You know you've graduated from primary school to high school when you've watched Will Prowse and feel comfortable with all his content and start watching Off-Grid Garage and appreciate the depth of explanation of seriously complex concepts!
You continue to explore the various characteristics of LifePo4 cells in a very scientific manner. There are lots of RUclips channels doing things with this chemistry but I am not aware of anyone doing all the things you have taught us about this specific chemistry. I thank you, sir. I have learned so much from you.
Thank you Andy for the comprehensive reviews and analysis of the topics. I'm a professional electrician, recently I've also been dealing with solar systems and your videos are of great help to me. Thanks and greetings from Bulgaria!
Marvelous! Thank you very much for the lab experiments - so much appreciated! This is one reason why I went with LifeP04 from the start - and will actively discourage anyone from using plain Lithium batteries, especially since those are far more prone to dangerous activity.
Thanks so much for this active demonstration. I have thought in my head for some time now that this is exactly what would happen. I currently have 6ea Valence U27-12xp batteries in parallel and have had zero problems on the boat. Most will state to only put 4 in series or parralel at any time, but my 6 have worked just fine. I have purchased another 7 of these batteries to add to the bank and it has been suggested I have different charge controllers. Nonsense I thought, and hooked the all to the same buss bar with verying length of wire. Of course I made sure all the wires had the same resistance (small short ones and long large ones) as when starting a very large diesel engine, I need in excess of 1000 amps and need that balance under this high load. Now with the 13 batteries each capable of 300 amps output for 30 seconds, that should give me almost 4000 amps for engine starting, easy even with different resistance cables as long as they are close. Thanks again for confirming what I always thought was the case.
Great video Andy. I have 10 batteries now. I found using a buss bar vs parallel cables from one battery to another easier to ballance batteries. All JKBMS. Different AH batteries. Normal operation I stay around 80%. Maintenance now every week i take one battery one cell swap out for uohm testing and cell curve testing for my spread sheet. Even grade B cells operating fine. Thanks for your testing.
I recently built a 2nd bank of 16 x 280Ah cells and put them in parallel to the existing 3 year old bank of 16 x 280Ah cells. I have found that the older bank discharges at a faster rate than the new bank. Old will drop ~32%, the new one will drop ~18% overnight. The older bank also charges at a faster rate. They both reach the Absorb voltage at roughly the same time though, and charge tapers off to
That's exactly what I like about your canal - you show what happens when... I can confirm it exactly like that... I'm currently building my PV system and have 2x280Ah batteries. I had one at SOC 100% and the other at SOC 40%, the voltages were the same except for 0.01V, so I could connect them in parallel. Unfortunately I'm currently missing the panels on the roof...😊
Its very reassuring to see a test done like this. Means you know that the batteries will cope. Just as long as it doesn't have a full time running active balancer. I'm thinking for mine of Seplos, with a Neey active balancer for the win.
Thank you so much for this . Over the years I've asked a number of experts this exact question. All of whom have looked at me as if I'm insane for wanting to mix capacities (of the same chemistry) . "I wouldn't if i were you" is the usual response , with no justification or reasoning why this would be so bad . No evidence, nada , nothing . You are the only person who has actually had the cojones to try , film and publish real world results . As an adendum to this test/demonstration i would be curious if there would be any detrimental effects to each battery over an extended period ? Thanks again Andy. Fattrucker
Thank s for your feedback. There is no downside of paralleling different capacities with LiFePO4. The voltages are all the same and batteries will balance against each other when fully charged/discharged.
Inverters like to 'talk' to batteries, but it's not technically needed, although some inverters won't 'invert' if they can't 'see' the battery BMS data... No good reason for it...
I will parallel all batteries I have at some stage without any communication. As we have seen from the battery shelf long-term experiment, coms is not needed. The BMS take care of their individual battery just fine...
@@OffGridGarageAustralia im preaching this since I got it thanks to you experiments... No one is believing me without your proof videos... I guess now they see. Everybody is hardly trying to get the bms talking to their inverter and doesn't know why 😅
@@finfin82 Technically no, comms is not needed, in a very crude manner you can just set a "cutoff" voltage in the inverter..... But, my question then to you is. How do you know what the SOC of your battery is? Otherwise, what would set your very expensive home inverter system apart from a car battery and and a 12V inverter?.....
@@GapRecordingsNamibia well, do i need to know the SoC? it wouldnt change if i do? im reading the battery-stats with a small nmc and build my own grafana graphs, but actually when the bat is full enough it is used if not, its not... so what? all smart stuff like if the bat is full in morning and the day will give me sunshine i handle in nodered with readed stuff and having the option to suck the rest out of the battery... no inverter communication would help there either?!
I experienced this exactely like that with my 6x16KWH 300AH packs my packs have the Active balancers with voltage trigger set at 54.2 -53.5 works so nice...
I’m missing something about that challenge with the active balancer. It stopped charging because one cell hit the 3.65 cutoff. Shouldn’t the active balancer drain off some of that energy and distribute it to the other cells? Lowering the voltage of that cell and allowing it to start charging again.
Depending on the charge cutoff the bms will stop charge at the max cell voltage. The highest cell will balance the lowest cell. When the highest cell voltage drops below the setpoint, the charge will turn on.
Wish I could give two thumbs up on this - one for your normal, everyday, "It's 100 amps outside" :) and one for the "dumba$$" section. Well done. Love the channel!
Hi Andy, I just love your channel and I have learned so much from your very detailed and no bs explanations. When you explain it in simple terms like you do that means that you know exactly what it is. I am so addicted to the stuff you do it makes me want to go out and buy batteries, Chinese test equipment and of course beer! I am not sure if you will get notified of a question that I have regarding leaving LFP, or the Salty, sitting at 100% SOC all the time and possibly for months and maybe longer. This is a backup UPS and to be honest it is a good thng if we do not lose input power to the UPS because that means our power grid is performing well. Do you have any best practices on charging and discharging periodically for no reason other that to perhaps keep the cells from gettting too fat. LOL. Do they really need to be exercised? Thank you my friend for all the information you pass to us. I rally appreciate it.
Great explanation, experimentation & analogy with Sponge Bob Andy, it was good to see this done with ur nice big battery setup, but no surprises here after watching ur old videos way back using the Palo cells & bigger batteries when u were in ur early testing phases & a bit of my own experimentation on this. Like to see this again with ur Seplos setup, maybe try 30, 60, 90% SOC or a 10, 50, 90% SOC test & see how they vary. Love ur scientific approach & logic. Cheers
Thanks 👍 Yeah, I'll repeat the test at some stage. The current will increase slightly when we leave the flat part of the curve and go 10% or 90%. Still, it is not a drama as I have done this with my battery shelf several times. LFP for the win.
Hi Sir, for the Gobel battery which had an OVP, is the capacity truly 100% or did it jump from a certain percentage (say 85%) to 100% when it hit the OVP? Thus the 292 AH reading isn't accurate anymore?
Does discharging work similarly in reverse, i.e., taking from the higher capacity battery until the Ah of all batteries reach the same Ah then discharges from all batteries equally?
Very good as always, Andy! Nice to see the same game with discharging. It's interesting to figure out if the lowest capacity battery will be blocked by bms or all the batteries come to the bottom line at the same time 😮, it's a miracle 🎉)). It's really interesting from the current distribution point of view. cheers 🍻
Thank you. Yeah, that's is what I observed as well, regardless the capacity, all batteries will come to the same high SOC or low SOC pretty much at the same time.
Hi Andy, I would like to ask you for advice, I have a 200ah Victron battery on my camper, I would like to add a second battery but the Victron battery is very expensive, according to your tests can I add a different battery by placing it in parallel? Thank you
Not at full SOC, no. This is the time to balance so that's not causing any issues. the problem is when the cells go back in the flat part of the curves and you would balance there, so below 3.35V. This causes the problems if the balancer is on. But, you should not leave the battery fully charged for several weeks. That's really unhealthy.
Thank a lot for this video i have learn so much. I have a question about lithium battery. I have dev a pcb for a gps tracking that auto cut off when power goes down and switch to battery witch are 2 lithium cell in parralell can i add a passive balancer to each cell
I have the seplos 2a active balancer on the way. do you have any plans to do video on it? also are all the 16s connectors interchangable between active balancers? so for example could the wire harness (from gobelpower) fit the neey balancer? so you dwouldnt thave to take apart the battery to change balancer
Excellent video Andy. Suggestion: Could you show the real time results with the same system, this time testing the impact on batteries with less capacity while connected to batteries with more capacity. What is the best approach to limiting the discharge on the smaller capacity batteries with this type of arrangement?
I have a video where I paralleled a 5Ah 12V battery with a 300Ah 12V battery and showed everything in real time. That may already help? ruclips.net/video/fQz7vZEYLfY/видео.html
question.. because both of the terminals are connected to the bottom shelf.. wouldnt that mean that there is a greater load on it. it would be getting worn faster? wouldlnt it be better to connect the postive to the bottom battery and the negative to the top battery? spread the load? or am I seeing this wrong?
Imma follow this question, because I also have this exact same connection where my battery capacities are different. I want to make sure I connected it right too. Will it be better to have the positive line connected at the larger capacity battery or just the same?
Very interesting. The question that comes to mind now is how the discharge SOC will be managed ? When discharging, the smaller batteries will discharge faster, as they have less charge stored. So how do you manage the batteries not going below 15% SOC, as the smaller ones will reach this before the larger batteries ? Can the BMS be configured to manage the cut-off SOC for each battery independently ?
The batteries with the smaller capacity will discharge slower as they have a higher resistance than the ones with higher capacity. Watch this video here with a 5Ah and 300Ah battery in parallel: ruclips.net/video/fQz7vZEYLfY/видео.html
I have learned a lot from you Andy. Greetings from Philippines! I wonder how much spark is happening inside the breakers whenever you turned it on/off under big loads. Doing it always might harm the contacts of the mcb. Am i right? Should it be better if we put high amp switch inline one of the poles? Turning on the mcb first before the high amp switch and the switch first before the mcb when turning off. The switch will do the on/off thing and the mcb for overload. And the switch i think is much cheaper to replace. But i dont know which pole is best to connect the switch tho.
Hang on a mo!!! Andy was that you I see burning a fossil fuel or was I still tripping??? You got your money's worth out of that sponge dear boy! Luv ya Gaz 🏴
Great test, would it make any difference if you connect the charging cables diagonal. Positive on bottom battery and negitive on the top battery ? That is the way that Victron recommends connecting parallel batteries.
@@furyjk98, I think Douglas means that the top pack sees more parasitic resistence of the cables than the bottom packs. By connecting e.g. the positive to the top pack and the negative to the bottom pack (= diagonal), the parasitic resistence is more evenly spread across the packs.
I have my battery shelf just connected from the top and did not run the negative cable all the way down just to connect it to the busbar there. I have also done the same with the Seplos Polo batteries and the aluminium busbar I installed at the back. I feed this form the top. Theoretically, the top battery sees a bit of a higher voltage while charging and a lower voltage while discharging than the other batteries. From my experience this difference is so small though that it would not matter much. In larger installations (maybe 6+ batteries in parallel) and much higher charge and discharge currents I would connected them across as well.
Nice one Andy, thank you for sharing this experience🙏 I'm planning to mix at least two types of batteries and I'm glad to see, from your test, exactly what I would expect to see. My mix is going to be a little extreme as I have one 5.12Kvh and one just under 16kWh. PS) Yes, the Zketech 40A is a must and I'm glad to have it as part of my test equipment.
Hi Andy. Please always connect parallel batteries diagonally. Meaning i.e. one lead on the negativ of the bottom battery and the other on the positiv of the top battery. Then the currents actually tell you something.
There is no way to do this with packs that do not have the same pole/ terminal spacing....... That is why he used cables.... if all the batteries are the same make and model this is doable, otherwise not.
Based on your testing, which BMS do you recommend as the most stable/durable for a hybrid system. (S16-2P, 100A) I have been testing Daly (with Daly active load balancer and parallel board. The Calls are 138Ah BYD blade cells. Set up is S16-2p. 2 battery packs in parallel. the BMSs work well for a few months but then start losing connecting with one or more cells, showing those particular cell"s" at lower voltage than they real are, Which in turn end up damaging the cell"s".
What bms do you recommend with lifepo? Have a griwatt 12kw off grid split phase inverter and a 16s 2 parrell 3.2-48v lifepo pack, having lots of trouble keeping the cells balanced
Does this means I can connect my two batteries 200Ah and 100Ah in parallel and use them as one 300Ah battery permanently? I wanted to try, but wouldn't like to damage something..
Makes sure every battery has its own BMS and circuit breaker. They also need to have the same voltage, cell count and chemistry. Example, 51.2V, 16s, LiFePO4
What would you say about using rack mount batteries wired with drop in style lifepo4 batteries? I have some 48 volt rack and several 12 volt drop ins and would like to use the drop ins in my system, only problem I see is that the 12 volt drop ins have a PCM (protection circuit module) instead of a BMS
Yeah, probably don't do that. You also need to find out if the 12V batteries can be connected in series with such a PCM and can withstand the higher voltage in case one turns of.
Personally, SOC% is not important; what is important is the small voltage delta. 3:00 min 20% SOC, max 80% SOC... hmmm. well since these all have PACE BMS with charge current limit circuit, it is definitely OK to parallel them even when one of them is 100% SOC, while the others are at 0% - because there is a charge current limit circuit. However those other BMSes in the battery 2.0 without charge current limit circuit, its gonna be xxxxx. PS: Charge Current Limit and Over Current Protection circuits are not same. The latter stops charging when over current, the former limits the charge current when a threshold is reached.
Yes, the Pace and Seplos BMS have current limiter, so it keeps them save. As we saw, there was only a mere 30A between the 80% and 20% battery. However, I have done this a few times with my battery shelf as well and if the current gets too high, the BMS will simply disconnect the battery, wait a moment and tries again. It may do this a few times until the voltage has equalized and the current is below the protection settings.
Better of using a single shunt to feed the inverter with information (Battery voltage, SOC). So long as the total battery capacity is properly set there would be no reason for the inverter to 'see' all of the batteries....
What would be a meaningful way in your terms? There are some (small) benefits in having the BMS talkig to the inverter, but as the other viewer suggested, get a shunt in front of all your batteries and forget about the communication to the inverter. Unless you have a super large system, it's not really a huge benefit.
Thanks Andy - I suppose I'm trying to get my head around whether/how to mix two SunSynk 5.3kWh LifePO4s with a Seplos Mason 280L DIY kit in the future - I think you've covered how to use Victron kit in the past as a simpler more compact solution than your shelf bank, so I'll re-watch those videos when the time comes. I would then probably add SolarAssistant for monitoring battery packs as well as for controlling the SunSynk inverter.
Heya, because the flet charge curf of LiFiPo4 is differant then lion ( 18650 ) we have to charge differantly and LiFiPo4 holds lot's of high Ah you need an active balancer with some nice amp's balancing current but the active balancer only start balancing in the high end of the CC. that's what I have learned from all the test's that you have done. thanks for that and all the hours of enterteanment.
Hi Andy, nice video (again). Suggestion for an experiment: how does parasitic resistence affect the load on 2 (identical) parallel batteries. E.g. 2 batteries in parrallel where 1 pack gets longer cables and/or additional connectors. My expectation is that the pack with the lowest parasitic resistence, will see the biggest load (= delta in SoC). But how much? Is it significant? Would it wear out one pack significantly faster than the other pack?
Yes, that's a good experiment as well. I have many batteries connected with different cable lengths and it is very interesting to watch what is happening during charging and discharging. I'll put your suggestion on my list. Thanks.
Hi, you are connecting and disconnecting a lot of batteries. Maybe using forklift battery connectors might ease your work. They are available as 80, 169, 320 and 640 amps as a standard. Thanks for your great video! BR Björn
Thank you, Bjoern. I will need to look at something better in the future, definitely. I have some upgrade to to for this area anyway. It is really just a temporary setup.
How about discharging of battery different amp? Many people set their inverter to cut off at 10% or 20% Soc to reserve their battery life cycle. Once we mix battery with different capacity the smaller one will go off 0% while the bigger one still provide power ...
It makes no difference what the SOC is they will alwasys charge normally to 100% the only difference is the highest capacity will take the majority of the power.
Exactly what ☝this person said.. The pack with the lowest SOC at that time will sink the most current..... The pack with the biggest AH rating will take the longest to charge and will take the most energy to "fill up", where as the smaller the AH rating the faster it will charge. But, in the end they should all equal out at "100%" SOC.
You can, once you have connected the CAN of the inverter and the GX or VX and have setup your Victron account and dashboard and configured your VX/ GX to connect to the account, use the VE Configure Software on your PC and then create, save and export the config file, then connect to the Victron dashboard and through the internet you can load your config file up to the inverter, (Andy has a video showing this). BE WARNED! If you do this, there are certain programming levels that need to stop the inverter to complete. This means the inverter WILL SWITCH OFF and if you are powering your devices from that inverter you can brick the inverter if it loses power and programming signal at the wrong or (right) time. Just make sure that what you are using to power the rest of the equipment from can maintain power while you do this. The inverter also needs a stable mains input during this time. This is very important.......
@@dirk_p My pleasure. But, using the Mk3 dongle or not, the power supply issues remain the same, all during programming the mains supply must remain constant to all your devices.
That's just a calculation of the BMS. It has nothing to do with the real SOH. I have done a lot of testing with these batteries and BMS including disconnecting the BMS sot he calculation is off until they are calibrated again. They should not show this number anywhere as people may freak out 😉
You know you've graduated from primary school to high school when you've watched Will Prowse and feel comfortable with all his content and start watching Off-Grid Garage and appreciate the depth of explanation of seriously complex concepts!
You’re in high school? I grew up in the wrong country 😂 Watching this as a mechanical engineering student and still some things go over my head..
You continue to explore the various characteristics of LifePo4 cells in a very scientific manner. There are lots of RUclips channels doing things with this chemistry but I am not aware of anyone doing all the things you have taught us about this specific chemistry.
I thank you, sir. I have learned so much from you.
Thanks a lot, my friend. I'm very happy to share all this with a great community.
You are by far the most thorough and logically detailed person online concerning solar stuff….I have learned a lot….thank you………..jim
Awesome, thank you!
Thank you Andy for the comprehensive reviews and analysis of the topics. I'm a professional electrician, recently I've also been dealing with solar systems and your videos are of great help to me. Thanks and greetings from Bulgaria!
I always love those dramatic moments of flipping up the cirtuit breaker whatever I do as well :D Greetings from Slovakia
Even I check everything several times and take all the measurements, it's an exciting moment. Especially in such large systems.
Marvelous! Thank you very much for the lab experiments - so much appreciated! This is one reason why I went with LifeP04 from the start - and will actively discourage anyone from using plain Lithium batteries, especially since those are far more prone to dangerous activity.
Thank you. Yeah, LiFePO4 is pretty save and forgiving. Usually no high currents in these setups.
The comparison with the sponges is ingenious. Thanks for this video.
Kind regards from Germany.
Thankyou. I thought it would be easier to understand...
@@OffGridGarageAustralia Yes it is !!!
Love the doing analogy and that commercial is one of my favorites of all time
Mr, Dumass! I didn't know it until I searched for it😂
@@OffGridGarageAustralia 😂
I am from India..
,,,I am regularly watching your video..
Very interesting..❤
Thanks a lot and welcome!
❤
Thanks so much for this active demonstration. I have thought in my head for some time now that this is exactly what would happen. I currently have 6ea Valence U27-12xp batteries in parallel and have had zero problems on the boat. Most will state to only put 4 in series or parralel at any time, but my 6 have worked just fine. I have purchased another 7 of these batteries to add to the bank and it has been suggested I have different charge controllers. Nonsense I thought, and hooked the all to the same buss bar with verying length of wire. Of course I made sure all the wires had the same resistance (small short ones and long large ones) as when starting a very large diesel engine, I need in excess of 1000 amps and need that balance under this high load. Now with the 13 batteries each capable of 300 amps output for 30 seconds, that should give me almost 4000 amps for engine starting, easy even with different resistance cables as long as they are close. Thanks again for confirming what I always thought was the case.
Excellent explanations! Thank you for doing this test and sharing your findings!
Great explanation Andy! This should clear up any confusion people have when buying or using different batteries! Great Job!!
Another great informative video from the best solar/battery guy on YT. Thanks Andy!
Thanks so much😊
Great video Andy. I have 10 batteries now. I found using a buss bar vs parallel cables from one battery to another easier to ballance batteries. All JKBMS. Different AH batteries. Normal operation I stay around 80%. Maintenance now every week i take one battery one cell swap out for uohm testing and cell curve testing for my spread sheet. Even grade B cells operating fine. Thanks for your testing.
Thanks for sharing. Yeah, with 10 batteries in parallel, I would use a bus bar as well.
You test one cell every week? I thought I was nerdy... 😁
Excellent video Andy! Have held off connecting my original well used LiFePo battery with the new one I built from new cells. Time to hook them up!
Yes, get them connected!
I recently built a 2nd bank of 16 x 280Ah cells and put them in parallel to the existing 3 year old bank of 16 x 280Ah cells. I have found that the older bank discharges at a faster rate than the new bank. Old will drop ~32%, the new one will drop ~18% overnight. The older bank also charges at a faster rate. They both reach the Absorb voltage at roughly the same time though, and charge tapers off to
@@drdos6718 thanks for sharing, that is quite a large difference between your two banks. It can only be internal resistance being very different...
That's exactly what I like about your canal - you show what happens when... I can confirm it exactly like that... I'm currently building my PV system and have 2x280Ah batteries. I had one at SOC 100% and the other at SOC 40%, the voltages were the same except for 0.01V, so I could connect them in parallel.
Unfortunately I'm currently missing the panels on the roof...😊
Thank you. Yeah, it's quite fascinating watching these batteries charge and discharge when they all have different capacities and also cable lengths.
Its very reassuring to see a test done like this. Means you know that the batteries will cope.
Just as long as it doesn't have a full time running active balancer.
I'm thinking for mine of Seplos, with a Neey active balancer for the win.
You cannot go wrong with the NEEY!
YESSS!! I love the sponge tests
Sponges are sexy!😂
Another Great hands-on test backed by fine science and engineering
Keep it up!
Thank you.
Thank you so much for this .
Over the years I've asked a number of experts this exact question. All of whom have looked at me as if I'm insane for wanting to mix capacities (of the same chemistry) . "I wouldn't if i were you" is the usual response , with no justification or reasoning why this would be so bad . No evidence, nada , nothing .
You are the only person who has actually had the cojones to try , film and publish real world results .
As an adendum to this test/demonstration i would be curious if there would be any detrimental effects to each battery over an extended period ?
Thanks again Andy.
Fattrucker
Thank s for your feedback. There is no downside of paralleling different capacities with LiFePO4. The voltages are all the same and batteries will balance against each other when fully charged/discharged.
Thanks Andy, as usual a great description! Cheers
Thanks, Dave.
Very interesting. I was waiting for the KABOOM 😂👍
i live in Kyiv, UA, KABOOM is our reality now for 2+ yrs so if all my battery pack blows up - nobody gives a shit ((
Love this oldman, cheers.
Great demonstration!
Thank you. A very frequently asked question.
off grid garage - home of frankenstein battery and its relatives
great video
Thank you for sharing this experiment. I understand much more about lithium iron oxide batteries.
Great, thank you for the feedback.
Please! Nobel prize to Andy for sharing knowledge around the world!
Hahaha, thank you. I'm happy with a S.P.A.T. here and there 🍺
The best video showing that communication between the batteries and at least inverter doesn't matter anyway! Thank you very much! ❤
Inverters like to 'talk' to batteries, but it's not technically needed, although some inverters won't 'invert' if they can't 'see' the battery BMS data... No good reason for it...
I will parallel all batteries I have at some stage without any communication. As we have seen from the battery shelf long-term experiment, coms is not needed. The BMS take care of their individual battery just fine...
@@OffGridGarageAustralia im preaching this since I got it thanks to you experiments... No one is believing me without your proof videos... I guess now they see. Everybody is hardly trying to get the bms talking to their inverter and doesn't know why 😅
@@finfin82 Technically no, comms is not needed, in a very crude manner you can just set a "cutoff" voltage in the inverter..... But, my question then to you is. How do you know what the SOC of your battery is? Otherwise, what would set your very expensive home inverter system apart from a car battery and and a 12V inverter?.....
@@GapRecordingsNamibia well, do i need to know the SoC? it wouldnt change if i do? im reading the battery-stats with a small nmc and build my own grafana graphs, but actually when the bat is full enough it is used if not, its not... so what? all smart stuff like if the bat is full in morning and the day will give me sunshine i handle in nodered with readed stuff and having the option to suck the rest out of the battery... no inverter communication would help there either?!
What a amazing Power storage, great
So good for testing. I can combine all sort of batteries and test it all out.
I experienced this exactely like that with my 6x16KWH 300AH packs
my packs have the Active balancers with voltage trigger set at 54.2 -53.5 works so nice...
Cant wait to see the video of the Gobel Power with the Neeeee balancer. Have one with the 5A active balancer and a 2nd in order, waiting for shipping.
I have received the NEEY already, just need to find the time to start the project...
Thanks, looks like my jakiper 100ah and my selfbuild 280ah will go play nicely together.
Great video Andy 👍
Thank you 😊
Groovy .. nice flick
Thanks Andy
Wayne, thank you!
Thanks for the lesson. 👍
I’m missing something about that challenge with the active balancer. It stopped charging because one cell hit the 3.65 cutoff. Shouldn’t the active balancer drain off some of that energy and distribute it to the other cells? Lowering the voltage of that cell and allowing it to start charging again.
Depending on the charge cutoff the bms will stop charge at the max cell voltage. The highest cell will balance the lowest cell. When the highest cell voltage drops below the setpoint, the charge will turn on.
Wish I could give two thumbs up on this - one for your normal, everyday, "It's 100 amps outside" :) and one for the "dumba$$" section. Well done. Love the channel!
love your work
Thank you!
I would love to see if you have something on the active balancing issues, I will look at ur library
Hi Andy, I just love your channel and I have learned so much from your very detailed and no bs explanations. When you explain it in simple terms like you do that means that you know exactly what it is. I am so addicted to the stuff you do it makes me want to go out and buy batteries, Chinese test equipment and of course beer!
I am not sure if you will get notified of a question that I have regarding leaving LFP, or the Salty, sitting at 100% SOC all the time and possibly for months and maybe longer. This is a backup UPS and to be honest it is a good thng if we do not lose input power to the UPS because that means our power grid is performing well. Do you have any best practices on charging and discharging periodically for no reason other that to perhaps keep the cells from gettting too fat. LOL. Do they really need to be exercised?
Thank you my friend for all the information you pass to us. I rally appreciate it.
Great explanation, experimentation & analogy with Sponge Bob Andy, it was good to see this done with ur nice big battery setup, but no surprises here after watching ur old videos way back using the Palo cells & bigger batteries when u were in ur early testing phases & a bit of my own experimentation on this.
Like to see this again with ur Seplos setup, maybe try 30, 60, 90% SOC or a 10, 50, 90% SOC test & see how they vary. Love ur scientific approach & logic. Cheers
Thanks 👍
Yeah, I'll repeat the test at some stage. The current will increase slightly when we leave the flat part of the curve and go 10% or 90%. Still, it is not a drama as I have done this with my battery shelf several times. LFP for the win.
Nice work.
Hi Sir, for the Gobel battery which had an OVP, is the capacity truly 100% or did it jump from a certain percentage (say 85%) to 100% when it hit the OVP? Thus the 292 AH reading isn't accurate anymore?
Does discharging work similarly in reverse, i.e., taking from the higher capacity battery until the Ah of all batteries reach the same Ah then discharges from all batteries equally?
Yes, it works exactly the same just in reverse.
@@OffGridGarageAustralia Thanks, Andy.
Very good as always, Andy!
Nice to see the same game with discharging. It's interesting to figure out if the lowest capacity battery will be blocked by bms or all the batteries come to the bottom line at the same time 😮, it's a miracle 🎉)). It's really interesting from the current distribution point of view. cheers 🍻
They will all get to charged or discharged state at the same time when in parallel...
Thank you.
Yeah, that's is what I observed as well, regardless the capacity, all batteries will come to the same high SOC or low SOC pretty much at the same time.
Hi Andy, I would like to ask you for advice, I have a 200ah Victron battery on my camper, I would like to add a second battery but the Victron battery is very expensive, according to your tests can I add a different battery by placing it in parallel? Thank you
Yes, you can parallel any battery with the same voltage and cell chemistry as long as all BMS have their own individual BMS.
Maaate. I like your vids and your style.😁
Thanks Andy. Will an active balancer that is always on unbalance the battery if the battery is sitting for weeks at full state of charge?
Not at full SOC, no. This is the time to balance so that's not causing any issues. the problem is when the cells go back in the flat part of the curves and you would balance there, so below 3.35V. This causes the problems if the balancer is on.
But, you should not leave the battery fully charged for several weeks. That's really unhealthy.
Hi, you have a list of batteries and BMS you use... could you also link your tools e.g. the DC Clamp Amperemeter?
Thank a lot for this video i have learn so much. I have a question about lithium battery. I have dev a pcb for a gps tracking that auto cut off when power goes down and switch to battery witch are 2 lithium cell in parralell can i add a passive balancer to each cell
21:18 I haven’t heard any comments regarding this high current to the third battery. Why is that?
I have the seplos 2a active balancer on the way. do you have any plans to do video on it? also are all the 16s connectors interchangable between active balancers? so for example could the wire harness (from gobelpower) fit the neey balancer? so you dwouldnt thave to take apart the battery to change balancer
Excellent video Andy. Suggestion: Could you show the real time results with the same system, this time testing the impact on batteries with less capacity while connected to batteries with more capacity. What is the best approach to limiting the discharge on the smaller capacity batteries with this type of arrangement?
I have a video where I paralleled a 5Ah 12V battery with a 300Ah 12V battery and showed everything in real time. That may already help?
ruclips.net/video/fQz7vZEYLfY/видео.html
Such an interesting analogy!
It's not 100% but roughly how it works.
Hah, watching for a 2nd time, when you go to the whiteboard you say, "Let's explain what's 😂currently😂 happening" 😂😂
question..
because both of the terminals are connected to the bottom shelf.. wouldnt that mean that there is a greater load on it. it would be getting worn faster?
wouldlnt it be better to connect the postive to the bottom battery and the negative to the top battery? spread the load? or am I seeing this wrong?
Imma follow this question, because I also have this exact same connection where my battery capacities are different. I want to make sure I connected it right too. Will it be better to have the positive line connected at the larger capacity battery or just the same?
Very interesting. The question that comes to mind now is how the discharge SOC will be managed ? When discharging, the smaller batteries will discharge faster, as they have less charge stored. So how do you manage the batteries not going below 15% SOC, as the smaller ones will reach this before the larger batteries ? Can the BMS be configured to manage the cut-off SOC for each battery independently ?
All parallel batteries will discharge over the same time period, i'e their SOC will be aligned.
The batteries with the smaller capacity will discharge slower as they have a higher resistance than the ones with higher capacity.
Watch this video here with a 5Ah and 300Ah battery in parallel: ruclips.net/video/fQz7vZEYLfY/видео.html
Not the case, please don't reply if you are not qualified to answer the question.@@dougle03
I have learned a lot from you Andy. Greetings from Philippines! I wonder how much spark is happening inside the breakers whenever you turned it on/off under big loads. Doing it always might harm the contacts of the mcb. Am i right? Should it be better if we put high amp switch inline one of the poles? Turning on the mcb first before the high amp switch and the switch first before the mcb when turning off. The switch will do the on/off thing and the mcb for overload. And the switch i think is much cheaper to replace. But i dont know which pole is best to connect the switch tho.
Very nice explanation with Spongebob 😅
very good. thank you!!!
Hang on a mo!!! Andy was that you I see burning a fossil fuel or was I still tripping???
You got your money's worth out of that sponge dear boy!
Luv ya
Gaz 🏴
Great test, would it make any difference if you connect the charging cables diagonal. Positive on bottom battery and negitive on the top battery ? That is the way that Victron recommends connecting parallel batteries.
That would become a series connection, and the voltage will increase. 51.2+51.2 = 102.4V
@@furyjk98, I think Douglas means that the top pack sees more parasitic resistence of the cables than the bottom packs. By connecting e.g. the positive to the top pack and the negative to the bottom pack (= diagonal), the parasitic resistence is more evenly spread across the packs.
Thanks you are correct and you understands what I was trying to explain,@@ThePetervangils
I have my battery shelf just connected from the top and did not run the negative cable all the way down just to connect it to the busbar there.
I have also done the same with the Seplos Polo batteries and the aluminium busbar I installed at the back. I feed this form the top.
Theoretically, the top battery sees a bit of a higher voltage while charging and a lower voltage while discharging than the other batteries. From my experience this difference is so small though that it would not matter much.
In larger installations (maybe 6+ batteries in parallel) and much higher charge and discharge currents I would connected them across as well.
Nice one Andy, thank you for sharing this experience🙏 I'm planning to mix at least two types of batteries and I'm glad to see, from your test, exactly what I would expect to see. My mix is going to be a little extreme as I have one 5.12Kvh and one just under 16kWh. PS) Yes, the Zketech 40A is a must and I'm glad to have it as part of my test equipment.
Thanks. That should be no problem connecting the 5.1kWh with the 16kWh battery. Exactly what I had here in the test.
Great Test, I connected 6 Large Capacitors in parallel with 4x 18650 batteries to make 12v jumper battery. I hope it works!
Use 6 3000F super caps in series no batteries required.
@@universeisundernoobligatio3283...at great expense of course....
Energy needs to come from somewhere...@@universeisundernoobligatio3283
I have LTO batteries here someone send me. He had them as a 12V starter battery connected.
If LTO batteries were as cheap as Lipo4 batteries, I'd build big bank of them.
Is it better to charge them separately before connecting them ?
Hi Andy. Please always connect parallel batteries diagonally. Meaning i.e. one lead on the negativ of the bottom battery and the other on the positiv of the top battery.
Then the currents actually tell you something.
Hola, I would like to see this same test but with parralle brass bar each side of battery pack instead of cable from top to bottom. I love this show !
There is no way to do this with packs that do not have the same pole/ terminal spacing....... That is why he used cables.... if all the batteries are the same make and model this is doable, otherwise not.
What do you expect from brass connections instead of the cables I used?
Will this work if you don’t have batteries with BMS’s that can be set at a certain cutoff charge?
Based on your testing, which BMS do you recommend as the most stable/durable for a hybrid system. (S16-2P, 100A)
I have been testing Daly (with Daly active load balancer and parallel board. The Calls are 138Ah BYD blade cells. Set up is S16-2p. 2 battery packs in parallel. the BMSs work well for a few months but then start losing connecting with one or more cells, showing those particular cell"s" at lower voltage than they real are, Which in turn end up damaging the cell"s".
The new JK-BMS is just at the doorstep, so probably wait for the test results. That would get my recommendation.
Is it perhaps possible to connect 2 several bms? Pace and seplos?
What bms do you recommend with lifepo? Have a griwatt 12kw off grid split phase inverter and a 16s 2 parrell 3.2-48v lifepo pack, having lots of trouble keeping the cells balanced
have you got any sodium batteries for testing? (CAL)
Yes
Does this means I can connect my two batteries 200Ah and 100Ah in parallel and use them as one 300Ah battery permanently? I wanted to try, but wouldn't like to damage something..
Exactly correct. Enjoy your growing power bank :)
Makes sure every battery has its own BMS and circuit breaker. They also need to have the same voltage, cell count and chemistry. Example, 51.2V, 16s, LiFePO4
Does this video mean thatt its not necessary for me to balance my lifepo4 cells with a power supply before connecting them to my overkill brand bms?
You should still top balance your single cells to ensure they run optimally as a pack.
What would you say about using rack mount batteries wired with drop in style lifepo4 batteries? I have some 48 volt rack and several 12 volt drop ins and would like to use the drop ins in my system, only problem I see is that the 12 volt drop ins have a PCM (protection circuit module) instead of a BMS
Yeah, probably don't do that. You also need to find out if the 12V batteries can be connected in series with such a PCM and can withstand the higher voltage in case one turns of.
@@OffGridGarageAustralia my thoughts to but figured another expert opinion couldn't hurt.
Can you do this with different BMS example a Pace and a Seplos?
Is it possible also paralel blue cells baterie lifepo?
you have them daisy chained in parallel. In theory is it ecaxtly the same if they are in parallel via centralised busbar? same results?
Personally, SOC% is not important; what is important is the small voltage delta.
3:00 min 20% SOC, max 80% SOC... hmmm. well since these all have PACE BMS with charge current limit circuit, it is definitely OK to parallel them even when one of them is 100% SOC, while the others are at 0% - because there is a charge current limit circuit.
However those other BMSes in the battery 2.0 without charge current limit circuit, its gonna be xxxxx.
PS: Charge Current Limit and Over Current Protection circuits are not same. The latter stops charging when over current, the former limits the charge current when a threshold is reached.
The BMS will cut off charging if the current exceeds allowed, there is no moderation of the current by each BMS...
Yes, the Pace and Seplos BMS have current limiter, so it keeps them save. As we saw, there was only a mere 30A between the 80% and 20% battery.
However, I have done this a few times with my battery shelf as well and if the current gets too high, the BMS will simply disconnect the battery, wait a moment and tries again. It may do this a few times until the voltage has equalized and the current is below the protection settings.
Andy have you a hazard warning sign on your garage with all those batteries ?
Yes, of course.
It doesn't matter. Hello! From the Netherlands 😁
Hello! 👋
Super my buddy
🥈silver for you
Could the BMSs be connected in any meaningful way in this configuration to an inverter ?
Better of using a single shunt to feed the inverter with information (Battery voltage, SOC). So long as the total battery capacity is properly set there would be no reason for the inverter to 'see' all of the batteries....
What would be a meaningful way in your terms?
There are some (small) benefits in having the BMS talkig to the inverter, but as the other viewer suggested, get a shunt in front of all your batteries and forget about the communication to the inverter. Unless you have a super large system, it's not really a huge benefit.
Thanks Andy - I suppose I'm trying to get my head around whether/how to mix two SunSynk 5.3kWh LifePO4s with a Seplos Mason 280L DIY kit in the future - I think you've covered how to use Victron kit in the past as a simpler more compact solution than your shelf bank, so I'll re-watch those videos when the time comes. I would then probably add SolarAssistant for monitoring battery packs as well as for controlling the SunSynk inverter.
Can you connect LTO with LFP in parallel?
Nice....
Heya, because the flet charge curf of LiFiPo4 is differant then lion ( 18650 ) we have to charge differantly and LiFiPo4 holds lot's of high Ah you need an active balancer with some nice amp's balancing current but the active balancer only start balancing in the high end of the CC. that's what I have learned from all the test's that you have done. thanks for that and all the hours of enterteanment.
Hi Andy, nice video (again). Suggestion for an experiment: how does parasitic resistence affect the load on 2 (identical) parallel batteries. E.g. 2 batteries in parrallel where 1 pack gets longer cables and/or additional connectors. My expectation is that the pack with the lowest parasitic resistence, will see the biggest load (= delta in SoC). But how much? Is it significant? Would it wear out one pack significantly faster than the other pack?
Yes, that's a good experiment as well. I have many batteries connected with different cable lengths and it is very interesting to watch what is happening during charging and discharging.
I'll put your suggestion on my list. Thanks.
👍
Hi,
you are connecting and disconnecting a lot of batteries. Maybe using forklift battery connectors might ease your work. They are available as 80, 169, 320 and 640 amps as a standard.
Thanks for your great video!
BR Björn
Thank you, Bjoern. I will need to look at something better in the future, definitely. I have some upgrade to to for this area anyway. It is really just a temporary setup.
How about discharging of battery different amp? Many people set their inverter to cut off at 10% or 20% Soc to reserve their battery life cycle. Once we mix battery with different capacity the smaller one will go off 0% while the bigger one still provide power ...
0:04 oh lord, I'm hungry now!
Same here...
Great
❤
Would it do the same? If the biggest ah batteries are at the lower state of charge from the beginning?
It makes no difference what the SOC is they will alwasys charge normally to 100% the only difference is the highest capacity will take the majority of the power.
Exactly what ☝this person said.. The pack with the lowest SOC at that time will sink the most current..... The pack with the biggest AH rating will take the longest to charge and will take the most energy to "fill up", where as the smaller the AH rating the faster it will charge. But, in the end they should all equal out at "100%" SOC.
Love these tests you do! all the blublah about how not to mix different brands is crap! Electricity laws dont change because of a brand
❤❤❤❤❤
Haven't we already done a test like this?
No, not on this channel. And even if so, there are always new viewers ...
Could someone Tell me If i need an Interface mk3-usb to Set Up a victron Multiplus 2 or can i Set IT Up with cerbo gx connected via LAN cable🤔
If you plan on using it as an ESS I think you will need the mk3 cable in order to enable the ESS assistant in the multiplus..
@@223Sako OK, thank you👍
You can, once you have connected the CAN of the inverter and the GX or VX and have setup your Victron account and dashboard and configured your VX/ GX to connect to the account, use the VE Configure Software on your PC and then create, save and export the config file, then connect to the Victron dashboard and through the internet you can load your config file up to the inverter, (Andy has a video showing this). BE WARNED! If you do this, there are certain programming levels that need to stop the inverter to complete. This means the inverter WILL SWITCH OFF and if you are powering your devices from that inverter you can brick the inverter if it loses power and programming signal at the wrong or (right) time. Just make sure that what you are using to power the rest of the equipment from can maintain power while you do this. The inverter also needs a stable mains input during this time. This is very important.......
@@GapRecordingsNamibia thank you very much for your detailed advice, i think i will better Order the MK3 too, to be on the save side. Thank you👍
@@dirk_p My pleasure. But, using the Mk3 dongle or not, the power supply issues remain the same, all during programming the mains supply must remain constant to all your devices.
Seems the 1st battery has reduced it's capacity, though it shows SOC as 100%, FCC and RM shows 91.7 AH. Looks like BMS prob to me.
That's just a calculation of the BMS. It has nothing to do with the real SOH. I have done a lot of testing with these batteries and BMS including disconnecting the BMS sot he calculation is off until they are calibrated again.
They should not show this number anywhere as people may freak out 😉
Like# 397 - no notification again!
Ma abiti in australia ? Li c'è sempre sole o c'è anche inverno con nebbia e freddo?
Hello! 👋