Him: "you either love it, or you hate it. there's no in-between." Him LITERALLY one second later: "Personally, i think it's alright." Edit: time stamp is 1:09
In my opinion all of the minecraft discs are good because all of them make you feel something, like they all make you feel different emotions. C418 is a genius And Lena Raine has talent.
13 does have lore, its essential for the theorist community along with 11 and 5. the lore segment is faint and is hard to hear, but it connects with disc 11.
mellohi isn't for scary stuff it's just for the beginning. i prefer ward for what mellohi's start has to offer since the stuff after it is on the same level as say chirp or mall for me
Did you know if you play discs 5, 11, and 13 at the same time it will explain lots of lore such as a guy breathing heavily while lighting a portal and a huge monster coming out and sending the guy who recorded these to an unknown fate , this also adds lore because disc 5 is the deep dark disc which can be found in ancient cites right by the huge portal looking thing
Ward is a personal favorite of mine. I remember listening to it when I first started out in minecraft and played on flat worlds in creative mode, for awhile. It takes me back to times where id build the weirdest contraptions. I also love ward because it gives that mysterious adventure vibe. Also 13 scares me
13, and 11 and music disc 5 are soothing and beautiful songs. I'm so glad they added them both so I can keep replaying and listening to these amazing songs. I knew right off with both of them they were gonna be good, the start off sound is a absolutely a amazing part.
I remember in 2017 when I was building an entire theme park in Minecraft and I wanted to have a music disc for every different themed area, strad for the ocean area, mellohi for the haunted area, Chirp for the ice area, and wait for the ticket line area.
I hope they start just adding multiple music discs per update. they are fun to collect and display. maybe give a unique music disc to each structure. that would give like 16 extra discs.
All the older discs have a special feel to them that makes them feel special and very nostalgic, personally love otherside, was listening to it on Spotify on repeat for a few weeks on my drives to work however it and all the other Lena music I feel just doesn't feel like minecraft music and I just can't listen to them ingame. Minecraft has always had this certain vib with its music and they have broken it with the new discs and honestly its not a great change even if it was with fantastic music
He should’ve ranked the scary disks on how good of a job they do at being scary or eerie… The disk 13 literally made it into the official Backrooms video as the only song in that video, and it fit very well… The lack of melody doesn’t make it trash, it just means that it has a different purpose, same with the other ones
@@brevortofficial personally i joined in 1.8, but i just find the 1.8 features forgetabble, i cant really remember what was added other than that, my favourite updates must be 1.13, 1.16 and 1.18
@@Uasnordyeah Most updates before 1.8 were really forgettable. i only really remember 1.5 Redstone update 1.6 Added horses 1.7 Changed Terrain (wait 1.7 and 1.17) 1.8 Added the command block types which is really all i remember 1.9 The combat update (and end cities) 1.10 wait does anyone actually know what was added here lol 1.11 Exploration update which added the woodland mansion and illagers 1.12 Color update added concrete and changed some textures 1.13 i really hate this one but it fixed the oceans so yay 1 14 Village and Pillage 1.15 Buzzy Bees but also fixed the horrible 1.13 lag 1.16 One of the best recent updates 1.17 Caves and Cliffs Part 1, Other than copper, what really was added 1.18 I really like what they did to the terrain here 1.19 The mild Update , the warden was good everything else is forgettable 1.20 Trails and Tales, Dont get me wrong here its still a good update but everything in it you'll use for like 2 weeks and forget it except for like the cherry trees they look cool
3:49 i live in pennsylvania and was born in colorado. I have been to king of prussia, and it is AMAZING! The marbe floors, the store selection, etc is all so alien to me. The malls i went to in colorado were.. meh, kind of bland.
I love discs 5, 11 and 13, the sound of a previous survivor running from mobs and fucking dying is the only thing keeping me sane these last few months
3:32 w taste in music i just love pigstep, i love c418's music but in discs pigstep is just the goat some people say that it's overrated but i think that it's underrated af.
i think the most nostalgic part about this video is the battleblock theatre gift shop music. i grew up playing battleblock so the background music really took me back lol
My favorite disc by C4-18 is Ward, it’s just got a really cool vibe, not as good as Pigstep or Otherside, but better than a lot others. The new one, Relic, is pretty cool, I think ward is a bit better
personally my top 5 imo: 5: otherside (sounds cool) 4: chirp (reminds me of nostalgia) 3: pigstep (do i need an explanation?) 2: mellohi (sounds boring to some but i personally love it) 1: not stal, but dog (not fully released, used to play after cat, it's like the kind of music your dog would hear when you walk them)
stal is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo amazinggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
I feel like nostalgia may be influencing this because Pigstep and otherwise are the best discs, I to am nostalgic for blocks and chirp as I used to love listening to them but they're kinda mid now
you should check out the video where disc 5, 11, and 13 gets played all together. it eerily fits together and makes more sense than just playing it by themselves.
I watched retrogamingnow and he talked about "diegetic" which means something that a fictional character can hear within a fictional world. the theory goes in 11 the guy lights a flint and steel and on his second light he sees the endermen in which digs out to get away and ofc the endermen catches him. well we hear that little music bit in the background while he digs, a bit like when we see an enderman and it chases us, so that would mean the physical sound when the enderman is chasing us is actually real, like its not a scary sound, no they genuinely make that sound
Strad is my favorite of the bunch, such a good tune. But I will always have a place in my heart for chirp because I remember playing the og Xbox one edition Minecraft mini games and in the lobby I would always go find this disc. So those are my favorites
Him: "you either love it, or you hate it. there's no in-between."
Him LITERALLY one second later: "Personally, i think it's alright."
Edit: time stamp is 1:09
peak comedy
(bad to the bone riff here)
That's what I'm saying lol
IK BRO I WAS LITERALLY ABOUT TO COMMENT THIS 😂
thats wot am san
In my opinion all of the minecraft discs are good because all of them make you feel something, like they all make you feel different emotions. C418 is a genius And Lena Raine has talent.
Human Humanson is the best, though.
and also Samuel Aberg is like *heaven sounds for seconds*
@@patriciakhadijah7788 Actually, it's Samuel Åberg.
@@patriciakhadijah7788 I don't think so
My name is samuel
I love the "I don' care what you think I'm putting it here" vibe of these tier list creations
don'd dell me whad do do
Which are kinda how opinions are supposed to work
Fr
I like it cause it’s how it should be
Stal sounds like a decent middle school Jazz band
Ye
13 does have lore, its essential for the theorist community along with 11 and 5. the lore segment is faint and is hard to hear, but it connects with disc 11.
but it sounds like utter crap
@@thedogmaster278 Sounds like garbage but tells a story with 11 and was an og
🤓
I love listening to 11 and especially 13 they are very calming to me
@@TdoggVRReal 😬 bro thinks I'm a nerd
1:08 “you either love it or you hate it, no in between. personally I think it’s alright” 😭
Melloni is a good disk when you listen for it a while, everyone thinks it sucks because it has a pretty bad start.
The start ain’t bad at all
mellohi isn't for scary stuff it's just for the beginning. i prefer ward for what mellohi's start has to offer since the stuff after it is on the same level as say chirp or mall for me
Or they dislike waltz music, my problem is it’s the shortest “actual” music disc
mellohi sounds like the mafia
Mellohi is the theme of a tyrannical server admin
Cat will always hold a special place in my heart. The nostalgia, the comfort, the xbox 360 memories! This is truly a perfect music disc.
same the Cat music disc was the first music disk that was added that wasn't trash
fr
Its nostalgic in general even if you haven't heard of cat or minecraft
Did you know if you play discs 5, 11, and 13 at the same time it will explain lots of lore such as a guy breathing heavily while lighting a portal and a huge monster coming out and sending the guy who recorded these to an unknown fate , this also adds lore because disc 5 is the deep dark disc which can be found in ancient cites right by the huge portal looking thing
Wait really?
5 also has what is very clearly armored soldiers marching.
Not at the exact same time ur suppose to wait
@kainoa1290 There is a moment in disc 13 that goes quiet and that's where disc 11 goes
I’d say the huge monster threw him into the portal and destroyed it
Who knows
We’ll know in the next update
Ward is a personal favorite of mine. I remember listening to it when I first started out in minecraft and played on flat worlds in creative mode, for awhile. It takes me back to times where id build the weirdest contraptions. I also love ward because it gives that mysterious adventure vibe. Also 13 scares me
I remember playing ward in a funeral on a server after our villager killing zombie died 😂,
ward is my favorite too. its very underrated
Ward is THE GOAT
When I made custom maps on the 360, I always played Ward as the boss theme. I still think it gives boss battle vibes.
I was playing ward when I did a minecraft school party, it's not memories, it was last week.
Disc 11 the bop obvi
freal
Freal
freal
freal
freal
My 5 favorite discs:
1) Otherside
2) Cat
3) Wait (Where are we now)
4) Pigstep
5) Far
Otherside goes so hard .
Not chirp? :(
@@VermillionPotatochirp is what you'd hear in the backrooms.
Mine:
1. 13
2. 5
3. 11
4. Nothing, I only like these three
@@You_Yh14f*** I hate those because how scary it is but 5 on that "RAOOORR" Part gets me laughing
I have 13 saved in my playlist and I gladly listen to it in my free time, and I don’t feel ashamed for it
I'm not the only one?! This is life changing.
You shouldn't feel Shame, You should Feel Guilt
Go to sleep with it on repeat
"stal, you either like it or you hate it, no in between... i think it's ok."
13, and 11 and music disc 5 are soothing and beautiful songs. I'm so glad they added them both so I can keep replaying and listening to these amazing songs.
I knew right off with both of them they were gonna be good, the start off sound is a absolutely a amazing part.
Can't wait for 7 and 9 after the skulk dimension
@@Anipaper_ no I think you mean disc 1 and 2 obviously 🤦♂️
@@Timlba63Jonesy bro what about disk 245 and disk 241🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
And disc 666
@@Timlba63Jonesy bruh
Getting a music disc is just like getting diamonds, they are very rare and also sometimes good to listen too. Relic and Otherside are bangers to me
Agreed
How are you listening to diamonds
@@AtomicVegetabletext interpretation on top
I was gonna say the same thing 💀@@AtomicVegetable
@@AtomicVegetablethe jukebox. You use diamonds to make the jukebox, lol
My Top 5:
5. Relic (It's good, but it needs time to grow on me.)
4. Wait
3. Pigstep
2. Strad
1. Otherside
Yooo, a fellow Strad fan. I wholeheartedly agree with your ranking
help. YOU PUT OTHERSIDE AT FIRST??????????? my mom literally made me turn off the song because it is so repetitive.
@@CraftingCole It’s a bop to be fair. At least it isn’t mellohi or something
@@megadynamic7888 bro Mellon I is one of the best music discs. But Strad is just amazing
@@megadynamic7888mellohi is a solid song but we all have our opinions
Mall is criminally underrated
This is actually how I would rank them all, these are all very reasonable, and pigstep is literally such a bop
8:25 The relic disc also has the same melody as the song "The Well of Fate" from Minecraft Legends
so Its both LORE and A Bop!
Takes notes 11, 13 and 5
So Legends is canon?
“You either love it or you hate it. Personally I think it’s ok.”
I know what you mean, like your size right?
I went straight to the comments lol
Stal gives me the feeling that other dics don't. The entire disc is dirpy and funny, one that stands out.
careful, change the spelling of "disc" before people reply with "AYO" and the flushed emoji...
"you either love it or you hate it, there's no in between". "I personally think it's alright"
WHAT??!!
Mellohi sounds like the bad dystopian ending in a video game.
It sort of reminded me of presentable liberty
reminds of the mafia
I remember in 2017 when I was building an entire theme park in Minecraft and I wanted to have a music disc for every different themed area, strad for the ocean area, mellohi for the haunted area, Chirp for the ice area, and wait for the ticket line area.
Chirp to me is literally defined by Stampy and Squid.
minecraft music discs: sadness, loneliness, feeling of time passing
pigstep: *v i b e*
Mellohi sounds like an argument at a bar where tensions are slowly rising
I hope they start just adding multiple music discs per update. they are fun to collect and display. maybe give a unique music disc to each structure. that would give like 16 extra discs.
13 fills out a blank spot in the broken music disc, giving a little bit of a fuller story
All the older discs have a special feel to them that makes them feel special and very nostalgic, personally love otherside, was listening to it on Spotify on repeat for a few weeks on my drives to work however it and all the other Lena music I feel just doesn't feel like minecraft music and I just can't listen to them ingame. Minecraft has always had this certain vib with its music and they have broken it with the new discs and honestly its not a great change even if it was with fantastic music
Yeah pigstep and otherside is good music but if you would have asked me which game this was from I wouldn’t say Minecraft
I think wait is one of the best ones
It sound fermilsry form when I used to play minecraft back when it was a stillbrelitiy new song
i agree with everything except that out of all the new music you only like otherside. It is so repetitive.
@@CraftingCole you have a point there if I would say something negative it would be that
1:09 “you either love it or you hate it. No in between.”
3 seconds later : “it’s alright”
5:44 the most nostalgic thing you could hear (OPINION)
My Top 5:
5. Pigstep
4. Far
3. Strad
2. Otherside
1. Stal
stal
opinion: agreed
"you either love it or hate it, no inbetween."
-"I personally think its alright"
2:30 chirp is great because of the Xbox 360 tutorial
He should’ve ranked the scary disks on how good of a job they do at being scary or eerie… The disk 13 literally made it into the official Backrooms video as the only song in that video, and it fit very well… The lack of melody doesn’t make it trash, it just means that it has a different purpose, same with the other ones
Disc 13 is the Backrooms theme?
am i the only one that thinks chirp is really creepy
@@FlameyClockspeedchirp sounds a bit creepy hearing it first, but it kinda reminds you of 90s music/nostalgia
1.16 is my favorite update because of Pigstep (probably also because i started playing in 1.15 but you get the point).
Makes sense, I got Minecraft in 1.7 and my favorite Update was 1.8, but now 1.20 is my favorite (I've heard people say 1.20 is like 1.8 Part II)
@@brevortofficial personally i joined in 1.8, but i just find the 1.8 features forgetabble, i cant really remember what was added
other than that, my favourite updates must be 1.13, 1.16 and 1.18
I started in 1.16
@@Uasnordyeah Most updates before 1.8 were really forgettable.
i only really remember
1.5 Redstone update
1.6 Added horses
1.7 Changed Terrain (wait 1.7 and 1.17)
1.8 Added the command block types which is really all i remember
1.9 The combat update (and end cities)
1.10 wait does anyone actually know what was added here lol
1.11 Exploration update which added the woodland mansion and illagers
1.12 Color update added concrete and changed some textures
1.13 i really hate this one but it fixed the oceans so yay
1
14 Village and Pillage
1.15 Buzzy Bees but also fixed the horrible 1.13 lag
1.16 One of the best recent updates
1.17 Caves and Cliffs Part 1, Other than copper, what really was added
1.18 I really like what they did to the terrain here
1.19 The mild Update , the warden was good everything else is forgettable
1.20 Trails and Tales, Dont get me wrong here its still a good update but everything in it you'll use for like 2 weeks and forget it except for like the cherry trees they look cool
I wish we had a disc that was just the classical part of disc 5, but extended. I’ve always though that part sounds great on its own as eerie music.
3:49 i live in pennsylvania and was born in colorado. I have been to king of prussia, and it is AMAZING! The marbe floors, the store selection, etc is all so alien to me. The malls i went to in colorado were.. meh, kind of bland.
Please do more longer videos like this
alr
@@G1zzmo82man said ok
In disk 5 it has some of Minecraft Legends noises
Yes, stal, I quite like it as well. Otherside has grown on me. and thank you for not putting wait in a low rank
STAL IS EASY BANGER. The Jazzy of beat notes with the scetchy drums are just amazing along with the low base
@@CraftingCole yes, big banger
"You either love it or you hate it. There's no in between. Me personally, I think it's alright" - This amused me more than it should have.
Pigstep, stal, and chirp are the best in my opinion. but 13 is my favorite lore disc of all time.
Relic and other side make me feel like a rainbow is partying inside of my head
Congrats ahead of time on a well-deserved 20k subs!! 🎉🎉
ty🎉
"You either love it or hate it, no in between!"
"Personally I think it's alright."
Bros ranking every item in minecraft
fr
I love discs 5, 11 and 13, the sound of a previous survivor running from mobs and fucking dying is the only thing keeping me sane these last few months
bro already had the worst tear named “13”
Music discs should continue a creepy vibe
0:28 only twenty eight seconds in and I’m already cracking up😂
The battleblock theater music at the beginning brought back good memories
1. Stal
2. Pigstep
3. 13
All I gotta say
Here's my ranking of the music discs:
1. Strad
2. Ward (yes, I ACTUALLY like that one)
3. Wait (aka Where are we now)
4. Chirp
5. otherside
Can’t listen to Pigstep without being sad because it reminds me of Techno 😢
Are you insulting my favorite music genre
No? He’s not
@@cjxander9205what are you talkin about?
@@cjxander9205no
Stal is my favorite, along with creator and pigstep
I unironically listen to 5 when I study
Wow. 😧
Really fits my mood while studying
For me personally, I think that disk 13 seems like something out of a horror game.
Far used to be my favorite disc ever. Now with 1.20, it is:
3rd place: Far
2nd place: Otherside
1st place: Relic
3:32 w taste in music
i just love pigstep, i love c418's music but in discs pigstep is just the goat
some people say that it's overrated but i think that it's underrated af.
I like how he has the time to rate all of these and reply to our comments. None of the big youtubers I know of have done this.
this is why you should subscribe and smash like
@@G1zzmo82fax
My top 3:
1) Wait
2) Otherside
3) Stal
7:08 okay, okay ill wait.
Stal is my GOAT. I understand why someone would hate it, but it clears everything else
The beat drop go crazy
I'd switch Mall with Melloshi, put Blocks higher and Relic a bit lower
nice
i think the most nostalgic part about this video is the battleblock theatre gift shop music. i grew up playing battleblock so the background music really took me back lol
My favorite disc by C4-18 is Ward, it’s just got a really cool vibe, not as good as Pigstep or Otherside, but better than a lot others. The new one, Relic, is pretty cool, I think ward is a bit better
Favorite song c418 cat
Favorite song Lena raine otherside
Ward is a very good disc. Tbh most discs are pretty amazing.
Stal is my favorite but I understand why u like wait its my 2nd
ward is my favorite. its really underrated
I love that 13 has its own tier
I love disc 13, should i get a therapist?
you might need
more than that
I personally like it too
Otherside is my all time favourite, it sounds like a pokemon medley which is so nostalgic to me
3:45 mall
Great video!
You should update this again for 1.21 because we're getting another three music discs!
L G1zzmo for making Lacking green, it’s yellow, it’s always yellow
my b
think of it as limited edition lacking tier
@@G1zzmo82 no lacking is good only in green
Bro the mall one 😂
Mall is so underrated tbh
pigstep was a cultural reset
Pig step is just the best music disc, whenever I listen to it I just imagine Piglins dancing in a bastion 😂
“Stal: either you love it or you hate, it there is no in between”
Also him “I guess it okay”
first
W
13 when played with 11 has lots of lore
personally my top 5 imo:
5: otherside (sounds cool)
4: chirp (reminds me of nostalgia)
3: pigstep (do i need an explanation?)
2: mellohi (sounds boring to some but i personally love it)
1: not stal, but dog (not fully released, used to play after cat, it's like the kind of music your dog would hear when you walk them)
Strad brings back so many memories
Relic is the best and I will fight anyone that disagrees
I agree with you
I prefer any c418 discs
agreed
I agree 100%
True
Chirp is so good change my mind
stal is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo amazinggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
i think bro likes stal a bit too much
The otherside music disc is my favourite it's a banger!
My personal ranking:
1. Blocks Masterpiece
2. Chirp
______________________
3. Cat (including Dog)
4. Pigstep Amazing
5. Stal
_______________________
6. Wait
7. Otherside Pretty good
8. Mall
9. Relic
_______________________
10. Ward
11. Strad Average
12. Far
_______________________
13. Mellohi Boring asf
14. Disc 5
_______________________
15. Disc 11
16. Disc 13 What the
hell am I listening too?!?
I feel like nostalgia may be influencing this because Pigstep and otherwise are the best discs, I to am nostalgic for blocks and chirp as I used to love listening to them but they're kinda mid now
you should check out the video where disc 5, 11, and 13 gets played all together. it eerily fits together and makes more sense than just playing it by themselves.
mellohi sounds good imo
I watched retrogamingnow and he talked about "diegetic" which means something that a fictional character can hear within a fictional world. the theory goes in 11 the guy lights a flint and steel and on his second light he sees the endermen in which digs out to get away and ofc the endermen catches him. well we hear that little music bit in the background while he digs, a bit like when we see an enderman and it chases us, so that would mean the physical sound when the enderman is chasing us is actually real, like its not a scary sound, no they genuinely make that sound
My top 5:
5. Cat
4. Otherside
3. Relic
2. Pigstep
1. ✨Stal✨
Wait is surprisingly underrated
Your blocks ranking should have you arrested
come at me
@@G1zzmo82your a monster
@@MrMolotus you're* 🤓
@@klopsmmmno.
@@gameswithdarn oh, you too? Go back to first grade
Ward is very nostalgic to me. Also the bit with music after the cut in 13 will 100% give you chills down your spine
M U S I C
yes
D I S C
Fun fact: playing "Cat" for your cat irl will make it fly
My ranking
16)11
15)13
14) Disc 5
13) Strad
12) Mall
11) Far
10) Ward
9) Otherside
8)Relic
7)Cat
6)Stal
5)blocks
4)pigstep
3)mellohi
2)Wait
1)Chirp
great list, i agree with most of it, but mellohi isnt that good imo. nice to see wait so high too
Strad is good and far better than blocks
Finally someone who doesn’t have otherside in top tier
@@EmilyS1234right. And relic too
I just imagined a detective siiting when mellohi is playing
ward is best
Strad is my favorite of the bunch, such a good tune. But I will always have a place in my heart for chirp because I remember playing the og Xbox one edition Minecraft mini games and in the lobby I would always go find this disc. So those are my favorites