musicians in his genre: "Stop no you can't do that one of the rules is that you have to stick with tried and tested progressions. bill wurtz: "How bout I do, anyway?"
I feel like Bill doesn’t get enough credit for the crazy intricate ways he composes these pieces, people just sort of see it as “meme music” but I’m glad Charles is showing how cool and complex it is!
I had never realized just how good Bill is at writing music. I definitely noticed his writing was great and creative and flowed well, but holy cow. I had no clue.
Yeah he’s a music theory expert but there are hundreds of thousands of those in the world. What makes him brilliant are the magnificent things he uses that theory to help him say.
Me: *ANGRY AT STUFF* Bill: I'm riding a pony, into the sunset, everything's green and gold, so I'm not in Hell yet Me: *now happier for some stupid ass reason*
Seeing someone who understands music theory randomly pause a song and go "woah" for reasons entirely beyond me, is what fascinates me about the subject.
There are moments like this all over the world through many fields. I had the pleasure of experiencing it for myself when I started looking into visual astronomy. I went to an Observatory for a Valentine's Day evening and it wasn't like the Atacama observatory or Mauna Loa or anything fancy, a large scope and a few professional amateurs with their own super expensive hobby scopes. So I was looking into the eyepieces of several observations, galaxies, nebulae, etc. but it's all quite plain - not like a hubble picture or anything, which is what most people expect to see and are quite disappointed when they see otherwise. But I looked into one that was pointed at the Jewelbox Globular Cluster and I gasped audibly and the hobbyist went "Yesss!!! Hahah! That's it. That's what we like to hear!" And my enthusiasm was matched by hers. And I was saying "there's so many stars! Are they all actually close together or is that just how we see them from this perspective?" And my date at this point is quite miffed but I am just vibing at the amazing work this person has done. I was pointing out to other people like "hey come look at this one, you see how it looks like..." And the hobbyist and myself were just... Ahhh man
It's interesting how Bill uses modulation to highlight the surreal comedy - where there's a tonal whiplash in the lyrics, it's accompanied by a *literal* tonal whiplash in the harmony.
Im literally only 3 minutes in, and I've just got to say; This is how music theory and music classes should be taught at uni. Hearing how excited you are about what's happening in the music makes us (the student in this situation) so much more excited to learn why what's happening is so cool. Its a really engaging method and Charles does this so well. Bravo bravo, I really love these break downs.
Yeah, thats what separates a teacher from like, a mentor. My favorite moment with my favorite teacher, my English Teacher, was a moment where he was vulnerable and comfortable enough with us to share some very personal and close to the heart poetry with us, and he cried because the emotions he put into them were that powerful, and that he was willing to share such passionate works with us made me feel like I was with someone who really cared about not only subject we were in but also us as people. He was just so happy and passionate when we did any kind of creative writing and he always shared his writing with us as well and he just felt so, human, and it made me want to do nothing more than learn more. I’ve never had that feeling with a teacher before that and never have since.
I’d love it if you did La De Da De Da De Da De Day-oh. I’ve always considered it his most functional “pop” song but it’s still full of crazy weird shit.
bill wurtz is my favorite musician and I’ve always wanted to write like him, but I’d simultaneously have to know everything about music and also forget everything about music to do so
i dont think he consciously does all this crazy music theory stuff when he writes the music, i get the impression he just has an idea and is like "oh this would sound cool" and then does that
@@FirstnameLastname-nd9wx oh, he certainly knows what he's doing. He might not consciously use theory to create the music, just like highly original writers don't consciously think about how they construct their sentences. But they have a vast vocabulary to draw from, as well as a very well developed sense of how things work together. There's evidence that he is highly educated in music.
Not really like the picture of it, but the colors are very right! In "at the airport terminal" is a great example of the colors and the way they blend and mold together is perfect with the video imagery (I have synesthesia)
The Five-Poem by C. Cornell (9:37): "Putting a five in front a modulation just helps it flow to that new key. And you see that we're only a half step away from where we wanna be. And we end on this five but it's a five in the key of A flat, we wanna be in G. So what does Bill do? He just drops it."
@@caleb2050 I have no problem understanding this and I've never taken a lesson, they'll be fine. You just need to know basic chords and the idea of a key lol
Al the Alligator nah you also need to know how to build chords and chord functionality if you wanna understand what bill wurtz is doing. It’s a big jump from knowing scales to understanding chord movements.
Deep Moticons the way schools curriculums are design are to be inclusive. Not all kids move at the same pace. You are overestimating how much music classes are able to cover especially for kids without backgrounds in music. This type of harmony composition isn’t something I would teach kids without first going over basic harmony and then basic jazz harmony, which might be a semester class if I wanted my students to get a firm grasp of the concepts. It is impressive composition and most high school students - unless self motivated and learning on their own time - are not ready for these concepts just from school curriculum music.
From the little I’ve looked up from him, he’s pretty intentional about his sound and theoretical approach to stuff. Hard to make complex harmonic structures sound like pop without the know how lol
Just purely from a musical perspective is how he is looking at it, not specifically in a piano frame of mind. He just happens to know piano and so uses it to demonstrate
Which do you think I'm eating for dinner tonight. I'll tell you one thing for sure, it's not this rabbit food. Why? Because this *points to salad* will just leave me craving this *points to pizza*
When he explained the lyrics in a Genius video, he said "That's the theory about bridges. Just get lost and find your way back." It's so cool knowing that he's both referring to the lyrics and the music when he said that!
See. No one takes him seriously and discounts him as just a meme writer, but he has an amazing understanding of music theory and applies it in a way that is unique to his style. He doesn't fall under any musical style enough to call it said styles. His music needs a style name of its own.
I've loved Bill Wurtz for ages and discovered Charles fairly recently. I thought "Hey I wonder if Charles knows about Bill, it seems like he'd have a lot to say about his musical style" and Hey presto as if the stars themselves have aligned here are two Charles x Bill videos and I've never been so satisfied.
You would as a music student or some who frequently listens to music- though you wouldn't have the language to describe what you're expecting, the way a music student would.
Seconding this, please consider doing a video in this style on The Road! It is super extra when it comes to the kind of stuff you discussed in this video, lol. Here's the song: ruclips.net/video/YZ7xgZXta8M/видео.html
Me, watching this knowing literally no music theory: *nods along thoughtfully* Yes I definitely also see these things I absolutely know what’s going on
Charles: *Passionately explaining what’s happening* Me: *Have no idea what he’s talking about* Also me: *Pretending to understand what he’s talking about* Oh yeah that is fascinating, that explains a lot
This is something I've noticed about theory channels: The human ear has an incredible capacity to understand what they hear in spite of your knowledge. Kinda like how it is easier to run than to play QWOP, it is easier for your ear to understand the music than it is for your brain to understand it.
Peter Fitzsimmons If by “understand” you mean “enjoy”, then yeah your ear can understand faster than your brain can. But if you by “understand” you mean “able to identify and comprehend the intricacies”, then you need your brain for that.
I also don't know shit, but having listened to music since forever and him making analogies like "home base" and such make it easy to follow along with his enthusiasm.
Yea uh I have no clue wtf he's talking about but I love Bill Wurtz. He's saying it's a G buts it's a 4? Then he says the next is a Emj or something but also a 6? I'm lost but I don't care
7:58 I dont know music that much but I recognise that chord progression anywhere. It's a very common progression used in Chinese/Taiwanese music; so common that it basically defines the "genre".
typical western music uses 12 notes total, and most scales have 7 notes, spaced in different ways to create the scale's identity. you can use the notes of the scale as guidance to creating chords. certain chords, called 'triads', take one of the scales notes, another note two scale-notes higher, and a third thats another two scale-notes higher. the triad is named based on the beginning note you used in relation to the scale's starting note, scaling from 1-7, often displayed in Roman numerals (I, II, III, IV, V, VI, and VII). the chord progression at 7:58 cycles through the second, fifth, and first chords ( ii, V, I ) of the E-flat major scale. this type of progression is very common in all kinds of music, more in western and classical. the resolution from a fifth chord to a first chord has a feeling of resonance and wholeness, and a strong sense of tension, into release. its called a 'perfect cadence'.
I’ve always thought that Bill Wurtz’s ability to genre-bend as well as the eccentricity he has in his lyrics and writing is very evocative of the music from Phineas and Ferb? If that makes sense. Same energy
Someone needs to write a jukebox musical out of Bill's songs. Some of them are incredibly catchy and you can easily picture choreography. Not to mention the music is just fantastic and criminally unknown.
Another thing thats suprisingly interesting is that the song modulates DOWN to the bridge. Modulating down is pretty rare, most songs modulate up to add energy.
@@seblat1086 "And the people who work in my office went on vacation, 'Cause they say I haven't been paying them very much anymore." It's in the bridge, after the pony bit.
I never really gave bill the credit for being such a masterful composer. His randomness really hides his talent in a way (not really, as a whole package he’s brilliant, but when you mostly notice that he’s “so random and silly” it’s easy to not notice just how musically adventurous he is)
Yes! The visualization at 11:59 is great and something you’ve been building towards for a while!! Keep it up! I think there are even other ways to show what’s happening!
I just found my new favorite music related channel. When you explained the shift to A Major, I was like... wait isn't that a 5 of 5? It is! IT SO COOL. It is interesting how he basically just skipped the D Maj chord entirely, but it makes sense in a way. Super neat random moments where the music theory I learned actually happens! I love those!
Fantastic explanation. Musical notation is something I can never quite wrap my head around, for some reason, but the way you explain the meaning of the chords and demonstrate them on your piano makes it clear as water.
Please please do "at the airport terminal"! The verses have such a straightforward melody that when the craziness is introduced later, the contrast is very pronounced, and then little bits of harmonic weirdness get inserted back into the harmony during the verse. It's like, airport terminals should be this simple thing, but they're always stressful and weird, and you never get to have the simple experience you feel like you should have.
I really don't understand any of this, or barely, but it's just entertaining somehow. It makes sense, or feels like it does, without me actually understanding. So cool.
What next?!
YES
more wurtz! preferably and the day goes on
Music Theory on the soundtrack of the game Cuphead
history of japan 🙏
How about Faster and his music?
Most musicians: regular, time-tested chord progressions.
Bill Wurtz: "Oh, nothing, I was just *shaving my pianoooo* "
i literally sung that last part internally in his voice
Its been growin hair he gotta shave it
This made me laugh harder than it should have. Ha ha ha ha!
Hahaha omg. I love Bill's work so fucking much.
Bill: I was just killing time, I was just partying in the flowerrrr
"People expertly explaining weird music" is the favorite youtube genre I didn't know existed.
I agree. I don't even know what he's talking about half the time and it's still great to watch someone love something as much as he does
You could make a religion out of this
@@AeonAxisProductions No, don’t
I have truly no idea what any of this means, but man it's fun to hear people get excited and compliment others!
@@dr.whippersnatch7200 So wholesome, I love it :)
I think Charles is literally making a religion out of this
you could make a religion out of this
Yes, do
*Yes do*
Chadivich no... actually yes
You could make a religion out of this.. No don't
musicians in his genre: tried and tested progressions
bill wurtz: we are now in the key of :)
musicians in his genre: "Stop no you can't do that one of the rules is that you have to stick with tried and tested progressions.
bill wurtz: "How bout I do, anyway?"
Musicians: "This is the most common one and sounds nice."
Bill Wurtz: *Writing it on his 'what NOT to do list'* "Oh, alright."
@@SmaMan i dont think musicians in his genre say that shit lol
the key of smile
The key of :D
11:27 “We find ourselves a half-step away from where we want to be” sounds like it would fit perfectly as a Bill Wurtz lyric.
That does sound like something Bill Wurtz would write
I feel like Bill doesn’t get enough credit for the crazy intricate ways he composes these pieces, people just sort of see it as “meme music” but I’m glad Charles is showing how cool and complex it is!
He is a true artist ...and a legend like nikola tesla
And Legends never need credit
They just leave wonderful peice behind them...
@@sahilssk4244 it ok
@@Taizunx thanks
I had never realized just how good Bill is at writing music. I definitely noticed his writing was great and creative and flowed well, but holy cow. I had no clue.
Giving people credit based on what mindless masses do is like looking through the wrong end of a telescope.
Most people: Look at those edits!
Charles: LOOK AT THAT CHORD PROGRESSION
*listen to
Luigi_125 *View with your ears
@@createnewhandle_ bruh
Look at those mounds
You could say it's *EVEN CRAAAZIER SPACE DUST*
This Bill Wurtz/Charles Cornell series is what i neeeeeed
Oscar Cervarich !!!^^^
THISSS
I completely agree
Bill hasn't posted since March of last year :(
YESSSS
Bill either knows music theory so intricately that he can break rules at will or he knows nothing and just does what sounds good
I could see this stuff as intuituvely made ... But by someone who has conventional harmonies stuck in his mind very firmly
Bill is a very talented, trained musician who knows the rules so well he can break them.
There's a whole page on his website with jazz standard improv so he certainly knows what he's doing
@@RusNad :0
Yeah he’s a music theory expert but there are hundreds of thousands of those in the world. What makes him brilliant are the magnificent things he uses that theory to help him say.
Me: *ANGRY AT STUFF*
Bill: I'm riding a pony, into the sunset, everything's green and gold, so I'm not in Hell yet
Me: *now happier for some stupid ass reason*
Because yoymu see something peaceful and you be happpy
We can make a religion out of this
@@applicableapple3991 No, don’t.
@@faithful2025 how bout I do, anyway~
Lol, I read this comment just as he got to that part in the song!
Seeing someone who understands music theory randomly pause a song and go "woah" for reasons entirely beyond me, is what fascinates me about the subject.
I think you perfectly worded my feeling through this video lol. It does make the song more interesting to me
Understanding some music theory and hearing him go woah at the same time is similarly surreal
There are moments like this all over the world through many fields.
I had the pleasure of experiencing it for myself when I started looking into visual astronomy.
I went to an Observatory for a Valentine's Day evening and it wasn't like the Atacama observatory or Mauna Loa or anything fancy, a large scope and a few professional amateurs with their own super expensive hobby scopes.
So I was looking into the eyepieces of several observations, galaxies, nebulae, etc. but it's all quite plain - not like a hubble picture or anything, which is what most people expect to see and are quite disappointed when they see otherwise.
But I looked into one that was pointed at the Jewelbox Globular Cluster and I gasped audibly and the hobbyist went "Yesss!!! Hahah! That's it. That's what we like to hear!"
And my enthusiasm was matched by hers. And I was saying "there's so many stars! Are they all actually close together or is that just how we see them from this perspective?" And my date at this point is quite miffed but I am just vibing at the amazing work this person has done. I was pointing out to other people like "hey come look at this one, you see how it looks like..." And the hobbyist and myself were just... Ahhh man
Charles: "This is not a jazz song"
Morgan Freeman as Narrator: "But it was a jazz song..."
😂
But alas, the song was jazz
This is the best comment I've ever read.
alternatively, ron howard as narrator
Musical Blueberry haha well thank you
Super cool!
Thanks for bringing me here
Just watched the St. Helens vid, glad that you found this
Hey it’s the drummer guy, cool
Didn't think I'd see you here
Ello
Bill Wurtz’s chords are basically like:
“Yeah this sounds normal and honestly pretty good and WOAH THERE BUCKO why does this work?”
as someone who's transcribed some of his chord progressions, this is correct
It's interesting how Bill uses modulation to highlight the surreal comedy - where there's a tonal whiplash in the lyrics, it's accompanied by a *literal* tonal whiplash in the harmony.
Yes. This is the comment that I needed to see.
It’s probably bc he writes his lyrics at the exact same time as he’s writing the music, which he said he does. They’re inextricable from each other
Bill's music goes on tangents just like his lyrics.
Oh boy you should check out his questions page on his website
Im literally only 3 minutes in, and I've just got to say; This is how music theory and music classes should be taught at uni. Hearing how excited you are about what's happening in the music makes us (the student in this situation) so much more excited to learn why what's happening is so cool. Its a really engaging method and Charles does this so well. Bravo bravo, I really love these break downs.
Yeah, thats what separates a teacher from like, a mentor. My favorite moment with my favorite teacher, my English Teacher, was a moment where he was vulnerable and comfortable enough with us to share some very personal and close to the heart poetry with us, and he cried because the emotions he put into them were that powerful, and that he was willing to share such passionate works with us made me feel like I was with someone who really cared about not only subject we were in but also us as people. He was just so happy and passionate when we did any kind of creative writing and he always shared his writing with us as well and he just felt so, human, and it made me want to do nothing more than learn more. I’ve never had that feeling with a teacher before that and never have since.
I’d love it if you did La De Da De Da De Da De Day-oh. I’ve always considered it his most functional “pop” song but it’s still full of crazy weird shit.
"When did all the windmills start to turn so slow?" is such a Bill Wurtz lyric, right on the verge of sounding deep but still sounds weird.
I can’t go home.
That one's my favorite, I'd really like that to be the next one!!!
Please do it!!
The part at the end where he goes "la dee-da da-dee dum dee-da diddly dway-ah diddy dum dwee-ay" always sticks with me
Bill's music is just an entire new genre called "Bill". I can recognize any of his music anywhere, it is so unique.
Bill Wirtz is the type of guy that would write a song about a hurricane then change the subject to vanilla ice cream
And then giraffes
That is a perfect way to explain his songs.
@@cactiman6593 And then cacti
@@cactiman6593 and then kitties
To Bill Wurtz, they are the same
Me: Does not know anything about music theory or music in general
Also me during this video: oh yes yes Bill music big brain
Oh yeah definitely he drops it he drops it
Yes yes he drops it and modulates A and he does the bridge, for sure, indubitably.
Jazz musicians are like an invasive species to other genres. They've got no natural predators or competition.
Classical musicians: *scoffing*
Hate to burst your bubble but hasn't jazz been a dying genre for a while now?
@@jackaguirre8576 not really, it's just become more niche
Oh shit, by liking Bill wurtz did I accidentally start liking jazz?? Fuck!
@@jackaguirre8576 Quite the opposite. Jazz influences are popping up everywhere now, it just depends on the subgenre of Jazz.
bill wurtz is my favorite musician and I’ve always wanted to write like him, but I’d simultaneously have to know everything about music and also forget everything about music to do so
i dont think he consciously does all this crazy music theory stuff when he writes the music, i get the impression he just has an idea and is like "oh this would sound cool" and then does that
@Theanonymous memester wants to do it but not that bad
@@FirstnameLastname-nd9wx oh, he certainly knows what he's doing. He might not consciously use theory to create the music, just like highly original writers don't consciously think about how they construct their sentences. But they have a vast vocabulary to draw from, as well as a very well developed sense of how things work together. There's evidence that he is highly educated in music.
@@martinpaddle fax he definitely understands some intricacies he's doing
@@FirstnameLastname-nd9wx
Kinda, he's definitely a master of theory but he bends it according to what he thinks sounds cool.
Id imagine that if a person with synesthesia listened to Bill Wurtzs music without seeing the video they would imagine the same type of imagery
Can confirm. You can also try mushrooms + low dose dxm which is basically the same thing with good headphones xD
@@kylezo hmm yes i will encourage drug usage
TheGraveAccent i mean his name IS kyle stoner
@@kylezo his videos are what it’s like when I’m falling asleep
Not really like the picture of it, but the colors are very right! In "at the airport terminal" is a great example of the colors and the way they blend and mold together is perfect with the video imagery (I have synesthesia)
Bill wanted to express himself and decided to create a new genre of music to do it, respect
The Five-Poem by C. Cornell (9:37):
"Putting a five in front a modulation
just helps it flow to that new key.
And you see that we're only a half step away
from where we wanna be.
And we end on this five but it's a five in the key of A flat,
we wanna be in G.
So what does Bill do?
He just drops it."
This comment deserves more upvotes
@@ariehchrem3067 Reddit much?
@@endershr000m3 shut up
Alexnader Hamiltoon lmao
He just dropped that D
Them: Jacob Collier
Me, an intellectual: *Bill Wurtz*
Why not both?
they're both amazing, they'd probably be friends
@@finesse5820 Remember when Jacob Collier had a public Liked Videos lists and they include Bill Wurtz's videos?
@@PentameronSV his subscriptions are still public and he's subscribed to bill
Me, a musician who lives under a rock: wait, Charles, who are these Jacob Collier and Bill Wurtz's which you speak of? 🙆♂️.
I wish they taught his music in schools. Music would expand so much if children were exposed to it at a young age.
it might be a little too complex to teach to young children, probably a basic understanding of jazz harmony is necessary first.
@@caleb2050 I have no problem understanding this and I've never taken a lesson, they'll be fine. You just need to know basic chords and the idea of a key lol
Al the Alligator nah you also need to know how to build chords and chord functionality if you wanna understand what bill wurtz is doing. It’s a big jump from knowing scales to understanding chord movements.
Deep Moticons the way schools curriculums are design are to be inclusive. Not all kids move at the same pace. You are overestimating how much music classes are able to cover especially for kids without backgrounds in music. This type of harmony composition isn’t something I would teach kids without first going over basic harmony and then basic jazz harmony, which might be a semester class if I wanted my students to get a firm grasp of the concepts. It is impressive composition and most high school students - unless self motivated and learning on their own time - are not ready for these concepts just from school curriculum music.
I started learning jazz at 12, 2 years later still learning
Charles throughout this entire video:
"Yeah this is pretty standard"
*listens to 2 more seconds of the song*
"What did i just hear"
"I'm a princess" is legit my mew favorite song on earth. Might be a fun one for a breakdown, especially with all the modulation near the end.
it's a gem, truly
it's amazing!
Charles: “so this progression has [effect] because [complex music theory stuff]”
B. Wurtz: ”i don't know, just tryin' to be reasonable”
Nice
Idk man, I probably dropped a cheese stick on the piano and thought it sounded okay enough
From the little I’ve looked up from him, he’s pretty intentional about his sound and theoretical approach to stuff. Hard to make complex harmonic structures sound like pop without the know how lol
@@MostLikelyMortal, indeed. Wurtz must be very aware of what he's doing. But the man got quite a character.
@@MostLikelyMortal he is but when he explains his own work, he downplays it immensely
Bill Wurtz x Jacob Collier collab
The world needs it
I need it
Bill Wurtz x Jacob Collier × Charles Cornell I would cryyyyy
i would die happy
I’m honestly not ready
That would be *EPIC!*
bill has openly stated he hates jacob collier and would never work with him
Charles: *explains complicated musical jargon*
Me: hmm yes the music here is made out of music
"That b flat minor 7 is functioning like a 2 in a 251"
Um...
@@sheridan5175 I recognize all of these words, but not in this order
@@JeepnHeel I made it up I think
Me, who knows literally nothing about piano:
*Interesting*
Lol same
Just purely from a musical perspective is how he is looking at it, not specifically in a piano frame of mind. He just happens to know piano and so uses it to demonstrate
Me, knowing stuff about piano and still lost:
Interesting…
my mom said bill wurtz "isn't music" so im showing her this
Now that's where she's wrong
Disown her.
Why would she even say that? He's basically Steely Dan but funnier
Wow, I listened to Slipknot and Meshuggah to shock my parents...now it is Bill Wurtz. Interesting! What will be my kids shocking me with?
does she even know what the definition of music is?
Charles: now I want you to listen for the inner voicings.
RUclips ad: Pizza or salad?
Pizza
Vshred add? 😂
Which do you think I'm eating for dinner tonight. I'll tell you one thing for sure, it's not this rabbit food. Why? Because this *points to salad* will just leave me craving this *points to pizza*
Salad or fries, the two most different foods in the universe.
Also, "inner voicings" played on the top of the chords... So not really inner at all.
bill wurtz has successfully created the most complex coordinated chaos
When he explained the lyrics in a Genius video, he said "That's the theory about bridges. Just get lost and find your way back." It's so cool knowing that he's both referring to the lyrics and the music when he said that!
Bill Wurtz's style is like a mixture of lofi, jazz and musical music
Musical music yes
@@oliviergagnon8719 like showtunes
Seeing his upload is honestly the most exciting thing in quarantine
Right?
Agreed
IKR
Ur still in quarantine?
How is this 3 hrs ago when it says this was uploaded 2 hrs ago 😳
I have no idea what anything he's saying means, but his excitement is extremely contagious
Bill said his favourite genre of music is "normal" so that's probably what his genre is
See. No one takes him seriously and discounts him as just a meme writer, but he has an amazing understanding of music theory and applies it in a way that is unique to his style. He doesn't fall under any musical style enough to call it said styles. His music needs a style name of its own.
what makes you think people don't appreciate his music properly?
Bill: I'm avoiding the IRS for evading taxation
Me: *Straight vibing*
I've loved Bill Wurtz for ages and discovered Charles fairly recently. I thought "Hey I wonder if Charles knows about Bill, it seems like he'd have a lot to say about his musical style" and Hey presto as if the stars themselves have aligned here are two Charles x Bill videos and I've never been so satisfied.
Charles: See you'd expect this to go to a II V I.
Me: No, no I didn't.
You would as a music student or some who frequently listens to music- though you wouldn't have the language to describe what you're expecting, the way a music student would.
@@SakuraMoonflower I wanna be a music student but I have not found any way to learn to play my keyboard
3:16
"Listen again"
I suddenly get an ad with trump and I was extremely confused. Lol.
I got a RUclips premium ad 😂😂
Same!!
That’s a bruh
Same dude, except it was this guy with long hair wanting to teach you guitar,,, you know him
It's like hes aaying listen to trump lol
This makes me want to hear a full piano version of some of Bill Wurtz's songs
Yes! He needs to do a jazz cover version of mt St. Helens
Piano version of Here comes the sun
ruclips.net/video/V9XwNBw3-cw/видео.html
I dunno if there are also his others songs
Bill is walking the line between total jazz mastering and complete chaos and i love it
6:15 it’s actually quite simple
Ladies and gentlemen we have the Mumbo of piano
yoooo a fellow mumbo jumbo fan!
chuffed to bits with this
Ayyyy
I have a friend who loves Jumbo and music. Going to recommend this channel to him👍
15:04 it's a D9sus (or C/D) chord.
I also noticed that!
thanks, chord man
I can hear an 11 in there, but good ear, dude. It makes sense, too, because the chord before it and the chord after it are both 4ths away. A->D->G
Sus what
Fitting name
you should do some of bills older songs, particularly “the road” is one of the most amazing and harmonically quirky jazz compositions ever imo
Seconding this, please consider doing a video in this style on The Road! It is super extra when it comes to the kind of stuff you discussed in this video, lol. Here's the song: ruclips.net/video/YZ7xgZXta8M/видео.html
6:00
“What’s happening?”
It’s really actually quite simple! He’s riding a pony into the sunset!
Me, watching this knowing literally no music theory: *nods along thoughtfully* Yes I definitely also see these things I absolutely know what’s going on
Lowkey i wished i understood what was going on but music stuffs is so hard for me to understand
It's always a fine swell day when Charles Cornell posts something
Charles: *Passionately explaining what’s happening*
Me: *Have no idea what he’s talking about*
Also me: *Pretending to understand what he’s talking about*
Oh yeah that is fascinating, that explains a lot
This is something I've noticed about theory channels: The human ear has an incredible capacity to understand what they hear in spite of your knowledge.
Kinda like how it is easier to run than to play QWOP, it is easier for your ear to understand the music than it is for your brain to understand it.
Peter Fitzsimmons If by “understand” you mean “enjoy”, then yeah your ear can understand faster than your brain can. But if you by “understand” you mean “able to identify and comprehend the intricacies”, then you need your brain for that.
@@SoniCraft98 nah i understand it even through ive never learned about music
I also don't know shit, but having listened to music since forever and him making analogies like "home base" and such make it easy to follow along with his enthusiasm.
Yea uh I have no clue wtf he's talking about but I love Bill Wurtz. He's saying it's a G buts it's a 4? Then he says the next is a Emj or something but also a 6? I'm lost but I don't care
I really want to see "when the day goes on" but it's like very, very complex especially with the breakdown
“Woke up in the morning traveling straight into the sun”
@@Caleb-jq5mj This is my alarm every morning
I don't think it would be that complex. For the most part it sounds pretty functional to me
@@Oberkobold Most of it seems really quite simple to me. But, I know very little about music theory tbh
@@isaacthecorncob OK?
"So, let's take a look at Mt. St Helens and see how it's put together."
Did Bill write that line?
bill is either a sleeper genius or he has never taken a music theory class
and i cant tell which it is
Both is good
I believe he studied Jazz at university
He is absolutely a genius. He knows exactly what he is doing theory wise.
He learned theory, mastered it, then proceeded to spam chords and figure out how to perfect it.
Why not both?
please continue doing bill wurtz videos! I love that guy and his music
I really like "new canaan" and "la de da de da de da de day oh"
“When I get older“ is one of my favorites! Would be cool to see that taken apart. Just the way it transitions into the bridge is so UGHH... _pleasant_
realizing you just watched a guy fangirling about music for 18 and a half minutes
and that it was amazing
cringy sans fangirl.
A guy fanboying maybe dhhdhd
I feel like Bill Wurtz learn the 'rules' of musicology, then just decided 'no one tells me what to do'
You need to know how the rules work in order to break them in a good way. Otherwise it's just erratic.
7:58 I dont know music that much but I recognise that chord progression anywhere. It's a very common progression used in Chinese/Taiwanese music; so common that it basically defines the "genre".
typical western music uses 12 notes total, and most scales have 7 notes, spaced in different ways to create the scale's identity. you can use the notes of the scale as guidance to creating chords. certain chords, called 'triads', take one of the scales notes, another note two scale-notes higher, and a third thats another two scale-notes higher. the triad is named based on the beginning note you used in relation to the scale's starting note, scaling from 1-7, often displayed in Roman numerals (I, II, III, IV, V, VI, and VII).
the chord progression at 7:58 cycles through the second, fifth, and first chords ( ii, V, I ) of the E-flat major scale. this type of progression is very common in all kinds of music, more in western and classical. the resolution from a fifth chord to a first chord has a feeling of resonance and wholeness, and a strong sense of tension, into release. its called a 'perfect cadence'.
Bill Wurtz: *makes a specific noise out of a specific instrument
Charles Cornell: We can make a religion out of this
i think the phrase, “that is super cool, and i’ll explain why-“ would work great on merch. just sayin’.
YES!
mansplain but for good
Jeremy Meyers wait how?How do you have that with 200 subs?
@@lolom8772 why does it matter
Jeremy Meyers just wondering, also kinda weird how all of your top videos have 10s of thousands of views yet can barely get 20 comments.
just sayin, i feel like charles is the only person i'd ever trust to do a decent job at covering one of bill wurtz's songs.
just sayin.
Josh Turner did an amazing job. You also should go down that rabbit hole. Josh is my favorite
@@andrewscott95 ooh I'll be sure to check it out!
I'd also recommend June Lee and Leon Waves channels if you're interested in transcriptionist channels
I think Adam Neely could do a great job of it
loved this!! Bill is a master, and you explained he mastery quite well. Thanks Charles!
hey look it's chops let me thing of an interesting thing to say... um... "yeah I agree with you, total youtube stranger"
🎶is loving bill wurtz legal yet🎶
I love how you have fun with the song at 8:04. You were straight vibing there.
I’ve always thought that Bill Wurtz’s ability to genre-bend as well as the eccentricity he has in his lyrics and writing is very evocative of the music from Phineas and Ferb? If that makes sense. Same energy
Oh totally, if there was another PnF-universe series coming out, and Bill composed for it, I would have 0 complaints.
PLEASE DO “Still a piece of garbage” ik its short but its extraordinary
hey thanks for checking in, i’m
@@ofexistence267 still a piece of ✨garbage✨🤪
What about the first part
he-llo, I’m ✨ *a piece of garbage* ✨
Someone needs to write a jukebox musical out of Bill's songs. Some of them are incredibly catchy and you can easily picture choreography. Not to mention the music is just fantastic and criminally unknown.
The way you played over the pony segment was just gorgeous. 6:40
Another thing thats suprisingly interesting is that the song modulates DOWN to the bridge. Modulating down is pretty rare, most songs modulate up to add energy.
Nobody:
Charles after every chord: *OMG THIS IS SOOO COOL, THIS IS INSANE*
charles, i luv u man
The three dislikes are from Bill's underpaid employees.
Chava Lampert is this a joke?
Hope they're enjoying their vacation!
@@seblat1086 "And the people who work in my office went on vacation,
'Cause they say I haven't been paying them very much anymore."
It's in the bridge, after the pony bit.
I never really gave bill the credit for being such a masterful composer. His randomness really hides his talent in a way (not really, as a whole package he’s brilliant, but when you mostly notice that he’s “so random and silly” it’s easy to not notice just how musically adventurous he is)
10:40 “You can do whatever you want as long as you throw a five” YOU JUST BLEW MY FREAKING MIND!!!
I really haven’t appreciated the theory enough. Thank you so much!
That was an inner voice movement
Charles: I want you to listen for the inner voice movement
YES!!
Yes! The visualization at 11:59 is great and something you’ve been building towards for a while!! Keep it up! I think there are even other ways to show what’s happening!
I just found my new favorite music related channel. When you explained the shift to A Major, I was like... wait isn't that a 5 of 5? It is! IT SO COOL. It is interesting how he basically just skipped the D Maj chord entirely, but it makes sense in a way. Super neat random moments where the music theory I learned actually happens! I love those!
No... V/V means the A should be dominant 7th chord instead of major 7th chord...
Bill: *(maybe I could eat blades of grass)*
Charles: *I felt dat*
Fantastic explanation. Musical notation is something I can never quite wrap my head around, for some reason, but the way you explain the meaning of the chords and demonstrate them on your piano makes it clear as water.
Please please do "at the airport terminal"! The verses have such a straightforward melody that when the craziness is introduced later, the contrast is very pronounced, and then little bits of harmonic weirdness get inserted back into the harmony during the verse. It's like, airport terminals should be this simple thing, but they're always stressful and weird, and you never get to have the simple experience you feel like you should have.
Ok I can't be the only one who wants a Cornell jazz version of this song 😤
It’s already too jazzy
@@frozennbutter6425 it'd be nice to see a Cornell version tho! Jazz varies it's really a reflection of the composer
Oh Bill Wurtz, how I miss thee
What? Did he quit?
@@reubenshiflet Nah, he just hasn't uploaded in a while. A long, long while
@@franciscobaltazarlabranago6248 he said in an h3h3 interview that he's planning on planning a concert tour
Please talk about his new song he just released less than an hour ago.
Bill Wurtz is unironically one of my favorite musicians. Truly no one like him.
This is one of the best breakdown videos I've ever seen. Thank you so much!
I can't thank you enough for showing me the light that is Bill Wurtz. I've watched nearly everything on youtube since your last video
Also would love to see "just did a bad thing"
Who watches Charles's videos upside down to see what he's doing on the piano 😂
you are my hero what the heck how didnt i notice this
Wow why i never thought of this
Genius explanation of a genius song.
I love how you explain complicated musical theory in a way that doesn’t belittle people for struggling to understand. Keep it up!
Music: exists
Charles: *claps and laughs* omygawd this is sooo good
I can't be the only person who watches this, having no idea what is going on, but loving it anyway- right?
You should check out Josh Turner's cover of that one, he's the only one I've seen nail Bill's chords in a cover
Charles's major fanboy moments:
1:25
2:04
2:29
2:44
3:21
4:41
5:24
6:05
7:48
8:19
8:47
12:28
12:59
13:05
13:25
14:07
15:20
16:06
16:20
basically the whole video
We have the major ones but what about the minor ones?
Dartrevas or the diminished add4 flat 11
So everything?
Charles is the type of person to look at a bill wurtz song and ask “ is anyone going to figure out the cord progressions” and not wait for an answer
is it bad I know what this references?
I really don't understand any of this, or barely, but it's just entertaining somehow. It makes sense, or feels like it does, without me actually understanding.
So cool.
And seeing him get so excited is amazing