2023 really starts gaining an advantage at like A4. I wish there were longer attempts of Bb4 and C5 from 2023. Overall we know 2023 won, but 2022 was confident with joy to the world intro and whistles.
In 2022 her nodules were probably the size of golf balls 💀- but that made nice whistles and terrible everything else. I would think she would be able to go higher in her whistle range? But idk
@@outsideskippy1997 maybe if she's in really good shape D5 is not as much a struggle, but on the other hand, she at times struggle with an A4, even G#4 sometimes iirc. Even if we assume that's like her at her absolute worst and she's sick or something, I just cannot in good faith say that at her average day, she suddenly has D5 in her bag when she barely has Bb4s and B4s. The fact that notes above a C#5 is something that she has to gamble on, and we celebrate when she get it right, means that those notes are simply not something within the range that her voice is consistent and reliable in.
I think her comfort range is like this (I am not a vocal professional) Normal day:B2-D5 and maybe a D#5-G#6 Healthy day:Bb2-D#5 or maybe a raspy Eb5-Eb6 Nodules day:A2-B4 Maybe a quick C#5-B6
I disagree on Eb3 tho 🌝 2022 sounded more airy, muffled, less volume and decent vibrato. 2023 sounded more fuller, rolling vibrato and much more audible
![Singers Expectation vs. Reality [FAIL Version]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AJ-h1P7CF4k/mqdefault.jpg)
![Mariah Carey SLAYS "TGIFY" [2016] [Vocal Showcase]](/img/1.gif)
2022 whistles were actually so good wait a minute😭
2024 outsold 💅
yeah awhile ago she said when her full voice isn't giving, that's when her whistles are good vice versa and I so see that
2023 really starts gaining an advantage at like A4. I wish there were longer attempts of Bb4 and C5 from 2023. Overall we know 2023 won, but 2022 was confident with joy to the world intro and whistles.
Actually you can already hear 2022 struggle with G4/G#4 💀
2022 confidence + late 2023 vocals would've been so good actually😭 hopefully we get this in 2024🤔😍
@@Dubairiah + the rich tone of 2022.
@@DubairiahTbh, we might because these little snippets she’s posting is giving that
Her low register is golden in these current years. Her 2022 whistle tone ✨ and 2023 belts ❤❤ shining.
Haven't even started the video and I can confidently say 2023 won😭
I thought the same before doing this video but 2022 kinda ate 2023 with the whistles😭
@@Dubairiah fr like I actually underestimated 2022's whistles😭
Literally it’s like 2022 was like 2006 all over again
Chest voice: 2023
Whistles: 2022
Can we say her current tessitura is C#3 - D5 - G#6?
In 2022 her nodules were probably the size of golf balls 💀- but that made nice whistles and terrible everything else. I would think she would be able to go higher in her whistle range? But idk
@@outsideskippy1997 HELP. But true, 2022 was the first year in like a decade where she regained that airy sound in her whistles
D5 sounds a bit too high. Her natural comfort now kinda ends at A4, Bb4 if we're being generous
@@badatchoosingnames3556 natural comfort when she doesn’t warm up? I feel like assuming her voice is in good condition D5 is pretty accurate
@@outsideskippy1997 maybe if she's in really good shape D5 is not as much a struggle, but on the other hand, she at times struggle with an A4, even G#4 sometimes iirc. Even if we assume that's like her at her absolute worst and she's sick or something, I just cannot in good faith say that at her average day, she suddenly has D5 in her bag when she barely has Bb4s and B4s.
The fact that notes above a C#5 is something that she has to gamble on, and we celebrate when she get it right, means that those notes are simply not something within the range that her voice is consistent and reliable in.
2022´s C5 sounds like she drank enough for a family of ten💀🪁
Omg😭😭
Let’s not talk abt the second C#5 in 2022😭
I think her comfort range is like this (I am not a vocal professional)
Normal day:B2-D5 and maybe a D#5-G#6
Healthy day:Bb2-D#5 or maybe a raspy Eb5-Eb6
Nodules day:A2-B4 Maybe a quick C#5-B6
2022 whistles and 2023 everything else 😭
First note for 2022 (Bb2) is actually a D/D#3
It dips to bb2 at the end of the word.
Bb2: 2022
B2: 2022
C#3: 2023
D3: 2023
Eb3: 2022
E3: 2023
F4: 2022
F#4: 2022
G4: 2023
G#4: 2023
A4: 2023
Bb4: 2022
B4: 2023
C5: 2022
C#5: 2023
D5: 2023
C6: 2023
C#6: 2023
D6: 2023
Eb6: 2022
F6: 2022
F#6: 2023
G6: 2022
G#6: 2022
I disagree on Eb3 tho 🌝
2022 sounded more airy, muffled, less volume and decent vibrato. 2023 sounded more fuller, rolling vibrato and much more audible
1:27 her way of shouting like gospel HAY NAWW🥁✝️✝️
❤my angle butterfly
I hope you enjoyed it! Sorry if I made any mistakes (let me know if I made any!) Thanks for watching❤
Im pretty sure the my all clip you used for the c#3 is actually a d3
The 2023 one (my all)
@@Inspiration_Series Oh😭😭😭😭 thank you
I found that actually the 2022 F6 was an E6 and the 2023 F6 was a G6
0:54 it’s actually G#4
muauauah this is a vile video. can’t wait 😈
not me thinking this was gonna be a tour comparison
1:47 isn’t it the bg singer reaching the D5?
I think its Mariah but ig it could be a bg singer
2022 > 2023
0:21 where is this from please 🫠?
@Dubairiah
Where are the F4s from
For 2022 I used the second Toronto concert and for 2023 I used the first Hollywood Bowl one
@@Dubairiah which songs
@@TheStoryOfMariah They're from Hark! The Herald Angels Sing
@@Dubairiah thx