"A Free Society Does Not Ban Books" - Nikole Hannah-Jones

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024

Комментарии • 608

  • @balcorn9211
    @balcorn9211 Год назад +481

    "...the highest calling of patriotism, which is to see the ways in which your country is failing, to see the hypocrisy of your country, to see the way your country is not living up to it's highest ideals, but still believing that your country can become the thing that we all dream it to be."

  • @cal2780
    @cal2780 Год назад +2

    When I was in junior highschool, 1963, I asked about the contributions of people of color and native Americans to the history of America. I was ridiculed and bullied....by my history teacher. I grew up in an all "white" city in the Midwest. I was taught to fear anyone not "white" like me. It didn't work. Just made me more curious about people "not like me". Ignorant adults!

  • @sapna627
    @sapna627 Год назад

    they cut out the song at the end which was perfect

  • @reneekad
    @reneekad Год назад

    I understand the desire to own people but that’s not great policy. Plus I’m sure there are some laws against such things.

  • @ivannano
    @ivannano Год назад

    The complete opposite of how right wing politicians are framing this.

  • @berthabridges3483
    @berthabridges3483 Год назад +65

    "The question is not whether we can afford to invest in every child; it is whether we can afford not to."
    ~ Marian Wright Edelman, American lawyer, activist, writer, and founder of the Children's Defense Fund

  • @berthabridges3483
    @berthabridges3483 Год назад +44

    "All of us must recognize that education and innovation will be the currency of the twenty-first century."
    ~ Barack Obama, American lawyer, writer, politician, activist, and humanitarian who served as the 44th President of the United States 🇺🇸

  • @jonstewartsuperfan2988
    @jonstewartsuperfan2988 Год назад +64

    Ironically the Facts dont care about your feelings crowd get really offended by this lady just stating historical facts

    • @martytrueblood5902
      @martytrueblood5902 Год назад

      orbis spike 1610 is earth record..
      ju wish though
      hun...
      snickers

    • @JSephH76
      @JSephH76 Год назад +10

      @@martytrueblood5902 Did you just have a stroke my man

    • @martytrueblood5902
      @martytrueblood5902 Год назад

      @@JSephH76 Facts don't care about your feelings
      sweety

    • @johnmesser3278
      @johnmesser3278 Год назад +3

      A coherent comment might help you eventually

    • @JSephH76
      @JSephH76 Год назад +3

      @@martytrueblood5902 No I mean you were literally incomprehensible. Genuinely thought you might have had a stroke because if you decided to type and submit that comment while completely sober then there is no hope for you. I am either going to be worried for your physical health (stroke) or mental health (sanity) so pick which it is.

  • @berthabridges3483
    @berthabridges3483 Год назад +98

    "The whole world 🌎 opened to me when I learned to read."
    ~ Mary McLeod Bethune (1875-1955), American educator, stateswoman, philanthropist, humanitarian, and activist

    • @gloriaf6971
      @gloriaf6971 Год назад +7

      Ms Bethune was absolutely right. People who know how to read but don't do so are no better off than someone who is illiterate.

  • @SirRocktober
    @SirRocktober Год назад +28

    "When you tear out a man's tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you are only telling the world that you fear what he might say" George R.R. Martin (edited because of autocorrect)

  • @Rebel_AF
    @Rebel_AF Год назад +139

    Absolutely brilliant! Wish I'd learned about this sooner in school but glad to be educated about it now. Love that Stephen Colbert is having important guests like this on the show. ❤️👍🤘🙏

  • @berthabridges3483
    @berthabridges3483 Год назад +168

    "Empower yourselves with a good education, then get out there and use that education to build a country worthy of your boundless promise."
    ~ Michelle Obama, American lawyer, writer, activist, and humanitarian who served as the First Lady of the United States of America 🇺🇸

    • @shirleyrombough8173
      @shirleyrombough8173 Год назад +2

      It's encouraging that Stephen's audience knew of and supported the 1619 project and its author.

    • @enviromental2565
      @enviromental2565 Год назад +2

      My husband was raised in a racist family, who were die hard Republicans. During the Obama presidency, he became completely became enamored with Michelle Obama. He greatly admired her strength, intelligence, and grace as First Lady.

    • @alfredlutz7258
      @alfredlutz7258 Год назад

      Good idea, but I'd like to know how many black kids couldn't afford to get that education because her husband promoted bankers' interests over those of black people trapped in subprime mortgages. The Obamas were a lot of hat but no cattle.

    • @feliciapate7926
      @feliciapate7926 Год назад +1

      I don't know if you copy-and-pasted this or if you wrote it, but it's cool that "First Lady" wasn't the first thing listed in Ms. Obama's accomplishments here.

  • @craigsavarese4554
    @craigsavarese4554 Год назад +146

    As a history major, I hold it in the highest regards. History is not meant to make a person feel good or bad, it is a tool to inform you of what has taken place before and to learn from it. Those that choose to ignore, deny, or edit the truth of history are doomed to repeat its tragedies.

    • @eponymousIme
      @eponymousIme Год назад +6

      >>History is not meant to make a person feel good or bad, it is a tool to inform you of what has taken place before and to learn from it.

    • @leannej.mangano1097
      @leannej.mangano1097 Год назад +6

      EXACTLY!!!! It's such a simple concept and it blows my mind that so many people don't understand it

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Год назад +7

      Then maybe you'd know that her books have literally been debunked thousand of times

    • @darkphoenix6807
      @darkphoenix6807 Год назад +1

      Can you please add a link to one of those times? If you’re going to say alms thing like that, prove it.

    • @m.j.cicero276
      @m.j.cicero276 Год назад +4

      @@karankapoor2701 Yes, do educate us, please - exactly when, where, and how did this "debunking" take place? You see, some of us value actual facts over bullshit.

  • @MrJimmy1953
    @MrJimmy1953 Год назад +62

    Thank you Nikole. Yes, in a free country no book should be banned. Especially a book called the 1619 project.

    • @luisnieves8242
      @luisnieves8242 Год назад

      why do I need to know all about blacks.not interested

  • @mrpearson1230
    @mrpearson1230 Год назад +76

    Thankyou for bringing this very educated queen on! Love this woman! Get her book & read it! It's so good! I plan on reading again! 18 non-fictional essays 17 scholars 36 poems and/or works of fiction! Many historians took part in this wonderful work! You will benefit from reading this book!

    • @brianag9726
      @brianag9726 Год назад +10

      I will be buying, reading and sharing with my students, as appropriate. Thankfully I don’t teach in one of the 14 states that she mentions.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @JEric P., I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

    • @mrpearson1230
      @mrpearson1230 Год назад +1

      ​@StumblingThroughItAll oversight? Be careful who you "stumble across". Everybody has a narrative of history. Just because you read something with a different narrative and you personally agree with it more doesn't make it more true than the folks who may have a more accurate representation of history like 1619 which many historians took part in.

  • @hugovallarta
    @hugovallarta Год назад +84

    I had no knowledge of any of this. I'm looking forward to educating myself. Thank you for having her on your show

    • @gcromer903
      @gcromer903 Год назад +1

      Thank you for listening 🙂

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Hugo Aguirre, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @dustykashifeathers858
    @dustykashifeathers858 Год назад +214

    if ignorance is bliss, then I'd rather be uncomfortably aware; thank you Nicole Hannah Jones, can't wait to read your vital book; and we all know how when a book gets banned, it only goes viral and sold out ✨🙏

    • @3rdmm
      @3rdmm Год назад +13

      Innocence is bliss, ignorance is evil.

    • @Anuchan
      @Anuchan Год назад +2

      The closest I'd come to banning is to restrict a book to certain ages.

    • @lindabb7064
      @lindabb7064 Год назад +15

      @@Anuchan Why restrict when we recommend and explain the basis of the recommendation? Let people have a free enlightened choice for their children. I was a gifted child, and I hated fairy tales and most "children" books. There are other kids like this out there.

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Год назад +1

      @@lindabb7064 then make sure your kids read the book Kamasutra and make sure you narrate it by doing a practical

    • @lindabb7064
      @lindabb7064 Год назад +4

      @@karankapoor2701 you are more than welcome to do so with your kids, since those are your words not mine. I said no book banning and instead provide age recommendation and let the parents decide. If kamasutra is what you decide for your kids, you will face the consequence of any laws you might break. Banning books because people like you are afraid to make a mistake or thar other would be tempted is beyond me. Adults take accountability for there choices. If we can't we are maybe big babies needing a censure system acting like mommy and daddy.

  • @tommyt1971
    @tommyt1971 Год назад +35

    She brought up the point about book banning that I always do -- as a college librarian myself -- which is that 99/100 times, the people who want to challenge/ban/remove a book have NOT read it themselves. And that's NOT to suggest that actually reading the book, taking it in, understanding the themes involved will in any way change their thinking about it -- they're often just too ignorant to try to learn something rather than get militant and destructive about it.

    • @feliciapate7926
      @feliciapate7926 Год назад

      What those same folks don't know is that kids nowadays have access to VPNs and shadow libraries online where they can find the banned books if they know about them. I would've been the kid to distribute banned books to all my friends if we'd have had the tech back then. Surely, there are kids like that now.

  • @bowelsoftrogdor
    @bowelsoftrogdor Год назад +96

    Recognizing oppressive behavior is very important to teach. I have no eloquence but I hold to my heart that reducing anyone to "lesser" is absolute bullshit.

    • @mariaaguadoball3407
      @mariaaguadoball3407 Год назад +10

      Sometimes succinctness is better than eloquence.

    • @Andrea.1tree
      @Andrea.1tree Год назад

      We’ve got to vote Democrat candidates in, all the way down the ballot if we want to keep a fascist government from taking over. They’re currently focused on anti semetic rhetoric, but black, brown and LGBTQ+ people will quickly see their rights disappear under that rule. For starters. Vote blue!

    • @konradyearwood5845
      @konradyearwood5845 Год назад +8

      Believe me, your statement was eloquent.

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Год назад +1

      This woman has literally been debunked thousand of times

    • @mariaaguadoball3407
      @mariaaguadoball3407 Год назад +6

      @@karankapoor2701 She literally has not. The consensus of respected historians is on her side. Maybe if you stopped listening to rightwing extremists, you might learn something.

  • @shondacannon6218
    @shondacannon6218 Год назад +48

    This is why I appreciate, and will continue to support this show! Thank you ❤

  • @gloriaf6971
    @gloriaf6971 Год назад +13

    I must get that book. The 1619 Project is a must read for me. I hope other people will read it too!

  • @randeehughes99
    @randeehughes99 Год назад +60

    We need more people like her shining the light on what and how America has fault for this nation to be the leaders in our democracy! She is totally right our freedom’s are being taken even when the right- wing bans books!

    • @mobydick3895
      @mobydick3895 Год назад

      But slavery is not the cause of history. Philosophy is the cause of history.

  • @stevie4641
    @stevie4641 Год назад +6

    Ray Bradbury is rolling over in his grave. Book banning is 'Fahrenheit 451' in real time. Thank you for educating me about the 1619 Project.

  • @jasongreene6311
    @jasongreene6311 Год назад +91

    "A free society does not ban books." 100% correct

    • @ireallyreallyhategoogle
      @ireallyreallyhategoogle Год назад +3

      Name one society that has never banned any book.
      I'll wait.

    • @PhobosHCM
      @PhobosHCM Год назад

      you want kindergartners read book about giving blow job?

    • @ireallyreallyhategoogle
      @ireallyreallyhategoogle Год назад

      @@PhobosHCM get lost troll

    • @nilo70
      @nilo70 Год назад +1

      No , it does not ! Only repressive regime’s do that shite .

    • @nilo70
      @nilo70 Год назад

      America and the Library of Congress .

  • @debrahelmlinger6256
    @debrahelmlinger6256 Год назад +144

    As a retired Librarian, I approve this message

  • @JuiceMyRandomness
    @JuiceMyRandomness Год назад +33

    I had no idea about the year 1619. Thanks for teaching me something new. I am British and even though it’s hard to hear about the past and the horrid British/American people that enslaved those and created slavery like this. I never get Thai banning books thing! Either you wanna read it or not don’t stop a whole state being able to read it!

    • @eponymousIme
      @eponymousIme Год назад +1

      In fact, the earliest form of slavery were the white European indentured servants living in the colonies established by the folks who had fled England.

    • @melanies.6030
      @melanies.6030 Год назад +2

      @@eponymousIme She pointed out the significant differences in indentured slavery vs. race-based slavery. Not sure how you could miss that in the conversation, unless you didn't watch or listen to it.

    • @Brianbeesandbikes
      @Brianbeesandbikes Год назад +3

      @@eponymousIme Chattle slavery is in no way similar to indentured service. Gotta be careful making comparisons

    • @feliciapate7926
      @feliciapate7926 Год назад

      Book burners would probably like to take us all back to 1619 when you could burn a book and virtually erase it forever...along with possibly burning/hanging the author. There's a part of me that'd like to ship them all off to Mars to settle so they could burn books to stay warm, but I fear they'd then get their act together and try to come back and conquer Earth with their space rayguns and Mars-rifles.

    • @infoscrolls
      @infoscrolls Год назад

      @@Brianbeesandbikes slavery is slavery

  • @GoldSag1
    @GoldSag1 Год назад +23

    My sister purchased the book for me last year. It wasnt an easy read for me, I will admit, but it is a vital piece of American literature. It's a one stop shop if you will for information pertaining to slavery and how it evolved into systemic racism to the Civil rights movement to present day. It's told from a point of facts and not opinion. A must read.

    • @kayecastleman6353
      @kayecastleman6353 Год назад +4

      I'm not sure there can be an unbiased book on such a highly-charged subject, since deciding which facts to include and which facts to omit can't help but slant the contents in a given direction. That is exactly why we need to read multiple books on subjects like these, with a range of perspectives from a variety of authors. One-stop-shopping is how we too often get narrow opinions perpetuating themselves. That being said, given how informed and articulate this author presents, I wager "The 1619 Project" is one of the top three publications that should be required reading for anyone wanting to be fully knowledgeable of these historical events, and probably an excellent place to start.

    • @GoldSag1
      @GoldSag1 Год назад +1

      @@kayecastleman6353 have you read the book?

    • @kayecastleman6353
      @kayecastleman6353 Год назад

      @@GoldSag1 Not yet.

    • @Brianbeesandbikes
      @Brianbeesandbikes Год назад +1

      @@kayecastleman6353 Those that claim to be unbias are complying with and confirming truths that are inconvenient or horrific to keep whatever systemic racism/ sexism/ classism serves its 1%.
      Gerald Horne and DuBois are bright lights in exposing past and present injustices.
      Gerald Horne interview ruclips.net/video/aYwTDuwH2UU/видео.html
      On DuBois
      ruclips.net/video/rYQa9EnG8Ck/видео.html

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @GoldSag, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @simondalton3726
    @simondalton3726 Год назад +13

    How can the land of the free and the home of the brave be banning books?
    Where is the freedom to examine your history?
    Where is the bravery to face it?
    Every decent person knows what is like to say sorry to someone you have hurt. The weight that is lifted - the sense of new beginnings.
    Just get on with it. The world is a better place when the U.S is strong and united.

    • @TheAureliac
      @TheAureliac Год назад +1

      Exactly. Over and over again our country has been offered the chance to acknowledge the past and move forward more equitably. It saddens me greatly that women like Hannah-Jones are more willing to forgive than conservatives are willing to be forgiven.

  • @edge918
    @edge918 Год назад +24

    We are thankful for your father's service Nikole 💙💙💙

  • @krisfrederick5001
    @krisfrederick5001 Год назад +40

    Book burners are threatened by thought. 👀

  • @thomasdimattia3556
    @thomasdimattia3556 Год назад +57

    As important and moving as this interview is, the fact that a picture of her dad got on an important popular national talk show today brought me to tears. As a clear representative of the most underrated Americans in history, this gentleman post humosly needs to receive the metal of freedom award.

    • @brainmachine235
      @brainmachine235 Год назад +7

      Can I recommend something that I found to be very rewarding? There are recordings available online that were done about 100 years ago with sharecroppers, servants, etc. It is amazing to hear them speak in their own voices. There is also a small selection of autobiographies. Marvelous!

    • @TheAureliac
      @TheAureliac Год назад +4

      Me too. And I wholeheartedly agree with her premise that seeking to correct faults is more patriotic than pretending they don't exist.

  • @roxannaweaver2155
    @roxannaweaver2155 Год назад +10

    Well, imagine that - I learned something new today and I'm 71. The White Lion, huh? Another item to add to my stack of things I need to learn more about before I jump to my next adventure. It never ceases to amaze me how much information about this country is out there that so few of us know bout and so many do not want to know or want any of us to know. Mind-boggling. Education matters.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Roxanna Weaver, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

    • @roxannaweaver2155
      @roxannaweaver2155 Год назад

      @@StumblingThroughItAll Indentured servants, yes. I did know about them and have mentioned that in prior posts. I did not know about the information you shared here though. I will need to read the book mentioned in this interview.

  • @brianag9726
    @brianag9726 Год назад +30

    In teaching my students US history, I also learned of the cannibalism that took place among the Jamestown settlers . That was never taught to me…interesting.

    • @eponymousIme
      @eponymousIme Год назад +4

      I imagine there's also a lot of shady stuff about our classic American Founding Fathers and other heroes that never made the light of day. Or, if it did, was buried so that it wouldn't make into a history book.

    • @Iloveswedes
      @Iloveswedes Год назад

      And the Donner Party, and many other desperate white parts of society who claim to be the most civilized. They'll tell you about the African cannibals they've come across, though.

  • @angus7278
    @angus7278 Год назад +11

    When anyone wants to ban a book you DEFINITELY should read it. The 1619 Project is a great, eye-opening read.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Angus Mac, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @NatashaMay10
    @NatashaMay10 Год назад +74

    As a Millennial, my middle school in middle America had a project where we learned about 1619. I can still recall parts of our “rap” today. It also saddens me that people from my generation are fighting to keep these facts from the next generation.

    • @ColoringKaria
      @ColoringKaria Год назад +1

      Tell me you guys didn’t do a “rap” about 1619

    • @NatashaMay10
      @NatashaMay10 Год назад +11

      @@ColoringKaria Oh yeah we did. “16 👏🏽 19, 16 👏🏽 19”

    • @ThatOpalGuy
      @ThatOpalGuy Год назад +4

      cant control the narrative when people listening are educated in reality

    • @feliciapate7926
      @feliciapate7926 Год назад +3

      Music is one of the easiest and oldest ways of teaching things because we tend to remember songs even if we don't remember anything else. Look up Sabaton, if you want an example of a metal band that teaches history. Unfortunately, even though you and I are probably roughly the same age, my school likely skimmed over 1619. If anything, all I recall about whatever we were taught is that some colonies were being founded at that time.

    • @brettg274
      @brettg274 Год назад +1

      😂 🤡

  • @cindyhill9091
    @cindyhill9091 Год назад +31

    Thank you, Nikole Hannah-Jones, for your work. It is so important!

  • @zeldasmith6154
    @zeldasmith6154 Год назад +19

    Censorship is very dominant in the education system. The narrative is shaped by the school systems at every level.

  • @neilsoulman
    @neilsoulman Год назад +9

    'a free society does NOT ban books"

  • @theresarosenquist7810
    @theresarosenquist7810 Год назад +10

    Thank you SO MUCH for this interview! #Brilliant! I truly hope her voice and vision is heard loud & clear by ALL!

  • @naomibee8881
    @naomibee8881 Год назад +24

    I have the greatest respect for this woman. Thank you so much for this fantastic interview!

  • @brandydouble338
    @brandydouble338 Год назад +4

    I'll take that bite of the apple of knowledge....and accept the responsibility of doing better....rather than the bs ignorance of all the lack of knowledge. Thanks for the educational information....and for trying to keep book banning from happening.

  • @chinookvalley
    @chinookvalley Год назад +6

    I'm currently reading "Profiles in Courage", by JFK. It tells of how our forefathers used slavery. It's an abomination that we weren't taught. If we don't learn history and realize our mistakes, and TAKE RESPONSIBILITY for the actions of our forefathers, we should be ashamed!! So many people are STILL suffering for their actions.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @chinookvalley, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @constanceadams9992
    @constanceadams9992 Год назад +10

    You made us all so proud sister!!❤❤❤ way to go Nikolie Olie!

  • @matthuck378
    @matthuck378 Год назад +8

    Should have given up the entire show to talk with her, Stephen.

  • @dewilton7712
    @dewilton7712 Год назад +3

    I recently noticed a correlation between the most democratic country lists and the happiest country lists. America is 25-36th most democratic and 16-19th happiest.

  • @jamesclark6142
    @jamesclark6142 Год назад +11

    I think this interview could have been much longer. I mean you spent 15 (+) minutes with George R.R. Martin...

    • @seegxyber4803
      @seegxyber4803 Год назад

      L🤣L‼ 'cause he's an "All Thℹngs #TOLKℹEN-ℹsh" #STAN‼

    • @jamesclark6142
      @jamesclark6142 Год назад

      @@seegxyber4803 Still...

  • @DonJorgeRM
    @DonJorgeRM Год назад +12

    That last bit about loving your country enough to want to see it do better. That's true patriotism. Love doesn't mean not seeing imperfections.

    • @TheAureliac
      @TheAureliac Год назад +1

      Exactly. Loving your country, as with loving your child, can be unconditional but should still involve trying to mold it to be its best self.

  • @dusseau13
    @dusseau13 Год назад +9

    That is patriotism.

  • @bowdencable7094
    @bowdencable7094 Год назад +4

    We are long overdue a reckoning on our origin myths. Updating this will make us a stronger, better community and country.

  • @Numismatists_Matter
    @Numismatists_Matter Год назад +3

    " I cannot live without books;..." - Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, June 10, 1815
    My public library card will be filled with books including yours.💯💪🏻💙

  • @jeanetteschock4744
    @jeanetteschock4744 Год назад +3

    My favorite bookstore is City Lights in San Francisco.. the front window proudly says WE SELL BANNED BOOKS.

  • @mistadomino
    @mistadomino Год назад +13

    Wonderful having her on the show!

  • @williamthomas3359
    @williamthomas3359 Год назад +4

    You all know who else Banned books? The Gestapo in 1930s Germany. And of course, they are always the first thing we think of as a paragon of virtue and nothing bad ever happened to them.

  • @peggypolo3643
    @peggypolo3643 Год назад +18

    Thank you for this Stephen Colbert!

  • @valiizajames925
    @valiizajames925 Год назад +10

    Salute to "A Truth Teller"

  • @chrisl9293
    @chrisl9293 Год назад +7

    Short and simple. I love the way you stand up truth and reality. Nice to see there is an opposition too, shall we say social media.

  • @idaslapter5987
    @idaslapter5987 Год назад +6

    Thank you for having her on as a guest. what a wonderful person.

  • @JM-sj5oi
    @JM-sj5oi Год назад +6

    She is truly an incredible person. I have read the book twice because there is SO much to learn. I'm a little disappointed Colbert had not read the book before the interview.

  • @erikschaepers
    @erikschaepers Год назад +16

    I am definitely going to buy that book, and what a great interview there again by Stephen the Maestro.. Us Europeans still do not appreciate enough how the race issue has divided over decades, and actually centuries the American society on so many levels. Looking forward to reading up on it - and thank you, Nikole for writing it.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @erik schaepers, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @alexaales7937
    @alexaales7937 Год назад +3

    I don't understand why they would not teach this in school, it's part of your history. I am german and was taught extensively about my country's shameful past. why - to learn from our ancestor's mistake. what's wrong with that? History is such a powerful tool!

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Alexa Ales, because NHJ absolutely has a very specific ideological bent she is trying to support through her "historical argument". I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @dsaint372
    @dsaint372 Год назад +8

    Thank you for having Nikole on.

  • @EricAllen8494
    @EricAllen8494 Год назад +3

    #History & #Education builds people's outlook while hopefully preventing a repeat. The reason history tends to repeat is because of short memory, short lifespans & whitewashing history.

  • @bearlady5694
    @bearlady5694 Год назад +5

    Wonderful lessons which should be taught in our public schools. Her book should be in every school library and every public library so that persons can read and comtemplate how this history impacts our society today.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Bearlady5, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @conniekitzinger53
    @conniekitzinger53 Год назад +6

    This book was the most impactful book I have read in almost my entire lifetime and I am 61. It is beyond comprehension, but sadly understandable, that the information in this book has been completely obscured from our history. It is despicable that people are trying to ban this book. We are never going to move forward if we can't honestly address our past. Thank you Nikole.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Connie Kitzinger, speaking of honestly addressing the past...I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @drbettyschueler3235
    @drbettyschueler3235 Год назад +3

    I also believe our country can become a better country if we elect better representatives. So I voted in the midterm election this morning.

  • @brainmachine235
    @brainmachine235 Год назад +3

    I recommend the book Hiroshima by John Hersey and Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury if you missed this too. (The first movie rendition of the book with Julie Christie is excellent. OMG the final scene! Unforgettable.) I never managed to watch the newer version.) These belong in every 12th grade English class as foundational reading.
    Does anyone else have a suggestion?
    Ah! How does literature affect us? When I traveled to Europe I added Finland because I enjoyed the textile designs of the designer Marimekko. I was on a bus at one point and saw a man tending reindeer and realized that I was watching my first Laplander (the Sami as they prefer to be called). I was beside myself with awe. Why? Because in the third grade my class read about this people. That’s what literature does. It’s like eating a banquet with a new and fabulously delicious food that you’ve never eaten before and making it later as part of your own repertoire.

  • @elizabethpatterson578
    @elizabethpatterson578 Год назад +2

    When we educate ourselves we grow and create more growth. When we lie about education we lower ourselves. Unfortunately we a great number of Americans than want to lie to children on things that happened many years ago because they feel ashamed and want to hide it. Do the opposite show how we are not in that place anymore and nobody needs to feel ashamed anymore. What happened back in history is not our fault, but we have the obligation to show those mistakes so we do not commit the same atrocities anymore.

  • @caliscribe2120
    @caliscribe2120 Год назад +6

    You also don't ban political philosophies from a medium that is now more important than book publishing, the internet. You also don't ban people you disagree with from what should be the most open arena in our society, our universities and colleges.

    • @KingsguardRP
      @KingsguardRP Год назад +2

      Yes you can ban them if they are violating the rules within the establishment ie. Hate, discrimination, violence.
      Just as you wouldnt allow a pornographic book or a book that preaches hate and violence to be in a library.
      There is a difference between that and a book teaching history in an objective manner.

    • @rickkwitkoski1976
      @rickkwitkoski1976 Год назад

      @cali scribe
      Got anyone in particular in mind?

    • @mariag.8242
      @mariag.8242 Год назад

      Passionate arguments are fine as long as they’re based in facts and reason from there. People can say what they like if the foundation is true and the opinions build on the foundation. Lying and getting people upset over things that aren’t happening is vile.

  • @hidalgov1
    @hidalgov1 Год назад +2

    All major corporations donate money to both parties. It is difficult to change the status quo and have a corporation publicly align with one specific party. It’s bad for business, bad for society and bad for democracy.

  • @kenknight5983
    @kenknight5983 Год назад +7

    I think it's especially important to preserve something as hateful as Hitler's Mein Kampf as we need a record of where things went wrong. What you do with that information afterwards is a much bigger topic

    • @seegxyber4803
      @seegxyber4803 Год назад

      -&-#PARTℹCULARLY AS ~ THAT ~accordℹng to hℹs late spouse~ℹS THE.SℹNGLE.BOOK~{actually ~ a book of Der Fürher's speeches....} that #45 kept ▶bedsℹde◀‼

    • @kenknight5983
      @kenknight5983 Год назад

      @@seegxyber4803 What people do with it is the problem. It's just as important to keep a copy of The Art of the Deal for the same reasons. People will still do stupid things with it though

  • @lindaward3156
    @lindaward3156 Год назад +3

    when I learned about slavery as a child, about 55 years ago, I didn't feel any guilt because it seemed to be ancient history (kid think) and had nothing to do with me. I didn't even consider the thot. Later on, as an adult, I understood it more but I think learning history as it really was is very important. Give kids more credit. I think some parents feel guilty about their own anxiety over race. I wonder if Asian children feel guilt over Genghis Kahn? I think not.

  • @nata3467
    @nata3467 Год назад +8

    She is such an inspiration. I taught history with a group of wonderful colleagues many of us teaching history that was more true to the facts but did not fit into the propaganda narrative others would have liked. Sometimes we chuckle that in today's climate our heads would have been served on a platter but I tell you nothing like real history to excite and interest students... And to support critical thinking something that the right wing seems to be very afraid of.
    I wish you would spend more time with guess of this caliber and a little less time on celebrities love everything about this show you are a beacon of Hope

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Nata, Speaking of "real history" did you make sure to teach this?
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @lorenrenee1
    @lorenrenee1 Год назад +2

    Ma’am “a free society doesn’t ban books”. That should be in every classroom. My whole life I wanted to know the thoughts of the black pilots who liberated the camps thought conning home to segregation and our domestic oppression/tiered citizenry

  • @jaden8084
    @jaden8084 Год назад +2

    What a wonderful interview! I love the wisdom she is sharing. My list of books to read lately is getting longer and longer. Honestly if you are going to ban books, you might as well burn them and call yourself a Nazi because that's the ideology of such censorship. Not to mention its pretty pathetic to be afraid of some inanimate objects.

  • @Thinkingaroundthebox
    @Thinkingaroundthebox Год назад +3

    One of the common occurrences when a society falls into dictatorship is that they start with burning books to control the flow the knowledge
    The importance of learning history, is not learning how great your ancestors were. It is learning what mistakes they made and how not to repeat them
    I can create a very long list of books that I would rather didn't exist that would enrage the far right to no end
    Pretty much anything from Ayn Rand, the bible (I'm an aehiest), etc...
    If you don't offend anyone, you aren't doing anything
    Life is compromise

  • @timisaac8121
    @timisaac8121 Год назад +8

    My Grandfather died in Battle of the Bulge with 101st airborne. USA crushed them. I feel a equality with this woman's father that goes beyond words.

  • @jtremblay100
    @jtremblay100 Год назад +2

    You know when she was talking about her father loving America and it’s potential. It made me think we need Russians to think that way about their country now. To believe in its greatness and potential. Such a shame.

  • @elfari100
    @elfari100 Год назад +4

    If you don't understand a problem there's no way to solve it.

  • @joannejohnson7006
    @joannejohnson7006 Год назад +5

    Stephen Colbert you are enlightening with your guests, raising us all up, for the highest good. ❤Thank you for sharing this brilliant brave woman with us today.

  • @TR4zest
    @TR4zest Год назад +5

    What an eloquent, smart author Nikole is.

  • @jorjastonej
    @jorjastonej Год назад +2

    I’ve read The 1619 Project. It’s not new history, but it broadens the USA history from the perspective, lived experience, and research of descendants of slavery. I hope and encourage everyone to read it.

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Julie Johnson, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @Mister006
    @Mister006 Год назад +3

    Excellent interview! Stephen is the best! Nikole Hannah-Jones is an exceptional excellent academic talent!

  • @allthingswavy6420
    @allthingswavy6420 Год назад +3

    This interview was waaay too short. This conversation needed to extend into a full-length segment.

  • @weirdunclebob
    @weirdunclebob Год назад +2

    4:05 Sorry, Stephen, but it seems that you're wrong! Race-based slavery was already big in the 14th century. 1492, roughly when Europeans started the main invasion of North America, is in the 15th century. Race-based slavery did change due to the invasion of NA but it was already a thing.

  • @oliviapowers8280
    @oliviapowers8280 Год назад +2

    Poignant, Powerful, & Fabulous!!

  • @shawnhampton8503
    @shawnhampton8503 Год назад +2

    "...the highest calling of patriotism, which is to see the ways in which your country is failing, to see the hypocrisy of your country, to see the way your country is not living up to it's highest ideals, but still believing that your country can become the thing that we all dream it to be." So well said. To anyone who says "America, love it or leave it!" and "How dare you criticize this nation!" I say "Do you just tell your kids they are perfect and never ever question their actions or point out when they are not behaving as decent people?" I sure as hell hope you do. Does that mean you do not love your kids? Nope. It means you really really love them because you are holding them to high standards and believing that they can live up to that.

  • @mackymintle7806
    @mackymintle7806 Год назад +13

    More Nikole please.
    Americans needs her to educate them.

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Год назад +1

      She's a legit clown and only people who use the word BIRTHING PEOPLE take her seriously

  • @beataylorsdeeppinkecstasy9013
    @beataylorsdeeppinkecstasy9013 Год назад +8

    This book is on my list of books to read when I return to the U.S. after having lived abroad for several years. I truly don't understand the scare tactics that politicians use to try to win votes. I'm Caucasian, but I'm not responsible for what any ancestors of mine might have done in promoting slavery. I'm responsible for my own actions, As far as I know I've never engaged in any enabling behavior that would have encouraged others to act in immoral or unethical ways. By the way, does anyone know if German schools/libraries outlaw books about the Holocaust for fear that German children might feel guilty?

    • @TheAureliac
      @TheAureliac Год назад +1

      No, Germany acknowledges their responsibility for the Holocaust and the horrors it entailed. As another white person, I know that I have benefitted from slavery whether my family ever owned slaves or not. I cannot suggest too strongly that you also read about institutional racism.

    • @infoscrolls
      @infoscrolls Год назад

      @@TheAureliac self hating

    • @TheAureliac
      @TheAureliac Год назад +3

      @@infoscrolls I'm sorry you are. However, we do not need to hate ourselves for what our ancestors or predecessors did. We do, however, need to be clear-eyed about their actions. Only then can we make informed judgements about how our society operates and resolve to improve its inequities.

  • @renatacantore3684
    @renatacantore3684 Год назад +2

    May God bless this Treasured American ❤

  • @lynnebucher6537
    @lynnebucher6537 Год назад +2

    Any time I hear someone wants to ban a book, I wonder what they are hiding.

  • @eponymousIme
    @eponymousIme Год назад +3

    Good interview. Glad she was invited as a guest.

  • @anonimuse6553
    @anonimuse6553 Год назад +2

    What an interesting woman. Love her.

  • @astropioneer3296
    @astropioneer3296 Год назад +2

    Powerful stuff. Nikole Hannah-Jones is a great American.

  • @frankboyd.
    @frankboyd. Год назад +2

    Never found history interesting in schools. I'm now finding most of it was lies. The actual truth is really interesting and helpful. 🇨🇦 And yes, the truth is difficult to absorb at times, but definitely not boring.🇺🇸

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Frank Boyd, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @jpdemer5
    @jpdemer5 Год назад +2

    When did being conservative start to require being in denial about so much of reality?

  • @rebeccawinters7244
    @rebeccawinters7244 Год назад +1

    I’m in the middle of The 1619 Project now….it is so interesting, and very eye opening. If we were taught these stories in school, we would be able to easily recognize some of the actions of politicians today that are racist.

    • @karankapoor2701
      @karankapoor2701 Год назад +1

      Jussie smollet should take few lessons Fromm that book

    • @StumblingThroughItAll
      @StumblingThroughItAll Год назад

      @Rebecca Winters, I may have missed this fascinating/haunting detail in NHJ's book, which I stumbled across when studying the origins of the institution of US chattel slavery. Maybe it was an honest oversight.
      The first African "slaves" to come to the US in 1619 were actually indentured servants, not race-based chattel slaves. They worked out their "contracts" and went on to become free men.
      One of the first court cases that was foundational to the legal protection of lifelong chattel slavery was in 1655, Johnson v. Casor. This case was pivotal in laying the foundation for the profoundly vile institution of lifelong chattel slavery (humans as permanent property). The Northampton County Court ruled in favor of Anthony Johnson, which allowed him to keep a black man in lifelong slavery as his property, and John Casor became the first person to be declared a slave for life in the US.
      To show that history has a wildly complex irony;
      Anthony Johnson, who's victory in Johnson v. Casar is credited with laying the foundation for chattel slavery in the US, was also a black man, and was one of the 20 African indentured servants brought to Jamestown in 1619....

  • @peacefulfanpuppylover2311
    @peacefulfanpuppylover2311 Год назад +2

    Phenomenal interview!

  • @goldenroux612
    @goldenroux612 Год назад +1

    You tube algorithm made it so I had to search this segment out. I got notifications for all other parts of the show, except this important interview. Thank God for truth tellers! Hmm, I feel like there may be a lesson here.

  • @ProfessorBurlingame
    @ProfessorBurlingame Год назад +3

    More Nikole Hannah-Jones, please.

  • @laslobas1234
    @laslobas1234 Год назад +2

    I love it and obviously the live audience does also, when the show has people on with something to say. Most actors do not