and then pick one that interests you and has interesting implications. Good luck!
Thank you so much for your reply! I have decided to analyze Victor but took the route of how the monster is his "dark double" and then will compare and contrast them both. I will be talking about Victor's obsessiveness and definitely the Oedipus complex about his childhood! Currently in the making since the draft is due next Monday.
Hello, Mr Nance, I want to conduct my undergraduate research paper about analyzing the maturity development of Huckleberry Finn using Robert Kegan's stages of Social Maturity. Is it possible for me to do that?
I am going to use psychoanatic criticism for my thesis project and your video is really helpful. I can easily make a general questions of the object I use. Could you suggest me which books I should read that has relation with Kohlberg? Thanks!
You might read Kohlberg's book of essays: Kohlberg, Lawrence (1981). Essays on Moral Development, Vol. I: The Philosophy of Moral Development. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row. Also, you should look at his use of the Heinz Dilemma. Good luck on your thesis project!
These are good basic psychology questions that I think my Chinese students will understand. Great work, Mr Nance. Thank you for uploading your video :)
+Genevieve Cortes Psychoanalysis is a method of examining someone's mental state through questioning & associations, etc. Picture a person on a couch talking to a psychologist. This is more generally applying principles and methods of psychology to literature.
Ah! True! And I just suggested him for archetypal study to a student. Oh, well! Yes, Melville is very interesting, psychologically. I'd say Moby Dick is much more psychologically driven than plot driven.
Melville was a sailor first Moby Dick and Billie Budd just reek of that POV. I am enjoying your classroom I never had any formal English Lit after HS. I studied Engineering at Cornell and almost all My arts electives were in the Classics. I guess that's formal literatary study come to think of it.
Plot twist--Lacan and friends who spill over into Deconstruction as well (and make it so that we only understand like 32% of what they say, fun times).
I'm pretty sure you just saved me from failing my literary honors course! Thank you! You explain psychological criticism in a quick and simple way for me to understand, and your enthusiasm helps me stay engaged with the content! You're amazing!
Mr. Nance, I'm so glad I came across this video!
Thanks for the help man. Glad is still helpful even 8 years later!
This is so helpful, Mr. Nance! Thank you for this literary criticism series!
My essay is due in a few hours and... I still have to write it. I focused very much on the psychology of the story, but don’t feel confident enough to apply it but thank you for lightening my mood a little :)
I'm considering writing a thesis using psychological criticism approach and this video helps! Thank you! You're amazing :)
thankyou! i have completed a huge part in my literature syllabus of a semester.... by looking at your videos sir! thankyou
This is just what I needed for my essay! Thank you so much!
Thanks for your help!
Wow, ang video na ito ay talagang nakakatulong sa akin! Matagal na akong interesado sa paksa na ito, at ang iyong paliwanag ay talagang nakatulong sa akin na mas maintindihan ito. Pinapahalagahan ko ang iyong kahusayan at pagkahilig sa paksa na ito. Ako rin ay isang content creator, at nag-eexplore rin ako ng mga katulad na tema sa aking channel. Gusto ko makipag-ugnayan at magpalitan ng mga ideya sa mga taong may parehong interes. Keep up the good work!
I was so confused until I saw this. Thank you!
Wow, your videos on Literary Criticism are really helpful! I am taking Ap Lang & Comp this year and I have an exam tomorrow on a bunch of the different criticisms and how they are used. The reading we were assigned didn't really provide much clarity, but your videos did. Thank you very much!
Hey!
Thank you so much . This is so informative
Crystal clear! Just as it needs to be!! Whoever can't explain something simply hasn't understood it completely either. That's a general comment for all these professors who make our lives harder...
Hi! Can you please talk about Marxist approach?
Great course, im sure these points will help me greatly.
Very useful. Helped me in my exams. Thank you
Difficult topics explained in an easy manner. Thank you.
Thank you! All of your videos have come in handy during COVID :)
Could you please talk about Russian Formalism?
This is so helpful for my current project.... Thanks a lot...
Thanks for the very informative lecture. I have a couple of questions about this approach.
Why?
in helping a
reader understand these texts? Why?
to help in your
explication of texts? Why?
I really benefited from your lecture and I hope you have good answers to those questions. I really appreciate your time.
Beautiful! thankyouuu Sir!
How about the Lacanian theory?
This video helps me a lot! Thanks!
Thank You!
Thank you👏🏻
Hello, I am a graduate student from Taiwan. This video is really helpful. Thank you! But I'm studying on Michel Foucault recently, and I can not find any videos relates to him on your channel. I'm really looking forward to the subsequent videos. (:
Thank you. I don’t currently have any videos on him specifically, but I’ve had a few requests, so I’ll keep it in mind. I want to get back to making literary criticism videos, but I’ve had trouble finding time.
Hi :D My question is, is there a difference between psychological criticism and psychoanalytic criticism? Thank you.
Yes. I would say psychological criticism is generally using psychology to study literature, whereas psychoanalytical crit is specifically using psychoanalysis to study the subconscious of the characters. It's more specific and related to the balance of the Id, Ego and Superego, as discussed by Freud. This video only introduces the use of psychology generally.
Okay. Thank you so much. I've searched for the difference, but nothing appeared. Again, Thank you!
Thank u so much ❤ u literally save me . U have a great potential in teaching and I do like your style , which helps me a lot in my study. Criticism is interesting and u make it way more fun 🥰 thanks again.
Can you explain what is archetypal criticism
can Tajfel 's social theory be applied on literary text?
Certainly.
Thank you so very much for this video! It was extremely helpful.
thanks for making me understand these topics in such a lucid way.
Thank you so much you helped me a lot I appreciate. From Algeria
Wow thank you so much for saving my life during finals week i love you
Hey
Can you do a video on postcolonialism?
Thank you so much for this. I need to do a power point applying a type of criticism to a play and chose psychological criticism, this makes the way it's used clear and gives me a good starting place!
Do you think you will ever do the rest of the theories?
I may do more if I ever have time.
can you make videos on formalism and structuralism also. plz
Hi! Thank you so much for your awesome videos. I am taking a class right now on Theories and Teachings of Literature and we are reading about all of these different theories including Psychoanalysis. I am a bit confused though since you did comment on someone that psychoanalysis is different to psychological criticism...Because what I read in my book is similar to what you're saying in the video...But my main question is that I currently have to write a research paper on any literary/critical theory on any literary text and I have chosen to write about "Frankenstein" using psychoanalysis. Would you have any tips as to how I could approach this? I don't even know my thesis yet either, so therefore am quite lost, to be honest. Any help would be appreciated! Thank you!
I suppose psychoanalysis as you're seeing it means simply applying psychoanalysis to a character in a book, which I would consider a subcategory of psychological criticism, but could I guess be used somewhat interchangeably.
Are you intending to psychoanalyze Frankenstein or the monster? Both are interesting because each has complex and even conflicting motives for their actions. You could focus on Victor's obsessive work habits, or the desire for love and the complexity of relationships. How about Oedipal complexes stemming from being rejected by a father? Or, of course, you could blend a little historical criticism in and psychoanalyze Mary Shelley. How much of the monster story is a reaction to her deteriorating relationship with her husband? There are many options. A good place to start would be to list all the possible psychological issues you see and then pick one that interests you and has interesting implications. Good luck!
Thank you so much for your reply! I have decided to analyze Victor but took the route of how the monster is his "dark double" and then will compare and contrast them both. I will be talking about Victor's obsessiveness and definitely the Oedipus complex about his childhood! Currently in the making since the draft is due next Monday.
Sounds interesting! Good luck!
hi Dr
tnx for this lesson
l am from egypt waiting you continue poetry lessons
Hopefully I'll get back to making videos next week!
Hello, Mr Nance, I want to conduct my undergraduate research paper about analyzing the maturity development of Huckleberry Finn using Robert Kegan's stages of Social Maturity. Is it possible for me to do that?
Thank you sir!
Thank you for this video!
You're welcome!
I am going to use psychoanatic criticism for my thesis project and your video is really helpful. I can easily make a general questions of the object I use. Could you suggest me which books I should read that has relation with Kohlberg? Thanks!
You might read Kohlberg's book of essays: Kohlberg, Lawrence (1981). Essays on Moral Development, Vol. I: The Philosophy of Moral Development. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row.
Also, you should look at his use of the Heinz Dilemma. Good luck on your thesis project!
Thanks for you that is good
Love your videos :)
Is this the same with psychoanalytic theory
These are good basic psychology questions that I think my Chinese students will understand. Great work, Mr Nance. Thank you for uploading your video :)
You're welcome! Thank you!
Muwah this video was godsent thank you!!
Is this the same as "Pschoanalysis"?
+Genevieve Cortes Psychoanalysis is a method of examining someone's mental state through questioning & associations, etc. Picture a person on a couch talking to a psychologist. This is more generally applying principles and methods of psychology to literature.
I'am a storyteller - You missed a bet Tim Jung!
Melville's works would be a good case study here.
Ah! True! And I just suggested him for archetypal study to a student. Oh, well! Yes, Melville is very interesting, psychologically. I'd say Moby Dick is much more psychologically driven than plot driven.
Melville was a sailor first Moby Dick and Billie Budd just reek of that POV. I am enjoying your classroom I never had any formal English Lit after HS. I studied Engineering at Cornell and almost all My arts electives were in the Classics. I guess that's formal literatary study come to think of it.
You are an interesting guy....
hype it up! we love psychoanaltic theory
thanks for this e test to
I am an arabic guy studies English literature , and i have 2nd midterm tomorrow in literary criticism
Good luck!
Tim Nance Thank you so much you have helped us me and khalid my classmate
I am going to report about psychological approach in our lit crit.
I loooove ur videos since I’m lost in the theories field 😫i wish you had added just a little more
Hello, is it possible that i could get your email?
I need to ask a lot of things.
Feel free to ask them here, and I’ll try to answer them.
🙏🏻🌸
but how is this different from biographical criticism they both seem to focus on the author and how they think
Is Psychoanalytical criticism the same?
Psychoanalytical is a little more specific, using Freud’s psychoanalytic model on characters and their motivations.
Tim Nance thank you prof. I have to do one today on a book. Any tips? Should i read the book and analyse at the same time or finish the book first
You could do either. Maybe take notes as you read, and then, develop the response fully after you finish. Good luck!
Or that they all carry meaning. Which they do.
example?
tihis sounds more like a checklist thena tutorial
انت رائع
Plot twist--Lacan and friends who spill over into Deconstruction as well (and make it so that we only understand like 32% of what they say, fun times).
Epic
i like the way this guy explains things. kinda makes me want to kidnap him and make him teach my literature class XD im kidding HAHAHAHAHA
Ha, ha! *Checks to make sure my door is locked.
Hello
He's a turn on for me, great job! 🤭
rip annotations
You are adorable
Goo
Jim Nance's nerdy nephew.
Thank you sir!