Punishment is at best irrelevent, a waste of time and effort. At worse it is counterproductive. Righting the wrongs is the immediate and most important act of change. Finding ways of transfomring the tragedy into a civilized peace is the only worthy cause.
@@jorge227able1 He is an expert in his Field. Experts tend to know a lot and remember all of it. He knows his human rights violations and violators like a surgeon knows his anatomy and a lawyer knows his tax loopholes.
@S Biswas If right wingers unknowingly support the ideology behind these war motivations, then it is what it is. But sorry, he cracks down on the political left in the US all the time for equal share, if not worse.
@@inoshikachokonoyarobakayar2493 The person I responded to has deleted their comment. Why on earth would you then respond to me without seeing the context of the type of person I was answering?
How is "patriot" a compliment? Patriotism, nationalism, fascism... they're all tied together. Why would anyone die or kill for their country is beyond me... A country is just a government, a flag is just a piece of fabric.
What a well informed, in-depth observation of Gaza. It’s such a hopeless situation. People such as yourself and Gideon Levy are the voice for the voiceless.Thank you Max. Stay Blessed.
I disagree emphatically. He gives one side and assumes that side is voiceless. Most of the world agrees with the "voiceless." By writing that, you are imo, spewing narrative without thinking about the truth of which group is voiceless. A sliver of the world sides with Israel. Very few understand the actual history or anything about the Jews of Israel.
Tha k you to Max for sure, so much deceit and we can infact all have love for one another instead of fighting as it is wanted for us to believe, believing we might fight to be safe, is danger to our families
I find it astonishing that it has taken me this long to realize the extent of this injustice; and I used to have a good imagination and a compassionate sensibility, but over the years I've become war-weary. I appreciate being jolted out of my malaise with these poignant reports; even though I would rather ignore this. We must shake the gates of power. I'll share this with my Congressman, asap. I'm sorry you had to experience such depravity and sorrow, Max.
It’s not a coincidence that this information isn’t readily available so don’t be too hard on yourself. When Seymour Hersh left the NewYorker that was arguably the last decent/honest investigative journalist in main stream American journalism. Anyone relying on CNN, FOX, NYT or WSJ are not just uninformed but misinformed. Very few people are interested or even open to information which contradicts or requires a realignment of their worldview. You’re an exception. But you’re gonna find yourself increasingly isolated. You’re better off forgetting this truth and I hopeful that you have. I hope you just say “it’s complicated” and tell ppl to consult the Ministry of Truth. PS: Tell me your congressman and I’ll tell you how much money they received from AIPAC, Jewish World Congress and other Zionist lobbying groups.
Telling the truth, sharing our understandings, listening to each other and making sure to be heard and navigating the rifts designed for us, that for all sides it is love, and in standing together the only answers
As an American, I am deeply ashamed by the US funding and complicity in these horrors and the use of my tax dollars. We share the responsibility and shame. Support the BDS Movement!
I can imagine he's at near the top of hit list of many people. There are many people wants him voiceless(dead). It makes me wonder what's the price tag on his head. And he knows that more than anybody else. He must be the most courageous(and fearless) man in the world today.
He wants to right the wrong his People are doing. He is clarifying the difference between Israelis and Zionists. We should not reiterate our fears for him, only bless him.
Not too many human beings on earth like Max. He is a beautiful, truthful, courageous soul that reports the truth no matter how painful it is. Thank you Max. We see and hear you. We respect you and pray that you continue on. Your books are amazing.
I'm new to Max and all those at Grayzone, Max is a rarity compelled by truth and justice, something our elected officials no nothing of. What a tragedy our complacency as citizens has unleashed on the world.
One of the sources I get my news from is The Grayzone. The corporate media just spreads the lies of the state & is there to entertain & manufacture consent.
Mad Blumenthal is my little hero! No doubt in my mind,one of the most original & extremely intellectual journalists that this s****y world has been blessed wit!!!! Keep up the good work? & God bless the GRAY ZONE. MOST SINCERELY MICHAEL FOLEY ESQ:
Max Blumenthal is an exceptional reporter. Because of the horror of the Israeli army he first-hand is reporting he also has to control his own emotions. We can see this struggle with his representation which makes it so authentic and true. Thank you Mr Blumenthal for your engagement for truth of the Palestinian tragedy.
My heart hurts , this is 5 years old !!!! MA you are so good at explaining the situation in real terms ! How we can celebrate " Christmas" in this country with this lived reality by the peoples of the " Holy Land" God save Palestine !
This video needs to be widely shared again today as the genocide in Gaza rages on. Blumenthal is brilliant - a concise and effective communicator. This 8-year-old report on the '51-day War" is a chilling indictment of Israel's historically ongoing war crimes and of their clear intent (now and then). So much respect for this man and his commitment to the truth
I've just watched this video which is now nearly four years old, and it reminded me of how utterly genocidal Israel's policy is towards a whole nation. I've also had to remind myself of the fact that this Israeli mass murder policy is constantly there even though we are forced to sometimes turn our attention away from it and live our normal lives. I'm in Ireland, the Republic of Ireland, and here the vast majority of people are sympathetic to the Palestinians. We empathize with them as our history was similar to Palestine as a nation occupied by British colonialism, extant in the north of our country, but that's another story. However, our government, no matter which party is in power never reflects the true feelings and attitude of the overwhelming majority of Irish people for the Palestinians. American economic and political power and hegemony, extends into our ruling power system, preventing any serious expression of our nation's support for Palestine. I don't know if Max Blumenthal has visited Ireland or not. If not I hope he does come and speaks to the issues of how we can dislodge American/Israeli power from our so-called democratic governing system.
I feel what you mean. I am from Somalia and I used to do the same Max is doing talking in details how the fight went in our town but now I am in England i can't remember what i was doing yesterday so much worries disappointment just i am angry with me.
This should have a billion views… it should. It’s an injustice more people refuse to view things from a different perspective. They want so badly to believe Israel is good. That somehow, although human, that they are incapable of evil. They want to believe that Judaism is the same as Z!onism. It is not.
Am reading "Goliath" at the moment. As one who served in the Vietnam War as an infantryman, I thought that I had seen inhumanity to man, but in comparison to the Israelis, we were certified saints.
God Bless Max. I wish the people in the US would her about this. Death destruction 2014 & 2021 ..the crimes still continue. Great to know how our $$ is being spent & our BEST friend in Democracy is acting. This is criminal
He should get a world citezenship, so he can bring the real news through history,facts and main cause of the war,unjust&caos in the every corner of the world. MAX , you are true, journalist of the world,GOODLUCK to your journalisam journey.
Bellum omnium contra omnes, war of one class against others, is the translation. The means of competing are not in everyone's hands in America and that is how the politicians want it. The question is what is to be done about that?
we listen to proponents of both sides but only hashem knows whose heart is bound to truth no matter the cost what is really in bibi's heart and what is in the heart of this sincere young man
If you search hard enough you can find the footage of Bibi that will give you your answer. He hasn’t always been as guarded and vague as he is on MSM. I have no question who’s lying and if you look hard enough you won’t either.
53:56 He's right, "The Lab" by Yotam Feldman is one of the best documentaries on Israeli society ever made. It is currently on youtube for free and worth the watch.
Max' arrest has only highlighted the importance of his work.
humanidee HU-MANNA-DEE ✊🏼✌️🌅
israel committed many acts of terror and war crimes but still hasnt been punished once
Winners and the USA are never held responsible for war crimes
some people with bad humor might suggest "they" have been "punished" beforehand...
They haven't even stopped the acts of terror!
Just this week bombing Gaza for an alarm going off.
Punishment is at best irrelevent, a waste of time and effort. At worse it is counterproductive. Righting the wrongs is the immediate and most important act of change. Finding ways of transfomring the tragedy into a civilized peace is the only worthy cause.
DmeshOnPS3 The international criminal court wants to go into Israel. But the PM isn’t allowing it. What is Israel hiding
Max, you’re more effective than any military weapon. I just hope there is still humanity left in America.
Most Americans still believe an Arab in a cave did 911 - What Hope.
We need Tulsi. She brings the Humanity out in People.
There isn't any!
@@billhanna8838
😂😂😂😂
@@hakunamatata887 "5 Dancing Israelis - We were there to document the event " ????
I really respect this guy. He's extremely informed. He shows this in every talk/interview he gives. You can tell he really does his homework.
Agreed. Mr. Blumenthal has impressed me more than once, Tsar Nicholas ll.
couldn't agree more our majesty
I think he might has imaginative memory or some kind of autistic thing where he can remember names easily.
@@jorge227able1 He is an expert in his Field. Experts tend to know a lot and remember all of it. He knows his human rights violations and violators like a surgeon knows his anatomy and a lawyer knows his tax loopholes.
Oh please, he is No expert. He spews narratives and quotes from radical unreliable sources or spins more reliable sources to make them fit his agenda.
The whole world should be watching, Max. Stay safe.
You can't fool all the people all the time is what he's saying.
@@OwenSichone He is fooling you with narrative.
It's tragic that this video has only 31,000 views. Whilst Millions are exposed to Israeli lies.
31K in 4 years; almost to 61K in the last 11 months. It is gaining momentum. I am sharing it.
80k, so much more info ofc too thou
This is a true American patriot
This is a real human being.
@S Biswas
If right wingers unknowingly support the ideology behind these war motivations, then it is what it is. But sorry, he cracks down on the political left in the US all the time for equal share, if not worse.
@@virtuousglean7216 So what? The left is infallible? Telling the truth "is what it is."
@@inoshikachokonoyarobakayar2493
The person I responded to has deleted their comment. Why on earth would you then respond to me without seeing the context of the type of person I was answering?
How is "patriot" a compliment? Patriotism, nationalism, fascism... they're all tied together. Why would anyone die or kill for their country is beyond me... A country is just a government, a flag is just a piece of fabric.
Excellent Talk. Wow. Good luck to you while you tell the world the truth.
What a well informed, in-depth observation of Gaza. It’s such a hopeless situation. People such as yourself and Gideon Levy are the voice for the voiceless.Thank you Max. Stay Blessed.
The ones that stole Palestine are still around today embedded in the West and ruling it.
I disagree emphatically. He gives one side and assumes that side is voiceless. Most of the world agrees with the "voiceless." By writing that, you are imo, spewing narrative without thinking about the truth of which group is voiceless. A sliver of the world sides with Israel. Very few understand the actual history or anything about the Jews of Israel.
Connecting the aggression to the Israeli business interests is a great point.
It made everything clear and very easy to understand to me.
We are all blessed to have Max in our lives.
No we are not. He has a nice speaking voice but spews narrative as if it were fact and most of what he says is simply Not fact.
Tha k you to Max for sure, so much deceit and we can infact all have love for one another instead of fighting as it is wanted for us to believe, believing we might fight to be safe, is danger to our families
WE NEED MORE MAX BLUMENTHALS IN THE U.S. SPREADING THE WORD OF TRUTH FOR PALESTINE! GOD BLESS AND KEEP YOU ALWAYS
Gov't may try to silence you but your arrest has revitalized your old videos.
Keep speaking truth
I find it astonishing that it has taken me this long to realize the extent of this injustice; and I used to have a good imagination and a compassionate sensibility, but over the years I've become war-weary. I appreciate being jolted out of my malaise with these poignant reports; even though I would rather ignore this. We must shake the gates of power. I'll share this with my Congressman, asap. I'm sorry you had to experience such depravity and sorrow, Max.
It’s not a coincidence that this information isn’t readily available so don’t be too hard on yourself. When Seymour Hersh left the NewYorker that was arguably the last decent/honest investigative journalist in main stream American journalism. Anyone relying on CNN, FOX, NYT or WSJ are not just uninformed but misinformed.
Very few people are interested or even open to information which contradicts or requires a realignment of their worldview. You’re an exception. But you’re gonna find yourself increasingly isolated. You’re better off forgetting this truth and I hopeful that you have. I hope you just say “it’s complicated” and tell ppl to consult the Ministry of Truth.
PS: Tell me your congressman and I’ll tell you how much money they received from AIPAC, Jewish World Congress and other Zionist lobbying groups.
Telling the truth, sharing our understandings, listening to each other and making sure to be heard and navigating the rifts designed for us, that for all sides it is love, and in standing together the only answers
Wow this detailed information Matt provides in this lecture is simply outstanding. Kudos!
To be such an Authority comes with a cost. A genuine well-deserved respect. I salute you Max.
Deeply much, and the others he has named
As an American, I am deeply ashamed by the US funding and complicity in these horrors and the use of my tax dollars. We share the responsibility and shame. Support the BDS Movement!
Long live Max Blumenthal and freedom of speech :(
Why sad face
I can imagine he's at near the top of hit list of many people.
There are many people wants him voiceless(dead).
It makes me wonder what's the price tag on his head.
And he knows that more than anybody else.
He must be the most courageous(and fearless) man in the world today.
They have him locked up now for some bullshit lies. Hope he’s guarded better than Epstein.
Next to Assange, Max is a modern day hero. Another Thomas Paine, George Orwell.
He wants to right the wrong his People are doing. He is clarifying the difference between Israelis and Zionists. We should not reiterate our fears for him, only bless him.
@@highjinx6519 Max got out, and has been interviewed on the Grayzone. He awaits the bogus trial.
@@cambriawellness3102 I read the charges against Max have been dropped.
MAX is the BEST example of goodness, smartness,
pureness,
trueness, in an American Man! ❣️🙏 Many blessings!
Max Blumenthal grows more impressive by the hour to me. He is a great man, a brave man and a brilliant journalist.
Making up stuff is not good journalism.
@@MrBoBoTom Good thing he is so factual and careful about his sources.
@@comingviking lol
@@MrBoBoTom Everything he writes is referenced. Zero retractions. More than you can say about msm.
@@MrBoBoTom I agree, most of what he says is based on a grain of truth or entirely made up.
Not too many human beings on earth like Max. He is a beautiful, truthful, courageous soul that reports the truth no matter how painful it is. Thank you Max. We see and hear you. We respect you and pray that you continue on. Your books are amazing.
Got so much love for this guy!!!Good information sir MAX.Thank you 😎
Thank you Max for speaking the truth.
Thank you so much for inviting Blumenthal
I really wish a Transcript was available, though. :(
Show transcript is available in video description o:D
Thank you max for speaking out and telling the truth on the situation.
I'm new to Max and all those at Grayzone, Max is a rarity compelled by truth and justice, something our elected officials no nothing of. What a tragedy our complacency as citizens has unleashed on the world.
Tragically Beautiful storytelling, thank you, Max. I can’t stop crying. (2019)
2024, like 20 years been listening and people don't understand/;
I had read a book about this, but Max really gives the details of the war.
Max, people like you give me hope!
One of the sources I get my news from is The Grayzone. The corporate media just spreads the lies of the state & is there to entertain & manufacture consent.
I wish all journalists would be like Max Blumental.
They would all be in jail.
Mad Blumenthal is my little hero! No doubt in my mind,one of the most original & extremely intellectual journalists that this s****y world has been blessed wit!!!! Keep up the good work? & God bless the GRAY ZONE.
MOST SINCERELY MICHAEL FOLEY ESQ:
Max Blumenthal is an exceptional reporter. Because of the horror of the Israeli army he first-hand is reporting he also has to control his own emotions. We can see this struggle with his representation which makes it so authentic and true. Thank you Mr Blumenthal for your engagement for truth of the Palestinian tragedy.
Max Blumenthal, you are the best. I follow all your work. If anyone wants to know the truth about something they need to listen to you.
Very informative.
Max, you're fearless. Thanks for your work on exposing Israel's apartheid and occupation.
Holy hell this was dynamite but very interesting.
Highly disturbing, disgusting and disappointing this has been going on for so long
My heart hurts , this is 5 years old !!!! MA you are so good at explaining the situation in real terms ! How we can celebrate " Christmas" in this country with this lived reality by the peoples of the " Holy Land" God save Palestine !
This video needs to be widely shared again today as the genocide in Gaza rages on. Blumenthal is brilliant - a concise and effective communicator. This 8-year-old report on the '51-day War" is a chilling indictment of Israel's historically ongoing war crimes and of their clear intent (now and then). So much respect for this man and his commitment to the truth
I am black South African so this interests me.
During the apartheid era, Israel, South Africa and USA, always clung together; a federation of low-lifes.
I've just watched this video which is now nearly four years old, and it reminded me of how utterly genocidal Israel's policy is towards a whole nation. I've also had to remind myself of the fact that this Israeli mass murder policy is constantly there even though we are forced to sometimes turn our attention away from it and live our normal lives. I'm in Ireland, the Republic of Ireland, and here the vast majority of people are sympathetic to the Palestinians. We empathize with them as our history was similar to Palestine as a nation occupied by British colonialism, extant in the north of our country, but that's another story. However, our government, no matter which party is in power never reflects the true feelings and attitude of the overwhelming majority of Irish people for the Palestinians. American economic and political power and hegemony, extends into our ruling power system, preventing any serious expression of our nation's support for Palestine. I don't know if Max Blumenthal has visited Ireland or not. If not I hope he does come and speaks to the issues of how we can dislodge American/Israeli power from our so-called democratic governing system.
Max has a sense of humor
How the hell do you remember so much in fine detail ?... I can't remember what I do from one day to the next...
I feel what you mean. I am from Somalia and I used to do the same Max is doing talking in details how the fight went in our town but now I am in England i can't remember what i was doing yesterday so much worries disappointment just i am angry with me.
He is passionate with the injustice, I admire him and his ability for being a soldier of truth.
Thanks YT for recommending I watch this again. Hope NuttinYahoo goes to jail.
I agreed with you a year ago, and even more this day
Great stuff. Thanks a ton, for this!!
April 04-2021, Thanks for exposing their crimes.
I respect this journalist
Based on the questions, it seems Jews are more concerned with protecting the image of Israel and Jews than with justice.
Very important info, to make an opinion.
Max alone gives möre news then all fake nieuws combined.
Thank you max and all who speak the truth. And bring awarness
May God protect you. You are so brave for speaking the truth in this environment of lies.
Powerful. Thank you for the truth.
This should have a billion views… it should. It’s an injustice more people refuse to view things from a different perspective. They want so badly to believe Israel is good. That somehow, although human, that they are incapable of evil. They want to believe that Judaism is the same as Z!onism. It is not.
Revolutionary . Just another brother.
Thankyou.
Always in awe listening to Max Blumenthal This is real education on Evil people in power very very evil people
39:10
How can that be done?
Boycott apartheid Israel. Justice for Palestine 🇵🇸
"...field tested weapons." Un-@#$%ing-believable.
God Bless Max Blumenthal he is a pure genius
I appreciate U Max.. Hat tip..
The Stephen Walt and John Mearsheimer report on the influence of the Israel Lobby on U.S. Foreign Policy
Am reading "Goliath" at the moment. As one who served in the Vietnam War as an infantryman, I thought that I had seen inhumanity to man, but in comparison to the Israelis, we were certified saints.
God Bless Max. I wish the people in the US would her about this. Death destruction 2014 & 2021 ..the crimes still continue. Great to know how our $$ is being spent & our BEST friend in Democracy is acting. This is criminal
Listen. A righteous man named Max.
Max Blumenthal reminds me of a young Noam Chomsky .
God bless you sir !!!
MB is well versed and poignant. He knows his stuff and he expresses it with heart.
Max is awesome!
Max also has a good sense of humor
Nothing has changed. 30/10/2023.
He should get a world citezenship, so he can bring the real news through history,facts and main cause of the war,unjust&caos in the every corner of the world. MAX , you are true, journalist of the world,GOODLUCK to your journalisam journey.
My anonymous friends enlightened me about the Palestinian persecution by Israel 6 years ago.
Damn, this is hard to hear, I am overwhelmed by empathy. And we are guilty of murder, are we not the sole supporter of this gang of terrorist.
Thank you Max!!!!!!!!!!
Very good and very true speech from Max Blumenthal.
I’m an American but live in Glasgow. I’ve been to Nice ‘n Sleazy many times, and I’ve never been thrown out.
Are you female? I think he said males in Scotland. Maybe when females get drunk they don’t sound American?
Allah bless You Max. Allah bless you.
Nothing so say😭😭😭 until now Israelis are murdering the Palestinian.
Outstanding
I respect Max Blumenthal!!! Thank you max
What a beautiful world🎵
Buy the book!
Is it me or did he not answer that last lil old lady’s question? Other than that I’m impressed with his heart and his knowledge.
"stay human." Vic Arrigoni before Israel killed him
Bellum omnium contra omnes, war of one class against others, is the translation.
The means of competing are not in everyone's hands in America and that is how the politicians want it.
The question is what is to be done about that?
You know exactly what has to be done.
That lady in the black had no idea what she signed up for. Talk about uncomfortable 😂😂😂
Deflections, equivocations, obfuscation, and hypocrisy. So intellectual.
What a great man… max
we listen to proponents of both sides but only hashem knows whose heart is bound to truth no matter the cost what is really in bibi's heart and what is in the heart of this sincere young man
If you search hard enough you can find the footage of Bibi that will give you your answer. He hasn’t always been as guarded and vague as he is on MSM. I have no question who’s lying and if you look hard enough you won’t either.
Long live communism and freedom
Just as relevant today as it was a decade ago
I think its time to stop giving them money then if they are laying to you
Yes Winger the APAC IS CENSORING THIS.
Just curious how other anti-Zionist Jews get along with family who are strident, patriotic supporters of this apartheid regime.
Carla Cohen founded Politics and Prose. Do you think Blumenthal would be allowed to speak there if she was still alive?
True American patriot!!!
53:56 He's right, "The Lab" by Yotam Feldman is one of the best documentaries on Israeli society ever made. It is currently on youtube for free and worth the watch.
This is soooo difficult to listen to 😭
You go brother.