I think after this trilogy the lads should immediately do them again but extended versions. Because I enjoy their pain and then they would have to upload Hobbit Extended and then Hobbit Extended Extended.
@@Hockeyhobo89 to be fair I was pleasantly surprised when I finally watched the extended Hobbits. There is a lot to like. There's just a few things I don't, and I like it better when it's focused on Bilbo and the company
It shows that even though he didn't wana make the movie, PJ has brass balls and dedication to his work. "I hate this movie.... Wait you want who? The 'thats not what a killing stab sounds like and trust me on that I know, whaddaya mean this sword is only decorational, do I really have to bring my own?'-guy? Owh well, guess thats one way out of the seat"
Wasn't one of the orcs from this movie modeled after Harvey weinstein? Can't remember if it was Azog or a LOTR orc. Anyways, classic Mr. Sunday movies review, I especially enjoyed when Morbius showed up in the Hobbit post credit scene
Nah, the deformed orc from Return of the King (Gothmog or something) was the one based on Weinstein bc he previously interfered with the production of the films and tried to stop them from being made I believe
When cinematographers had to contrive reasons for characters to point various pointy things straight into the camera for reasons that did not serve the plot or mise-en-scène in any way
You think THIS looks like shit? My parents refuse to switch off the motion smoothing on their new TV so anything with a BBC type budget like DR WHO looks supremely terrible.
I am a very for real Tolkien geek, 50 years old, grew up on it and as much a "scholar" (at least within the Christopher Tolkien edit) of Middle Earth as anyone. I am not a fan of the Jackson LOTR flicks because of the dreadful butchering of the lore, characters and storyline in favour of what some witless screenwriting hack thinks would be better than what old JRR wrote himself. Imagine what I think of this pile of awful pile of s**te. Dwarves with no beards, so they can be pretty. Jesus.
@@Henez89 Funnily enough I hate it a lot less than the Jackson films. But that's 'cos I've only watched the first one so far probably. Tolkien himself thought Galadriel was woefully underwritten and always wanted to expand her story a bit. Now, the notion of her as a sort of junior ranking war captain is pretty absurd, and the idea that she hung around Middle Earth solely to avenge her brother is also way off. But I manage, in my head, to see it as a bit of fan fiction written by someone who doesn't know the lore that well (even if the reality is actually just another corporate nightmare) . Whereas Jackson had an actual screenplay in the the form of the LOTR novels (obviously needing an edit for a movie) but simply chose to deliberately bsstsrdise it. As an aside, colour blind casting of black elves and dwarves etc means bugger all to me, it's fine, but again a deliberate corporate choice to not only avoid being accused of not being inclusive, but I think purposefully rattling the chains of all the silly f***kers on the Internet who can't cope with with the idea of colour blind casting, which in turn gets lots of extras buzz from s**t eating journalists writing columns about foamy mouthed keyboard warriors. And so it goes on. It wouldn't surprise me me that by episode 3 I'll switch it off and never turn it back on, mind.
I think after this trilogy the lads should immediately do them again but extended versions. Because I enjoy their pain and then they would have to upload Hobbit Extended and then Hobbit Extended Extended.
It always triggers me when someone doesn’t watch the extended editions. I literally can’t watch the theatrical cuts anymore.
@@Hockeyhobo89 LOTR Extended all day. For the Hobbit I watch a fan edit that plays like a single extended cut film ha
@@Henez89 I’m one of the few who likes the hobbit so that wouldn’t fly with me. 😂
@@Hockeyhobo89 to be fair I was pleasantly surprised when I finally watched the extended Hobbits. There is a lot to like. There's just a few things I don't, and I like it better when it's focused on Bilbo and the company
I love when he drops the blue harvest bit… everytime😂😂
I completely forgot Christopher Lee was in this till they brought it up. What a legend.
It shows that even though he didn't wana make the movie, PJ has brass balls and dedication to his work.
"I hate this movie.... Wait you want who? The 'thats not what a killing stab sounds like and trust me on that I know, whaddaya mean this sword is only decorational, do I really have to bring my own?'-guy? Owh well, guess thats one way out of the seat"
23:20 Thorin is the Flexo from Futurama of this universe. "Hahaha, just kidding, you're a wonderful man."
Mr. Dumbday Movies
Got 'em
Wrecked. They have been wrecked. Wrecking has occured.
Don’t see how they’re ever gonna recover from this one
Wasn't one of the orcs from this movie modeled after Harvey weinstein? Can't remember if it was Azog or a LOTR orc. Anyways, classic Mr. Sunday movies review, I especially enjoyed when Morbius showed up in the Hobbit post credit scene
Nah, the deformed orc from Return of the King (Gothmog or something) was the one based on Weinstein bc he previously interfered with the production of the films and tried to stop them from being made I believe
@@orsonlepherd7064 ahhh I see. Thanks for clarifying!
Remember back in the 2010s when everyone thought 3D would catch on? That was such a horrible and stupid time in human history.
When cinematographers had to contrive reasons for characters to point various pointy things straight into the camera for reasons that did not serve the plot or mise-en-scène in any way
Nice
You think THIS looks like shit? My parents refuse to switch off the motion smoothing on their new TV so anything with a BBC type budget like DR WHO looks supremely terrible.
First world problems :D
In fairness Doctor Who looks terrible irrespective or whether or not there is motion smoothing
You all are making the Hobbit good right now
I am a very for real Tolkien geek, 50 years old, grew up on it and as much a "scholar" (at least within the Christopher Tolkien edit) of Middle Earth as anyone. I am not a fan of the Jackson LOTR flicks because of the dreadful butchering of the lore, characters and storyline in favour of what some witless screenwriting hack thinks would be better than what old JRR wrote himself. Imagine what I think of this pile of awful pile of s**te. Dwarves with no beards, so they can be pretty. Jesus.
For the love of God go outside
@@videogamenostalgia :D That coming from someone calling themselves "videogamenostalgia"
Bet you're loving the Rings of Power
@@Henez89 Funnily enough I hate it a lot less than the Jackson films. But that's 'cos I've only watched the first one so far probably. Tolkien himself thought Galadriel was woefully underwritten and always wanted to expand her story a bit. Now, the notion of her as a sort of junior ranking war captain is pretty absurd, and the idea that she hung around Middle Earth solely to avenge her brother is also way off. But I manage, in my head, to see it as a bit of fan fiction written by someone who doesn't know the lore that well (even if the reality is actually just another corporate nightmare) . Whereas Jackson had an actual screenplay in the the form of the LOTR novels (obviously needing an edit for a movie) but simply chose to deliberately bsstsrdise it. As an aside, colour blind casting of black elves and dwarves etc means bugger all to me, it's fine, but again a deliberate corporate choice to not only avoid being accused of not being inclusive, but I think purposefully rattling the chains of all the silly f***kers on the Internet who can't cope with with the idea of colour blind casting, which in turn gets lots of extras buzz from s**t eating journalists writing columns about foamy mouthed keyboard warriors. And so it goes on. It wouldn't surprise me me that by episode 3 I'll switch it off and never turn it back on, mind.
@@andrewgoodall2183 fair enough. I'm cautiously enjoying RoP so far. I will enjoy an expensive second age location tour if nothing else