TOP moments of One Piece Censorhip in First Episodes
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 сен 2021
- Fandomion Anime Merch Sale:
www.fandomion.com/sale/sale?s... Please, subscribe for new videos! 😉
Hello everyone! Here you can see how studio 4kids decided to censor some moments in the legendary one piece anime. Activate the notification bell so you do not lose everything that happens on the channel, be an active subscriber !!
One Piece censorship comparison
This is 7 episode
#anime#onePiece
piece original vs 4kids,one piece 4kids,one piece censored,one piece toei animation vs 4kids 
Кино
They censored the black off his skin…
and shanks sounds like he barely knows English
Why would they censor the black skin tho it seems kinda racist ngl
@@idontsleepatall1618 "fighting racist" is the new being racist.
@@DeathGoesCrazy really did not know
The reason for the sensory was because of the lip and usually how the Portrayed black characters back in the day of western animation witch was rasist
They also made the onigiri to cookies and not donuts
Japanese: These are rice balls!
English: wtf, balls? You eat balls? Nah cancel that, make it a cookie
HAHAHAHAHA
😂😂😂😂
Also weird they had to change her hair colour as well. Like they were panicking that they didnt change enough so had to do one more thing.
And
Japanese: he’s black
4kids: OMG HES BLACK THAT NEEDS TO BE CENSORED
Biscuits*
Watching 4kids version: How did they not get hurt from that?!?
Watching the original: How did they survive that?!?
Yeah Same Here
The 4Kids era was an interesting one, to say the least. The effort they put into censorship was somewhat admirable. At the same time, though, it was clear that a studio literally called "For Kids" wasn't really meant to dub an anime like One Piece. If they wanted to live up to their name, they should've solely focused on family-oriented and kid-oriented anime, which Japan has made plenty of, believe it or not.
Thing is, they didn’t really want One Piece. Tokyo Mew Mew, the show they actually wanted, was only available in a packaged deal with OP. It was both or none. They went with the deal, and figured that they might as well do SOMETHING with OP while they had it.
@@paperluigi6132It wasn't just "May as well" they were contractually obligated to do so
I think one piece came in a packaged deal
@@paperluigi6132 That was a lie they told to save face, the actual evidence shows that they were fighting hard for the rights and outbid Funimation
Truer words were never spoken. All of the previous series they had dubbed were originally marketed towards kids and families, as such, it made little sense to market One Piece towards kids and families since it wasn't intended for them.
That's funny, in Spain they did the opposite from censoring. I remember when Luffy meets Smoker again in Arabasta he says : "I thought you had died of cancer!"😂😂
LOL I'm spanish but I didn't know that, wtf 🤣
But yeah, spanish dub is great 😂
De todas formas el doblaje español da bastante pena🤣😅
@@VictorLdVS Nah, en serio, está bien, hace bastante gracia pero lo importante está perfectamente traducido.
They grimdarked' it
Makes me glad i never saw the 4kids dub of one piece. Funimation handled this show greatly
Fr
@Guilherme Costa to be honest they just didn't censor anything
@@thunderman4412 Nah you're just a hater imo
Fr
The only thing i hate about animation is on the start and people say its bad vecause of the 1st ep animating
2:02 without the wound he just look constipated lmao
Bro- how ain't anybody replying to this goofy funny ass comment 💀
They made black characters white in 4 kids
And white characters black in the live action
Grey characters in one piece games confirmed
To be fair, the way many manga artists used to draw black characters was pretty racist, with the big red lips and all that.
@@trashteamracing8262It is not, most of them are literally as you described IRL
I can't believe Shanks sounds like the Crocodile Hunter lol
Bwabbery
Lol after I heard his voice I came looking for this comment
He sounds like a Brutus
which crocodile
Steve Irwin.😔
Silly 4Kids, you didn't need to re-edit the rice balls, just call them 'jelly-filled donuts".
Who did that wasn't it Pokémon
@@ItsR3ckL3sss yup
Pokemon kicks in my brain now
@@ItsR3ckL3sss same studio
Lmao why were they so terrified of japanese food
0:21 Really, He Used Toys For Shooting him 🤣
actually it makes sense, devil fruit users are weak to sea water so water guns filled with that stuff would immobilise him.
@@icyycold515that not how it works
@@icyycold515they have to be fully in water so like in a pool or the ocean
It’s honestly quite impressive how they’re able to redraw entire scenes of animation and edit existing frames without having it looking edited or out of style.
Censorship aside 4kids artists got some real talent they deserve recognition for it.
Making that one random Kids have light skin though 💀
@@caioaugusto3138 💀
Well, this or blackface
@@Radamor the design would be sus if it wasn't a clown based pirate crew.
Naw, there were some pretty damn bad ones. 💀
“I’ll pummel his head flatter than the shape of the earth!!”
I’m dead 😂
Flat-Earther detected 😂😂😂
Bro zolo sounds so proper
Helmeppo is a flat earther
That was one of the few funny moments in this train wreck of a dub.
1:47 amazing Knife throwing skill luffy got there
Can’t believe they just played it in reverse sound and all 😭
4kids bought this without even watching a frikin single ep like how dumb can they be. 🙄😒
@@Cleo_-ks3kq yeah lol
Reversed XD
bro spawned a knife from his chest
1:25 bro it was more brutal then the original
Honestly, I feel like a spring hammer is something Helmeppo would have as a spoiled rich kid.
Also, can we all agree "I'll pummel him flatter than the shape of the earth," is honestly a hilarious line?
1:01 so shanks is British now
Hell yeeeahh maete ! Hes naaoww gonnha fokh demm uphh
I have only one thing to say to this so called"dubpiece"
I.HATE.IT😐
Yows Mayt
Shanks became shamks
He’b briish now maete
So Zolo's Attack name is Rengoku Cookie😂
Rengoku onigiri: purgatory orge cutter not rice onigiri.
@@danishsyazzry4288 i bet you like to eat rise
Rengoku cookie
Tiky: is for me?
Rengoku jelly filled donut
@@jeremytrinh221 I remember this from Pokemon 😂😂🤦🏻♀️ just call it ricecake damn it🤣
The fact that they censored the marines into simply another branch of the military (the navy) is absolutely priceless and 110% perfect
11/10 would recommend
They changed 14+ to 7+ :)))))))))))
My favorite is changing the color of drinks. Changed a light yellow beer to a darker still beer color. And a bottle of wine to looking like a bottle of liquor.😂
I remember seeing that hammer and thinking how in the world is that kid (kobi) afraid of that hammer is he that lame?
lmao
One piece:alr lets let this charector hold this bomb to carry to buggy for the cannon to fire
4kids:N O. N I G G A S A L L O W E D
Sadsad
its so obvious why they lightened his skin
Blue popo
💀 let’s be honest tho thats the one change that was for the best
They shot the block offa him💀
4 Kids really hates rice balls.
表現規制の恐ろしさがよく分かる
So basically Zoro got stabbed in his ass while in the original he got stabbed in the gut.
Who's Zoro? Are you talking about Zolo?
@@blizerystorm6701 Yes.
zolo*
@@joelsupersss They called him that because of copyright.
Japanese dub is the way.
@@yashyashino3135 Yeah, Zoro is his actual name
Therapist: British shank isn't real, british sinks can't hurt you
British shanks:
More like Australian shanks
You somehow managed to spell it differently all 3 times
More like southern australian.
@@Unknownboi57that is not an Australian accent bruh
The way he just spits out the sword and just reversed the clip tho
Censorship at its finest
My first intro to one piece was the 4kids dub it was a pretty jarring but overall pleasant experience to realise that one piece was even better than I thought.
I don't even understand the point of a lot of these. For example changing the gun into a hammer? I mean it's still essentially a death threat so is the weapon really the issue? Then there's changing the color of the bottles, changing rice cakes into cookies, and don't even get me started on 1:08
It’s mainly to appeal to western audiences so they can relate/connect to anime is some way without everything being japanese
Still seems a bit extreme and not really necessary to me. Plus that only explains the rice cakes, and doesn't really explain everything else
Theh literally censored black like qht 🤣😂
guns arent child friendly and 4 kids is a show for pretty young kids, so they make the edits so that its PG and so that they can understand things
oh yeah and i feel the black guy censorship is very obvious
theyre racist
I think kids are more likely to recognize a rice ball than they are to know the definition to "stipulation"
That's how you learn
I always get my very own captain obvious on these things.
Nothing could have prepared me for Shanks’ voice.
Also Helmeppo’s weird…spring-loaded hammer(?) is the funniest thing I’ve seen in awhile.
"ZOOLLOOO" 💀
Fun fact
In the big mom arc, lollipop sanji makes its first canon Appearance, though is just a mirror clone.
I Don't know if it's just a coincidence or oda deliberately wanted to poke fun at 4kids
Wow
If he indeed did intend to poke fun at 4kids I would very much understand.
I swear even Gintama referenced that censorship
ruclips.net/video/3zLKca1xJFs/видео.htmlsi=Xm5UsqGN6FoZ9aFS
Edit: forgot to mention that Zoro's Japanese VA is in this scene lol
1:08
Congrats, 4Kids, you played yourself
They did it because of the lips because of how black people were Portrayed back in the day in western animation
But that's still bad and you can't ignore it😐 what's wrong with being black it's just a color😒
@@Cleo_-ks3kq bro they did it because it looked racist because back then they potrayed black people in a bad way so don’t blam them
@@gan_rr8118 , if they were going to censor the Black person than just edit in new lips because it takes more time to render in new skin tone done by hand than just making the lips a different color and shape, I’m not even a professional artist like Oda, and I realize how much harder hand drawn animation is than computer animation.
@@Cleo_-ks3kq you understand literally nothing of this.
One piece originally showed the black person to be a racist stereotype or caricature of black people.
(dark skin, big red thin lips? have you ever seen that caricature before?)
4kids tried to correct it by making the skin lighter so it doesn't appease to the stereotype
4kids really had to censor rice
Nahhh The thumbnail tho😭💀
"Zolo!" i died of laughter
It's kinda funny, I'll be honest.
Oh yeah, fun fact: Because of translating issues from Japanese to English, Zoro was called Zolo for a while.
@@SandmanTheSleeperStill called zolo in the manga actually.Why did they censor zoro.
1:07 I don't know if I should be sad or laughing at this 😂😭😂😭😂😭.. you broke me
Dont be sad the original was racist because of stupid sterotypes back then
@@fuhgy109huh?
What whong with the original? 4kids is racist
@@fuhgy109日本を妬むな😂👎
@JAYIQ-ip6bd the original are just stereotypes
4kids knew what they were doing in the thumbnail
"I'll pummel his head flatter than the shape of the Earth."
4Kids is trying to fool us
Idk why, but that split second of Luffy suddenly smiling in the original version at 0:54 is really funny to me 🤣
bro couldn't hold it
Original : ✊🏿
4 kids : ✊🏻
...
4kids be like, no black characters allowed lol
4kids: yes kids be racist kill black
@@33dbz or no black characters that are uncomfortably close to looking like a minstrel show
@@rickywilliams1586
Even usopp’s original design look horrible as just a black teenager
4 KIDS IS RAIST
the cover of the video killed me with hate 💀
shanks took the alcohol to a whole new level with his voice
When you can't show your American audience the existence of rice.
It was probably the same thing like the famous Pokemon meme with Brock and the "jelly donuts". But they actually changed it at least
Right!😂
0:31 - I cant believe they had Zoro say 'stipulation' 🤦♂️
He can't even spell left
The thumbnail 💀
👴
Bro the freaking thumbnail
Dont forget to subscribe, new videos every day 💗
1:48 did they seriously just reverse this clip? the 4kids dub is just stupid on so many levels
1:48 did they seriously give him a happy face while biting the knife? Was his original, menacing expression too intimidating? This anime adaptation is just stupid on so many levels
@@KombatGodI mean its the original one...
@@cl4ka_keyrox nope. The original is the manga. They censored a bunch of stuff when they adapted it to the screen.
@@KombatGod the happy face fits Luffy's character more
@@KombatGod um the happy face is supposed to be Luffy thing since he liked smiling heck that's most of his wanted pictures is him smiling
Lol why did they give Helmeppo this whole contraption when they could have just given him...a hammer.
The thumbnail went real
One Piece is not for kids in the first place.
Yes, but the bosses of some channels think: This is a cartoon series, so, is for kids, lets buy de rights of emission.
When the series is released, they watch it and them reaction is: Censure! Censured everything!
Oh.i didn know about that.
4 kids exist to make family friendly versions of anime I do admit they did a horrible job
@@iliveunderarock8070yes
Shank's voice 💀
He's British 😂
@@Cleo_-ks3kq kinda Ironic since his name is "*Shank*'s😂
Me seeing the thumbnail. "Why did you change the color of his skin?"
Someone should make a documentary about the history and making of this dub. Maybe get interviews of the original 4kids staff who worked on it.
I think a lot of you are misinterpreting the censorship at 1:08
I'm pretty sure they changed the skin tone because the original one resembled racist caricatures of black people popularized in earlier American cartoons. They weren't trying to censor black people themselves, but lightened the skintone to avoid showing what could be interpreted as a big oval lipped, very dark skinned racist caricature. Just look up "Blackface in cartoons" and you can see what I'm talking about.
That being said, I'll admit that I don't know the true intentions of the editors. But as a black woman, this was the first thought that came to me when seeing the changes in the video. I also feel that there are better ways of editing the censorship that could keep the character darker skinned, but it seems that they tried.
Edit: I forgot I made this comment. Genuinely surprised that I'm getting so many replies over a year later. As a bit of extra clarification:
I still believe that the example in the video was an attempt to make something that is racist appear less so. But ultimately, the look and mannerisms of the character itself are so flawed that no matter what they tried, it would be pretty hard to near impossible to remove all of the problems the design poses.
So yeah. I feel like they tried something to make the character less racist than the original, but it wasn't the best solution, coming off as erasure instead.
That's so racist for 4Kids.
Thanks for explaining it was about to make the most controversial joke ever seen
Trust me, rather look like that then some of the white characters because either they have been hit by a hot shovel then left in the microwave for 10 min or they let a literal child draw out these guy's and gal's hair. Also I didn't look at him like some cartoonic stereotypical black man, to me he just fell in the category of everyone else that was just going to get swatted away like every other character in the show that's not a main
But that's an accurate representation of black people, they have big lips
@@dragonballisbest2723 not that big
0:40 OFC Pistol not for kids
Nah, the thumbnail is insane 💀💀
man these *censorhip* moments got me
(he accidentally spelled censorship wrong)
1:15 i cant believe that orange juice have bubble in it
Censor failed it an orange beer
0:47
“Flatter than the shape of the Earth”
0:38*
I'm happy I was introduced to this show because of Netflix with the funimation uncensored dub.
The thumbnail 😂
0:39 “FLATTER THAN THE SHAPE OF THE EARTH” Helmeppo is a flat earther confirm
Can’t imagine all the little kids who thought this was the real one piece
They probably think it's too childish 😔 we not knowingly lost so many fans
Zeff ate his own leg when he was stranded in an island along with sanji
Buggy fr shoved the knife in "Zolo's" augh...
... AND DON'T GET ME STARTED ON NAMI'S MOAN
now THIS is a perfect example of a dark era.
Thanks god its from void century thanks for the goverment to hide it
you mean bad Era? 4kids wasn't a 'dark' Era. Y'know
Who else remembered that scene where luffy has a green plunger thing in his back or shoulder but in the original HE GOT STABBED.
“I’ll pummel his head flatter than the shape of the earth”
That thumbnail was personal
And yes I liked my own comment
0:15 cant stop laughing
Why? It's the least funny thing in the entire video ._.
What have they done to Shanks' voice
look how they massacared my boy
British Shanks
nono he became shunsi boi
BRO THAT THUMBNAIL THO😭
Bro shanks had my crying 💀
Seeing buggy made me realize , the world is bigger than u think as he thinks he is too strong , he doesn't know about Yonkos yet probably or stupidly insanely overestimates himself
Buggy D. Clown is the strongest in the world tho
ofc he knows about the yonkous, he was a pirate on gol d. rogers ship when he was a kid. The only reason he overestimates his power is because he is on the weakest sea (east blue) in the beginning of the series, where all this is taking place.
Ofc he knew about yonko he is shanks sworn brother
He is Shanks' friend
Buggy literally survived after mihawk sliced him.
1:23 racism
Ok and
@@Mef___ u ok with it?
@@Mef___ and??? Bro you deaf
@@Mef___ so if you were black would you like to get your skin white washed just bc your black
Valma
this is too funny man lmao
Zolo?! I watched a little of the 4kods version back in the day but man I don't remember this
1:30 Zowoooooooo!!
*inhales* 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shanks sounds like he smokes 3 packs of cigaretes a day
Ironically, pummeling a child's head flat is likely a more gruesome way to murder than to simply shoot him
He looks like a fool with that weapon don't you think
this is why schools think shoulders are bad bad idea to show off 2:20
Why does 4kids censor every black people
because the drawen guy was a "stereotype" back in the day for black people, if you look in very OLD cartoons, they draw them as this, so they do this so people won't get offended and cry on twitter
Because racial slurs
@@Ok-jh5el Twitter isnt even invented that time
@@myseveredwrjsts was Facebook?
@@PhoenixAce No, this was ten yearsbefore that
Something about changing 'MARINE' to 'NAVY' is just intensely hilarious to me
Like it or not, this is some intense fight between Yonkous.
Ahhh yes they censored a fight from a fighting anime sounds about right
0:20 TF WATER GUNS 🤦
Man they didn't even show all the Sanji smoking shots they turned the cigarette into a damn lollipop. Did my boy dirty 😭
Them rewinging the part that buggy stabs luffy is so funny
Honestly the minstrel sensor was a good idea
“LETS PROTECT THE KIDS”
Meanwhile kids in Xbox parties: “Ni-“
Xbox and Ps4 both aim to decrease it. It’s people like you and republicans who are fine with it, and make excuses to keep it going.
@@Kelper30000 that comments had nothing to do with anything you just said
@@Kelper30000 huh? Dude, I think ur in the wrong comment section.
@@blackriverjack4722 It does. He speaks on how in Xbox parties kids often us the N-word, but Xbox and Ps4 have made it possible to report parties to decrease things like that, but then you have republicans like y’all who find things like this acceptable.
@@acethefiredragon8525 No. I’m in the right one.
Not the white wash💀
taht would be really bad if kids saw that captain buggy was drinking yellow beverage
Ok a few of these are actually pretty clever, like at 1:24 how they edited in a completely different scene to tell the same event, Zoro being stabbed, without showing the blade piercing his body.
It feels like some really talented people jumped through hoops to comply with those weird requests.
And you can laugh all you want at there being censorship in the first place but it's kinda natural, there also are changes/censorship in the original Japanese anime compared to the manga. Out of these very scenes for example, Zoro's wound was much more bloody on the pages, and at 1:54 for whatever reason they gave Luffy a happy expression while in the manga he had an angry, more menacing smile.
And then the first scene is ruined by luffy calling him zolo
@@AnnihilationXable zoro is called zolo in the manga
@@carlwheezer653 hes only called zolo because of 4kids. hes not called zolo in japan
@@gyro999 but I read the manga, and he is called zolo
@@carlwheezer653 did you not read what i just said? he’s called zolo in the viz translation because of 4kids. his name is not zolo in any version of the manga besides the viz translations
To be fair Buggy having a voice of legion when he’s angry is pretty cool.
That's pretty good that you also add dubbed version