Partition of India, Jinnah and the Future of Pakistan | Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed | Episode-3

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024

Комментарии • 38

  • @jabarnews7476
    @jabarnews7476 2 года назад +7

    Nehru is criticized not because he supported muslims..but his mistakes of taking Kashmir issue to UN and 1962 war mistake..

  • @shaheenmalik7232
    @shaheenmalik7232 2 года назад +3

    Bahot sahi frmaya Dr sb ne 💯

  • @shids2158
    @shids2158 2 года назад +2

    thanks for this

  • @hardayaldawra1458
    @hardayaldawra1458 Год назад

    I got this book, Jinnah yesterday and started reading.

  • @hardayaldawra1458
    @hardayaldawra1458 Год назад +2

    Why did you attack Mumbai and India’s temples? And target Hindus of Kashmir? We cannot trust you.

  • @adarshpatel8567
    @adarshpatel8567 2 года назад +9

    Jawarharlal Nehru was responsible for Kashmir Blunder.. He shouldn't have taken the Kashmir matter to the UN..
    Nehru was also responsible for loss of 1962 war with China.. where Air Force was not used.. FYI, in 1962, Indian Airforce was stronger than the Chinese.. And we lost Aksai Chin to China.. That's why Nehru is blamed for the Jammu and Kashmir Blunder..
    Had Sardar Patel given the leverage to deal Kashmir issue, the all wars India-Pakistan fought wouldn't have happened

    • @suchitaguria2134
      @suchitaguria2134 2 года назад +1

      Do you even understand the situation of India wasn't what it is today, Stop the rhetoric that you have been fed and educate yourself first

    • @adarshpatel8567
      @adarshpatel8567 2 года назад +4

      @@suchitaguria2134 Rhetoric?? I don't see a word in your argument that i can call a fact..
      1. Nehru shouldn't have taken the Kashmir matter to the UN and should have secured the remaining areas of the JK as we had the Instrument of Accession..
      2. IAF had strategic advantage in 1962, cuz indian air bases were in lower heights than the Chinese on the Tibetan Plateau.. read more about 1962 and you will know, how Nehru ignored the initial agression bt China at Arunachal Pradesh.. Even the USSR didn't came for help in 1962.. He was delusional leader “Hindi Chini Bhai Bhai"
      He never deserved PMship..It was Sardar
      3. Had JK not divided into parts, the whole history of India would have been different.. No Wars with Pakistan

    • @adarshpatel8567
      @adarshpatel8567 2 года назад +5

      @@suchitaguria2134 One more.. Gifting of Coco island to Myanmar, on which today China is sitting..
      Gifting of islands to Sri Lanka which belonged to Tamil People from ancient times
      There are numerous blunders that Nehru did.. Yes he was a good leader, who gave a firm bas to this newly independent nation..
      But don't forget the blunders that he did years ago and we are suffering due to those even today in the 22nd year of 21st century

    • @hardayaldawra1458
      @hardayaldawra1458 Год назад

      Kashmir issue. Sardar Patel was equally responsible in decision making.

  • @shaheenmalik7232
    @shaheenmalik7232 2 года назад +2

    Great great 👍

  • @devendrasingh681
    @devendrasingh681 2 года назад +2

    I respect Ishtiaq Ahmed, but he is totally biased towards Sardar Patel and Jawaharlal Nehru.
    How could someone unit India into one nation without a comprehensive vision. Also I would say that Jawaharlal Nehru did not have a comprehensive vision. That's why he refused the seat of the United Nations and also advocated giving this seat to China... how can you say that he was a visionary?
    He was always do appeasement politics. for example, he reformed in one community and free hand to other community.

    • @shubhamrawat530
      @shubhamrawat530 2 года назад

      bhai suppose INDIA USA k kehne pe UNSC ki permanent seat k liye haa bol deta to kya USSR uspe VETO nhi krta? and vice versa.. i dont NEHRU & PATEL visnery the ya nhi but tum chutiya ho without any doubt. khud soch UN k charter m likha UNSC koi v change jb sari VETO power agree krengi kya..

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    🧡♥️🧡♥️🧡

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    💚💙💚💙💚

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    🖤💜🖤💜🖤

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    💜❤️💜❤️💜

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    ❤️🧡❤️🧡❤️

  • @vijaykrish64
    @vijaykrish64 2 года назад

    I am starting to like your videos Jabraan!

  • @hulkman4351
    @hulkman4351 2 года назад +1

    Modi ji also said muslim bache ke haath me computer aur ek haath me Quran hona chahiye.....

  • @harisadu8998
    @harisadu8998 2 года назад

    Ishtiaq sahab, Dina Wadia claims that as a Khoja, many aspects of Hindu law apply rather than normal Islamic law for inheritance. Hence, she claimed Jinnah's bombay house. Nusli Wadia is still a claimant based on Dina Wadia's claim.
    Another interesting allegation has come up that the Nehru government was supposed to hand over Jinnah's bombay house to the Mohatta family if the Mohatta family gave up their palace to the Pakistani government. However this didn't happen. The Pakistani house belongs to the government and is a museum and the Jinnah house (South Court) in Bombay is still under dispute from multiple parties with no final settlement, which is a real shame because it is a valuable property on very valuable land (around 955 crore pakistani rupees or even more!).

  • @hardayaldawra1458
    @hardayaldawra1458 Год назад

    Gandhi was visionary, he chose Nehru for PM besides congress voted Patel

  • @hardayaldawra1458
    @hardayaldawra1458 Год назад +1

    Keep Mullahism aside. Let it not become part of your life.

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    ♥️🧡♥️🧡♥️

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    ❤️💜❤️💜❤️

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    💙💚💙💚💙

  • @muhtesem1946
    @muhtesem1946 2 года назад +1

    ♥️💙♥️💙♥️