Ramses Shaffy and Liesbeth List, Pastorale (with English subtitles) REACTION!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии • 55

  • @MLWitteman
    @MLWitteman Год назад +65

    Probably one of the most beautiful songs every written in the Dutch language. The incredible instruments from the orchestra, combined with the poetic lyrics makes this a small treasure for the ears. I’m really proud that this song was written and composed by my fellow Haarlemmers: Boudewijn de Groot & Lennaert Nijgh. But it couldn’t be performed better than by Ramses Shaffy & Liesbeth List. These 4 truly created a masterpiece with this song.

    • @Tuinlaaf
      @Tuinlaaf Год назад +14

      Totally agree with the above. One of the most beautiful musical pieces in the Dutch language. Also kudo's to the one who subtitled this, he or she did an amazing job. Not translating word by word, but somewhat looser to better convey the meaning of the sentences.

    • @petermaardananders6803
      @petermaardananders6803 Год назад +2

      @@Tuinlaaf They were hopelesly in love back then, very special and it always gives me 'chicken-skin'.

    • @johnmeijer1246
      @johnmeijer1246 Год назад +1

      Totally agree. One of a kind

  • @dutchman7623
    @dutchman7623 Год назад +23

    This song mostly about their complex relationship. Every word, every sentence, refers to it.
    There is a deep double meaning to it. 'You cannot love the sun!' it will burn you, destroy you when you come too close, tear up everything you care for, yet you cannot exist without it...
    She loved him dearly, passionately, and couldn't live without him, he was her inspiration. Yet he lived a different life. Was gay, ended up in all kind of relations, got disappointed, turned to alcohol and drugs, got depressed. And every time she pulled him out of the shit and put him back on his tracks. But he wanted to be free, and unbound to anyone, so he made the same mistakes over and over again. And though she knew they couldn't have the relation she wanted, she stayed committed to him.

  • @melodiemaker86
    @melodiemaker86 Год назад +35

    Song is written by Boudewijn de Groot and great lyrics by Lennaert Nijgh. They did also "Meneer de President" also present on your channel. Ramses Shaffy is the sun and Liesbeth List the earth in this story. Greetings from The Netherlands.

    • @MarcelNL
      @MarcelNL Год назад +1

      The only thing that always has bothered me is how casual he says: "Je kunt niet houden van de zon".
      To me it felt that the writer wanted that to be expressed with much more emotion and strength. More drama perhaps.

  • @lbergen001
    @lbergen001 Год назад +22

    This is epic. Hearing this after decades again gave me goosebumps. It should be part of the Dutch Canon. Well done Ramses, Liesbeth, Boudewijn en Lennart.👍👍

    • @MarcelNL
      @MarcelNL Год назад +1

      Brings me back to my childhood. Even back then I absolutely loved this song.
      It has a special place in my heart, just like Paolo Conte's "Max". Completely different style, but it also gave me strong feelings every time I heard it.

  • @renevaanhold
    @renevaanhold Год назад +18

    A unique dutch classic song. The love between the sun and the earth.
    The singers also had a unique relationship. They loved each other but never lived together.

    • @dutchman7623
      @dutchman7623 Год назад +5

      This song is also about their complex relationship. Every word, every sentence, refers to it.
      There is a deep double meaning to it. 'You cannot love the sun!' it will burn you, destroy you when you come too close, tear up everything you care for, yet you cannot exist without it...

  • @nelvanommen9324
    @nelvanommen9324 Год назад +8

    Back to my childhood, i love them both.

  • @Chris29_11
    @Chris29_11 Год назад +4

    Aaw! Love this song for years! Still beautiful 😊

  • @katlijnroovers7357
    @katlijnroovers7357 Год назад +3

    This song stays beautiful, for.i grew up with that kind of songs thanks for this memory lane ❣️

  • @AnaryaVhargon
    @AnaryaVhargon Год назад +6

    This song always, always makes me cry and I have no clue why ...

  • @jeroent5079
    @jeroent5079 Год назад +4

    This song is way up there in my life’s Top 10 songs. Thanks for reacting to it.

  • @I.Toverheks
    @I.Toverheks Год назад +4

    I used to have an LP with this song.. sang and danced the hell out of it when i was 9 or 10 when I was alone in my room early 80s
    This and meester prikkebeen..
    I was a weird kid.
    Even then.

  • @ronaldderooij1774
    @ronaldderooij1774 Год назад +8

    I think this is the most beautiful song and music ever written in the Dutch language. The singers and songwriter had very complicated characters. The singers were deeply in love with each other for years, but never married or even shared a home. The songwriter lived on a ship in Haarlem at the time, I think (he was an alcoholic).

    • @annemariehoutenbos212
      @annemariehoutenbos212 8 месяцев назад

      Ramses Shaffey was gay, so there was no chance of him and Liesbeth List ever coming together😏

    • @taand4725
      @taand4725 29 дней назад

      ​@@annemariehoutenbos212 he was bisexual

    • @annemariehoutenbos212
      @annemariehoutenbos212 28 дней назад

      @ That’s as may be, but he did not have a sexual relationship with Liesbeth List.
      My family was close to her parents and their biggest regret was that she ended up with ‘the great’ Cees Nooteboom in stead of the man she really loved: Ramses Shaffy.🤷🏼‍♀️

  • @ad61video
    @ad61video 6 месяцев назад +2

    Its a conversation between the fiery male sun aroynd whom everything revolves and the sunloving feminine earth.

  • @reinjanmaat1839
    @reinjanmaat1839 Год назад +5

    For me this is childhood sentiment, it's nice to hear your comments on it

  • @wilmagrevenmulder6225
    @wilmagrevenmulder6225 Год назад +3

    Stays good this classic song 👍

  • @-Mieke
    @-Mieke Год назад +5

    Beautiful Dutch music history🌟❤

  • @evertvdb000
    @evertvdb000 3 месяца назад +1

    Not only in Holland, also in Belgium it's a classic.

  • @MarcelNL
    @MarcelNL Год назад +1

    NOOOOOO MY GOD!!! :D I wanted to request this one some day! (Perhaps I did mention it a few times in the comments, but I had no subs.) Awesome, gonna check right away!
    Good to see that Dutch fans here have such good taste! :D

    • @MarcelNL
      @MarcelNL Год назад

      "Simply worded"? Haha, it's poetic as hell!
      I wonder at which point you'll find out that he's supposed to be the sun in this song. :-)
      This song always reminds me of the Star Trek episode "Masks" in which Data gets influenced by some ancient alien object from an extinct species, and gets programmed to be their sun god. In the end of the episode, Picard needs to become the moon god to put him to rest.

  • @tarquinmidwinter2056
    @tarquinmidwinter2056 Год назад +1

    Sadly both Liesbeth List and Ramses Shaffy have both now departed, but they've left a lot for us to enjoy. There's a great RUclips video of them singing this duet live, both well advanced in years but still magical.

  • @jcjhudson
    @jcjhudson Год назад +5

    I LOVED this song when it first came out (yes I’m that old…lol)

  • @astridsandifort-joffer9792
    @astridsandifort-joffer9792 Год назад +3

    Love this song

  • @EricvanDorp007
    @EricvanDorp007 7 дней назад

    So beautiful!

  • @MarthaSpherical
    @MarthaSpherical Год назад +2

    Wow flash back to my youth. Great lyrics by Boudewijn de Groot 👏

  • @kellyvandijk3269
    @kellyvandijk3269 Год назад +1

    This is my all time favorite Dutch song.

  • @jeffreyscholte4737
    @jeffreyscholte4737 Год назад +2

    In 2009, a few weeks before Ramses passed away, i was figurating in a videoclip from a group and then suddenly i saw Ramses walking with his "rollator" walker, but i was afraid to ask a picture with him. That's why i do regret it a bit that i didn't ask him.

  • @tropenkindje1
    @tropenkindje1 Год назад +2

    Best Dutch song ever.

  • @ronoudshoorn5349
    @ronoudshoorn5349 5 месяцев назад +1

    a love story

  • @miran4471
    @miran4471 Год назад

    Omg i have great memories ❤️🌷

  • @sebvansteijn7227
    @sebvansteijn7227 8 месяцев назад +1

    Wagneriaans...Fantastisch...

  • @mischake
    @mischake Год назад +1

    Hey man, love your channel, always awesome to see you cover dutch videos
    I was hoping you could do one that is really dear to me:
    Boudewijn de Groot - Verdronken Vlinder

  • @chantalmelijn3652
    @chantalmelijn3652 Год назад

    The creator speaks

  • @aidanheemskerk6778
    @aidanheemskerk6778 10 месяцев назад

    After this you should listen to the song 'De Sneeuwkoningin'(The Snowqueen) a solosong by Liesbeth. It is written as a diptych with this song.

    • @HighlyCombustibleReacts
      @HighlyCombustibleReacts  10 месяцев назад

      Hi, Please add your suggestions to googleform. You can find the link under every video. Make sure it has english subtitles though. Thanks

  • @manhassetport-washington4546
    @manhassetport-washington4546 Год назад

    I think the guy has narcissistic tendencies (everything evolves around me, like the sun. You cannot love the sun), but the lady does not want to listen to his warnings... she keeps on loving him even though there is a chance that she may get burned by him.

  • @justmandy6572
    @justmandy6572 Год назад

    Love that song. Never knew what it was about though. Still don't...even with English subs, lol

    • @Tuinlaaf
      @Tuinlaaf Год назад +2

      It's about the love between the sun (shaffy) and the earth (list)

    • @justmandy6572
      @justmandy6572 Год назад

      @@Tuinlaaf thanx...im not that poetic, lol

  • @tinekew8859
    @tinekew8859 20 дней назад

    Hij is de zon en zij is de aarde

  • @katjavanderlei8402
    @katjavanderlei8402 Год назад

    To me ??? Best Dutch song ever

  • @i.w.vanderlubben3395
    @i.w.vanderlubben3395 9 месяцев назад

    Dude this stuf is about 50 years old , do you have avy clue?

  • @henkoosterink8744
    @henkoosterink8744 Год назад

    Simply worded....?

  • @meestercrypto
    @meestercrypto 29 дней назад

    Simply worded. Really?

  • @tamarys89east38
    @tamarys89east38 Год назад

    Leuk hoor ons cultuur erfgoed maar kom op man.. dit staat toch echt te ver van hem af😅
    Dit is zo Hollands... Nederlandse wordt het niet.