I do love this idea. I have a need for this. I am building a shed for my layout. This could save me time and money. Please let me know more in the future.
Hi James, I really think you should be on the blower (or should that be the "sucker"? No pun intended!) to Peco / Hornby straight away with this before they pinch your design! As for an improvement, if it could clean up the shoulder of the ballast edge at the same time, leaving nice, clean straight lines it would be perfect - possibly with some sort of "Fence" at each side of the attachment which directed the suction to the edges? Imagine just having to dump the ballast onto the track without having to take particular care to spread it evenly, give it a quick once over with your tool, and all done. I think you're on to a winner here.
Thank you Paul. I have designed a version with a built it hopper/shoulder former, which I'm sure would work very well indeed. The set-up shown in the video works really well without any extra 'clutter' and is great for other clean-up jobs too. My thoughts are that this ought to be available with two 'heads', one as you describe and the one shown in the video.
Hi James. I rather like this idea and also the shoulder former you mentioned in your reply to Paul James. I have a few questions: have your ideas progressed at all? You mentioned that it also worked on N gauge track; exactly the same tool? Although yet to start ballasting, I have bought a mini handheld vacuum cleaner for ballast and static grass. I don't know if all mini handheld vacuum cleaners are a standard size, but could you design/build an adaptor for the minis? Look forward to hearing from you.
Echoing the thoughts and comments of many, what brilliant, simple idea. I think the big benefit you have is looking at the various tasks with a new set of eyes and not being fixated on the ‘we’ve always done it like that’ approach. Well done and thank for for ALL your great videos.
Brilliant and practical solution. This is similar to how I ballasted my recent layout, almost discovered using controlled vacuum by accident (ie vacuum collector with spacer), but the hardware was not as elegant as your solution and required precise hand control as was too heavy. If you ever sell or produce the 3D prints on shape ways or other please let us know.
I think you have come up with a great product which i would like to buy one complete as i have only just got into this hobby and i have not got a layout as yet but i am collecting ideas to make my task much easier thank you.
Hi James, I am absolutely delighted with my ballast tool. I was really worried about doing the ballasting on what is my first layout, as it makes such a difference when it is done well. Your tools make it so easy. Thank you again.
What a brilliant invention, can i place my order for one now please James. may i say, just like all your videos well explained and presented really informative and a pleasure to watch.your daughter will be very proud of her dad, and thank you James for bringing your fresh approach to modelling and your ideas to us all.
Thank you Nigel, I hadn't expected such positivity so quickly in the comments. It's making me think I ought to take this further. I'm pleased you've been enjoying my videos, such feedback is rare in my day job - the kindness shown through the comments is really appreciated. My best wishes, James
I don't think you need to think about taking your invention further i would be applying for a patent on it now, what with your other abilities regarding model buildings etc which could be made in kit form in no time you be giving up your day job where it sounds like your talents are not appreciated, to be very much appreciated by all us modellers
It's a superb idea, and product. I'm sure it'd sell, depending on price, I'd buy one. If required a version for collecting excess scenics, flock, static grass, would be most saleable.
Get a patent or something to protect your idea. This is so brilliant, such a time-saver and more importantly easy to use everyone will want one. I know i'd have one tomorrow. I've got a boatload od ballasting to do and this wouks same me hours and hours. Well done.
HI Alan, I'm pleased you enjoyed this. The design is registered, and I'm thinking about how to get this out-there. I thought it was a good idea and I'm pleased others can see the benefit as well. Thanks for watching, James
Nothing new to say here but just providing you with more feedback. I too think you are on to a winner. Seems to do what's required with efficiency and minimal complexity. What's not to like. Good luck.
Hi Earl, I have. 😀 It’s available from www.makeitminiature.co.uk Or in the USA from mpeterll who can be found on RUclips. Also from Model Railway Techniques in Australia.
From what i have seen, this is one of the best idea's in model rail ballasting i have come accross. Please carry on with this. I live in Holland and i am a member of a model rail club and most of my fellow club members hate ballasting. I think with this idea you will bring even more enjoyment to the hobby
I agree with the comments of others - that is such a great tool! So much easier than laying ballast by hand or with the spreader systems. Well done and more power to your elbow!
The think you are on to something that would be great, have seen this idea many a times but getting to see it work so great makes it a real game changer th o me....thanks for sharing....Jack and hope tut o see more on it in RH he future 👍👍👍👍👍
Brilliant! Especially because it's such a simple concept. (I want one, NOW!) You must make sure your idea is protected. You could, perhaps sell the software/program, which would give you some sort of return, without consuming your time. I, too, have a daughter with a lively, creative mind - she has been a constant delight to me, as I'm sure your daughter is to you. Your output on youtube is the most enjoyable material to emanate from my PC monitor. Thank you. Mike.
The first thing I would do is to take out a patent on your device which I think is brilliant, When I saw the demonstration I could not believe my eyes when you sucked up the ballast material and yet the ballast between the rails stayed in place. You are on a winner. I would love to hear more. Cheers Greg
Thank you Greg - it really does seem to work like magic. I'm very pleased with it. :) I will post an update when I've figured out how to share the idea efficiently. Best wishes, James
Brilliant - I would buy one straight away - You really need to set up production . This would sell easily . There is certainly a market there. Well done .
So we have the ‘Bexhill Ballast Blaster’ !.......don’t move your operation to Taiwan though just yet. Seriously, this has to be a very popular item for railway modeller’s wish lists! Well done James, ‘simple is best’!
First of all I want to say "Great idea". To add to this I must say that I personally find ballasting therapeutic. It also marks an end to the construction of a section of the layout and the beginning of the 'tarting up' and the final stages of the section. Having said that, I love gadgets and would probably buy one if you intended on selling them. This brings me to the next point. I do 3d printing and with the sim to sell and unless you can make lots of an object in a short space of time it is not viable to sell and make money from it unless that is the product is so unique and people really want to buy it irrespective of cost. So yes, brilliant idea, very simple and like mist simple things not much to go wrong. If you do intend selling them let me know and I will buy one. Regards Geoff.
Thank you Geoff. I think that 3d printing these to sell myself will not be possible. I work full-time and just don't have the spare time available. I am considering looking into crowd-funding to see if there's a way to make these cheaply available to all. I'll keep you posted.
@@BexhillWest I know the feeling too well. I myself am working full time and when I get home I can often be up to the small hours 3d printing and generating stock for when the exhibitions and shows resume so I can sell the things I have made. At some point I need more than 3 hours sleep a night.
Wow That is truly amazing I found this article/ video via a share from Facebook southern railway modelling group I’d be really interested to hear how this goes and if there’s a chance one day to be able to use this myself I’ve also subscribed to your RUclips channel
Hi James - This seems a great idea and for someone who has the ballasting to do on my layout it looks a lot easier than the bang the tracks with a spoon method....................Cheers Kev
Hi James, I will be ballasting a decent sized layout in about February 2022 & I would certainly buy this as a product to help the ballasting process. You should market it yourself or sell the design to a manufacturer as soon as possible! I hope you make some money out of your work. Well done.
Hi James. I’m only just catching up with a lot of your videos but this idea is genius, just like so much of the other work you do. I look forward to watching each and every video you put up as the content is always fascinating and full of interesting ideas and perspective. I have to congratulate you on the extensive research you put in to every element of your modelling and the results speak for themselves...simply outstanding.
I am watching this quite a while after you filmed it, but if you haven’t patented that design already you need to hurry up. There is a very large market for something such as this. Well done again!
Bugger! I invented (utilised) a cyclone (using a pop bottle) for my vac to collect ballast, years ago! I recently (a few months ago) had a go at 3D printing a tee tube vac end too! It's not the first time someone has brought to market a product that I had thought of years ago! Richard of DCC concepts will attest to being a better businessman than me! lol
Hi James! Brilliant video and having read the other comments, I really can’t add anything else! You’re design definitely solves the problem. Ballasting is certainly a job I put off and the idea would help greatly with getting over this task! Thanks again, Keith
Thank you Keith. With the prospect of so much ballast to lay, and not much enthusiasm for the task, it was a case of necessity being the mother of invention. :)
Morning James, what a brilliant idea, and I've been reading some of your other comments and some people have suggested shoulder and other mods , I must say I like the simplicity of the original design, it looks versatile. Could be used for loads of clean up on the railway. The main thing for me would be cost! If you're only just starting out then maybe you could invest in something like this, if like me your layout is mainly done and only a bit of alterations to do you would need to think about it. It would all come down to cost. Your very lucky to be able to print your own bits, and what a great inventive mind you have. Very well done. Looking forward to seeing the results on your layout take care. Eddy xx
Thank you Eddy for your kind comments. I've considered every variation of this with all sorts of additional extras, but in all honesty I think the version in the video is the most useful. It seems to do it all it needs to with no fuss. :) All the best, James
I think you have done probably the best thing by getting it seen on RUclips to get the general feeling of modellers. Its a job many peopke hate and put off doing particularly in N gauge, ballast hoppers became and still are very popular, but yours easier and quicker as you demonstrated. If you have your own 3D printer produce some kits and let the big boys in railway modelling promote them. Good luck with your project James.
Very interesting James, the ballasting of my track is a task I’m not sure I’m looking forward too. I have one of those track ballaster box things that sit on the track but your hoover attachment looks like something that could save a lot of time and by the looks of it makes a really neat job. I’d certainly be interested in one if you start producing them, cheers John
Hi James. You can put washable PVA on a length of greaseproof paper. Put the track down on top and sprinkle the ballast. Leave to dry overnight. Turn the track upside down and the loose ballast will fall off.
Looks like a good idea, a couple of things come to mind:- 1. can you attach to any vacuum cleaner with a hose or will more powerful cleaners suck out the contents of the collection hopper and weaker ones not have enough power ? If it will work with multiple different cleaners then all you need is some sort of universal adapter 2. I think I saw a couple of rail width grooves in the nozzle so do you need different sizes for different gauges ? 3. Will this work with lighter materials such as flock ? If so this could be a really useful tool for anyone working in any type of scenery not just model railways 4. Maybe a couple of extra tools for getting into tight locations might be useful ? You might want to design to use some sort of easily obtainable standard size container as the collector
Thanks David, you always leave a positive comment! 1. This works on a standard domestic vacuum cleaner. I've designed it to connect to my Numatic Henry, but I'm sure it would fit most. An adaptor ring would enable it to fit just about any vacuum I'm sure. 2. I designed this for OO, but tested it on N gauge too and it worked just as well which was a surprise! 3. My thoughts exactly, I think it would be perfect for lifting static grass. However to do which I think a filter inside the collector head might need to be added as the lightweight fibres would not drop from the cyclone separator. 4. I've already designed a couple...watch this space. :) Finally, the collection head will fit a wide range of containers as is. Thanks for the feedback, it's much appreciated! James
Hi, just seen this for the first time. It seems very good for the gutty task of ballasting. Has the project moved forward? How is the vacuum powered? Well done for thinking it up.
Hi James I think this is great idea in our club we usually have a ballasting night that way a boring job is dealt with with loads of spoon tapping an brush work to get it done. My only question is when are you going into production with this thing, I think you have a winner. Regards Alan Massie
Excellent idea James, how about elongating the suction sole over the total width of the track including the shoulder? The outer flow of the suction should have the slightest impact as your flow diagram showed. Haven’t come to laying track yet, but when I do, I will certainly apply ballast with your method. Also, your Mary Poppins reference is greatly appreciated, as is your short story about your daughter. Truly saw her in the hardware store with those doubtful eyes kids can share, your narration on the surprise of the shared success following all the more heartfelt. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you so much for an inspiring video, well done. Track ballasting for me personally is a big problem for me, I just can't seem to get it right, looking like the real thing, I've watched numerous videos ask advice at Model Railway Exhibitions ! Your idea I feel is light at the end of the tunnel, a winner. I look forward to purchasing one. All success to you.
That is pretty cool but you can achieve the same results just as quick with a ballast spreader and a spoon/brush handle. The ballast spreader on the same piece of track takes about 10-15 seconds to put down, then you just rush a brush through the center track, then take the brush (or a spoon) and gently tap the rails. This will remove the ballast pieces from the sleepers. You will still get ballast pieces back on the sleepers once you spray the track with water, then water-pva mix. Might be why the idea was abandoned?
¡Hola buenas tardes James! Having spent the best part of half an hour practicing my very first ballast laying (on a small diorama test piece) my jaw dropped as I watched the first video clip you showed. I say this as, the half hour I spent ballasting was 90% vacuuming-up and, relaying various trial amounts of ballast material. Ignoring the issue of the shoulders being tidy, the fact that your system can actually remove just the excess top-of-the-sleeper ballast, has to be a winner. Should you find a way to provide this equipment commercially, I would definitely be adding my name to the preorder list! Brilliant James and, so well demonstrated. Un saludo. Gary
Thank you Gary. I've tried this now in various configurations, and believe me, this simple first-effort is by far the best. Modifications to produce a tidy ballast shoulder have worked well, but hinder the wider use of the tool as a vacuum. If I could only find a way to get the idea out to the masses I'm sure it would be a winner. It needs to be dirt cheap though, and therein lies the problem. It may be that the best solution is simply to make the files available for 3d printing at home. I tried Shapeways and it was way too expensive. Thanks for the support though, it's much appreciated. :)
Wow just come across this and as I have in excess of 200 ft of track to ballast I think it is brilliant. I would definitely be in the market for such a handy device. Have you thought about starting your own cottage industry, certainly you could put me down for one.
Hi Len, I'm trying to get this thing off the ground and hope to have some news soon. I'm just too busy. I need another couple of days in the week to catch-up. :)
Hi James. I'm convinced. It does a fantastic job. However the success or failure of this as a commercial product is the retail price. Firstly I would copyright it. Secondly I would approach a manufacturer say WWS to make it under licence and pay you a %. The problem I see is a ballast machine like static grass applicators is that they are used once as the layout is set up then they have a tendency to gather dust on the shelf. So overall they work out to be rather expensive. Its personally why i'm still debating whether to buy an applicator. Yet. But its definitely worth further exploration.
I couldn't agree more Gordon. I think a product like this should be available very cheaply, sub £10, after all it's just two bits of plastic and a pipe!. So far I'm not having much luck in finding a suitable manufacturer. :(
Hi James...just had another thought on using any `hoover' of any power/suction...Just looked at my hoover and there is a small slide switch on the pipe extension which you slide open/shut to increase/decrease the suction. You could incorporate a similar switch on the pipe section just prior to the flexible pipe connection. Then possibly any power hoover would work by adjusting sliding open/closing the slide switch. (it certainly works on my hoover). 2. You could also put a slide-on mini brush at the tip to give a final dust off as the hoover is dragged along the track. 3. I like the size of the ballast collector as well.. Maybe a similar size ballast dispenser could be attached through a splayed tip (as your collector). Hope you can follow my gobbledegook James. Good luck with this project
Hello James, I have just watched the August video of your ballasting tool and I think it is a great idea. I hope that you have developed it further and if you have could you please let me know.Many thanks Lloyd Togneri.
Hello James, I’ve just stumbled across your site and I am now a subscriber. If you were to make this tool available I would certainly purchase one. The video content is brill., and I look forward to more. Have a safe and Merry Christmas
Thank you Chas, I'm so pleased you are enjoying the content and thank you for your subscription. Hopefully, I'll have some positive news about this in the new year. Thanks for watching, James
Brilliant concept and execution James. You could add a `reverse' snow plough guide (perhaps a snap on/slip fit to the funnel to make the shoulder clean up all in one pass. Find a bulk builder and sell this `GEM'. Thankyou
Absolutely superb gizmo, when are you going into production...I would have thought a kit of parts + a small set of instructions would be a winner. [Chris Marshall 32a model club, Catfield]
James you never cease to amaze me, that is not a good design it's a brilliant design my friend. Using a hopper with it you will have fantastic results along with it being very quick to use. It is totally amazing and like everyone else I would love to have one for use on my N gauge layout. I will try to remember to mention this fantastic gizmo in my next video. You are truly onto something, at the moment only for use with ballast laying on a model railway but knowing you you will very likely find other uses for it, it is certainly not a daft idea. At a model railway show it would sell like hot cakes. You should think about taking a patent out on it, I think that's what it is called before some nasty person steals your brilliant idea. Regards Chris
Thank you Chris, I though of you when I tested the idea on some N gauge track. Although this was designed for OO it worked just as well on N gauge. I suspect it will work well on O gauge too. I have registered the design, so we will see if it's possible to take it further. All the best, James
Yes, excellent video James. It's a great idea. Looking into the future though,what would stop us automating the whole ballast laying set-up into a fully functioning model? I'm thinking of the laying, profiling and "wetting" of the ballast by a series of trucks hauled by say an old class 47. Food for thought eh. Keep up the good work, your articles are most interesting.
Hi Bill, I have a Mk2 version already designed with some improvements. The concept is so simple that I'm sure it could be developed further. Watch this space, as they say!
Please advise the price of the HO scale complete system that includes the cleaned-up Ballast holding jar. Is Mpeterll a distributor in the States for you and if there are any other distributors kindly advise. I will have approximately 300 ft. to ballast. Thanks for providing a wonderful product to enhance model railroading. l will have approximately 300 ft. to ballast. Thanks for providing a wonderful product to enhance model railroading. Best, Wiley T
Excellent James, would it also be suitable for 7mm (O) Gauge, and what is the optimum Size for the Ballast? Also how does it behave on curved Track? Thank you for sharing.
Hi Peter, I’ve literally just made an O gauge version of the collector which has been tested by a viewer who said it works perfectly. I will be adding it to my online store in the next few days. I will send him a message and ask what size ballast he used, although I reckon it would work with most ballast sizes/types, especially OO size, which I think is what many 7mm modellers use. Thank you for your interest. James
@@BexhillWest Thank you James, I would like to tell you how much I enjoy all your Videos, I really wonder how you find the Time to do all your modelling and development Work whilst also being a busy Teacher, I suspect you don’t sit down much or watch much Television. I am going to try to create a small 0 Gauge Version of either Westerham, or Plumpton Green.
Awesome work! As an Engineer, I can totally appreciate the work that went into this simple concept. Do you have a USA distributor yet? I first came upon this on the Model Railroad Techniques youtube channel but I hope you'll not keep it from us Yanks.
Hi Dirk, my apologies for my delayed reply. Check out Peter at 'mpeterll' RUclips channel. He is supplying to the USA and has just uploaded a video detailing the product. He will be able to sort you out with what you need. My best wishes, James
This is the second time I have watched this video and this device continues to fascinate me. I have one question and this is it. Our vacuum cleaner as a variable setting knob which controls the suction power of the cleaner, so can I assume that the suction setting would need to be set at the lowest suction possible. I would buy one tomorrow. Cheers Greg from Australia
Thank you Greg, I'm using a standard 'Henry' vacuum cleaner set on 'low', although it works just the same when switched to the 'high' setting. It really does make an irksome task rather fun. I reckon a yard of track could easily be ballasted and vacuumed ready for glue in less than a minute. Thanks for watching (again) :) James
Hi James , as others have said a Brilliant Idea I reiterate what others have said in the comments get the Idea Patented before some Cowboy starts production themselves , could this be used for removing excess static grass instead of the " Lets put a sock over the end of the Vac " method because if it could I can see its appeal to War Gamer's and Diorama hobbyists . Looking forward to part 5 of the CAD series , Hope you enjoyed your visit to Gods Little Acre
Thank you Steven. Yes it can, I made a neat filter to go into the collection cap this afternoon and it seems to work very well. Next CAD video later in the week.
It's brilliant in its simplicity - which is the key to all good design, is it not? Please take this to the next level. I noticed the two small indentations which looked like OO/HO gauge track so I was interested to hear you say you had tested it in N gauge. Presumably those indents are intended to keep the head centralised on the rail. Versions for other track gauges would be easy enough to produce would they not OR for the purchaser to modify to suit? [ I have HOm (12mm) gauge track] I would like to buy one, even a prototype. Keep safe and take care.
Hi John, I think there's always an elegance to simplicity, which is what I always aim for. I've experimented with this some more today and its seems to work perfectly with different grades of ballast, and sand too. I would have every confidence in recommending the prototype for 12mm track. I'll let you know if and when I am able to share this more fully. Thanks for watching, James
Sorry that I'm late to the party. I agree with all the previous comments. It's a brilliant invention. How are you progressing with getting it (or the CAD files) to market? I'll certainly buy one (or the CAD files). Be aware that not all vacuum cleaner hoses are the same diameter, so an adapter might be needed for some. Also, is the collection cup a standard (readily available) size or 3D printable?
Thank you Henry. I'm looking to get this made available for everyone. Shapeways is too expensive, and manufacturers either aren't interested or are copying it for themselves. So it looks as though releasing the CAD files is the best bet. At least it will enable those with a 3d printer to get hold of it. I am also working on a simpler fabricated version so that those without a 3d printer can enjoy one too. Stay tuned, there will be an announcement soon.
Great video James thank you ... so how do I obtain what you've made? I certainly don't want to reinvent what you e already done... I'd like to buy one, thanks VinnyD
Hi Vinny, take a look at www.makeitminiature.co.uk. I have them for sale there. Currently they are only shipping to the UK, but I hope to add The rest of the world in a couple of weeks time. Thanks for watching, James
Just come across this and it is a great idea. Any chance you will share the STL files?. I also fly RC planes, there is a company that design planes you can 3D print. They are called 3D labprint it might be worth talking to them about their business model and how they go about selling the files etc needed to print the planes. Either that or you could publish them here for free 🤓
I bought one of these and it is FANTASTIC!
Easy and quick. A great big thank you!
Fabulous Idea Would Definitely Take The Frustration Of Ballasting Away
Liked it a lot
Yes, it is a great idea. I first saw this idea on Facebook railpage that I am a member of. Well done.
It sounds really usefull, I'll look out for the product, thank you. Gary
Will it work on any vacuum cleaner?
Superb idea and it clearly works! Wish I’d see this before ballasting @HighFell!
Top invention! This is an inspiring channel, good stuff
Super idea - definitely something i would be interested in buying.
Hello James this is by far the best version of this type I have seen.
You should seriously consider doing this commercially.
I do love this idea. I have a need for this. I am building a shed for my layout. This could save me time and money. Please let me know more in the future.
Brilliant.
Looks like a great idea to me
Take. My. Money. I am ordering one now to deliver to my brother in Liverpuddle so he can ship it to me in Canada. Merry Christmas me!
Oh, and (minor) suggestion - sizing the screw cap for a mason jar might be more useful to some.
I thought I had seen something like this sometime ago, look forward to seeing the STL files🇦🇺🦘👍🏻
great idea.
It looks great James, you should definitely think about selling it commercially, I personally would purchase one.
Yes please!
Hi James, I really think you should be on the blower (or should that be the "sucker"? No pun intended!) to Peco / Hornby straight away with this before they pinch your design! As for an improvement, if it could clean up the shoulder of the ballast edge at the same time, leaving nice, clean straight lines it would be perfect - possibly with some sort of "Fence" at each side of the attachment which directed the suction to the edges? Imagine just having to dump the ballast onto the track without having to take particular care to spread it evenly, give it a quick once over with your tool, and all done. I think you're on to a winner here.
Thank you Paul. I have designed a version with a built it hopper/shoulder former, which I'm sure would work very well indeed. The set-up shown in the video works really well without any extra 'clutter' and is great for other clean-up jobs too. My thoughts are that this ought to be available with two 'heads', one as you describe and the one shown in the video.
Hi James. I rather like this idea and also the shoulder former you mentioned in your reply to Paul James. I have a few questions: have your ideas progressed at all? You mentioned that it also worked on N gauge track; exactly the same tool? Although yet to start ballasting, I have bought a mini handheld vacuum cleaner for ballast and static grass. I don't know if all mini handheld vacuum cleaners are a standard size, but could you design/build an adaptor for the minis? Look forward to hearing from you.
Echoing the thoughts and comments of many, what brilliant, simple idea. I think the big benefit you have is looking at the various tasks with a new set of eyes and not being fixated on the ‘we’ve always done it like that’ approach. Well done and thank for for ALL your great videos.
Brilliant and practical solution. This is similar to how I ballasted my recent layout, almost discovered using controlled vacuum by accident (ie vacuum collector with spacer), but the hardware was not as elegant as your solution and required precise hand control as was too heavy. If you ever sell or produce the 3D prints on shape ways or other please let us know.
I think you have come up with a great product which i would like to buy one complete as i have only just got into this hobby and i have not got a layout as yet but i am collecting ideas to make my task much easier thank you.
Hi James, I am absolutely delighted with my ballast tool. I was really worried about doing the ballasting on what is my first layout, as it makes such a difference when it is done well. Your
tools make it so easy. Thank you again.
What a brilliant invention, can i place my order for one now please James. may i say, just like all your videos well explained and presented really informative and a pleasure to watch.your daughter will be very proud of her dad, and thank you James for bringing your fresh approach to modelling and your ideas to us all.
Thank you Nigel, I hadn't expected such positivity so quickly in the comments. It's making me think I ought to take this further.
I'm pleased you've been enjoying my videos, such feedback is rare in my day job - the kindness shown through the comments is really appreciated.
My best wishes,
James
I don't think you need to think about taking your invention further i would be applying for a patent on it now, what with your other abilities regarding model buildings etc which could be made in kit form in no time you be giving up your day job where it sounds like your talents are not appreciated, to be very much appreciated by all us modellers
It's a superb idea, and product. I'm sure it'd sell, depending on price, I'd buy one. If required a version for collecting excess scenics, flock, static grass, would be most saleable.
Get a patent or something to protect your idea. This is so brilliant, such a time-saver and more importantly easy to use everyone will want one. I know i'd have one tomorrow. I've got a boatload od ballasting to do and this wouks same me hours and hours. Well done.
HI Alan, I'm pleased you enjoyed this.
The design is registered, and I'm thinking about how to get this out-there. I thought it was a good idea and I'm pleased others can see the benefit as well.
Thanks for watching,
James
Nothing new to say here but just providing you with more feedback. I too think you are on to a winner. Seems to do what's required with efficiency and minimal complexity. What's not to like. Good luck.
Thank you Paul. It's quite fun to use, although ballasting is way off of becoming my favourite job. :)
Brilliant idea for which you've received some good replies previously and some helpful ideas. I look forward to hearing more as time goes on.
Thanks Bob, the Mk 2 version is quite the beast. :)
@@BexhillWest Will follow this up. Thank you
I hope that you get this product made; so that we the railway modelers will have a useful tool for ballasting.
Hi Earl, I have. 😀
It’s available from www.makeitminiature.co.uk
Or in the USA from mpeterll who can be found on RUclips.
Also from Model Railway Techniques in Australia.
From what i have seen, this is one of the best idea's in model rail ballasting i have come accross. Please carry on with this. I live in Holland and i am a member of a model rail club and most of my fellow club members hate ballasting. I think with this idea you will bring even more enjoyment to the hobby
I agree with the comments of others - that is such a great tool! So much easier than laying ballast by hand or with the spreader systems. Well done and more power to your elbow!
Thank you David, you always leave a positive comment, and your support is much appreciated.. I'm pleased you enjoyed the video.
Best wishes,
James
Yup!!!! You got my attention!!!!! I want one!
Thank you. I hope to have an update on this soon.
James
Brilliant idea. Would definitely purchase when available
Thank you very much. :)
The think you are on to something that would be great, have seen this idea many a times but getting to see it work so great makes it a real game changer th o me....thanks for sharing....Jack and hope tut o see more on it in RH he future 👍👍👍👍👍
Brilliant! Especially because it's such a simple concept. (I want one, NOW!) You must make sure your idea is protected. You could, perhaps sell the software/program, which would give you some sort of return, without consuming your time. I, too, have a daughter with a lively, creative mind - she has been a constant delight to me, as I'm sure your daughter is to you. Your output on youtube is the most enjoyable material to emanate from my PC monitor. Thank you. Mike.
The first thing I would do is to take out a patent on your device which I think is brilliant, When I saw the demonstration I could not believe my eyes when you sucked up the ballast material and yet the ballast between the rails stayed in place. You are on a winner. I would love to hear more. Cheers Greg
Thank you Greg - it really does seem to work like magic. I'm very pleased with it. :)
I will post an update when I've figured out how to share the idea efficiently.
Best wishes,
James
What a great idea and problem solver. Would be very interested if it goes into production
Brilliant. I'd certainly be able to make use of this when I get to build my oo guage model of Wolverton center sidings!
Thanks Steve, I'm pleased that you like the idea.
I think it's an amazing idea I would buy one right away.
Brilliant James ,This could be a game changer . Regards David
Brilliant - I would buy one straight away - You really need to set up production . This would sell easily . There is certainly a market there. Well done .
Thank you very much for your feedback. James
I really like it I want one
So we have the ‘Bexhill Ballast Blaster’ !.......don’t move your operation to Taiwan though just yet. Seriously, this has to be a very popular item for railway modeller’s wish lists! Well done James, ‘simple is best’!
Thank you Tony, I always strive for simplicity and am very pleased with this device.
Very interesting indeed! Excellent tangent off into the world of fluid dynamics, in a way that is understandable to a lay-person. Thank you.
First of all I want to say "Great idea". To add to this I must say that I personally find ballasting therapeutic. It also marks an end to the construction of a section of the layout and the beginning of the 'tarting up' and the final stages of the section. Having said that, I love gadgets and would probably buy one if you intended on selling them. This brings me to the next point. I do 3d printing and with the sim to sell and unless you can make lots of an object in a short space of time it is not viable to sell and make money from it unless that is the product is so unique and people really want to buy it irrespective of cost. So yes, brilliant idea, very simple and like mist simple things not much to go wrong. If you do intend selling them let me know and I will buy one. Regards Geoff.
Thank you Geoff. I think that 3d printing these to sell myself will not be possible. I work full-time and just don't have the spare time available. I am considering looking into crowd-funding to see if there's a way to make these cheaply available to all. I'll keep you posted.
@@BexhillWest I know the feeling too well. I myself am working full time and when I get home I can often be up to the small hours 3d printing and generating stock for when the exhibitions and shows resume so I can sell the things I have made. At some point I need more than 3 hours sleep a night.
Wow
That is truly amazing
I found this article/ video via a share from Facebook southern railway modelling group
I’d be really interested to hear how this goes and if there’s a chance one day to be able to use this myself
I’ve also subscribed to your RUclips channel
Thanks for the sub Jon, which facebook group was it. I'm on a couple myself but hadn't seen mention of the device anywhere.
All the best,
James
Hi James - This seems a great idea and for someone who has the ballasting to do on my layout it looks a lot easier than the bang the tracks with a spoon method....................Cheers Kev
Cheers Kev, it does indeed kick that method into the grass. When my printer is idle I'll have to run you one up to try. :)
Thanks James that would be good 😀😀👍🏾
Genius! Never before seen this made so easy!
Thank you very much. It certainly is a time saver.
Hi James, I will be ballasting a decent sized layout in about February 2022 & I would certainly buy this as a product to help the ballasting process. You should market it yourself or sell the design to a manufacturer as soon as possible! I hope you make some money out of your work. Well done.
Brilliant idea
Thanks Jim, I appreciate your feedback. :)
Brilliant idea and prototype well done
Thank you Pete, I'm pleased you like it.
Hi James. I’m only just catching up with a lot of your videos but this idea is genius, just like so much of the other work you do. I look forward to watching each and every video you put up as the content is always fascinating and full of interesting ideas and perspective. I have to congratulate you on the extensive research you put in to every element of your modelling and the results speak for themselves...simply outstanding.
Fantastic! How about adding to the sides in order to clean up the shoulder at the same time? Cheers, Mike
I am watching this quite a while after you filmed it, but if you haven’t patented that design already you need to hurry up. There is a very large market for something such as this. Well done again!
Bugger! I invented (utilised) a cyclone (using a pop bottle) for my vac to collect ballast, years ago! I recently (a few months ago) had a go at 3D printing a tee tube vac end too! It's not the first time someone has brought to market a product that I had thought of years ago! Richard of DCC concepts will attest to being a better businessman than me! lol
What a great idea. I'm sure that anything to help with ballasting is going to be a winner with modellers. Cheers Andy
Thank you Andy, I appreciate your feedback.
Hi James! Brilliant video and having read the other comments, I really can’t add anything else!
You’re design definitely solves the problem.
Ballasting is certainly a job I put off and the idea would help greatly with getting over this task!
Thanks again, Keith
Thank you Keith. With the prospect of so much ballast to lay, and not much enthusiasm for the task, it was a case of necessity being the mother of invention. :)
Morning James, what a brilliant idea, and I've been reading some of your other comments and some people have suggested shoulder and other mods , I must say I like the simplicity of the original design, it looks versatile. Could be used for loads of clean up on the railway. The main thing for me would be cost! If you're only just starting out then maybe you could invest in something like this, if like me your layout is mainly done and only a bit of alterations to do you would need to think about it. It would all come down to cost. Your very lucky to be able to print your own bits, and what a great inventive mind you have. Very well done. Looking forward to seeing the results on your layout take care. Eddy xx
Thank you Eddy for your kind comments.
I've considered every variation of this with all sorts of additional extras, but in all honesty I think the version in the video is the most useful. It seems to do it all it needs to with no fuss. :)
All the best,
James
Excellent, would definitely be interested in getting one for our railway!
I will definitely buy this when it becomes available.
That's great, I'll post an update when they are available.
Excellent Idea James I am sure you can take it further hopefully into production. Good luck.
I will work on the idea a little more. It would be nice to take it into production, but I'm not sure of the best approach.
I think you have done probably the best thing by getting it seen on RUclips to get the general feeling of modellers. Its a job many peopke hate and put off doing particularly in N gauge, ballast hoppers became and still are very popular, but yours easier and quicker as you demonstrated. If you have your own 3D printer produce some kits and let the big boys in railway modelling promote them. Good luck with your project James.
Very interesting James, the ballasting of my track is a task I’m not sure I’m looking forward too. I have one of those track ballaster box things that sit on the track but your hoover attachment looks like something that could save a lot of time and by the looks of it makes a really neat job. I’d certainly be interested in one if you start producing them, cheers John
Thanks John, it makes the task a breeze. Fun to use too. :)
Hi James. You can put washable PVA on a length of greaseproof paper. Put the track down on top and sprinkle the ballast. Leave to dry overnight. Turn the track upside down and the loose ballast will fall off.
Looks like a good idea, a couple of things come to mind:-
1. can you attach to any vacuum cleaner with a hose or will more powerful cleaners suck out the contents of the collection hopper and weaker ones not have enough power ? If it will work with multiple different cleaners then all you need is some sort of universal adapter
2. I think I saw a couple of rail width grooves in the nozzle so do you need different sizes for different gauges ?
3. Will this work with lighter materials such as flock ? If so this could be a really useful tool for anyone working in any type of scenery not just model railways
4. Maybe a couple of extra tools for getting into tight locations might be useful ?
You might want to design to use some sort of easily obtainable standard size container as the collector
Thanks David, you always leave a positive comment!
1. This works on a standard domestic vacuum cleaner. I've designed it to connect to my Numatic Henry, but I'm sure it would fit most. An adaptor ring would enable it to fit just about any vacuum I'm sure.
2. I designed this for OO, but tested it on N gauge too and it worked just as well which was a surprise!
3. My thoughts exactly, I think it would be perfect for lifting static grass. However to do which I think a filter inside the collector head might need to be added as the lightweight fibres would not drop from the cyclone separator.
4. I've already designed a couple...watch this space. :)
Finally, the collection head will fit a wide range of containers as is.
Thanks for the feedback, it's much appreciated!
James
GENIUS!!!!
Thank you!! :)
Hi, just seen this for the first time. It seems very good for the gutty task of ballasting. Has the project moved forward? How is the vacuum powered? Well done for thinking it up.
Hi James I think this is great idea in our club we usually have a ballasting night that way a boring job is dealt with with loads of spoon tapping an brush work to get it done. My only question is when are you going into production with this thing, I think you have a winner. Regards Alan Massie
Totally stunning wow, amazing James there seems to be no limit to your genius chum. Best from Paul at Sandling Junction. We need a catch up .
Thanks Paul, you are too kind.
Excellent idea James, how about elongating the suction sole over the total width of the track including the shoulder? The outer flow of the suction should have the slightest impact as your flow diagram showed. Haven’t come to laying track yet, but when I do, I will certainly apply ballast with your method. Also, your Mary Poppins reference is greatly appreciated, as is your short story about your daughter. Truly saw her in the hardware store with those doubtful eyes kids can share, your narration on the surprise of the shared success following all the more heartfelt. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you Vincent for your lovely comment. It was a special moment when we tried the gadget out and it worked perfectly - we were both chuffed!
Thank you so much for an inspiring video, well done. Track ballasting for me personally is a big problem for me, I just can't seem to get it right, looking like the real thing, I've watched numerous videos ask advice at Model Railway Exhibitions ! Your idea I feel is light at the end of the tunnel, a winner. I look forward to purchasing one. All success to you.
Thank you Ian and my best wishes to you. James
That is pretty cool but you can achieve the same results just as quick with a ballast spreader and a spoon/brush handle. The ballast spreader on the same piece of track takes about 10-15 seconds to put down, then you just rush a brush through the center track, then take the brush (or a spoon) and gently tap the rails. This will remove the ballast pieces from the sleepers. You will still get ballast pieces back on the sleepers once you spray the track with water, then water-pva mix. Might be why the idea was abandoned?
¡Hola buenas tardes James! Having spent the best part of half an hour practicing my very first ballast laying (on a small diorama test piece) my jaw dropped as I watched the first video clip you showed. I say this as, the half hour I spent ballasting was 90% vacuuming-up and, relaying various trial amounts of ballast material. Ignoring the issue of the shoulders being tidy, the fact that your system can actually remove just the excess top-of-the-sleeper ballast, has to be a winner. Should you find a way to provide this equipment commercially, I would definitely be adding my name to the preorder list! Brilliant James and, so well demonstrated. Un saludo. Gary
Thank you Gary. I've tried this now in various configurations, and believe me, this simple first-effort is by far the best.
Modifications to produce a tidy ballast shoulder have worked well, but hinder the wider use of the tool as a vacuum.
If I could only find a way to get the idea out to the masses I'm sure it would be a winner. It needs to be dirt cheap though, and therein lies the problem. It may be that the best solution is simply to make the files available for 3d printing at home. I tried Shapeways and it was way too expensive. Thanks for the support though, it's much appreciated. :)
I think this is a great idea. I think it never took on before, is that it was too expensive to produce.
Wow just come across this and as I have in excess of 200 ft of track to ballast I think it is brilliant. I would definitely be in the market for such a handy device. Have you thought about starting your own cottage industry, certainly you could put me down for one.
Hi Len, I'm trying to get this thing off the ground and hope to have some news soon. I'm just too busy. I need another couple of days in the week to catch-up. :)
Well done James, this is a winner.
Thank you Jeff. I'll be posting another video of it in use very soon as I'm about to begin that particular chore at Bexhill West.
Hi James. I'm convinced. It does a fantastic job. However the success or failure of this as a commercial product is the retail price. Firstly I would copyright it. Secondly I would approach a manufacturer say WWS to make it under licence and pay you a %. The problem I see is a ballast machine like static grass applicators is that they are used once as the layout is set up then they have a tendency to gather dust on the shelf. So overall they work out to be rather expensive. Its personally why i'm still debating whether to buy an applicator. Yet. But its definitely worth further exploration.
I couldn't agree more Gordon. I think a product like this should be available very cheaply, sub £10, after all it's just two bits of plastic and a pipe!. So far I'm not having much luck in finding a suitable manufacturer. :(
Hi James...just had another thought on using any `hoover' of any power/suction...Just looked at my hoover and there is a small slide switch on the pipe extension which you slide open/shut to increase/decrease the suction. You could incorporate a similar switch on the pipe section just prior to the flexible pipe connection. Then possibly any power hoover would work by adjusting sliding open/closing the slide switch. (it certainly works on my hoover).
2. You could also put a slide-on mini brush at the tip to give a final dust off as the hoover is dragged along the track.
3. I like the size of the ballast collector as well.. Maybe a similar size ballast dispenser could be attached through a splayed tip (as your collector).
Hope you can follow my gobbledegook James. Good luck with this project
Hello James, I have just watched the August video of your ballasting tool and I think it is a great idea. I hope that you have developed it further and if you have could you please let me know.Many thanks Lloyd Togneri.
Great Idea quick clean tidy ballasting .
Can I order this please?
well done mate. Share this video. I would love to do some testing for you too.
Hello James, I’ve just stumbled across your site and I am now a subscriber. If you were to make this tool available I would certainly purchase one.
The video content is brill., and I look forward to more.
Have a safe and Merry Christmas
Thank you Chas, I'm so pleased you are enjoying the content and thank you for your subscription.
Hopefully, I'll have some positive news about this in the new year.
Thanks for watching,
James
Brilliant concept and execution James. You could add a `reverse' snow plough guide (perhaps a snap on/slip fit to the funnel to make the shoulder clean up all in one pass. Find a bulk builder and sell this `GEM'. Thankyou
Thank you Martin, I'm looking into it. I'll keep you all informed of the process. Thanks for watching. :)
Absolutely superb gizmo, when are you going into production...I would have thought a kit of parts + a small set of instructions would be a winner. [Chris Marshall 32a model club, Catfield]
James you never cease to amaze me, that is not a good design it's a brilliant design my friend. Using a hopper with it you will have fantastic results along with it being very quick to use. It is totally amazing and like everyone else I would love to have one for use on my N gauge layout. I will try to remember to mention this fantastic gizmo in my next video.
You are truly onto something, at the moment only for use with ballast laying on a model railway but knowing you you will very likely find other uses for it, it is certainly not a daft idea.
At a model railway show it would sell like hot cakes.
You should think about taking a patent out on it, I think that's what it is called before some nasty person steals your brilliant idea.
Regards Chris
Thank you Chris, I though of you when I tested the idea on some N gauge track. Although this was designed for OO it worked just as well on N gauge. I suspect it will work well on O gauge too.
I have registered the design, so we will see if it's possible to take it further.
All the best,
James
Let me know what you think of this idea. Am I onto something, or is this a daft idea? :)
👍
Yes, excellent video James. It's a great idea. Looking into the future though,what would stop us automating the whole ballast laying set-up into a fully functioning model? I'm thinking of the laying, profiling and "wetting" of the ballast by a series of trucks hauled by say an old class 47.
Food for thought eh. Keep up the good work, your articles are most interesting.
Hi Bill,
I have a Mk2 version already designed with some improvements. The concept is so simple that I'm sure it could be developed further. Watch this space, as they say!
Please advise the price of the HO scale complete system that includes the cleaned-up Ballast holding jar. Is Mpeterll a distributor in the States for you and if there are any other distributors kindly advise. I will have approximately 300 ft. to ballast. Thanks for providing a wonderful product to enhance model railroading. l will have approximately 300 ft. to ballast. Thanks for providing a wonderful product to enhance model railroading.
Best, Wiley T
Excellent James, would it also be suitable for 7mm (O) Gauge, and what is the optimum Size for the Ballast? Also how does it behave on curved Track? Thank you for sharing.
Hi Peter,
I’ve literally just made an O gauge version of the collector which has been tested by a viewer who said it works perfectly.
I will be adding it to my online store in the next few days.
I will send him a message and ask what size ballast he used, although I reckon it would work with most ballast sizes/types, especially OO size, which I think is what many 7mm modellers use.
Thank you for your interest.
James
@@BexhillWest Thank you James, I would like to tell you how much I enjoy all your Videos, I really wonder how you find the Time to do all your modelling and development Work whilst also being a busy Teacher, I suspect you don’t sit down much or watch much Television. I am going to try to create a small 0 Gauge Version of either Westerham, or Plumpton Green.
Awesome work! As an Engineer, I can totally appreciate the work that went into this simple concept. Do you have a USA distributor yet? I first came upon this on the Model Railroad Techniques youtube channel but I hope you'll not keep it from us Yanks.
Hi Dirk, my apologies for my delayed reply. Check out Peter at 'mpeterll' RUclips channel. He is supplying to the USA and has just uploaded a video detailing the product. He will be able to sort you out with what you need.
My best wishes,
James
@@BexhillWest Thanks for the info, ordered mine today!
This is the second time I have watched this video and this device continues to fascinate me. I have one question and this is it. Our vacuum cleaner as a variable setting knob which controls the suction power of the cleaner, so can I assume that the suction setting would need to be set at the lowest suction possible.
I would buy one tomorrow. Cheers Greg from Australia
Thank you Greg, I'm using a standard 'Henry' vacuum cleaner set on 'low', although it works just the same when switched to the 'high' setting.
It really does make an irksome task rather fun. I reckon a yard of track could easily be ballasted and vacuumed ready for glue in less than a minute.
Thanks for watching (again) :)
James
Hi James , as others have said a Brilliant Idea I reiterate what others have said in the comments get the Idea Patented before some Cowboy starts production themselves , could this be used for removing excess static grass instead of the " Lets put a sock over the end of the Vac " method because if it could I can see its appeal to War Gamer's and Diorama hobbyists . Looking forward to part 5 of the CAD series , Hope you enjoyed your visit to Gods Little Acre
Thank you Steven.
Yes it can, I made a neat filter to go into the collection cap this afternoon and it seems to work very well.
Next CAD video later in the week.
Super. Just the ticket, any manufactures out there? Hattons etc.
It's brilliant in its simplicity - which is the key to all good design, is it not? Please take this to the next level. I noticed the two small indentations which looked like OO/HO gauge track so I was interested to hear you say you had tested it in N gauge. Presumably those indents are intended to keep the head centralised on the rail. Versions for other track gauges would be easy enough to produce would they not OR for the purchaser to modify to suit? [ I have HOm (12mm) gauge track] I would like to buy one, even a prototype. Keep safe and take care.
Hi John, I think there's always an elegance to simplicity, which is what I always aim for.
I've experimented with this some more today and its seems to work perfectly with different grades of ballast, and sand too. I would have every confidence in recommending the prototype for 12mm track.
I'll let you know if and when I am able to share this more fully.
Thanks for watching,
James
Very interesting, so did you workout a way to share or sell the components
I did. Have a look at www.makeitminiature.co.uk for details.
Thanks for watching,
James
Sounds and looks great...would purchase it from you, if you’d offer it.
Thank you, I will post an update video when there is something to report.
Thanks for watching,
James
Sorry that I'm late to the party. I agree with all the previous comments. It's a brilliant invention.
How are you progressing with getting it (or the CAD files) to market? I'll certainly buy one (or the CAD files).
Be aware that not all vacuum cleaner hoses are the same diameter, so an adapter might be needed for some.
Also, is the collection cup a standard (readily available) size or 3D printable?
Thank you Henry. I'm looking to get this made available for everyone. Shapeways is too expensive, and manufacturers either aren't interested or are copying it for themselves. So it looks as though releasing the CAD files is the best bet. At least it will enable those with a 3d printer to get hold of it. I am also working on a simpler fabricated version so that those without a 3d printer can enjoy one too. Stay tuned, there will be an announcement soon.
This is an excellent idea. Does it work with any vacuum cleaner? It looks good and works very well.
Yes, just a usual domestic hose-type vacuum cleaner. The vacuum nozzle just pushes into the collector head.
Thanks for watching.
Great video James thank you ... so how do I obtain what you've made? I certainly don't want to reinvent what you e already done... I'd like to buy one, thanks VinnyD
Hi Vinny, take a look at www.makeitminiature.co.uk. I have them for sale there. Currently they are only shipping to the UK, but I hope to add The rest of the world in a couple of weeks time.
Thanks for watching,
James
Fantastic idea, does it work as well with all sizes of ballast? Cheers, Phil from Hastings.
Just come across this and it is a great idea. Any chance you will share the STL files?. I also fly RC planes, there is a company that design planes you can 3D print. They are called 3D labprint it might be worth talking to them about their business model and how they go about selling the files etc needed to print the planes. Either that or you could publish them here for free 🤓