The op is correct. This is clearly rejection by maternal bulbul. The father bulbul is the experienced parent, mother isn't. Not only did mom build an inadequate nest in an unusual spot, but it was not strong enough or correctly built either. Thus it continued to tilt and contributed to this sad outcome. The mother is obviously frustrated while feeding. The babies are weak and not properly grasping her beak to signal get to let the food go. So she repeats the cycle and gets further frustrated. Finally she eats the food intended for the babies. The issue is further compounded by mom feeding insects that were way too large for these babies. This further created frustration for mom. That's a lack of experience on mom's behalf. However, the father bulbul feeds without issues. Sadly the mother bulbul eventually kicks babies from the nest TWICE. That's no accident twice. Clear rejection due to failure to thrive because of inexperienced mother. The poor father bulbul returns with food to an empty nest. He's clearly confused why the babies aren't there. The op tried to intervene and replace the babies after the first rejection. Op had hope it was accidental. It was not an accident. Mother kicks the babies out of the nest a second time. She made her decision clear. Larger birds will throw a rejected baby out with their beaks. These birds are much smaller, with tiny beaks, thus they'll kick the rejected babies out of the nest with their feet. The action is obvious. If there was any doubt she repeats the process of kicking them backwards out of the nest. It's very intentional. They were failing to thrive due to insufficient feedings by mom. Dad was great, he did everything right. As the babies got weaker from mom's starvation, so did their ability to close their beaks around mom's beak. So inexperienced Mom didn't know to let the food go. As this communication issue continued, the babies further declined and weakened. Without Dad they'd have declined much sooner. Finally the babies were so weak and close to death she just rejected them from the nest. It's nature, it's imprinted within these birds to reject offspring that aren't strong enough to thrive and survive. It ensures the species has the best genetics. The weak are culled, rejected, or die. The strong and best genetics thrive and survive to reproduce. There's no point wasting time and resources on babies that aren't thriving. It's a natural act, there's no malice or evil intent. It's sad, but it's how nature ensures the best genetics are passed on and the weaker or defective ones aren't. Even if the weakness or issues we're caused by the parent themselves. It's sad. It's how nature works.
Standard stuff in mother nature. I used to have a bunny who was a terrible mother and ate her babies twice in a row. One morning you try to change her water in her own private quiet spot for raising the babies undisturbed, only to realize theres bloody chunks of baby rabbits all over the place.
When I was little when I would find the baby bird dead on the ground I would always pick them up and take it to my mom and ask her to bring it back to life. I thought my mom could do everything. I miss her so much 🥺😓
She looked confused when she returned with food to an empty nest, I'm not sure she intentionally pushed them out, every video I've seen of mothers throwing out a weakling is by her grabbing them with their beak and tossing them.
I felt like the nest wasn’t made straight enough and they fell ? Also does appear to be a 1st time mum. With practice she will get better. I found a baby newborn in the street alive. Sadly it died shortly after I carried it to the grass.
Они выпали из-за разваливается гнезда. Люди сделали ненадежную основу для гнезда из веревочек., чтобы понаблюдать за птицами с удобного места. Но это искусственное гнездо не подошло птицам и развалилась.
Looks like the nest was moved or tampered with. Why is it being held up by knotted rope. A bird didn’t tie those knots. I really hope it wasn’t and that she just chose the wrong spot
This probably her first babies. Many of the bits of food were too big plus sometimes she didn't let go. Maybe the dad should also be feeding them and they'd been allowed to live since would be healthier.
@@aprilgates1474 Who ever was filming this,I wonder why they didn't pick them up and take them to a wild life rehabilitation center? That was a short fall as fast and then went to the ground.
@@mattmalone524 She did well to throw them out cause they were incompetent, picky rats. She should have forced those insects down their greedy beaks or let them choke on it
Apparently they thought it might have been an accident so they put it back in the nest but it rejected it again. I don't know what happened after that but I'm not an expert on bird conservationism
I’ve heard both sides of the argument on whether it was on purpose or not. After careful analysis I believe she did do it on purpose. The first chick was the most lethargic and she was frustrated, most likely. She sat on them and pushed them with her feet. Can’t convince me otherwise
:15 through :30 made me laugh so hard for a second, I didn't realize the cut and it looked like the mom came and wiggled her bum all over their faces, flew off, and then the baby screamed in despair 🤣🤣🤣
for a channel that seems to understand about birds, the guy choose the title seems to be quite unaware of what happened there. She did not "PUSHED ALL OUT" at all - the nest was badly build, and it was tilted. What happened there was a tragic accident. Sadly birds do not have enough intelligence to realize what was happening... 💔
You are right.The mom did not pushed that baby out of the nest.It is an accident and the mom don’t know how to put them back.If he is filming this why he did not rescue that baby bird and put it back to the nest…BAD FILM 🎥
Look again, she very obviously “kicks” her feet back, as if she were ejecting an egg. Even after she turns and sees the baby dangling, she kicks again.
it looked pretty deliberate the second one. she was trying to feed it and it couldnt get up. you'll notice she had the fly in her mouth and while the baby had his mouth open he wasnt swallowing it. after 5 6 attempts it was like nah. better luck next batch1
I think two parents were feeding. While one was feeding well and the chicks were eating, the other was either not letting go the food or the food she put was too big to swallow (this is what I observed, perhaps someone can explain) Also the first chick looked fine while the 2nd one was mostly lying on its back. Perhaps the first chick dropped accidentally and then the mother kicked out the 2nd chick (only the 2nd one looked deliberate to me)
@@matirmanush5404 being a doctor or a PhD has nothing to do with animal behaviour. Where did I claim that I was an expert on animal behaviour. I wrote what I thought and asked if someone knew better to explain. Still you are so frustrated, don't know why . The way you replied to my comment shows your judgement capacity 😂😂😂
You are very much right. But it seems to me one of the parents was not mentally sound. It was trying to feed the food which was inappropriate in size or it picked up the food from the mouth of the chick before it swallowed the food. This parent of deranged mentality caused the real problems for the chicks. And ultimately finished them off totally. Dr. Das I am really sorry for what happened. You are quite OK.
I had the same impression. A very obvious example at about 22:30, when one of the parents kept offering and withdrawing the food which would be small enough to be swallowed by the chick. I had the feeling the feeding wasn't OK.
They weren't eating. Unfortunately it was a long thought out decision. She tried to give them time to start taking the food from her but they just couldn't do it. She realized there was two choices. She could keep holding food over their mouths while they didn't eat it until they died or help that process come sooner by abandoning them.
It just looks like they're first time parents. The nest was poorly constructed and at an angle. They kept bringing food way too big for the babies as well. They're simply brand new parents that didnt know what they were doing and unfortunately this is the consequences of that. They'll undoubtedly learn from their mistakes here and do better next time
Mom didn’t mean to kick out her babies. They were both fat & growing. Her nest kept getting shallower & it’s at a dangerous angle. She’s has no idea what happened. She was oddly clumsy in nestling over her babies.
Read the top comment here. The bird kicked the baby out twice. It ain't a coincidence. The hint is in its inexperienced behavior feeding, whereas the father was doing things correctly.
I got so sad. I was expecting a beautiful future for the babies. My heart is broken. I'm going to sleep. Bye everyone. Sorry for my sad feeling. Blessings on you all.
Don’t be sorry for being sad. This is incredibly sad 😞 I love watching bird and wildlife videos but I can’t stand seeing stuff like this. I know it’s nature but…I only went on this to see the comments to see if anyone else had a hard time watching this and after I send this comment I’m getting off the video. But don’t be sorry for being empathetic and caring cuz this world needs more people like that not less….❤️
At the early of the video, iw as wondering why the nest wad build tipping to a side which makes the babies easily toppled down. And it happened. The mother was caring for the babies but the babies accidently dropped to the ground
Seems to me that if you are a Mama and have food in ur mouth and don't let go of it while ur forcing it down ur babies' throats... Then ur a Mama just teasing with food. No wonder that these babies were immature and sickly without any nourishment, this becomes ur fate. Perhaps new Mama?
No, that was no accident. She seems to an experienced mother. Probably her first year. She was definitely frustrated. This happens a lot more than people realize…across bird species.
And parents do not throw or kick birds out, they don't 'smell' weak and immature birds, as ALL chicks are weak or immature. If mum was planning on evicting them, why would she continue to feed, why would she continue to brood?
They realize that the nest is tilting that’s why they are always coming to feed from the higher end of the nest mostly. They know what they are doing.💕
@gamblerfls Mate, the nest literally slants more and more as the video goes on. I know it's fun to try to pretend you see something most people didn't, but you can't just ignore what you obviously watched in the video to make stuff up man.
Correct. She was not only feeding food that was inadequate or too large, but she wouldn't let go when the food was correct. So frustrating. She's clearly inexperienced and lacking maternal instinct. The father did everything right. So sad when he returned to the empty nest with a small insect. He seemed so confused. He was a great father. Mom was either young and it was her first clutch, or she's seriously lacking maternal instinct to care for her young. Hopefully she'll do better next time. Better with selecting a nesting space and better with selecting the correct size foods and actually letting the food go! She caused them to become weak and fail to thrive. Then she rejected them because of that. Nature is brutal sometimes. Sigh.
The nest was either tampered or that was another parent getting rid of the competition. But, it looks like the nest is slowly being tilted more and more.
She got tired of feeding them lil bastards and they weren't growing so whoopsyyy. She started pretending they got kidnapped after she noticed she was being filmed..😆
@@dianneking3842 My comment was directed towards the horrible initial statement. I promise you I was not trying to be funny in any way as much of my life that I have dedicated to protecting animals.
If you look, you'll see that the nest is badly made and sloping at an angle from NW to SE downwards. That's why they fell out. Poor mother. Probably her first brood.
The anchor is to create a topic. Two points: 1. The bird's nest is tilted, and the broadcaster did not rescue the bird; 2. The bird leaked out, and it was not eliminated by the bird parents because of weakness
These chicks are having a hard time as they struggle to stay upright in a nest that's obviously tilted nearly at 40+ degree angle! Parent birds are bringing some insects that are too large to swallow! It's difficult to eat properly when your nest is compromised!
i think there was something wrong with the 2 babies, normally at each feeding or definitely some we should have seen the babies pooping, but we didn't catch it even once and their stomachs were looking overly bloated. Seems like they were born with not everything fully developed. 1 one did seem like an accident but the 2nd she def pushed with her feet several times
I'm here because we have had Robins laying her eggs in the nest on my property for the past 20 years. I saw Mom and Dad bird feeding them. I also saw little beaks waiting for food. I got home to my surprise to see 2 dead birds one at the bottom of my porch and the other in my driveway. The neighborhood toddler children who love to use my long driveway saw them before I could pick them up now their upset. In this video she legit pushed them out!!!!! I wonder were our birds weak
Похоже люди сделали эти веревки которые держат гнездо, но они не учли, что гнездо стало наклоняться в одну сторону и из за этого птенцы упали, люди которые установили камеру могли бы помочь этой птице, когда гнездо уже совсем склонилось в одну сторону
I thought there were two parents feeding. One was enthused with feeding, while the other just pretended to feed by sticking the food in the baby's mouth but kept pulling it out. She was the one who pushed them out casually and pretended it was an accident, lol. I could hear her say, oops, nothing to see here folks, just going to bed.
Ending yang menyedihkan ... Tapi si induk mempunyai insting untuk kelangsungan hidup anak** nya, bukan tanpa alasan dia menjatuhkan anak - anak nya, inilah yang di namakan seleksi alam ... Video yang keren, good job 👍👍
The nest tilted and the fell out. It was not secured enough. It happens, she did not push them out the nest basically was collapsing and the fell out.,
Chicks fell out twice and were put back and fell out again. The nest is practically vertical so who ever can film it all. Shame on whoever did this just to film babies, they killed those chicks by interfering with the slant of the nest.
“Observe intently the birds of heaven; they do not sow seed or reap or gather into storehouses, yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not worth more than they are?”
she positively did push them out on purpose. If you watch, she lays on them, pushes them with her feet, looks back, and when they are hanging on, she pushes until they are gone. At one point I was wondering why she bought that huge bug and tried to choke them to death.
That was Dad. There's two birds. Mom was refusing to feed them correctly and bring food too large. Dad did everything right. Mom rejected the babies and dad returned with food to an empty nest.. So sad.
Olhando no final do vídeo da pra ver que ela não queria saber desses filhotes e ela mesmo fez com que eles caíssem do seu ninho e com certeza eles foram comida de outros animais e ela não ligou pra eles tadinhos infelizmente isso aí faz parte da cadeia alimentar pra servir de comida para outros
Marcia, eu culpo o maldito que, para ganhar dinheiro na internet, inclinou o ninho para a câmera pegar bem. A mãe parecia inexperiente, mas o pai não. Mas foi a inclinação que causou tudo, os filhotes sempre ficam sentados, com pescoço e boca bem retos, aí a comida desce direitinho. Eles não conseguiam equilíbrio, o mais fraco nem conseguia sentar, o outro até conseguia, mas imagina lutar pra tentar ficar na posição e ainda comer... comiam muito menos do que deveriam por causa dessa dificuldade e da inexperiência da mãe, ficaram super fracos. Duvido que essa foi a única ninhada que o lixo matou por fama e grana.
You captured excellent footage of parent birds caring for two chicks. However, in careful review, it appears that the parent was providing equal care to both chicks, but most importantly, there's no evidence of intentional ejection by the parent. The chick was lying on the rim of a nest with an increasingly slanted incline, and when the parent moved, the chick laying on the rim accidentally slipped out of the nest. This was not intentional ejection at all, and the parent bird's behavior is consistent with that fact. It's unfortunate, but does happen, and the parent would not have been able to retrieve that youngster back to the nest, though would have been able to care for it wherever it fell. Another problem is your titling and description, even if intentional ejection had been the case. These birds *cannot* smell "weakness." Birds have somewhat limited olfactory senses, but one ability they actually do possess is sensing chemical signatures of *predatory* species nearby. Avians in taxonomy Family Cathartidae, which includes vulture and condor, have the additional documented ability of olfactory sense to detect carrion while kettling, even thousands of feet up in the air, and miles from a carcass. But, that's not at all what's happening here in this video, and I'm certain these are not vultures, but uncertain if or which species of bulbul this may be. You've mischaracterized a behavior, claiming the parent can "smell fear." The parent can't because avians simply don't possess that ability. *Therefore, your clip title and the claims made are wholly inaccurate and incorrect.* If this actually had been a case of intentional ejection, which it wasn't, that would be an example of adaptive behaviors such as possible parasitism by another avian species, environmental quality impact on selective neglect or rejection by parents of chicks (relative abundance of food), reproductive "insurance," where a second chick is only cared for till/if the oldest chick survives, is healthy, and begins normal growth (at which time the second chick is ignored), or because a chick displays sickly/injured condition after hatching, wherein parents will then passively ignore or remove the chick. So again, this was an accidental loss of a chick, and parent birds do not "smell" fear, weakness, nor anything else of the kind. There is so much interesting content on YT which is mislabeled, inaccurately titled, and misrepresented, all because the person posting it isn't knowledgeable, didn't make an effort to properly describe the content, or does so, knowingly, for attention or revenue. *STOP DOING THAT.* Now that you've been provided with accurate information, you have an obligation to update the title and description. Anything else isn't acceptable. Failing to properly label and describe, especially after it's been provided, is promoting inaccurate or fake information. Please don't do that.
It is not harshness of nature but the nest was made with those strings on the first place to tilt towards the camera for us to see instead of making it level for the birds and chicks.
It could be pesticide in their food chain, nothing is to be discarded in this video, those babies look weak but that's not the case, to me is that they didn't grow as fast as they should, the bigger the stronger.
Alot of splicing here, I think if we saw the entire situation we would see the chics not getting enough heat from mom bc dad isn't bringing her food that she needs to stay strong, cow birds are usually just awful parents, but mom is trying here but, heat is more important than food at this stage and there's no dad to help with that so mom let's her chics get too cold too often and that is why they're so weak
@@eRacer314 If they can't figure it out, then they won't reproduce and whatever is defective will be eliminated from the gene pool, eventually. Evolution is an amazing thing. Survival of the fittest.
Why is the nest held up by twine ? This nest was built by a human on purpose for the birds to fall out. Clearly the nest is made of twine, rigged up in a tree.
There were two different birds. Mom and dad. Mom was incorrectly feeding, feeding too large of insects, and not letting the food go when it was adequate. Dad was experienced. He feed properly, correct size, and always let go. Mom rejected babies by deliberately kicking them TWICE from the nest. Dad comes back with food to an empty nest, confused. With larger beaked birds they'll throw the rejected babies with their beaks. In smaller species with smaller beaks they'll kick the babies backwards from the nest. I've seen both of these done before. Hopefully mom does better with the next clutch of eggs. Hopefully she'll do better with selecting a nesting space, selecting the correct size foods to feed, and actually let's the food go. It's all learning. The babies were too far gone and weakened by the point they were rejected. They'd have never survived. While sad, it's nature to cull the weak and insufficient and care for the strong and thriving. In the animal world there's no point wasting time and resources on a baby that's not likely to thrive. Even if it's the mother's inexperience that causes the failure to thrive. It creates a stronger genetic line to keep the species alive. They intentionally reject any baby that seems to be off in anyway or weak. Sad, but nature isn't always happy.
@@Lyzi.B don’t blame the mum. she did well cause they were incompetent, picky rats. She should have forced those insects down their greedy beaks or let them choke on it
The op is correct. This is clearly rejection by maternal bulbul. The father bulbul is the experienced parent, mother isn't. Not only did mom build an inadequate nest in an unusual spot, but it was not strong enough or correctly built either. Thus it continued to tilt and contributed to this sad outcome. The mother is obviously frustrated while feeding. The babies are weak and not properly grasping her beak to signal get to let the food go. So she repeats the cycle and gets further frustrated. Finally she eats the food intended for the babies. The issue is further compounded by mom feeding insects that were way too large for these babies. This further created frustration for mom. That's a lack of experience on mom's behalf. However, the father bulbul feeds without issues. Sadly the mother bulbul eventually kicks babies from the nest TWICE. That's no accident twice. Clear rejection due to failure to thrive because of inexperienced mother. The poor father bulbul returns with food to an empty nest. He's clearly confused why the babies aren't there.
The op tried to intervene and replace the babies after the first rejection. Op had hope it was accidental. It was not an accident. Mother kicks the babies out of the nest a second time. She made her decision clear.
Larger birds will throw a rejected baby out with their beaks. These birds are much smaller, with tiny beaks, thus they'll kick the rejected babies out of the nest with their feet. The action is obvious. If there was any doubt she repeats the process of kicking them backwards out of the nest. It's very intentional.
They were failing to thrive due to insufficient feedings by mom. Dad was great, he did everything right. As the babies got weaker from mom's starvation, so did their ability to close their beaks around mom's beak. So inexperienced Mom didn't know to let the food go. As this communication issue continued, the babies further declined and weakened. Without Dad they'd have declined much sooner. Finally the babies were so weak and close to death she just rejected them from the nest.
It's nature, it's imprinted within these birds to reject offspring that aren't strong enough to thrive and survive. It ensures the species has the best genetics. The weak are culled, rejected, or die. The strong and best genetics thrive and survive to reproduce. There's no point wasting time and resources on babies that aren't thriving. It's a natural act, there's no malice or evil intent. It's sad, but it's how nature ensures the best genetics are passed on and the weaker or defective ones aren't. Even if the weakness or issues we're caused by the parent themselves. It's sad. It's how nature works.
Thankyou
Survival of the fittest
Summary: Little rats weren’t able to eat properly so mum made them fly early
Excellent explanation, thank you
@@janalphenaar6984 I prefer the explanation in the comment just above yours.
neighbor: hyper inflation costs?
mother bird: yea... i built the nest cheap, sloping...
Mom: "Heres some food, not really, got some food for ya, not really, mmm delicious that tasted great, sorry kids"
And this biiirrrdd you cannot chaaaaaannggee.........Looorrrdd knows she can't change..........LYNYRD SKYNYRD!
And the mother of the year award goes to....
I wish our justice system was like this getting rid of prisoners based on worst they have done in life
Yes not that mum !!!!
Standard stuff in mother nature. I used to have a bunny who was a terrible mother and ate her babies twice in a row. One morning you try to change her water in her own private quiet spot for raising the babies undisturbed, only to realize theres bloody chunks of baby rabbits all over the place.
@@Meitti I had a cat who ate her newborn kitten once. Nature is brutal.
Video begins at 21:30
Thanks buddy
When I was little when I would find the baby bird dead on the ground I would always pick them up and take it to my mom and ask her to bring it back to life. I thought my mom could do everything. I miss her so much 🥺😓
stay strong.everything will be alright
Oh... This is unexpected,I understand you(( but every wound heals with time
I'm so sorry you miss the little bird.
@@wxman2003she misses her mom not the bird dumbasz
@@weirdokid528 Zooom, right over the top of your clueless head.
She looked confused when she returned with food to an empty nest, I'm not sure she intentionally pushed them out, every video I've seen of mothers throwing out a weakling is by her grabbing them with their beak and tossing them.
Don't read the title, the mom bird was just inexperienced and didnt know what to do. It happens quite often.
I felt like the nest wasn’t made straight enough and they fell ? Also does appear to be a 1st time mum. With practice she will get better. I found a baby newborn in the street alive. Sadly it died shortly after I carried it to the grass.
@@Rai2M babies were weak so they were tossed with full intent.
I'd agree with inexperienced parents. Didn't break up the food much.
guy brought the chicks back to the nest.
@@codnw1491 in some other video?
Они выпали из-за разваливается гнезда. Люди сделали ненадежную основу для гнезда из веревочек., чтобы понаблюдать за птицами с удобного места. Но это искусственное гнездо не подошло птицам и развалилась.
Looks like the nest was moved or tampered with. Why is it being held up by knotted rope. A bird didn’t tie those knots. I really hope it wasn’t and that she just chose the wrong spot
I don't know why I find this so hilarious lmao. 🤣
stupid bird
😅
This probably her first babies. Many of the bits of food were too big plus sometimes she didn't let go. Maybe the dad should also be feeding them and they'd been allowed to live since would be healthier.
The nest was also crap as well. Far too flat for any chicks to remain inside.
Yeah, a lot of times she wouldn’t let go if the food. That angered me
@@aprilgates1474 Who ever was filming this,I wonder why they didn't pick them up and take them to a wild life rehabilitation center? That was a short fall as fast and then went to the ground.
@@mattmalone524 She did well to throw them out cause they were incompetent, picky rats. She should have forced those insects down their greedy beaks or let them choke on it
Apparently they thought it might have been an accident so they put it back in the nest but it rejected it again. I don't know what happened after that but I'm not an expert on bird conservationism
Nest is somewhat tilt, may be that is why baby fell down😢. God bless
thank you so much for the update, I hope they fix the nest also, so the next eagle babies will be safe
Мать года! Премию в студию!
Dumps them out comes back with more unbroken down food and has the audacity to look around like where the fuck my kids at 😂😂😂
I think that was the dad bird.
긴 시간 찰영 하느라 고생 하셨네요 리얼하게 영상을 보여줘서 감사 합니다ᆢ
I’ve heard both sides of the argument on whether it was on purpose or not. After careful analysis I believe she did do it on purpose. The first chick was the most lethargic and she was frustrated, most likely. She sat on them and pushed them with her feet. Can’t convince me otherwise
Actually I think the first one that fell is the one getting all the food at the start.
Thank you for your very careful analysis. I was waiting for this.
@@TitaniumTurbine😂😂
:15 through :30 made me laugh so hard for a second, I didn't realize the cut and it looked like the mom came and wiggled her bum all over their faces, flew off, and then the baby screamed in despair 🤣🤣🤣
Que bayuncada pésima lo que a dicho no viendo a los pajaritos con hambre y su madre no les lleva la comida
for a channel that seems to understand about birds, the guy choose the title seems to be quite unaware of what happened there. She did not "PUSHED ALL OUT" at all - the nest was badly build, and it was tilted. What happened there was a tragic accident.
Sadly birds do not have enough intelligence to realize what was happening... 💔
You are right.The mom did not pushed that baby out of the nest.It is an accident and the mom don’t know how to put them back.If he is filming this why he did not rescue that baby bird and put it back to the nest…BAD FILM 🎥
Look again, she very obviously “kicks” her feet back, as if she were ejecting an egg. Even after she turns and sees the baby dangling, she kicks again.
먼소라야 100% 어미새가 발로 밀었는데...
it looked pretty deliberate the second one. she was trying to feed it and it couldnt get up. you'll notice she had the fly in her mouth and while the baby had his mouth open he wasnt swallowing it. after 5 6 attempts it was like nah. better luck next batch1
Correct
ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧੀਆ ਵੀਡੀਓ ਬਣਾਈ ਬਾਈ
I think two parents were feeding. While one was feeding well and the chicks were eating, the other was either not letting go the food or the food she put was too big to swallow (this is what I observed, perhaps someone can explain)
Also the first chick looked fine while the 2nd one was mostly lying on its back. Perhaps the first chick dropped accidentally and then the mother kicked out the 2nd chick (only the 2nd one looked deliberate to me)
@@matirmanush5404 Who are YOU to judge like that? Are you a doctor?
@@matirmanush5404 being a doctor or a PhD has nothing to do with animal behaviour. Where did I claim that I was an expert on animal behaviour. I wrote what I thought and asked if someone knew better to explain. Still you are so frustrated, don't know why .
The way you replied to my comment shows your judgement capacity 😂😂😂
You are very much right.
But it seems to me one of the parents was not mentally sound.
It was trying to feed the food which was inappropriate in size or it picked up the food from the mouth of the chick before it swallowed the food.
This parent of deranged mentality caused the real problems for the chicks.
And ultimately finished them off totally.
Dr. Das I am really sorry for what happened.
You are quite OK.
I had the same impression. A very obvious example at about 22:30, when one of the parents kept offering and withdrawing the food which would be small enough to be swallowed by the chick. I had the feeling the feeding wasn't OK.
@@TrillianaEM 🎉One thing is for sure,they don't live there no more.😂
That just looked like poor nest making. It didn't look like she meant to do it.
I didn't think she meant to either until I saw her push the 2nd one out, now it's obvious she meant to for both.
yeah I seen the same video somewhere people tried to fix the nest but it didnt work
Seems like an inexperienced mother bird. Can't feed or build properly 😞
They weren't eating. Unfortunately it was a long thought out decision. She tried to give them time to start taking the food from her but they just couldn't do it. She realized there was two choices. She could keep holding food over their mouths while they didn't eat it until they died or help that process come sooner by abandoning them.
She did it.
Watching the nest get more and more slanted was so painful lol.
THANK you! poor bird must have been so confused why its home was tilting.
At least they didn’t go to waste. They was food for something. Circle of life
It just looks like they're first time parents. The nest was poorly constructed and at an angle. They kept bringing food way too big for the babies as well. They're simply brand new parents that didnt know what they were doing and unfortunately this is the consequences of that. They'll undoubtedly learn from their mistakes here and do better next time
Mom didn’t mean to kick out her babies. They were both fat & growing. Her nest kept getting shallower & it’s at a dangerous angle. She’s has no idea what happened. She was oddly clumsy in nestling over her babies.
I agree, every video I've seen of mothers throwing out a weakling is her grabbing them with their beak and tossing them.
Read the top comment here. The bird kicked the baby out twice. It ain't a coincidence. The hint is in its inexperienced behavior feeding, whereas the father was doing things correctly.
@@anonymousl5150 That was a replay of the birds falling out again, go back & watch, there was no 'twice'
That bird and the camera man have a whole lot of patience.
She definitely earned nature’s worst mom of the year award. 😵
Not true!!
I got so sad. I was expecting a beautiful future for the babies. My heart is broken. I'm going to sleep. Bye everyone. Sorry for my sad feeling. Blessings on you all.
🌃
Tf man go to sleep pussy
Don’t be sorry for being sad. This is incredibly sad 😞 I love watching bird and wildlife videos but I can’t stand seeing stuff like this. I know it’s nature but…I only went on this to see the comments to see if anyone else had a hard time watching this and after I send this comment I’m getting off the video. But don’t be sorry for being empathetic and caring cuz this world needs more people like that not less….❤️
@@squirrelgirl1853 You have bright heart! Thank God.
🥳🥳🥳🥳
Mommie dearest mother bird..
At the early of the video, iw as wondering why the nest wad build tipping to a side which makes the babies easily toppled down. And it happened. The mother was caring for the babies but the babies accidently dropped to the ground
Seems to me that if you are a Mama and have food in ur mouth and don't let go of it while ur forcing it down ur babies' throats... Then ur a Mama just teasing with food. No wonder that these babies were immature and sickly without any nourishment, this becomes ur fate. Perhaps new Mama?
You clearly didn’t watch the video after a few times they stopped taking food which they are going to die anyways
Incredible footage. Life is tough. We don’t know we’re alive. With our hospitals and surgeons and massive infrastructure for disabilities.
Lol love it!
The only thing is, given the title of the video, the first 21 minutes of the video is unnecessary.
No, that was no accident. She seems to an experienced mother. Probably her first year. She was definitely frustrated. This happens a lot more than people realize…across bird species.
And parents do not throw
or kick birds out, they don't 'smell' weak and immature birds, as ALL chicks are weak or immature. If mum was planning on evicting them, why would she continue to feed, why would she continue to brood?
They realize that the nest is tilting that’s why they are always coming to feed from the higher end of the nest mostly. They know what they are doing.💕
It may have something to do with all the messing that's gone on with the nest....looks like it's been strung up.
It's not the nest that's tilted, the camera is slanted if you didn't notice it. Look at the rest of the environment.
@gamblerfls Mate, the nest literally slants more and more as the video goes on. I know it's fun to try to pretend you see something most people didn't, but you can't just ignore what you obviously watched in the video to make stuff up man.
@@nmr7203 The camera that's slanting further... or the whole planet earth is flat and it is slanting
Mother of the Year!
Glad the mom bird tied strings to the nest to add support
Damn, that's brutal. It looked like she wasn't actually feeding them. She kept putting the worm in their mouth then pulling it back out. odd.
They squeeze the blood out to feed the chicks.
Shes selfish.
@@bispamagdasomdoceu5743 no
Correct. She was not only feeding food that was inadequate or too large, but she wouldn't let go when the food was correct. So frustrating. She's clearly inexperienced and lacking maternal instinct. The father did everything right. So sad when he returned to the empty nest with a small insect. He seemed so confused. He was a great father. Mom was either young and it was her first clutch, or she's seriously lacking maternal instinct to care for her young. Hopefully she'll do better next time. Better with selecting a nesting space and better with selecting the correct size foods and actually letting the food go! She caused them to become weak and fail to thrive. Then she rejected them because of that. Nature is brutal sometimes. Sigh.
They seemed unable to take the food she sensed their weakness and gave up on them knowing they wouldn’t make it.
Only a novice mom will learn to grow by trying, it's that simple.
Quá tuyệt vời
السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته جزاك الله خيرا
The nest was either tampered or that was another parent getting rid of the competition. But, it looks like the nest is slowly being tilted more and more.
😅
She got tired of feeding them lil bastards and they weren't growing so whoopsyyy. She started pretending they got kidnapped after she noticed she was being filmed..😆
😂
if you noticed; First she threw him out of the nest, and then she ate the worm. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
You're the only BASTARD within a 500 mile radius of where you sit with your 2 brain cells attacking each other constantly!
Are you both trying to be funny? Because you’re not.
@@dianneking3842 My comment was directed towards the horrible initial statement. I promise you I was not trying to be funny in any way as much of my life that I have dedicated to protecting animals.
ايتها العائله الجميله صباح الخير☺️
É lindo de sê ver, Deus é perfeito, sem palavra🥰🥰❤❤🙌🙌👏👏
If you look, you'll see that the nest is badly made and sloping at an angle from NW to SE downwards. That's why they fell out. Poor mother. Probably her first brood.
The anchor is to create a topic. Two points: 1. The bird's nest is tilted, and the broadcaster did not rescue the bird; 2. The bird leaked out, and it was not eliminated by the bird parents because of weakness
大自然的事 憑什麼插手？
那麼厲害你怎麼不去非洲救每天被肉食性動物吃的動物？
These chicks are having a hard time as they struggle to stay upright in a nest that's obviously tilted nearly at 40+ degree angle! Parent birds are bringing some insects that are too large to swallow! It's difficult to eat properly when your nest is compromised!
You act like birds know that..
Thank you for this vidio
i think there was something wrong with the 2 babies, normally at each feeding or definitely some we should have seen the babies pooping, but we didn't catch it even once and their stomachs were looking overly bloated. Seems like they were born with not everything fully developed. 1 one did seem like an accident but the 2nd she def pushed with her feet several times
I'm here because we have had Robins laying her eggs in the nest on my property for the past 20 years. I saw Mom and Dad bird feeding them. I also saw little beaks waiting for food. I got home to my surprise to see 2 dead birds one at the bottom of my porch and the other in my driveway. The neighborhood toddler children who love to use my long driveway saw them before I could pick them up now their upset. In this video she legit pushed them out!!!!! I wonder were our birds weak
They were sickly the poop was wet and cold
probably magpies, they kill small birds and raid nests if not well hidden
Похоже люди сделали эти веревки которые держат гнездо, но они не учли, что гнездо стало наклоняться в одну сторону и из за этого птенцы упали, люди которые установили камеру могли бы помочь этой птице, когда гнездо уже совсем склонилось в одну сторону
Ptenzi ne upali, a ptiza sama umishlenno wikinula ptenzow iz gnezda,tak kak pochyjala postoronniy zapah...
21:36 the thud from the baby falling 😰
22:54
De quanto em quanto tempo eles sao alimentados pela mãe?🤔
Have a feeling momma was tired of all the work involved in feeding them and hunting for food endlessly and decided she had enough of that
You say that like you'd do it because it's ok..
O ninho era mais feito e Lala estava tentando ajeitar para eles não cair
If these were humans, the mother would still get custody.
man that splat sound they make when they drop, on top of that agony some other crazy thing will just swoop down and eat them up.
Mother Smells Weak Immature babies & PUSHED OUT ALL ''
Me: Well..... that's motherly love right there
Looks like human(s) placed the nest sideways. Thus, making it difficult for the babies to stay inside. Smh . . .
I thought there were two parents feeding. One was enthused with feeding, while the other just pretended to feed by sticking the food in the baby's mouth but kept pulling it out. She was the one who pushed them out casually and pretended it was an accident, lol. I could hear her say, oops, nothing to see here folks, just going to bed.
Good video thanks for 👍
いつも思うんだけど、雛が落ちた時に親鳥はクチバシで摘んで巣に戻せないんだろうか？小鳥は厳しいのかな？特に大型の鳥なら絶対自分で巣に戻せるはずなのに、戻さないのはなんでだろうってずっと疑問。事故だとしても巣から落ちた時点で弱い個体って認識になるのかなぁ。
Hopefully the next clutch has better odds of mom and dad choosing a better nesting sight. 😆
Enjoyed watching this video my friend Really awesome views Thank you Stay connected
you installed a camera.....did you pick the babies up and rescue them in your home??.... i hope so!!
Why does the mother keep bringing food even after the babies were pushed out of the nest?
Because birds have no thoughts.
She will just make more
@@kylec.8350 Birds have no thoughts? According to who? If they didn’t have any thoughts then they wouldn’t be raising babies and building nests etc.
Other parent possibly
@@knowjusticeknowpeace15 No kidding 😄
Ending yang menyedihkan ...
Tapi si induk mempunyai insting untuk kelangsungan hidup anak** nya, bukan tanpa alasan dia menjatuhkan anak - anak nya, inilah yang di namakan seleksi alam ...
Video yang keren, good job 👍👍
The nest tilted and the fell out. It was not secured enough. It happens, she did not push them out the nest basically was collapsing and the fell out.,
Chicks fell out twice and were put back and fell out again. The nest is practically vertical so who ever can film it all. Shame on whoever did this just to film babies, they killed those chicks by interfering with the slant of the nest.
No. They just did a rewind of her pushing them
You buffoon, its the same clip
@@Sceptonic "it's the same clip" sans the personal insult is the appropriate response.
@@msmydo idc
😂😂😂😂😂its a rewind bro wakeuppppp
One side of nest is inclined. It needs be fixed. Very sad for babies....
The sound, when they smashed the ground ... simply awesome and so satisfying! Love it!!! 🥰👌👍
You're sick.
I like their attempts to turn around. It's funny to see. Goodye baby 😂
“Observe intently the birds of heaven; they do not sow seed or reap or gather into storehouses, yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not worth more than they are?”
Amen...Jesus is coming SOON.
???????
@@aimilios-christos363 hes coming again because he didn’t get it right the first time! Every generation says that stupid shit. Grow up
saçma, göksel baba yalan.
nonsense, heavenly father lie.
巣のバランスが悪いので風に晒され、寒さで弱ってしまったのでは？
Quá đẹp rồi chú chim mẹ
This bird is very beautiful, where is this bird?
she positively did push them out on purpose. If you watch, she lays on them, pushes them with her feet, looks back, and when they are hanging on, she pushes until they are gone. At one point I was wondering why she bought that huge bug and tried to choke them to death.
Nop. Her nest wasn't in a good place, and they the babies can eat insects.
Maybe try watching it again but this time with your eyes open.
And she did well cause they were incompetent, picky rats. She should have forced those insects down their greedy beaks or let them choke on it.
birds lie on their young dude, thats not to kill them
Must be birdman.
Akıllı kuş nasılda koruyor yavrularını maşallah Allah güç versin sana cicikuşum.
Yavruları yuvadan düşürdü :) sonunu izle
This looks like first time parents, the mother did not intentionally turf them out i don’t think..! Better look next year aye
She's like: "You don't want my food? Then get the f... out and hunt for your own."
She looks quite upset that there are no birds in her nest
That was Dad. There's two birds. Mom was refusing to feed them correctly and bring food too large. Dad did everything right. Mom rejected the babies and dad returned with food to an empty nest.. So sad.
Mom knows best good stuff loved the plopping
Good thing she threw those greedy little weasels out
Grate.! 👍
Dam, you could hear the "splat" of the first baby hitting the ground... SPLAT!
you can hear the baby hit the ground
This decided me to watch the video. I love it when weak birds are wacked.
Lmao 😢
lazy bums
@@BuxarooBanzai damn
Shhhhhhh… we didn’t hear anything…
Olhando no final do vídeo da pra ver que ela não queria saber desses filhotes e ela mesmo fez com que eles caíssem do seu ninho e com certeza eles foram comida de outros animais e ela não ligou pra eles tadinhos infelizmente isso aí faz parte da cadeia alimentar pra servir de comida para outros
Nao ela ficou chamando eles
,no ninho,,mae de primeira viagem,o ninho muito largo,ralo,,pouco reforco,,,tadinhos,,,Brasil
Какие не родивые родители
Que bom para outros animais... teve um rango fácil. kkkkkkkkk
Male się nie rozwijały i matka je wyrzucila
Marcia, eu culpo o maldito que, para ganhar dinheiro na internet, inclinou o ninho para a câmera pegar bem.
A mãe parecia inexperiente, mas o pai não.
Mas foi a inclinação que causou tudo, os filhotes sempre ficam sentados, com pescoço e boca bem retos, aí a comida desce direitinho. Eles não conseguiam equilíbrio, o mais fraco nem conseguia sentar, o outro até conseguia, mas imagina lutar pra tentar ficar na posição e ainda comer... comiam muito menos do que deveriam por causa dessa dificuldade e da inexperiência da mãe, ficaram super fracos.
Duvido que essa foi a única ninhada que o lixo matou por fama e grana.
It’s seems to be another bird, not the mother. The second one pushing them out has older backfeathers, birds are aggressive competitors
Linda 🙏
You captured excellent footage of parent birds caring for two chicks.
However, in careful review, it appears that the parent was providing equal care to both chicks, but most importantly, there's no evidence of intentional ejection by the parent.
The chick was lying on the rim of a nest with an increasingly slanted incline, and when the parent moved, the chick laying on the rim accidentally slipped out of the nest.
This was not intentional ejection at all, and the parent bird's behavior is consistent with that fact.
It's unfortunate, but does happen, and the parent would not have been able to retrieve that youngster back to the nest, though would have been able to care for it wherever it fell.
Another problem is your titling and description, even if intentional ejection had been the case.
These birds *cannot* smell "weakness."
Birds have somewhat limited olfactory senses, but one ability they actually do possess is sensing chemical signatures of *predatory* species nearby.
Avians in taxonomy Family Cathartidae, which includes vulture and condor, have the additional documented ability of olfactory sense to detect carrion while kettling, even thousands of feet up in the air, and miles from a carcass.
But, that's not at all what's happening here in this video, and I'm certain these are not vultures, but uncertain if or which species of bulbul this may be.
You've mischaracterized a behavior, claiming the parent can "smell fear." The parent can't because avians simply don't possess that ability.
*Therefore, your clip title and the claims made are wholly inaccurate and incorrect.*
If this actually had been a case of intentional ejection, which it wasn't, that would be an example of adaptive behaviors such as possible parasitism by another avian species, environmental quality impact on selective neglect or rejection by parents of chicks (relative abundance of food), reproductive "insurance," where a second chick is only cared for till/if the oldest chick survives, is healthy, and begins normal growth (at which time the second chick is ignored), or because a chick displays sickly/injured condition after hatching, wherein parents will then passively ignore or remove the chick.
So again, this was an accidental loss of a chick, and parent birds do not "smell" fear, weakness, nor anything else of the kind.
There is so much interesting content on YT which is mislabeled, inaccurately titled, and misrepresented, all because the person posting it isn't knowledgeable, didn't make an effort to properly describe the content, or does so, knowingly, for attention or revenue.
*STOP DOING THAT.*
Now that you've been provided with accurate information, you have an obligation to update the title and description.
Anything else isn't acceptable. Failing to properly label and describe, especially after it's been provided, is promoting inaccurate or fake information. Please don't do that.
Didn’t read your whole novella but the mother did well to throw those little weasels out they were too incompetent to eat, period.
@Felix S. it's only a "novella" if you have attention deficit issues and lack knowledge on avian behavior. Period.
@@EyeSeeThruYou Thanks for taking this comment seriously 😂❤️🤡
@@FelixS. You're welcome, and *Here's your sign!* 🃏🃏🃏🃏🃏
@@EyeSeeThruYou :)
Have a great day. Seriously: Impressive comment you posted there and I actually did read it with a lot of interest.
雛がもう少しでも成長して居れば、
残念な事にはならなかったか？😢。
ラストの悲しさには自然の厳しさを
見た気がした。
So sad 😞 😔
It is not harshness of nature but the nest was made with those strings on the first place to tilt towards the camera for us to see instead of making it level for the birds and chicks.
It could be pesticide in their food chain, nothing is to be discarded in this video, those babies look weak but that's not the case, to me is that they didn't grow as fast as they should, the bigger the stronger.
that thud when those babies fell to the ground LOL
Good Mom 🤣
Alot of splicing here, I think if we saw the entire situation we would see the chics not getting enough heat from mom bc dad isn't bringing her food that she needs to stay strong, cow birds are usually just awful parents, but mom is trying here but, heat is more important than food at this stage and there's no dad to help with that so mom let's her chics get too cold too often and that is why they're so weak
I agree...looks like alot of things wrong here. Better luck next time.
@@eRacer314 If they can't figure it out, then they won't reproduce and whatever is defective will be eliminated from the gene pool, eventually. Evolution is an amazing thing. Survival of the fittest.
It looked like the chicks keep flipping on their backs.
Good lesson for the naive Gaïa lovers.
Why is the nest held up by twine ? This nest was built by a human on purpose for the birds to fall out. Clearly the nest is made of twine, rigged up in a tree.
She didn’t mean to push them out as she came back with food confused, also if they throw the chicks out they’d grab them and toss them.
There were two different birds. Mom and dad. Mom was incorrectly feeding, feeding too large of insects, and not letting the food go when it was adequate. Dad was experienced. He feed properly, correct size, and always let go. Mom rejected babies by deliberately kicking them TWICE from the nest. Dad comes back with food to an empty nest, confused.
With larger beaked birds they'll throw the rejected babies with their beaks. In smaller species with smaller beaks they'll kick the babies backwards from the nest. I've seen both of these done before.
Hopefully mom does better with the next clutch of eggs. Hopefully she'll do better with selecting a nesting space, selecting the correct size foods to feed, and actually let's the food go. It's all learning.
The babies were too far gone and weakened by the point they were rejected. They'd have never survived. While sad, it's nature to cull the weak and insufficient and care for the strong and thriving. In the animal world there's no point wasting time and resources on a baby that's not likely to thrive. Even if it's the mother's inexperience that causes the failure to thrive. It creates a stronger genetic line to keep the species alive. They intentionally reject any baby that seems to be off in anyway or weak. Sad, but nature isn't always happy.
@@Lyzi.B don’t blame the mum. she did well cause they were incompetent, picky rats. She should have forced those insects down their greedy beaks or let them choke on it
Thats what happens if you are picky with food mom brings 🤭
like that big grasshopper ?