What does Navalny's death mean for the future of the Russian opposition? | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 май 2024
- Russian police have detained dozens of supporters of the opposition leader Alexei Navalny who died suddenly in a remote penal camp. Navalny's close allies have confirmed his death, but say the authorities are refusing to release his body. With many questions still not resolved, many world leaders, campaigners and Navalny's family are all pointing the finger at Russia's president Vladimir Putin.
00:00 Background
02:40 Juri Rescheto, DW Correspondent
08:45 Keir Giles, Russia analyst, Chatham House
Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#navalny #russia #opposition
You can't kill an idea.
Tell that to Martin Luther king, Malcolm X and others. We dam sute tried.
Putin is certainly trying to kill everyone who has ideas. Russia would be a lot better place if their leaders didn't keep murdering everyone in the country who can think.
@@Color-of-love Their ideas are alive and well today. Freedom is universal. We celebrate Martin Luther King and Malcolm X here in the U.S. There is a holiday dedicated to Dr. Martin Luther King. Do some research before you troll...Russian factory troll.
@@Color-of-loveWell, the people of color misunderstood his idea
@@youngabudhabi5711 Racism will always exist. The point is there are laws created so that everyone is treated more fairly.
Poor people living under these monsters, wake up world
Good morning
Me...all of us up here in Canada...living under Justin Trudeau. Thank-you for posting about us and our situation in Canada under these tyrannical western monsters who believe they are no longer accountable to the electorate because they now "rule over us"
It's the Russians who need to wake up. Only a small fraction of them fully reject imperialism and wish to live in a democratic country.
Warum protestieren dann unsere Bauern, und Mittelstaendler gegen ein Democratur ?
Yeah, so are you, we all are. Wake up.
Rest in peace Sir🙏
He was a convicted Ultra Nationalist, are you sure ?
These children do not want to know any other truth than the "true" western media provides them, I see it in my country 😂😂😂@@ernstwiltmann6
Did you know that Navalny supporter all slavic nation in russia? no other races and no other religion than Orthodoxy? Russia is a multirace and multi religion country. That is why he had only 2-3% support among people and it is why western countrires supported him to creat unrest against russia and Mr.Putin
@@monumentaltravel3745 I do not know.
Julian Assange and Gonzalo Lira where indeed tried by a Kangaroo Court.
what about kara murza?@@ernstwiltmann6
Poor mother
If your are into grieving Parents, why not send a nice note to Gonzalo Lira's or Julian Assange's Father ?
@@ernstwiltmann6No bc does not apply :)
@@ernstwiltmann6 Those are alive
@@ernstwiltmann6You believe in freedom,right?
Did you know that Navalny supporter all slavic nation in russia? no other races and no other religion than Orthodoxy? Russia is a multirace and multi religion country. That is why he had only 2-3% support among people and it is why western countrires supported him to creat unrest against russia and Mr.Putin
RIP Alexei Navalny, you were a true hero and patriot of Russia. I do hope his sacrifice will not be in vein.
Who most likely killed him ? CIA - MI6 - UKRAINE SECRET SERVICE ?
less than 2% support🤣
@@rhetorical1488 У путина? 😂
@@jillmaikls7776 Zelenski 😆
@@rhetorical1488Putin looks like he’s running on 2% battery, did you see him shaking his leg and holding the table in the meeting with Shoigu? He has some illness, let’s call it “sudden death syndrome”. It must be contagious in Russia, Prigozhin had it too 😂
His courage will be remembered. There was someone standing. 🌻
The longer his body remains a secret, the more chance evidence of his murder will never be found. Not like we need evidence.
You do need evidence. Western spin is western spin, next week forgotten. Me i'm a old investigator and look always first at motive. Who benifits ? Certainly not Russia which has a huge embarrassing situation.
Ukraine as we all know operates assination sqads in Russia. Me i'm thinking heart attack. He was built up in the west but actually he had little support in Russia itself.
Is it really needed tho, if they are so hellbent on keeping it secret, it can only mean one thing, and harshest possible reprecussion should be taken
@@cookiecola5852where is Julian Assange?
@@abstraqtphilosophy7357living a free life somewhere on a beach with his laptop. Daily criticism of the west being freely available for all to see….., oh wait hmm no… he’s in prison being treated like a criminal of the highest order and never seen a true day in court
@@abstraqtphilosophy7357 whataboutery strikes again 🙄
Don't give up russia,make Navalny proud and vote in accordance to such a terrible situation.
Let the masses speak and peace to all.
Я испорчу бюллетень
Voting is meaningless.
@@tominnis8353 this voting, very likely is, will be'.
What do they vote for? Putin or Putin. Where is nothing else. Mafia ruling
I am surprised some of them said positive stuff about Navalny in Russia. In case Russian government watches this video.
I would at least wear sunglasses.
i am crryinng ....
He was not afraid of the death, he knew what is going to happen to him if he came back to russia. He sacrificed himself. But does his sacrifice going to make any change?
🤧 😂
RIP Brother of Protest, Democracy, and peace.
He didn’t care about peace if you his comments on Chechnya, Georgia, annexation of Crimea or even his last speech
Democracy? Democracy was inwented in antic Greene and it worked for a Fed years. So what are u talking about.
Germany wants to ban AfD? Yeah, "democracy" LOL
RIP Gonzalo Lira, murdered by UkroISIS and CIA
(same as this nava-Judah, now he is more valuable than alive)
@@user-vf7yj6uk4j Yes, comrade! Have potato for comment! Earn your living producing агитпроп! You will be hero to Russia like Maxim Gorky!
Убили хорошего человека. В России это стало нормой, очень страшно.
So now that Russian Reptile is even ordering people laying flowers at memorials to be arrested. A question for the average Russian. Do you have any rights left, any at all?
350k casualties have not produced the slightest response of discontent in Russian society.. what can just another loss amount to?
gonzalo lira also thought he had rights but he was wrong thanks to zelensky 😔
Free Julian Assange. Where is his rights?
@@onlymelodic109 Over 500 thousand and counting… Russia is a Gulag. Those who protested were tortured, imprisoned or killed. How do you suggest anyone do anything without weapons? Oh, Putin’s goons have plenty of weapons.
More than you do …
Navalny: a Martyr for Russias democracy. A humanitarian
How long Oh Lord before the Wicked are punished 😞😞
Maybe because there is no god or allah or budda etc the true god is Mother nature and she has a way of dealing with things in her own special way
The Evil is the west and their Lakais like Navalny and Selenski
I wish he never went back. He could fight from outside until putin is done and return and run for president.
Man even Jesus knew that wasn't an option for him...❤
He refused to stay in Germany unfortunately. He liked his country and his people.
Ему его кураторы не давали такого сценария.
@@user-cv6ei8te9rзакройся, кремлеботина
This still feels surreal. Navalny was the top of the top opposition force. It must have severe repercussion, otherwise, it sets a very dangerous precedent. You don't kill your political opponent.
There will be no repercussions.
What was the repercussion when CIA conducted regime change assasinations across the world vis a vis Patrice Lumumber and many more
You must not have been following news, Putin's opponents have the habit of getting drunk and leaning out of 20th story windows for years!
Not to mention doing the polonium tidepod challenge.
It's Russia.
It's cultural.
Putin has both jailed and killed political opponents before with zero repercussions.
You meanvlike JFK ?
We know what this is. Deepest condolences to his loved ones, we lost a voice for freedom and democracy, but gained immortal inspiration 🙏🏽!!
It was a warning to Russian opposition: behave and don’t get your hopes up for the elections
@@monumentaltravel3745 You have a choice that doesn't matter
What “opposition” is that? The murdered Opposition or the imprisoned Opposition? Elections in RF - what an oxymoron!
I guess Putin doesn't meet your "high standards" of Justin Trudeau, Olaf Scholz, and Joe Biden as a great leader??
@@Eggardy 🤡🤡🤡🤡👹👹👹👹☢☢☢☢
Ну и вас то лидеры . Цирк шапито а не главы государств. Ваши лидеры ,пощечина мировому сообществу.
Heartbreaking 😭
What this means is that Putin is becoming increasingly concerned with the prospect of the finish of his career.
Он не боялся и мы не будем. Прости нас Алексей! Покойся с миром
Спасибо, что вспомнили Политковскую😭🙏
Ich kann mich auch noch an Sacco und Vancetti erinnern
Amen. I have paid attenfion. Аминь. Я заплатил аттенфион.
und an soboka pavlov@@ernstwiltmann6
And Vlasov... and Judah....
ind ich mich an trotzki@@ernstwiltmann6
I know that Alexei died for what he believed in, and he stated that in his last video, and he also said that the Russian people should NOT give up, but keep on standing up for freedom and peace, so let's hope that the Russian people stand firm in their beliefs of peace and freedom and keep going toward that goal. DON'T GIVE UP RUSSIA.
What did he believe in? CIA money?
Западу? Не отдадим
Note that the bots have no answer to this other than spamming with lots of whatabouts and deflections.
Putin is a freight of Navaly, dead body to???
Are you a Bot if you also wanted Julian Assange freed, and remind our audience of what happened to Gonzalo Lira ?
@@ernstwiltmann6
We rest our case 👆🏻
Yes there are out in full force everywhere!
@@ernstwiltmann6👈😂😂😂
Of course they're hiding the body, hard to hide bullet holes. RIP Alexey 🙏
Did you know that Navalny supporter all slavic nation in russia? no other races and no other religion than Orthodoxy? Russia is a multirace and multi religion country. That is why he had only 2-3% support among people and it is why western countrires supported him to creat unrest against russia and Mr.Putin
You saw bullet holes with your own eyers?
@@user-es1xe6jh6u Russian troll factory working overtime I see.
It's a poison. The bullets aren't in his body. I think.
@@lopppqw you allready did the poison- test and find poison??
A champion of his people has been laid low by the powers he sought to expose. I carve another name of great men into the rock of life, as tears stream down my face, my rage at the inhumanity of man burns white hot in my heart with every hammer strike. R.I.P Alexei Navalny, thankyou for the work you did, thankyou for the example you set, and thankyou for helping me to understand just how blessed I am to live in a nation where the rights you fought and died for are taken for granted. You sir, will be missed.
Да ладно, его соратники активно поддерживают вооружённые силы Украины. Были бы они за Россию, то вообще бы не поддерживали бы войну
Навальный стал игрушкой Запада в игре против России.
@@user-kd1bc1ozg my geek foo is weak, I can't translate your response, apologies
@@SeamusDunmaggotindon't answer them, and moreover don't make excuses. This is, in russian named, kremlin trolls. Whole botfarms working for goverment, controlled by FSB (FBI)
@@SeamusDunmaggotindon't answer them, this is kremlin trolls. Botfarms, working for FSB (FBI)
I never knew Navalny, but have the utmost *respect* for him, his courage, bravery, selflessness, and love for his people. He paid the ultimate price for freedom. May he be rewarded in the *after-life* for his sacrifice. 🕊
😔❤💙Navalny rest in peace.😔💐
He should have never come back to Russia!
There are millions of people who support Alexey. If poo-tin thinks he’s scared people- he’s wrong. Dictators are always cowards and no one is afraid of cowards
My heart is broken for this courageous man whose love for Russia shone like a beacon of democracy. Condolences to his family and friends, and those of Alexander Litvinenko, Sergei Magnitsky, Stanislav Markelov, Anastasia Baburova, Natalia Estemirova, Anna Politkovskaya, Yuri Shchekochikhin, Boris Berezovsky, Boris Nemtsov, Mikhail Lesin and countless others who have been murdered, supressed, detained and tortured by Putin.
Russia....don't give up hope.
Navalny was so defiant, spirited, and brave, that the loss of such a legend doesn't really hit me until now when I see him smiling behind the glass and in those penal colony videos, especially his last one. The Russian opposition movement suffers from in-fighting, and now a new figurehead will have to be chosen to fill some pretty big shoes. Navalny was not the ideal opposition leader for everybody, but he had some traits that will be hard to replace, especially enduring as much as he did. If there is someone out there who can rise up to the challenge, surely "Дед Мороз" left his best present for last: inspiration.
I'm scared that Russia will become another Belarus. I remember all the protests there 4 years ago, how defiant and determined the people were. And now, complacency, fear, no more resistance. Is this Russia's future?
Such an intelligent handsome guy. How Russian people did not see that it is better leader for their country. So sorry about his death
He was a convicted Ultra Nationalist.
You're right. If Navalny were president, Russian troops would have been in Kyiv long ago.
Research why the Amnesty international disowned him
Мы то простые люди давно увидели, что он хороший человек, почему вы так говорите?
@@user-zu8dv2et8b
Ага такой хороший что ещё до того как он стал активистом он занимался махинациями
Good, clear interview! Thank you.
Navalny was an honest man who deeply cared for Russia and its people. He had extraordinary courage. His death will become a tipping point for rebellion in Russia. Putin has pushed things too far now.
Putin is the man who puts Russia first that's why the west are crying😅😅
Show me how he cared deeply. He was attempting a CIA-backed maidan-style revolution in Russia, funded and supported by the MI6 and CIA. Gonzalo Lira...Julian Assange, what about them?
@@krishnaisaga4817by putting his citizens first, you mean locking them up for speech
Navalny was a convicted Ultra Nationalist.
@@krishnaisaga4817 Move there then!
Where is Assange? 😢
It's so shocking how one minute he was taking his normal unsupervised walk in the Siberian Arctic weather and the next he was dead... such a tragic twist of fate 😮....
And you guys still want to trust Putin with BRICS!
Rest in power Mr. Navalny, you taught us how to protest peacefully. Thank you for everything you did. -on behalf of those who can’t speak out!
Someone said that Putin is going to fall on his own sword. I pray for the people that they will have a true Independence Day!!! In Russia.
Where is Tucker now?
Probably writing a script to explain why Navalry was rightfully imprisoned.
Carlson is putins employee
@@nataliaakulenko2865 Сarlson is Putins employee, Navalny was Bidens employee, so everything is in harmony
Living a luxurious life spending money of russian people
Pavel Antov and Vladimir Budanov died in India under mysterious circumstances.
Tucker said that Putin is a great leader. Just a reminder.
And you should read up on who Navalny really was, rather than listen to western mainstream media.
@@mercurial382 nah. We all know Putin is an evil dictator.
@@mercurial382 Do you want me to watch Russian state media to get the truth when they themselves murdered him?
Guys, don't mind the trolls. They are still defending Putin, believe it or not.
Navalny career started as Skinhead. Anti immigrant.
It brings tears😢 to my eyes as I am watching Navalny painting a Heart
on the glas in the prison.Navalny will live forever now !
His name will be remembered forever for Honesty, Fearless Courage, Fighting for free Speech, Love & Compassion🙏🌹🕊️🌍🕊️🌏🕊️🌎🕊️
Navalny loved the russian People that much that he flew back and died for Freedom and Peace in Russia🙏🌹🕊️🌹🙏😪❤
In Russia the government think for you. If you think differently, you are in big trouble.
Really?
Haha! Yeah, CIA should think for you like in USA and occupied EU.
Why oh why Russians wont follow CIA agents like navalny???
Dit was nog eens iemand,die doorzetting had en geloofde in verandering. Jammer dat er zoveel russen schrik hadden en niet durfden wat hij deed.
Echt jammer,en nu al de zoveelste,en allemaal op mystrieuse manieren.
😢😢😢
Russians that believe as Navalny does, know that millions of Americans here grieve with you and are awed by your courage and noble aspirations. Bless Alexei Navalny, his widow & daughter, their extended family and millions of friends & admirers around the globe. Please copy and spread the word. And f V.P., D.J.T. & T.C., all dirt with bile compared to Navalny.
Thanks a lot for support
Вы можете убить человека, но никогда не сможете уничтожить дух народа.
Народ собственно никогда и не считал Навального своим лидером. Народ не ошибается.
meanwhile on the other side of the pond; Republican still support Putin!
How is it possible that some western political parties still support the Russian regime?
You mean Trump?
The Republicans..
"Silencing"
💔❤️ terrible heartbreaking loss for us but Navalny’s legacy is alive, Russia will be free from the monsters that killed him.
Alexey Navalny was destined to be the next leader of Russia and Putin should've stepped down and let him take their nation forward.
Вы за нас будете решать кому быть президентом России?
He wasn’t exactly an angel
@@user-tn7pr3cq7z
За тебя уже решиши 3.14 дорашка
@@a.r.stellmacher8709 He risked his life coming back to Russia to lead the opposition after getting poisoned. He wanted to guide Russia into democracy.
Nah, the powers that be would never allow it….
And Assange, his live matter too.
🤡🤡🤡🤡👹👹👹👹☢☢☢☢
How can you say that about someone with no moral character, he repeatedly refused to release damaging classified documents that would hurt his party, hes literally just an anti dnc shill…
Assange is wanted in Sweden for alleged ra pe and other se xu al crimes.
They fear Navalny even after death. They don't let people say goodbye, lay flowers, arrest the priest who wanted to hold a memorial service. Не забудем, не простим!
не забудем
Like laying flowers for AdoIf or for bin Laden in NY
Unbelievable
Look at all of that Russian democracy and freedom of speech.
One may conclude that Assange is of better health than was Navalny.
it’s so hard to believe in this.. he, such a brave and bright man, because he supported us, although he himself was in terrible, inhuman conditions, and now he was killed, there was almost no strength to hope, we are even afraid to take flowers...
This is the time to invoke the eye for an eye rule.
I guess Putin doesn't meet your "high standards" of Justin Trudeau and Joe Biden as a great leader??
@@ernstwiltmann6 I don't know anything about Trudeau, and Biden is passable.
But yes, comparing tyrants like Tre45on and Putin to just meh Biden they don't even come close. It's like comparing a bowl of sh t to a stale bagel. I will take the bagel every time. So would anybody with any sense.
@@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 I got it, you are the Eagle that sores about the flogging Turkeys (old Roman Proverb).
or you remind my about the 50's song from Sam Cook : "Wonderful World",
Lyrics go like :
I do not know about History ......
Please enlighten me which kind you are !
@@ernstwiltmann6 Speaking of eye for and eye. Dr King. And many others.
@@ernstwiltmann6 oh so now it's about me is it? 😂😂😂
I guess when you're eating that bowl of sh t the stale bagel looks like a patriotic eagle soaring thru the skies of America
You can blow out a candle
But you can't blow out a fire
Once the flames begin to catch
The wind will blow it higher
🔥🔥🔥
Few weeks ago it was a report that Putin travelled 1200 km to an unimportant factory in the vecinity of Navalny's detention camp. It stinks from afar..
Он не умер!!!! Его убили!!!!!!
I'm guessing you were there and saw it for yourself?
Rest in power and peace Alexi. Navalny will be remembered in the ranks of Nelson Mandella strong, intelligent, powerful, good, kind, pro-democracy. It's no wonder, Putin hated him, because more people loved Navalny.
Как Горбачёва?
Why does the hardly benign Mandela always somehow CREEP into the conversation. He was an unrepentant communist who along with his co-conspirators were mercifully arrested while plotting to blow cities in South Africa to kingdom come and to usurp power by whatever violent means they had at their disposal. World's apart from Navalny, I would say.
@@user-nt6rq2rm6oGorbachev - great LEADER whose reforms got trampled in the dust by the depraved ruling elite that followed.
My heart goes out to Mr. Navalny's family especially the Mother. With decency and for the sake of your People return his Body at least to his Mother. None of my business but this brings back memories of our own history. Dr. Jose Rizal's firing squad in 1892 and Ninoy Aquino assassination in front of millions of people watching the television while getting out of the plane upon returning to the country from being an exile. Both Mothers mourned the assassination of their sons but that didn't end it from there. My own kid was the first group to be sent to the borders during the start of your war. We have no business to be there but for the sake of Peace and alliance there he was. I was grieving the very first day the war begun in Ukraine and I didn't even lose my kid. Praying for the people of Russia and Ukraine. Please don't forget the Power of the People. We proved it 2x in the People Power.
What can you say about why his son is now president of that country?
What happened to Assange? We in the west are such criminal Hypocrites .
Those who disclose state secrets face imprisonment (on every nation), not remotely similar from cases of political persecution where individuals are targeted and even murdered simply for being opposition party or for criticizing the govt
"we"
That is your false opinion that Assange disclosed state secrets. The whole world knows there is no evidence against him ! He is being persecuted for being a journalist exposing American war crimes.Follow the facts@@tluangasailo3663
Shame
This is what Trump would do to his compation if he gets a chance.
It's look like Navalny is more popular in West than in his own country.
Hey, anyone remember Edward Snowden or Julian Asange? 😂
Those who disclose state secrets/classified information face imprisonment (on every nation), it's not remotely similar from cases of political persecution where individuals are targeted and even murdered simply for being opposition party or for criticizing the govt
@@tluangasailo3663 so, spying on American citizens is not dystopian, totally normal, totally democratic, totally not 1984
Well, internally changing Russia through politics isnt gonna work huh? Whats next Europe asks.
Too bad this guy wont get justice in this lifetime
He has said his piece in this life. St. Peter will discuss Alexi’s next mission at the gates….😊
wonder if the Tucker Carlson /Putin interview had any influence over the timing of this incident ?
🙏🙏🙏🙏😢😢😢😢
Doctors signed a petition saying he wasn’t receiving adequate medical care and was being slowly poisoned
Gestapo
Avdiivka falls into Russian hands... Navalny is dead... Free thinking world is under a lot of strain by strongmen... 😢
Монстры не во вне, они и внутри вас 😊
Why Fight in Ukraine when Russia coud Fight Putin.wake up Russia
Putin saw Saudi Arabia getting away with doing this sort of thing and said why not
Тысячу бабушке дали и печеньки Нуланд. И не про такое наговорит!
😭😭😭😭😭😭
Do you cover Gonzalo Lira to! Who died in Ukrain prison ! He was an Amerikan journalist ! And Julian Assange in prison in England ! But then you are silence !
Apparently you trolls are very loud.
Those who disclose state secrets /classified info face imprisonment (on every nation), it's not remotely similar from cases of political persecution where individuals are targeted and even murdered simply for being opposition party or for criticizing the govt..
Now extremely worrying about Volodya Kara-Murza
straight out of 1984
Edward Snowden says hello
That's all he can say, he lives in Russia.
@@16252 Edward Snowden is freedom of speech advocate who runs away from democratic America seeking asylum from communist Russia 🤣
He was just taking his usual walk in the frozen Siberian winter. 🤥
I’m crying fourth day
What happened to Julian Asange?
He committed crimes.
He is wanted in Sweden for alleged ra pe and other se xu al crimes.
You can go out and protest on his behalf, if you live in the West.
Media trying to wash out the fact that avdiivka has fallen😂😂
Should opportunistic govts stop buying oil from rogue regimes ?
Never trust a comrade
Тела не отдадут
Ты хочешь чтобы его на мощи растащили сатанисты?
@@user-tn7pr3cq7z не тыкайте
Oni prosto razmnozhili Naval'nykh.
My nikogda ne sdadimsya.
They just multiplied the Navalnys
We will never give up.
He was as influential as Solzhenitsyn. RIP sir.
Evil still reigns but
Christ has overcome the darkness
Christ is anti woke anti Queen.....like Mr putin 😊
Heartfelt condolences to a brave and courageous Aleksei Navalny. It's a message to America - wake up and vote - vote against Trump and the extremist, pro Putin Republican Party.
Why do these individuals seem to be surprised this man was killed and the Russian government being silent? This is business as usual for them. We’ve know this for ages. This isn’t anything new.
Свободу Алексею Анальному!
😢 sad, rest in peace Navalny.....you were public enemy number 1. You would have made an impact that will forever be remembered.
The people of Russia deserves to be free. Real democracy and freedom of speech and expression.
Now its becoming more and more like North Korea every day.
Не из ваших рук, а то мы с голоду умрём
@@user-nt6rq2rm6o они не этого не понимают, так не знают историю )))