Midway 2019 | Landing on carrier scene

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 янв 2025

Комментарии • 177

  • @thegammingbolaschannel7529
    @thegammingbolaschannel7529 2 года назад +130

    I love how everything he practiced here at the beginning is necessary at the very end after sinking the second carrier. Such a nice way to reference the beginning scene, but if it happened both times irl, then it’s a cool nod

    • @Britishwolf89
      @Britishwolf89 2 года назад +8

      It's called set up and pay off. You set up a character by establishing them learning something new, something seemingly irrelevant at the time. Then later you have them save the day by using that skill. It's one of the oldest storytelling tricks in the book.

    • @TheMechanic554
      @TheMechanic554 2 года назад +3

      Chekhov’s Gun - details within a story or play will contribute to the overall narrative

  • @MikeJones-qn1gz
    @MikeJones-qn1gz 3 года назад +91

    Boy its a good thing he decided to do this on Dec 7th. Any other day and he would have been grounded and likely court martialed for being a jackass and risking his plane, his crew, and the carrier

    • @db5757
      @db5757 2 года назад

      @Mile Jones It’s a very good thing they didn’t ground or court martial Best. He was a major player in the battle of Midway.

  • @kevinwaters9135
    @kevinwaters9135 3 года назад +324

    Let's see him do it without CGI!

    • @CT-Woods
      @CT-Woods 3 года назад +58

      Apparently he did in real life.

    • @buddhagurung4181
      @buddhagurung4181 3 года назад

      rk

    • @o.o1018
      @o.o1018 3 года назад +19

      I'm sure if he did it, the Japanese would have copyright striked him for "crash" landing (get it?)

    • @rescue08jrgaming72
      @rescue08jrgaming72 3 года назад

      Bruh what it’s a movie

    • @Wirgah
      @Wirgah 3 года назад +4

      @@o.o1018 considering how stingy japanese companies are about copyright, this is accurate

  • @salsbery32
    @salsbery32 3 года назад +85

    A slip coming in from that altitude would carry enough speed to rip the hook right off that plane, or.. snap the line and behead any deck crew within range. But comon, everybody knows a Dauntless was as nible as a spitfire.

    • @SuperiorBrick
      @SuperiorBrick 2 года назад +2

      Don’t forget you want to hit 3 wire, not 1, 1 is a bad catch cause you put down too early lmao

    • @Rocky-69
      @Rocky-69 2 года назад +5

      this did happen in real life but I doubt it was that steep

    • @helicopter7997
      @helicopter7997 2 месяца назад

      Dauntless was light but armoured

  • @jonnyb70
    @jonnyb70 3 года назад +57

    ...he's not wrong.

  • @raymondyee2008
    @raymondyee2008 2 года назад

    Another reason why after so many years this movie is largely forgotten.

  • @SpoonyJeffUK
    @SpoonyJeffUK 3 года назад +15

    if you landed a that speed and height your about to be crushed by your own carrier

  • @baenana7666
    @baenana7666 3 года назад +18

    Another happy landing

  • @paulc6471
    @paulc6471 3 года назад +16

    What accent is this?! New York? Boston? Philly? The answer is YES.

    • @robertrafford6068
      @robertrafford6068 3 года назад +1

      North New Jersey. He's from Bayonne, NJ

    • @robertrafford6068
      @robertrafford6068 3 года назад +1

      He's pretty close. Live in JC

    • @darkspire91
      @darkspire91 3 года назад +3

      Hollywood thinks American accents are either hillbilly, ghetto or 'joisey' and nothing else.

    • @connorbranscombe6819
      @connorbranscombe6819 2 года назад

      @@darkspire91 Yeah stupid Hollywood, imagine giving a dude from New Jersey a New Jersey accent, that would be ridiculous!

  • @groller7295
    @groller7295 2 года назад +7

    He wasn’t lying it saved them at the end of the movie

    • @Rocky-69
      @Rocky-69 2 года назад +1

      and In real life war too.....

  • @captainalex0018
    @captainalex0018 2 года назад +3

    When you make stuff 500% more fancy:

  • @Sahilprakash1999
    @Sahilprakash1999 3 года назад +11

    0:52 McCluskey: better not crash that damn plane

  • @D.AKULA_TK208
    @D.AKULA_TK208 3 года назад +17

    One happy lading

  • @Jermster_91
    @Jermster_91 2 года назад +25

    Kind of odd when you think that he is telling his rear gunner that what he is doing might save his life. Like when is he gonna have a chance to fly.

    • @Montreal95
      @Montreal95 2 года назад +2

      What an odd comment. He's his rear gunner, so when Best's sharpening his skills he's improving the chances of survival for both of them

  • @williamphillips6049
    @williamphillips6049 3 года назад +11

    I'd be . . kind of like . . terrified out of my wits to go up in one of those things if the pilot wasn't Evel Knievel.

  • @edwardgozdowski834
    @edwardgozdowski834 2 года назад +6

    Top Gun, even back then!!! Marvelous.

  • @Giallo92
    @Giallo92 2 года назад +3

    Wondered why I never watched this movie. Now I know why.

  • @benmcccool0123
    @benmcccool0123 2 года назад

    I just realised that the destroyer in the foreground is a Sumner's class destroyer with it's distinctive dual 5in cannons

  • @karoldrozdz813
    @karoldrozdz813 3 года назад +2

    another happy landing!

  • @RobertdMacGregor
    @RobertdMacGregor 3 года назад +8

    Why is there a Gearing Class Destroyer here? Its a few years to early

    • @Amann0407
      @Amann0407 2 года назад

      It's actually either a Somers or a Porter class destroyer, both had twin mounts and predated Pearl Harbor, being built in the 1930s.

  • @Arty_Gamer
    @Arty_Gamer 2 года назад +1

    Every War Thunder Player every landing ever

  • @Subbers00
    @Subbers00 2 года назад

    Other airlines : smooth landing
    ryanair : 1:07

  • @w0mbatina
    @w0mbatina 4 года назад +71

    Oh my fucking god, AT LEAST USE THE GODDAMN AIRBRAKES

    • @shodanhideo8286
      @shodanhideo8286 3 года назад +8

      brakes are for cowards

    • @TheRocketdrive
      @TheRocketdrive 3 года назад +32

      with a dead engine you dont have the hydralics to pull them in. The side slip trick is true, though the exact path taken is extremely risky. It's a case of valid on paper but probably never done, or if done never acceptable to the IRL forces.

    • @bomber6258
      @bomber6258 3 года назад +4

      @@TheRocketdrive Casully pulls out hand pump, opens up the intrument panel, sticks it into the hydralics, starts pumping the air brake open against the wind manually with guarentteed leaks, all the while trying to glide the plane down onto a moving carrier deck. lol

    • @joshm3257
      @joshm3257 3 года назад +2

      how do you use them without a engine smart man

    • @bomber6258
      @bomber6258 3 года назад +4

      @@joshm3257 Well if you read my comment, I would manually actuate the hydralics with aa hand pump, which is a humorous attempt to still use dive brakes when landing

  • @satheeshs3646
    @satheeshs3646 3 года назад +10

    Aircrew is able to hear each other without radio???

    • @Ryan_Christopher
      @Ryan_Christopher 2 года назад

      Crew Intercom is separate from radio.

    • @pinchespiderman
      @pinchespiderman 2 года назад

      Microphones are at throat, which cuts down on external noise

  • @tloco28
    @tloco28 3 года назад +17

    Good lord, the dumbing down of our youth by Hollywood strikes again.

  • @kiyan110
    @kiyan110 2 года назад +2

    Let's see Paul Allen's landing

  • @Pilotsfp
    @Pilotsfp 3 года назад +9

    Text book forward slip

  • @Mofoindustries
    @Mofoindustries 2 года назад

    Now let’s see Paul Allen’s landing

  • @joserolandoredondobonilla9332
    @joserolandoredondobonilla9332 2 года назад

    1:02 bro imagine if the pilot didnt actually puil the plane up in time

  • @markogronfors3826
    @markogronfors3826 2 года назад

    oh boy and the cows will fly.

  • @pinchespiderman
    @pinchespiderman 2 года назад +1

    Late June 1942, San Diego U.S.A
    Lt (jg.) Hunt, " 710,556... 710,557,...710,558..."
    "Hey Lieutenant Hunt! Did you hear the news? Your old carrier was in a huge battle!"
    Hunt, "710,5- #&§%€¥Ω !!!"

  • @dkseegz
    @dkseegz 2 года назад +2

    LSO is pissed about this one

    • @pinchespiderman
      @pinchespiderman 2 года назад +1

      Mechanics too I'd bet.
      "Aww Screw you, Mr. Best!"

  • @nolracthorne
    @nolracthorne 3 года назад +18

    Pretty movie, leaves out lots of real history.

    • @williamphillips6049
      @williamphillips6049 3 года назад +7

      This movie prides itself on it's accuracy . .
      What did they leave out?

    • @nolracthorne
      @nolracthorne 3 года назад +5

      @@williamphillips6049 Lets start with no F4-F Wildcat fighters in the movie. Best and his rear gunner never claimed to have shot down a fighter during the battle. Those are only two I can name off the top of my head.

    • @williamphillips6049
      @williamphillips6049 3 года назад +1

      @@nolracthorne I just recently saw a documentary that explained the "strategy" used by wildcats when dealing with Zeros was to just get away.
      It was stated that although tough and durable; they were so slow and cumbersome that they weren't a match at all for far better designed and nimble Zeros . .
      At least during the early part of the war.
      . . 'And then we went from that to the "Great Marianas Turkey Shoot".
      I know we got better and better with our plane designs and the Japanese suffered from poor judgment and bad luck.
      I also know we managed to get our hands on a captured Zero in the Alaskan campaign; an enormous advantage.
      I suppose these factors can account for this sudden reversal from the best plane in the war to big fat targets.

    • @dairyprods
      @dairyprods 2 года назад +6

      @@nolracthorne dont remember best or his rear gunner ever shooting down a plane during the battle of midway in the movie

    • @nolracthorne
      @nolracthorne 2 года назад

      @@dairyprods Here you go plus on the attack on the Gilbert Islands earlier his rear gunner shoots down an enemy fighter ruclips.net/video/hPVPbnF2iq8/видео.html. If you don't want to click on a link just look up the attack on the Hiryu from the 2019 movie. Also in the scene where he bombs the Hiryu he releases the bomb at almost deck height, during the actual battle it was at 1000 feet.

  • @johnforealdoe8999
    @johnforealdoe8999 3 года назад +11

    The actor playing Best SUCKS lol

    • @russell5078084
      @russell5078084 3 года назад +1

      Bet you didn't think so when he was on the show Game of thrones. Or any of the other numerous parts he has played.

    • @StarflightProductions
      @StarflightProductions 2 года назад +3

      Hey I don't think Ed Skrien did all that bad.

    • @albay543
      @albay543 2 года назад +1

      I think he did very well

    • @skunkape2
      @skunkape2 2 года назад +1

      Yep. He's easy to dislike with that annoying arrogance.

    • @johnforealdoe8999
      @johnforealdoe8999 2 года назад +1

      @@skunkape2 Just seemed like a very forced performance.

  • @AKAviation97
    @AKAviation97 2 года назад +34

    Coming in that high he would pick up a lot of speed even with dive brakes and flaps deployed. Approach speed on the dauntless is 70 kts. With the angle he's coming in at he'd be reaching speeds of 200kts. Nowhere near slow enough to put it down on a carrier. Fake as balls

    • @Ryan_Christopher
      @Ryan_Christopher 2 года назад +4

      There's a lot of time-cutting in the film. In Real Time he could shave-off a lot of speed with multiple side slips not shown in this scene. Still bit fast for a 70-knot final approach but also nowhere near 200 knots anymore.

    • @porkhunt8798
      @porkhunt8798 2 года назад +4

      its a movie

    • @ernesthill4017
      @ernesthill4017 2 года назад

      It's Hollywood. Everything is fake

  • @proudamerican183
    @proudamerican183 3 года назад +4

    The only thing I'm wondering is if this is true to life or just Hollywood bs.

    • @StarflightProductions
      @StarflightProductions 2 года назад +2

      I don't think it happened, but for someone like Richard Best, it wouldn't surprise me

    • @albay543
      @albay543 2 года назад

      Watch maxsmodel's midway review he talks about how this is not possible, he talks about it at the near end of the video if you wanna skip the review

  • @skeletonjam
    @skeletonjam 2 года назад

    would they just chuck the plane in the sea or attempt to fix it?

    • @ditto9300
      @ditto9300 2 года назад

      They can drop the plane into the hanger bay and fix any issues the plane had.

  • @m.s.769
    @m.s.769 2 года назад +22

    Wow. The over-confident, gum-smacking, arrogant American aviator is something I have never seen on the big screen before.

    • @raymondyee2008
      @raymondyee2008 2 года назад

      I think the U.S naval academy should use this as an example of how NOT to be a pilot.

  • @HihiHahaEntertainment
    @HihiHahaEntertainment 2 года назад

    Летишь такой на самолёте, а как тормозить:)

  • @andreare8767
    @andreare8767 2 года назад

    filem yg sangat seru paling ku suka

  • @wnguyen4092
    @wnguyen4092 2 года назад

    Jake Paul of ww2

  • @rzgamefactory
    @rzgamefactory 2 года назад

    I do in warthunder

  • @Topper_Harley68
    @Topper_Harley68 2 года назад

    Yeah right.

  • @bluetopguitar1104
    @bluetopguitar1104 2 года назад +2

    Disappointing movie. The action scenes are good CGI I guess

  • @Vito_993
    @Vito_993 3 года назад +2

    Ugh the battle and the fight was crazy as is in real life , why do they have to add this fake crap over the top moments

  • @Pastrami_femboy137
    @Pastrami_femboy137 2 года назад

    War thunder Landing.

  • @cuda7133
    @cuda7133 2 года назад +1

    Such an unrealistic scene... hard to watch

  • @louannwatt4447
    @louannwatt4447 2 года назад +2

    How is it he can go below the flight deck then just hop up and stop? Bad movie. Paid good money to see it and told everyone I saw to save there money. If you watch at home at least you can always change channels. Typical Hollywood BS.

  • @ЛюбительД
    @ЛюбительД 3 года назад +3

    Супер американские солдаты))) точно такое же недавно делали в Афганистане 😂😂😂

  • @ronmorgan1906
    @ronmorgan1906 2 года назад +1

    Bull shit bull shit bull shit. I knew there was a reason why I never watched this movie. I flew fighters in the USAF. This is just bull shit. An SBD Dauntless is NOT a fighter first of all and shining your ass like this (if you could) would end up with the pilot getting boarded and losing their wings. It's just not necessary.

    • @raymondyee2008
      @raymondyee2008 2 года назад

      Because the SBD here is CGI they can cheat like hell. Try that on an airworthy SBD (which is super rare to find) and see what happens.

  • @FaLaTiCi
    @FaLaTiCi 2 года назад

    xD

  • @Envy_me94
    @Envy_me94 2 года назад +2

    Awful movie, it has the typical American war hero chewing gum and treating WW2 like its fun.

    • @Ryan_Christopher
      @Ryan_Christopher 2 года назад

      This was a short time before the Pearl Harbor attack. So technically not "WW2" yet in their case. Still plenty of gum-chewing allowed.

    • @captainrusca
      @captainrusca Год назад

      Nah

  • @burakturan5733
    @burakturan5733 2 года назад

    bullshit . any pilot cannot do thing like that . or he will be fired

  • @Gregwing
    @Gregwing 2 года назад +2

    One of the worst remakes of a movie ever.

  • @deano2160
    @deano2160 3 года назад +15

    Cheesy and hell and terrible acting. Film sucked unfortunately.

    • @weksheddweller
      @weksheddweller 2 года назад

      would you take this or Michael Bay's Pearl Harbor? :)

  • @andyappley7902
    @andyappley7902 3 года назад +3

    Where do I begin with this dross ?!? Typical Hollywood rubbish,up there with Fury for inaccuracies,implausible action etc etc !!! If these films are meant as a tribute, MAKE THEM ACCURATE !!!!

    • @raymondyee2008
      @raymondyee2008 2 года назад

      Also WW2 war movies are getting very boring to see never mind if some are remakes like this.

  • @mediapeikko5900
    @mediapeikko5900 2 года назад

    What a cocky acting.

  • @Watkinsstudio
    @Watkinsstudio 2 года назад

    Total crap.

  • @ammatathammavongsa9478
    @ammatathammavongsa9478 2 года назад

    The fallacious swamp analogously judge because note atypically beam about a innate history. awake, obsequious tip

  • @skunkape2
    @skunkape2 2 года назад

    Is it that hard to make an entertaining and accurate war movie? This was about as disappointing as the Pearl Harbor movie.

    • @raymondyee2008
      @raymondyee2008 2 года назад

      At least the 1976 “Midway” was better than this.