Are MCKINSEY, BCG Consultants Controlling IAS (Indian Administrative Service)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 82

  • @tusharsangtani8874
    @tusharsangtani8874 Год назад +98

    I really appreciate your work sir. But I'm deeply sad by current generation where they never recognised anti india campaign and have soft corner for west .

  • @vijaynats
    @vijaynats Год назад +39

    Earlier we had East India Cpmpany, now we have Fortune 500

  • @rahulwahi774
    @rahulwahi774 5 месяцев назад +4

    Hat's off to you for bringing this critical issue up. Sadly, we do not have proper checks and balances in place to safeguard ourselves from such external influence and hidden agendas of the multinational firms. Hope someone powerful watching your video takes cognizance of the same and perhaps takes some action to protect the interests of country going forward.

  • @vaibhavkarv
    @vaibhavkarv 7 месяцев назад +3

    I am so happy that you see the value which the management consulting firms bring.

  • @55555ehnx
    @55555ehnx Год назад +31

    There are both pros n cons.
    They bring expertise, targets and suggest a path to good governance. However, as greatly articulated, we need to strengthen the "system of checks and balances" to stop any conflict of interest...

    • @kshitijkant1950
      @kshitijkant1950 Год назад +1

      "good governance" itself can be a euphemism for many agendas esp Neo liberalism. We need to look beyond packaging into the heart of policies. But as aspirants we also have to limit our scope . Best thing is to be humble and keep learning life long

  • @shabiranshaikh4391
    @shabiranshaikh4391 8 месяцев назад +3

    You have very great values Naman sir . Even though Im not an IAS aspirant , I'm greatly inspired by your work .

  • @yogeshpratapsingh9233
    @yogeshpratapsingh9233 5 месяцев назад +2

    I am amazed by the facts you come up with. People like you are a must so that a common man can understand the functioning of government, formulation of govt policies and so many other things. Kudos to your contribution. Thank you so much.

  • @sociosugam
    @sociosugam 7 месяцев назад +4

    Man you are amazing ... I have never been exposed to insights like this... I wish students whom you are teach should and must become an IAS and IPS. Also, If possible can you start spreading knowledge to general public in a way to awaken them and making them conscious. Because, public need to come out of the cloud of supporting right or Left and start thinking about INDIA/BHARAT.

  • @bhagat_metaphor
    @bhagat_metaphor Год назад +5

    Yes your are correct #Big 4(EY,Deloitte….) is consulting Madhya Pradesh government

  • @shreeanshshukla148
    @shreeanshshukla148 10 месяцев назад +6

    This is what "Rajiv Malhotra". Wants to convey to the masses. #infinityfoundation

  • @bhabisbhitria9370
    @bhabisbhitria9370 Год назад +8

    Sir you are speaking my mind.. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @pocketsfullofdynamite
    @pocketsfullofdynamite Год назад +7

    I believe the lack of knowledge is less importance than lack of interest when it comes to citizens that should ask these questions. If we somehow mechanize that we the people are more important than some political icon, we India can bring more solutions on table right away than depending on these political and corporate to lead us and the use of tax payer's money can then be transparent in the process. The SYSTEM has to be questioned through our IAS and like mined people. 👍

  • @padmaoruganti9179
    @padmaoruganti9179 4 месяца назад +2

    Citizens will never know when and what is happening in your country 😎 big people game's!!

  • @manu18190
    @manu18190 4 месяца назад

    This is true , not just IAS officers but even defence officers . Kudos to Indian government that is threading a thin line .

  • @himanshut114
    @himanshut114 Год назад +6

    You are really good at speaking ........... exceptional i maust say ............ please explain rise of Saudi Arabia with vision 2030

  • @kaustubhraizada
    @kaustubhraizada Год назад +9

    so now i came to know how gst destroyed the small scale industries in india , i always blamed indian corporates but its mickensey all along

  • @rakeshmohanty7243
    @rakeshmohanty7243 5 месяцев назад +3

    I don't see anything wrong with that. McKinsey,BCG hires PhDs to do research and implement projects.
    Better than our bureaucrats who lack expertise in specific areas.

    • @rajatgupta3093
      @rajatgupta3093 5 месяцев назад +4

      Yes but you don't outsource thinking to a foreign company 🤔

    • @rajatgupta3093
      @rajatgupta3093 3 месяца назад

      @@shrishri8898still we are paying for them it means we can afford them 🤔

  • @sandyj342
    @sandyj342 5 месяцев назад +2

    East India Company was just rebranded to Crown Corporation from city of London... it's not controlled by UK government

  • @MayankSharma-co5sw
    @MayankSharma-co5sw Год назад +2

    Thank you sir,,, a mind opener

  • @anantmalik
    @anantmalik Год назад +8

    IASes should be selected through the UPSC examination and promotion. There should not be lateral entry for businessmen as joint secretaries. Otherwise businessmen would control the Indian bureaucracy.
    Edit: I have been a former UPSC aspirant. I know how deadly difficult the UPSC examination is. I would clearly say this: anyone who advocates direct entry of businessmen as joint secretaries is a deshdrohi grr ... ;-/

    • @amitesh3588
      @amitesh3588 Год назад +1

      Lateral entries will enhance the competency of Government

    • @Nik-km2qy
      @Nik-km2qy 10 месяцев назад

      Commie sala

    • @rajpriyadarshi6016
      @rajpriyadarshi6016 6 месяцев назад

      IAS are the real corrupt deshdrohis . They are more interested in stacking crores of money from corruption. No scam has ever taken place without the knowledge of an IAS.

    • @exoticindiaa
      @exoticindiaa 3 месяца назад

      Lateral entry will only increase Baniya nexus, they are already sucking blood of poor

  • @mithunnair8587
    @mithunnair8587 Год назад +2

    Damn, interesting video to think on man

  • @kvapower3925
    @kvapower3925 4 месяца назад +1

    0:48 This is not just influential Indians exploiting the US IVY league admission. There were a case brought about by ASIANS mainly oriental against Harvard and UNC Chappell Hill, NC admission process where Asians are discriminated so causation do not lose spot in these school. They won the case against these schools in highest courts SCOTUS. But they either knowingly or unknowingly did not include legacy admission as also form of discrimination. If one of your parent attended these schools your seat is reserved whether u deserves or not. There is #1 US STEM high school in my backyard. The influx of IT professionals to metro DC area skyrocketed admission by Asians (Chinese Koreans & Indians - not many Japanese in this area and not many Pakistani traditionally got college admission to this school) to 71%. Under mediocracy otherwise with fancy acronym DEI formula limited Asian students admission to 51%. The same SCOTUS refused to hear parents case. So I under the disguise of DEI non deserving students were admitted to this prestigious high school. It had 2 objectives. Cut down influence of Asians using minority card to ensure causation are admitted. Same model as the IVY league schools have adopted to limit Jewish students.

  • @Bharatkiawazz
    @Bharatkiawazz Год назад +8

    Sir,I think you should make vedios in Hindi because your vedios reach the large audience,and most people can get aware such as topic

  • @ayushimishra1912
    @ayushimishra1912 Год назад +3

    Isha ambani is daughter of Mukesh Ambani so she has lot of money so she can easily grab a job in mickinsey because she and her family wants to stay in power and limelight

  • @Hierarchy_Of_Power
    @Hierarchy_Of_Power 10 месяцев назад +2

    I always had a feeling that our IAS are on sale...😂

  • @greytalks2871
    @greytalks2871 11 месяцев назад +3

    isse acha to desh ka, king ya queen ho......
    at least..............democracy ke naam pe kachra to nehi rehega........

  • @Rohit54763
    @Rohit54763 3 месяца назад

    Keep up the good work

  • @zaqs1970
    @zaqs1970 Год назад +3

    after listening to you....only one thing comes to my mind
    "there is no CURE for suspicion"

    • @fazer79
      @fazer79 5 месяцев назад +1

      When it is about national interest we have to. Or else people would loot you like you were looted by british.

    • @zaqs1970
      @zaqs1970 5 месяцев назад

      @@fazer79 gone are the days of British era or mughal era......we are living in 21st century
      today the politician, the crony capitalist are looting the country

  • @harshapatil3497
    @harshapatil3497 4 месяца назад

    1. But what is the solution? 2. Is there any crime in consulting these firms?
    3. Every company looks for their benefits and makes a policy that helps them.
    4. Our policy makers should be careful when they give their proposal. Otherwise they loot.
    In such cases India won't have solutions.

  • @saujanyasuman5121
    @saujanyasuman5121 Год назад +2

    Indeed, its true.

  • @Nick-du9ss
    @Nick-du9ss Год назад +4

    How will management consultant find a place in the era of AI

    • @asishpanda1353
      @asishpanda1353 Год назад +1

      AI wll never replace Consultng obs. There is a big difference between data gathering (done by analysts) and bringing out meaningful infromation from the data(consultant's job). Consultng is not any alogorithim. A lot goes into the thinking process that finally brings out the information sorted from the data. AI has no barin of its own. It works on a specific algorithim but our mind makes decisions which is at its discreetion.

    • @46rise
      @46rise 6 месяцев назад +1

      It is also yo be noted that even though AI will ve available, the eco system for using it shall be available only by a few elite corporates. World is not far from Corporates running the World. Even without AI major Corporations are influencing Democracies and Elections. It will not be Far that the Super Rich class will allign with these corporations for their benefits.Even the technocrats and beuracrats who are highly educated with western values will never have a connect with the Common Citizen and the needs of them. Unless a major overhaul is brought in Education system, Taxation system, And major Social and Civil Laws ,the future of India will look good only on paper but not on ground reality.

  • @heartlifeprolove1027
    @heartlifeprolove1027 4 месяца назад

    GGI charges student fees, have mentors from the consulting firms and other premier institutes including government agencies, and then the students have potential to get the jobs at their mentor or coach institutes.. is this the gist of GGI business model ?

  • @PJPrivacy-ns5fc
    @PJPrivacy-ns5fc 4 месяца назад

    Wanna know Shantanu Deshpande's pov....

  • @mylaidbacklife
    @mylaidbacklife Год назад

    Beccause there are the highest paid companies honestly

  • @sandyj342
    @sandyj342 5 месяцев назад

    And not a single Indian Consulting firm like McK or BCG

  • @sahilkhanna4159
    @sahilkhanna4159 Год назад +1

    Please provide a discounted price Sir.

  • @aniteshmukherjee
    @aniteshmukherjee Год назад +2

    @Naman sir. Does Consulting firms expect their resources to have knowledge of everything?.

    • @namanshrivastava
      @namanshrivastava  Год назад +4

      Absolutely not! At your age - you'd interview for Junior Roles in the firm - you'd be tested on Problem Solving, structured thinking aspects.

    • @aniteshmukherjee
      @aniteshmukherjee Год назад +1

      @@namanshrivastava this is releaving. Thank you so much for the valuable response

  • @ayushimishra1912
    @ayushimishra1912 11 месяцев назад

    When will uncome inequality decrease in india

  • @rohittalwar5602
    @rohittalwar5602 6 месяцев назад

    CANT WE SEE WE DONT WANT ETHICS GOVERNANCE VSLUES LAWS

  • @heartlifeprolove1027
    @heartlifeprolove1027 4 месяца назад

    Naman S runs GGI with other RUclipsr founder Shatakshi S.. and the goal of GGI is to help educate people and get them job at Consulting companies like BCG and Other institute.. so all the lecture about having checks n balances in govt system seems only on paper.. how is u r business model not to be questioned.. when GGI will have former employees of GOI (Neeti Ayog), and all these consulting firms helping in mentoring or coaching GGI students to get jobs at these companies.. now doesn't this seems like u scratch my back n I will scratch u r system..? (1/n)

  • @yahooezone
    @yahooezone Месяц назад

    But BREXIT failed

  • @niranjanishetty8069
    @niranjanishetty8069 Год назад +6

    100% reservation for Indian baman bania in these consultant firms 😂😂😂😂 and they cry over OBC SC St reservation. Policy makers are these baman bania for us 😂😂😂😂

    • @Optimistic_mind441
      @Optimistic_mind441 Год назад +2

      Because they're more talented.

    • @genuinehuman1
      @genuinehuman1 Год назад +4

      ​@@Optimistic_mind441yes very talented in scamming. Every big corporate scam done by these owners only.

    • @Optimistic_mind441
      @Optimistic_mind441 Год назад +2

      @@genuinehuman1 most of Indian scanners are lower caste.

    • @DarkMasterEdits-Mashups
      @DarkMasterEdits-Mashups Год назад +5

      Don't bring cast here
      As a maharastrian and st
      I have to say reservation need review and scammer is scammer

    • @genuinehuman1
      @genuinehuman1 Год назад +1

      @@Optimistic_mind441 nah look up major corporate frauds loan frauds everywhere they are done in the entire nation, they are done by dark dirty looking people born from underarms and hips.

  • @OzoTenzing
    @OzoTenzing 3 месяца назад

    Sir aap toh pura pol khol rahe ho!

  • @topmovieclipstrailers3652
    @topmovieclipstrailers3652 Год назад

    Bhai Hindi mein video banao please 🥲

  • @harshapatil3497
    @harshapatil3497 4 месяца назад +1

    Isha Ambani worked there to get some experience. To understand the work process and people. Absolutely nothing wrong with that. Stop portraying as if they are doing some sort of crime.

  • @marlenegomes6501
    @marlenegomes6501 2 месяца назад

    Your teaching style is strange. You only talk, non stop, giving your opinion, your students just sit the whole time and just listen. There is no active interaction between you and them. They are just your spectators. You could just have your own videos. Strange teaching methid. I don't think they are absorbing and holding on to what you speak.